Topic 4: Angular Momentum and Central Forces - Problem Sets

Source: sources/cuatrimestre-1/03-engineering-mechanics/problemas/Problems.pdf (2026 Edition)
Statements and solutions: Each card gives the statement from the official collection (with the PDF page) and a worked solution in the order of the course: frames, bases and coordinates, the change of basis and the position vector, kinematics, forces and equations of motion, and the answers with unit and limit checks. Only Problems 17 and 39 (part f) have an official key entry; the other results are derived here and checked numerically.
Problem 42

Particle Attracted to the Origin by $F = m\mu/r^\alpha$

Original statement · Problems.pdf, p. 29
Binet + Effective Potential

(Advanced problem.) A point particle $P$ of mass $m$ is attracted by the origin of coordinates $O$ of the inertial reference frame $S_0$ by a force with magnitude

$$ F = \frac{m\mu}{r^\alpha} $$

where $r$ is the distance between $O$ and $P$, and $\mu, \alpha$ are known constants.

Notation.

The official text writes $F = m\alpha/r^\beta$ (strength $\alpha$, exponent $\beta$) and asks for $\beta = 1, 2, 3, 4$. Here the strength is called $\mu$ and the exponent $\alpha$, so the cases "$\alpha = 1, 2, 3, 4$" below are the official $\beta = 1, 2, 3, 4$, and $\mu/h^2$ is the official $\alpha/h^2$.

Hint: try to solve first the problem with $\alpha = 2$, and then try the other values.

Worked Solution [ Click to Expand ]

Constraints, Degrees of Freedom & Coordinates

  • System: a particle $P$ of mass $m$ attracted to the fixed point $O$ by $\mathbf{F} = -\dfrac{m\mu}{r^\alpha}\mathbf{e}_r$, where $r = \|\overrightarrow{OP}\|$.
  • Hypotheses: $S_0$ is inertial; $\mu \gt 0$ and $\alpha \gt 0$ are constants; no other force acts; $h \ne 0$ unless stated.
  • Constraints: none. $P$ is a free particle, so $\text{CDOF} = 3$. Part (a) proves that the motion is planar; that is a consequence of the dynamics, not an imposed constraint. In the plane, $\text{CDOF} = 2$.
  • Coordinates: polar coordinates $(r, \theta)$ in the plane of motion. For the orbit equation we also use $u(\theta) = 1/r(\theta)$ and $u' = du/d\theta$; $h$ is the magnitude of the angular momentum per unit mass.
  • Special case $h = 0$: the motion is then radial and the Binet formulation does not apply. It is treated at the end of part (c).
  • Notation: the official text writes $F = m\alpha/r^\beta$ and asks for $\beta = 1, 2, 3, 4$. Here the strength is $\mu$ and the exponent is $\alpha$.
SymbolMeaningSI unit
$\mu$force strength per unit mass, $F/m = \mu/r^\alpha$m$^{\alpha+1}$/s$^2$
$h$specific angular momentumm$^2$/s
$u$reciprocal radiusm$^{-1}$
$\xi$specific mechanical energyJ/kg = m$^2$/s$^2$

Reference Frames & Vector Bases

  • Inertial frame: $S_0 = \{O; \mathbf{i}, \mathbf{j}, \mathbf{k}\}$ with its origin at the attracting centre.
  • Polar basis. Take $\mathbf{k}$ along $\mathbf{H}_O$ (justified in 3.3). The polar basis $\mathcal{B}_1 = \{\mathbf{e}_r, \mathbf{e}_\theta, \mathbf{k}\}$ is the inertial basis $\mathcal{B}_0 = \{\mathbf{i}, \mathbf{j}, \mathbf{k}\}$ rotated by $\theta(t)$ about $\mathbf{k}$:
$$ [{}_0 R_1] = \begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta & -\sin\theta & 0 \\ \sin\theta & \cos\theta & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \det[{}_0R_1] = \cos^2\theta + \sin^2\theta = 1, \qquad [{}_0R_1]^T[{}_0R_1] = I $$

Multiplying out, $RR^T$ has diagonal entries $\cos^2 + \sin^2 = 1$ of the rotation angle (and $1$) and off-diagonal entries $\pm(\cos\sin - \sin\cos) = 0$, so it is the identity.

  • Angular velocity and angular acceleration of $\mathcal{B}_1$ with respect to $S_0$: $\boldsymbol{\omega}_{10} = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{k}$ and $\boldsymbol{\alpha}_{10} = \ddot{\theta}\,\mathbf{k}$.
  • Time derivatives of the unit vectors (Poisson's formula $\dot{\mathbf{e}} = \boldsymbol{\omega}\times\mathbf{e}$):
$$ \dot{\mathbf{e}}_r = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{k}\times\mathbf{e}_r = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_\theta, \qquad \dot{\mathbf{e}}_\theta = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{k}\times\mathbf{e}_\theta = -\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_r $$

Derivation

3.1 Kinematics

Pedagogical Justification: the force acts along the line $OP$, so the position vector is simply $r\mathbf{e}_r$. The basis vector $\mathbf{e}_r$ is not constant in $S_0$, so each derivative uses the product rule and Poisson's formula. These planar polar formulas are valid for a motion contained in the plane of the basis; that the motion is indeed planar is proved in 3.3, and here it only fixes the choice of $\mathbf{k}$.
$$ \mathbf{r} = r\,\mathbf{e}_r $$
$$ \mathbf{v} = \frac{d}{dt}\left(r\mathbf{e}_r\right) = \dot{r}\,\mathbf{e}_r + r\,\dot{\mathbf{e}}_r = \dot{r}\,\mathbf{e}_r + r\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_\theta $$
$$ \mathbf{a} = \ddot{r}\,\mathbf{e}_r + \dot{r}\,\dot{\mathbf{e}}_r + \left(\dot{r}\dot{\theta} + r\ddot{\theta}\right)\mathbf{e}_\theta + r\dot{\theta}\,\dot{\mathbf{e}}_\theta = \left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right)\mathbf{e}_r + \left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right)\mathbf{e}_\theta $$
  • The angular momentum per unit mass about $O$ follows from the velocity:
$$ \mathbf{h} = \mathbf{r}\times\mathbf{v} = r\mathbf{e}_r\times\left(\dot{r}\mathbf{e}_r + r\dot{\theta}\mathbf{e}_\theta\right) = r^2\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{k}, \qquad h = r^2\dot{\theta} $$

3.2 Forces

  • Applied force: the attraction $\mathbf{F} = -\dfrac{m\mu}{r^\alpha}\mathbf{e}_r$. It is central: its line of action always passes through $O$.
  • Constraint forces: none. Inertia forces: none, because Newton's second law is written in the inertial frame $S_0$.
Pedagogical Justification: the force is purely radial and depends only on $r$, so its elementary work $\mathbf{F}\cdot d\mathbf{r} = F(r)\,dr$ is the exact differential of a function of $r$ (equivalently, $\nabla\times\mathbf{F} = \mathbf{0}$). The force is therefore conservative. The potential energy per unit mass is minus the work per unit mass from a reference radius to $r$ (Barrow's rule). For $\alpha \gt 1$ the reference is at infinity, and the term at the lower limit $s \to \infty$ vanishes because $1 - \alpha \lt 0$:
$$ V_0(r) = -\int_\infty^r\left(-\frac{\mu}{s^\alpha}\right)ds = \mu\left[\frac{s^{1-\alpha}}{1 - \alpha}\right]_\infty^r = \mu\left[\frac{r^{1-\alpha}}{1 - \alpha} - \lim_{s\to\infty}\frac{s^{1-\alpha}}{1 - \alpha}\right] = -\frac{\mu}{(\alpha - 1)\,r^{\alpha - 1}} $$

For $\alpha \le 1$ the integral from infinity diverges, so the reference radius $r_*$ is arbitrary. For $\alpha = 1$:

$$ V_0(r) = -\int_{r_*}^r\left(-\frac{\mu}{s}\right)ds = \mu\left[\ln s\right]_{r_*}^r = \mu\ln\frac{r}{r_*} $$
  • In all cases the force per unit mass is recovered by differentiating, e.g. for $\alpha \gt 1$, $V_0'(r) = -\dfrac{\mu}{\alpha - 1}\cdot\left(-(\alpha - 1)\,r^{-\alpha}\right) = \dfrac{\mu}{r^\alpha}$, and for $\alpha = 1$, $V_0'(r) = \mu/r$.

