2nd Midterm: Exam-Style Problems

20 exam-style problems written for this portal. Part II of Assessment Test II this year is two problems: a longer one on phase diagrams (3 points: a binary diagram with its invariant reactions, the lever rule and the microconstituents, or the steels of the Fe-Fe3C diagram) and a shorter one on the mechanical properties of Unit 5 (2 points: a tensile test or a loaded bar). These are practice items, not official exercises. The Exam simulator draws one of each after the test.

Problem 1 · Phase diagrams (3 points) 12 problems

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Binary diagram with intermetallics and invariant reactions · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P01 — Two eutectics around a congruently melting compound in a hypothetical A-B system

The figure shows the equilibrium phase diagram of a hypothetical binary system A-B (composition in wt% B). Every invariant temperature and the compositions of the phases on each invariant line are printed on the diagram.

0 (A) 20 40 60 80 100 (B) 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 Composition (wt% B) Temperature (°C) 700 °C 10 35 60 850 °C 60 78 92 900 °C 1050 °C 1150 °C L α α + L α + γ γ + L γ + L γ + β β γ β + L
Figure 1. Hypothetical A-B phase diagram (wt% B): α and β terminal solid solutions, compound γ of 60 wt% B melting at 1150 °C, eutectics at 700 °C (α 10, L 35, γ 60) and 850 °C (γ 60, L 78, β 92); A melts at 900 °C and B at 1050 °C.

a) Determine all the invariant reactions: type of reaction, temperature and composition of every phase involved.

b) For an alloy A-50 wt% B at 700 − ΔT °C, give the phases present with their compositions and amounts, and the microconstituents present with their amounts.

c) Sketch the microstructure of an alloy A-20 wt% B at 700 + ΔT °C and at 700 − ΔT °C, labelling every microconstituent and giving its amount.

d) Indicate whether the intermetallic compound γ melts congruently or incongruently, and give the maximum solubility of B in A and of A in B, with the temperature at which each is observed.

Data and model

Data read on the diagram

ItemValue read on the figure
Melting point of A900 °C (left axis)
Melting point of B1050 °C (right axis)
Compound γvertical line at 60 wt% B, top of the liquidus at 1150 °C
Invariant line at 700 °Cα 10 wt% B, L 35 wt% B, γ 60 wt% B
Invariant line at 850 °Cγ 60 wt% B, L 78 wt% B, β 92 wt% B
Alloys$C_0$ = 50 wt% B (part b), $C_0$ = 20 wt% B (part c)

Unit conversion: a composition in wt% is a mass fraction times 100, so 50 wt% B means 0.50 kg of B per kg of alloy. The lever rule uses the ratio of two differences of compositions, so the fractions it gives are dimensionless mass fractions whether the compositions are written in wt% or as fractions. No formula of this problem needs kelvin, so the temperatures stay in °C.

Model

  • Invariant reactions [Session 8 Slide 6]: three phases coexist on a horizontal line at a fixed temperature. On cooling, eutectic $L \rightarrow \alpha + \beta$ (a liquid field ends in a V on the line), peritectic $\alpha + L \rightarrow \beta$ (a solid field ends in an inverted V below the line), eutectoid $\gamma \rightarrow \alpha + \beta$ and peritectoid $\alpha + \beta \rightarrow \gamma$ in the solid state.
  • Tie line and lever rule [Session 7 Slides 15-16]: in a two-phase field, the horizontal line through the alloy point gives the compositions of the two phases at its ends; each phase takes the arm on the side of the other phase, divided by the length of the tie line.
  • Microconstituents [Session 7 Slides 30-32]: the primary (proeutectic) constituent is counted on the tie line just above the eutectic temperature, where the remaining liquid has the eutectic composition and becomes the eutectic; the total phases are counted on the tie line just below it.
  • Intermetallic compounds and melting [Session 8 Slides 14-15, 17]: a stoichiometric compound is a vertical line; it melts congruently when it sits at a maximum of the liquidus (the liquid keeps its composition) and incongruently when it ends at a peritectic line.
  • Hypotheses: equilibrium cooling, pressure fixed at 1 atm, values read on the figure as printed.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Determine all the invariant reactions, with their type, temperature and the composition of every phase

Find the three-phase lines on the diagram

The diagram has two horizontal lines, at 700 °C (from 10 to 60 wt% B) and at 850 °C (from 60 to 92 wt% B). By the Gibbs phase rule at constant pressure, $F = C - P + 1$ [Session 7 Slide 13], three phases in a two-component system leave $F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$, so a three-phase equilibrium can only appear as a horizontal line at one temperature with three fixed compositions. Those are the invariant reactions [Session 8 Slide 6].

Classify the line at 700 °C

Above the line, between 10 and 60 wt% B, there are two fields, α + L and γ + L, whose liquidus branches fall from 900 °C (pure A) and from 1150 °C (γ) and meet in a V at 35 wt% B on the line. Below the line there is the single two-solid field α + γ. A liquid that ends in a V on the line and gives two solids below it is a eutectic [Session 8 Slide 6]. Reading the three points on the figure, on cooling:

$$L\,(35\ \text{wt\% B}) \;\xrightarrow{\;700\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \alpha\,(10\ \text{wt\% B}) + \gamma\,(60\ \text{wt\% B}) \qquad \text{eutectic}$$

Classify the line at 850 °C

Between 60 and 92 wt% B the liquidus falls from the maximum of γ (1150 °C) and from the melting point of B (1050 °C) to a V at 78 wt% B on the line; below the line lies γ + β. Again a liquid gives two solids, so this is a second eutectic:

$$L\,(78\ \text{wt\% B}) \;\xrightarrow{\;850\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \gamma\,(60\ \text{wt\% B}) + \beta\,(92\ \text{wt\% B}) \qquad \text{eutectic}$$

Check that no other point is invariant

The melting points of A (900 °C) and B (1050 °C) and the maximum of γ (1150 °C) are points where one solid melts to a liquid of its own composition; they behave as one-component transformations ($F = 1 - 2 + 1 = 0$ with the composition fixed) and involve two phases, not three, so they are not invariant reactions of the binary system. Each eutectic temperature lies below the melting points of its two neighbouring solids (700 < 900 and 700 < 1150; 850 < 1150 and 850 < 1050), as a eutectic must.

Key results
  • 700 °C, eutectic: L (35 wt% B) → α (10 wt% B) + γ (60 wt% B).
  • 850 °C, eutectic: L (78 wt% B) → γ (60 wt% B) + β (92 wt% B).
  • The maximum of γ at 1150 °C is a congruent melting point, not a three-phase reaction.

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Phases and microconstituents of A-50 wt% B at 700 − ΔT °C

Locate the alloy and derive the lever rule

The alloy, 50 wt% B, lies between the eutectic composition (35) and γ (60), so on cooling it first crosses the γ liquidus and forms primary γ. Just below 700 °C it lies in the α + γ field. On a tie line with phases α and γ the two mass balances are, for the alloy and for B [Session 7 Slide 16]:

$$W_\alpha + W_\gamma = 1 \qquad W_\alpha C_\alpha + W_\gamma C_\gamma = C_0$$

Substituting $W_\gamma = 1 - W_\alpha$ in the second balance:

$$W_\alpha C_\alpha + (1 - W_\alpha) C_\gamma = C_0$$
$$W_\alpha (C_\alpha - C_\gamma) = C_0 - C_\gamma$$

Dividing by $(C_\alpha - C_\gamma)$ and changing the sign of numerator and denominator:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\gamma - C_0}{C_\gamma - C_\alpha} \qquad W_\gamma = 1 - W_\alpha = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\gamma - C_\alpha}$$

This is the lever rule: each phase takes the arm on the side of the other phase.

Apply it to the phases just below 700 °C

Tie line read on the figure: $C_\alpha$ = 10 wt% B, $C_\gamma$ = 60 wt% B, length 60 − 10 = 50 wt% B.

$$W_\alpha = \frac{60 - 50}{60 - 10} = \frac{10}{50} = 0.200 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{50 - 10}{60 - 10} = \frac{40}{50} = 0.800$$

Count the microconstituents on the tie line just above 700 °C

Just above 700 °C the alloy is γ (60 wt% B) + liquid that has reached the eutectic composition, 35 wt% B. All that liquid becomes eutectic at 700 °C, and the γ already present stays as primary γ. The same lever rule on the tie line from L (35) to γ (60), length 25 wt% B:

$$W_{\gamma,\text{primary}} = \frac{C_0 - C_E}{C_\gamma - C_E} = \frac{50 - 35}{60 - 35} = \frac{15}{25} = 0.600 \qquad W_{E} = W_{L}(700 + \Delta T) = \frac{60 - 50}{60 - 35} = \frac{10}{25} = 0.400$$

Split the eutectic into its phases

All the α of the alloy is inside the eutectic (there is no primary α), so eutectic α = $W_\alpha$ = 0.200. The γ inside the eutectic is the total γ minus the primary γ:

$$W_{\gamma,\text{eutectic}} = W_\gamma - W_{\gamma,\text{primary}} = 0.800 - 0.600 = 0.200$$

Check: $0.200 + 0.200 = 0.400 = W_E$. The eutectic itself has the composition 35 wt% B, so inside it the fraction of α is $(60 - 35)/(60 - 10) = 25/50 = 0.500$, and $0.500 \times 0.400 = 0.200$, the same eutectic α.

Answer and checks

At 700 − ΔT °C: phases α (10 wt% B, 20.0 %) and γ (60 wt% B, 80.0 %); microconstituents primary γ (60.0 %) and eutectic α + γ (40.0 %). B balance: $0.200 \times 10 + 0.800 \times 60 = 2 + 48 = 50$ wt% B $= C_0$.

Key results
  • Phases at 700 − ΔT °C: α (10 wt% B) 0.200 and γ (60 wt% B) 0.800.
  • Microconstituents: primary γ 0.600 and eutectic (α + γ) 0.400.
  • Inside the eutectic: eutectic α 0.200 and eutectic γ 0.200 of the alloy.

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Sketch the microstructure of A-20 wt% B at 700 + ΔT and 700 − ΔT °C

Follow the cooling path to the eutectic line

The vertical line of 20 wt% B crosses the α liquidus (at about 800 °C, a reading of the figure): grains of primary α nucleate and grow, while the liquid becomes richer in B along the liquidus. Just above 700 °C the α has 10 wt% B and the liquid 35 wt% B, the eutectic composition [Session 7 Slides 30-31].

Amounts at 700 + ΔT °C

Lever rule derived in part (b), on the tie line from α (10) to L (35), length 25 wt% B:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{35 - 20}{35 - 10} = \frac{15}{25} = 0.600 \qquad W_L = \frac{20 - 10}{35 - 10} = \frac{10}{25} = 0.400$$

Amounts at 700 − ΔT °C

At 700 °C the liquid (0.400) transforms at constant temperature into the eutectic $L \rightarrow \alpha + \gamma$; the primary α (0.600) does not change. The total phases come from the tie line from α (10) to γ (60), length 50:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{60 - 20}{60 - 10} = \frac{40}{50} = 0.800 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{20 - 10}{60 - 10} = \frac{10}{50} = 0.200$$

The eutectic holds all the γ (0.200) and $0.800 - 0.600 = 0.200$ of α, and $0.200 + 0.200 = 0.400$, the eutectic fraction.

The sketches

Left: rounded grains of primary α (60 %) surrounded by liquid. Right: the same α grains, now surrounded by a lamellar eutectic of alternating α and γ layers (40 %).

primary α liquid L 700 + ΔT °C primary α eutectic (α + γ) 700 − ΔT °C
Figure 2. A-20 wt% B: left, at 700 + ΔT °C, primary α grains (60 %) in liquid of 35 wt% B (40 %); right, at 700 − ΔT °C, the same primary α grains in the lamellar eutectic α + γ (40 %).
Key results
  • 700 + ΔT °C: primary α (10 wt% B) 0.600 in liquid (35 wt% B) 0.400.
  • 700 − ΔT °C: primary α 0.600 in eutectic α + γ 0.400; total phases α 0.800 and γ 0.200.

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Melting of γ and maximum solubilities

Classify the melting of γ

The vertical line of γ (60 wt% B) reaches the liquidus at its maximum, 1150 °C: heated to that point, γ gives a liquid of 60 wt% B, its own composition, and no other solid appears. By Session 8 Slide 17 that is congruent melting. Had γ ended at a horizontal peritectic line below the liquidus, it would decompose into a liquid plus another solid (incongruent melting); this diagram has no peritectic line.

Maximum solubility of B in A

The α field is bounded by the solidus (from 900 °C) and the solvus (down to 200 °C); both meet the eutectic line at 10 wt% B, the widest point of the field. So α dissolves at most 10 wt% B, at 700 °C; below 700 °C the solvus moves back towards A and the solubility falls.

Maximum solubility of A in B

The β field is widest where its boundaries meet the 850 °C line, at 92 wt% B, so β holds at most

$$100 - 92 = 8\ \text{wt\% A}$$

at 850 °C.

Key results
  • γ melts congruently at 1150 °C (maximum of the liquidus).
  • Maximum solubility of B in A (α): 10 wt% B at 700 °C.
  • Maximum solubility of A in B (β): 100 − 92 = 8 wt% A at 850 °C.

Interpretation and checks

The compound γ splits the diagram into two simple eutectic sub-systems, A-γ and γ-B, each read exactly like Pb-Sn: a hypoeutectic alloy of the A-γ side (20 wt% B) gives primary α in an α + γ eutectic, a hypereutectic one (50 wt% B) gives primary γ. Control cases of the lever rule: as $C_0 \to 35$ wt% B the primary γ of part (b) tends to $(35-35)/25 = 0$ and the alloy becomes 100 % eutectic; as $C_0 \to 60$ it tends to 1. All fractions lie between 0 and 1 and add up to 1. Dimensions: the lever rule is a ratio of compositions (wt% over wt%), so every fraction is dimensionless, as a mass fraction must be. A common exam mistake is to give the primary γ from the tie line below 700 °C ($W_\gamma$ = 0.800): that number is the total γ, which also contains the γ inside the eutectic.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Binary diagram with intermetallics and invariant reactions · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P02 — Alloy composition from the eutectic fraction in an M-N system with an incongruent compound (at%)

The figure shows the equilibrium phase diagram of a hypothetical binary system M-N, with the composition in atomic percent of N. The intermediate phase δ is the stoichiometric compound MN₂.

0 (M) 20 40 60 80 100 (N) 300 500 700 900 1100 1300 1500 Composition (at% N) Temperature (°C) 1000 °C 25 66.7 78 600 °C 66.7 92 98 1400 °C 700 °C L α α + L α + δ δ + L δ + β δ β + L β
Figure 1. Hypothetical M-N phase diagram (at% N): α solid solution, compound δ = MN₂ (66.7 at% N) formed by a peritectic reaction at 1000 °C (α 25, δ 66.7, L 78), eutectic at 600 °C (δ 66.7, L 92, β 98); M melts at 1400 °C and N at 700 °C.

a) Write all the invariant reactions: type, temperature and composition (at% N) of every phase involved.

b) Does δ melt congruently or incongruently? Give the phases and their amounts when δ is heated to 1000 + ΔT °C, and the maximum solubility of N in M and of M in N, with their temperatures.

c) A slowly cooled M-N alloy, examined just below 600 °C, shows grains of primary δ surrounded by 30.0 % of eutectic microconstituent (atom fraction 0.300). Find the composition of the alloy.

d) For the alloy of part (c), give the phases present, their compositions and their amounts at 1000 + ΔT °C, at 1000 − ΔT °C and at 600 − ΔT °C.

Data and model

Data read on the diagram

ItemValue read on the figure
Melting pointsM 1400 °C, N 700 °C
Compound δ = MN₂vertical line at 66.7 at% N, from the 1000 °C line down
Invariant line at 1000 °Cα 25 at% N, δ 66.7 at% N, L 78 at% N
Invariant line at 600 °Cδ 66.7 at% N, L 92 at% N, β 98 at% N
Microstructure of part (c)primary δ + eutectic, $x_E$ = 0.300 just below 600 °C

Units: the axis is in at% N, so a composition of 66.7 at% N means 0.667 mol of N atoms per mol of atoms. The lever rule is a ratio of composition differences, so on an atomic axis it gives atom (mole) fractions $x$ of each phase or constituent; this reading of the lever rule on an at% axis is an extension of Session 7 Slide 16, where the axis is in wt% and the fractions are mass fractions $W$ (the same construction, with the balance written for atoms instead of mass). The value 66.7 is $2/3 \times 100$, the N content of MN₂ (two N atoms out of three).

Model

  • Invariant reactions [Session 8 Slide 6]: eutectic $L \rightarrow \alpha + \beta$; peritectic $\alpha + L \rightarrow \beta$, where a solid field ends in an inverted V below the line [Session 8 Slides 8-9].
  • Gibbs phase rule at constant pressure, $F = C - P + 1$ [Session 7 Slide 13]: three phases of two components give $F = 0$, a horizontal line.
  • Lever rule on a tie line [Session 7 Slides 15-16]; microconstituents counted on the tie line just above the eutectic line [Session 7 Slides 30-32].
  • Congruent and incongruent melting [Session 8 Slide 17]: a compound at a maximum of the liquidus melts congruently; one ending at a peritectic line melts incongruently (liquid plus another solid).
  • Hypotheses: equilibrium cooling (complete peritectic reaction, no coring), 1 atm, compositions read on the figure as printed.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Write all the invariant reactions

Why horizontal lines are the invariant reactions

With $C = 2$ and $P = 3$ the phase rule gives $F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$ [Session 7 Slide 13]: temperature and the three compositions are fixed, so every three-phase equilibrium is one horizontal line. The diagram has two of them.

Classify the line at 1000 °C

The line runs from α (25) to L (78). Above it lies the two-phase field α + L. Below it, the vertical line of δ (66.7) starts at the line and splits it into α + δ (left) and δ + L (right): a new solid appears below the line between the two phases above it, the inverted V of a peritectic [Session 8 Slides 8-9]. On cooling:

$$\alpha\,(25\ \text{at\% N}) + L\,(78\ \text{at\% N}) \;\xrightarrow{\;1000\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \delta\,(66.7\ \text{at\% N}) \qquad \text{peritectic}$$

Classify the line at 600 °C

The liquidus of δ falls from 78 at% N at 1000 °C and the liquidus of β falls from 700 °C (pure N); they meet in a V at 92 at% N on the line, and below it lies δ + β. A liquid that gives two solids is a eutectic:

$$L\,(92\ \text{at\% N}) \;\xrightarrow{\;600\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \delta\,(66.7\ \text{at\% N}) + \beta\,(98\ \text{at\% N}) \qquad \text{eutectic}$$

Check

Each reaction has the composition of the product (or the liquid of the eutectic) between the other two: $25 < 66.7 < 78$ and $66.7 < 92 < 98$. The eutectic temperature, 600 °C, is below the melting point of N (700 °C) and below the temperature at which δ stops existing (1000 °C).

Key results
  • 1000 °C, peritectic: α (25 at% N) + L (78 at% N) → δ (66.7 at% N).
  • 600 °C, eutectic: L (92 at% N) → δ (66.7 at% N) + β (98 at% N).

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Melting of δ, decomposition at 1000 + ΔT °C and maximum solubilities

Classify the melting of δ

The δ line stops at 1000 °C, on the peritectic line, well below the liquidus. Heating δ through 1000 °C runs the peritectic backwards, $\delta \rightarrow \alpha + L$: the compound gives a liquid of a different composition (78 at% N) plus another solid (α). By Session 8 Slide 17 this is incongruent melting.

Derive the lever rule for atom fractions

Just above 1000 °C the δ composition, $C_0$ = 66.7 at% N, lies in α + L on the tie line from α (25) to L (78). The atoms of the alloy are shared by the two phases, and so are the N atoms:

$$x_\alpha + x_L = 1 \qquad x_\alpha C_\alpha + x_L C_L = C_0$$

Substituting $x_L = 1 - x_\alpha$:

$$x_\alpha C_\alpha + (1 - x_\alpha) C_L = C_0$$
$$x_\alpha (C_\alpha - C_L) = C_0 - C_L$$
$$x_\alpha = \frac{C_L - C_0}{C_L - C_\alpha} \qquad x_L = 1 - x_\alpha = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha}$$

Amounts at 1000 + ΔT °C

Tie line length $78 - 25 = 53$ at% N:

$$x_\alpha = \frac{78 - 66.7}{78 - 25} = \frac{11.3}{53} = 0.213 \qquad x_L = \frac{66.7 - 25}{78 - 25} = \frac{41.7}{53} = 0.787$$

Most of the compound turns into liquid, and about a fifth of its atoms stay as solid α.

Maximum solubilities

The α field is widest where it touches the peritectic line, at 25 at% N: N dissolves in M up to 25 at% N at 1000 °C. The β field touches the eutectic line at 98 at% N, so M dissolves in N up to

$$100 - 98 = 2\ \text{at\% M}$$

at 600 °C.

Key results
  • δ melts incongruently (it ends at the peritectic line, 1000 °C).
  • At 1000 + ΔT °C, δ has become α (25 at% N) 0.213 + L (78 at% N) 0.787.
  • Maximum solubility of N in M: 25 at% N at 1000 °C; of M in N: 2 at% M at 600 °C.

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Composition of the alloy with primary δ and 30.0 % eutectic

Choose the side of the eutectic

The eutectic microconstituent at 600 °C forms from alloys between 66.7 and 98 at% N. Those between 66.7 and 92 at% N reach 600 °C with primary δ, those between 92 and 98 at% N with primary β. The alloy shows primary δ, so $66.7 < C_0 < 92$.

Write the eutectic fraction with the lever rule

Just above 600 °C the alloy is δ (66.7) + liquid of eutectic composition (92). All that liquid becomes eutectic, so the eutectic fraction is the liquid fraction on this tie line (lever rule of part b):

$$x_E = x_L(600 + \Delta T) = \frac{C_0 - C_\delta}{C_E - C_\delta}$$

Isolate the composition

Multiply both sides by $(C_E - C_\delta)$:

$$x_E\,(C_E - C_\delta) = C_0 - C_\delta$$

Add $C_\delta$ to both sides:

$$C_0 = C_\delta + x_E\,(C_E - C_\delta)$$

Substitute $x_E$ = 0.300, $C_\delta$ = 66.7 and $C_E$ = 92 at% N:

$$C_0 = 66.7 + 0.300 \times (92 - 66.7) = 66.7 + 0.300 \times 25.3 = 66.7 + 7.59 = 74.29\ \text{at\% N}$$

Check

$66.7 < 74.29 < 92$, as required. Back-substitution: $(74.29 - 66.7)/(92 - 66.7) = 7.59/25.3 = 0.300$. The primary δ is $1 - 0.300 = 0.700$. The other root, from the hypereutectic side, $x_E = (98 - C_0)/(98 - 92)$, would give $C_0 = 98 - 0.300 \times 6 = 96.2$ at% N, but that alloy has primary β, not δ, so it is rejected.

Key results
  • The alloy is between δ (66.7) and the eutectic point (92), because its primary constituent is δ.
  • $C_0$ = 74.29 at% N (about 74.3 at% N).

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Phases of the alloy M-74.29 at% N at 1000 ± ΔT and 600 − ΔT °C

Just above the peritectic line

The alloy, 74.29 at% N, lies on the tie line from α (25) to L (78), length 53:

$$x_\alpha = \frac{78 - 74.29}{78 - 25} = \frac{3.71}{53} = 0.0700 \qquad x_L = \frac{74.29 - 25}{78 - 25} = \frac{49.29}{53} = 0.930$$

Just below the peritectic line

At 1000 °C all the α reacts with part of the liquid to form δ. Since $C_0 = 74.29 > 66.7$, the α runs out first and liquid is left over (as for alloy 2 of Session 8 Slide 9). Tie line from δ (66.7) to L (78), length 11.3:

$$x_\delta = \frac{78 - 74.29}{78 - 66.7} = \frac{3.71}{11.3} = 0.328 \qquad x_L = \frac{74.29 - 66.7}{78 - 66.7} = \frac{7.59}{11.3} = 0.672$$

Just below the eutectic line

Between 1000 and 600 °C more δ grows from the liquid, which follows the liquidus to 92 at% N; at 600 °C the remaining liquid (0.300, part c) becomes eutectic δ + β. Tie line from δ (66.7) to β (98), length 31.3:

$$x_\delta = \frac{98 - 74.29}{98 - 66.7} = \frac{23.71}{31.3} = 0.758 \qquad x_\beta = \frac{74.29 - 66.7}{98 - 66.7} = \frac{7.59}{31.3} = 0.242$$

Check with the microconstituents

The δ total (0.758) is primary δ (0.700) plus eutectic δ, so the eutectic δ is 0.0575 and the eutectic β 0.242; together $0.0575 + 0.242 = 0.300 = x_E$. N balance at 600 − ΔT: $0.758 \times 66.7 + 0.242 \times 98 = 50.56 + 23.72 = 74.28$ at% N, equal to $C_0$ = 74.29 within the rounding of the fractions.

Key results
  • 1000 + ΔT °C: α (25 at% N) 0.0700 and L (78 at% N) 0.930.
  • 1000 − ΔT °C: δ (66.7 at% N) 0.328 and L (78 at% N) 0.672.
  • 600 − ΔT °C: δ (66.7 at% N) 0.758 and β (98 at% N) 0.242.

Interpretation and checks

δ cannot be melted as a single liquid of its own composition: it decomposes at 1000 °C into a liquid and the M-rich α, which is why it ends in a peritectic and not at a maximum of the liquidus. The fraction of eutectic is a fingerprint of the composition: on the δ side it grows linearly from 0 at 66.7 at% N to 1 at 92 at% N, so a measured eutectic fraction fixes $C_0$ uniquely once the primary constituent is known. Limiting cases: $x_E \to 0$ gives $C_0 \to 66.7$ (pure δ) and $x_E \to 1$ gives $C_0 \to 92$ (fully eutectic). Dimensions: every fraction is at% over at%, dimensionless, and every composition stays between the ends of its tie line. Common mistake: using mass fractions or quoting the result in wt%; on an at% diagram the lever rule gives atom fractions, and converting to wt% would need the atomic masses of M and N, which the problem does not give.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Binary diagram with intermetallics and invariant reactions · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P03 — Cooling an X-40 wt% Y alloy through a peritectic, a eutectic and a eutectoid

The figure shows the equilibrium phase diagram of a hypothetical binary system X-Y (composition in wt% Y). γ is an intermetallic compound of 55 wt% Y; β is an intermediate solid solution that exists only between 1100 and 600 °C.

0 (X) 20 40 60 80 100 (Y) 300 500 700 800 1000 1200 1300 Composition (wt% Y) Temperature (°C) 1100 °C 15 30 45 900 °C 38 50 55 650 °C 55 80 95 600 °C 10 25 55 1300 °C 800 °C 1000 °C L α + L α β α + β β + L β + γ α + γ γ + L γ + δ γ γ + L δ + L δ
Figure 1. Hypothetical X-Y phase diagram (wt% Y): peritectic at 1100 °C (α 15, β 30, L 45), eutectic at 900 °C (β 38, L 50, γ 55), compound γ of 55 wt% Y melting at 1000 °C, eutectic at 650 °C (γ 55, L 80, δ 95) and eutectoid at 600 °C (α 10, β 25, γ 55); X melts at 1300 °C and Y at 800 °C.

a) Write all the invariant reactions with their type, temperature and the composition of the three phases, and say how γ melts.

b) Apply the Gibbs phase rule (pressure constant) at the point of 25 wt% Y and 600 °C, inside the β + L field and inside the β field, and explain what each result means.

c) An alloy X-40 wt% Y is cooled slowly from the liquid. Describe its solidification down to 900 °C, giving the phases, their compositions and their amounts at 1100 + ΔT, 1100 − ΔT, 900 + ΔT and 900 − ΔT °C.

d) Continue the cooling to 600 − ΔT °C: give the phases and the microconstituents with their amounts, and sketch the microstructure at 1100 + ΔT, 900 − ΔT and 600 − ΔT °C.

