1st Midterm: Exam-Style Problems
16 exam-style problems on Units 1 to 5, written for this portal. The Midterm 1 papers of 2011 to 2024 are one problem of 10 points with 5 to 7 parts; the Exam simulator draws one of these and times it.
P01 — Bead on a vertical helical wire: Frenet triad, constant angular acceleration and the reaction
A rigid wire has the shape of a circular helix of radius $R$ wound around the vertical axis $Oz$ of the inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ ($z$ upward, uniform gravity $-g\,\mathbf k$). In cylindrical coordinates $(\rho,\varphi,z)$, with $\varphi$ measured from the $x$ axis and counter-clockwise seen from above, the wire is
so it rises a height $2\pi b$ (the pitch) per turn. A bead $P$ of mass $m$ slides without friction along the wire. At $t=0$ it is released from rest at $\varphi=\varphi_0$.
Use the cylindrical basis $\{\mathbf e_\rho,\mathbf e_\varphi,\mathbf k\}$ with $\mathbf e_\rho=\cos\varphi\,\mathbf i+\sin\varphi\,\mathbf j$, $\mathbf e_\varphi=-\sin\varphi\,\mathbf i+\cos\varphi\,\mathbf j$, and the intrinsic (Frenet) triad $\{\mathbf t,\mathbf n,\mathbf b\}$ of the helix, with $\mathbf t$ oriented towards increasing $\varphi$. Write $h=\sqrt{R^2+b^2}$.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $R$, $b$, $g$, $\varphi_0$. In the numerical part (f): $R=0.30$ m, $b=0.40$ m (so $h=0.50$ m), $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$.
- Hypotheses: point particle, rigid fixed wire, no friction (the reaction has no component along $\mathbf t$), $S_0$ inertial.
- The bead is threaded on the wire, so the constraint is bilateral: the reaction may point either way in the normal plane.
- Notation: the scalar $b$ is the pitch parameter of the helix ($z=b\varphi$); the bold $\mathbf b$ is the binormal unit vector. They are unrelated.
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Degrees of freedom and kinematics
How many degrees of freedom has $P$? Classify the constraints. Write the position, velocity and acceleration of $P$ in the cylindrical basis as functions of $\varphi$, $\dot\varphi$, $\ddot\varphi$.
Step 1. Count
The configuration of a free particle needs 3 coordinates $(\rho,\varphi,z)$. The wire imposes $f_1=\rho-R=0$ and $f_2=z-b\varphi=0$: two independent holonomic equations (positions only), with no explicit time (scleronomic), and two-sided (bilateral). Hence $3-2=1$ degree of freedom (Notes §2.7), and $\varphi$ is a convenient coordinate: $\rho$ and $z$ follow from it.
Step 2. Change of basis
The cylindrical basis turns with $\varphi$; its relation to the inertial basis is
Checks: rows 1 and 2 have length $\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi=1$ and $-\cos\varphi\sin\varphi+\sin\varphi\cos\varphi=0$, row 3 is $\mathbf k$, so $[R][R]^T=I$; $\det[R]=\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi=+1$ (right-handed, $\mathbf e_\rho\times\mathbf e_\varphi=\mathbf k$). Differentiating the rows with the chain rule, $\dfrac{d\mathbf e_\rho}{d\varphi}=\mathbf e_\varphi$ and $\dfrac{d\mathbf e_\varphi}{d\varphi}=-\mathbf e_\rho$.
Step 3. Position and velocity
$\mathbf r=\rho\,\mathbf e_\rho+z\,\mathbf k=R\,\mathbf e_\rho+b\varphi\,\mathbf k$. The cylindrical velocity (Notes §2.6.2) is $\mathbf v=\dot\rho\,\mathbf e_\rho+\rho\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi+\dot z\,\mathbf k$. Here $\dot\rho=0$ and, by the chain rule, $\dot z=\dfrac{dz}{d\varphi}\dot\varphi=b\dot\varphi$:
Step 4. Acceleration
The cylindrical acceleration is $\mathbf a=(\ddot\rho-\rho\dot\varphi^2)\mathbf e_\rho+(\rho\ddot\varphi+2\dot\rho\dot\varphi)\mathbf e_\varphi+\ddot z\,\mathbf k$. With $\rho=R$, $\dot\rho=\ddot\rho=0$ and $\ddot z=\dfrac{d}{dt}(b\dot\varphi)=b\ddot\varphi$:
Check by direct differentiation of $\mathbf v$ with $\dot{\mathbf e}_\varphi=-\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\rho$: $\dot{\mathbf v}=R\ddot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi+R\dot\varphi(-\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\rho)+b\ddot\varphi\,\mathbf k$, the same result.
- 1 degree of freedom, coordinate $\varphi$; two holonomic, scleronomic, bilateral constraints $\rho-R=0$, $z-b\varphi=0$.
- $\mathbf v=R\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi+b\dot\varphi\,\mathbf k$, $\ |\mathbf v|=h\,|\dot\varphi|$.
- $\mathbf a=-R\dot\varphi^2\,\mathbf e_\rho+R\ddot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi+b\ddot\varphi\,\mathbf k$.
Part (b) · 2 points
Intrinsic triad, curvature and torsion
Obtain the unit vectors $\mathbf t$, $\mathbf n$, $\mathbf b$ of the helix in the cylindrical basis, its curvature $\kappa$ and torsion $\tau$, and the intrinsic components of the acceleration of $P$.
Step 1. Arc length and tangent
$ds=|\mathbf v|\,dt=h\,d\varphi$ (taking $s$ increasing with $\varphi$), so $s=h(\varphi-\varphi_0)$ and $\dot s=h\dot\varphi$. The unit tangent (Notes §2.4) is
using $\dfrac{d\mathbf e_\rho}{d\varphi}=\mathbf e_\varphi$.
Step 2. Curvature and normal
With $\dfrac{d\mathbf e_\varphi}{d\varphi}=-\mathbf e_\rho$ and $\mathbf k$ constant:
The modulus is the curvature and the unit vector the principal normal: $\kappa=R/h^2=R/(R^2+b^2)$, $\mathbf n=-\mathbf e_\rho$. The normal is horizontal and points to the axis, although the helix is inclined.
Step 3. Binormal and torsion
$\mathbf b=\mathbf t\times\mathbf n=\dfrac1h(R\,\mathbf e_\varphi+b\,\mathbf k)\times(-\mathbf e_\rho)$. With $\mathbf e_\varphi\times\mathbf e_\rho=-\mathbf k$ and $\mathbf k\times\mathbf e_\rho=\mathbf e_\varphi$:
Then $\dfrac{d\mathbf b}{ds}=\dfrac1h\cdot\dfrac{-b}{h}\dfrac{d\mathbf e_\varphi}{d\varphi}=\dfrac{b}{h^2}\,\mathbf e_\rho=-\dfrac{b}{h^2}\,\mathbf n$, so $\tau=b/h^2=b/(R^2+b^2)$. In matrix form the triad is $(\mathbf t,\mathbf n,\mathbf b)^T=[Q]\,(\mathbf e_\rho,\mathbf e_\varphi,\mathbf k)^T$ with rows $(0,\ R/h,\ b/h)$, $(-1,\ 0,\ 0)$, $(0,\ -b/h,\ R/h)$: the rows are unit and mutually orthogonal ($R^2/h^2+b^2/h^2=1$, $-bR/h^2+bR/h^2=0$), so $[Q][Q]^T=I$, and expanding along the second row $\det[Q]=-(-1)\big(\tfrac Rh\tfrac Rh+\tfrac bh\tfrac bh\big)=+1$: $\{\mathbf t,\mathbf n,\mathbf b\}$ is right-handed. The third Frenet formula $\dfrac{d\mathbf n}{ds}=-\kappa\,\mathbf t+\tau\,\mathbf b$ checks: $\dfrac1h\dfrac{d(-\mathbf e_\rho)}{d\varphi}=-\dfrac{\mathbf e_\varphi}{h}$ and $-\dfrac{R}{h^3}(R\mathbf e_\varphi+b\mathbf k)+\dfrac{b}{h^3}(R\mathbf k-b\mathbf e_\varphi)=-\dfrac{R^2+b^2}{h^3}\mathbf e_\varphi=-\dfrac{\mathbf e_\varphi}{h}$.