3.3 Equations of Motion

Pedagogical Justification: the torque about the fixed point $O$ vanishes because $\mathbf{F}$ is parallel to $\mathbf{r}$. The angular momentum theorem about a fixed point (Notes Eq. 4.53) is a consequence of Newton's second law and gives a first integral right away.
$$ \mathbf{M}_O = \mathbf{r}\times\mathbf{F} = r\mathbf{e}_r\times\left(-\frac{m\mu}{r^\alpha}\mathbf{e}_r\right) = \mathbf{0} \implies \left.\frac{d\mathbf{H}_O}{dt}\right|_0 = \mathbf{0} \implies \mathbf{H}_O = m\,\mathbf{r}\times\mathbf{v} = \text{const} $$
  • Planar motion. From $\mathbf{H}_O = m\,\mathbf{r}\times\mathbf{v}$, both $\mathbf{r}\cdot\mathbf{H}_O \equiv 0$ and $\mathbf{v}\cdot\mathbf{H}_O \equiv 0$. Then $P$ stays in the plane through $O$ perpendicular to $\mathbf{H}_O$, and we orient $\mathbf{k}$ along $\mathbf{H}_O$.
  • Newton's second law in the plane. With $\mathbf{a}$ from 3.1 and $\mathbf{F}$ from 3.2, projected on $\mathbf{e}_r$ and $\mathbf{e}_\theta$:
$$ m\left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right) = -\frac{m\mu}{r^\alpha}, \qquad m\left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right) = 0 $$
  • Check of closure: two unknowns, $r(t)$ and $\theta(t)$, and two independent scalar equations.
  • Angular momentum from the transverse equation. Multiplying by $r/m$ and using the product rule:
$$ \frac{d}{dt}\left(r^2\dot{\theta}\right) = 2r\dot{r}\dot{\theta} + r^2\ddot{\theta} = r\left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right) = 0 \implies h = r^2\dot{\theta} = \text{const} $$
  • Energy from the radial equation. The force is conservative (3.2), so the mechanical energy per unit mass $\xi = \tfrac{1}{2}\left(\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}^2\right) + V_0(r)$ is a first integral. Differentiating with the product and chain rules, and using $V_0'(r) = \mu/r^\alpha$:
$$ \dot{\xi} = \dot{r}\ddot{r} + r\dot{r}\dot{\theta}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}\ddot{\theta} + V_0'(r)\dot{r} = \dot{r}\left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right) + r\dot{\theta}\left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right) + \frac{\mu}{r^\alpha}\dot{r} $$
$$ \dot{\xi} = \dot{r}\left(-\frac{\mu}{r^\alpha}\right) + 0 + \frac{\mu}{r^\alpha}\dot{r} = 0 \implies \xi = \tfrac{1}{2}v^2 + V_0(r) = \text{const} $$

