Conservation of Angular Momentum & Turbomachinery Torque
1. The Master Angular Momentum Equation
In continuum mechanics, the moment of momentum (angular momentum) of a closed material fluid system $V_f(t)$ about an arbitrary fixed point in space $\vec{x}_0$ changes at a rate equal to the resultant external moment acting on the fluid:
Substituting intensive angular momentum $\vec{b} = (\vec{x} - \vec{x}_0)\times\vec{v}$ into the universal Reynolds Transport Theorem yields the Master Integral Angular Momentum Equation for any moving control volume $V_c(t)$:
The external moments $\sum \vec{M}_{\vec{x}_0, \text{ext}}$ consist of pressure forces, viscous shear forces, body forces (e.g., gravity), and mechanical holding torques applied by shaft couplings or mounting flanges:
Angular Momentum: Complete Derivation Chain (Notes.pdf, Eqs. 3.37-3.38)
Step 1: Angular momentum of a fluid volume (Eq. 3.37)
Let $\vec{r}=\vec{x}-\vec{x}_0$, with $\vec{x}_0$ a fixed point of an inertial frame. A fluid particle of mass $\rho\,dV$ has angular momentum $\vec{r}\wedge\rho\vec{v}\,dV$ about $\vec{x}_0$ (Notes, p. 33), so the angular momentum of the fluid volume is $\int_{V_f}\rho\,\vec{r}\wedge\vec{v}\,dV$. Newton's second law for angular momentum states that its rate of change equals the moment of the external forces about $\vec{x}_0$. The moment of the surface force $\bar{\bar{\tau}}\cdot\vec{n}\,d\sigma$ on each element of the boundary and the moment of the body force $\rho\vec{f}_m\,dV$ on each particle give Eq. 3.37:
Step 2: Consistency with the local momentum equation (extension)
Extension, not in the Notes. For a fluid particle the mass $\rho\,dV$ is constant and $D\vec{r}/Dt=\vec{v}$ because $\vec{x}_0$ is fixed. The product rule gives
since $\vec{v}\wedge\vec{v}=\vec{0}$. Insert Cauchy's equation (Eq. 3.25), $\rho D\vec{v}/Dt=\nabla\cdot\bar{\bar{\tau}}+\rho\vec{f}_m$, and integrate over the volume:
It remains to show that the first integral on the right equals the surface integral of Eq. 3.37. With the permutation symbol $\epsilon_{kij}$, component $k$ of the integrand is $\epsilon_{kij}r_i\,\partial\tau_{lj}/\partial x_l$. The product rule and $\partial r_i/\partial x_l=\delta_{il}$ give
The last term vanishes because $\epsilon_{kij}$ is antisymmetric in $(i,j)$ and $\tau_{ij}$ is symmetric (Eq. 3.19). Gauss' theorem on the first term, together with $\tau_{lj}n_l=\tau_{jl}n_l=(\bar{\bar{\tau}}\cdot\vec{n})_j$, gives
which shows that linear momentum together with a symmetric stress tensor is equivalent to Eq. 3.37. The symmetry of the stress tensor is exactly the condition that makes both statements agree. Note that this is not a derivation of Eq. 3.37 from linear momentum alone: in Notes.pdf (pp. 29-30) the symmetry of $\bar{\bar{\tau}}$ (Eq. 3.19) is itself obtained from angular momentum, so the argument would be circular if read that way.
Step 3: Transfer to a moving control volume (Eq. 3.38)
Apply Eq. 3.8 with the density $\vec{\phi}=\rho\,\vec{r}\wedge\vec{v}$, evaluate the right-hand side of Eq. 3.37 on $\Sigma_c$, $V_c$ (coincident with $\Sigma_f$, $V_f$ at the instant considered) and split the stress with Eq. 3.28. Since $\vec{r}\wedge\big((-p\bar{\bar{I}})\cdot\vec{n}\big)=-\vec{r}\wedge(p\vec{n})$:
Because $\vec{x}_0$ is fixed, $\vec{r}$ is not differentiated in the control-volume term; the point $\vec{x}_0$ may be placed anywhere, and the choice is a matter of convenience.