Step 4. Intrinsic acceleration
The intrinsic acceleration (Notes §2.5) is $\mathbf a=\ddot s\,\mathbf t+\kappa\dot s^2\,\mathbf n$. With $\dot s=h\dot\varphi$, $\ddot s=h\ddot\varphi$ and $\kappa\dot s^2=\dfrac{R}{h^2}h^2\dot\varphi^2$:
Cross-check with (a): $\mathbf a\cdot\mathbf t=\dfrac1h(R\cdot R\ddot\varphi+b\cdot b\ddot\varphi)=h\ddot\varphi$, $\ \mathbf a\cdot\mathbf n=R\dot\varphi^2$, $\ \mathbf a\cdot\mathbf b=\dfrac1h(-bR\ddot\varphi+Rb\ddot\varphi)=0$.
- $\mathbf t=\dfrac{R\,\mathbf e_\varphi+b\,\mathbf k}{h}$, $\ \mathbf n=-\mathbf e_\rho$ (horizontal, towards the axis), $\ \mathbf b=\dfrac{-b\,\mathbf e_\varphi+R\,\mathbf k}{h}$.
- $\kappa=\dfrac{R}{R^2+b^2}$, $\ \tau=\dfrac{b}{R^2+b^2}$.
- $\mathbf a=h\ddot\varphi\,\mathbf t+R\dot\varphi^2\,\mathbf n$, no binormal component.
Part (c) · 1 point
Forces on the bead
Write the weight and the reaction of the wire in the intrinsic basis. How many unknowns does the problem have?
Step 1. Weight
$\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf t=b/h$, $\ \mathbf k\cdot\mathbf n=-\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf e_\rho=0$, $\ \mathbf k\cdot\mathbf b=R/h$. Hence
The weight has no component along $\mathbf n$, because $\mathbf n$ is horizontal.
Step 2. Reaction
The wire is smooth: its reaction is orthogonal to the tangent, i.e. it lies in the normal plane spanned by $\mathbf n$ and $\mathbf b$ (Notes §6.5):
The three scalar equations of Newton's law will determine the three unknowns $\varphi(t)$, $N_n$, $N_b$.
- $\mathbf k=\dfrac{b}{h}\mathbf t+\dfrac{R}{h}\mathbf b$, so $\mathbf W=-mg\dfrac bh\,\mathbf t-mg\dfrac Rh\,\mathbf b$.
- $\mathbf N=N_n\,\mathbf n+N_b\,\mathbf b$; unknowns $\varphi(t)$, $N_n$, $N_b$.
Part (d) · 2 points
Equation of motion and reaction
Obtain the equation of motion free of reactions and integrate it. Obtain $N_n$ and $N_b$ as functions of $\dot\varphi$. Does the bead move like a pendulum?
Step 1. Projections
With $\mathbf a$ of (b) and the forces of (c):
Step 2. Equation of motion
The tangential equation contains no reaction:
The right-hand side does not depend on $\varphi$: there is no restoring term and no equilibrium. The tangential acceleration is $\ddot s=h\ddot\varphi=-g\,\dfrac bh=-g\sin\alpha$, with $\alpha$ the constant inclination of the helix ($\sin\alpha=b/h$): the bead moves exactly as on an inclined plane wound around a cylinder. It is not a pendulum.
Step 3. Integration
Integrating once between $0$ and $t$ (Barrow's rule, $\dot\varphi(0)=0$): $\dot\varphi(t)-\dot\varphi(0)=\displaystyle\int_0^t\ddot\varphi\,dt'=-\frac{gb}{h^2}\,[t']_0^t$, so $\dot\varphi=-\dfrac{gb}{h^2}t$. Integrating again with $\varphi(0)=\varphi_0$:
The bead descends ($\varphi$ and $z=b\varphi$ decrease).
Step 4. Reactions
$N_b$ supports the part of the weight normal to the wire and is constant; $N_n$ (pointing to the axis) supplies the centripetal force of the horizontal circular motion and grows with the speed.
- $\ddot\varphi=-\dfrac{gb}{R^2+b^2}$: constant. $\ \varphi(t)=\varphi_0-\dfrac{gb}{2h^2}t^2$.
- $N_n=mR\dot\varphi^2$, $\ N_b=\dfrac{mgR}{h}$ (constant).
Part (e) · 1.5 points
First integral
Show that the mechanical energy is conserved and use it to write $\dot\varphi^2$ and $N_n$ as functions of $\varphi$.
Step 1. Power of the forces
$\mathbf v=h\dot\varphi\,\mathbf t$ and $\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf t=0$, so $\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf v=0$: the reaction of a fixed smooth curve does no work (Notes §6.4). The weight is conservative with $V=mgz=mgb\varphi$. Hence (Notes §4.5)
Step 2. Same result from the equation of motion
Multiply $h^2\ddot\varphi=-gb$ by $\dot\varphi$: $h^2\dot\varphi\ddot\varphi=\dfrac{d}{dt}\Big(\tfrac12h^2\dot\varphi^2\Big)$ (chain rule) and $-gb\dot\varphi=\dfrac{d}{dt}(-gb\varphi)$. Integrating from $0$ to $t$ with Barrow's rule: $\tfrac12h^2\dot\varphi^2-0=-gb(\varphi-\varphi_0)$.
Step 3. Speed and reaction along the wire
With $\kappa=R/h^2$ and the height fallen $\Delta z=b(\varphi_0-\varphi)$: $N_n=2mg\kappa\,\Delta z$, i.e. $N_n=m\kappa v^2$ with $v^2=2g\Delta z$.
- $E=\tfrac12mh^2\dot\varphi^2+mgb\varphi=mgb\varphi_0$.
- $\dot\varphi^2=\dfrac{2gb(\varphi_0-\varphi)}{h^2}$, $\ N_n=\dfrac{2mgRb(\varphi_0-\varphi)}{h^2}=2mg\,\kappa\,\Delta z$ with $\Delta z=b(\varphi_0-\varphi)$.
Part (f) · 2 points
One full turn: time, speed and reaction
Find the time $t_1$ the bead needs to complete one turn and its speed then. For $R=0.30$ m, $b=0.40$ m, $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$ give $\kappa$, $\tau$, $\ddot\varphi$, $t_1$, the speed and the reaction (in units of $mg$) at $t_1$. Is the acceleration vector of the bead constant?