3.4 Integration and Answers

(a) Conserved quantities and planar motion
  • The angular momentum $\mathbf{H}_O = m\,\mathbf{r}\times\mathbf{v}$ and the mechanical energy $\xi = \tfrac{1}{2}v^2 + V_0(r)$ are conserved, and the motion occurs in the plane through $O$ perpendicular to $\mathbf{H}_O$. All three statements were proved in 3.3.
(b) Binet equation for a power law
Pedagogical Justification: we want the orbit $u(\theta)$, so time is eliminated with $h = r^2\dot{\theta}$, i.e. $\dot{\theta} = hu^2$. The chain rule for $r = u^{-1}$ gives $dr/d\theta = -u'/u^2$.
$$ \dot{r} = \frac{dr}{d\theta}\dot{\theta} = \left(-\frac{u'}{u^2}\right)\left(hu^2\right) = -hu', \qquad \ddot{r} = \frac{d}{dt}\left(-hu'\right) = -hu''\,\dot{\theta} = -h^2u^2u'' $$
  • The radial equation $\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2 = -\mu/r^\alpha = -\mu u^\alpha$ with $r\dot{\theta}^2 = \frac{1}{u}\left(hu^2\right)^2 = h^2u^3$ becomes
$$ -h^2u^2u'' - h^2u^3 = -\mu u^\alpha \quad\overset{\div\,(-h^2u^2)}{\Longrightarrow}\quad \boxed{u'' + u = \frac{\mu}{h^2}\,u^{\alpha - 2}} $$
(c) First integral and limits of the motion
Pedagogical Justification: write the specific energy with $\dot{r} = -hu'$ and $r\dot{\theta} = hu$. Since $\xi$ is constant, the result is a first integral (a quadrature) with no second derivative.
$$ \xi = \tfrac{1}{2}h^2\left[(u')^2 + u^2\right] + V_0\!\left(\frac{1}{u}\right) \implies \boxed{(u')^2 + W_{\text{eff}}(u) = E^*}, \quad E^* \equiv \frac{2\xi}{h^2}, \quad W_{\text{eff}}(u) = u^2 + \frac{2V_0(1/u)}{h^2} $$
  • Derivative of $W_{\text{eff}}$ (chain rule). With $\dfrac{d}{du}\left(\dfrac{1}{u}\right) = -\dfrac{1}{u^2}$ and $V_0'(r) = \mu/r^\alpha$ evaluated at $r = 1/u$:
$$ \frac{d}{du}V_0\!\left(\frac{1}{u}\right) = V_0'\!\left(\frac{1}{u}\right)\left(-\frac{1}{u^2}\right) = \mu u^\alpha\left(-\frac{1}{u^2}\right) = -\mu u^{\alpha - 2} \implies W_{\text{eff}}'(u) = 2u - \frac{2\mu}{h^2}u^{\alpha - 2} $$
  • Check. $\dfrac{d}{d\theta}\left[(u')^2 + W_{\text{eff}}\right] = u'\left(2u'' + W_{\text{eff}}'\right) = 0$. Where $u' \ne 0$ this gives $u'' = -\tfrac{1}{2}W_{\text{eff}}'$, which is the Binet equation; at the points where $u' = 0$ the Binet equation holds by continuity.
  • Limits of the motion. Because $(u')^2 \ge 0$, motion exists only where $W_{\text{eff}}(u) \le E^*$. The turning points ($u' = 0$) are the roots of $W_{\text{eff}}(u) = E^*$, and a minimum or a maximum of $W_{\text{eff}}$ is a circular orbit. The constant is fixed by the initial data $u_0 = u(0)$ and $u_0' = u'(0)$:
$$ E^* = (u_0')^2 + W_{\text{eff}}(u_0) $$
  • The three questions are: (i) escape, $u \to 0$; (ii) reaching the origin, $u \to \infty$; (iii) oscillation between two values of $u$.
Case $\alpha = 2$: inverse square (Kepler)
  • Binet: $u'' + u = \mu/h^2$. Potential: $V_0 = -\mu u$, so $W_{\text{eff}} = u^2 - \dfrac{2\mu}{h^2}u = \left(u - \dfrac{\mu}{h^2}\right)^2 - \left(\dfrac{\mu}{h^2}\right)^2$, a parabola with minimum $-(\mu/h^2)^2$ at $u = \mu/h^2$. The constant is $E^* = (u_0')^2 + u_0^2 - \dfrac{2\mu}{h^2}u_0$.
  • (i) Escape: possible if and only if $E^* \ge W_{\text{eff}}(0) = 0$, i.e. $(u_0')^2 + u_0^2 \ge \dfrac{2\mu}{h^2}u_0$ (parabola or hyperbola). For $E^* \gt 0$ a particle moving inward ($u_0' \gt 0$) is first reflected at the positive root and then escapes.
  • (ii) Reaching $r = 0$: impossible for $h \ne 0$, because $W_{\text{eff}} \to +\infty$ as $u \to \infty$.
  • (iii) Oscillation: for $-(\mu/h^2)^2 \lt E^* \lt 0$: $u$ oscillates between the two roots (periapsis and apoapsis of an ellipse); $E^* = -(\mu/h^2)^2$ is the circular orbit.
Case $\alpha = 1$: $F \propto 1/r$
  • Binet: $u'' + u = \dfrac{\mu}{h^2u}$. With the reference radius $r_*$, $V_0 = \mu\ln(r/r_*) = -\mu\ln(ur_*)$, so $W_{\text{eff}} = u^2 - \dfrac{2\mu}{h^2}\ln(ur_*)$ and $E^* = (u_0')^2 + u_0^2 - \dfrac{2\mu}{h^2}\ln(u_0r_*)$.
  • $W_{\text{eff}} \to +\infty$ both as $u \to 0$ (because $-\ln u \to +\infty$) and as $u \to \infty$. Its minimum is at $W_{\text{eff}}' = 2u - \dfrac{2\mu}{h^2u} = 0$, i.e. $u_c = \sqrt{\mu}/h$.
  • (i) Escape is impossible for any finite energy. (ii) Reaching $r = 0$ is impossible. (iii) Every orbit with $E^* \gt W_{\text{eff}}(u_c)$ oscillates between two finite turning points; $E^* = W_{\text{eff}}(u_c)$ is the circular orbit $r = h/\sqrt{\mu}$. Since $E^* \ge W_{\text{eff}}(u_c)$ always, every motion with $h \ne 0$ is of type (iii) or circular.
Case $\alpha = 3$: $F \propto 1/r^3$
  • $V_0 = -\dfrac{\mu}{2r^2} = -\dfrac{\mu}{2}u^2$. Binet: $u'' + \lambda u = 0$ with $\lambda \equiv 1 - \mu/h^2$. Then $W_{\text{eff}} = \lambda u^2$ and $(u')^2 + \lambda u^2 = E^*$.
  • $h^2 \gt \mu$ ($\lambda = \kappa^2 \gt 0$, $\kappa = \sqrt{1 - \mu/h^2}$): $u = A\cos(\kappa\theta + \delta)$; the initial conditions $u_0 = A\cos\delta$ and $u_0' = -\kappa A\sin\delta$ give, squaring and adding, $A = \sqrt{u_0^2 + (u_0'/\kappa)^2}$. The cosine vanishes at a finite angle, so $u \to 0$ in every case: (i) the particle always escapes; a particle moving inward ($u_0' \gt 0$) is first reflected at the periapsis $u = A$. (ii) never, since $u \le A$. (iii) no oscillation between two positive values.
  • $h^2 \lt \mu$ ($\lambda = -\kappa^2 \lt 0$, $\kappa = \sqrt{\mu/h^2 - 1}$): $u = C_1e^{\kappa\theta} + C_2e^{-\kappa\theta}$ with $C_1 = \tfrac{1}{2}(u_0 + u_0'/\kappa)$, $C_2 = \tfrac{1}{2}(u_0 - u_0'/\kappa)$. If $C_1 \gt 0$ (i.e. $u_0' \gt -\kappa u_0$), $u \to \infty$: (ii) the particle reaches the origin. If $C_1 \lt 0$ ($u_0' \lt -\kappa u_0$), $u$ reaches $0$ at a finite angle: (i) escape. If $C_1 = 0$, $u = u_0e^{-\kappa\theta} \to 0$ only asymptotically (spiral $r = r_0e^{\kappa\theta}$), a limiting case of escape. (iii) no oscillation.
  • $h^2 = \mu$ ($\lambda = 0$): $u'' = 0 \Rightarrow u = u_0 + u_0'\theta$ (reciprocal spiral). $u_0' \gt 0$: reaches the origin; $u_0' \lt 0$: escapes at $\theta = u_0/|u_0'|$; $u_0' = 0$: circle $r = 1/u_0$.
Case $\alpha = 4$: $F \propto 1/r^4$
  • Binet: $u'' + u = \dfrac{\mu}{h^2}u^2$. $V_0 = -\dfrac{\mu}{3}u^3$, so $W_{\text{eff}} = u^2 - \dfrac{2\mu}{3h^2}u^3 = u^2\left(1 - \dfrac{2\mu}{3h^2}u\right)$ and $E^* = (u_0')^2 + u_0^2 - \dfrac{2\mu}{3h^2}u_0^3$.
  • $W_{\text{eff}}'(u) = 2u - \dfrac{2\mu}{h^2}u^2 = 2u\left(1 - \dfrac{\mu}{h^2}u\right)$: stationary points $u = 0$ (minimum, $W = 0$) and $u_b = h^2/\mu$ (maximum, barrier $W_{\max} = u_b^2 - \dfrac{2\mu}{3h^2}u_b^3 = \dfrac{h^4}{3\mu^2}$). For $u \gt u_b$, $W_{\text{eff}}$ decreases without bound and crosses zero at $u_z = 3h^2/(2\mu) \gt u_b$.
  • There is no interior minimum, so the allowed set $\{W_{\text{eff}} \le E^*\}$ either contains $u = 0$ or extends to $u \to \infty$. Because $\dot{\theta} = hu^2 \gt 0$, $u'$ has the sign of $\dot{u}$.
  • Allowed regions by energy (with $u_0 \gt 0$):
    • $E^* \lt 0$: only $u \ge u_2$ with $u_2 \gt u_z$ is allowed.
    • $E^* = 0$: $u = 0$ is a double root, so the allowed set is $\{0\} \cup [u_z, \infty)$; a particle at finite $r$ has $u_0 \ge u_z$.
    • $0 \lt E^* \lt W_{\max}$: two roots $u_1 \in (0, u_b)$ and $u_2 \gt u_b$; allowed $u \le u_1$ or $u \ge u_2$.
    • $E^* = W_{\max}$: $u_b$ is a stationary point of $W_{\text{eff}}$; the unstable circular orbit $u = u_b$ and the motions that approach it asymptotically.
    • $E^* \gt W_{\max}$: no turning points.
  • Motion in each region. For $0 \lt E^* \lt W_{\max}$ and $u_0 \le u_1$: if $u_0' \gt 0$ the particle is reflected at $u_1$, and in any case it escapes. For $u_0 \ge u_2$: if $u_0' \lt 0$ it is reflected at $u_2$, and in any case it falls to the origin. For $E^* = W_{\max}$: with $u_0 \lt u_b$, $u_0' \lt 0$ escapes and $u_0' \gt 0$ approaches $u_b$ asymptotically; with $u_0 \gt u_b$, $u_0' \gt 0$ falls to the origin and $u_0' \lt 0$ approaches $u_b$ asymptotically. For $E^* \gt W_{\max}$, $u_0' \lt 0$ escapes and $u_0' \gt 0$ falls to the origin.
  • (i) escape: $0 \lt E^* \lt W_{\max}$ with $u_0 \lt u_b$; or $E^* = W_{\max}$ with $u_0 \lt u_b$ and $u_0' \lt 0$; or $E^* \gt W_{\max}$ with $u_0' \lt 0$.
  • (ii) reaching $r = 0$: $E^* \le 0$ (then $u_0 \ge u_z$); or $0 \lt E^* \lt W_{\max}$ with $u_0 \gt u_b$; or $E^* = W_{\max}$ with $u_0 \gt u_b$ and $u_0' \gt 0$; or $E^* \gt W_{\max}$ with $u_0' \gt 0$.
  • (iii) bounded oscillation between two values of $u$: does not occur; it would need an interior minimum of $W_{\text{eff}}$, and the only bounded motion is the unstable circle $u = u_b$.
Special case $h = 0$ (radial motion)
Pedagogical Justification: with $h = 0$, $\dot{\theta} = 0$ and the particle moves on a straight line through $O$. The Binet equation does not apply ($u = 1/r$ cannot be expressed as a function of $\theta$), so we use the radial equation and the energy directly: $\ddot{r} = -\mu/r^\alpha \lt 0$ and $\tfrac{1}{2}\dot{r}^2 + V_0(r) = \xi$.
  • (ii) A particle with $\dot{r}_0 \lt 0$ reaches $r = 0$ for every $\alpha$, since the acceleration is always inward. (i) Escape requires $\dot{r}_0 \gt 0$ and $\xi \ge \lim_{r\to\infty}V_0 = 0$, which exists only for $\alpha \gt 1$; for $\alpha \le 1$, $V_0 \to +\infty$ and the particle always turns back. (iii) Without angular momentum, a particle that turns back falls to the origin, so there is no oscillation between two values.