Step 4: Uniform ports and the pivot rule (extension)
Extension, not in the Notes. If a port $A_k$ is small compared with its distance to $\vec{x}_0$, then $\vec{r}\approx\vec{r}_k$ is constant over the port. With uniform $\rho_k$, $\vec{v}_k$ normal to the port and a fixed volume,
For steady flow the equation reduces to $\sum_k\dot m_k\,\vec{r}_k\wedge\vec{v}_k=\sum\vec{M}_{\vec{x}_0}$, with $\dot m_k$ negative at inlets. An unknown reaction force $\vec{R}$ applied at the point $\vec{x}_R$ contributes the moment $(\vec{x}_R-\vec{x}_0)\wedge\vec{R}$, which is zero if $\vec{x}_0=\vec{x}_R$ (or if $\vec{x}_0$ lies on the line of action of $\vec{R}$). This is the pivot rule.
Step 5: Euler turbomachinery equation (every step)
Extension, not in the Notes. Take a fixed annular control volume around the rotor axis $z$, with an inlet cylinder $r=r_1$ (normal $-\vec{e}_r$) and an outlet cylinder $r=r_2$ (normal $+\vec{e}_r$), with $\vec{x}_0$ on the axis. The flow is periodic and is treated as steady and axisymmetric on average, with $\rho$, $v_r$, $v_\theta$ uniform on each cylinder. The end walls are impermeable. The $z$ component of the angular momentum per unit mass follows from $\vec{r}=r\vec{e}_r+z\vec{e}_z$ and $\vec{v}=v_r\vec{e}_r+v_\theta\vec{e}_\theta+v_z\vec{e}_z$:
Convective flux in the $z$ component of Eq. 3.38. On the outlet $\vec{v}\cdot\vec{n}=+v_r$ and on the inlet $\vec{v}\cdot\vec{n}=-v_r$. The mass flow through each cylinder is the same, $\dot m=\int\rho v_r\,d\sigma$, by Eq. 3.11 in steady flow:
Moments on the right-hand side. A pressure force on a cylinder of constant $r$ is $\mp p\,\vec{e}_r\,d\sigma$, and $(r\vec{e}_r+z\vec{e}_z)\wedge\vec{e}_r=z\,\vec{e}_z\wedge\vec{e}_r=z\,\vec{e}_\theta$, which has no $z$ component. On the end walls the force is along $\pm\vec{e}_z$ and $r\vec{e}_r\wedge\vec{e}_z=-r\vec{e}_\theta$, again with no $z$ component. Viscous stresses on the ports and the moment of the body force about the axis are neglected. The only remaining moment is the moment $M_z$ exerted by the blades (solid surfaces inside the volume) on the fluid:
Here $M_z$ is the torque exerted by the rotor on the fluid. The torque exerted by the fluid on the rotor is $-M_z$ (Newton's third law). Each blade point moves with velocity $\Omega r\,\vec{e}_\theta$, so the power transmitted to the fluid is $\Omega M_z$ and the work per unit mass is
Dimensional check: $[\dot m\,r\,v_\theta]=\mathrm{kg\,s^{-1}\,m\,m\,s^{-1}}=\mathrm{N\,m}$ and $[u\,v_\theta]=\mathrm{m^2/s^2}=\mathrm{J/kg}$.
2. Strategic Pivot Selection Strategy
In many exam problems (such as pipe elbows, nozzle mounts, and rotating sprinklers), several complex linear reaction forces $\vec{R}$ act at physical supports, bearings, or hinges. Solving for these linear reaction forces simultaneously with moments can be tedious and prone to algebraic errors.
Always place the reference reduction point $\vec{x}_0$ directly at the support hinge, bearing axis, or bolt circle where unknown linear reaction forces act!
Because the position vector from $\vec{x}_0$ to the reaction point is zero ($\vec{r} = \vec{x} - \vec{x}_0 = \vec{0}$), the moment arm is zero: $\vec{r}\times\vec{R} = \vec{0}$. The unknown linear reaction forces completely vanish from the moment balance, allowing direct solution for holding torque or shaft power in a single line!
1D Streams Approximation
For discrete 1D inlets and outlets with mass flow rates $\dot{m}_i$, position vectors $\vec{r}_i = \vec{x}_i - \vec{x}_0$, and mean velocities $\vec{v}_i$, steady angular momentum reduces to:
Holding Torque on an Offset Pipe Bend / Mixing Elbow
Physical Setup: Consider a horizontal planar pipe bend in the $xy$-plane. Water enters at inlet 1 located at $\vec{r}_1 = (0, -L_1, 0)$ flowing in $+y$ direction with speed $v_1$, area $A_1$, and gauge pressure $p_{g1}$. It is deflected through $90^\circ$ and exits at $\vec{r}_2 = (L_2, 0, 0)$ discharging in $+x$ direction with speed $v_2$, area $A_2$, at atmospheric pressure ($p_{g2} = 0$). Mass flow rate is $\dot{m} = \rho A_1 v_1$.
