Linear Independence of Canonical Solution Pairs via Wronskian
Original statement · ProblemsCh3.pdfBy finding the Wronskian of the following pairs of functions, show that they are linearly independent:
- $x_1(t) = e^{k_1 t}$ and $x_2(t) = e^{k_2 t}$ with $k_1 \neq k_2$
- $x_1(t) = e^{k t}$ and $x_2(t) = t e^{k t}$
- $x_1(t) = e^{\rho t}\sin(\omega t)$ and $x_2(t) = e^{\rho t}\cos(\omega t)$ with $\omega \neq 0$
For two continuously differentiable functions $x_1, x_2 \in C^1(I)$, the Wronskian determinant is defined as: $$ W[x_1, x_2](t) = \det \begin{pmatrix} x_1(t) & x_2(t) \\ \dot{x}_1(t) & \dot{x}_2(t) \end{pmatrix} = x_1(t)\dot{x}_2(t) - x_2(t)\dot{x}_1(t) $$ If $W[x_1, x_2](t_0) \neq 0$ at even a single point $t_0 \in I$, the functions $x_1(t)$ and $x_2(t)$ are strictly linearly independent on the interval $I$.
The notes define $W(x_1, x_2) = x_1x_2' - x_2x_1'$ and list the Wronskian of each pair of Cases 01 to 03: $(k_2 - k_1)e^{(k_1 + k_2)t}$ for $e^{k_1t}, e^{k_2t}$; $e^{2kt}$ for $e^{kt}, te^{kt}$; $\omega e^{2\rho t}$ for $e^{\rho t}\cos\omega t, e^{\rho t}\sin\omega t$. These are the three pairs of this problem. In (iii) the order is reversed (sine first), so the sign flips: $W = -\omega e^{2\rho t}$, still never zero for $\omega \neq 0$.
For solutions of $x'' + px' + qx = 0$ the notes also show that $W \equiv 0$ or $W$ never vanishes (Problem 3.2), so one point with $W \neq 0$ is enough.
Differentiating each function:
$$\dot{x}_1(t) = k_1 e^{k_1 t}, \qquad \dot{x}_2(t) = k_2 e^{k_2 t}$$Formulating the Wronskian determinant:
$$ W[x_1, x_2](t) = e^{k_1 t}\left( k_2 e^{k_2 t} \right) - e^{k_2 t}\left( k_1 e^{k_1 t} \right) = (k_2 - k_1) e^{(k_1 + k_2)t} $$Since the exponential function satisfies $e^{(k_1 + k_2)t} > 0$ for all $t \in \mathbb{R}$, and $k_1 \neq k_2 \implies k_2 - k_1 \neq 0$:
$$ W[x_1, x_2](t) \neq 0 \quad \forall t \in \mathbb{R} \implies \text{Linearly Independent on } \mathbb{R} $$Differentiating using the product rule on $x_2(t)$:
$$\dot{x}_1(t) = k e^{kt}, \qquad \dot{x}_2(t) = 1 \cdot e^{kt} + t(k e^{kt}) = (1 + kt)e^{kt}$$Formulating the Wronskian determinant:
$$ W[x_1, x_2](t) = e^{kt}\left[ (1 + kt)e^{kt} \right] - t e^{kt}\left[ k e^{kt} \right] = e^{2kt} \left[ (1 + kt) - kt \right] = e^{2kt} $$Since $e^{2kt} > 0$ for every real $t$, $W(t)$ is strictly positive everywhere:
$$ W[x_1, x_2](t) = e^{2kt} \neq 0 \quad \forall t \in \mathbb{R} \implies \text{Linearly Independent on } \mathbb{R} $$Differentiating via product rule:
$$\dot{x}_1(t) = e^{\rho t}\left[ \rho \sin(\omega t) + \omega \cos(\omega t) \right]$$ $$\dot{x}_2(t) = e^{\rho t}\left[ \rho \cos(\omega t) - \omega \sin(\omega t) \right]$$Assembling $W(t) = x_1 \dot{x}_2 - x_2 \dot{x}_1$ and factoring $e^{2\rho t}$:
$$ W(t) = e^{2\rho t}\left[ \sin(\omega t)\left(\rho \cos(\omega t) - \omega \sin(\omega t)\right) - \cos(\omega t)\left(\rho \sin(\omega t) + \omega \cos(\omega t)\right) \right] $$ $$ W(t) = e^{2\rho t}\left[ \rho\sin\omega t\cos\omega t - \omega\sin^2\omega t - \rho\cos\omega t\sin\omega t - \omega\cos^2\omega t \right] $$The cross terms $\rho\sin\omega t\cos\omega t$ cancel identically. Applying $\sin^2\omega t + \cos^2\omega t = 1$:
$$ W[x_1, x_2](t) = e^{2\rho t}\left[ -\omega(\sin^2\omega t + \cos^2\omega t) \right] = -\omega e^{2\rho t} $$Because $\omega \neq 0$ and $e^{2\rho t} > 0$:
$$ W[x_1, x_2](t) = -\omega e^{2\rho t} \neq 0 \quad \forall t \in \mathbb{R} \implies \text{Linearly Independent on } \mathbb{R} $$(i) Distinct Exponentials: $W[e^{k_1 t}, e^{k_2 t}](t) = \mathbf{(k_2 - k_1) e^{(k_1 + k_2)t}} \neq 0$
(ii) Critical Damping Secular Mode: $W[e^{kt}, t e^{kt}](t) = \mathbf{e^{2kt}} > 0$
(iii) Damped Harmonic Oscillations: $W[e^{\rho t}\sin\omega t, e^{\rho t}\cos\omega t](t) = \mathbf{-\omega e^{2\rho t}} \neq 0$