Interpretation & Checks

  • Dimensional check: $[F/m] = \text{m/s}^2 = [\mu]/\text{m}^\alpha$ gives $[\mu] = \text{m}^{\alpha+1}/\text{s}^2$. With $[h^2] = \text{m}^4/\text{s}^2$ and $[u] = \text{m}^{-1}$, $\dfrac{\mu}{h^2}u^{\alpha - 2}$ has units $\text{m}^{\alpha - 3}\,\text{m}^{-(\alpha - 2)} = \text{m}^{-1}$, the same as $u$ and $u''$ ($\theta$ is dimensionless).
  • Stability of circular orbits (consequence of the first integral): for general $\alpha$, $W_{\text{eff}}'(u_c) = 0$ gives $u_c^{\alpha - 3} = h^2/\mu$ and $W_{\text{eff}}''(u_c) = 2 - 2(\alpha - 2)\dfrac{\mu}{h^2}u_c^{\alpha - 3} = 2(3 - \alpha)$, so the circular orbit is a minimum (stable) for $\alpha \lt 3$ and a maximum (unstable) for $\alpha \gt 3$, in agreement with the cases above ($\alpha = 4$: barrier at $u_b = h^2/\mu$).
  • Check against the official key: Problems.pdf has no entry for Problem 42 in its solution keys, so the result is verified by independent derivation. A symbolic check with sympy confirms the substitution $\dot{r} = -hu'$, $\ddot{r} = -h^2u^2u''$, the Binet equation, the first integral $\frac{d}{d\theta}\left[(u')^2 + W_{\text{eff}}\right] = 0$, the barrier $W_{\max} = h^4/(3\mu^2)$ and $W_{\text{eff}}'' = 2(3 - \alpha)$.
  • Numerical check (Python, DOP853 with relative tolerance $10^{-12}$ on $u'' = -u + (\mu/h^2)u^{\alpha-2}$, units with $\mu = h = 1$ unless stated). Blow-up angles are given for the cut-off $u = 10^6$; they change by less than $0.003$ rad when the cut-off is $10^9$.
CaseInitial data $(u_0, u_0')$PredictedIntegration result
$\alpha = 2$$(1.5, 0)$bounded, $0.5$ to $1.5$$u \in [0.5000, 1.5000]$ over $60$ rad
$\alpha = 2$$(0.5, -0.9)$, $E^* \gt 0$escape$u = 0$ at $\theta = 0.823$
$\alpha = 4$$(0.5, 0)$, $E^* = 1/6 \lt 1/3$reflected, then escape$u = 0$ at $\theta = 2.078$
$\alpha = 4$$(1.2, 0)$, $E^* = 0.288 \lt 1/3$collapse$u \to \infty$ at $\theta = 4.058$
$\alpha = 4$$(0.5, 0.9)$, $E^* = 0.977 \gt 1/3$collapse$u \to \infty$ at $\theta = 3.604$
$\alpha = 4$$(0.5, -0.9)$, $E^* = 0.977 \gt 1/3$escape$u = 0$ at $\theta = 0.524$
$\alpha = 4$$(1, 0)$, $E^* = W_{\max}$unstable circular orbit$u = 1$ for $20$ rad
$\alpha = 4$$(1.5, 0)$, $E^* = 0$, $u_0 = u_z$collapse$u \to \infty$ at $\theta = 3.139$
$\alpha = 4$$(0.5, -0.408)$, $E^* = W_{\max}$escape$u = 0$ at $\theta = 0.975$
$\alpha = 4$$(0.5, +0.408)$, $E^* = W_{\max}$tends to $u_b = 1$ asymptoticallyfollows $u \to 1$ until round-off, amplified by $e^{\theta}$, takes it off the separatrix at $\theta \approx 34$
$\alpha = 3$, $\mu/h^2 = 2$$(1, 0.2)$, $C_1 \gt 0$collapse$u = \cosh\theta + 0.2\sinh\theta$ grows without bound with $\theta$ and no zero appears
$\alpha = 3$, $\mu/h^2 = 2$$(1, -1.5)$, $C_1 \lt 0$escape$u = 0$ at $\theta = 0.805$
$\alpha = 3$, $\mu/h^2 = 1/2$$(1, 0)$escape$u = 0$ at $\theta = 2.221$, equal to $\dfrac{\pi/2}{\sqrt{1/2}}$
$\alpha = 3$, $\mu = h^2$$(1, -0.1)$escape at $\theta = 10$$u = 1 - 0.1\theta$, zero at $\theta = 10$
$\alpha = 1$$(0.5, 0.3)$bounded$u \in [0.471, 1.653]$ over $100$ rad
Problem 43

Two Connected Particles through a Hole

Original statement · Problems.pdf, p. 30
Angular Momentum + EnergyIn-Class Session 8

We consider a smooth horizontal plane wih [sic] a small hole in it. One of the ends of a massless cord of length $2a$ is passed through the hole and then, two point particles, $P_1$ and $P_2$, each with the same mass $m$, are attached to the ends of the cord. Therefore, $P_1$ is constrained to move on the plane and $P_2$ moves along a vertical line below the hole.

Initially, half of the cord lies under the plane and half of the cord is on the plane. At that instant, $P_1$ is pushed with a speed $v_0$ perpendicular to the cord, counterclockwise as seen from above. Assume that the cord is always in tension.

Smooth horizontal plane with a small hole, particle P1 on the plane at distance r from the hole and particle P2 hanging below it, both of mass m
Figure: Smooth horizontal plane with a small hole, particle P1 on the plane at distance r from the hole and particle P2 hanging below it, both of mass m (Problems.pdf, p. 30).

Hint: the roots of the polynomial $-3x^3 + 7x^2 - 4$ are $x_1 = 1$, $x_2 = 2$ and $x_3 = -2/3$.