The pipe is anchored to a central mounting hub at the origin $\vec{x}_0 = (0,0,0)$. Determine the holding torque $\vec{\mathcal{M}}_0 = \mathcal{M}_z \hat{k}$ that the support must exert to prevent the elbow from spinning.
Compute the convective angular momentum cross-products about $\vec{x}_0 = \vec{0}$:
- Inlet flux: Position $\vec{r}_1 = -L_1 \hat{j}$, velocity $\vec{v}_1 = v_1 \hat{j}$. $$\vec{r}_1 \times \vec{v}_1 = (-L_1 \hat{j}) \times (v_1 \hat{j}) = \vec{0} \qquad (\text{parallel vectors!})$$
- Outlet flux: Position $\vec{r}_2 = L_2 \hat{i}$, velocity $\vec{v}_2 = v_2 \hat{i}$. $$\vec{r}_2 \times \vec{v}_2 = (L_2 \hat{i}) \times (v_2 \hat{i}) = \vec{0} \qquad (\text{parallel vectors!})$$
Thus, in this symmetric offset orientation, the convective angular momentum flux is zero! What creates the torque?
Evaluate moments of surface gauge pressure forces:
- Inlet pressure force: Pushes inward ($+y$): $\vec{F}_{p1} = p_{g1} A_1 \hat{j}$. $$\vec{r}_1 \times \vec{F}_{p1} = (-L_1 \hat{j}) \times (p_{g1} A_1 \hat{j}) = \vec{0}$$
- Outlet pressure force: Zero because $p_{g2} = 0$ (atmospheric).
General Offset Case: Now suppose the exit is offset by a moment arm $d$ from the $x$-axis, so $\vec{r}_2 = L_2 \hat{i} + d \hat{j}$.
Then $\vec{r}_2 \times \vec{v}_2 = (L_2 \hat{i} + d \hat{j}) \times (v_2 \hat{i}) = -d v_2 \hat{k}$.
The angular momentum balance yields:
The anchor must apply a clockwise holding torque of magnitude $\dot{m} d v_2$ to resist the jet's reaction moment!
Euler's Turbomachinery Equation (Rotor Shaft Power)
Problem: A centrifugal compressor or pump rotor rotates at steady angular velocity $\vec{\Omega} = \Omega \hat{e}_z$. Fluid of density $\rho$ enters at inner radius $r_1$ with mass flow rate $\dot{m}$ and tangential velocity component $v_{\theta 1}$, and exits at outer radius $r_2$ with tangential velocity component $v_{\theta 2}$. Determine the torque $M_z$ and shaft power $\dot{W}_{\text{shaft}}$ transmitted from the impeller to the fluid.
Select a fixed cylindrical control volume enclosing the rotating impeller. In cylindrical coordinates $(r, \theta, z)$, position vectors from the axis are $\vec{r}_1 = r_1 \hat{e}_r$ and $\vec{r}_2 = r_2 \hat{e}_r$.
The cross product of radius with velocity $\vec{v} = v_r \hat{e}_r + v_\theta \hat{e}_\theta + v_z \hat{e}_z$ isolates the tangential velocity component:
Projecting onto the axis of rotation $z$, the angular momentum per unit mass is simply $r v_\theta$.
For steady flow, the net torque $M_z$ exerted by the rotor blades on the fluid equals the net outflow of angular momentum:
Multiplying torque by rotor angular speed $\Omega$ gives the shaft mechanical power $\dot{W}_{\text{shaft}}$ delivered to the fluid:
Defining blade peripheral speeds $u_1 = \Omega r_1$ and $u_2 = \Omega r_2$, we obtain the celebrated Euler Turbomachinery Equation:
- Pumps, Fans, and Compressors ($w_{\text{Euler}} > 0$): The impeller increases the fluid's whirl ($u_2 v_{\theta 2} > u_1 v_{\theta 1}$). Mechanical shaft work is consumed to raise fluid pressure and stagnation enthalpy.
- Turbines ($w_{\text{Euler}} < 0$): The fluid enters with high swirl created by stationary guide vanes/nozzles and leaves with reduced tangential velocity ($u_2 v_{\theta 2} < u_1 v_{\theta 1}$). Fluid delivers mechanical shaft work to drive aircraft generators or compressor spools!