Step 1. Time for one turn
From $\varphi(t_1)=\varphi_0-2\pi$: $\dfrac{gb}{2h^2}t_1^2=2\pi\Rightarrow t_1=\sqrt{\dfrac{4\pi h^2}{gb}}=2h\sqrt{\dfrac{\pi}{gb}}$.
Step 2. Speed after one turn
From (e) with $\varphi_0-\varphi=2\pi$: $\dot\varphi_1^2=\dfrac{4\pi gb}{h^2}$ and $v_1=h|\dot\varphi_1|=\sqrt{4\pi gb}$. Equivalently $v_1=h|\dot\varphi(t_1)|=h\dfrac{gb}{h^2}t_1=\dfrac{gb}{h}\cdot2h\sqrt{\dfrac{\pi}{gb}}=\sqrt{4\pi gb}$. Since the fall per turn is $2\pi b$, $v_1=\sqrt{2g\cdot2\pi b}$: the speed depends only on the height fallen, not on $R$.
Step 3. Numbers
$h=\sqrt{0.09+0.16}=0.5$ m; $\kappa=0.3/0.25=1.2$ m$^{-1}$; $\tau=0.4/0.25=1.6$ m$^{-1}$; $\ddot\varphi=-9.81\cdot0.4/0.25=-15.696$ rad s$^{-2}$, $\ddot s=h\ddot\varphi=-7.848$ m s$^{-2}$ ($\sin\alpha=0.8$, $\alpha=53.13^\circ$).
Step 4. Reaction after one turn
$|\mathbf N|=mg\sqrt{6.032^2+0.6^2}\approx6.062\,mg$. The tangential acceleration is constant, but $\mathbf a=h\ddot\varphi\,\mathbf t+R\dot\varphi^2\,\mathbf n$ has a growing normal part and a direction that turns with the triad: the acceleration vector is not constant.
- $t_1=2h\sqrt{\dfrac{\pi}{gb}}$, $\ v_1=\sqrt{4\pi gb}=\sqrt{2g\,(2\pi b)}$ (independent of $R$).
- $\kappa=1.2$ m$^{-1}$, $\tau=1.6$ m$^{-1}$, $\ddot\varphi=-15.70$ rad s$^{-2}$, $\ddot s=-7.848$ m s$^{-2}$, $t_1=0.8948$ s, $v_1=7.022$ m/s, $|\dot\varphi_1|=14.04$ rad/s.
- $N_n=1.92\pi\,mg\approx6.032\,mg$, $N_b=0.6\,mg$, $|\mathbf N|\approx6.062\,mg$. The acceleration is not constant: its normal part $R\dot\varphi^2$ grows.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $\kappa$ and $\tau$ are m/m$^2$ = m$^{-1}$; $gb/h^2$ is (m s$^{-2}$)(m)/m$^2$ = s$^{-2}$, an angular acceleration; $t_1=2h\sqrt{\pi/(gb)}$ has m/$\sqrt{\text{m}^2\,\text{s}^{-2}}$ = s; $N=mR\dot\varphi^2$ is kg m s$^{-2}$ = N.
- Limits: $b\to0$ (horizontal ring): $\ddot\varphi\to0$, the bead stays at rest and $N_b\to mg$ carries the whole weight. $R\to0$ (vertical straight wire): $\ddot z=b\ddot\varphi=-g\,b^2/h^2\to-g$ (free fall), $\kappa\to0$ and the reaction vanishes. $\kappa$ is largest for $b\to0$ and $\tau$ is largest for $b=R$.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) expecting a pendulum-type equation: on a helix the gravity component along the wire is the same everywhere, so $\ddot\varphi$ is constant; (2) taking $\mathbf n$ along the "radius of the coil" tilted with the helix: it is exactly $-\mathbf e_\rho$, horizontal; (3) forgetting $N_b$, which exists even at rest; (4) concluding that the acceleration is constant because $\ddot\varphi$ is: the normal acceleration $R\dot\varphi^2$ grows linearly with the height fallen.
P02 — Particle on a smooth paraboloid of revolution: axial angular momentum, circular orbits and radial oscillations
A particle $P$ of mass $m$ moves on the inner face of a smooth, fixed paraboloid of revolution whose axis $Oz$ is vertical (upward; uniform gravity $-g\,\mathbf k$). In cylindrical coordinates $(r,\varphi,z)$ of the inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ the surface is
with $O$ at its vertex. The particle rests on the surface from above (the contact can only push $P$ away from the surface, towards the inside of the bowl). The azimuth $\varphi$ is measured from the $x$ axis, counter-clockwise seen from above.
Use the cylindrical basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\varphi,\mathbf k\}$, and write $q=\sqrt{1+r^2/c^2}$ and $\Omega_0=\sqrt{g/c}$.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $c$, $g$. In part (f): initial radius $r_0=c/2$, $\dot r(0)=0$, initial velocity horizontal and tangent to the parallel with speed $v_0=2r_0\Omega_0=c\,\Omega_0$; for numbers, $c=1$ m and $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$.
- Hypotheses: point particle, no friction, $S_0$ inertial. The contact is unilateral: the model is valid while the normal reaction is non-negative (checked in (f)).
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Degrees of freedom and kinematics
How many degrees of freedom has $P$ while it stays on the surface? Write its velocity and acceleration in the cylindrical basis using the constraint.
Step 1. Count
A free particle needs $(r,\varphi,z)$. The surface $f=z-r^2/(2c)=0$ is one holonomic equation without explicit time: $3-1=2$ degrees of freedom (Notes §2.7), with generalized coordinates $r$ and $\varphi$. The constraint is unilateral, because the particle is only pressed against the surface.
Step 2. Derivatives of $z$
By the chain rule, $\dot z=\dfrac{dz}{dr}\dot r=\dfrac{r\dot r}{c}$. By the product rule, $\ddot z=\dfrac1c\dfrac{d}{dt}(r\dot r)=\dfrac{\dot r\,\dot r+r\ddot r}{c}=\dfrac{\dot r^2+r\ddot r}{c}$.
Step 3. Change of basis
The cylindrical basis turns with $\varphi$; its relation to the inertial basis is
Checks: rows 1 and 2 have length $\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi=1$ and $-\cos\varphi\sin\varphi+\sin\varphi\cos\varphi=0$, row 3 is $\mathbf k$, so $[R][R]^T=I$; $\det[R]=\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi=+1$ (right-handed, $\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\varphi=\mathbf k$). By the chain rule, $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$ and $\dot{\mathbf e}_\varphi=-\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_r$.
Step 4. Velocity and acceleration
In cylindrical coordinates (Notes §2.6.2), $\mathbf v=\dot r\,\mathbf e_r+r\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi+\dot z\,\mathbf k$ and $\mathbf a=(\ddot r-r\dot\varphi^2)\mathbf e_r+(r\ddot\varphi+2\dot r\dot\varphi)\mathbf e_\varphi+\ddot z\,\mathbf k$. With Step 2:
- 2 degrees of freedom, coordinates $(r,\varphi)$; one holonomic, scleronomic, unilateral constraint.
- $\dot z=r\dot r/c$, $\ \ddot z=(\dot r^2+r\ddot r)/c$.