Data and model

Data read on the diagram

ItemValue read on the figure
Melting pointsX 1300 °C, Y 800 °C, γ 1000 °C (top of its liquidus)
Line at 1100 °Cα 15, β 30, L 45 wt% Y
Line at 900 °Cβ 38, L 50, γ 55 wt% Y
Line at 650 °Cγ 55, L 80, δ 95 wt% Y
Line at 600 °Cα 10, β 25, γ 55 wt% Y
Alloy$C_0$ = 40 wt% Y

Units: 40 wt% Y is a mass fraction of 0.40 kg of Y per kg of alloy; the lever rule divides two composition differences, so the fractions it gives are dimensionless mass fractions. Temperatures stay in °C because no formula here needs kelvin.

Model

  • Invariant reactions [Session 8 Slide 6]: eutectic $L \rightarrow \alpha + \beta$, peritectic $\alpha + L \rightarrow \beta$ [Session 8 Slides 8-9], eutectoid $\gamma \rightarrow \alpha + \beta$ in the solid state [Session 8 Slide 7], peritectoid $\alpha + \beta \rightarrow \gamma$ [Session 8 Slide 11].
  • Gibbs phase rule $F = C - P + N$, with $N = 1$ at constant pressure [Session 7 Slide 13].
  • Lever rule on the tie line [Session 7 Slides 15-16]; primary constituents counted just above an invariant line, total phases just below it [Session 7 Slides 30-32].
  • Congruent melting at a maximum of the liquidus [Session 8 Slide 17].
  • Hypotheses: equilibrium cooling (the peritectic reaction and the solid-state diffusion are complete), 1 atm, values as printed.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Invariant reactions and the melting of γ

Why each horizontal line is an invariant reaction

Three phases of a two-component system at constant pressure leave $F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$ [Session 7 Slide 13], so each three-phase equilibrium is one horizontal line with three fixed compositions. The diagram has four.

The line at 1100 °C

Above it lies α + L, from α (15) to L (45). Below it the field of β starts at 30 wt% Y, between the two: a new solid forms from a solid and a liquid, the inverted V of a peritectic [Session 8 Slides 8-9]:

$$\alpha\,(15) + L\,(45) \;\xrightarrow{\;1100\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \beta\,(30) \qquad \text{peritectic, wt\% Y}$$

The lines at 900 and 650 °C

At 900 °C the liquidus of β (falling from 45 at 1100 °C) and the left branch of the liquidus of γ (falling from 1000 °C) meet in a V at 50 wt% Y; below lies β + γ. At 650 °C the right branch of the γ liquidus and the liquidus of δ (from 800 °C, pure Y) meet in a V at 80 wt% Y; below lies γ + δ. Both are eutectics:

$$L\,(50) \;\xrightarrow{\;900\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \beta\,(38) + \gamma\,(55) \qquad L\,(80) \;\xrightarrow{\;650\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \gamma\,(55) + \delta\,(95)$$

The line at 600 °C

No liquid reaches this line. The single-phase field β narrows downwards between its two solvus lines and closes in a V at 25 wt% Y on the line; below it lies α + γ. A solid that transforms into two other solids is a eutectoid [Session 8 Slide 7]:

$$\beta\,(25) \;\xrightarrow{\;600\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \alpha\,(10) + \gamma\,(55) \qquad \text{eutectoid}$$

Melting of γ

The vertical line of γ reaches the liquidus at its maximum, 1000 °C, where γ gives a liquid of its own composition (55 wt% Y): congruent melting [Session 8 Slide 17].

Key results
  • 1100 °C, peritectic: α (15) + L (45) → β (30).
  • 900 °C, eutectic: L (50) → β (38) + γ (55).
  • 650 °C, eutectic: L (80) → γ (55) + δ (95).
  • 600 °C, eutectoid: β (25) → α (10) + γ (55). All in wt% Y.
  • γ melts congruently at 1000 °C.

Part (b) · 0.5 points

Gibbs phase rule at the eutectoid point, in β + L and in β

State the rule and why N = 1

The phase rule is $F = C - P + N$ [Session 7 Slide 13]. Pressure is fixed at 1 atm in a phase diagram of this kind, so only temperature is a non-compositional variable, $N = 1$, and $F = C - P + 1$. The system has two components, X and Y, so $C = 2$.

At the eutectoid point

Three phases coexist, β, α and γ, so $P = 3$:

$$F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$$

Nothing can be changed: the transformation happens only at 600 °C, with β of 25, α of 10 and γ of 55 wt% Y. On a cooling curve it gives a plateau, like the eutectic.

Inside β + L

Two phases, $P = 2$:

$$F = 2 - 2 + 1 = 1$$

Choosing the temperature uses the only degree of freedom: the compositions of β and L are then fixed by the ends of the tie line, and the alloy composition only changes their amounts.

Inside β

One phase, $P = 1$:

$$F = 2 - 1 + 1 = 2$$

Temperature and composition can both change (within the field) without a new phase appearing.

Key results
  • Eutectoid point (25 wt% Y, 600 °C): $F = 0$.
  • β + L field: $F = 1$.
  • β field: $F = 2$.

Part (c) · 1 point

Solidification of X-40 wt% Y down to 900 °C

First solid: primary α

The 40 wt% Y vertical crosses the liquidus of α just above 1100 °C (the liquidus reaches 45 wt% Y at 1100 °C, so for 40 wt% Y it is a few tens of degrees higher; a reading of the figure). Crystals of α start to grow, and the liquid becomes richer in Y along the liquidus.

Derive the lever rule and apply it at 1100 + ΔT

On a tie line with phases α and L the alloy and the element Y must both be conserved:

$$W_\alpha + W_L = 1 \qquad W_\alpha C_\alpha + W_L C_L = C_0$$

Substituting $W_L = 1 - W_\alpha$ in the balance of Y:

$$W_\alpha C_\alpha + (1 - W_\alpha) C_L = C_0$$

Expanding the bracket:

$$W_\alpha C_\alpha + C_L - W_\alpha C_L = C_0$$

Grouping the terms in $W_\alpha$ and moving $C_L$ to the right-hand side:

$$W_\alpha (C_\alpha - C_L) = C_0 - C_L$$

Dividing by $(C_\alpha - C_L)$ and changing the sign of numerator and denominator:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_L - C_0}{C_L - C_\alpha} \qquad W_L = 1 - W_\alpha = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha}$$

Just above 1100 °C, α has 15 and L has 45 wt% Y (length 30):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{45 - 40}{45 - 15} = \frac{5}{30} = 0.167 \qquad W_L = \frac{40 - 15}{45 - 15} = \frac{25}{30} = 0.833$$

The peritectic reaction at 1100 °C

At 1100 °C, α (15) reacts with L (45) to give β (30). The alloy (40) lies to the right of β, between β and L, so the α runs out before the liquid. Just below 1100 °C the tie line runs from β (30) to L (45), length 15:

$$W_\beta = \frac{45 - 40}{45 - 30} = \frac{5}{15} = 0.333 \qquad W_L = \frac{40 - 30}{45 - 30} = \frac{10}{15} = 0.667$$

From 1100 to 900 °C: β grows from the liquid

In β + L the liquid follows the β liquidus from 45 to 50 wt% Y and β follows its solidus from 30 to 38 wt% Y; the amount of β grows. Just above 900 °C (β 38, L 50, length 12):

$$W_\beta = \frac{50 - 40}{50 - 38} = \frac{10}{12} = 0.833 \qquad W_L = \frac{40 - 38}{50 - 38} = \frac{2}{12} = 0.167$$

This β, formed partly by the peritectic and partly from the liquid, is the primary β (0.833), and the liquid, now of eutectic composition, is the future eutectic (0.167).

The eutectic at 900 °C

The remaining liquid transforms at 900 °C into β (38) + γ (55). Just below the line, the total phases on the tie line from β (38) to γ (55), length 17:

$$W_\beta = \frac{55 - 40}{55 - 38} = \frac{15}{17} = 0.882 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{40 - 38}{55 - 38} = \frac{2}{17} = 0.118$$

Microconstituents: primary β 0.833 and eutectic (β + γ) 0.167. All the γ is in the eutectic, and the eutectic β is $0.882 - 0.833 = 0.049$; $0.049 + 0.118 = 0.167$.

Key results
  • 1100 + ΔT: α (15) 0.167, L (45) 0.833.
  • 1100 − ΔT: β (30) 0.333, L (45) 0.667.
  • 900 + ΔT: β (38) 0.833, L (50) 0.167.
  • 900 − ΔT: β (38) 0.882, γ (55) 0.118; microconstituents primary β 0.833 and eutectic β + γ 0.167.

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Cooling to 600 − ΔT °C and the three sketches

From 900 to 600 °C: precipitation of γ

In β + γ the boundary of β moves from 38 to 25 wt% Y as the temperature falls, so the β loses Y and γ precipitates from it in the solid state (Session 8 Slides 2-4 call this solid-state precipitation). Just above 600 °C (β 25, γ 55, length 30):

$$W_\beta = \frac{55 - 40}{55 - 25} = \frac{15}{30} = 0.500 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{40 - 25}{55 - 25} = \frac{15}{30} = 0.500$$

The γ grew from 0.118 to 0.500, so $0.500 - 0.118 = 0.382$ of γ precipitated between 900 and 600 °C.

The eutectoid at 600 °C

All the β (0.500), which now has the eutectoid composition 25 wt% Y, transforms into the fine eutectoid α + γ. Below the line the total phases on the tie line from α (10) to γ (55), length 45:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{55 - 40}{55 - 10} = \frac{15}{45} = 0.333 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{40 - 10}{55 - 10} = \frac{30}{45} = 0.667$$

The microconstituents are counted just above the line, like a primary constituent above a eutectic: eutectoid = $W_\beta(600 + \Delta T)$ = 0.500, and γ outside it = 0.500. Check: inside the eutectoid (25 wt% Y) the fraction of α is $(55 - 25)/(55 - 10) = 30/45 = 0.667$, and $0.667 \times 0.500 = 0.333$, all the α of the alloy.

The three sketches

At 1100 + ΔT: a few rounded grains of primary α in a large amount of liquid. At 900 − ΔT: large grains of primary β (the α has disappeared in the peritectic) in a lamellar eutectic β + γ. At 600 − ΔT: every former β region, primary and inside the eutectic, is now a fine eutectoid α + γ, with films of γ precipitated on the boundaries of the former β grains.

primary α liquid L 1100 + ΔT °C primary β eutectic (β + γ) 900 − ΔT °C eutectoid (α + γ) γ film former eutectic 600 − ΔT °C
Figure 2. X-40 wt% Y: at 1100 + ΔT °C, primary α (16.7 %) in liquid; at 900 − ΔT °C, primary β (83.3 %, formed by the peritectic reaction and grown from the liquid) in the eutectic β + γ (16.7 %); at 600 − ΔT °C, every β has become the fine eutectoid α + γ, with γ films precipitated between 900 and 600 °C on the grain boundaries.
Key results
  • 600 + ΔT: β (25) 0.500, γ (55) 0.500.
  • 600 − ΔT: α (10) 0.333, γ (55) 0.667.
  • Microconstituents at 600 − ΔT: eutectoid (α + γ) 0.500 and γ outside the eutectoid 0.500 (eutectic γ 0.118 plus γ precipitated in the solid 0.382).

Interpretation and checks

The alloy passes through three invariant reactions, but none of the original microconstituents survives unchanged: the primary α is consumed by the peritectic, and the primary β disappears in the eutectoid, leaving only a trace of its shape. This is the solid-state counterpart of the eutectic: like a eutectic liquid, the β of 25 wt% Y transforms at one temperature into two phases ($F = 0$). Checks: every fraction lies between 0 and 1, each pair adds up to 1, and the Y balance at 600 − ΔT is $0.333 \times 10 + 0.667 \times 55 = 3.33 + 36.67 = 40.0$ wt% Y. Limiting case: an alloy of exactly 30 wt% Y would leave neither α nor liquid after the peritectic and be 100 % β just below 1100 °C. Dimensions: all fractions are wt% over wt%, dimensionless. Common mistake: taking the eutectoid fraction from the tie line below 600 °C ($W_\alpha$ = 0.333, a phase) instead of from the β just above it (0.500, a microconstituent).

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Binary diagram with intermetallics and invariant reactions · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P04 — Building a G-H diagram with a congruent and an incongruent compound from a table of equilibria

A laboratory has measured the following features of a hypothetical binary system G-H (compositions in wt% H). No diagram is given.

FeatureMeasured data
Pure Gmelts at 1500 °C; forms the terminal solid solution α
Pure Hmelts at 1350 °C; forms the terminal solid solution β
Compound θ (stoichiometric, 30 wt% H)melts at 1400 °C to a liquid of 30 wt% H
Compound η (stoichiometric, 60 wt% H)stable only below 1150 °C
Three-phase equilibrium at 1250 °Cα (6 wt% H), L (15 wt% H), θ (30 wt% H)
Three-phase equilibrium at 1150 °CL (50 wt% H), η (60 wt% H), β (88 wt% H)
Three-phase equilibrium at 1000 °Cθ (30 wt% H), L (40 wt% H), η (60 wt% H)
Solvus linesα holds 3 wt% H and β 92 wt% H at 700 °C

a) Draw the phase diagram between 700 and 1600 °C to scale and label every phase field.

b) Name each invariant reaction, writing it on cooling with the compositions of the three phases, say which compound melts congruently and which incongruently, and give the maximum solubility of H in G and of G in H with their temperatures.

c) A casting of 2.00 kg of G-55 wt% H is cooled slowly. Give the mass and composition of each phase at 1150 + ΔT °C and at 1150 − ΔT °C, and the mass of β used up by the reaction at 1150 °C.

d) For the same casting at 1000 − ΔT °C, give the mass of each microconstituent and of each phase, and the masses of θ and η inside the eutectic.

Data and model

Data

SymbolMeaningValue
$T_G$, $T_H$melting points of G and H1500 °C, 1350 °C
$C_\theta$, $C_\eta$compositions of the compounds30, 60 wt% H
1250 °Cα, L, θ6, 15, 30 wt% H
1150 °CL, η, β50, 60, 88 wt% H
1000 °Cθ, L, η30, 40, 60 wt% H
$m_0$, $C_0$mass and composition of the casting2.00 kg, 55 wt% H

Unit conversions: 55 wt% H is a mass fraction of 0.55, so the casting contains $0.55 \times 2.00\ \text{kg} = 1.10$ kg of H and 0.90 kg of G. The lever rule gives mass fractions $W$ (dimensionless); the mass of a phase is $m_i = W_i\,m_0$ in kg.

Model

  • Phase fields [Session 7 Slides 26-27]: liquidus, solidus and solvus bound the fields; single-phase and two-phase fields alternate across every boundary, and three phases meet only on a horizontal invariant line ($F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$, Session 7 Slide 13).
  • Invariant reactions [Session 8 Slide 6]: eutectic $L \rightarrow \alpha + \beta$ (the liquid lies between the two solids on the line), peritectic $\alpha + L \rightarrow \beta$ (the new solid lies between the solid and the liquid) [Session 8 Slides 8-9].
  • Compounds [Session 8 Slides 14-15, 17]: a stoichiometric compound is a vertical line; congruent melting at a maximum of the liquidus, incongruent melting at a peritectic line.
  • Lever rule [Session 7 Slides 15-16]; primary constituent counted just above the eutectic line [Session 7 Slides 30-32].
  • Hypotheses: equilibrium cooling (complete peritectic reaction), 1 atm, the boundaries between the given points drawn as smooth curves (their exact shape is not measured, only their end points).

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Draw the phase diagram and label every field

Place the fixed points

On axes of 0 to 100 wt% H and 700 to 1600 °C: the melting points (0, 1500) and (100, 1350); the top of θ (30, 1400), because θ gives a liquid of its own composition there; the three horizontal lines at 1250 °C (6 to 30), 1150 °C (50 to 88) and 1000 °C (30 to 60), each with its three points marked; the vertical line of θ at 30 wt% H from 700 to 1400 °C, and that of η at 60 wt% H from 700 °C up to 1150 °C only, because η exists only below that temperature.

Draw the liquidus

The liquidus must pass through every liquid point of the table, in order of composition: from G (1500 °C) down to the liquid of the 1250 °C line (15), up to the maximum of θ (1400 °C at 30), down to the liquid of the 1000 °C line (40), up to the liquid of the 1150 °C line (50), and up to H (1350 °C). Above it everything is liquid.

Draw the solid boundaries

α: solidus from (0, 1500) to (6, 1250) and solvus from (6, 1250) to (3, 700). β: solidus from (100, 1350) to (88, 1150) and solvus from (88, 1150) to (92, 700).

Label the fields

Two-phase fields fill the gaps between neighbouring single-phase regions: α + L (between the α solidus and the liquidus), θ + L on each side of θ above 1250 and 1000 °C, α + θ (below 1250 °C between α and θ), θ + η (below 1000 °C), η + L (between 1000 and 1150 °C, left of η), η + β (below 1150 °C), and β + L (above 1150 °C, between the liquidus and the β solidus). Each boundary crossed horizontally changes the number of phases by one (one, two, one, two), as required.

0 (G) 20 40 60 80 100 (H) 700 900 1100 1300 1500 Composition (wt% H) Temperature (°C) 1250 °C 6 15 30 1000 °C 30 40 60 1150 °C 50 60 88 1500 °C 1350 °C 1400 °C L α θ + L θ+L α + θ θ + η η + L η + β β + L β θ η α + L
Figure 1. Hypothetical G-H phase diagram (wt% H) drawn from the data of the statement: eutectic at 1250 °C (α 6, L 15, θ 30), compound θ of 30 wt% H melting congruently at 1400 °C, eutectic at 1000 °C (θ 30, L 40, η 60), peritectic at 1150 °C (L 50, η 60, β 88); G melts at 1500 °C and H at 1350 °C.
Key results
  • Liquidus: 1500 °C (0) → 1250 °C (15) → 1400 °C (30) → 1000 °C (40) → 1150 °C (50) → 1350 °C (100).
  • Vertical lines: θ at 30 wt% H up to 1400 °C, η at 60 wt% H up to 1150 °C.
  • Fields: L; α; α + L; α + θ; θ + L on both sides of θ; θ + η; η + L; η + β; β + L; β.

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Invariant reactions, melting of the compounds and maximum solubilities

The line at 1250 °C

The liquid (15) lies between α (6) and θ (30), with α + L and θ + L above and α + θ below: the liquid gives two solids, a eutectic [Session 8 Slide 6]:

$$L\,(15) \;\xrightarrow{\;1250\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \alpha\,(6) + \theta\,(30) \qquad \text{eutectic, wt\% H}$$

The line at 1150 °C

Here the solid η (60) lies between the liquid (50) and β (88), and η exists only below the line. Above the line there is β + L; below it η + L and η + β. A liquid and a solid combine into a new solid: a peritectic [Session 8 Slides 8-9]:

$$L\,(50) + \beta\,(88) \;\xrightarrow{\;1150\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \eta\,(60) \qquad \text{peritectic}$$

The line at 1000 °C

The liquid (40) lies between θ (30) and η (60), with θ + L and η + L above and θ + η below: a second eutectic:

$$L\,(40) \;\xrightarrow{\;1000\ ^\circ\text{C}\;}\; \theta\,(30) + \eta\,(60) \qquad \text{eutectic}$$

Melting of the compounds

θ melts at 1400 °C to a liquid of 30 wt% H, its own composition, at the top of the liquidus: congruent melting [Session 8 Slide 17]. η ends at the peritectic line: heated above 1150 °C it decomposes into L (50) + β (88), a liquid of another composition plus another solid, so it melts incongruently.

Maximum solubilities

α is widest on the 1250 °C line: 6 wt% H in G at 1250 °C. β is widest on the 1150 °C line, at 88 wt% H, so it holds

$$100 - 88 = 12\ \text{wt\% G}$$

at 1150 °C. Both solubilities fall on cooling, along the solvus lines (to 3 wt% H and 8 wt% G at 700 °C).

Key results
  • 1250 °C, eutectic: L (15) → α (6) + θ (30).
  • 1150 °C, peritectic: L (50) + β (88) → η (60).
  • 1000 °C, eutectic: L (40) → θ (30) + η (60).
  • θ melts congruently (1400 °C); η melts incongruently (1150 °C).
  • Maximum solubility: 6 wt% H in G at 1250 °C; 100 − 88 = 12 wt% G in H at 1150 °C.

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Masses of the phases of 2.00 kg of G-55 wt% H at 1150 ± ΔT °C

Derive the lever rule

On a tie line with phases L and β the mass of the alloy and the mass of H are conserved:

$$W_L + W_\beta = 1 \qquad W_L C_L + W_\beta C_\beta = C_0$$

Substituting $W_\beta = 1 - W_L$:

$$W_L C_L + (1 - W_L) C_\beta = C_0 \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad W_L (C_L - C_\beta) = C_0 - C_\beta$$
$$W_L = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_L} \qquad W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_L}{C_\beta - C_L}$$

Just above 1150 °C

The alloy lies in β + L on the tie line from L (50) to β (88), length 38 wt% H:

$$W_L = \frac{88 - 55}{88 - 50} = \frac{33}{38} = 0.8684 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{55 - 50}{88 - 50} = \frac{5}{38} = 0.1316$$

Masses, with $m_i = W_i\,m_0$:

$$m_L = 0.8684 \times 2.00\ \text{kg} = 1.737\ \text{kg} \qquad m_\beta = 0.1316 \times 2.00\ \text{kg} = 0.263\ \text{kg}$$

Just below 1150 °C

At 1150 °C, L (50) and β (88) react to form η (60). The alloy (55) lies left of η, between L and η, so the β runs out first and liquid remains. Tie line from L (50) to η (60), length 10:

$$W_\eta = \frac{55 - 50}{60 - 50} = \frac{5}{10} = 0.500 \qquad W_L = \frac{60 - 55}{60 - 50} = \frac{5}{10} = 0.500$$
$$m_\eta = 0.500 \times 2.00\ \text{kg} = 1.000\ \text{kg} \qquad m_L = 0.500 \times 2.00\ \text{kg} = 1.000\ \text{kg}$$

Mass balance of the reaction

All 0.263 kg of β disappear. The η formed (1.000 kg) comes from that β and from $1.000 - 0.263 = 0.737$ kg of liquid, which is exactly the drop of the liquid from 1.737 to 1.000 kg. H check: $0.263 \times 0.88 + 0.737 \times 0.50 = 0.2316 + 0.3684 = 0.600$ kg of H in 1.000 kg of η, that is 60 wt% H, the composition of η.

Key results
  • 1150 + ΔT: L (50 wt% H) 1.737 kg, β (88 wt% H) 0.263 kg.
  • 1150 − ΔT: η (60 wt% H) 1.000 kg, L (50 wt% H) 1.000 kg.
  • All the β, 0.263 kg, is used up by the peritectic.

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Microconstituents and phases of the casting at 1000 − ΔT °C

Primary η just above 1000 °C

The tie line runs from the eutectic liquid (40) to η (60), length 20 wt% H. The η is primary and the liquid will become eutectic:

$$W_{\eta,\text{primary}} = \frac{55 - 40}{60 - 40} = \frac{15}{20} = 0.750 \qquad W_E = \frac{60 - 55}{60 - 40} = \frac{5}{20} = 0.250$$
$$m_{\eta,\text{primary}} = 0.750 \times 2.00 = 1.500\ \text{kg} \qquad m_E = 0.250 \times 2.00 = 0.500\ \text{kg}$$

Phases just below 1000 °C

Tie line from θ (30) to η (60), length 30:

$$W_\theta = \frac{60 - 55}{60 - 30} = \frac{5}{30} = 0.1667 \qquad W_\eta = \frac{55 - 30}{60 - 30} = \frac{25}{30} = 0.8333$$
$$m_\theta = 0.1667 \times 2.00 = 0.333\ \text{kg} \qquad m_\eta = 0.8333 \times 2.00 = 1.667\ \text{kg}$$

Split the eutectic

All the θ is in the eutectic (there is no primary θ), so eutectic θ = 0.333 kg. The eutectic η is the total η minus the primary η:

$$m_{\eta,E} = 1.667 - 1.500 = 0.167\ \text{kg}$$

Check: $0.333 + 0.167 = 0.500$ kg, the mass of eutectic. The eutectic has 40 wt% H, so inside it the θ fraction is $(60 - 40)/(60 - 30) = 20/30 = 0.667$, and $0.667 \times 0.500 = 0.333$ kg, as found.

Key results
  • Primary η 1.500 kg; eutectic (θ + η) 0.500 kg.
  • Phases: θ (30 wt% H) 0.333 kg, η (60 wt% H) 1.667 kg.
  • Inside the eutectic: θ 0.333 kg and η 0.167 kg.

Interpretation and checks

The two compounds split the diagram into three simpler parts: G-θ (a simple eutectic), θ-η (a simple eutectic) and η-H (a peritectic). θ behaves like a pure metal because it melts at a maximum of the liquidus; η cannot be melted as a single liquid. The casting of 55 wt% H shows the peritectic in action: the 0.263 kg of β formed first is completely consumed at 1150 °C, so the final microstructure has no trace of β, only primary η in a θ + η eutectic. Checks: every pair of fractions adds up to 1 and the masses add up to 2.00 kg; H balance at 1000 − ΔT: $0.333 \times 0.30 + 1.667 \times 0.60 = 0.100 + 1.000 = 1.100$ kg of H $= 0.55 \times 2.00$ kg. Limiting case: a casting of exactly 60 wt% H would leave no liquid after the peritectic and be 100 % η. Dimensions: $W$ is wt% over wt%, dimensionless, and $m = W\,m_0$ has units of kg. Common mistake: drawing η up to the liquidus as if it melted congruently; the table says η exists only below 1150 °C, which is the signature of a peritectic.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Eutectic system: lever rule and microconstituents · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P05 — Cooling of a Pb-50 wt% Sn alloy read from the Pb-Sn diagram

The figure shows the Pb-Sn phase diagram with the values of Session 7 Slide 32. A Pb-50 wt% Sn alloy is cooled slowly (equilibrium) from 300 °C to 100 °C. The readings needed are printed on the figure: the alloy meets the liquidus at 215 °C; at 200 °C the tie line through the alloy ends at 16.7 and 55.7 wt% Sn; at 100 °C it ends at 4.8 and 99.8 wt% Sn.