Worked Solution [ Click to Expand ]

Constraints, Degrees of Freedom & Coordinates

  • System: $P_1$ on a smooth horizontal plane at polar position $(r, \theta)$ and $P_2$ hanging on the vertical through the hole $O$, joined by an inextensible massless cord of length $2a$ that passes through $O$.
  • Hypotheses: inertial frame $S_0$ with $O$ at the hole; smooth hole and plane for parts (a) to (e); the cord stays taut ($T \gt 0$, checked in (e)); no drag.
  • Constraints (holonomic and scleronomic; the cord is unilateral in principle, so $T \ge 0$ is verified afterwards):
    • $P_1$ on the plane: $z_1 = 0$.
    • $P_2$ on the vertical through the hole: $x_2 = y_2 = 0$.
    • Cord of constant length: $r + \ell_2 = 2a$, where $\ell_2$ is the hanging length, so $z_2 = -\ell_2 = r - 2a$ ($Oz$ pointing up).
    • Geometric feasibility: $\ell_2 \ge 0$, i.e. $r \le 2a$ ($P_2$ cannot go above the hole). This is a unilateral limit that the solution must respect (see Phase 4).
  • Degrees of freedom: two particles have $6$ coordinates and there are $4$ independent constraints, so $\text{CDOF} = 6 - 4 = 2$.
  • Coordinates: $(r, \theta)$, polar coordinates of $P_1$ on the plane.
  • Initial state: $r(0) = a$, $\dot{r}(0) = 0$, $r(0)\dot{\theta}(0) = v_0$, hence $\dot{\theta}(0) = v_0/a$ and $\dot{z}_2(0) = 0$.
SymbolMeaningSI unit
$m$mass of each particlekg
$a$half of the cord lengthm
$v_0$initial speed of $P_1$m/s
$g$gravitational accelerationm/s$^2$
$\mu$friction coefficient (part f)1

Reference Frames & Vector Bases

  • Inertial frame: $S_0 = \{O; \mathbf{i}, \mathbf{j}, \mathbf{k}\}$, horizontal plane $z = 0$, $\mathbf{k}$ up.
  • Polar basis of $P_1$. $\mathcal{B}_1 = \{\mathbf{e}_r, \mathbf{e}_\theta, \mathbf{k}\}$ is the inertial basis rotated by $\theta(t)$ about $\mathbf{k}$:
$$ [{}_0 R_1] = \begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta & -\sin\theta & 0 \\ \sin\theta & \cos\theta & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \det[{}_0R_1] = 1, \qquad [{}_0R_1]^T[{}_0R_1] = I $$

Multiplying out, $RR^T$ has diagonal entries $\cos^2 + \sin^2 = 1$ of the rotation angle (and $1$) and off-diagonal entries $\pm(\cos\sin - \sin\cos) = 0$, so it is the identity.

  • $\boldsymbol{\omega}_{10} = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{k}$, so by Poisson $\dot{\mathbf{e}}_r = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_\theta$ and $\dot{\mathbf{e}}_\theta = -\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_r$. $P_2$ moves along $\mathbf{k}$, so it needs no extra basis.

Derivation

3.1 Kinematics

Pedagogical Justification: the constraints leave $r$ and $\theta$ free; the position of $P_2$ follows from the cord constraint $z_2 = r - 2a$. For $P_1$ we use the polar formulas of Problem 42 (product rule and Poisson).
$$ \mathbf{r}_1 = r\mathbf{e}_r, \qquad \mathbf{v}_1 = \dot{r}\,\mathbf{e}_r + r\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_\theta, \qquad \mathbf{a}_1 = \left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right)\mathbf{e}_r + \left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right)\mathbf{e}_\theta $$
$$ \mathbf{r}_2 = (r - 2a)\,\mathbf{k}, \qquad \mathbf{v}_2 = \dot{r}\,\mathbf{k}, \qquad \mathbf{a}_2 = \ddot{r}\,\mathbf{k} $$

3.2 Forces

  • On $P_1$: its weight $-mg\,\mathbf{k}$; the normal reaction of the smooth plane $N_1\,\mathbf{k}$ (unknown magnitude, vertical because the plane is smooth); and the tension of the cord $-T\,\mathbf{e}_r$ (the cord is horizontal on the plane and pulls toward the hole).
  • On $P_2$: its weight $-mg\,\mathbf{k}$, the tension $+T\,\mathbf{k}$ (same cord, massless, smooth hole) and the horizontal reaction of the vertical line $R_{2x}\,\mathbf{i} + R_{2y}\,\mathbf{j}$ that keeps $x_2 = y_2 = 0$ (unknown, to be determined).
  • Inertia forces: none, because the frame $S_0$ is inertial.
  • Unknowns: $r(t)$, $\theta(t)$, $T(t)$, $N_1(t)$, $R_{2x}(t)$ and $R_{2y}(t)$.

3.3 Equations of Motion

Pedagogical Justification: Newton's second law, one vector equation for each particle, gives six scalar equations. The vertical equation of $P_1$ and the horizontal ones of $P_2$ only fix reactions, so we project on the tangent directions of the constraints first.
$$ P_1,\ \mathbf{e}_r: \; m\left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right) = -T, \qquad P_1,\ \mathbf{e}_\theta: \; m\left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right) = 0, \qquad P_1,\ \mathbf{k}: \; 0 = N_1 - mg $$
$$ P_2,\ \mathbf{k}: \; m\ddot{r} = T - mg, \qquad P_2,\ \mathbf{i}: \; 0 = R_{2x}, \qquad P_2,\ \mathbf{j}: \; 0 = R_{2y} $$
  • Check of closure: six unknowns ($r$, $\theta$, $T$, $N_1$, $R_{2x}$, $R_{2y}$) and six equations. The reactions are decoupled: $N_1 = mg$ and $R_{2x} = R_{2y} = 0$, because $\mathbf{a}_2$ is parallel to $\mathbf{k}$. Only $r$, $\theta$ and $T$ remain, with three equations.
  • Dynamical decoupling. Adding the $\mathbf{e}_r$ equation of $P_1$ and the equation of $P_2$ eliminates $T$:
$$ m\left(2\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right) = -mg $$
  • Angular momentum. Multiplying the transverse equation by $r/m$ gives $\frac{d}{dt}\left(r^2\dot{\theta}\right) = r\left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right) = 0$, so $h = r^2\dot{\theta}$ is constant.
  • Energy. The tension does work $-T\dot{r}$ on $P_1$ and $+T\dot{r}$ on $P_2$, which cancel (inextensible cord); the plane does no work. With the kinetic energy $K = \tfrac{1}{2}m\left(\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}^2\right) + \tfrac{1}{2}m\dot{r}^2$ and $V = mgz_2 = mg(r - 2a)$, the energy is conserved. Replacing $r^2\dot{\theta}^2 = h^2/r^2$:
$$ E = K + V = m\dot{r}^2 + \frac{mh^2}{2r^2} + mg(r - 2a) = \text{const} $$