- $\mathbf a=(\ddot r-r\dot\varphi^2)\mathbf e_r+(2\dot r\dot\varphi+r\ddot\varphi)\mathbf e_\varphi+\dfrac{\dot r^2+r\ddot r}{c}\mathbf k$.
Part (b) · 1 point
Forces
Obtain the unit normal of the surface and write the forces on $P$.
Step 1. Normal vector
$\nabla f=\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial r}\mathbf e_r+\dfrac1r\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial\varphi}\mathbf e_\varphi+\dfrac{\partial f}{\partial z}\mathbf k=-\dfrac rc\,\mathbf e_r+\mathbf k$, of modulus $\sqrt{1+r^2/c^2}=q$ (Notes §6.3). Its $\mathbf k$ component is positive, so it points into the bowl, the side on which the particle lies:
Check: $\mathbf n\cdot\mathbf v=\dfrac1q\Big(-\dfrac{r\dot r}{c}+\dfrac{r\dot r}{c}\Big)=0$.
Step 2. Forces
The weight $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf k$ and the smooth normal reaction $\mathbf N=N\,\mathbf n$ (Notes §6.4). Contact requires $N\ge0$. Note that $\mathbf N$ lies in the meridian plane (it has no $\mathbf e_\varphi$ component) but does not pass through $O$ in general.
- $\mathbf n=\dfrac{-(r/c)\,\mathbf e_r+\mathbf k}{q}$ (towards the inside of the bowl).
- $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf k$, $\ \mathbf N=N\mathbf n$ with $N\ge0$ for contact.
Part (c) · 2 points
Equations of motion and first integrals
Project Newton's law, show that the component $H=r^2\dot\varphi$ of the specific angular momentum along the axis is conserved, write the energy and obtain one equation for $r(t)$ free of $N$. Give $N$ as a function of the state.
Step 1. Projections
With $\mathbf a$ of (a), $\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf e_r=-Nr/(cq)$, $\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf k=N/q$:
Step 2. Axial angular momentum
By the product rule, $\dfrac{d}{dt}(r^2\dot\varphi)=2r\dot r\dot\varphi+r^2\ddot\varphi=r(2\dot r\dot\varphi+r\ddot\varphi)$, so the $\mathbf e_\varphi$ equation is $\dfrac mr\dfrac{d}{dt}(r^2\dot\varphi)=0$: $H=r^2\dot\varphi$ is constant. Physical reason (Notes §4.8): $\mathbf k\cdot(\mathbf r\times\mathbf F)$ is the moment about the $z$ axis; $\mathbf W$ is parallel to the axis and $\mathbf N$ lies in the meridian plane, which contains the axis, so both have zero moment about it. The full vector $\mathbf H_O$ is not conserved ($\mathbf r\times\mathbf N\neq\mathbf 0$ in general): only its axial component is.
Step 3. Equation for $r$
From $\mathbf k$: $\dfrac Nq=m\Big(\dfrac{\dot r^2+r\ddot r}{c}+g\Big)$. Substituting in $\mathbf e_r$ (which contains $\dfrac{r}{c}\cdot\dfrac Nq$) and using $\dot\varphi=H/r^2$:
Step 4. Energy
$\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf v=0$ (fixed smooth surface) and $\mathbf W$ derives from $V=mgz=mgr^2/(2c)$, so $E=\tfrac12m|\mathbf v|^2+V$ is constant (Notes §4.5). With $|\mathbf v|^2$ of (a) and $r\dot\varphi=H/r$:
Check: $\dfrac{d}{dt}\dfrac Em=\dot r\Big[\Big(1+\dfrac{r^2}{c^2}\Big)\ddot r+\dfrac{r\dot r^2}{c^2}-\dfrac{H^2}{r^3}+\dfrac{gr}{c}\Big]=0$ by Step 3 (the term $\dfrac{r\dot r^3}{c^2}$ comes from the chain rule on $\dfrac{r^2}{c^2}\dot r^2$).
Step 5. Reaction
$N=mq\Big(\dfrac{\dot r^2+r\ddot r}{c}+g\Big)$, with $\ddot r$ from Step 3.
- $H=r^2\dot\varphi=$ const (the moment about the axis of $\mathbf W$ and $\mathbf N$ is zero; $\mathbf H_O$ itself is not conserved).
- $\Big(1+\dfrac{r^2}{c^2}\Big)\ddot r+\dfrac{r\dot r^2}{c^2}-\dfrac{H^2}{r^3}+\dfrac{gr}{c}=0$.
- $\dfrac Em=\tfrac12\Big[\Big(1+\dfrac{r^2}{c^2}\Big)\dot r^2+\dfrac{H^2}{r^2}\Big]+\dfrac{gr^2}{2c}$; $\ N=mq\Big(\dfrac{\dot r^2+r\ddot r}{c}+g\Big)$.
Part (d) · 1.5 points
Horizontal circular orbits
Find the angular rate of a horizontal circular motion at radius $r_0$, its speed and the normal reaction. Discuss the dependence on $r_0$.
Step 1. Rate
With $\dot r=\ddot r=0$ and $H=r_0^2\dot\varphi$: $\dfrac{H^2}{r_0^3}=r_0\dot\varphi^2=\dfrac{gr_0}{c}$, hence
All horizontal circles are described in the same time, whatever their radius (isochronous orbits). This is the trap of the item: on a cone or on a sphere the rate depends on the radius; on the paraboloid the slope $dz/dr=r/c$ grows exactly in proportion to the centripetal acceleration $r\Omega^2$ needed.
Step 2. Reaction
$N=mq_0(0+g)=mg\sqrt{1+r_0^2/c^2}$. Its vertical component $N/q_0=mg$ carries the weight; its horizontal component $Nr_0/(cq_0)=mgr_0/c=mr_0\Omega_0^2$ is the centripetal force.
- $\dot\varphi^2=g/c$: $\Omega_0=\sqrt{g/c}$, the same for every $r_0$; period $2\pi\sqrt{c/g}$; speed $r_0\Omega_0$.
- $N=mg\sqrt{1+r_0^2/c^2}$.
Part (e) · 2 points
Small radial oscillations about a circular orbit
Perturb the circular orbit of radius $r_0$ keeping $H=r_0^2\Omega_0$. Obtain the frequency $\omega_r$ of the small radial oscillations and the ratio $\omega_r/\Omega_0$. For which $r_0$ is the perturbed orbit closed after one revolution? What happens for $r_0\to0$ and $r_0=c$?
Step 1. Linearisation
$G(r,\dot r)=\dfrac{F(r)-r\dot r^2/c^2}{1+r^2/c^2}$ with $F(r)=\dfrac{H^2}{r^3}-\dfrac{gr}{c}$, and $F(r_0)=0$ by (d). Put $r=r_0+\varepsilon$ with $\varepsilon$, $\dot\varepsilon$ small. $\partial G/\partial\dot r=-2r\dot r/(c^2q^2)$ vanishes at $\dot r=0$. Since $F(r_0)=0$, $\dfrac{\partial G}{\partial r}\Big|_{r_0}=\dfrac{F'(r_0)}{1+r_0^2/c^2}$ (the derivative of the denominator multiplies $F(r_0)=0$). With $F'(r)=-\dfrac{3H^2}{r^4}-\dfrac gc$ and $H^2=r_0^4\,g/c$:
Step 2. Frequency and ratio
The orbit is stable (positive $\omega_r^2$) for every $r_0$. The trap: the radial frequency is not $\Omega_0$, and the factor $1+r_0^2/c^2$ (the inertia of the vertical motion that comes with $\dot r$) cannot be dropped.