0 (Pb) 18.3 50 61.9 80 100 (Sn) 0 100 183 200 232 327 Composition (wt% Sn) Temperature (°C) 97.8 327 °C 232 °C E C0 = 50 215 °C 16.7 55.7 4.8 99.8 L α β α + β α + L β + L
Figure 1. Pb-Sn phase diagram with the values of Session 7 Slide 32 (Pb melts at 327 °C, Sn at 232 °C; eutectic at 183 °C and 61.9 wt% Sn; α of 18.3 and β of 97.8 wt% Sn at 183 °C). The dashed vertical line is the alloy of 50 wt% Sn, which meets the liquidus at 215 °C; the tie line at 200 °C ends at 16.7 (α) and 55.7 (L) wt% Sn, and the one at 100 °C at 4.8 (α) and 99.8 (β) wt% Sn.

(a) Write the invariant reaction of the diagram (name, temperature, compositions of the three phases). Classify the alloy and say at which temperatures its solidification starts and ends, and which phase forms first.

(b) At 200 °C, give the phases present, their compositions and their mass fractions.

(c) Just above (183 + ΔT) and just below (183 − ΔT) the eutectic temperature, give the phases with their compositions and mass fractions, and the microconstituents with their mass fractions. What fraction of all the α of the alloy is inside the eutectic?

(d) At 100 °C, give the phases, their compositions and mass fractions. Explain where the extra β comes from.

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueWhere it is read
Alloy composition$C_0$50 wt% Sn (mass fraction 0.50 of Sn)statement
Melting points$T_{Pb}$, $T_{Sn}$327 °C, 232 °Cends of the liquidus
Eutectic point$T_E$, $C_E$183 °C, 61.9 wt% Snpoint E
Ends of the eutectic line$C_\alpha$, $C_\beta$18.3 and 97.8 wt% Snends of the horizontal line at 183 °C
Liquidus of the alloy$T_L$215 °Cthe dashed alloy line meets the liquidus
Tie line at 200 °C$C_\alpha$, $C_L$16.7 and 55.7 wt% Snsolidus and liquidus at 200 °C
Tie line at 100 °C$C_\alpha$, $C_\beta$4.8 and 99.8 wt% Snthe two solvus lines at 100 °C

The compositions are mass percentages; the lever rule only uses differences and ratios of them, so they can stay in wt% (the conversion to mass fractions, dividing by 100, cancels in every ratio).

Model

  • Gibbs phase rule at constant pressure for two components, $F = C - P + 1 = 3 - P$ [Session 7 Slide 13]: in a two-phase field $F = 1$, so once the temperature is fixed the compositions of both phases are fixed; they are the ends of the horizontal tie line [Session 7 Slide 15].
  • Lever rule [Session 7 Slides 15-16]: on a tie line from $C_1$ to $C_2$, $W_1 = \dfrac{C_2 - C_0}{C_2 - C_1}$ and $W_2 = \dfrac{C_0 - C_1}{C_2 - C_1}$ (derived in part (b)).
  • Microconstituents of a hypoeutectic alloy [Session 7 Slides 30, 32]: the α present just above 183 °C is the primary α; the liquid present then (of 61.9 wt% Sn) becomes the eutectic. Hypotheses: equilibrium cooling, closed system (no loss of mass).

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Invariant reaction, type of alloy and start and end of solidification

Identify the invariant reaction at point E

The only horizontal line of the diagram is at 183 °C. It touches three phase fields from above and below: the liquid meets it at a single point E (the minimum of the liquidus), α ends at its left end and β at its right end. A liquid that turns into two solids at a fixed temperature and composition is a eutectic reaction [Session 7 Slides 26-27]. Reading the three compositions on the line:

$$\text{cooling: } L\ (61.9\ \text{wt\% Sn}) \rightarrow \alpha\ (18.3\ \text{wt\% Sn}) + \beta\ (97.8\ \text{wt\% Sn}) \quad \text{at } 183\ ^\circ\text{C (eutectic)}$$

It is invariant: with three phases, $F = 3 - P = 3 - 3 = 0$, so neither the temperature nor any composition can change while the reaction proceeds [Session 7 Slide 13].

Classify the alloy

The eutectic line runs from 18.3 to 97.8 wt% Sn, and the eutectic point is at 61.9 wt% Sn. An alloy between the α end and E is hypoeutectic, and its primary (proeutectic) phase is α [Session 7 Slide 30]:

$$C_\alpha = 18.3 < C_0 = 50 < C_E = 61.9 \quad\Rightarrow\quad \text{hypoeutectic alloy, primary phase } \alpha$$

Read the start and the end of solidification

Following the dashed vertical line $C_0 = 50$ from above: it stays in L down to the liquidus, which it meets at 215 °C (printed on the figure). Below that the alloy is in the α + L field, so the first solid is α, the phase on the left boundary of that field. The liquid keeps changing its composition along the liquidus until it reaches E; the last liquid, of 61.9 wt% Sn, solidifies as eutectic at 183 °C, where solidification ends. Solidification therefore takes place over the interval $215 - 183 = 32$ °C.

Key results
  • Eutectic at 183 °C: L (61.9 wt% Sn) → α (18.3 wt% Sn) + β (97.8 wt% Sn) on cooling.
  • $18.3 < 50 < 61.9$: hypoeutectic alloy; the primary phase is α.
  • Solidification starts at 215 °C (first solid α) and ends at 183 °C.

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Phases, compositions and amounts at 200 °C

Place the point and read the tie line

At 200 °C the alloy point (50, 200) is in the α + L field. The horizontal tie line through it meets the α solidus at $C_\alpha = 16.7$ wt% Sn and the liquidus at $C_L = 55.7$ wt% Sn (printed on the figure). These are the compositions of the two phases [Session 7 Slide 15].

Derive the lever rule from two mass balances

Take a mass of alloy as the unit. The alloy is made only of α and L, so their mass fractions add up to one (total mass balance); the tin in the alloy is the tin in α plus the tin in L (mass balance of Sn):

$$W_\alpha + W_L = 1$$
$$W_\alpha C_\alpha + W_L C_L = C_0$$

From the first equation, $W_\alpha = 1 - W_L$. Substituting into the second:

$$(1 - W_L)\,C_\alpha + W_L C_L = C_0$$
$$C_\alpha + W_L\,(C_L - C_\alpha) = C_0$$
$$W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha}$$

and then $W_\alpha = 1 - W_L = \dfrac{C_L - C_\alpha - C_0 + C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha} = \dfrac{C_L - C_0}{C_L - C_\alpha}$. Each phase is given by the arm of the lever on the side of the other phase, divided by the length of the tie line [Session 7 Slide 16].

Substitute the readings at 200 °C

The tie line has length $C_L - C_\alpha = 55.7 - 16.7 = 39.0$ wt% Sn:

$$W_L = \frac{50 - 16.7}{55.7 - 16.7} = \frac{33.3}{39.0} = 0.854$$
$$W_\alpha = \frac{55.7 - 50}{55.7 - 16.7} = \frac{5.7}{39.0} = 0.146$$

Check: $0.854 + 0.146 = 1.000$, and the Sn balance $0.1462 \times 16.7 + 0.8538 \times 55.7 = 2.44 + 47.56 = 50.0$ wt% Sn returns $C_0$. The alloy is still mostly liquid, because 200 °C is only 15 °C below its liquidus.

Key results
  • Phases: α (16.7 wt% Sn) and L (55.7 wt% Sn).
  • $W_L = 0.854$, $W_\alpha = 0.146$.

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Phases and microconstituents at 183 ± ΔT °C

Lever rule just above 183 °C

At 183 + ΔT the alloy is still in α + L; the tie line ends at the two ends of the left part of the eutectic line, $C_\alpha = 18.3$ and $C_L = C_E = 61.9$ wt% Sn (length $61.9 - 18.3 = 43.6$). With the lever rule of part (b):

$$W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_E - C_\alpha} = \frac{50 - 18.3}{61.9 - 18.3} = \frac{31.7}{43.6} = 0.727$$
$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_E - C_0}{C_E - C_\alpha} = \frac{61.9 - 50}{43.6} = \frac{11.9}{43.6} = 0.273$$

Lever rule just below 183 °C (total phases)

At 183 − ΔT the eutectic reaction has consumed all the liquid and the alloy is in α + β. The tie line is the whole eutectic line, from $C_\alpha = 18.3$ to $C_\beta = 97.8$ wt% Sn (length $97.8 - 18.3 = 79.5$) [Session 7 Slide 32]:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{97.8 - 50}{79.5} = \frac{47.8}{79.5} = 0.601$$
$$W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{50 - 18.3}{79.5} = \frac{31.7}{79.5} = 0.399$$

Microconstituents just below 183 °C

The α that existed at 183 + ΔT does not take part in the reaction: it stays as primary α. The liquid, which has exactly the eutectic composition, becomes the eutectic microconstituent (alternating α and β) [Session 7 Slides 30, 32]. Therefore the microconstituent fractions are the phase fractions just above the eutectic temperature:

$$W_{\alpha'} = W_\alpha(183 + \Delta T) = 0.273 \qquad W_E = W_L(183 + \Delta T) = 0.727$$

Split the α between primary and eutectic

All the β is inside the eutectic (the primary phase is α). The α inside the eutectic is the total α minus the primary α; with four significant figures, $W_\alpha = 47.8/79.5 = 0.6013$ and $W_{\alpha'} = 11.9/43.6 = 0.2729$:

$$W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha - W_{\alpha'} = 0.6013 - 0.2729 = 0.328$$
$$\frac{W_{\alpha,E}}{W_\alpha} = \frac{0.3283}{0.6013} = 0.546$$

So 54.6 % of all the α of the alloy is eutectic α. Check: the eutectic is $W_{\alpha,E} + W_{\beta,E} = 0.328 + 0.399 = 0.727 = W_E$, and its own make-up is $(97.8 - 61.9)/79.5 = 0.452$ α, so $0.727 \times 0.452 = 0.328$ (checked).

Key results
  • 183 + ΔT: α (18.3) and L (61.9 wt% Sn); $W_\alpha = 0.273$, $W_L = 0.727$.
  • 183 − ΔT: α (18.3) and β (97.8 wt% Sn); $W_\alpha = 0.601$, $W_\beta = 0.399$.
  • Microconstituents: primary α $W_{\alpha'} = 0.273$, eutectic $W_E = 0.727$; α inside the eutectic 0.328 of the alloy; 54.6 % of all the α is eutectic α.

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Phases at 100 °C and precipitation of β

Lever rule at 100 °C

The alloy is still in α + β; the tie line now ends on the α solvus at 4.8 and on the β solvus at 99.8 wt% Sn (length $99.8 - 4.8 = 95.0$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{99.8 - 50}{99.8 - 4.8} = \frac{49.8}{95.0} = 0.524$$
$$W_\beta = \frac{50 - 4.8}{99.8 - 4.8} = \frac{45.2}{95.0} = 0.476$$

Explain the change with the solvus

The α solvus slopes to the left: the solubility of Sn in α falls from 18.3 wt% at 183 °C to 4.8 wt% at 100 °C. The α of the alloy (primary and eutectic) is therefore supersaturated as it cools and rejects the excess Sn as small particles of β inside its grains: this is precipitation in the solid state, which grows as the temperature decreases [Session 8 Slides 3-4]. The amount of β gained is

$$\Delta W_\beta = W_\beta(100\ ^\circ\text{C}) - W_\beta(183 - \Delta T) = 0.4758 - 0.3987 = 0.077$$

that is, 7.7 % of the mass of the alloy. The β side changes little (97.8 → 99.8 wt% Sn), so almost all the change comes from the α side. The microconstituents keep their names: primary α (now with fine β precipitates) and eutectic.

Key results
  • α (4.8 wt% Sn) and β (99.8 wt% Sn); $W_\alpha = 0.524$, $W_\beta = 0.476$.
  • β grows by 0.077 of the alloy between 183 − ΔT and 100 °C: it precipitates from the α, whose Sn solubility falls from 18.3 to 4.8 wt%.

Interpretation and checks

On cooling, the Pb-50 Sn alloy starts to solidify at 215 °C with α, holds 14.6 % α at 200 °C and 27.3 % just above 183 °C; the remaining 72.7 % of liquid, now of eutectic composition, solidifies at 183 °C as eutectic. Because 50 wt% Sn is close to E (61.9), the eutectic dominates the microstructure, and more than half of the α (54.6 %) is eutectic α.

Control cases: as $C_0 \to 18.3$ the eutectic fraction $W_E = (C_0 - 18.3)/43.6 \to 0$ (all primary α), and as $C_0 \to 61.9$, $W_E \to 1$ (fully eutectic). All fractions lie between 0 and 1, and each pair adds up to 1. Dimensional check: the lever rule is a ratio of two composition differences, (wt% Sn)/(wt% Sn), so the fractions are dimensionless, as they must be.

Common exam mistake: taking the primary α from the long tie line below 183 °C (0.601). That number is the total α (primary plus eutectic); the primary α must be read on the short tie line just above 183 °C, which ends at the eutectic liquid.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Eutectic system: lever rule and microconstituents · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P06 — Building a eutectic diagram from a description and using it

Two metals A and B are completely soluble in the liquid state and partially soluble in the solid state, where they form a solid solution α rich in A and a solid solution β rich in B. Metal A melts at 900 °C and metal B at 700 °C. The system has a single invariant point, a eutectic at 550 °C, where the liquid contains 70 wt% B. At that temperature α can dissolve at most 20 wt% B and β at most 8 wt% A. At room temperature (20 °C) the solubilities fall to 5 wt% B in α and 3 wt% A in β. Assume that every boundary of the diagram is a straight line between the points given, and that cooling is slow (equilibrium).

(a) Draw the phase diagram (temperature against wt% B), label every region and write the invariant reaction.

(b) For an alloy of 85 wt% B: at which temperature does it start to solidify and what is the composition of the first solid? Give the phases, their compositions and their mass fractions at 600 °C.

(c) For the same alloy, give the microconstituents and their mass fractions just below 550 °C, and the mass fraction of each phase inside the eutectic.

(d) Which alloys of the system contain eutectic at room temperature? An alloy of 12 wt% B contains none: at which temperature does β appear in it, and how much β is there at 20 °C?

Data and model

Data

Feature of the statementPoint of the diagram (wt% B, °C)Meaning
A melts at 900 °C(0, 900)top of the liquidus and of the α solidus
B melts at 700 °C(100, 700)top of the liquidus and of the β solidus
Eutectic, liquid of 70 wt% B at 550 °CE = (70, 550)lowest point of the liquidus
α holds at most 20 wt% B at 550 °C(20, 550)α end of the eutectic line
β holds at most 8 wt% A at 550 °C(100 − 8, 550) = (92, 550)β end of the eutectic line
α holds 5 wt% B at 20 °C(5, 20)lower end of the α solvus
β holds 3 wt% A at 20 °C(100 − 3, 20) = (97, 20)lower end of the β solvus
Alloys$C_0$ = 85 and 12 wt% Bparts (b) to (d)

The composition axis is wt% B, so a content of A is turned into a content of B with $C_B = 100 - C_A$: 8 wt% A is 92 wt% B, and 3 wt% A is 97 wt% B. The lever rule uses ratios of composition differences, so the wt% can be used directly (the factor 1/100 that turns them into mass fractions cancels).

Model

  • Binary eutectic system with partial solid solubility [Session 7 Slides 26-27]: liquidus from each melting point down to E; solidus from each melting point to the end of the eutectic line; solvus from each end of the eutectic line down to room temperature.
  • Straight boundary through $(C_1, T_1)$ and $(C_2, T_2)$, as the statement imposes: $C = C_1 + (T - T_1)\dfrac{C_2 - C_1}{T_2 - T_1}$ (linear interpolation).
  • Lever rule on a horizontal tie line [Session 7 Slides 15-16]; microconstituents of a hypereutectic alloy: primary β and eutectic [Session 7 Slides 31-32]; precipitation of β when an alloy crosses the solvus [Session 8 Slides 3-4].

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Diagram and invariant reaction

Draw the boundaries from the points

The liquidus is the line above which only liquid exists; in a eutectic system it falls from the melting point of each metal to the eutectic point, so it is made of the two segments (0, 900)–(70, 550) and (70, 550)–(100, 700). The solidus is the line below which there is no liquid; it falls from each melting point to the corresponding end of the eutectic line: (0, 900)–(20, 550) for α and (100, 700)–(92, 550) for β. The horizontal eutectic line joins (20, 550) and (92, 550). Below it, the solvus lines give the limit of solubility in each solid solution: (20, 550)–(5, 20) for α and (92, 550)–(97, 20) for β [Session 7 Slides 26-27].

Label the regions

Above the liquidus: L. Between the A-side liquidus and the α solidus: α + L. Between the B-side liquidus and the β solidus: β + L. Left of the α solidus and α solvus: α. Right of the β solidus and β solvus: β. Below the eutectic line, between the two solvus lines: α + β. Every two-phase field lies between two one-phase fields of the phases it contains, as it must in a binary diagram.

0 (A) 12 20 40 70 85 100 (B) 20 267 550 625 700 900 Composition (wt% B) Temperature (°C) 5 97 92 20 E (70) 900 °C 700 °C C0 = 85 C0 = 12 L α β α + L β + L α + β
Figure 1. The A-B diagram of Bank P06 drawn with straight lines: A melts at 900 °C and B at 700 °C; eutectic at 550 °C and 70 wt% B; at 550 °C α holds 20 wt% B and β 92 wt% B (8 wt% A); at 20 °C the solvus lines reach 5 and 97 wt% B. Dashed: the alloys of 85 wt% B (liquidus 625 °C) and 12 wt% B (solvus 267 °C).

Write the invariant reaction

At 550 °C a liquid of fixed composition gives two solids of fixed compositions; this is a eutectic reaction, and with three phases it has $F = 3 - P = 0$ degrees of freedom [Session 7 Slide 13]:

$$\text{cooling: } L\ (70\ \text{wt\% B}) \rightarrow \alpha\ (20\ \text{wt\% B}) + \beta\ (92\ \text{wt\% B}) \quad \text{at } 550\ ^\circ\text{C (eutectic)}$$

The diagram is thermodynamically sensible: both liquidus branches fall towards E, each solid solution is richest in solute at the eutectic temperature, and the eutectic composition lies between those of α and β.

Key results
  • Liquidus (0, 900)–(70, 550)–(100, 700); solidus (0, 900)–(20, 550) and (100, 700)–(92, 550); eutectic line (20, 550)–(92, 550); solvus (20, 550)–(5, 20) and (92, 550)–(97, 20).
  • Regions: L; α + L; β + L; α; β; α + β.
  • Cooling: L (70 wt% B) → α (20 wt% B) + β (92 wt% B) at 550 °C, eutectic.

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Start of solidification and the tie line at 600 °C

Liquidus temperature of the alloy

On the straight B-side liquidus from (70, 550) to (100, 700), the temperature rises by $(700 - 550)/(100 - 70) = 150/30 = 5$ °C per wt% B. Writing the line and putting $C = 85$:

$$T = 550 + 5\,(C - 70) = 550 + 5\,(85 - 70) = 550 + 75 = 625\ ^\circ\text{C}$$

Composition of the first solid

At 625 °C the first crystal is the solid in equilibrium with the liquid, at the other end of the tie line, on the β solidus from (92, 550) to (100, 700). On that line the composition grows by $(100 - 92)/(700 - 550) = 8/150$ wt% B per °C:

$$C_\beta = 92 + (T - 550)\,\frac{8}{150} = 92 + (625 - 550)\,\frac{8}{150} = 92 + 4.0 = 96.0\ \text{wt\% B}$$

The first solid (β of 96 wt% B) is richer in B than the alloy, as the tie line requires.

Ends of the tie line at 600 °C

At 600 °C the alloy (85, 600) lies between the liquidus and the β solidus: β + L. The liquid end is found by isolating $C$ in the liquidus equation:

$$600 = 550 + 5\,(C_L - 70) \quad\Rightarrow\quad C_L - 70 = \frac{600 - 550}{5} = 10 \quad\Rightarrow\quad C_L = 80\ \text{wt\% B}$$
$$C_\beta = 92 + (600 - 550)\,\frac{8}{150} = 92 + 2.667 = 94.67\ \text{wt\% B}$$

Derive the lever rule and apply it

With W the mass fractions of the two phases, the total mass balance and the mass balance of B are

$$W_L + W_\beta = 1$$
$$W_L C_L + W_\beta C_\beta = C_0$$

Putting $W_L = 1 - W_\beta$ into the second equation and expanding:

$$(1 - W_\beta)\,C_L + W_\beta C_\beta = C_0$$
$$C_L + W_\beta\,(C_\beta - C_L) = C_0$$

so

$$W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_L}{C_\beta - C_L} \qquad W_L = 1 - W_\beta = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_L}$$

With a tie line of length $94.67 - 80 = 14.67$ wt% B [Session 7 Slide 16]:

$$W_\beta = \frac{85 - 80}{94.67 - 80} = \frac{5}{14.67} = 0.341$$
$$W_L = \frac{94.67 - 85}{94.67 - 80} = \frac{9.667}{14.67} = 0.659$$

Check of the B balance: $0.659 \times 80 + 0.341 \times 94.67 = 52.73 + 32.27 = 85.0$ wt% B.

Key results
  • Liquidus temperature 625 °C; first solid β of 96 wt% B.
  • At 600 °C: L of 80 wt% B and β of 94.7 wt% B; $W_L = 0.659$, $W_\beta = 0.341$.

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Microconstituents just below 550 °C

Phases just above 550 °C

The tie line now runs from the eutectic liquid ($C_E = 70$) to the β end of the eutectic line ($C_\beta = 92$), length 22 wt% B:

$$W_{\beta}(550 + \Delta T) = \frac{C_0 - C_E}{C_\beta - C_E} = \frac{85 - 70}{92 - 70} = \frac{15}{22} = 0.682$$
$$W_{L}(550 + \Delta T) = \frac{92 - 85}{22} = \frac{7}{22} = 0.318$$

Microconstituents just below 550 °C

The alloy is hypereutectic ($70 < 85 < 92$), so its primary phase is β [Session 7 Slide 31]. The β formed above 550 °C remains as primary β, and the liquid of 70 wt% B turns entirely into the eutectic microconstituent [Session 7 Slide 32]:

$$W_{\beta'} = 0.682 \qquad W_E = 0.318$$

Total phases just below 550 °C

Now α + β, on the tie line from 20 to 92 wt% B (length 72):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{92 - 85}{92 - 20} = \frac{7}{72} = 0.0972$$
$$W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{85 - 20}{72} = \frac{65}{72} = 0.903$$

Phases inside the eutectic

The primary constituent is β, so every bit of α is in the eutectic: $W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha = 0.0972$. The β of the eutectic is the total β minus the primary β, with four figures:

$$W_{\beta,E} = W_\beta - W_{\beta'} = 0.9028 - 0.6818 = 0.221$$

Check with the make-up of the eutectic, which is $(92 - 70)/72 = 0.3056$ α: $0.3182 \times 0.3056 = 0.0972$ α, and $0.0972 + 0.221 = 0.318 = W_E$.

Key results
  • Primary β $W_{\beta'} = 0.682$; eutectic $W_E = 0.318$.
  • Total phases: $W_\alpha = 0.0972$, $W_\beta = 0.903$.
  • Inside the eutectic: α 0.0972 and β 0.221 of the alloy.

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Alloys with eutectic, and the 12 wt% B alloy

Range of alloys with eutectic

An alloy contains eutectic only if some of its liquid reaches the eutectic point at 550 °C, that is, if its vertical line crosses the eutectic line. The line runs from 20 to 92 wt% B, so the alloys with eutectic are those with $20 < C_0 < 92$ wt% B. An alloy of 12 wt% B solidifies completely as α before reaching 550 °C (it crosses the α solidus), so it has no eutectic.

Temperature at which β appears

Below its solidus the 12 wt% B alloy is single-phase α, until its vertical line meets the α solvus, the straight line from (20, 550) to (5, 20). Writing that line as temperature against composition and putting $C = 12$:

$$T = 20 + (C - 5)\,\frac{550 - 20}{20 - 5} = 20 + (12 - 5)\,\frac{530}{15} = 20 + 7 \times 35.33 = 267.3\ ^\circ\text{C}$$

Below 267.3 °C α cannot hold all its B, and β precipitates as fine particles inside the α grains and on their boundaries [Session 8 Slides 3-4].

Amount of β at 20 °C

At 20 °C the tie line runs from the α solvus (5 wt% B) to the β solvus (97 wt% B), length 92:

$$W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{12 - 5}{97 - 5} = \frac{7}{92} = 0.0761$$
$$W_\alpha = \frac{97 - 12}{92} = \frac{85}{92} = 0.924$$

All this β (7.61 % of the alloy) is precipitated β; none of it is eutectic.

Key results
  • Eutectic at room temperature for $20 < C_0 < 92$ wt% B.
  • The 12 wt% B alloy crosses the α solvus at 267.3 °C; at 20 °C it holds $W_\beta = 0.0761$ of precipitated β.

Interpretation and checks

The description fixes the diagram completely once straight lines are assumed: seven points, six boundaries and six regions. The 85 wt% B alloy starts to solidify at 625 °C with β of 96 wt% B, is two-thirds primary β at 550 °C, and the last 31.8 % of liquid becomes a eutectic that holds all the α of the alloy (9.72 %). The 12 wt% B alloy shows that a two-phase structure does not need a eutectic: it appears by precipitation when the solvus is crossed at 267.3 °C.

Control cases: for $C_0 \to 70$ the primary β $W_{\beta'} = (C_0 - 70)/22 \to 0$ and the alloy is all eutectic; for $C_0 \to 92$, $W_{\beta'} \to 1$. For $C_0 \to 5$ the solvus temperature tends to 20 °C, and for $C_0 \to 20$ to 550 °C. Dimensional check: interpolation slopes are in °C per wt% B (5 °C/wt%, 530/15 = 35.33 °C/wt%) or wt% B per °C (8/150), so every interpolated temperature is in °C and every composition in wt% B; the fractions are ratios of compositions and are dimensionless.

Common exam mistake: writing the β end of the eutectic line at 8 wt% B instead of 92 wt% B; the statement gives the solubility of A in β, and the axis is wt% B.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Eutectic system: lever rule and microconstituents · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P07 — Composition of an Ag-Cu alloy worked backwards from its micrograph

A casting of 3.0 kg of an Ag-Cu alloy of unknown composition was cooled slowly. Its micrograph (sketch below) shows rounded, dendritic grains of a primary constituent in a fine lamellar matrix. Image analysis gives 55 % of the section as lamellar matrix and 45 % as primary grains; take these area fractions as mass fractions. Microanalysis shows that the primary grains are the Cu-rich solid solution (Cu).

The Ag-Cu diagram of the problem sheet has a single eutectic at 779.1 °C, where the liquid contains 28.1 wt% Cu; at that temperature the Ag-rich solid solution (Ag) holds 8.8 wt% Cu and the Cu-rich solid solution (Cu) holds 92 wt% Cu.

primary grains (45 % of the area) lamellar matrix (55 % of the area)
Figure 1. Sketch of the micrograph of Bank P07 at room temperature: rounded, dendritic grains of a primary constituent (shaded) in a fine lamellar eutectic matrix; image analysis gives 55 % of the section as lamellar matrix.

(a) Show that the eutectic fraction alone allows two compositions of the alloy, compute both, and use the micrograph to choose the right one.

(b) Just below 779.1 °C, give the phases with their compositions and mass fractions, and the mass fraction of each phase inside the eutectic.

