Official Problem Statement
We want to estimate the driving power $W$ necessary to move at a peak velocity $V = 10$ m/s a marine freighter of length $l = 100$ m and total mass at full load $m = 1000$ Tm. For that purpose, a small model of length $l_e = 1$ m, geometrically similar to the real ship, is to be tested on a hydraulic channel. To guide the design of the experiment, follow these steps:
1. Use the dimensional analysis to reduce the parametric dependence of the required power $W$.
2. Write the three equations that need to be satisfied to guarantee physical similarity between the experiment and the full-scale prototype. Verify that it is not possible to find the values of the mass $m_e$ and velocity $V_e$ of the experiment that satisfy simultaneously all three equations, so that complete physical similarity cannot be attained.
3. Assuming that the effect of viscosity on the fluid motion is negligible, determine the values of $m_e$ and $V_e$. Check that the corresponding values of the Reynolds number for both the real prototype and the experiment are indeed sufficiently large for the assumption of negligible viscosity to be a reasonable approximation.
4. If the experimental measurement of the power obtained with the experimental model is $W_e = 10$ W, obtain the value of the driving power $W$ needed to operate the real prototype at the required conditions.
Source: DA1.pdf (page 1, statement and handwritten key). Notes.pdf, Chapter 6: Π theorem, Eq. 6.25; physical similarity, Eqs. 6.57-6.59.
Worked solutionexpand / collapse
Hypotheses, Data and Dimensional Table
- The ship moves at constant velocity on the free surface of water, which is the same liquid in the channel and in the sea: $\rho_e = \rho$, $\mu_e = \mu$, so $\nu_e = \nu = \mu/\rho \simeq 10^{-6}$ m$^2$/s.
- The power goes into the waves made at the free surface (gravity $g$ matters, since the free surface is not flat; Notes.pdf, p. 66) and into the viscous drag ($\mu$ matters, a priori).
- The mass $m$ fixes how deep the hull floats: by Archimedes, the submerged volume is $m/\rho$.
- "Tm" is the metric ton: $m = 1000\ \text{t} = 10^6$ kg.
| Parameter | Meaning | Dimensions | Value (prototype) |
|---|---|---|---|
| $W$ | driving power (unknown) | $ML^2T^{-3}$ | ? |
| $V$ | ship velocity | $LT^{-1}$ | 10 m/s |
| $g$ | gravity | $LT^{-2}$ | 9.81 m/s$^2$ |
| $m$ | mass at full load | $M$ | $10^6$ kg |
| $l$ | ship length | $L$ | 100 m |
| $\rho$ | water density | $ML^{-3}$ | 1000 kg/m$^3$ |
| $\mu$ | water viscosity | $ML^{-1}T^{-1}$ | $10^{-3}$ kg/(m s) |
Application of the Π Theorem
There are $n = 6$ governing parameters. Exponent matrix, rows $V$, $l$, $\rho$; columns $L$, $M$, $T$:
so $(V, l, \rho)$ have independent dimensions and $k = 3$: there are $n - k = 3$ dimensionless parameters. $(V, l, \rho)$ is chosen because velocity, size and the inertia of the water clearly matter (Notes.pdf, p. 68).
Power. $[W] = [\rho]^a[V]^b[l]^c$:
so $a = 1$, $b = 3$ and $c = 2 + 3 - 3 = 2$: $\Pi_0 = W/(\rho V^3 l^2)$.
Gravity. $[g] = [V]^b[l]^c$ (no mass, so no $\rho$): $T:\; -2 = -b$, $L:\; 1 = b + c$, so $b = 2$, $c = -1$ and $g/(V^2/l)$ is dimensionless; its inverse is the square of the Froude number, $V^2/(gl)$.
Mass. $[m] = [\rho]^a[V]^b[l]^c$: $M:\; 1 = a$, $T:\; 0 = -b$, $L:\; 0 = -3a + b + c$, so $a = 1$, $b = 0$, $c = 3$: $m/(\rho l^3)$.
Viscosity. $[\mu] = [\rho]^a[V]^b[l]^c$: $M:\; 1 = a$, $T:\; -1 = -b$, $L:\; -1 = -3a + b + c$, so $a = 1$, $b = 1$, $c = 1$: $\mu/(\rho V l)$, the inverse of the Reynolds number.
- $V^2/(gl)$ (Froude number squared): inertia against gravity, that is the waves at the free surface.
- $m/(\rho l^3)$: by Archimedes $m/\rho$ is the submerged volume, so this group is proportional to the ratio of the submerged volume to the total volume of the ship.
- $\rho V l/\mu$: the Reynolds number.
Physical Similarity
Model (subscript $e$) and prototype are physically similar when the three governing groups are equal. With the same liquid and the same $g$:
The third equation fixes $m_e$. The first two ask for two different velocities: with $l_e/l = 10^{-2}$, Froude asks for $V_e = 10^{-1}V$ and Reynolds for $V_e = 10^{2}V$. Both hold only if $(l_e/l)^{1/2} = l/l_e$, that is $(l_e/l)^{3/2} = 1$, $l_e = l$: with the same liquid, no scaled model can be fully similar (Notes.pdf, p. 71: partial similarity).
Negligible Viscosity
If viscosity has a negligible effect ($\mathrm{Re}\gg 1$), the group $\rho V l/\mu$ drops out of the law (Notes.pdf, Eq. 6.55):
and only the Froude and mass conditions remain:
Check of the assumption, with $\nu = 10^{-6}$ m$^2$/s:
Both are very large, so neglecting viscosity is reasonable in the model and in the ship, even though the two Reynolds numbers differ by a factor $10^3$.
Power of the Prototype
With the two remaining groups equal, $\Pi_0$ is equal too (Notes.pdf, Eq. 6.58):
Answers and Checks
- Reduced law: $W/(\rho V^3 l^2) = f\left(V^2/(gl),\, m/(\rho l^3),\, \rho V l/\mu\right)$.
- Full similarity needs $V_e = (l_e/l)^{1/2}V$ and $V_e = (l/l_e)V$ at once: impossible for $l_e \neq l$.
- With negligible viscosity: $V_e = 1$ m/s, $m_e = 1$ kg; $\mathrm{Re} = 10^9$, $\mathrm{Re}_e = 10^6$.
- Prototype power: $W = 100$ MW.
- Dimensions: $\rho V^3 l^2$ has $ML^{-3}\cdot L^3T^{-3}\cdot L^2 = ML^2T^{-3}$, a power.
- Scaling check: under Froude similarity $V \propto l^{1/2}$, so $W \propto V^3 l^2 \propto l^{7/2}$, and $100^{7/2} = 10^7$ times 10 W is $10^8$ W, the same.
- Check against the official key: DA1.pdf gives $V_e = 1$ m/s, $m_e = 1$ kg, $\mathrm{Re}\simeq 10^9$, $\mathrm{Re}_e = 10^6$ and $W = 100$ MW, the same results.