Step 3. Special radii
- $r_0\to0$: ratio $2$: two radial oscillations per revolution, a centred ellipse, as for an isotropic harmonic bowl ($z\approx r^2/(2c)$ is then the potential of a linear spring of stiffness $mg/c$).
- $r_0=c$: ratio $\sqrt2$, irrational: the perturbed orbit precesses and never closes.
- $r_0=\sqrt3\,c$: ratio $2c/\sqrt{4c^2}=1$: one radial oscillation per revolution, a closed orbit.
- $\omega_r^2=\dfrac{4g}{c\,(1+r_0^2/c^2)}=\dfrac{4gc}{c^2+r_0^2}$, $\quad\dfrac{\omega_r}{\Omega_0}=\dfrac{2c}{\sqrt{c^2+r_0^2}}$.
- Ratio 1 for $r_0=\sqrt3\,c$ (closed after one revolution); $2$ for $r_0\to0$; $\sqrt2$ for $r_0=c$ (not closed).
Part (f) · 2 points
Turning points and contact
The particle starts at $r_0$ with $\dot r=0$ and a horizontal velocity $v_0$ tangent to the parallel. Find the turning radii. Then take $r_0=c/2$, $v_0=2r_0\Omega_0$: give the turning radii, $\ddot r$ and $N$ at both, and decide whether the particle ever leaves the surface.
Step 1. Constants
$\mathbf v(0)=v_0\mathbf e_\varphi$, so $H=r_0\cdot r_0\dot\varphi(0)=r_0v_0$ and $E/m=\tfrac12v_0^2+\dfrac{gr_0^2}{2c}$.
Step 2. Turning radii
At $\dot r=0$ the energy of (c) gives $\dfrac{H^2}{r^2}+\dfrac{gr^2}{c}=v_0^2+\dfrac{gr_0^2}{c}$. Multiply by $u=r^2$:
(expanding the product gives back the three terms). Roots: $r=r_0$ and $r^*=v_0\sqrt{c/g}=v_0/\Omega_0$. If $v_0>r_0\Omega_0$ the particle climbs to $r^*>r_0$; if $v_0=r_0\Omega_0$ both coincide (circular orbit of (d)). The time between them is a quadrature: from the energy, $dt=\dfrac{q\,dr}{\sqrt{2E/m-H^2/r^2-gr^2/c}}$.
Step 3. The numerical case
$r_0=c/2$, $v_0=c\Omega_0$: $r^*=c\Omega_0/\Omega_0=c$. So $r$ oscillates between $c/2$ and $c$ ($z$ between $c/8$ and $c/2$). With $H^2=r_0^2v_0^2=c^3g/4$, $E/m=\tfrac58gc$. For $c=1$ m: $\Omega_0=v_0=3.132$ (rad/s and m/s), $\omega_r(r_0)=\tfrac{4}{\sqrt5}\Omega_0=5.603$ rad/s for the small oscillations of (e), which do not apply here because the amplitude is large.
At the turning points $\dot r=0$, so $q^2\ddot r=\dfrac{H^2}{r^3}-\dfrac{gr}{c}$:
- $r=c/2$: $\dfrac{H^2}{r^3}=\dfrac{c^3g/4}{c^3/8}=2g$, $\dfrac{gr}{c}=\dfrac g2$, $q^2=\dfrac54$: $\ddot r=\dfrac{3g/2}{5/4}=\dfrac65g$.
- $r=c$: $\dfrac{H^2}{r^3}=\dfrac g4$, $\dfrac{gr}{c}=g$, $q^2=2$: $\ddot r=-\dfrac{3g}{8}$.
Then $N=mq\Big(\dfrac{r\ddot r}{c}+g\Big)$: at $r=c/2$, $N=m\dfrac{\sqrt5}{2}\Big(\dfrac35g+g\Big)=\dfrac{4}{\sqrt5}mg\approx1.789\,mg$; at $r=c$, $N=m\sqrt2\Big(-\dfrac38g+g\Big)=\dfrac{5\sqrt2}{8}mg\approx0.884\,mg$.
Step 4. Contact along any motion
From Step 3 of (c), multiplied by $r$: $r\ddot r\,q^2=\dfrac{H^2}{r^2}-\dfrac{r^2\dot r^2}{c^2}-\dfrac{gr^2}{c}$. Adding $q^2\dot r^2$ to both sides and using $q^2-r^2/c^2=1$:
From the energy of (c), $q^2\dot r^2=2E/m-H^2/r^2-gr^2/c$. Multiplying the previous line by $q^2$ and substituting $q^2\dot r^2$:
because $(q^2-1)\dfrac{H^2}{r^2}=\dfrac{H^2}{c^2}$ and $(1+q^2)\dfrac{gr^2}{c}=\Big(2+\dfrac{r^2}{c^2}\Big)\dfrac{gr^2}{c}$. So
Substituting in $N=mq\big[(\dot r^2+r\ddot r)/c+g\big]=\dfrac{m}{cq^3}\big[q^4(\dot r^2+r\ddot r)+gc\,q^4\big]$ and using the identity
we get $N=\dfrac{m}{cq^3}\Big(\dfrac{2E}{m}+\dfrac{H^2}{c^2}+gc\Big)$, and with $cq^3=(c^2+r^2)^{3/2}/c^2$:
With $V=mgz\ge0$ the energy is positive, so $N>0$ on every motion: the particle never leaves the inner face. In the numerical case $2c^2E/m+H^2+gc^3=\tfrac54gc^3+\tfrac14gc^3+gc^3=\tfrac52gc^3$, so $N=\dfrac{5mgc^3}{2(c^2+r^2)^{3/2}}$, decreasing from $1.789\,mg$ at $r=c/2$ to its minimum $0.884\,mg$ at $r=c$, in agreement with Step 3.
- $(u-r_0^2)\Big(\dfrac{gu}{c}-v_0^2\Big)=0$: turning radii $r_0$ and $r^*=v_0\sqrt{c/g}=v_0/\Omega_0$.
- Case: $r^*=c$; $\ddot r(c/2)=\tfrac65g$ (outwards), $\ddot r(c)=-\tfrac38g$; $N(c/2)=\tfrac{4}{\sqrt5}mg\approx1.789\,mg$, $N(c)=\tfrac{5\sqrt2}{8}mg\approx0.884\,mg$.
- On every motion $N=\dfrac{m\,(2Ec^2/m+H^2+gc^3)}{(c^2+r^2)^{3/2}}>0$: contact is never lost. Here $N=\dfrac{5mgc^3}{2(c^2+r^2)^{3/2}}$.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $c$ is a length, so $g/c$ and $\omega_r^2=4gc/(c^2+r_0^2)$ are s$^{-2}$; $H=r^2\dot\varphi$ is m$^2$ s$^{-1}$, $H^2/r^3$ and $gr/c$ are m s$^{-2}$; in $N$, $(2c^2E/m+H^2+gc^3)$ is m$^4$ s$^{-2}$ and $(c^2+r^2)^{3/2}$ is m$^3$: $N$ is kg m s$^{-2}$.