(c) For the 3.0 kg casting, give the mass in kg of every microconstituent and of every phase just below 779.1 °C, and the mass and composition of the liquid just above 779.1 °C. How many kg of Cu does that liquid hold?

(d) The supplier's certificate states Ag-50 wt% Cu. What eutectic fraction would that alloy show? Is the certificate consistent with the micrograph?

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValue
Eutectic temperature$T_E$779.1 °C
Eutectic liquid$C_E$28.1 wt% Cu
(Ag) at $T_E$$C_\alpha$8.8 wt% Cu
(Cu) at $T_E$$C_\beta$92 wt% Cu
Eutectic fraction (lamellar matrix)$W_E$0.55
Primary fraction (grains)$W_{\beta'}$0.45, identified as (Cu)
Mass of the casting$m$3.0 kg
Certificate$C_{cert}$50 wt% Cu

In what follows α is (Ag) and β is (Cu). Compositions are mass percentages of Cu; in a ratio of composition differences the factor 1/100 that turns them into mass fractions cancels, but in a mass of Cu it does not: 28.1 wt% is a mass fraction of 0.281.

Model

  • Lever rule on a horizontal tie line [Session 7 Slides 15-16], derived in part (a) from the two mass balances.
  • Microconstituents [Session 7 Slides 30-32]: just below $T_E$ the primary phase is the solid present just above $T_E$, and the eutectic is the liquid of composition $C_E$ present just above $T_E$. A hypoeutectic alloy ($C_\alpha < C_0 < C_E$) has primary α; a hypereutectic one ($C_E < C_0 < C_\beta$) has primary β.
  • Hypotheses: equilibrium cooling; area fraction equal to mass fraction (as the statement imposes); closed system.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Two candidate compositions and the choice

Derive the lever rule for the eutectic fraction

Just above $T_E$ the alloy holds a primary solid and liquid of composition $C_E$; that liquid becomes the eutectic, so $W_E = W_L(T_E + \Delta T)$. For a tie line from a solid of composition $C_s$ to the liquid $C_E$, the total mass balance and the Cu balance are

$$W_s + W_L = 1$$
$$W_s C_s + W_L C_E = C_0$$

Putting $W_s = 1 - W_L$ in the second equation and expanding:

$$(1 - W_L)\,C_s + W_L C_E = C_0$$
$$C_s + W_L\,(C_E - C_s) = C_0$$

hence

$$W_E = W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_s}{C_E - C_s}$$

Hypoeutectic candidate (solid α, $C_s = 8.8$)

$$0.55 = \frac{C_0 - 8.8}{28.1 - 8.8} = \frac{C_0 - 8.8}{19.3}$$
$$C_0 - 8.8 = 0.55 \times 19.3 = 10.615 \quad\Rightarrow\quad C_0 = 8.8 + 10.615 = 19.4\ \text{wt\% Cu}$$

Hypereutectic candidate (solid β, $C_s = 92$)

With $C_s = 92$ the same formula reads $W_E = (C_0 - 92)/(28.1 - 92) = (92 - C_0)/(92 - 28.1)$:

$$0.55 = \frac{92 - C_0}{92 - 28.1} = \frac{92 - C_0}{63.9}$$
$$92 - C_0 = 0.55 \times 63.9 = 35.145 \quad\Rightarrow\quad C_0 = 92 - 35.145 = 56.86\ \text{wt\% Cu}$$

Choose with the primary constituent

The eutectic fraction is the same function of $C_0$ on both sides of E, rising from 0 at an end of the eutectic line to 1 at E, so one value of $W_E$ always corresponds to two alloys. The primary constituent tells them apart: a hypoeutectic Ag-Cu alloy would show primary (Ag), a hypereutectic one primary (Cu) [Session 7 Slides 30-31]. The microanalysis finds (Cu) grains, so

$$C_0 = 56.86\ \text{wt\% Cu} \qquad (28.1 < 56.86 < 92\text{, hypereutectic})$$
Key results
  • Hypoeutectic candidate: $C_0 = 19.4$ wt% Cu (primary would be (Ag)).
  • Hypereutectic candidate: $C_0 = 56.86$ wt% Cu (primary would be (Cu)).
  • The primary grains are (Cu): the alloy is Ag-56.86 wt% Cu.

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Phases just below 779.1 °C and the make-up of the eutectic

Total phases with the lever rule

Below $T_E$ the liquid has gone and the alloy is α + β. With the lever rule of part (a) on the tie line from $C_\alpha = 8.8$ to $C_\beta = 92$ (length 83.2), carrying $C_0 = 56.855$:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{92 - 56.855}{92 - 8.8} = \frac{35.145}{83.2} = 0.422$$
$$W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{56.855 - 8.8}{83.2} = \frac{48.055}{83.2} = 0.578$$

Split the β between primary and eutectic

The primary β is 0.45 of the alloy (data). The rest of the β, and all of the α, are inside the eutectic:

$$W_{\beta,E} = W_\beta - W_{\beta'} = 0.5776 - 0.45 = 0.128$$
$$W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha = 0.422$$

Check: $W_{\alpha,E} + W_{\beta,E} = 0.422 + 0.128 = 0.550 = W_E$.

Make-up of the eutectic

The eutectic is the liquid of 28.1 wt% Cu split on the tie line 8.8–92; its α fraction is

$$\frac{C_\beta - C_E}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{92 - 28.1}{83.2} = \frac{63.9}{83.2} = 0.768$$

so the eutectic is 76.8 % α and 23.2 % β whatever the alloy, and $0.55 \times 0.768 = 0.422$ reproduces $W_{\alpha,E}$. The lamellar matrix is mostly the Ag-rich phase.

Key results
  • α (8.8 wt% Cu) $W_\alpha = 0.422$; β (92 wt% Cu) $W_\beta = 0.578$.
  • Inside the eutectic: α 0.422 and β 0.128 of the alloy; the eutectic itself is 76.8 % α.

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Masses in the 3.0 kg casting

Microconstituents and phases just below 779.1 °C

The mass of each constituent is its mass fraction times the mass of the casting, $m_i = W_i\,m$:

$$m_{\beta'} = 0.45 \times 3.0\ \text{kg} = 1.35\ \text{kg} \qquad m_E = 0.55 \times 3.0\ \text{kg} = 1.65\ \text{kg}$$
$$m_\alpha = 0.4224 \times 3.0\ \text{kg} = 1.267\ \text{kg} \qquad m_\beta = 0.5776 \times 3.0\ \text{kg} = 1.733\ \text{kg}$$
$$m_{\beta,E} = 0.1276 \times 3.0\ \text{kg} = 0.383\ \text{kg}$$

Check: $1.35 + 1.65 = 3.00$ kg and $1.267 + 1.733 = 3.000$ kg.

The liquid just above 779.1 °C

Just above $T_E$ the alloy is β + L; the liquid has the eutectic composition, 28.1 wt% Cu, and its mass is the future eutectic, 1.65 kg. Converting the composition to a mass fraction, $28.1\ \text{wt\%} \rightarrow 0.281$:

$$m_{Cu,L} = 0.281 \times 1.65\ \text{kg} = 0.464\ \text{kg}$$

Cu balance of the casting

The Cu of the primary β is $0.92 \times 1.35\ \text{kg} = 1.242$ kg, so the casting holds $1.242 + 0.464 = 1.706$ kg of Cu, which is $1.706/3.0 = 0.5686$ of its mass: 56.86 wt% Cu, the composition found in part (a).

Key results
  • Primary β 1.35 kg, eutectic 1.65 kg; α 1.267 kg, β 1.733 kg (of which 0.383 kg in the eutectic).
  • Just above 779.1 °C: 1.65 kg of liquid of 28.1 wt% Cu, holding 0.464 kg of Cu.

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Checking the certificate

Eutectic fraction of the certified alloy

Ag-50 wt% Cu is also hypereutectic ($28.1 < 50 < 92$), so its eutectic is

$$W_E(50) = \frac{92 - 50}{92 - 28.1} = \frac{42}{63.9} = 0.657$$

and its primary (Cu) is $1 - 0.657 = 0.343$.

Compare with the measurement

The micrograph shows 0.55 eutectic, not 0.657: about 11 points less eutectic and therefore more primary (Cu) than the certified alloy would have. Because $W_E$ falls as $C_0$ moves from E towards β, less eutectic means more Cu: the measurement corresponds to 56.86 wt% Cu, not 50. Within the hypotheses of the problem (equilibrium cooling, area fraction equal to mass fraction), the certificate is not consistent with the micrograph. The two alloys would also differ in their total phase fractions: α would be $42/83.2 = 0.505$ for the certified alloy, against 0.422 for the alloy of the micrograph.

Key results
  • Ag-50 wt% Cu would show $W_E = 0.657$ eutectic and 0.343 primary (Cu).
  • Measured 0.55: the certificate overstates the Ag content of the alloy (or understates its Cu); the micrograph points to 56.86 wt% Cu.

Interpretation and checks

A eutectic fraction alone never fixes the composition: it gives one hypoeutectic and one hypereutectic alloy, here 19.4 and 56.86 wt% Cu, and the nature of the primary grains decides between them. The alloy is hypereutectic: 45 % primary (Cu) dendrites in a matrix that, although it is 55 % of the alloy, is three-quarters Ag-rich α.

Control cases: with $W_E \to 1$ both candidates tend to $C_E = 28.1$ (fully eutectic), and with $W_E \to 0$ they tend to the ends of the eutectic line, 8.8 and 92 wt% Cu. All fractions lie between 0 and 1 and the masses add up to 3.0 kg. Dimensional check: the lever rule is a ratio of composition differences, (wt% Cu)/(wt% Cu), so it is dimensionless; a mass is a dimensionless fraction times kg, so it is in kg; and a mass of Cu needs the composition as a fraction (0.281), not as 28.1.

Common exam mistake (the trap of this problem): solving only on the side of the eutectic point one is used to (the hypoeutectic one) and answering 19.4 wt% Cu, an alloy that would show primary (Ag), not the (Cu) grains of the micrograph.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Eutectic system: lever rule and microconstituents · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P08 — Cooling history of a 50 kg casting from a table of tie-line compositions

In a hypothetical A-B system, A melts at 1000 °C and forms with B a eutectic at 800 °C. Instead of the diagram, the laboratory gives the compositions (wt% B) of the phases that are in equilibrium at several temperatures:

T (°C)Liquid in equilibrium with αα (on the solidus or solvus)β (on the solvus)
10000 (pure A melts)0—
950124—
900248—
8503612—
800 (eutectic)481685
600—1088
400—691
20—394

Between two rows every boundary may be taken as straight (linear interpolation). A casting of 50 kg of an A-30 wt% B alloy is cooled slowly from 1050 °C to 20 °C.

(a) At which temperature does the casting start to solidify, and what is the composition of the first solid? At which temperature does it finish, and what is the composition of the last liquid?

(b) At 850 °C, give the phases, their compositions and their masses in kg.

(c) Just above and just below 800 °C, give the phases and the microconstituents with their masses in kg, and the mass of α inside the eutectic.

(d) At 20 °C, give the masses of α and β. How many kg of β form below 800 °C, from which constituent, and why?

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValue
Alloy$C_0$30 wt% B
Mass of the casting$m$50 kg
Eutectic$T_E$, $C_E$800 °C, 48 wt% B
Ends of the eutectic line$C_\alpha$, $C_\beta$16 and 85 wt% B
Tie linesrows of the tableliquid and α from 950 to 800 °C; α and β from 800 to 20 °C

The first column of compositions lies on the liquidus, the second on the α solidus (above 800 °C) or on the α solvus (below), the third on the β solvus. The table is the diagram: plotting its points and joining them gives the figure of part (a). The lever rule uses ratios of compositions in wt% B, where the factor 1/100 cancels; a mass is a fraction times 50 kg.

Model

  • Tie line at temperature $T$: its ends are the two compositions in the row of $T$ [Session 7 Slide 15]; between rows, linear interpolation, $C(T) = C_1 + (T - T_1)\dfrac{C_2 - C_1}{T_2 - T_1}$.
  • Lever rule [Session 7 Slides 15-16], derived in part (b).
  • Microconstituents of a hypoeutectic alloy [Session 7 Slides 30, 32]; precipitation below the solvus [Session 8 Slides 3-4]. Hypotheses: equilibrium cooling, closed system.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

First solid and last liquid

Place the alloy against the liquidus

On cooling, the alloy stays liquid until the liquid column of the table reaches its own composition: that point is on the liquidus. The liquid column goes from 24 wt% B at 900 °C to 36 wt% B at 850 °C, so 30 wt% B is reached between those two rows. Writing the liquidus between them as a straight line and isolating $T$:

$$C_L = 24 + (900 - T)\,\frac{36 - 24}{900 - 850} = 24 + 0.24\,(900 - T)$$
$$30 = 24 + 0.24\,(900 - T) \quad\Rightarrow\quad 900 - T = \frac{30 - 24}{0.24} = 25 \quad\Rightarrow\quad T = 875\ ^\circ\text{C}$$

Composition of the first solid

At 875 °C the first crystals are the α at the other end of the tie line, on the α solidus, interpolated between 8 wt% B (900 °C) and 12 wt% B (850 °C):

$$C_\alpha(875) = 8 + (900 - 875)\,\frac{12 - 8}{900 - 850} = 8 + 25 \times 0.08 = 10\ \text{wt\% B}$$

The first solid is much poorer in B than the alloy (10 against 30 wt% B), so the liquid left behind gets richer in B as α grows.

End of solidification

The alloy lies on the eutectic line, $16 < 30 < 48$, so it is hypoeutectic: its liquid keeps enriching along the liquidus until it reaches the eutectic point, 48 wt% B at 800 °C, and that last liquid turns into α + β at constant temperature [Session 7 Slides 30, 32]:

$$\text{cooling: } L\ (48\ \text{wt\% B}) \rightarrow \alpha\ (16\ \text{wt\% B}) + \beta\ (85\ \text{wt\% B}) \quad \text{at } 800\ ^\circ\text{C (eutectic)}$$
0 (A) 10 16 30 48 70 85 100 (B) 20 400 600 800 1000 Composition (wt% B) Temperature (°C) C0 = 30 10 36 12 E L B-rich side not in the table α β α + β α + L
Figure 1. The points of the table of Bank P08 joined by straight segments: liquidus (C_L) and solidus (C_α) from 1000 °C to the eutectic at 800 °C and 48 wt% B, α and β solvus down to 20 °C. Dashed: the alloy of 30 wt% B, which meets the liquidus at 875 °C (first solid α of 10 wt% B); tie lines at 875 and 850 °C.
Key results
  • Solidification starts at 875 °C; the first solid is α of 10 wt% B.
  • It ends at 800 °C with the eutectic reaction; the last liquid has 48 wt% B.

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Phases and masses at 850 °C

Read the tie line

850 °C lies between 875 °C and 800 °C, so the alloy is in α + L. The row of 850 °C gives the ends of the tie line: $C_\alpha = 12$ and $C_L = 36$ wt% B.

Derive the lever rule

The two phases make up the whole alloy (total mass balance), and the B of the alloy is the B of α plus the B of the liquid (mass balance of B):

$$W_\alpha + W_L = 1$$
$$W_\alpha C_\alpha + W_L C_L = C_0$$

Replacing $W_\alpha = 1 - W_L$ and expanding:

$$(1 - W_L)\,C_\alpha + W_L C_L = C_0$$
$$C_\alpha + W_L\,(C_L - C_\alpha) = C_0$$

so

$$W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha} \qquad W_\alpha = 1 - W_L = \frac{C_L - C_0}{C_L - C_\alpha}$$

Substitute and convert to kg

$$W_L = \frac{30 - 12}{36 - 12} = \frac{18}{24} = 0.75 \qquad W_\alpha = \frac{36 - 30}{24} = \frac{6}{24} = 0.25$$
$$m_L = 0.75 \times 50\ \text{kg} = 37.5\ \text{kg} \qquad m_\alpha = 0.25 \times 50\ \text{kg} = 12.5\ \text{kg}$$

Check of the B balance: $12.5 \times 0.12 + 37.5 \times 0.36 = 1.5 + 13.5 = 15.0$ kg of B, which is $0.30 \times 50$ kg.

Key results
  • L of 36 wt% B and α of 12 wt% B.
  • $W_L = 0.75$: 37.5 kg of liquid and 12.5 kg of α.

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Just above and just below 800 °C

Just above 800 °C

The row of 800 °C gives $C_\alpha = 16$ and $C_L = C_E = 48$ wt% B (length 32):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{48 - 30}{48 - 16} = \frac{18}{32} = 0.5625 \qquad W_L = \frac{30 - 16}{32} = \frac{14}{32} = 0.4375$$
$$m_\alpha = 0.5625 \times 50 = 28.125\ \text{kg} \qquad m_L = 0.4375 \times 50 = 21.875\ \text{kg}$$

Just below 800 °C: phases

The eutectic reaction has used up the liquid. The tie line is the whole eutectic line, $C_\alpha = 16$ to $C_\beta = 85$ wt% B (length 69):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{85 - 30}{85 - 16} = \frac{55}{69} = 0.7971 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{30 - 16}{69} = \frac{14}{69} = 0.2029$$
$$m_\alpha = 0.7971 \times 50 = 39.86\ \text{kg} \qquad m_\beta = 0.2029 \times 50 = 10.14\ \text{kg}$$

Just below 800 °C: microconstituents

The α formed above 800 °C stays as primary α, and the liquid of eutectic composition becomes the eutectic [Session 7 Slide 32]:

$$m_{\alpha'} = 28.125\ \text{kg} \qquad m_E = 21.875\ \text{kg}$$

All the β is in the eutectic (the primary phase is α); the α of the eutectic is the total α minus the primary α:

$$m_{\alpha,E} = 39.86 - 28.125 = 11.73\ \text{kg}$$

Check with the make-up of the eutectic, $(85 - 48)/69 = 0.5362$ α: $0.5362 \times 21.875 = 11.73$ kg, and $11.73 + 10.14 = 21.87$ kg $= m_E$.

Key results
  • 800 + ΔT: α 28.125 kg, L 21.875 kg.
  • 800 − ΔT: α 39.86 kg (16 wt% B), β 10.14 kg (85 wt% B).
  • Primary α 28.125 kg, eutectic 21.875 kg; α inside the eutectic 11.73 kg.

Part (d) · 0.75 points

At 20 °C and the precipitated β

Phases at 20 °C

Below 800 °C the ends of the tie line follow the two solvus columns; at 20 °C they are $C_\alpha = 3$ and $C_\beta = 94$ wt% B (length 91):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{94 - 30}{94 - 3} = \frac{64}{91} = 0.7033 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{30 - 3}{91} = \frac{27}{91} = 0.2967$$
$$m_\alpha = 0.7033 \times 50 = 35.16\ \text{kg} \qquad m_\beta = 0.2967 \times 50 = 14.84\ \text{kg}$$

β formed in the solid state

$$\Delta m_\beta = m_\beta(20\ ^\circ\text{C}) - m_\beta(800 - \Delta T) = 14.835 - 10.145 = 4.69\ \text{kg}$$

(with the unrounded masses $50 \times 27/91 = 14.835$ kg and $50 \times 14/69 = 10.145$ kg). The α column falls from 16 wt% B at 800 °C to 3 wt% B at 20 °C: α can hold less and less B, so the α of the casting (primary α and the α of the eutectic) becomes supersaturated and rejects the excess as small β particles, which grow as the temperature falls [Session 8 Slides 3-4]. The β column also moves (85 → 94 wt% B), so the β already present gets slightly richer in B too. The microconstituents keep their names; the primary α now holds fine β precipitates.

Key results
  • α (3 wt% B) 35.16 kg; β (94 wt% B) 14.84 kg.
  • 4.69 kg of β precipitate below 800 °C, from the α (primary and eutectic).

Interpretation and checks

The table is enough to follow the whole cooling: the casting starts to solidify at 875 °C with α of 10 wt% B, is three-quarters liquid at 850 °C, reaches 800 °C with 28.1 kg of primary α and 21.9 kg of liquid of 48 wt% B, and that liquid becomes eutectic. In the solid, another 4.69 kg of β precipitate down to room temperature.

Control cases: for $C_0 \to 16$ the eutectic vanishes and for $C_0 \to 48$ the casting is all eutectic; at the liquidus temperature (875 °C) the lever rule gives $W_L = (30 - 10)/(30 - 10) = 1$, all liquid, as it must. Every pair of masses adds up to 50 kg. Dimensional check: the lever rule is (wt% B)/(wt% B), dimensionless; the interpolation slopes are 0.24 and 0.08 wt% B per °C, so $(T_1 - T)$ in °C times them gives wt% B; masses are fractions times kg.

Common exam mistake: taking the first solid to have the alloy composition (30 wt% B). The first solid sits at the other end of the tie line, on the solidus, and is much poorer in B (10 wt% B).

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Fe-Fe3C diagram and steel microstructures · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P09 — Hypoeutectoid steel bar above and below the eutectoid temperature

A bar of plain carbon steel with a mass of 8.0 kg and a carbon content of 0.45 wt% C is fully austenitised and then cooled slowly enough to stay at equilibrium. Use the metastable Fe-Fe₃C diagram of the course.

(a) Just above the eutectoid temperature (727 + ΔT °C), name the phases present and give their chemical composition and mass fraction.

(b) Just below the eutectoid temperature (727 − ΔT °C), name the phases and the microconstituents present and give the mass fraction of each.

(c) Calculate the mass, in kg, of proeutectoid ferrite, of eutectoid ferrite (the ferrite inside the pearlite) and of cementite in the bar at 727 − ΔT °C.

(d) Draw a schematic sketch of the microstructure at 727 − ΔT °C, and explain how the amount of proeutectoid ferrite and the pearlite would change if the bar were cooled faster.

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueAs a fraction or in SI
Mass of the bar$m$8.0 kg8.0 kg
Carbon content of the steel$C_0$0.45 wt% C0.0045
Carbon in ferrite at 727 °C (maximum solubility)$C_\alpha$0.022 wt% CSession 9, Slides 5 and 10
Eutectoid composition (austenite at 727 °C)$C_E$0.76 wt% CSession 9, Slide 10
Carbon in cementite, Fe₃C$C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$6.67 wt% CSession 9, Slides 4 and 8
Eutectoid temperature$T_E$727 °CSession 9, Slide 10

The lever rule uses ratios of compositions, so the wt% values can be used directly: the factor 1/100 that turns wt% into a mass fraction cancels between numerator and denominator.

Model

  • Metastable Fe-Fe₃C diagram, Session 9, Slide 4. Eutectoid reaction on cooling, Session 9, Slide 10: γ (0.76 wt% C) → α (0.022 wt% C) + Fe₃C (6.67 wt% C) at 727 °C; its product is pearlite.
  • Since $C_0 = 0.45 < C_E = 0.76$, the steel is hypoeutectoid (Session 9, Slide 4): its microconstituents below 727 °C are proeutectoid ferrite and pearlite (Session 9, Slide 14).
  • Lever rule on a tie line (Session 7, Slides 15-21), derived in part (a).
  • Hypothesis: slow (equilibrium) cooling, so the compositions of the phases are those read on the diagram.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Phases, compositions and amounts just above the eutectoid temperature

Locate the alloy on the diagram and read the ends of the tie line

On cooling, the 0.45 wt% C austenite crosses the A3 line and ferrite starts to form at the austenite grain boundaries (Session 9, Slide 15). Just above 727 °C the point lies in the two-phase field α + γ. The horizontal tie line at 727 + ΔT °C ends on the ferrite boundary at $C_\alpha = 0.022$ wt% C and on the A3 line at the eutectoid point, $C_\gamma = C_E = 0.76$ wt% C (Session 9, Slides 4 and 17).

Derive the lever rule from the two mass balances

The phases are the only two places where the mass of the alloy can be, so the mass fractions add up to one (mass balance of the alloy):

$$W_\alpha + W_\gamma = 1$$

The carbon of the alloy is shared between the two phases (mass balance of carbon):

$$W_\alpha C_\alpha + W_\gamma C_\gamma = C_0$$

Substitute $W_\gamma = 1 - W_\alpha$ from the first balance into the second:

$$W_\alpha C_\alpha + (1 - W_\alpha) C_\gamma = C_0$$

Expand and group the terms in $W_\alpha$:

$$W_\alpha (C_\alpha - C_\gamma) = C_0 - C_\gamma$$

Divide by $(C_\alpha - C_\gamma)$ and change the sign of numerator and denominator:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\gamma - C_0}{C_\gamma - C_\alpha}, \qquad W_\gamma = 1 - W_\alpha = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\gamma - C_\alpha}$$

This is the lever rule of Session 7, Slides 15-21: each phase is weighted by the segment of the tie line on the opposite side of $C_0$.

Substitute the compositions

Tie line length: $C_\gamma - C_\alpha = 0.76 - 0.022 = 0.738$ wt% C.

$$W_\alpha = \frac{0.76 - 0.45}{0.76 - 0.022} = \frac{0.31}{0.738} = 0.4201$$
$$W_\gamma = \frac{0.45 - 0.022}{0.76 - 0.022} = \frac{0.428}{0.738} = 0.5799$$

Result: 42.0 % ferrite with 0.022 wt% C and 58.0 % austenite with 0.76 wt% C.

Checks: $0.4201 + 0.5799 = 1$. Carbon balance: $0.4201 \times 0.022 + 0.5799 \times 0.76 = 0.0092 + 0.4407 = 0.450$ wt% C $= C_0$.

Key results
  • Phases: ferrite α with 0.022 wt% C and austenite γ with 0.76 wt% C
  • $W_\alpha = 0.4201$ (42.0 %), $W_\gamma = 0.5799$ (58.0 %)

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Phases and microconstituents just below the eutectoid temperature

Phases: lever rule on the tie line from ferrite to cementite

Below 727 °C the point lies in the α + Fe₃C field (Session 9, Slide 9). The tie line at 727 − ΔT runs from $C_\alpha = 0.022$ to $C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 6.67$ wt% C, length $6.67 - 0.022 = 6.648$. With the lever rule of part (a), written for the pair α, Fe₃C (Session 9, Slide 18):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_0}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} = \frac{6.67 - 0.45}{6.67 - 0.022} = \frac{6.22}{6.648} = 0.9356$$
$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} = \frac{0.45 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{0.428}{6.648} = 0.0644$$

Microconstituents: the austenite of 727 + ΔT becomes pearlite

The proeutectoid (primary) ferrite formed above 727 °C does not change when the steel crosses the eutectoid line. The austenite present at 727 + ΔT has exactly the eutectoid composition, 0.76 wt% C, so all of it undergoes the eutectoid reaction γ (0.76) → α (0.022) + Fe₃C (6.67) and becomes pearlite (Session 9, Slides 10 and 18). The fractions are therefore those of part (a), which is the lever rule on the short tie line from $C_\alpha$ to $C_E$:

$$W_{\alpha_p} = \frac{C_E - C_0}{C_E - C_\alpha} = \frac{0.76 - 0.45}{0.738} = 0.4201, \qquad W_P = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_E - C_\alpha} = \frac{0.428}{0.738} = 0.5799$$

Result: two phases, ferrite (93.6 %, 0.022 wt% C) and cementite (6.4 %, 6.67 wt% C); two microconstituents, proeutectoid ferrite (42.0 %) and pearlite (58.0 %, overall 0.76 wt% C).