3.4 Integration and Answers

(a) Circular motion, $r \equiv a$
Pedagogical Justification: for $r$ constant, $\dot{r} = \ddot{r} = 0$, so $P_2$ is at rest and the cord tension must balance its weight, while $P_1$ moves on a circle under the tension alone. With $\dot{r} = 0$ the transverse equation gives $r\ddot{\theta} = 0$, so $\dot{\theta}$ is constant and equal to its initial value $v_0/a$ (equivalently $h = a^2\dot{\theta} = av_0$).
$$ P_1: \; m\left(0 - a\dot{\theta}^2\right) = -T \implies T = ma\dot{\theta}^2 = \frac{mv_0^2}{a}, \qquad P_2: \; 0 = T - mg \implies T = mg $$
$$ \frac{mv_0^2}{a} = mg \implies \boxed{v_0 = \sqrt{ag}} $$
(b) Tension in the circular case
$$ \boxed{T = mg} $$
(c) Quadratures for $v_0 = \sqrt{8ag/3}$
Pedagogical Justification: the two first integrals of 3.3 leave a single equation for $r(t)$. Evaluate $h$ and $E$ at the initial instant.
$$ h = r^2\dot{\theta} = a v_0 = a\sqrt{\frac{8ag}{3}} \implies h^2 = \frac{8}{3}a^3g, \qquad E(0) = \tfrac{1}{2}m v_0^2 + mg(a - 2a) = \tfrac{1}{2}m\cdot\frac{8ag}{3} - mga = \frac{1}{3}mga $$
  • Equating $E = E(0)$, dividing by $m$ and isolating $\dot{r}^2$:
$$ \dot{r}^2 + \frac{4a^3g}{3r^2} + gr - 2ga = \frac{1}{3}ga \implies \dot{r}^2 = \frac{7}{3}ga - gr - \frac{4a^3g}{3r^2} = \frac{g}{3r^2}\left(7ar^2 - 3r^3 - 4a^3\right) $$
  • Separating variables, with $P(r) \equiv -3r^3 + 7ar^2 - 4a^3$. The sign of $\dot{r}$ is $+$ in the first half-cycle, because $P_1$ starts at the inner turning point $r = a$ with $\ddot{r}(0) = -\tfrac{g}{2} + \tfrac{h^2}{2a^3} = \tfrac{5g}{6} \gt 0$ (from the radial equation of 3.3 with $\dot{\theta} = h/r^2$). Applying Barrow's rule from $r(0) = a$ on the left side and from $0$ to $t$ on the right side:
$$ \frac{dr}{dt} = +\sqrt{\frac{g}{3}}\,\frac{\sqrt{P(r)}}{r} \implies \int_a^r\frac{r'\,dr'}{\sqrt{P(r')}} = \sqrt{\frac{g}{3}}\int_0^t dt' = \sqrt{\frac{g}{3}}\,t, \qquad 0 \le t \le \frac{\tau_r}{2} $$

The integrand is improper at $r' = a$ (the radicand vanishes there) but integrable, since $P(r')$ has a simple root at $a$. After the outer turning point $r = 2a$, reached at $t = \tau_r/2$, the sign of $\dot{r}$ is $-$ and the quadrature restarts from $2a$:

$$ \int_r^{2a}\frac{r'\,dr'}{\sqrt{P(r')}} = \sqrt{\frac{g}{3}}\left(t - \frac{\tau_r}{2}\right), \qquad \frac{\tau_r}{2} \le t \le \tau_r $$

and the motion repeats with the radial period $\tau_r$ (see Phase 4).

  • Quadrature for the angle. With $\dot{\theta} = h/r^2$ and the same separation of variables, $d\theta = \dfrac{h}{r^2\dot{r}}\,dr$, and using $h/\sqrt{g/3} = \sqrt{8a^3}$. In the first half-cycle ($\theta(0) = \theta_0$) and in the second one:
$$ \theta(r) = \theta_0 + \sqrt{8a^3}\int_a^r\frac{dr'}{r'\sqrt{P(r')}}, \qquad \theta(r) = \theta(2a) + \sqrt{8a^3}\int_r^{2a}\frac{dr'}{r'\sqrt{P(r')}} $$

or, directly in time, $\theta(t) = \theta_0 + \displaystyle\int_0^t\frac{h}{r(t')^2}\,dt'$, which is valid for all $t$ because $\dot{\theta} = h/r^2 \gt 0$.

(d) Oscillation between $r = a$ and $r = 2a$
Pedagogical Justification: motion requires $\dot{r}^2 \ge 0$, i.e. $P(r) = -3r^3 + 7ar^2 - 4a^3 \ge 0$. With $x = r/a$ the polynomial is $a^3(-3x^3 + 7x^2 - 4)$, and the hint gives its roots.
$$ -3x^3 + 7x^2 - 4 = -(x - 1)(x - 2)(3x + 2) $$

(check: $(x - 1)(x - 2) = x^2 - 3x + 2$ and $(x^2 - 3x + 2)(3x + 2) = 3x^3 - 7x^2 + 4$).

  • Check of the roots: $x = 1$: $-3 + 7 - 4 = 0$; $x = 2$: $-24 + 28 - 4 = 0$; $x = -2/3$: $\frac{8}{9} + \frac{28}{9} - 4 = 0$. Since $r \gt 0$, $3x + 2 \gt 0$ and $P \ge 0$ requires $(x - 1)(x - 2) \le 0$:
$$ 1 \le x \le 2 \iff a \le r(t) \le 2a $$
  • The turning points ($\dot{r} = 0$) are $r_{\min} = a$ and $r_{\max} = 2a$. Both are simple roots of $P$, and the radial acceleration points back into the allowed interval at each one: $\ddot{r}(a) = \tfrac{5g}{6} \gt 0$ and $\ddot{r}(2a) = -\tfrac{g}{2} + \tfrac{h^2}{16a^3} = -\tfrac{g}{3} \lt 0$ (from $\ddot{r} = -\tfrac{g}{2} + \tfrac{h^2}{2r^3}$, derived in (e)). So $r$ reverses in finite time at both ends and the motion oscillates between them.
  • Feasibility: $r_{\max} = 2a$ is exactly the limit $\ell_2 = 2a - r \ge 0$ of Phase 1; at that instant $P_2$ reaches the hole with zero velocity.
(e) Tension of the cord
Pedagogical Justification: the equation of $P_2$ from 3.3 gives $T = m\left(g + \ddot{r}\right)$. We need $\ddot{r}$ as a function of $r$. It comes directly from the decoupled equation $2\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2 = -g$ of 3.3, with $\dot{\theta} = h/r^2$ (no division by $\dot{r}$ is needed):
$$ 2\ddot{r} = -g + \frac{h^2}{r^3} \implies \ddot{r} = -\frac{g}{2} + \frac{h^2}{2r^3} = -\frac{g}{2} + \frac{4a^3g}{3r^3} \qquad\left(h^2 = \tfrac{8}{3}a^3g\right) $$
  • Check by differentiating the energy integral of (c) (chain rule, $\frac{d}{dt}r^{-2} = -2r^{-3}\dot{r}$): $2\dot{r}\ddot{r} = \left(-g + \dfrac{8a^3g}{3r^3}\right)\dot{r}$, which gives the same $\ddot{r}$ wherever $\dot{r} \ne 0$.
$$ \boxed{T = mg\left(\frac{1}{2} + \frac{4a^3}{3r^3}\right)} $$
  • $T \gt 0$ for all $r \in [a, 2a]$, so the cord stays taut.
(f) Rough plane
Pedagogical Justification: Coulomb friction acts on $P_1$ opposite to its velocity, with magnitude $\mu N_1$. The normal force is $N_1 = mg$ (3.3), because the cord is horizontal on the plane and only the weight acts vertically.
$$ \mathbf{F}_f = -\mu mg\,\frac{\mathbf{v}_1}{\|\mathbf{v}_1\|} = -\mu mg\,\frac{\dot{r}\,\mathbf{e}_r + r\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_\theta}{\sqrt{\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}^2}} $$
$$ \mathbf{e}_r: \; m\left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right) = -T - \mu mg\frac{\dot{r}}{\sqrt{\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}^2}} $$
$$ \mathbf{e}_\theta: \; m\left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right) = -\mu mg\frac{r\dot{\theta}}{\sqrt{\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}^2}}, \qquad P_2: \; m\ddot{r} = T - mg $$
  • Adding the $\mathbf{e}_r$ equation and the $P_2$ equation eliminates $T$; multiplying the $\mathbf{e}_\theta$ equation by $r$ gives the evolution of $h$:
$$ 2\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2 = -g - \mu g\frac{\dot{r}}{\sqrt{\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}^2}}, \qquad \frac{d}{dt}\left(r^2\dot{\theta}\right) = -\mu g\,\frac{r^2\dot{\theta}}{\sqrt{\dot{r}^2 + r^2\dot{\theta}^2}} $$
  • Angular momentum and energy are no longer conserved (friction dissipates energy), so the problem cannot be reduced to the quadratures of (c).