- Limits: $c\to\infty$ (flat floor): $\Omega_0\to0$, no horizontal circle without a wall. $r_0\ll c$: the bowl acts as an isotropic linear spring, $\omega_r=2\Omega_0$ and the orbits are centred ellipses.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) claiming that the angular momentum about $O$ is conserved because "the reaction is normal": only the axial component is; (2) expecting the orbital rate to depend on $r_0$ (it does not on a paraboloid); (3) linearising without the factor $1+r_0^2/c^2$, which gives $\omega_r=2\Omega_0$ for every radius; (4) solving the quartic for the turning points instead of noticing that $r_0$ is a root; (5) not checking $N\ge0$ for a unilateral contact.
P03 — Bead on a parabolic wire spinning about its axis: Coriolis side force, Jacobi integral and the critical rate
A smooth rigid wire lies in a vertical plane and has the shape of the parabola $y=x^2/(2p)$ ($p>0$), with its vertex at $O$ and its axis along the upward vertical. The wire is driven by a motor so that it spins about that vertical axis with constant angular rate $\Omega>0$. A bead $P$ of mass $m$ is threaded on the wire.
Let $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i_0,\mathbf j_0,\mathbf k_0\}$ be inertial ($\mathbf j_0$ vertical upward, gravity $-g\,\mathbf j_0$) and $S_1=\{O;\mathbf i_1,\mathbf j_1,\mathbf k_1\}$ be attached to the wire, with $\mathbf j_1=\mathbf j_0$, the wire in the plane $x_1y_1$ and $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\Omega\,\mathbf j_0$. At $t=0$ both frames coincide, so $\mathbf i_1$ has turned the angle $\theta=\Omega t$ about $\mathbf j_0$. The position of $P$ on the wire is given by its abscissa $x$ along $\mathbf i_1$ (positive or negative).
Setup
- Data: $m$, $p$, $g$, $\Omega$. In part (g): $\Omega^2=2g/p$ and the bead is released at rest relative to the wire at $x_0=p/2$.
- Hypotheses: point particle, no friction, bead threaded on the wire (bilateral constraint), $S_0$ inertial.
- Write $q=\sqrt{1+x^2/p^2}$.
Part (a) · 1 point
Degrees of freedom and frames
Count the degrees of freedom and classify the constraints in $S_0$ and in $S_1$. Write the change-of-basis matrix $[{}_0R_1]$, check it, and give $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}$ and $\boldsymbol\alpha_{10}$.
Step 1. Count
In $S_1$ the wire is fixed: $z_1=0$ and $y_1-x_1^2/(2p)=0$ are two holonomic equations without time, so $3-2=1$ degree of freedom, coordinate $x$ (Notes §2.7). Seen from $S_0$ the same curve moves, so the constraints contain $t$ through $\theta=\Omega t$: rheonomic. This is why we work in $S_1$.
Step 2. Change of basis
The columns of $[{}_0R_1]$ are the components of $\mathbf i_1,\mathbf j_1,\mathbf k_1$ in $\mathcal B_0$ (Notes §1.5): $\mathbf i_1=\cos\theta\,\mathbf i_0-\sin\theta\,\mathbf k_0$, $\mathbf j_1=\mathbf j_0$, $\mathbf k_1=\sin\theta\,\mathbf i_0+\cos\theta\,\mathbf k_0$:
Step 3. Angular velocity
$\dot{\mathbf i}_1=\dot\theta(-\sin\theta\,\mathbf i_0-\cos\theta\,\mathbf k_0)=-\Omega\,\mathbf k_1$ and $\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf i_1=\Omega\,\mathbf j_1\times\mathbf i_1=-\Omega\,\mathbf k_1$ (Poisson, Notes §1.7), so $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\dot\theta\,\mathbf j_0=\Omega\,\mathbf j_0$, and $\boldsymbol\alpha_{10}=\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}_{10}=\mathbf 0$ because $\Omega$ is constant.
- 1 degree of freedom, coordinate $x$. Two holonomic constraints, scleronomic in $S_1$ ($z_1=0$, $y_1=x_1^2/(2p)$), rheonomic in $S_0$.
- $[{}_0R_1]=\begin{pmatrix}\cos\theta&0&\sin\theta\\0&1&0\\-\sin\theta&0&\cos\theta\end{pmatrix}$, $\det=1$, $RR^T=I$; $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\Omega\,\mathbf j_0$, $\boldsymbol\alpha_{10}=\mathbf 0$.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Relative and absolute kinematics
Write $\mathbf r$, $\mathbf v_{rel}$, $\mathbf a_{rel}$ in $\mathcal B_1$, and the absolute acceleration of $P$ with the Coriolis theorem.
Step 1. Relative motion
$\mathbf r=x\,\mathbf i_1+\dfrac{x^2}{2p}\mathbf j_1$. Differentiating in $S_1$ (where $\mathbf i_1,\mathbf j_1$ are constant), with the chain rule $\dfrac{d}{dt}\dfrac{x^2}{2p}=\dfrac{x\dot x}{p}$ and the product rule $\dfrac{d}{dt}\dfrac{x\dot x}{p}=\dfrac{\dot x^2+x\ddot x}{p}$:
Step 2. Transport and Coriolis terms
$O$ is fixed and $\boldsymbol\alpha_{10}=\mathbf 0$, so (Notes §3.2) $\mathbf a=\mathbf a_{rel}+\boldsymbol\omega\times(\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf r)+2\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf v_{rel}$. With $\mathbf j_1\times\mathbf i_1=-\mathbf k_1$ and $\mathbf j_1\times\mathbf j_1=\mathbf 0$:
- $\mathbf v_{rel}=\dot x\Big(\mathbf i_1+\dfrac xp\mathbf j_1\Big)$, $\ \mathbf a_{rel}=\ddot x\Big(\mathbf i_1+\dfrac xp\mathbf j_1\Big)+\dfrac{\dot x^2}{p}\mathbf j_1$.
- $\mathbf a_{tr}=-\Omega^2x\,\mathbf i_1$, $\ \mathbf a_{cor}=-2\Omega\dot x\,\mathbf k_1$, $\ \mathbf a=\mathbf a_{rel}+\mathbf a_{tr}+\mathbf a_{cor}$.
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Forces and inertia forces
Write the applied forces, the reaction of the wire and the inertia forces of $S_1$ in $\mathcal B_1$. Which of them do work in $S_1$?
Step 1. Applied force and reaction
$\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j_1$. The tangent of the wire is along $\boldsymbol\tau=\mathbf i_1+\dfrac xp\mathbf j_1$; the normal plane is spanned by the in-plane normal $\mathbf n=\dfrac1q\Big(-\dfrac xp\mathbf i_1+\mathbf j_1\Big)$ and by $\mathbf k_1$. A smooth wire gives (Notes §6.5) $\mathbf N=N_n\,\mathbf n+N_z\,\mathbf k_1$, two unknowns.
Step 2. Inertia forces
In $S_1$ Newton's law reads $m\mathbf a_{rel}=\mathbf W+\mathbf N+\mathbf F_{cf}+\mathbf F_{cor}$ (Notes §4.9), with
There is no Euler term ($\boldsymbol\alpha=\mathbf 0$) and no translational term ($O$ fixed).