Checks: each pair adds up to 1. The ferrite phase (93.6 %) is larger than the proeutectoid ferrite (42.0 %) because the pearlite also contains ferrite; part (c) separates the two.

Key results
  • Phases: α (0.022 wt% C) $W_\alpha = 0.9356$; Fe₃C (6.67 wt% C) $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.0644$
  • Microconstituents: proeutectoid ferrite $W_{\alpha_p} = 0.4201$; pearlite $W_P = 0.5799$ (0.76 wt% C)

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Mass of proeutectoid ferrite, eutectoid ferrite and cementite in the 8.0 kg bar

Split the ferrite phase into proeutectoid and eutectoid ferrite

The ferrite phase of part (b) is the sum of the proeutectoid ferrite and the ferrite of the pearlite lamellae (Session 9, Slide 18):

$$W_{\alpha} = W_{\alpha_p} + W_{\alpha_E}$$

Isolate the eutectoid ferrite:

$$W_{\alpha_E} = W_\alpha - W_{\alpha_p} = \frac{6.22}{6.648} - \frac{0.31}{0.738} = 0.9356 - 0.4201 = 0.5156$$

Convert mass fractions into masses

A mass fraction is the mass of the constituent divided by the mass of the bar, $W_i = m_i / m$, so $m_i = W_i\, m$ with $m = 8.0$ kg:

$$m_{\alpha_p} = 0.4201 \times 8.0\ \text{kg} = 3.360\ \text{kg}$$
$$m_{\alpha_E} = 0.5156 \times 8.0\ \text{kg} = 4.125\ \text{kg}$$
$$m_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.0644 \times 8.0\ \text{kg} = 0.515\ \text{kg}$$

(The products are computed with the unrounded fractions, 0.420054, 0.515566 and 0.064380.)

Check with the make-up of pearlite

Every pearlite has the make-up of the eutectoid steel, $W_\alpha = (6.67 - 0.76)/(6.67 - 0.022) = 5.91/6.648 = 0.8890$ ferrite and 0.1110 cementite (Session 9, Slide 13). The pearlite of the bar weighs $0.5799 \times 8.0 = 4.640$ kg, so it holds $0.8890 \times 4.640 = 4.125$ kg of ferrite and $0.1110 \times 4.640 = 0.515$ kg of cementite, the values above. Mass check: $3.360 + 4.125 + 0.515 = 8.000$ kg.

Key results
  • Proeutectoid ferrite: 3.360 kg
  • Eutectoid ferrite (inside the pearlite): 4.125 kg
  • Cementite: 0.515 kg (all of it inside the pearlite)

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Sketch of the microstructure and effect of a faster cooling

Draw the two microconstituents in their proportions

The proeutectoid ferrite nucleated at the austenite grain boundaries between the A3 line and 727 °C and grew into equiaxed, light grains; the remaining austenite became pearlite, alternating lamellae of ferrite and cementite (Session 9, Slides 12 and 14). As an approximation (not stated on the slides), the densities of ferrite and pearlite are taken as close, so the mass fractions are drawn as area fractions on the section: about 42 % of light ferrite grains and 58 % of lamellar colonies.

Proeutectoid ferrite, αp light grains, 0.022 wt% C Pearlite (α + Fe₃C) lamellar colonies, 0.76 wt% C 0.45 wt% C, 727 - ΔT °C
Figure 1. Bank P09 (d): 0.45 wt% C steel at 727 - ΔT °C. Light grains: proeutectoid ferrite (about 42 % of the area). Lamellar grains: pearlite (about 58 %), alternating ferrite and cementite lamellae.

Faster cooling: displacement of the eutectoid point

Session 9, Slide 21: if the cooling rate increases, the eutectoid point moves towards lower temperatures and lower carbon contents. The tie line used for the microconstituents then ends at a value $C_E' < 0.76$ wt% C, and the proeutectoid ferrite fraction $(C_E' - C_0)/(C_E' - C_\alpha)$ falls because its numerator shrinks faster than its denominator. So the bar would show less proeutectoid ferrite and more pearlite, and the pearlite lamellae would be closer together (fine pearlite), which raises its hardness (Session 9, Slides 12 and 21). The number 0.4201 is valid only for equilibrium cooling.

Key results
  • Sketch: light grains of proeutectoid ferrite (about 42 % of the area) and lamellar pearlite colonies (about 58 %)
  • Faster cooling: the eutectoid point moves to lower temperature and lower %C, so less proeutectoid ferrite, more pearlite and finer (harder) pearlite

Interpretation and checks

The steel spends its last moments above 727 °C as a 42/58 mixture of ferrite and eutectoid austenite; the eutectoid reaction turns all of that austenite into pearlite without touching the ferrite, which is why the microconstituent fractions below 727 °C equal the phase fractions above it. Most of the bar is ferrite (93.6 % by mass), and the 6.4 % of hard cementite is entirely inside the pearlite.

Limiting cases: with $C_0 \to C_\alpha = 0.022$ the lever rule gives $W_{\alpha_p} \to 1$ (all ferrite); with $C_0 \to C_E = 0.76$ it gives $W_{\alpha_p} \to 0$ (all pearlite, the eutectoid steel of Session 9, Slide 13).

Dimensional check: the lever rule is a ratio of two compositions, (wt%)/(wt%), so it is dimensionless; a mass is a dimensionless fraction times kg, so it is in kg.

Common exam mistake: giving the 0.9356 of the long tie line as the "proeutectoid ferrite". That is the whole ferrite phase; the proeutectoid ferrite comes from the short tie line ending at 0.76 wt% C.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Fe-Fe3C diagram and steel microstructures · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P10 — Slow cooling of a hypereutectoid tool steel read on the Fe-Fe3C diagram

A 2.5 kg forging of a tool steel with 1.10 wt% C is held at 950 °C (point a of the figure) until it is completely austenitic. It is then cooled slowly to room temperature, so the steel follows the equilibrium diagram. At point b the first new constituent appears at the grain boundaries; the steel goes on cooling through 780 °C, reaches the eutectoid line and ends at room temperature. The figure is the steel corner of the metastable Fe-Fe₃C diagram drawn with the values of the course; the Acm line is drawn as a straight segment between its two printed ends.

0 0.5 0.76 1.10 1.5 2.14 600 727 800 900 1000 1100 1147 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) 1.10 wt% C a b γ (austenite) α + γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C γ + L 0.022 912 727 °C Acm A3
Figure 1. Bank P10: steel region of the metastable Fe-Fe3C diagram with the values of Session 9 Slides 4 and 10 (eutectoid 727 °C at 0.76 wt% C, ferrite 0.022 wt% C, austenite 2.14 wt% C at 1147 °C). Dashed grid every 50 °C. The vertical line is the 1.10 wt% C steel; a is the start of the cooling, b the crossing of the Acm line.

(a) Read the temperature of point b on the diagram. Which constituent starts to form there, and where? Give the phases, their compositions and their mass fractions at 780 °C.

(b) Write the reaction that takes place at 727 °C and calculate the mass, in kg, of proeutectoid cementite and of pearlite in the forging at 727 − ΔT °C.

(c) Calculate the mass of the ferrite and cementite phases in the forging at 727 − ΔT °C.

(d) How much of the cementite is inside the pearlite? Check it in two independent ways, and explain where the proeutectoid cementite sits and what that means for the toughness of the steel.

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueSource
Mass of the forging$m$2.5 kgstatement
Carbon content$C_0$1.10 wt% Cstatement
Eutectoid point$(C_E, T_E)$(0.76 wt% C, 727 °C)figure; Session 9, Slide 10
Upper end of Acm (maximum solubility of C in γ)$(C_{\gamma,\max}, T_{eu})$(2.14 wt% C, 1147 °C)figure; Session 9, Slides 6 and 10
Carbon in ferrite at 727 °C$C_\alpha$0.022 wt% Cfigure; Session 9, Slides 5 and 10
Carbon in cementite$C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$6.67 wt% CSession 9, Slides 4 and 8

Compositions enter only as ratios in the lever rule, so they are used in wt% (the factor 1/100 that turns wt% into a fraction cancels). Masses stay in kg.

Model

  • Since $0.76 < C_0 = 1.10 < 2.14$ wt% C, the steel is hypereutectoid (Session 9, Slide 4): its microconstituents below 727 °C are proeutectoid cementite and pearlite (Session 9, Slide 19).
  • Lever rule, from the mass balances $W_1 + W_2 = 1$ and $W_1 C_1 + W_2 C_2 = C_0$ (Session 7, Slides 15-21); derived in part (a).
  • The straight Acm segment of the figure, through $(0.76, 727)$ and $(2.14, 1147)$, gives the boundary γ / γ + Fe₃C: $T_{Acm}(C) = 727 + (C - 0.76)\,\dfrac{1147 - 727}{2.14 - 0.76}$ °C.
  • Hypothesis: equilibrium (slow) cooling.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Start of the transformation and phases at 780 °C

Read point b on the Acm line

From a (950 °C) down to b the steel is single-phase austenite with 1.10 wt% C ($W_\gamma = 1$). Point b lies on the straight Acm segment. Between its printed ends, the temperature grows linearly with the composition: the slope is $(1147 - 727)/(2.14 - 0.76) = 420/1.38 = 304.3$ °C per wt% C. At $C_0 = 1.10$:

$$T_b = 727 + (1.10 - 0.76) \times \frac{420}{1.38} = 727 + 0.34 \times 304.3 = 727 + 103.5 = 830.5\ ^\circ\text{C}$$

On the dashed 50 °C grid of the figure, b lies three fifths of the way from the 800 °C line to the 850 °C line: about 830 °C, in agreement.

Constituent that forms at b

Below Acm the solubility of carbon in austenite is lower than 1.10 wt% C, so the excess carbon leaves the austenite as proeutectoid cementite, Fe₃C, which forms along the boundaries of the austenite grains (Session 9, Slide 19). The austenite that remains becomes poorer in carbon, following the Acm line down towards 0.76 wt% C.

Composition of the austenite at 780 °C

At 780 °C the tie line starts on Acm. Invert the straight line $T = 727 + (C - 0.76)\times 420/1.38$ for $C$: subtract 727, multiply by $1.38/420$, add 0.76:

$$C_\gamma(780) = 0.76 + (780 - 727) \times \frac{1.38}{420} = 0.76 + 53 \times 0.003286 = 0.76 + 0.1741 = 0.934\ \text{wt\% C}$$

The other end of the tie line is cementite, $C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 6.67$ wt% C (a vertical line on the diagram, Session 9, Slide 4).

Lever rule, derived from the mass balances

Mass of the alloy: $W_\gamma + W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 1$. Carbon: $W_\gamma C_\gamma + W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = C_0$. Put $W_\gamma = 1 - W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$ into the carbon balance:

$$C_\gamma + W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}(C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\gamma) = C_0$$

Subtract $C_\gamma$ and divide by $(C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\gamma)$:

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{C_0 - C_\gamma}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\gamma}, \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_0}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\gamma}$$

Substitute at 780 °C

Tie line length: $6.67 - 0.934 = 5.736$ wt% C.

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 1.10}{6.67 - 0.934} = \frac{5.57}{5.736} = 0.9711, \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{1.10 - 0.934}{5.736} = \frac{0.166}{5.736} = 0.0289$$

Result: at 780 °C, 97.1 % austenite with 0.934 wt% C and 2.9 % cementite with 6.67 wt% C. Check: $0.9711 \times 0.934 + 0.0289 \times 6.67 = 0.907 + 0.193 = 1.10$ wt% C.

Key results
  • Point b: about 830 °C (830.5 °C on the straight Acm); proeutectoid cementite starts to form at the austenite grain boundaries
  • At 780 °C: γ with 0.934 wt% C, $W_\gamma = 0.9711$; Fe₃C with 6.67 wt% C, $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.0289$

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Eutectoid reaction, proeutectoid cementite and pearlite in the forging

The eutectoid reaction

Cooling: γ (0.76 wt% C) → α (0.022 wt% C) + Fe₃C (6.67 wt% C) at 727 °C, eutectoid reaction; the lamellar product is pearlite (Session 9, Slides 10 and 12).

Tie line just above 727 °C

At 727 + ΔT the tie line runs from the eutectoid austenite, $C_E = 0.76$, to cementite, 6.67 wt% C; length $6.67 - 0.76 = 5.91$. With the lever rule of part (a):

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},p} = \frac{C_0 - C_E}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_E} = \frac{1.10 - 0.76}{5.91} = \frac{0.34}{5.91} = 0.0575$$
$$W_\gamma(727 + \Delta T) = \frac{6.67 - 1.10}{5.91} = \frac{5.57}{5.91} = 0.9425$$

Microconstituents at 727 − ΔT and their masses

The proeutectoid cementite does not take part in the reaction, and all the austenite of 0.76 wt% C becomes pearlite, so $W_P = 0.9425$ (Session 9, Slide 20). With $m_i = W_i\,m$ and $m = 2.5$ kg:

$$m_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},p} = 0.05753 \times 2.5\ \text{kg} = 0.1438\ \text{kg}, \qquad m_P = 0.9425 \times 2.5\ \text{kg} = 2.356\ \text{kg}$$

Checks: $0.1438 + 2.356 = 2.500$ kg. Between 780 °C (2.9 % cementite) and 727 °C (5.75 %) the proeutectoid cementite has kept growing, as expected while the austenite moves down Acm.

Key results
  • Reaction on cooling at 727 °C: γ (0.76) → α (0.022) + Fe₃C (6.67), eutectoid, product pearlite
  • $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},p} = 0.0575$ → 0.1438 kg; $W_P = 0.9425$ → 2.356 kg

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Ferrite and cementite phases in the forging at 727 − ΔT

Lever rule on the tie line α - Fe₃C

Below 727 °C the steel lies in the α + Fe₃C field (Session 9, Slide 9); the tie line runs from $C_\alpha = 0.022$ to 6.67 wt% C, length $6.67 - 0.022 = 6.648$:

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} = \frac{1.10 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{1.078}{6.648} = 0.1622, \qquad W_\alpha = \frac{6.67 - 1.10}{6.648} = \frac{5.57}{6.648} = 0.8378$$

Masses

$$m_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.16215 \times 2.5\ \text{kg} = 0.4054\ \text{kg}, \qquad m_\alpha = 0.83785 \times 2.5\ \text{kg} = 2.095\ \text{kg}$$

Check: $0.4054 + 2.095 = 2.500$ kg. Even this hard tool steel is about 84 % ferrite by mass.

Key results
  • $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.1622$ → 0.4054 kg of cementite
  • $W_\alpha = 0.8378$ → 2.095 kg of ferrite

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Cementite inside the pearlite, and where the proeutectoid cementite sits

First way: subtract the proeutectoid cementite from the total

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},E} = W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},p} = \frac{1.078}{6.648} - \frac{0.34}{5.91} = 0.16215 - 0.05753 = 0.1046$$
$$m_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},E} = 0.10462 \times 2.5\ \text{kg} = 0.2616\ \text{kg}$$

Second way: the make-up of pearlite

Every pearlite has the composition of the eutectoid, 0.76 wt% C, so its cementite fraction is the lever rule of the eutectoid steel (Session 9, Slide 13):

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}^{(P)} = \frac{0.76 - 0.022}{6.67 - 0.022} = \frac{0.738}{6.648} = 0.1110$$

The pearlite of the forging is 2.356 kg (part b), so its cementite is $0.1110 \times 2.356 = 0.2616$ kg, the same value.

Where the proeutectoid cementite sits

The proeutectoid cementite forms between b and 727 °C at the boundaries of the austenite grains, so after cooling it is a thin, continuous network around the pearlite colonies (Session 9, Slide 19). Cementite is hard and brittle (Session 9, Slide 8), and a continuous brittle film along the grain boundaries gives a crack an easy path: the 0.1438 kg network makes the forging hard but lowers its toughness.

Key results
  • Eutectoid cementite: $W = 0.1046$ → 0.2616 kg (both ways)
  • Proeutectoid cementite: a continuous network along the former austenite grain boundaries; hard and brittle, it lowers the toughness

Interpretation and checks

Of the 0.4054 kg of cementite in the forging, about one third (0.1438 kg) formed above 727 °C as a grain-boundary network and two thirds (0.2616 kg) formed at 727 °C inside the pearlite lamellae. The transformation starts about 103 °C above the eutectoid line because 1.10 wt% C exceeds what austenite can hold below 830 °C.

Limiting cases: $C_0 \to 0.76$ makes point b fall to 727 °C and $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},p} \to 0$ (all pearlite); $C_0 \to 2.14$ moves b to 1147 °C and gives the largest proeutectoid cementite of a steel, $(2.14 - 0.76)/5.91 = 0.234$.

Dimensional check: a temperature on Acm is °C + (wt%)·(°C/wt%) = °C; every lever rule is (wt%)/(wt%), dimensionless; a mass is a fraction times kg.

Common exam mistake: using the long tie line (0.022 to 6.67) for the proeutectoid cementite. That gives the total cementite, 0.1622; the proeutectoid part needs the short tie line from 0.76 wt% C.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Fe-Fe3C diagram and steel microstructures · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P11 — Carbon content of an unknown steel worked back from its micrograph

A bar of plain carbon steel of unknown composition (less than 2.14 wt% C) has been cooled slowly from the austenite field. A polished and etched section shows the structure of the figure. Point counting gives 88.0 % of lamellar colonies; the remaining 12.0 % is a constituent X that forms a thin, continuous network along the former austenite grain boundaries, around the colonies. Microhardness indentations show that X is much harder than the lamellar colonies. Take the area fractions as mass fractions; they are the fractions formed just below 727 °C, which the slow cooling to room temperature keeps.

X: continuous network at the grain boundaries Lamellar colonies 88.0 % of the area Slowly cooled, room temperature
Figure 1. Bank P11: schematic micrograph of the unknown steel after slow cooling (polished and etched). Lamellar colonies are surrounded by a thin, continuous network X along the former austenite grain boundaries.

(a) Identify the lamellar constituent. Show that a fraction of 88.0 % of it is compatible with two different carbon contents, one on each side of the eutectoid, and calculate both.

(b) Use the description of X to decide which of the two carbon contents is the right one, and justify it. For that steel, estimate the lowest temperature at which it is fully austenitic.

(c) Calculate the mass fractions of the ferrite and cementite phases of the steel just below 727 °C, and how the cementite is shared between X and the colonies.

(d) Give the phases present at 800 °C, their compositions and their mass fractions.

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueSource
Fraction of lamellar colonies$W_P$88.0 % = 0.880statement (point counting)
Fraction of constituent X$W_X$12.0 % = 0.120statement
Carbon in ferrite at 727 °C$C_\alpha$0.022 wt% CSession 9, Slides 5 and 10
Eutectoid composition$C_E$0.76 wt% CSession 9, Slide 10
Carbon in cementite$C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$6.67 wt% CSession 9, Slides 4 and 8
Austenite at the eutectic temperature$C_{\gamma,\max}$2.14 wt% C at 1147 °CSession 9, Slides 6 and 10
Eutectoid temperature$T_E$727 °CSession 9, Slide 10

Percentages are turned into fractions by dividing by 100 (88.0 % → 0.880). Compositions stay in wt% because the lever rule only uses their ratios.

Model

  • Lever rule from the mass balances $W_1 + W_2 = 1$ and $W_1 C_1 + W_2 C_2 = C_0$ (Session 7, Slides 15-21), here solved for $C_0$.
  • Hypoeutectoid steels: proeutectoid ferrite + pearlite, short tie line $C_\alpha$ to $C_E$ (Session 9, Slides 14 and 18). Hypereutectoid steels: proeutectoid cementite + pearlite, short tie line $C_E$ to $C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$ (Session 9, Slides 19-20).
  • Acm line approximated by the straight segment through $(0.76, 727)$ and $(2.14, 1147)$, as it is drawn in the bank figures of the Fe-Fe₃C diagram.
  • Hypothesis: equilibrium cooling, area fraction = mass fraction (stated).

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Lamellar constituent and the two candidate carbon contents

The lamellar constituent

Alternating lamellae of ferrite and cementite are pearlite, the product of the eutectoid reaction γ (0.76) → α (0.022) + Fe₃C (6.67) at 727 °C (Session 9, Slides 10 and 12). Pearlite always has the eutectoid composition, 0.76 wt% C, but it appears in both hypo- and hypereutectoid steels, so 88.0 % of pearlite alone does not tell on which side of 0.76 the steel lies.

Lever rule for the pearlite, derived once

Just above 727 °C the pearlite is still austenite of $C_E = 0.76$ wt% C, in equilibrium with a proeutectoid phase of composition $C_p$ ($C_\alpha$ or $C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$). Mass balance: $W_P + W_p = 1$. Carbon balance: $W_P C_E + W_p C_p = C_0$. Substitute $W_p = 1 - W_P$:

$$W_P C_E + (1 - W_P) C_p = C_0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad W_P (C_E - C_p) = C_0 - C_p \quad\Rightarrow\quad W_P = \frac{C_0 - C_p}{C_E - C_p}$$

Hypoeutectoid candidate ($C_p = C_\alpha$)

$$W_P = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_E - C_\alpha}$$

Multiply both sides by $(C_E - C_\alpha)$ and add $C_\alpha$:

$$C_0 = C_\alpha + W_P (C_E - C_\alpha) = 0.022 + 0.880 \times (0.76 - 0.022) = 0.022 + 0.880 \times 0.738 = 0.022 + 0.6494 = 0.671\ \text{wt\% C}$$

Hypereutectoid candidate ($C_p = C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$)

$$W_P = \frac{C_0 - C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}}{C_E - C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}} = \frac{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_0}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_E}$$

Multiply by $(C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_E)$ and isolate $C_0$:

$$C_0 = C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - W_P (C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_E) = 6.67 - 0.880 \times 5.91 = 6.67 - 5.2008 = 1.469\ \text{wt\% C}$$

Result: both 0.671 wt% C (hypoeutectoid, $0.671 < 0.76$) and 1.469 wt% C (hypereutectoid, $0.76 < 1.469 < 2.14$) are steels with 88.0 % pearlite. Check: both lie inside their ranges, so both are physically possible.

Key results
  • Lamellar colonies: pearlite (α + Fe₃C lamellae, 0.76 wt% C overall)
  • Hypoeutectoid candidate: $C_0 = 0.671$ wt% C
  • Hypereutectoid candidate: $C_0 = 1.469$ wt% C

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Choice of the right carbon content and full austenitisation

What X is

In a hypoeutectoid steel the proeutectoid constituent is ferrite, which forms equiaxed grains of its own between the pearlite colonies (Session 9, Slide 14). In a hypereutectoid steel it is cementite, which forms a thin network along the boundaries of the former austenite grains around the pearlite (Session 9, Slide 19). The grain-boundary position alone does not decide, because proeutectoid ferrite also nucleates on the austenite grain boundaries (Session 9, Slide 15; Topic 4, section 14.2), and a large amount of it can outline them too. The hardness does decide: ferrite is a soft phase (Session 9, Slide 5) and would be softer than the pearlite, which contains 11 % of cementite, whereas cementite is hard and brittle (Session 9, Slide 8) and is harder than the pearlite. X is much harder than the colonies, so X is proeutectoid cementite, and its thin continuous network is the shape Slide 19 shows for it. The steel is hypereutectoid and

$$C_0 = 1.469\ \text{wt\% C}$$

The other candidate, 0.671 wt% C, would show 12.0 % of ferrite grains, not a grain-boundary network, and is rejected.

Lowest temperature of the single-phase austenite field

A hypereutectoid steel is fully austenitic above the Acm line (Session 9, Slides 4 and 11). On the straight Acm segment the temperature grows by $(1147 - 727)/(2.14 - 0.76) = 420/1.38 = 304.3$ °C per wt% C above the eutectoid point:

$$T_{Acm} = 727 + (1.469 - 0.76) \times 304.3 = 727 + 0.709 \times 304.3 = 727 + 215.8 = 942.8\ ^\circ\text{C}$$

Result: the bar must have been above about 943 °C to be entirely austenite. (Had the steel been the 0.671 wt% C candidate, it would have been fully austenitic above the A3 line, which at 0.671 wt% C lies only some 5 to 20 °C above 727 °C, depending on how its curve is read: the slides do not give A3 in numbers.)

Key results
  • X is much harder than the pearlite, so it is proeutectoid cementite (not ferrite): the steel is hypereutectoid, $C_0 = 1.469$ wt% C
  • Fully austenitic above about 943 °C (Acm line)

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Phases below 727 °C and where the cementite is

Phases: lever rule on the tie line from 0.022 to 6.67 wt% C

Length $6.67 - 0.022 = 6.648$ (Session 9, Slide 9 for the α + Fe₃C field):

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} = \frac{1.469 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{1.447}{6.648} = 0.2177, \qquad W_\alpha = 1 - 0.2177 = 0.7823$$

Cementite inside the pearlite

The pearlite is the eutectoid steel, whose cementite fraction is (Session 9, Slide 13)

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}^{(P)} = \frac{C_E - C_\alpha}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} = \frac{0.738}{6.648} = 0.1110$$

so the cementite of the colonies, per unit mass of steel, is $W_P \times 0.1110 = 0.880 \times 0.1110 = 0.0977$. The rest of the cementite is X, the proeutectoid cementite, $W_X = 0.120$.

Check: $0.120 + 0.0977 = 0.2177 = W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$, the value of the long tie line: the two independent routes agree. The ferrite is all inside the pearlite: $0.880 \times (1 - 0.1110) = 0.7823 = W_\alpha$.

Key results
  • $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.2177$, $W_\alpha = 0.7823$
  • Cementite in X (proeutectoid): 0.120; cementite in the pearlite: 0.0977

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Phases at 800 °C

Field and ends of the tie line

Since $727 < 800 < 942.8$ °C, the point (1.469 wt% C, 800 °C) lies in the γ + Fe₃C field (Session 9, Slide 9). The tie line ends on Acm and on the cementite line. Inverting the straight Acm, $C = 0.76 + (T - 727)\times 1.38/420$:

$$C_\gamma(800) = 0.76 + (800 - 727) \times \frac{1.38}{420} = 0.76 + 73 \times 0.003286 = 0.76 + 0.2399 = 1.000\ \text{wt\% C}$$

Lever rule

Tie line length $6.67 - 1.000 = 5.670$:

$$W_\gamma = \frac{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_0}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\gamma} = \frac{6.67 - 1.469}{5.670} = \frac{5.201}{5.670} = 0.9172, \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 1 - 0.9172 = 0.0828$$

Result: 91.7 % austenite with 1.000 wt% C and 8.3 % proeutectoid cementite with 6.67 wt% C. Check: the proeutectoid cementite grows from 8.3 % at 800 °C to 12.0 % at 727 + ΔT, as it must while the austenite slides down Acm towards 0.76 wt% C; carbon balance $0.9172 \times 1.000 + 0.0828 \times 6.67 = 0.917 + 0.552 = 1.469$ wt% C.

Key results
  • γ with 1.000 wt% C, $W_\gamma = 0.9172$
  • Fe₃C with 6.67 wt% C, $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.0828$

Interpretation and checks

A pearlite fraction measured on a micrograph fixes the distance of the steel from the eutectoid, not the side: the same 88.0 % lies 0.089 wt% C below 0.76 (on the short ferrite side of the diagram) and 0.709 wt% C above it (on the long cementite side). The shape of the proeutectoid constituent, grains of ferrite or a network of cementite, is the second datum that removes the ambiguity, exactly as Slides 14 and 19 of Session 9 show it.