Interpretation & Checks

  • Tension at the turning points: $T(a) = mg\left(\tfrac{1}{2} + \tfrac{4}{3}\right) = \tfrac{11}{6}mg$ and $T(2a) = mg\left(\tfrac{1}{2} + \tfrac{4}{24}\right) = \tfrac{2}{3}mg$, both positive.
  • Consistency with (a): for $v_0^2 = ag$, $h^2 = a^3g$ and $\ddot{r}(a) = -\tfrac{g}{2} + \tfrac{h^2}{2a^3} = 0$, so $r = a$ is an equilibrium of the radial equation, as expected for the circular case.
  • Radial period (consequence of (c) and (d)): $\tau_r = 2\sqrt{3/g}\int_a^{2a}r\,dr/\sqrt{P(r)}$. With $x = r/a$, $r\,dr = a^2x\,dx$ and $\sqrt{P} = a^{3/2}\sqrt{(x - 1)(2 - x)(3x + 2)}$, so $\tau_r = 2\sqrt{3a/g}\int_1^2x\,dx/\sqrt{(x - 1)(2 - x)(3x + 2)}$. Then with $x = \tfrac{3}{2} - \tfrac{1}{2}\cos s$ ($x = 1 \to s = 0$, $x = 2 \to s = \pi$), $(x - 1)(2 - x) = \tfrac{1}{4}\sin^2 s$ and $dx = \tfrac{1}{2}\sin s\,ds$, so $\tau_r = 2\sqrt{\dfrac{3a}{g}}\displaystyle\int_0^\pi\dfrac{x(s)\,ds}{\sqrt{3x(s) + 2}} \approx 6.342\sqrt{\dfrac{a}{g}}$.
  • Dimensions: $[T] = [m][g] = \text{N}$ and $[v_0] = \sqrt{[a][g]} = \text{m/s}$.
  • Feasibility: the outer turning point $r_{\max} = 2a$ puts $P_2$ at the hole with zero velocity ($\ell_2 = 0$), the limit of the constraint $r \le 2a$. The tension there, $T(2a) = \tfrac{2}{3}mg \gt 0$, shows that the cord is still taut, so the motion is admissible for the whole cycle.
  • Check against the official key: Problems.pdf has no entry for Problem 43 in its solution keys (the tension in (e) is given in the statement and is derived above). All results are therefore verified by independent derivation and by numerical integration.
  • Quadratures (Python, DOP853 on the equations of 3.3 with $a = g = 1$): from $r = a$ to $r = 1.5a$ the integral for $t$ gives $1.361538\sqrt{a/g}$ and the integral for $\theta$ gives $1.635065$ rad, both equal to the values of the direct integration to $10^{-10}$.
  • Symbolic check (sympy): $\dot{r}^2 = \dfrac{g\,(2a - r)(r - a)(2a + 3r)}{3r^2}$ with roots $r = a$ and $r = 2a$; the tension $m(g + \ddot{r})$ equals $mg\left(\tfrac{1}{2} + \tfrac{4a^3}{3r^3}\right)$ identically.
  • Numerical check (Python, DOP853 on $\ddot{r} = -g/2 + 4a^3g/(3r^3)$ with $a = g = m = 1$, $r(0) = 1$, $\dot{r}(0) = 0$): minimum and maximum radius $1.0000$ and $1.9991$ over the sampled steps (the turning point $2.0000$ is reached between samples), period $6.34243$ (the quadrature gives $6.34243$), and the energy residual stays below $5\times 10^{-12}$.
Problem 44

The Little Prince Throwing Seeds

Original statement · Problems.pdf, p. 31
Angular Momentum + Vis-Viva

The little Prince is on his spherical asteroid, which has radius $R$ and mass $M$, and does not rotate. While he sits at the equator, he throws a baobab seed with an initial velocity of magnitude $v_0$ and angle $\gamma = 60^\circ$ with respect to the local horizontal. Knowing that it reaches an apocenter of $r = 3R$ before falling back, determine $v_0$ as a function of the parameters of the problem and the universal gravitational constant $G$.

Worked Solution [ Click to Expand ]

Constraints, Degrees of Freedom & Coordinates

  • System: a seed of mass $m \ll M$ launched from the surface ($r_0 = R$) with speed $v_0$ at $\gamma = 60^\circ$ above the local horizontal; it reaches the apocenter $r_a = 3R$.
  • Hypotheses: spherically symmetric, non-rotating asteroid, so the gravitational force is central and conservative with $\mu = GM$; vacuum (no drag); inertial frame $S_0$ centred on the asteroid.
  • Constraints: none (the seed is a free particle once it leaves the surface), so $\text{CDOF} = 3$. The central force makes the motion planar, so $\text{CDOF} = 2$ with the coordinates $(r, \theta)$ in the orbital plane.
  • Initial state: $r = R$, radial component $v_{r0} = v_0\sin\gamma = \tfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2}v_0$ and transverse component $v_{\theta 0} = v_0\cos\gamma = \tfrac{1}{2}v_0$. At the apocenter $\dot{r} = 0$.
SymbolMeaningSI unit
$M$, $R$mass and radius of the asteroidkg, m
$G$universal gravitational constant, $6.6743\times 10^{-11}$m$^3$/(kg s$^2$)
$\mu = GM$gravitational parameterm$^3$/s$^2$
$\gamma$launch angle above the local horizontal (given: $60^\circ$)rad
$r_a$apocenter radius (given: $3R$)m
$v_0$launch speed (unknown)m/s

Reference Frames & Vector Bases

  • Inertial frame: $S_0 = \{O; \mathbf{i}, \mathbf{j}, \mathbf{k}\}$ with $O$ at the centre of the asteroid.
  • Polar basis in the orbital plane. $\mathcal{B}_1 = \{\mathbf{e}_r, \mathbf{e}_\theta, \mathbf{k}\}$ is the inertial basis rotated by the true anomaly $\theta$ about $\mathbf{k}$ (along $\mathbf{H}_O$):
$$ [{}_0 R_1] = \begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta & -\sin\theta & 0 \\ \sin\theta & \cos\theta & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \det[{}_0R_1] = 1, \qquad [{}_0R_1]^T[{}_0R_1] = I $$

Multiplying out, $RR^T$ has diagonal entries $\cos^2 + \sin^2 = 1$ of the rotation angle (and $1$) and off-diagonal entries $\pm(\cos\sin - \sin\cos) = 0$, so it is the identity.

  • $\boldsymbol{\omega}_{10} = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{k}$, so by Poisson $\dot{\mathbf{e}}_r = \dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_\theta$ and $\dot{\mathbf{e}}_\theta = -\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_r$.

Derivation

3.1 Kinematics

Pedagogical Justification: the product rule and Poisson's formula (as in Problem 42, 3.1) give the position, velocity and acceleration in the polar basis. The velocity is what the conservation laws need, and the acceleration is needed to write Newton's second law in 3.3.
$$ \mathbf{r} = r\mathbf{e}_r, \qquad \mathbf{v} = \dot{r}\,\mathbf{e}_r + r\dot{\theta}\,\mathbf{e}_\theta, \qquad \mathbf{a} = \left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right)\mathbf{e}_r + \left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right)\mathbf{e}_\theta $$
$$ h = \|\mathbf{r}\times\mathbf{v}\| = r^2\dot{\theta} = r\,v_\theta $$
  • At launch, $\dot{r} = v_0\sin\gamma$ and $r\dot{\theta} = v_0\cos\gamma$. At the apocenter $\dot{r} = 0$, so the velocity is purely transverse: $v_a = r_a\dot{\theta}_a$.