Step 3. Work in $S_1$
$\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf v_{rel}=0$ and $\mathbf F_{cor}\cdot\mathbf v_{rel}=0$ (both orthogonal to the tangent). $\mathbf W$ has potential $mgy=\dfrac{mgx^2}{2p}$ and $\mathbf F_{cf}$ has potential $V_{cf}=-\tfrac12m\Omega^2x^2$ (check: $-\dfrac{dV_{cf}}{dx}=m\Omega^2x$).
- $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j_1$; $\ \mathbf N=N_n\mathbf n+N_z\mathbf k_1$ with $\mathbf n=\dfrac{-(x/p)\mathbf i_1+\mathbf j_1}{q}$.
- $\mathbf F_{cf}=m\Omega^2x\,\mathbf i_1$ (potential $-\tfrac12m\Omega^2x^2$), $\ \mathbf F_{cor}=2m\Omega\dot x\,\mathbf k_1$ (no work in $S_1$).
Part (d) · 2 points
Equation of motion and reactions
Obtain the equation of motion free of reactions and the two components of the reaction.
Step 1. Tangential projection
Dot $m\mathbf a_{rel}=\mathbf W+\mathbf N+\mathbf F_{cf}+\mathbf F_{cor}$ with $\boldsymbol\tau=\mathbf i_1+\dfrac xp\mathbf j_1$. Left: $m\Big[\ddot x+\dfrac xp\cdot\dfrac{x\ddot x+\dot x^2}{p}\Big]$. Right: $\mathbf W\cdot\boldsymbol\tau=-\dfrac{mgx}{p}$, $\mathbf F_{cf}\cdot\boldsymbol\tau=m\Omega^2x$, and $\mathbf N\cdot\boldsymbol\tau=\mathbf F_{cor}\cdot\boldsymbol\tau=0$:
Step 2. Out-of-plane projection
$\mathbf a_{rel}\cdot\mathbf k_1=0$, so $0=N_z+2m\Omega\dot x$:
The wire must cancel the Coriolis force. Seen from $S_0$: a bead moving outwards must gain the azimuthal speed $\Omega x$ of the wire; the drag direction of the rotation at $P$ is $\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf r=-\Omega x\,\mathbf k_1$, and for $x>0$, $\dot x>0$ the wire indeed pushes along $-\mathbf k_1$.
Step 3. In-plane normal projection
Dot with $q\,\mathbf n=-\dfrac xp\mathbf i_1+\mathbf j_1$. Left: $m\Big[-\dfrac xp\ddot x+\dfrac{x\ddot x+\dot x^2}{p}\Big]=\dfrac{m\dot x^2}{p}$. Right: $-mg$ (weight) $-\dfrac{m\Omega^2x^2}{p}$ (centrifugal) $+qN_n$:
a sum of positive terms: the wire always pushes the bead towards the concave side.
Step 4. Cross-check in $S_0$
As an extension (Lagrange equations are not in the course notes), the Lagrange equation of $L=\tfrac12m|\mathbf v|^2-mgy$ with the absolute velocity $\mathbf v=\mathbf v_{rel}-\Omega x\,\mathbf k_1$, $|\mathbf v|^2=q^2\dot x^2+\Omega^2x^2$, gives the same equation (checked with SymPy).
- $\Big(1+\dfrac{x^2}{p^2}\Big)\ddot x+\dfrac{x}{p^2}\dot x^2=x\Big(\Omega^2-\dfrac gp\Big)$.
- $N_z=-2m\Omega\dot x$; $\ N_n=\dfrac mq\Big(\dfrac{\dot x^2}{p}+\dfrac{\Omega^2x^2}{p}+g\Big)>0$.
Part (e) · 1 point
Jacobi first integral
Obtain a first integral of the motion. Is it the mechanical energy of the bead in $S_0$?
Step 1. Exact derivatives
By the product and chain rules, $\dfrac{d}{dt}\Big[\tfrac12\Big(1+\dfrac{x^2}{p^2}\Big)\dot x^2\Big]=\Big(1+\dfrac{x^2}{p^2}\Big)\dot x\ddot x+\dfrac{x\dot x}{p^2}\dot x^2=\dot x\Big[\Big(1+\dfrac{x^2}{p^2}\Big)\ddot x+\dfrac{x}{p^2}\dot x^2\Big]$, and $\dot x\cdot x\Big(\Omega^2-\dfrac gp\Big)=\dfrac{d}{dt}\Big[\tfrac12\Big(\Omega^2-\dfrac gp\Big)x^2\Big]$. Integrating from $0$ to $t$ (Barrow's rule):
Step 2. Meaning
$\tfrac12|\mathbf v_{rel}|^2=\tfrac12q^2\dot x^2$ and the potentials of (c): $J=\tfrac12|\mathbf v_{rel}|^2+gy-\tfrac12\Omega^2x^2$. In $S_1$ only $\mathbf W$ and $\mathbf F_{cf}$ work, so this "relative energy" is conserved. In $S_0$, $\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf v=N_z\mathbf k_1\cdot(-\Omega x\,\mathbf k_1)=2m\Omega^2x\dot x\neq0$: the motor feeds energy to the bead.
- $J=\tfrac12\Big(1+\dfrac{x^2}{p^2}\Big)\dot x^2+\tfrac12\Big(\dfrac gp-\Omega^2\Big)x^2=$ const (per unit mass).
- It is the energy in $S_1$ including the centrifugal potential; the energy in $S_0$ is not conserved (the motor works through $N_z$).
Part (f) · 1.5 points
Relative equilibrium and the critical rate
Find the positions of relative equilibrium and their stability for $\Omega^2<g/p$, $\Omega^2=g/p$ and $\Omega^2>g/p$. Give the frequency of small oscillations when it exists. What happens at the critical rate?
Step 1. Equilibria
$\dot x=\ddot x=0$ in (d) gives $x(\Omega^2-g/p)=0$. If $\Omega^2\neq g/p$ only $x=0$ (the vertex). $V_{eff}''(0)=m(g/p-\Omega^2)$ (Notes §4.6): a minimum (stable) for $\Omega^2<g/p$, a maximum (unstable) for $\Omega^2>g/p$.
Step 2. Small oscillations
Linearising (d) about $x=0$ ($q\to1$, the $x\dot x^2$ term is of third order): $\ddot x+\Big(\dfrac gp-\Omega^2\Big)x=0$, so $\omega=\sqrt{g/p-\Omega^2}$ for $\Omega^2<g/p$.
Step 3. The critical rate (the trap)
For $\Omega^2=g/p$ the linearised equation is $\ddot x=0$, which does not decide anything by itself. The full equation becomes $q^2\ddot x+\dfrac{x}{p^2}\dot x^2=0$, so $\ddot x=0$ whenever $\dot x=0$, at any $x$: every point is a relative equilibrium. $J$ reduces to $\tfrac12q^2\dot x^2=|\mathbf v_{rel}|^2/2=$ const: the bead slides with constant relative speed and never comes back (neutral, not stable). Geometric reason: at relative rest the resultant of gravity and centrifugal force must be normal to the wire, i.e. $dy/dx=\Omega^2x/g$; the parabola has $dy/dx=x/p$, which matches at every $x$ exactly when $\Omega^2=g/p$ (it is the shape of the free surface of a liquid spinning at that rate).
- $x=0$ is an equilibrium for every $\Omega$: stable for $\Omega^2<g/p$ ($\omega^2=g/p-\Omega^2$), unstable for $\Omega^2>g/p$.