Limiting cases: $W_P \to 1$ makes both candidates collapse to $C_E = 0.76$ wt% C (the eutectoid steel); $W_P \to 0$ gives $C_\alpha = 0.022$ on one side and 6.67 wt% C on the other, which is outside the steels: below 2.14 wt% C the pearlite of a hypereutectoid steel never falls below $(6.67 - 2.14)/5.91 = 0.7665$.

Dimensional check: $C_0 = C_\alpha + W_P (C_E - C_\alpha)$ is wt% + (dimensionless)(wt%) = wt%; $T_{Acm}$ is °C + (wt%)(°C/wt%) = °C.

Common exam mistake: stopping at the first root, 0.671 wt% C, without asking which proeutectoid phase the micrograph shows.

Part II problem · Unit 4 · Fe-Fe3C diagram and steel microstructures · 3 points · 30 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P12 — Three steels compared: microconstituents, hardness and alloying elements

A supplier offers three plain carbon steels, all slowly cooled from the austenite field:

SteelCarbon content (wt% C)
S10.25
S20.60
S31.35

(a) Classify each steel and calculate the mass fraction of each of its microconstituents just below 727 °C.

(b) Calculate the mass fractions of the ferrite and cementite phases of each steel just below 727 °C. Rank the three steels by hardness and justify the ranking.

(c) A designer wants a plain carbon hypoeutectoid steel with at least 50 % pearlite. What is the lowest carbon content that meets the requirement? Is there any hypereutectoid steel that does not meet it?

(d) Steel S2 is now alloyed in one version with chromium and in another with manganese. State how each element changes the eutectoid temperature and the eutectoid composition, and how the microconstituents of S2 change. What would S2 look like if the eutectoid composition fell below 0.60 wt% C?

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueSource
Carbon contents$C_0$0.25, 0.60, 1.35 wt% Cstatement
Carbon in ferrite at 727 °C$C_\alpha$0.022 wt% CSession 9, Slides 5 and 10
Eutectoid composition$C_E$0.76 wt% CSession 9, Slide 10
Carbon in cementite$C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$6.67 wt% CSession 9, Slides 4 and 8
Upper limit of steels$C_{\gamma,\max}$2.14 wt% CSession 9, Slide 4
Eutectoid temperature$T_E$727 °CSession 9, Slide 10

Compositions enter only as ratios in the lever rule, so the wt% values are used directly (the factor 1/100 cancels). Percentages of the answers are fractions times 100.

Model

  • Classification by carbon content: hypoeutectoid below 0.76, hypereutectoid from 0.76 to 2.14 wt% C (Session 9, Slide 4).
  • Lever rule from the mass balances $W_1 + W_2 = 1$ and $W_1 C_1 + W_2 C_2 = C_0$ (Session 7, Slides 15-21), derived in part (a).
  • Cementite is hard and brittle, ferrite is soft (Session 9, Slides 5 and 8).
  • Alloying elements (Session 9, Slides 22-23): α-stabilisers move the eutectoid to higher temperature and lower %C; γ-stabilisers move it to lower temperature and lower %C.

Part (a) · 0.75 points

Classification and microconstituents just below 727 °C

Classify the three steels

S1 (0.25) and S2 (0.60) are below 0.76 wt% C: hypoeutectoid, with proeutectoid ferrite and pearlite (Session 9, Slide 14). S3 (1.35) lies between 0.76 and 2.14 wt% C: hypereutectoid, with proeutectoid cementite and pearlite (Session 9, Slide 19).

Derive the lever rule once

At 727 + ΔT the steel is a proeutectoid phase of composition $C_p$ plus austenite of $C_E = 0.76$. Mass balance: $W_p + W_\gamma = 1$. Carbon balance: $W_p C_p + W_\gamma C_E = C_0$. Substitute $W_\gamma = 1 - W_p$ into the carbon balance:

$$W_p C_p + (1 - W_p) C_E = C_0$$

Expand, subtract $C_E$ and group the terms in $W_p$:

$$W_p (C_p - C_E) = C_0 - C_E \quad\Rightarrow\quad W_p = \frac{C_0 - C_E}{C_p - C_E} = \frac{C_E - C_0}{C_E - C_p}$$

All that austenite becomes pearlite at 727 °C, and the proeutectoid phase does not change, so just below 727 °C $W_P = 1 - W_p$ (Session 9, Slides 18 and 20).

S1 and S2: proeutectoid ferrite ($C_p = C_\alpha = 0.022$, tie line length $0.76 - 0.022 = 0.738$)

$$W_{\alpha_p}(S1) = \frac{0.76 - 0.25}{0.738} = \frac{0.51}{0.738} = 0.6911, \qquad W_P(S1) = 1 - 0.6911 = 0.3089$$
$$W_{\alpha_p}(S2) = \frac{0.76 - 0.60}{0.738} = \frac{0.16}{0.738} = 0.2168, \qquad W_P(S2) = 1 - 0.2168 = 0.7832$$

S3: proeutectoid cementite ($C_p = 6.67$, tie line length $6.67 - 0.76 = 5.91$)

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},p}(S3) = \frac{1.35 - 0.76}{5.91} = \frac{0.59}{5.91} = 0.0998, \qquad W_P(S3) = \frac{6.67 - 1.35}{5.91} = \frac{5.32}{5.91} = 0.9002$$
S1, 0.25 wt% C αp 69.1 % pearlite 30.9 % S2, 0.60 wt% C αp 21.7 % pearlite 78.3 % S3, 1.35 wt% C pearlite 90.0 % Fe₃Cp 10.0 % 0 % 25 % 50 % 75 % 100 %
Figure 1. Bank P12: mass fractions of the microconstituents just below 727 °C (lever rule with 0.022, 0.76 and 6.67 wt% C, Session 9 Slides 4 and 10).

Checks: each pair adds up to 1; the pearlite grows from S1 to S2 as $C_0$ approaches 0.76, and in S3 it falls again as $C_0$ moves away on the cementite side.

Key results
  • S1 (hypoeutectoid): $W_{\alpha_p} = 0.6911$, $W_P = 0.3089$
  • S2 (hypoeutectoid): $W_{\alpha_p} = 0.2168$, $W_P = 0.7832$
  • S3 (hypereutectoid): $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},p} = 0.0998$, $W_P = 0.9002$

Part (b) · 0.75 points

Phases and ranking by hardness

Lever rule on the tie line from 0.022 to 6.67 wt% C

Below 727 °C every steel lies in the α + Fe₃C field (Session 9, Slide 9). Tie line length $6.67 - 0.022 = 6.648$; with the lever rule of part (a) written for α and Fe₃C:

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha}, \qquad W_\alpha = 1 - W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$$
$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}(S1) = \frac{0.25 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{0.228}{6.648} = 0.0343, \qquad W_\alpha(S1) = 0.9657$$
$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}(S2) = \frac{0.60 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{0.578}{6.648} = 0.0869, \qquad W_\alpha(S2) = 0.9131$$
$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}(S3) = \frac{1.35 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{1.328}{6.648} = 0.1998, \qquad W_\alpha(S3) = 0.8002$$

Ranking by hardness

Ferrite is a soft phase and cementite is hard and brittle (Session 9, Slides 5 and 8), so at the same (slow) cooling the hardness grows with the fraction of cementite: S3 (20.0 % Fe₃C) > S2 (8.7 %) > S1 (3.4 %). The fraction of cementite grows linearly with $C_0$, which is why harder steels are those with more carbon. S3 pays for its hardness with a brittle network of proeutectoid cementite at the grain boundaries (Session 9, Slide 19).

Check: the cementite of S3 splits into 0.0998 proeutectoid and $0.9002 \times 0.1110 = 0.0999$ inside the pearlite (0.1110 is the cementite of any pearlite, Session 9, Slide 13); $0.09983 + 0.09993 = 0.1998$.

Key results
  • $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}$: S1 0.0343, S2 0.0869, S3 0.1998 (ferrite: 0.9657, 0.9131, 0.8002)
  • Hardness: S3 > S2 > S1, in the order of the cementite fraction

Part (c) · 0.75 points

Lowest carbon content for at least 50 % pearlite

Set up the inequality

For a hypoeutectoid steel the pearlite fraction is the lever rule of part (a):

$$W_P = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_E - C_\alpha} \geq 0.50$$

Multiply both sides by the positive length $(C_E - C_\alpha) = 0.738$ (the sense of the inequality is kept) and add $C_\alpha$:

$$C_0 \geq C_\alpha + 0.50\,(C_E - C_\alpha) = 0.022 + 0.50 \times 0.738 = 0.022 + 0.369 = 0.391\ \text{wt\% C}$$

Result: the hypoeutectoid steel needs at least 0.391 wt% C. S1 (0.25, 30.9 % pearlite) fails; S2 (0.60, 78.3 %) passes.

Hypereutectoid steels

For $C_0 > 0.76$, $W_P = (6.67 - C_0)/5.91$ decreases as $C_0$ grows, so its smallest value in the steel range is at $C_0 = 2.14$ wt% C (Session 9, Slide 4):

$$W_P(2.14) = \frac{6.67 - 2.14}{5.91} = \frac{4.53}{5.91} = 0.7665$$

That is above 0.50, so every hypereutectoid steel has more than 50 % pearlite.

Key results
  • Hypoeutectoid: $C_0 \geq 0.391$ wt% C (S1 fails, S2 meets it)
  • Every hypereutectoid steel meets it: the least pearlite, at 2.14 wt% C, is 0.7665

Part (d) · 0.75 points

Effect of chromium and manganese on S2

Direction of the shift for each element

Session 9, Slide 22: elements that favour α (Si, P, Al, Be, Sn, Sb, As, Ti, Nb, V, Ta, Mo, W, Cr) stabilise ferrite and displace the eutectoid to higher temperature and lower %C; elements that favour γ (Mn, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, Au) stabilise austenite and displace it to lower temperature and lower %C. Slide 23 gives the size of the shifts against the alloy content; the statement gives no content, so only the direction is asked.

Version of S2Eutectoid temperatureEutectoid composition
S2 + Cr (α-stabiliser)above 727 °Cbelow 0.76 wt% C
S2 + Mn (γ-stabiliser)below 727 °Cbelow 0.76 wt% C

Consequence for the microconstituents of S2

In both versions the eutectoid composition $C_E'$ is lower than 0.76, so the pearlite (which always has the eutectoid composition) carries less than 0.76 wt% C. The proeutectoid ferrite is $W_{\alpha_p} = (C_E' - C_0)/(C_E' - C_\alpha)$: a smaller $C_E'$ shrinks the numerator, so S2 has less proeutectoid ferrite and more pearlite than the plain 0.60 wt% C steel of part (a). Its total cementite fraction (the long tie line from ferrite to cementite) does not change when the eutectoid point moves; what changes is how the cementite is distributed: more of the soft proeutectoid ferrite is replaced by pearlite, which is harder than ferrite (it contains the hard cementite lamellae, Session 9, Slides 8 and 12).

If the eutectoid composition fell below 0.60 wt% C

Then $C_0 = 0.60 > C_E'$ and S2 would sit on the cementite side of the new eutectoid: on slow cooling it would form proeutectoid cementite at the austenite grain boundaries, followed by pearlite, like a hypereutectoid plain steel (Session 9, Slide 19).

Key results
  • Cr (favours α): eutectoid at higher temperature and lower %C
  • Mn (favours γ): eutectoid at lower temperature and lower %C
  • In both cases S2 is closer to the eutectoid: less proeutectoid ferrite, more pearlite, and the pearlite has less than 0.76 wt% C
  • If the eutectoid composition fell below 0.60 wt% C, S2 would behave as hypereutectoid: proeutectoid cementite + pearlite

Interpretation and checks

The three steels show the whole story of the Fe-Fe₃C steel corner: the pearlite fraction peaks at the eutectoid and falls on both sides, but the cementite fraction, which sets the hardness, grows steadily with the carbon content. S1 is a soft, mostly ferritic steel; S2 is mostly pearlite; S3 is the hardest and the least tough, because of its 10 % grain-boundary cementite network. Alloying moves the eutectoid point, so "hypo" and "hyper" are relative to the eutectoid of the actual alloy, not always to 0.76 wt% C.

Limiting cases: $C_0 \to 0.022$ gives $W_{\alpha_p} \to 1$ and $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} \to 0$; $C_0 \to 0.76$ gives $W_P \to 1$ from both sides; $C_0 \to 6.67$ would give $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} \to 1$ (outside the steels).

Dimensional check: every lever rule is (wt%)/(wt%), dimensionless; the bound of part (c) is wt% + (dimensionless)(wt%) = wt%.

Common exam mistake: saying that a γ-stabiliser such as Mn raises the eutectoid carbon content because it "stabilises austenite". Session 9, Slide 22 states that both kinds of element lower the eutectoid %C; they differ only in the direction of the temperature shift.

Problem 2 · Mechanical properties (2 points) 8 problems

Part II problem · Unit 5 · Tensile test and mechanical properties · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P13 — Titanium alloy tensile test from a load and gauge length table

A round specimen of a titanium alloy with a diameter of 10.0 mm and an initial gauge length of 50.000 mm is pulled in a uniaxial tension test. The machine records the load and the distance between the gauge marks:

RowLoad $F$ (N)Gauge length $l$ (mm)
0050.000
115 00050.089
230 00050.179
345 00050.268
460 00050.357
563 00050.420
666 00050.500
769 00050.900
872 00051.750
974 000 (maximum load)53.000
1071 000 (fracture)54.600

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueIn SI
Initial diameter$d_0$10.0 mm$10.0\times10^{-3}$ m
Initial gauge length$l_0$50.000 mm$5.0000\times10^{-2}$ m
Loads of the table$F$15 000 to 74 000 NN
Offset of the conventional yield strength$\varepsilon_{\text{off}}$0.002(dimensionless)

Initial cross-section, with the conversion to SI written out:

$$A_0 = \frac{\pi d_0^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\,(10.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m})^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\times1.000\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2}{4} = 7.854\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2 = 78.54\ \text{mm}^2$$

Since $1\ \text{N/mm}^2 = 10^6\ \text{N/m}^2 = 1\ \text{MPa}$, a load in N divided by an area in mm² gives the stress directly in MPa.

Model

  • Engineering stress and strain, defined with the original area and length [Session 11 Slide 9]: $\sigma = F/A_0$ and $\varepsilon = (l - l_0)/l_0$.
  • Hooke's law in the elastic zone, $\sigma = E\,\varepsilon$; the Young's modulus $E$ is the slope of the straight part of the curve [Session 11 Slide 12].
  • Conventional yield strength: the stress where the curve meets the line parallel to the elastic line drawn from $\varepsilon = 0.002$ [Session 11 Slide 28].
  • Tensile strength: the maximum engineering stress the specimen supports [Session 11 Slide 30].
  • Hypotheses: uniaxial stress, uniform over the gauge length up to the maximum load; between two rows of the table the curve is taken as a straight segment (linear interpolation).

Part (a) · 0.7 points

Compute the engineering stress and strain of the rows and the modulus of elasticity of the alloy

Engineering stress and strain of one row, written out

The idea is to remove the size of the specimen from the readings: the load per unit of original area and the elongation per unit of original length [Session 11 Slide 9]. For row 4:

$$\sigma_4 = \frac{F_4}{A_0} = \frac{60\,000\ \text{N}}{78.54\ \text{mm}^2} = 763.9\ \text{MPa}$$
$$\varepsilon_4 = \frac{l_4 - l_0}{l_0} = \frac{50.357\ \text{mm} - 50.000\ \text{mm}}{50.000\ \text{mm}} = \frac{0.357\ \text{mm}}{50.000\ \text{mm}} = 0.00714$$

The same operation for every row

The last column is the secant ratio $\sigma/\varepsilon$, which is constant only while Hooke's law holds:

Row$F$ (N)$l - l_0$ (mm)$\sigma$ (MPa)$\varepsilon$$\sigma/\varepsilon$ (GPa)
115 0000.089191.00.00178107.3
230 0000.179382.00.00358106.7
345 0000.268573.00.00536106.9
460 0000.357763.90.00714107.0
563 0000.420802.10.0084095.5
666 0000.500840.30.0100084.0
769 0000.900878.50.0180048.8
872 0001.750916.70.0350026.2
974 0003.000942.20.0600015.7
1071 0004.600904.00.092009.8

Pick the straight rows and average their slope

Rows 1 to 4 give the same ratio within the reading error of the last digit of $l$ (106.7 to 107.3 GPa); from row 5 on the ratio falls (95.5, 84.0 GPa), so the curve has left the straight line. The modulus is the slope of the straight part through the origin [Session 11 Slide 12], taken as the mean of the four secant ratios:

$$E = \frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{\sigma_1}{\varepsilon_1} + \frac{\sigma_2}{\varepsilon_2} + \frac{\sigma_3}{\varepsilon_3} + \frac{\sigma_4}{\varepsilon_4}\right) = \frac{107.3 + 106.7 + 106.9 + 107.0}{4}\ \text{GPa} = 106\,970\ \text{MPa} \approx 107.0\ \text{GPa}$$

(The sum is formed with the unrounded ratios.) Check: the slide's table gives $E = 107$ GPa for titanium [Session 11 Slide 17], so the readings are consistent with a titanium alloy.

0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10 200 400 600 800 1000 strain ε σ (MPa) max. load fracture 0.002 0.006 0.010 200 400 600 800 1000 strain ε σ (MPa) offset line from ε = 0.002 Y 835.9
Figure 1. Curve of the titanium alloy from the table: full test (left) and elastic zoom with the 0.2 % offset line (right).
Key results
  • $A_0 = 78.54\ \text{mm}^2$
  • Row 4: $\sigma = 763.9$ MPa, $\varepsilon = 0.00714$
  • $E = 107.0$ GPa (rows 1 to 4 are the straight part)

Part (b) · 0.8 points

Determine the yield strength with the 0.2 % offset method

Equation of the offset line

The conventional yield strength is read where the curve meets the line parallel to the elastic one, shifted to a plastic strain of 0.002 [Session 11 Slide 28]. Parallel means the same slope $E$; passing through $(0.002, 0)$ gives

$$\sigma_{\text{off}}(\varepsilon) = E\,(\varepsilon - 0.002)$$

Locate the crossing between two rows

The curve is above the offset line while $g = \sigma - E(\varepsilon - 0.002)$ is positive:

Row$\varepsilon$$\sigma$ (MPa)$E(\varepsilon - 0.002)$ (MPa)$g$ (MPa)
40.00714763.9549.8214.1
50.00840802.1684.6117.5
60.01000840.3855.8-15.4

$g$ changes sign between rows 5 and 6, so the yield point lies on the segment that joins them.

Equation of the segment between rows 5 and 6

Its slope is the rise over the run of the two rows:

$$m = \frac{\sigma_6 - \sigma_5}{\varepsilon_6 - \varepsilon_5} = \frac{840.34 - 802.14}{0.01000 - 0.00840}\ \text{MPa} = \frac{38.20}{0.00160}\ \text{MPa} = 23\,873\ \text{MPa}$$

and the segment is $\sigma(\varepsilon) = \sigma_5 + m\,(\varepsilon - \varepsilon_5)$.

Intersect the two lines

At the crossing $\varepsilon = \varepsilon^*$ both lines give the same stress:

$$\sigma_5 + m\,(\varepsilon^* - \varepsilon_5) = E\,(\varepsilon^* - 0.002)$$

Expanding both sides and moving the terms in $\varepsilon^*$ to the right:

$$\sigma_5 - m\,\varepsilon_5 + 0.002\,E = (E - m)\,\varepsilon^*$$

Dividing by $(E - m)$:

$$\varepsilon^* = \frac{\sigma_5 - m\,\varepsilon_5 + 0.002\,E}{E - m} = \frac{802.14 - 200.54 + 213.94}{106\,970 - 23\,873} = \frac{815.55}{83\,097} = 0.009814$$

Yield strength

Substituting $\varepsilon^*$ in the offset line:

$$\sigma_y = E\,(\varepsilon^* - 0.002) = 106\,970\ \text{MPa}\times(0.009814 - 0.002) = 106\,970\ \text{MPa}\times0.007814 = 835.9\ \text{MPa}$$

Check on the other line: $\sigma_5 + m(\varepsilon^* - \varepsilon_5) = 802.14 + 23\,873\times0.001414 = 835.9$ MPa, the same value, and it lies between $\sigma_5 = 802.1$ and $\sigma_6 = 840.3$ MPa, as it must.

Key results
  • The crossing lies between rows 5 and 6
  • Slope of that segment $m = 23\,873$ MPa
  • $\varepsilon^* = 0.009814$, $\sigma_y = 835.9$ MPa

Part (c) · 0.5 points

Give the tensile strength and compare it with the yield strength

Maximum engineering stress

The tensile strength is the maximum nominal stress the specimen supports [Session 11 Slide 30]. With $A_0$ fixed, the maximum of $F/A_0$ is at the maximum load, row 9:

$$\sigma_{TS} = \frac{F_{\max}}{A_0} = \frac{74\,000\ \text{N}}{78.54\ \text{mm}^2} = 942.2\ \text{MPa}$$

Comparison with the yield strength

$$\frac{\sigma_{TS}}{\sigma_y} = \frac{942.2\ \text{MPa}}{835.9\ \text{MPa}} = 1.127$$

The alloy hardens only about 13 % between yielding and the maximum load: a high-strength alloy with little strain hardening. After row 9 the load falls (row 10, 71 000 N) because the specimen necks [Session 11 Slide 30], so row 10 is not the tensile strength even though the specimen is longer.

Key results
  • $\sigma_{TS} = 942.2$ MPa (row 9)
  • $\sigma_{TS}/\sigma_y = 1.127$

Interpretation and checks

  • Order of magnitude. $E = 107.0$ GPa matches the titanium value of the slide's table (107 GPa) [Session 11 Slide 17]; $\sigma_y$ of about 840 MPa and $\sigma_{TS}$ of about 940 MPa are those of a high-strength titanium alloy, far above an aluminium alloy.
  • Control checks. The yield point lies after the last straight row (row 4) and before the maximum (row 9): $\varepsilon_4 = 0.00714 < \varepsilon^* = 0.009814 < \varepsilon_9 = 0.060$; and $\sigma_y < \sigma_{TS}$. If the offset were zero, the line would be the elastic line itself and the crossing would move back to the end of the straight part (about row 4): the offset is what makes the reading reproducible.
  • Dimensions. $\sigma = F/A_0$ is N/m² = Pa; $\varepsilon$ is m/m, dimensionless; $E = \sigma/\varepsilon$ and $m$ are in Pa; in $\varepsilon^* = (\sigma_5 - m\varepsilon_5 + 0.002E)/(E - m)$ the numerator and denominator are both in Pa, so $\varepsilon^*$ is dimensionless, as a strain must be.
  • Common exam mistake. Taking the yield strength as the stress of the last straight row (763.9 MPa) or as the stress at a total strain of 0.002 (on the elastic line, 214 MPa): the 0.2 % is a plastic strain, measured from the offset line, not from the origin.
Part II problem · Unit 5 · Tensile test and mechanical properties · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P14 — Ductility and true fracture stress of an aluminium alloy from the broken specimen

A round specimen of an aluminium alloy, 8.00 mm in diameter, with gauge marks 40.00 mm apart, is pulled to fracture. The highest load recorded during the test is 21.5 kN, and the load at the instant of fracture is 17.8 kN. After the test the two halves are fitted together: the gauge marks are then 45.60 mm apart, and the diameter of the neck at the fracture surface is 6.10 mm.

l0 = 40.00 mm d0 = 8.00 mm before the test lf = 45.60 mm neck: df = 6.10 mm after fracture
Figure 1. Specimen before the test (top) and the broken halves fitted together (bottom).

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueIn SI
Initial diameter$d_0$8.00 mm$8.00\times10^{-3}$ m
Initial gauge length$l_0$40.00 mm$4.000\times10^{-2}$ m
Maximum load$F_{\max}$21.5 kN$2.15\times10^{4}$ N
Load at fracture$F_f$17.8 kN$1.78\times10^{4}$ N
Gauge length after fracture$l_f$45.60 mm$4.560\times10^{-2}$ m
Neck diameter after fracture$d_f$6.10 mm$6.10\times10^{-3}$ m

Areas, with the conversions written out ($1\ \text{mm}^2 = 10^{-6}\ \text{m}^2$):

$$A_0 = \frac{\pi d_0^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\,(8.00\ \text{mm})^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\times64.00\ \text{mm}^2}{4} = 50.27\ \text{mm}^2 = 5.027\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2$$
$$A_f = \frac{\pi d_f^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\,(6.10\ \text{mm})^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\times37.21\ \text{mm}^2}{4} = 29.22\ \text{mm}^2 = 2.922\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2$$

A load in N over an area in mm² gives MPa, because $1\ \text{N/mm}^2 = 10^{6}\ \text{N/m}^2$.

Model

  • Engineering stress $\sigma = F/A_0$ [Session 11 Slide 9]; tensile strength = maximum engineering stress [Session 11 Slide 30]; fracture stress = stress at fracture [Session 11 Slide 31].
  • Percent elongation after failure $EL\,(\%) = \dfrac{l_f - l_0}{l_0}\times100$ [Session 11 Slide 32]; percent reduction in area $RA\,(\%) = \dfrac{A_0 - A_f}{A_0}\times100$ [Session 11 Slide 33].
  • True stress $\sigma_T = F/A_i$ with the instantaneous area; true strain $\varepsilon_T = \int dl/l$; after necking $\varepsilon_T = \ln(A_0/A) = 2\ln(D_0/D)$ [Session 11 Slides 37-38].
  • Hypotheses: uniaxial load; the measurements after fracture are made with the load removed, so the elastic strain has been recovered [Session 11 Slide 32].

Part (a) · 1 point

Calculate the tensile strength, the engineering fracture stress, the percent elongation and the percent reduction in area

Tensile strength and engineering fracture stress

The tensile strength is the largest engineering stress [Session 11 Slide 30]; with $A_0$ fixed it corresponds to the largest load:

$$\sigma_{TS} = \frac{F_{\max}}{A_0} = \frac{21\,500\ \text{N}}{50.27\ \text{mm}^2} = 427.7\ \text{MPa}$$

The engineering fracture stress is the load at fracture over the same original area [Session 11 Slide 31]:

$$\sigma_f = \frac{F_f}{A_0} = \frac{17\,800\ \text{N}}{50.27\ \text{mm}^2} = 354.1\ \text{MPa}$$

$\sigma_f < \sigma_{TS}$: after the maximum the load falls because the specimen necks.

Percent elongation

The marks are measured on the broken, unloaded specimen, so the elastic strain has been recovered and $l_f - l_0$ is the plastic elongation [Session 11 Slide 32]:

$$EL\,(\%) = \frac{l_f - l_0}{l_0}\times100 = \frac{45.60\ \text{mm} - 40.00\ \text{mm}}{40.00\ \text{mm}}\times100 = \frac{5.60}{40.00}\times100 = 14.0\ \%$$

Percent reduction in area

The final area is the area of the fracture surface in the neck [Session 11 Slide 33]:

$$RA\,(\%) = \frac{A_0 - A_f}{A_0}\times100 = \frac{50.265 - 29.225}{50.265}\times100 = \frac{21.040}{50.265}\times100 = 41.9\ \%$$

The circle areas share the factor $\pi/4$, so the same number comes from the diameters alone: $RA = \left(1 - d_f^2/d_0^2\right)\times100 = (1 - 37.21/64.00)\times100 = 41.9$ %. As the slide warns, $EL\,(\%) \neq RA\,(\%)$ [Session 11 Slide 33].