3.2 Forces

  • Applied force: the gravitation of the asteroid, $\mathbf{F} = -\dfrac{GMm}{r^2}\mathbf{e}_r$. It is central and conservative.
  • Constraint and inertia forces: none (free particle, inertial frame).
Pedagogical Justification: the potential energy per unit mass follows from Barrow's rule with the reference at infinity:
$$ V_0(r) = -\int_\infty^r\left(-\frac{GM}{s^2}\right)ds = GM\left[-\frac{1}{s}\right]_\infty^r = GM\left[-\frac{1}{r} - \lim_{s\to\infty}\left(-\frac{1}{s}\right)\right] = -\frac{GM}{r} $$

3.3 Equations of Motion

Pedagogical Justification: the unknowns are the orbit variables $r(t)$ and $\theta(t)$. Instead of integrating Newton's second law in time, we use its two first integrals, which follow from it and give the speed directly at two points (launch and apocenter), exactly what the question needs.
$$ m\left(\ddot{r} - r\dot{\theta}^2\right) = -\frac{GMm}{r^2}, \qquad m\left(r\ddot{\theta} + 2\dot{r}\dot{\theta}\right) = 0 $$
  • Angular momentum. The transverse equation times $r/m$ is $\frac{d}{dt}\left(r^2\dot{\theta}\right) = 0$, so $h = r^2\dot{\theta}$ is constant (the force is central).
  • Energy. The force is conservative, so $\xi = \tfrac{1}{2}v^2 - GM/r$ is constant. Both laws hold for the same particle between launch and apocenter.
  • Unknowns and equations: $v_0$ and $v_a$ are unknown, and there are two equations ($h$ and $\xi$ conservation), so the problem is closed.

3.4 Integration and Answers

Conservation of specific angular momentum
Pedagogical Justification: evaluate $h$ at launch and at the apocenter, where $v_a = r_a\dot{\theta}_a$.
$$ h = R\left(v_0\cos\gamma\right) = \frac{1}{2}Rv_0, \qquad h = r_av_a = 3Rv_a \implies v_a = \frac{h}{3R} = \frac{\tfrac{1}{2}Rv_0}{3R} = \frac{v_0}{6} $$
Conservation of specific energy
Pedagogical Justification: the energy takes the same value at launch and at the apocenter.
$$ \frac{1}{2}v_0^2 - \frac{GM}{R} = \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{v_0}{6}\right)^2 - \frac{GM}{3R} = \frac{v_0^2}{72} - \frac{GM}{3R} $$
Solving for $v_0$
$$ \left(\frac{1}{2} - \frac{1}{72}\right)v_0^2 = \left(1 - \frac{1}{3}\right)\frac{GM}{R} \implies \frac{35}{72}v_0^2 = \frac{2}{3}\frac{GM}{R} \implies v_0^2 = \frac{2}{3}\cdot\frac{72}{35}\frac{GM}{R} = \frac{48}{35}\frac{GM}{R} $$
$$ \boxed{v_0 = \sqrt{\frac{48}{35}\,\frac{GM}{R}}} $$

Interpretation & Checks

  • Bound orbit: the escape speed at the surface is $v_e = \sqrt{2GM/R}$, i.e. $v_e^2 = \tfrac{70}{35}GM/R$. Since $\tfrac{48}{35} \lt 2$, $v_0 \lt v_e$ and the orbit is an ellipse: the seed falls back.
  • Orbital parameters: $h^2 = \tfrac{1}{4}R^2v_0^2 = \tfrac{12}{35}GMR$ and the semi-latus rectum $p = h^2/\mu = \tfrac{12}{35}R$. From $r_a = p/(1 - e) = 3R$: $1 - e = \tfrac{4}{35}$ and $e = \tfrac{31}{35} \approx 0.8857$. The periapsis of the full conic is $r_p = p/(1 + e) = \tfrac{2}{11}R \lt R$, inside the asteroid.
  • Physical arc. On the orbit $r = p/(1 + e\cos\theta)$ the seed leaves the surface where $1 + e\cos\theta_0 = p/R$, i.e. $\cos\theta_0 = -\tfrac{23}{31}$ with $\sin\theta_0 \gt 0$ (the seed is moving away from the centre, $\dot{r}_0 \gt 0$), so $\theta_0 \approx 137.9^\circ$. It passes the apocenter at $\theta = \pi$ and lands where $r = R$ again, at $\theta = 2\pi - \theta_0 \approx 222.1^\circ$. The part of the conic that contains the periapsis ($\theta = 0$) is inside the asteroid and is not travelled: the seed describes about $84^\circ$ of orbit and falls back.
  • Independent check with the Binet solution. The orbit equation of Problem 42 for $\alpha = 2$ is $u'' + u = \mu/h^2$, with the first integral $\left(u - \mu/h^2\right)^2 + (u')^2 = \left(\mu e/h^2\right)^2$ that defines the eccentricity. The launch data give $u_0 = 1/R$ and $u_0' = -\dot{r}_0/h = -\dfrac{(\sqrt{3}/2)v_0}{(1/2)Rv_0} = -\dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{R}$, so
$$ \frac{\mu e}{h^2} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{1}{R} - \frac{35}{12R}\right)^2 + \frac{3}{R^2}} = \sqrt{\frac{529}{144R^2} + \frac{432}{144R^2}} = \frac{31}{12R} \implies e = \frac{31}{12R}\cdot\frac{12R}{35} = \frac{31}{35} $$
  • This eccentricity, obtained from the launch conditions alone, reproduces the prescribed apocenter: $r_a = \dfrac{p}{1 - e} = \dfrac{12R/35}{4/35} = 3R$. The value of $v_0$ found from energy and angular momentum is therefore consistent with a second, independent formulation.
  • Limiting cases of the general result. Repeating the algebra with $r_a$ and $\gamma$ as symbols ($h = Rv_0\cos\gamma$, $v_a = (R/r_a)v_0\cos\gamma$):
$$ v_0^2 = \frac{2\mu\left(\frac{1}{R} - \frac{1}{r_a}\right)}{1 - \left(\frac{R}{r_a}\right)^2\cos^2\gamma} $$

For $r_a = 3R$ and $\gamma = 60^\circ$ the denominator is $1 - \tfrac{1}{9}\cdot\tfrac{1}{4} = \tfrac{35}{36}$ and $v_0^2 = \tfrac{4}{3}\cdot\tfrac{36}{35}\,\mu/R = \tfrac{48}{35}\,\mu/R$. As $r_a \to \infty$, $v_0^2 \to 2\mu/R$, the escape speed. For $\gamma = 90^\circ$ (vertical launch) $v_0^2 = 2\mu\left(1/R - 1/r_a\right)$, the energy balance of a radial flight. For $\gamma = 0$ and $r_a \to R$ the quotient tends to $\mu/R$, the circular speed.

  • Dimensions: $[v_0] = \sqrt{[G][M]/[R]} = \sqrt{\dfrac{\text{m}^3}{\text{kg}\,\text{s}^2}\cdot\dfrac{\text{kg}}{\text{m}}} = \text{m/s}$.
  • Check against the official key: Problems.pdf has no entry for Problem 44 in its solution keys, so the result is verified by independent derivation: sympy solves the energy equation and returns $v_0^2 = \tfrac{48}{35}GM/R$, and the eccentricity obtained from the launch data reproduces the prescribed apocenter $r_a = 3R$.
  • Numerical check (Python, DOP853 integration of $\ddot{\mathbf{r}} = -\mu\mathbf{r}/r^3$ with $\mu = R = 1$ and $v_0 = \sqrt{48/35}$, $\gamma = 60^\circ$): the maximum radius reached is $2.99998R$ (sampling resolution of the output) and the speed there is $0.16668\,v_0$, in agreement with $r_a = 3R$ and $v_a = v_0/6$.
← Previous Topic Topic 3: Constraints and Reaction Forces Theory Reference Review Topic Theory → Back to Syllabus → Problems Hub