Key results
  • $\sigma_{TS} = 427.7$ MPa, $\sigma_f = 354.1$ MPa
  • $EL = 14.0$ %
  • $RA = 41.9$ %

Part (b) · 1 point

Calculate the true stress and the true strain at fracture, and explain why $\sigma_T = \sigma(1+\varepsilon)$ cannot be used here

True stress at fracture with the measured area

The true stress is the load over the area that actually carries it at that instant [Session 11 Slide 37]. At fracture that area is the neck, $A_f$:

$$\sigma_{T,f} = \frac{F_f}{A_f} = \frac{17\,800\ \text{N}}{29.22\ \text{mm}^2} = 609.1\ \text{MPa}$$

Equivalently $\sigma_{T,f} = \sigma_f\,A_0/A_f = 354.1\ \text{MPa}\times1.720 = 609.1$ MPa [Session 11 Slide 38].

True strain at fracture: derivation from constant volume in the neck

The true strain adds each small elongation $dl$ divided by the current length $l$ [Session 11 Slide 37]. An antiderivative of $1/l$ is $\ln l$, and Barrow's rule with the limits substituted gives

$$\varepsilon_T = \int_{l_0}^{l}\frac{dl}{l} = \left[\ln l\right]_{l_0}^{l} = \ln l - \ln l_0 = \ln\frac{l}{l_0}$$

After necking the length between the marks no longer describes the strain of the neck, so the integral is applied to a thin slice of the neck itself. Plastic deformation keeps the volume of that slice constant: its initial length $l_0$ and area $A_0$ become $l$ and $A$ with $A_0 l_0 = A l$. Dividing both sides by $A\,l_0$:

$$\frac{l}{l_0} = \frac{A_0}{A} \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad \varepsilon_T = \ln\frac{A_0}{A}$$

which is the expression of the slide for the necked region [Session 11 Slide 38]. At the fracture surface $A = A_f$. With $A = \pi D^2/4$ the factor $\pi/4$ cancels in the ratio, and the logarithm of a square is twice the logarithm:

$$\varepsilon_{T,f} = \ln\frac{A_0}{A_f} = \ln\frac{d_0^2}{d_f^2} = 2\ln\frac{d_0}{d_f} = 2\ln\frac{8.00}{6.10} = 2\times0.2712 = 0.542$$

Why the uniform-deformation formulas fail here

The formulas $\sigma_T = \sigma(1+\varepsilon)$ and $\varepsilon_T = \ln(1+\varepsilon)$ of Slide 38 come from constant volume, $A_0 l_0 = A l$, applied to a gauge length that deforms uniformly, so that one strain $\varepsilon$ describes every cross-section: from $A_0 l_0 = A l$, $A = A_0 l_0/l = A_0/(1+\varepsilon)$ and $\sigma_T = F/A = (F/A_0)(1+\varepsilon) = \sigma(1+\varepsilon)$. After the maximum load the strain concentrates in the neck: the average strain of the gauge length (0.14) is much smaller than the local strain at the fracture surface. Using them anyway gives

$$\sigma_f\,(1 + 0.140) = 354.1\ \text{MPa}\times1.140 = 403.7\ \text{MPa} \qquad \ln(1 + 0.140) = 0.131$$

against 609.1 MPa and 0.542 from the measured neck: the area ratio of the neck is $A_0/A_f = 1.720$, not $1 + \varepsilon = 1.140$. That is why the slide switches to $F_i/A_i$ and $\ln(A_0/A)$ after necking [Session 11 Slide 38].

Key results
  • $\sigma_{T,f} = 609.1$ MPa
  • $\varepsilon_{T,f} = 0.542$
  • $\sigma_f(1 + EL/100) = 403.7$ MPa underestimates it by about a third

Interpretation and checks

  • Physical meaning. The engineering curve falls after the maximum (427.7 to 354.1 MPa) only because it divides by the original area; the metal in the neck is still hardening, and at fracture it carries 609.1 MPa. The slide states $\sigma_{\text{real}} > \sigma_{\text{eng}}$ and $\varepsilon_{\text{real}} < \varepsilon_{\text{eng}}$ [Session 11 Slide 37]. The stress inequality holds here (609.1 > 354.1 MPa). The strain inequality is written for the uniform deformation of the gauge length, where $\ln(1+\varepsilon) < \varepsilon$ (0.131 < 0.140); the 0.542 found above is not a counterexample, because it is the local strain of the neck, while 0.14 is the average over the whole gauge length.
  • Control checks. $\sigma_f < \sigma_{TS} < \sigma_{T,f}$; $0 < RA < 100$ %; if the specimen had broken without necking ($d_f \to d_0$), $RA \to 0$ and $\sigma_{T,f} \to \sigma_f$, the behaviour of a brittle material.
  • Dimensions. $F/A$ is N/m² = Pa; %EL and %RA are ratios of lengths and of areas, and $\ln(A_0/A_f)$ is the logarithm of a pure number, so both strains are dimensionless.
  • Common exam mistake. Dividing the fracture load by the original area and calling it the true fracture stress, or computing %RA with the diameters instead of their squares ($1 - 6.10/8.00 = 23.8$ %, wrong).
Part II problem · Unit 5 · Tensile test and mechanical properties · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P15 — Resilience and true stress of a steel read from its stress-strain curve

The figure shows the engineering stress-strain curve of a steel, drawn to fracture (left), and the start of the same test enlarged (right). The marked points are: A on the straight part, Y where the dashed line parallel to the straight part from $\varepsilon = 0.002$ meets the curve, B on the rising part, U at the maximum and F at fracture.

0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 100 200 300 400 500 600 strain ε σ (MPa) U B F 560 0.08 0.001 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008 100 200 300 400 500 strain ε σ (MPa) parallel line from ε = 0.002 A 310 0.0015 Y 450
Figure 1. Engineering stress-strain curve of the steel (left) and enlarged start of the test (right).

Data and model

Data

Values read from the figure: A, B and Y have dashed projections that end on a printed axis value; U lies on the 0.15 and 600 gridlines; F is at (0.25, 500) and is not needed.

PointWhat it isStrain $\varepsilon$Stress $\sigma$ (MPa)In SI
Apoint of the straight part (right panel)0.0015310$3.10\times10^{8}$ Pa
Ycrossing with the 0.2 % offset line (right panel)read below450$4.50\times10^{8}$ Pa
Brising part, before the maximum (left panel)0.08560$5.60\times10^{8}$ Pa
Umaximum of the curve (left panel)0.15600$6.00\times10^{8}$ Pa

Model

  • Hooke's law $\sigma = E\varepsilon$ on the straight part; $E$ is its slope [Session 11 Slide 12].
  • Conventional yield strength at the crossing with the line parallel to the elastic one from $\varepsilon = 0.002$ [Session 11 Slide 28].
  • Modulus of resilience: energy per unit volume up to yielding, $U_r = \int_0^{\varepsilon_y}\sigma\,d\varepsilon$ [Session 11 Slide 35].
  • True stress $\sigma_T = F/A_i$ and true strain $\varepsilon_T = \int_{l_0}^{l} dl/l$ [Session 11 Slide 37]; before necking the volume is constant, $A_0 l_0 = A_i l_i$ [Session 11 Slide 38].
  • Hypothesis for $U_r$: as on Slide 35, the elastic region is taken as linear up to $\sigma_y$ (the small rounding of the curve between about 380 and 450 MPa is neglected).

Part (a) · 1 point

Read the modulus of elasticity and the yield strength, and derive and calculate the modulus of resilience

Modulus of elasticity from point A

The straight part passes through the origin and through A, and Hooke's law says its slope is $E$ [Session 11 Slide 12]:

$$E = \frac{\sigma_A - 0}{\varepsilon_A - 0} = \frac{310\ \text{MPa}}{0.0015} = 206\,667\ \text{MPa} = 206.7\ \text{GPa}$$

This agrees with the steel value of the slide's table, 207 GPa [Session 11 Slide 17].

Yield strength from point Y

The yield strength is the stress at the crossing of the curve with the offset line [Session 11 Slide 28]; the horizontal projection of Y ends at 450 on the stress axis:

$$\sigma_y = 450\ \text{MPa}$$

Check of the reading: on the offset line $\sigma = E(\varepsilon - 0.002)$, so the strain of Y must be $\varepsilon_Y = 0.002 + \sigma_y/E = 0.002 + 450/206\,667 = 0.004177$, which is where Y sits in the right panel (just to the right of the 0.004 gridline).

Elastic strain at the yield strength

Treating the elastic region as linear up to $\sigma_y$ (Slide 35) and isolating the strain from Hooke's law $\sigma_y = E\,\varepsilon_y$:

$$\varepsilon_y = \frac{\sigma_y}{E} = \frac{450\ \text{MPa}}{206\,667\ \text{MPa}} = 0.002177$$

Modulus of resilience as the area under the elastic line

The resilience is the energy absorbed per unit volume while the material deforms elastically, the area under the curve up to the yield point [Session 11 Slide 35]. In the elastic region $\sigma = E\varepsilon$, so

$$U_r = \int_0^{\varepsilon_y}\sigma\,d\varepsilon = \int_0^{\varepsilon_y}E\,\varepsilon\,d\varepsilon$$

$E$ is a constant and leaves the integral; an antiderivative of $\varepsilon$ is $\varepsilon^2/2$ (its derivative is $2\varepsilon/2 = \varepsilon$). Barrow's rule with the limits substituted:

$$U_r = E\left[\frac{\varepsilon^2}{2}\right]_0^{\varepsilon_y} = E\left(\frac{\varepsilon_y^2}{2} - \frac{0^2}{2}\right) = \frac{E\,\varepsilon_y^2}{2}$$

Replacing $\varepsilon_y = \sigma_y/E$: $U_r = \dfrac{E}{2}\,\dfrac{\sigma_y^2}{E^2} = \dfrac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}$, the formula of the slide, which is also the area of the triangle $\tfrac12\sigma_y\varepsilon_y$.

Numerical value

$$U_r = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E} = \frac{(450\ \text{MPa})^2}{2\times206\,667\ \text{MPa}} = \frac{202\,500}{413\,333}\ \text{MPa} = 0.490\ \text{MPa}$$

Since $1\ \text{MPa} = 10^6\ \text{N/m}^2 = 10^6\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m/m}^3 = 1\ \text{MJ/m}^3$, each cubic metre of this steel stores 0.490 MJ of recoverable elastic energy before it yields. Check with the triangle: $\tfrac12\times450\ \text{MPa}\times0.002177 = 0.490$ MPa.

Key results
  • $E = 206.7$ GPa
  • $\sigma_y = 450$ MPa, $\varepsilon_y = \sigma_y/E = 0.002177$
  • $U_r = 0.490$ MPa $= 0.490$ MJ/m³

Part (b) · 1 point

Calculate the true stress and the true strain at point B, deriving the formulas you use, and say why they cannot be used after point U

True strain as a sum of small increments

The true strain adds each small elongation $dl$ divided by the length $l$ the specimen has at that moment [Session 11 Slide 37]:

$$\varepsilon_T = \int_{l_0}^{l}\frac{dl}{l}$$

An antiderivative of $1/l$ is $\ln l$. Barrow's rule with the limits substituted:

$$\varepsilon_T = \left[\ln l\right]_{l_0}^{l} = \ln l - \ln l_0 = \ln\frac{l}{l_0}$$

Since $\varepsilon = (l - l_0)/l_0$, the ratio is $l/l_0 = (l_0 + l - l_0)/l_0 = 1 + \varepsilon$, and

$$\varepsilon_T = \ln(1 + \varepsilon)$$

True stress from constant volume

Plastic deformation does not change the volume, and before necking the specimen deforms uniformly, so the volume of the gauge length is the same at every instant [Session 11 Slide 38]:

$$A_0\,l_0 = A_i\,l_i$$

Isolating the instantaneous area: $A_i = A_0\,l_0/l_i$. The true stress is the load over that area [Session 11 Slide 37]:

$$\sigma_T = \frac{F}{A_i} = \frac{F}{A_0\,l_0/l_i} = \frac{F}{A_0}\cdot\frac{l_i}{l_0} = \sigma\,(1 + \varepsilon)$$

using again $l_i/l_0 = 1 + \varepsilon$.

Values at point B

Point B is read at $\varepsilon_B = 0.08$, $\sigma_B = 560$ MPa:

$$\varepsilon_{T,B} = \ln(1 + 0.08) = \ln 1.08 = 0.0770$$
$$\sigma_{T,B} = \sigma_B\,(1 + \varepsilon_B) = 560\ \text{MPa}\times1.08 = 604.8\ \text{MPa}$$

As Slide 37 predicts, $\sigma_T > \sigma$ (604.8 > 560 MPa) and $\varepsilon_T < \varepsilon$ (0.0770 < 0.08). The cross-section at B has shrunk by the factor $A_i/A_0 = 1/1.08 = 0.926$.

Why not after point U

Point U is the maximum of the curve, the tensile strength (600 MPa), and necking follows it [Session 11 Slide 30]. From U on the deformation concentrates in the neck: the gauge length no longer has one area, $A_0 l_0 = A_i l_i$ with a single $A_i$ fails, and $\sigma(1+\varepsilon)$ and $\ln(1+\varepsilon)$ no longer describe the neck. After necking the slide uses the measured area, $\sigma_T = F_i/A_i$ and $\varepsilon_T = \ln(A_0/A) = 2\ln(D_0/D)$ [Session 11 Slide 38], so the diameter of the neck would have to be measured (for example at F).

Key results
  • $\varepsilon_{T,B} = \ln(1.08) = 0.0770$
  • $\sigma_{T,B} = 560 \times 1.08 = 604.8$ MPa
  • Valid only up to U ($\varepsilon = 0.15$), where necking starts

Interpretation and checks

  • Physical meaning. $U_r = 0.490$ MJ/m³ is small next to the area under the whole curve (the toughness: a mean stress of about 530 MPa over a strain of 0.25 gives roughly $530\ \text{MPa}\times0.25 \approx 130$ MJ/m³): a structural steel absorbs almost all its energy plastically. A spring material needs high $\sigma_y$ and low $E$ [Session 11 Slide 35].
  • Limiting case. For small strains $\ln(1+\varepsilon) \approx \varepsilon$ and $1+\varepsilon \approx 1$: at A ($\varepsilon = 0.0015$) the true stress exceeds the engineering one by 0.15 % and the true strain is smaller by about 0.075 %; at B the stresses differ by 8 % and the strains by about 3.8 % (0.0770 against 0.08). The distinction matters only in the plastic range.
  • Dimensions. $\int\sigma\,d\varepsilon$ is Pa × (dimensionless) = Pa = J/m³; $\sigma_y^2/E$ is Pa²/Pa = Pa; $\ln(l/l_0)$ is the logarithm of a pure number; $\sigma(1+\varepsilon)$ is Pa.
  • Common exam mistake. Taking $\varepsilon_y = 0.002$ or $\varepsilon_Y = 0.004177$ (the strain of the crossing, which includes the plastic offset) in the resilience: $U_r$ uses only the elastic strain $\sigma_y/E$.
Part II problem · Unit 5 · Tensile test and mechanical properties · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P16 — Rebuilding the raw measurements of a magnesium alloy tensile test from its report

The raw data sheet of a tensile test on a round magnesium alloy specimen (initial diameter 9.00 mm, initial gauge length 45.00 mm) has been lost. The report only keeps the results: modulus of elasticity 45 GPa, yield strength (0.2 % offset) 170 MPa, tensile strength 255 MPa reached at an engineering strain of 0.080, elongation after fracture 11.0 % and reduction in area 13.0 %.

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValueIn SI
Initial diameter$d_0$9.00 mm$9.00\times10^{-3}$ m
Initial gauge length$l_0$45.00 mm$4.500\times10^{-2}$ m
Modulus of elasticity$E$45 GPa$4.5\times10^{10}$ Pa $= 45\,000$ MPa
Yield strength (0.2 % offset)$\sigma_y$170 MPa$1.70\times10^{8}$ Pa
Tensile strength$\sigma_{TS}$255 MPa$2.55\times10^{8}$ Pa
Engineering strain at the maximum load$\varepsilon_u$0.080(dimensionless)
Elongation after fracture$EL$11.0 %0.110
Reduction in area$RA$13.0 %0.130

Initial area, with the conversion written out:

$$A_0 = \frac{\pi d_0^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\,(9.00\ \text{mm})^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\times81.00\ \text{mm}^2}{4} = 63.62\ \text{mm}^2 = 6.362\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2$$

A stress in MPa times an area in mm² gives N, because $1\ \text{MPa} = 1\ \text{N/mm}^2$.

Model

  • $\sigma = F/A_0$ and $\varepsilon = (l - l_0)/l_0$ [Session 11 Slide 9]; Hooke's law $\sigma = E\varepsilon$ [Session 11 Slide 12].
  • 0.2 % offset: the yield point lies on the line $\sigma = E(\varepsilon - 0.002)$ [Session 11 Slide 28].
  • $EL\,(\%) = \dfrac{l_f - l_0}{l_0}\times100$ [Session 11 Slide 32] and $RA\,(\%) = \dfrac{A_0 - A_f}{A_0}\times100$ [Session 11 Slide 33].
  • Constant volume before necking, $A_0 l_0 = A_i l_i$, and $\sigma_T = F/A_i$ [Session 11 Slides 37-38].
  • Hypothesis: the deformation is uniform up to the maximum load, where necking starts [Session 11 Slide 30].

Part (a) · 1 point

Find the load at the yield strength, the maximum load, and the gauge length the extensometer read at the yield point

Loads from the stresses

The engineering stress is $\sigma = F/A_0$ [Session 11 Slide 9]; multiplying both sides by $A_0$ isolates the load, $F = \sigma A_0$:

$$F_y = \sigma_y\,A_0 = 170\ \text{N/mm}^2\times63.62\ \text{mm}^2 = 10\,815\ \text{N}$$
$$F_{\max} = \sigma_{TS}\,A_0 = 255\ \text{N/mm}^2\times63.62\ \text{mm}^2 = 16\,222\ \text{N}$$

Strain at the yield point from the offset line

The conventional yield point is where the curve meets the line parallel to the elastic one from $\varepsilon = 0.002$ [Session 11 Slide 28], so its coordinates satisfy $\sigma_y = E(\varepsilon_Y - 0.002)$. Dividing by $E$ and then adding 0.002 to both sides:

$$\varepsilon_Y - 0.002 = \frac{\sigma_y}{E} \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad \varepsilon_Y = 0.002 + \frac{\sigma_y}{E} = 0.002 + \frac{170\ \text{MPa}}{45\,000\ \text{MPa}} = 0.002 + 0.003778 = 0.005778$$

The total strain at that point is the plastic offset plus the elastic part, as the figure shows; the total strain before fracture is always $\varepsilon_t = \varepsilon_e + \varepsilon_p$ [Session 11 Slide 32].

0.002 σy strain ε σ (MPa) Y plastic 0.002 elastic σy/E ε at Y
Figure 1. Strain at the 0.2 % offset yield point: plastic offset plus elastic part.

Gauge length at the yield point

From $\varepsilon = (l - l_0)/l_0$, multiplying by $l_0$ and adding $l_0$: $l = l_0\,(1 + \varepsilon)$.

$$l_y = l_0\,(1 + \varepsilon_Y) = 45.00\ \text{mm}\times1.005778 = 45.260\ \text{mm}$$

The extensometer read an elongation of 0.260 mm. A student who places the yield point on the elastic line ($\varepsilon = 0.003778$) would rebuild 45.170 mm, missing the 0.090 mm of plastic offset.

Key results
  • $F_y = 10\,815$ N, $F_{\max} = 16\,222$ N
  • $\varepsilon$ at the yield point $= 0.005778$
  • $l_y = 45.260$ mm

Part (b) · 1 point

Rebuild the gauge length and the neck diameter measured after fracture, and the diameter and true stress of the specimen at the maximum load

Gauge length after fracture from %EL

From $EL = (l_f - l_0)/l_0$ (as a fraction, 0.110), multiplying by $l_0$ and adding $l_0$:

$$l_f = l_0\,(1 + EL) = 45.00\ \text{mm}\times(1 + 0.110) = 49.95\ \text{mm}$$

This is the distance between the marks with the two halves fitted together, after the elastic recovery [Session 11 Slide 32].

Neck diameter from %RA

From $RA = (A_0 - A_f)/A_0$ (0.130 as a fraction), multiplying by $A_0$ and isolating $A_f$:

$$A_f = A_0\,(1 - RA) = 63.62\ \text{mm}^2\times(1 - 0.130) = 63.62\ \text{mm}^2\times0.870 = 55.35\ \text{mm}^2$$

The area of a circle is $\pi d^2/4$, so $d_f = \sqrt{4A_f/\pi}$; the factor $\pi/4$ cancels against that of $A_0$, which gives directly

$$d_f = d_0\,\sqrt{1 - RA} = 9.00\ \text{mm}\times\sqrt{0.870} = 9.00\ \text{mm}\times0.9327 = 8.39\ \text{mm}$$

Diameter at the maximum load from constant volume

Up to the maximum load the deformation is uniform and the volume of the gauge length does not change [Session 11 Slide 38]: $A_0 l_0 = A_u l_u$. Isolating the area and writing $l_u/l_0 = 1 + \varepsilon_u$:

$$A_u = \frac{A_0\,l_0}{l_u} = \frac{A_0}{1 + \varepsilon_u} = \frac{63.62\ \text{mm}^2}{1.080} = 58.90\ \text{mm}^2$$

and, with $A \propto d^2$, $d_u = d_0/\sqrt{1 + \varepsilon_u} = 9.00\ \text{mm}/\sqrt{1.080} = 8.66$ mm.

True stress at the maximum load

The true stress is the load over the instantaneous area [Session 11 Slide 37]:

$$\sigma_{T,u} = \frac{F_{\max}}{A_u} = \frac{16\,222\ \text{N}}{58.90\ \text{mm}^2} = 275.4\ \text{MPa}$$

the same as $\sigma_{TS}(1 + \varepsilon_u) = 255\ \text{MPa}\times1.080 = 275.4$ MPa, as it must be, since both come from constant volume.

Key results
  • $l_f = 49.95$ mm, $A_f = 55.35$ mm², $d_f = 8.39$ mm
  • At the maximum load: $d = 8.66$ mm, $\sigma_T = 275.4$ MPa

Interpretation and checks

  • Consistency of the report. The neck diameter after fracture (8.39 mm) is smaller than the uniform diameter at the maximum load (8.66 mm): the neck kept thinning after the maximum, as it must [Session 11 Slide 30]. And $l_f = 49.95$ mm is longer than the length at the maximum, $45.00\times1.080 = 48.60$ mm, because the neck added plastic elongation even though the elastic part was recovered.
  • Order of magnitude. $E = 45$ GPa is the magnesium value of the slide's table [Session 11 Slide 17]; magnesium is hcp, with 6 slip systems against 12 for fcc and bcc [Session 11 Slide 25]. Extension (not on the slides): fewer slip systems usually mean less ductility, which fits the small %RA of 13 %.
  • Limiting case. If $RA \to 0$ (no neck), $d_f \to d_0$; if $\varepsilon_u \to 0$, $d_u \to d_0$ and $\sigma_T \to \sigma$.
  • Dimensions. $F = \sigma A_0$ is Pa·m² = N; $l_0(1 + \varepsilon)$ is m; $d_0\sqrt{1 - RA}$ is m; $F/A_u$ is Pa.
  • Common exam mistake. Getting the diameter after fracture as $d_0(1 - RA)$ = 7.83 mm: %RA is a reduction of the area, so the diameter scales with the square root.
Part II problem · Unit 5 · Bar or rod under load: elastic check, Poisson, design and unloading · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P17 — Nickel alloy tie rod under a tensile load

A tie rod of the engine mount of a light aircraft is a solid cylinder of a nickel alloy, 8.0 mm in diameter and 350 mm long. In service it is pulled along its axis by a force of 9.5 kN. The alloy has a Young's modulus of 207 GPa (the value of nickel in the table of the slides), a yield strength of 280 MPa and a Poisson's ratio of 0.31.

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValue givenIn SI
Initial diameter$d_0$8.0 mm$8.0\times10^{-3}$ m
Initial length$l_0$350 mm0.350 m
Axial force$F$9.5 kN$9.5\times10^{3}$ N
Young's modulus$E$207 GPa$207\times10^{9}$ Pa
Yield strength$\sigma_y$280 MPa$280\times10^{6}$ Pa
Poisson's ratio$\nu$0.31dimensionless

Model

  • Engineering stress and strain: $\sigma = F/A_0$ and $\varepsilon = (l - l_0)/l_0 = \Delta l/l_0$ [Session 11, Slide 9].
  • Elastic zone $\sigma < \sigma_y$, plastic zone $\sigma > \sigma_y$ [Session 11, Slide 10].
  • Hooke's law in the elastic zone, $\sigma = E\,\varepsilon$ [Session 11, Slide 12].
  • Poisson's ratio, $\nu = -\varepsilon_{\text{transverse}}/\varepsilon_{\text{longitudinal}}$ [Session 11, Slide 19].
  • Hypotheses: uniform uniaxial stress over the cross-section, isotropic material, no change of $A_0$ used in the stress (engineering stress).

Part (a) · 0.8 points

Does the rod deform plastically under the 9.5 kN load? Justify the answer.

Area of the cross-section, with the diameter in metres

The stress needs the initial area of the circular section. The diameter is first converted to metres, $d_0 = 8.0\ \text{mm} = 8.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m}$, and then:

$$A_0 = \frac{\pi d_0^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\,(8.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m})^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\times 6.4\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2}{4} = 5.027\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2$$

Engineering stress produced by the force

The force is converted to newtons, $F = 9.5\ \text{kN} = 9.5\times10^{3}\ \text{N}$. The engineering stress is the force over the initial area [Session 11, Slide 9]:

$$\sigma = \frac{F}{A_0} = \frac{9.5\times10^{3}\ \text{N}}{5.027\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2} = 1.890\times10^{8}\ \text{Pa} = 189.0\ \text{MPa}$$

Compare the stress with the yield strength

The rod deforms plastically only if the stress exceeds the yield strength [Session 11, Slide 10]. Here

$$\sigma = 189.0\ \text{MPa} < \sigma_y = 280\ \text{MPa}$$

so the rod stays in the elastic zone: it does not deform plastically, and all its deformation is recovered when the load is removed. The yield strength is $280/189.0 = 1.48$ times the applied stress.

Key results
  • $A_0 = 5.027\times10^{-5}$ m²
  • $\sigma = 189.0$ MPa $< \sigma_y = 280$ MPa: elastic, no plastic deformation
  • Ratio $\sigma_y/\sigma = 1.48$

Part (b) · 1.2 points

Length and diameter of the rod while the load is applied.

Axial strain from Hooke's law

Part (a) showed that the rod is elastic, so Hooke's law applies [Session 11, Slide 12]. Isolating the strain from $\sigma = E\,\varepsilon_z$ (divide both sides by $E$):

$$\varepsilon_z = \frac{\sigma}{E} = \frac{189.0\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{207\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}} = 9.130\times10^{-4}$$

Length under the load

From the definition $\varepsilon_z = \Delta l/l_0$ [Session 11, Slide 9], multiplying both sides by $l_0$ gives the elongation:

$$\Delta l = \varepsilon_z\,l_0 = 9.130\times10^{-4}\times 350\ \text{mm} = 0.3196\ \text{mm}$$
$$l = l_0 + \Delta l = 350\ \text{mm} + 0.3196\ \text{mm} = 350.320\ \text{mm}$$

Transverse strain from Poisson's ratio

A longitudinal elastic stretch comes with a transverse contraction [Session 11, Slide 19]. From $\nu = -\varepsilon_x/\varepsilon_z$, multiplying both sides by $-\varepsilon_z$:

$$\varepsilon_x = -\nu\,\varepsilon_z = -0.31\times 9.130\times10^{-4} = -2.830\times10^{-4}$$

Diameter under the load

The transverse strain is the relative change of the diameter, $\varepsilon_x = \Delta d/d_0$, so

$$\Delta d = \varepsilon_x\,d_0 = -2.830\times10^{-4}\times 8.0\ \text{mm} = -2.264\times10^{-3}\ \text{mm}$$
$$d = d_0 + \Delta d = 8.0\ \text{mm} - 0.002264\ \text{mm} = 7.9977\ \text{mm}$$

The diameter shrinks by about 2.3 µm while the length grows by about 0.32 mm.

Key results
  • $\varepsilon_z = 9.130\times10^{-4}$, $\Delta l = 0.3196$ mm, $l = 350.320$ mm
  • $\varepsilon_x = -2.830\times10^{-4}$, $\Delta d = -2.264\times10^{-3}$ mm, $d = 7.9977$ mm

Interpretation and checks

  • The rod works at 189 MPa, two thirds of its yield strength, so the whole deformation is elastic and is recovered on unloading. If the same force acted on a rod of 6.0 mm, the stress would rise by $(8/6)^2$ to 336 MPa and the rod would yield: the check of part (a) must always come before Hooke's law.
  • Control case: with $\nu = 0$ the diameter would not change; with $\nu = 0.5$ (incompressible, Slide 19) the contraction would be $-4.57\times10^{-4}$, larger than the one found. The value 0.31 lies in the range 0.25 to 0.4 of metals in the slide.
  • SI check: $\sigma = F/A_0$ in N/m² = Pa; $\varepsilon = \sigma/E$ in Pa/Pa, dimensionless; $\Delta l = \varepsilon\,l_0$ and $\Delta d = \varepsilon_x d_0$ in metres.
  • Common mistake: using the radius in place of the diameter in $\pi d_0^2/4$, or forgetting the minus sign of the transverse strain and giving a diameter that grows under tension.
Part II problem · Unit 5 · Bar or rod under load: elastic check, Poisson, design and unloading · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P18 — Choosing the alloy of a light control rod

A cylindrical control rod of an aircraft must be 250 mm long and 12 mm in diameter, and it carries an axial tensile load of 18 kN. The designer sets three requirements: (1) no yielding with a safety factor $N = 2$; (2) the diameter may not shrink by more than 10 µm under the load; (3) the rod may not weigh more than 150 g. Four alloys are available:

Alloy$E$ (GPa)$\sigma_y$ (MPa)$\nu$$\rho$ (g/cm³)
A, aluminium alloy693000.332.7
B, titanium alloy1078500.344.5
C, steel2074800.307.8
D, magnesium alloy452200.291.8

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValue givenIn SI
Length$l_0$250 mm0.250 m
Diameter$d_0$12 mm$12\times10^{-3}$ m
Axial force$F$18 kN$18\times10^{3}$ N
Safety factor$N$2dimensionless
Largest diameter loss$\lvert\Delta d\rvert_{\max}$10 µm$10\times10^{-6}$ m $= 10\times10^{-3}$ mm
Largest mass$m_{\max}$150 g0.150 kg

Moduli in pascals: $1\ \text{GPa} = 10^{9}\ \text{Pa}$, $1\ \text{MPa} = 10^{6}\ \text{Pa}$. Densities: $1\ \text{g/cm}^3 = 10^{3}\ \text{kg/m}^3$, so for example $\rho_A = 2.7\ \text{g/cm}^3 = 2700\ \text{kg/m}^3$.

Model

  • Engineering stress $\sigma = F/A_0$ [Session 11, Slide 9].
  • Working stress $\sigma_w = \sigma_y/N$: the design keeps $\sigma \le \sigma_w$ [Session 11, Slide 29].
  • Hooke's law $\sigma = E\,\varepsilon_z$ in the elastic zone [Session 11, Slide 12] and Poisson's ratio $\nu = -\varepsilon_x/\varepsilon_z$ [Session 11, Slide 19].
  • Mass $m = \rho\,V$ with $V = A_0\,l_0$ for a cylinder (geometry).
  • Hypotheses: uniform uniaxial stress; the dimensions are set, so the stress is the same for the four alloys; the deformation is elastic in every alloy that passes requirement (1).

Part (a) · 0.8 points

Which alloys meet the requirement of no yielding with the safety factor?

Stress in the rod, the same for every alloy

The diameter in metres is $d_0 = 12\times10^{-3}$ m, so the initial area is

$$A_0 = \frac{\pi d_0^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\,(12\times10^{-3}\ \text{m})^2}{4} = 1.131\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2$$

and with $F = 18\ \text{kN} = 18\times10^{3}$ N the engineering stress is [Session 11, Slide 9]

$$\sigma = \frac{F}{A_0} = \frac{18\times10^{3}\ \text{N}}{1.131\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2} = 1.592\times10^{8}\ \text{Pa} = 159.2\ \text{MPa}$$

Turn the safety factor into a minimum yield strength

The rod is safe when the stress does not exceed the working stress, $\sigma \le \sigma_w = \sigma_y/N$ [Session 11, Slide 29]. Multiplying both sides by $N$ isolates the yield strength the alloy needs:

$$\sigma_y \ge N\,\sigma = 2\times 159.2\ \text{MPa} = 318.3\ \text{MPa}$$

Screen the four alloys

Alloy$\sigma_y$ (MPa)$\sigma_y \ge 318.3$ MPa?
A300no, rejected (it would work with $N = 300/159.2 = 1.88$)
B850yes
C480yes
D220no, rejected ($N = 220/159.2 = 1.38$)

Only B and C meet the requirement of no yielding with $N = 2$. Alloy A would not yield (300 > 159.2 MPa), but its margin is below the one demanded.

Key results
  • $A_0 = 1.131\times10^{-4}$ m², $\sigma = 159.2$ MPa
  • Required $\sigma_y \ge 318.3$ MPa: A (300) and D (220) are rejected; B and C pass

Part (b) · 1.2 points

Check the diameter change and the mass of the remaining alloys and choose the material.

Diameter change from Hooke's law and Poisson's ratio

B and C are elastic at 159.2 MPa (part a). Hooke's law gives $\varepsilon_z = \sigma/E$ [Session 11, Slide 12]; Poisson's ratio gives $\varepsilon_x = -\nu\,\varepsilon_z$ [Session 11, Slide 19]; and $\Delta d = \varepsilon_x\,d_0$. Putting the three together, line by line:

$$\Delta d = \varepsilon_x\,d_0 = -\nu\,\varepsilon_z\,d_0 = -\nu\,\frac{\sigma}{E}\,d_0$$

For B, with $E = 107\times10^{9}$ Pa and $d_0 = 12$ mm:

$$\Delta d_B = -0.34\times\frac{159.2\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{107\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}}\times 12\ \text{mm} = -0.34\times 1.487\times10^{-3}\times 12\ \text{mm} = -6.07\times10^{-3}\ \text{mm} = -6.07\ \mu\text{m}$$

For C, with $E = 207\times10^{9}$ Pa:

$$\Delta d_C = -0.30\times\frac{159.2\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{207\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}}\times 12\ \text{mm} = -0.30\times 7.689\times10^{-4}\times 12\ \text{mm} = -2.77\ \mu\text{m}$$

Both losses are smaller than 10 µm, so B and C meet requirement (2).

Mass of the rod

The volume of the cylinder is the same for every alloy:

$$V = A_0\,l_0 = 1.131\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2\times 0.250\ \text{m} = 2.827\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^3 = 28.27\ \text{cm}^3$$

using $1\ \text{m}^3 = 10^{6}\ \text{cm}^3$. With $m = \rho V$:

$$m_B = 4.5\ \text{g/cm}^3\times 28.27\ \text{cm}^3 = 127.2\ \text{g} \le 150\ \text{g}$$
$$m_C = 7.8\ \text{g/cm}^3\times 28.27\ \text{cm}^3 = 220.5\ \text{g} > 150\ \text{g}$$

Steel C is rejected by the mass limit.

Choice and summary of the rejections

AlloyRequirement (1), $\sigma_y \ge 318.3$ MPaRequirement (2), $\lvert\Delta d\rvert \le 10$ µmRequirement (3), $m \le 150$ gResult
Afails (300 MPa)9.13 µm76.3 grejected by (1)
B850 MPa6.07 µm127.2 gchosen
C480 MPa2.77 µmfails (220.5 g)rejected by (3)
Dfails (220 MPa)fails (12.31 µm)50.9 grejected by (1) and (2)

The values of A and D in columns (2) and (3) are given only for completeness (computed with the same formulas). The rod is made of the titanium alloy B. Its elongation under the load is

$$\Delta l_B = \frac{\sigma}{E_B}\,l_0 = \frac{159.2\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{107\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}}\times 250\ \text{mm} = 0.372\ \text{mm}$$
Key results
  • $\Delta d_B = -6.07$ µm, $\Delta d_C = -2.77$ µm: both within 10 µm
  • $V = 28.27$ cm³; $m_B = 127.2$ g, $m_C = 220.5$ g: C is rejected by mass
  • Chosen: alloy B (titanium), elongation $\Delta l_B = 0.372$ mm

Interpretation and checks

  • The three requirements pull in different directions: steel is stiff and strong but heavy, the light alloys are too weak for $N = 2$, and the titanium alloy wins on strength per unit density. Extension (not on the slides): the specific strength $\sigma_y/\rho$ is the yield strength divided by the density; with the table it is about 111 (A), 189 (B), 61.5 (C) and 122 (D) MPa per g/cm³, so B is clearly ahead. On the specific modulus $E/\rho$ B is actually the lowest of the four (23.8 against 25.0 to 26.5 GPa per g/cm³): here stiffness is not the deciding property.
  • D fails twice: a low yield strength and a low modulus (a large elastic strain, hence a large diameter loss). A low $E$ makes $\lvert\Delta d\rvert$ grow as $\nu/E$.
  • Limiting check: the diameter loss of B, 6.07 µm, is $5\times10^{-4}$ of the diameter, a typical elastic strain of a metal, far below 1 %.
  • SI check: $\nu\,\sigma\,d_0/E$ has units Pa·m/Pa = m; $\rho\,V$ in (kg/m³)·m³ = kg.
  • Common mistake: rejecting A because "it yields". It does not yield at 159.2 MPa; it is rejected because its safety factor would be 1.88 < 2.
Part II problem · Unit 5 · Bar or rod under load: elastic check, Poisson, design and unloading · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P19 — Aluminium alloy specimen loaded beyond yield and unloaded

A cylindrical specimen of an aluminium alloy, 12.0 mm in diameter and with a gauge length of 50.0 mm, is pulled in a tensile machine up to a load of 40 kN. At that load the engineering strain measured on the gauge length is 0.035. The load is then removed completely, and later the same specimen is loaded again to 30 kN. Data of the alloy: $E = 69$ GPa, $\sigma_y = 275$ MPa (0.2 % offset).

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValue givenIn SI
Initial diameter$d_0$12.0 mm$12.0\times10^{-3}$ m
Gauge length$l_0$50.0 mm$50.0\times10^{-3}$ m
Maximum load$F_B$40 kN$40\times10^{3}$ N
Total strain at $F_B$$\varepsilon_B$0.035dimensionless
Reloading force$F_R$30 kN$30\times10^{3}$ N
Young's modulus$E$69 GPa$69\times10^{9}$ Pa
Yield strength$\sigma_y$275 MPa$275\times10^{6}$ Pa

Model

  • Engineering stress $\sigma = F/A_0$ and strain $\varepsilon = (l - l_0)/l_0$ [Session 11, Slide 9]; elastic zone for $\sigma < \sigma_y$, plastic for $\sigma > \sigma_y$ [Session 11, Slide 10].
  • Hooke's law $\sigma = E\,\varepsilon$ for the elastic part [Session 11, Slide 12].
  • Beyond yield the total strain is the sum of an elastic and a plastic part, $\varepsilon_t = \varepsilon_e + \varepsilon_p$; on unloading the elastic part is recovered along a line parallel to the elastic line and the plastic part remains [Session 11, Slide 32].
  • Extension (idealisation, not stated on the slides): on reloading, the unloaded specimen follows the unloading line elastically up to the previous maximum stress before it yields again. The slides only state that cold work raises the yield strength [Session 12, Slide 5].
  • Yielding is drawn, as an idealisation, at the end of the straight elastic line; the real 0.2 % offset value of 275 MPa lies on the curve at a strain of about 0.0060.
  • Hypotheses: uniform uniaxial stress; the engineering stress uses the initial area $A_0$; the unloading is elastic with the same modulus $E$; the elastic reloading of part (c) rests on the idealisation marked extension above.

Part (a) · 0.6 points

Show that the specimen deforms plastically at 40 kN and give its length under that load.

Stress at the maximum load

With $d_0 = 12.0\times10^{-3}$ m:

$$A_0 = \frac{\pi d_0^2}{4} = \frac{\pi\,(12.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{m})^2}{4} = 1.131\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2$$

and with $F_B = 40\ \text{kN} = 40\times10^{3}$ N [Session 11, Slide 9]:

$$\sigma_B = \frac{F_B}{A_0} = \frac{40\times10^{3}\ \text{N}}{1.131\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2} = 3.537\times10^{8}\ \text{Pa} = 353.7\ \text{MPa}$$

Elastic or plastic

$\sigma_B = 353.7\ \text{MPa} > \sigma_y = 275\ \text{MPa}$, so the specimen is in the plastic zone [Session 11, Slide 10]. Hooke's law does not hold up to this point: the measured strain 0.035 is much larger than the elastic strain at yield, $\sigma_y/E = 275\times10^{6}/69\times10^{9} = 3.986\times10^{-3}$.

Length under the load

The strain under load is given, so the length comes straight from the definition $\varepsilon_B = (l_B - l_0)/l_0$. Multiplying by $l_0$ and adding $l_0$ to both sides:

$$l_B = l_0\,(1 + \varepsilon_B) = 50.0\ \text{mm}\times(1 + 0.035) = 51.750\ \text{mm}$$
Key results
  • $A_0 = 1.131\times10^{-4}$ m², $\sigma_B = 353.7$ MPa $> 275$ MPa: plastic
  • $l_B = 51.750$ mm

Part (b) · 0.8 points

Length of the specimen after the 40 kN load is removed. Draw the loading and unloading path.

Split the total strain into its elastic and plastic parts

At point B of the curve the total strain is $\varepsilon_B = \varepsilon_e + \varepsilon_p$ [Session 11, Slide 32]. Unloading removes the stress from $\sigma_B$ to 0 along a straight line parallel to the elastic line, of slope $E$ [Session 11, Slide 32]. The strain recovered is therefore Hooke's law applied to the stress drop $\sigma_B - 0$:

$$\varepsilon_e = \frac{\sigma_B}{E} = \frac{353.7\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{69\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}} = 5.126\times10^{-3}$$

Permanent strain

Isolating the plastic part from $\varepsilon_B = \varepsilon_e + \varepsilon_p$ (subtract $\varepsilon_e$ from both sides):

$$\varepsilon_p = \varepsilon_B - \varepsilon_e = 0.035 - 5.126\times10^{-3} = 0.02987$$

Final length after unloading

The permanent strain is measured on the initial gauge length, so

$$l_P = l_0\,(1 + \varepsilon_p) = 50.0\ \text{mm}\times(1 + 0.02987) = 51.494\ \text{mm}$$

The specimen shortens on unloading by $l_B - l_P = 51.750 - 51.494 = 0.256$ mm, which is $\varepsilon_e\,l_0 = 5.126\times10^{-3}\times 50.0$ mm.

Loading and unloading path

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 100 200 300 400 engineering strain ε σ (MPa) O Y B P R 353.7 MPa σy = 275 MPa εp = 0.0299 ε = 0.035 slope E
Figure 1. Loading O-Y-B beyond yield (yielding idealised at the end of the elastic line Y), unloading B-P parallel to the elastic line, reloading P-R (to scale).

O to Y is the elastic line, with yielding idealised at its end (the 0.2 % offset value lies a little further along the curve); Y to B is the plastic loading up to 353.7 MPa at $\varepsilon = 0.035$; B to P is the unloading, parallel to OY, ending at the permanent strain 0.0299.

Key results
  • Recovered elastic strain $\varepsilon_e = 5.126\times10^{-3}$
  • Permanent strain $\varepsilon_p = 0.02987$
  • Final length $l_P = 51.494$ mm (the specimen shortens by 0.256 mm on unloading)

Part (c) · 0.6 points

Length of the specimen when it is loaded again to 30 kN.

Is the reloading elastic?

Extension: reloading to the previous maximum

The idealisation used here is not stated on the slides: a specimen unloaded from B climbs back along the unloading line PB elastically and yields again only when the stress reaches the previous maximum, 353.7 MPa. The slides only say that cold work raises the yield strength [Session 12, Slide 5].

With that idealisation, the reloading is elastic if the new stress stays below 353.7 MPa. The new stress is

$$\sigma_R = \frac{F_R}{A_0} = \frac{30\times10^{3}\ \text{N}}{1.131\times10^{-4}\ \text{m}^2} = 265.3\ \text{MPa} < 353.7\ \text{MPa}$$

so the specimen is elastic on the line PB (point R of the figure), even though 265.3 MPa is close to the original $\sigma_y = 275$ MPa.

Strain and length at R

The strain at R is the permanent strain plus the elastic strain of Hooke's law for $\sigma_R$:

$$\varepsilon_R = \varepsilon_p + \frac{\sigma_R}{E} = 0.02987 + \frac{265.3\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{69\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}} = 0.02987 + 3.844\times10^{-3} = 0.03372$$
$$l_R = l_0\,(1 + \varepsilon_R) = 50.0\ \text{mm}\times 1.03372 = 51.686\ \text{mm}$$
Key results
  • $\sigma_R = 265.3$ MPa $< \sigma_B = 353.7$ MPa: the reloading runs back up the line PB, elastically
  • $\varepsilon_R = 0.03372$, $l_R = 51.686$ mm

Interpretation and checks

  • The elastic recovery, 0.256 mm, is only about 1/7 of the total elongation of 1.750 mm: in a ductile metal loaded well past yield most of the strain is permanent.
  • Control cases: had the load stayed below $\sigma_y$, $\varepsilon_p = 0$ and the specimen would return to 50.0 mm; at R, setting $F_R = 0$ gives back $l_P$, and $F_R = 40$ kN gives back $l_B$, because $\varepsilon_p + \sigma_B/E = 0.035$.
  • SI check: $\sigma/E$ is Pa/Pa, dimensionless, and it adds to $\varepsilon_p$, also dimensionless; $l = l_0(1+\varepsilon)$ is in metres.
  • Common mistake: recovering $\sigma_y/E$ instead of $\sigma_B/E$ on unloading (that gives 51.551 mm), or computing the length under load with Hooke's law in the plastic zone.
Part II problem · Unit 5 · Bar or rod under load: elastic check, Poisson, design and unloading · 2 points · 15 min · Practice item, not an official exercise

P20 — Minimum diameter of a titanium hanger rod

In an engine test cell, a mass of 2400 kg hangs from a solid cylindrical rod of a titanium alloy, 1.20 m long. The alloy has $E = 107$ GPa and $\sigma_y = 880$ MPa, and the design uses a safety factor $N = 2.5$. Take $g = 9.81$ m/s².

Data and model

Data

QuantitySymbolValue givenIn SI
Hanging mass$m$2400 kg2400 kg
Rod length$l_0$1.20 m1.20 m $= 1200$ mm
Young's modulus$E$107 GPa$107\times10^{9}$ Pa
Yield strength$\sigma_y$880 MPa$880\times10^{6}$ Pa
Safety factor$N$2.5dimensionless
Gravity$g$9.81 m/s²9.81 m/s²

Model

  • Weight of the mass $F = m\,g$ (it is the axial force on the rod at rest).
  • Engineering stress $\sigma = F/A_0$ and strain $\varepsilon = \Delta l/l_0$ [Session 11, Slide 9].
  • Working stress $\sigma_w = \sigma_y/N$ [Session 11, Slide 29].
  • Hooke's law $\sigma = E\,\varepsilon$ [Session 11, Slide 12].
  • Modulus of resilience $U_r = \int_0^{\varepsilon_y}\sigma\,d\varepsilon$ [Session 11, Slide 35].
  • Hypotheses: uniform uniaxial stress; the weight of the rod is neglected against 2400 kg; linear elastic behaviour up to $\sigma_y$.

Part (a) · 0.8 points

Minimum diameter of the rod.

Load on the rod

The rod holds the mass at rest, so the axial force is its weight:

$$F = m\,g = 2400\ \text{kg}\times 9.81\ \text{m/s}^2 = 23\,544\ \text{N}$$

Largest stress allowed

The design keeps the stress at or below the working stress [Session 11, Slide 29]:

$$\sigma_w = \frac{\sigma_y}{N} = \frac{880\ \text{MPa}}{2.5} = 352\ \text{MPa} = 352\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}$$

Minimum area and diameter

The condition is $\sigma = F/A_0 \le \sigma_w$. Multiplying both sides by $A_0$ and dividing by $\sigma_w$ isolates the area:

$$A_0 \ge \frac{F}{\sigma_w} = \frac{23\,544\ \text{N}}{352\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}} = 6.689\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2$$

From $A_0 = \pi d_0^2/4$: multiply by 4, divide by $\pi$ and take the square root:

$$d_{\min} = \sqrt{\frac{4A_{\min}}{\pi}} = \sqrt{\frac{4\times 6.689\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2}{\pi}} = \sqrt{8.516\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2} = 9.228\times10^{-3}\ \text{m} = 9.23\ \text{mm}$$
Key results
  • $F = 23\,544$ N, $\sigma_w = 352$ MPa
  • $A_{\min} = 6.689\times10^{-5}$ m², $d_{\min} = 9.23$ mm

Part (b) · 0.6 points

The rod is made with the next whole millimetre, 10 mm. Find the real safety factor and the elongation of the rod under the load.

Stress with the 10 mm rod

$$A_0 = \frac{\pi\,(10\times10^{-3}\ \text{m})^2}{4} = 7.854\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2 \qquad \sigma = \frac{F}{A_0} = \frac{23\,544\ \text{N}}{7.854\times10^{-5}\ \text{m}^2} = 299.8\ \text{MPa}$$

Real safety factor

From $\sigma_w = \sigma_y/N$ with the working stress equal to the actual stress, isolating $N$:

$$N_{\text{real}} = \frac{\sigma_y}{\sigma} = \frac{880\ \text{MPa}}{299.8\ \text{MPa}} = 2.94 \ge 2.5$$

Elongation

The rod is elastic ($\sigma < \sigma_y$), so Hooke's law gives the strain [Session 11, Slide 12], and $\Delta l = \varepsilon\,l_0$ the elongation:

$$\varepsilon = \frac{\sigma}{E} = \frac{299.8\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{107\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}} = 2.802\times10^{-3} \qquad \Delta l = 2.802\times10^{-3}\times 1200\ \text{mm} = 3.36\ \text{mm}$$
Key results
  • $A_0 = 7.854\times10^{-5}$ m², $\sigma = 299.8$ MPa
  • $N_{\text{real}} = 2.94$
  • $\varepsilon = 2.802\times10^{-3}$, $\Delta l = 3.36$ mm

Part (c) · 0.6 points

Derive the modulus of resilience of the alloy from its definition as an integral and evaluate it.

Definition and upper limit

The modulus of resilience is the elastic energy per unit volume stored up to the yield point, the area under the curve from 0 to $\varepsilon_y$ [Session 11, Slide 35]. The upper limit follows from Hooke's law at the yield point, $\sigma_y = E\,\varepsilon_y$, divided by $E$:

$$\varepsilon_y = \frac{\sigma_y}{E} = \frac{880\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa}}{107\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}} = 8.224\times10^{-3}$$

Integrate with Barrow's rule

In the elastic range $\sigma = E\,\varepsilon$ with $E$ constant, so $E$ leaves the integral. The antiderivative of $\varepsilon$ is $\varepsilon^2/2$, and Barrow's rule substitutes the limits:

$$U_r = \int_0^{\varepsilon_y}\sigma\,d\varepsilon = \int_0^{\varepsilon_y}E\,\varepsilon\,d\varepsilon = E\left[\frac{\varepsilon^2}{2}\right]_0^{\varepsilon_y} = E\left(\frac{\varepsilon_y^2}{2} - \frac{0^2}{2}\right) = \frac{E\,\varepsilon_y^2}{2}$$

Replacing $\varepsilon_y = \sigma_y/E$:

$$U_r = \frac{E}{2}\,\frac{\sigma_y^2}{E^2} = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}$$
0 εy = 0.00822 880 strain ε σ (MPa) Ur σ = Eε
Figure 1. The modulus of resilience is the area under the elastic line from 0 to the yield strain.

Value

$$U_r = \frac{(880\times10^{6}\ \text{Pa})^2}{2\times 107\times10^{9}\ \text{Pa}} = \frac{7.744\times10^{17}\ \text{Pa}^2}{2.14\times10^{11}\ \text{Pa}} = 3.619\times10^{6}\ \text{J/m}^3 = 3.619\ \text{MPa}$$
Key results
  • $\varepsilon_y = 8.224\times10^{-3}$
  • $U_r = 3.619\times10^{6}$ J/m³ $= 3.619$ MPa

Interpretation and checks

  • Rounding the diameter up from 9.23 mm to 10 mm raises the safety factor from 2.5 to 2.94: the area grows with the square of the diameter, $(10/9.228)^2 = 1.174$.
  • Control case: with $N = 1$ the minimum diameter would be $9.228\sqrt{1/2.5} = 5.84$ mm, the rod that just reaches yield; the diameter scales as $\sqrt{N}$.
  • The resilience 3.62 MJ/m³ is high because $\sigma_y$ is high and $E$ moderate, the property Slide 35 asks of spring alloys. At the working load each cubic metre of the 10 mm rod stores only $\tfrac{1}{2}\sigma\varepsilon = 0.420$ MJ/m³, about 1/8.6 of $U_r$, since the energy goes with $\sigma^2$.
  • SI check: $F/\sigma_w$ in N/Pa = m²; $\sigma_y^2/E$ in Pa²/Pa = Pa = N/m² = J/m³, an energy per volume.
  • Common mistake: using the mass in kg as the force (forgetting $g$), or the yield strength in place of the working stress, which gives 5.84 mm and no margin.