- $\Omega^2=g/p$: every point of the wire is an equilibrium (neutral), and a bead with relative speed slides at constant speed along the wire: $q^2\dot x^2=$ const.
Part (g) · 1.5 points
Release at $\Omega^2=2g/p$: escape and side force
For $\Omega^2=2g/p$ and release from relative rest at $x_0=p/2$: show that the bead moves outwards, give $\dot x^2(x)$ and $N_z(x)$, their values at $x=p$ and their limits for $x\to\infty$.
Step 1. Direction
With $\dot x=0$ in (d): $q_0^2\ddot x=x_0\Big(\dfrac{2g}{p}-\dfrac gp\Big)=\dfrac{g x_0}{p}>0$. The bead starts outwards (the vertex is unstable, part (f)).
Step 2. Speed
$J(x,\dot x)=J(x_0,0)$ with $g/p-\Omega^2=-g/p$:
$\dot x^2\ge0$ only for $|x|\ge x_0$: the bead never returns towards the vertex, and $x$ grows monotonically. Consistency: $\dfrac{d(\dot x^2)}{dx}=2\ddot x$ reproduces (d) (checked with SymPy).
Step 3. Side force
$N_z=-2m\Omega\dot x$ with $\Omega=\sqrt{2g/p}$ and $\dot x>0$:
Step 4. Values
At $x=p$ ($x_0=p/2$): $\dot x^2=\dfrac gp\cdot\dfrac{p^2-p^2/4}{2}=\dfrac38gp$, and $N_z=-2m\sqrt{\dfrac{2g}{p}}\sqrt{\dfrac{3gp}{8}}=-2mg\sqrt{\dfrac34}=-\sqrt3\,mg$. The in-plane reaction there: $\dfrac{\dot x^2}{p}+\dfrac{\Omega^2x^2}{p}+g=\dfrac38g+2g+g=\dfrac{27}{8}g$ and $q=\sqrt2$, so $N_n=\dfrac{27}{8\sqrt2}mg\approx2.386\,mg$. The relative speed is then $|\mathbf v_{rel}|^2=q^2\dot x^2=\tfrac34gp$.
Step 5. Limits
For $x\to\infty$, $\dfrac{x^2-x_0^2}{1+x^2/p^2}\to p^2$, so $\dot x^2\to gp$ and $|N_z|\to2\sqrt2\,mg$. The abscissa grows at a bounded rate, while the speed along the wire $q|\dot x|$ grows without bound because the wire becomes steep.
- $\ddot x(x_0)=\dfrac{(g/p)\,x_0}{1+x_0^2/p^2}>0$; $\ \dot x^2=\dfrac gp\,\dfrac{x^2-x_0^2}{1+x^2/p^2}$.
- $N_z=-\dfrac{2\sqrt2\,mg}{p}\sqrt{\dfrac{x^2-x_0^2}{1+x^2/p^2}}$; at $x=p$: $\dot x^2=\tfrac38gp$, $N_z=-\sqrt3\,mg\approx-1.732\,mg$, $N_n=\dfrac{27}{8\sqrt2}mg\approx2.386\,mg$.
- $x\to\infty$: $\dot x^2\to gp$ and $|N_z|\to2\sqrt2\,mg\approx2.83\,mg$.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $g/p$ and $\Omega^2$ are s$^{-2}$; in (d) every term is m s$^{-2}$ ($x\dot x^2/p^2$ is m (m/s)$^2$/m$^2$); $N_z=2m\Omega\dot x$ is kg s$^{-1}$ m s$^{-1}$ = N; $\dot x^2\to gp$ is m$^2$ s$^{-2}$.
- Limits: $\Omega=0$: a bead in a fixed parabolic bowl, $\omega=\sqrt{g/p}$ about the vertex and $N_z=0$; $p\to\infty$ (straight horizontal wire): always $\Omega^2>g/p$, and $x(t)$ grows as $\cosh\Omega t$, the classic rotating rod.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) forgetting $N_z$ (the reaction of a wire has two components; the Coriolis force needs one of them); (2) writing the Jacobi integral as the absolute energy (the motor does work in $S_0$); (3) at $\Omega^2=g/p$, concluding "stable" or "unstable" from $\ddot x=0$: every point is an equilibrium and a moving bead keeps a constant relative speed; (4) dropping the $(x/p^2)\dot x^2$ term, which comes from differentiating the constraint $y=x^2/(2p)$ twice.
P04 — Radial tube on a turntable with increasing rate: Euler force, three regimes and the motor torque
A horizontal turntable turns about the fixed vertical axis $O\mathbf k$ of the inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i_0,\mathbf j_0,\mathbf k\}$ ($\mathbf k$ vertical upward, gravity $-g\,\mathbf k$). A motor imposes the angle $\theta(t)$ between $\mathbf i_0$ and a radial line of the table, with
($\Omega_0>0$ and $\beta$ constants). A smooth, thin, straight tube is fixed on the table along a diameter of the table, from the rim at $x=-L$ through $O$ to the rim at $x=L$. A bead $P$ of mass $m$ moves inside the tube and is joined to $O$ by a spring of stiffness $k$ and zero natural length. The frame $S_1=\{O;\mathbf i_1,\mathbf j_1,\mathbf k\}$ turns with the table, $\mathbf i_1$ along the tube and $\mathbf j_1=\mathbf k\times\mathbf i_1$; $x$ is the signed coordinate of $P$ along $\mathbf i_1$ (so $x<0$ means on the other side of $O$). The table and the tube have moment of inertia $I_T$ about the axis.
(The scalar $k$ is the stiffness; the bold $\mathbf k$ is the vertical unit vector.)
Setup
- Data: $m$, $k$, $g$, $\Omega_0$, $\beta$, $I_T$, $L$.
- Numerical parts (e), (f): $m=0.2$ kg, $k=20$ N/m (so $\omega_n=\sqrt{k/m}=10$ rad/s), $\beta=0$, $x(0)=x_0=0.1$ m, $\dot x(0)=v_0=0$, $L=0.5$ m, $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$, and $\Omega_0=6$, $10$ or $12.5$ rad/s.
- Hypotheses: point particle, no friction in the tube, $S_0$ inertial, the motor delivers whatever torque is needed to keep $\Omega(t)$.
Part (a) · 1 point
Degrees of freedom and frames
Count the degrees of freedom of $P$. Give $[{}_0R_1]$, $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}$ and $\boldsymbol\alpha_{10}$.
Step 1. Count
In $S_1$ the tube is the line $y_1=0$, $z_1=0$: two holonomic constraints, so $3-2=1$ degree of freedom, $x$ (Notes §2.7). In $S_0$ the tube turns with the prescribed $\theta(t)$, so the constraints depend explicitly on time (rheonomic).
Step 2. Frames
$\mathbf i_1=\cos\theta\,\mathbf i_0+\sin\theta\,\mathbf j_0$, $\mathbf j_1=-\sin\theta\,\mathbf i_0+\cos\theta\,\mathbf j_0$: the columns of $[{}_0R_1]$ above, a simple rotation about $\mathbf k$ (Notes §1.5) with $\det=\cos^2\theta+\sin^2\theta=1$ and $RR^T=I$. Then $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\dot\theta\,\mathbf k=\Omega(t)\,\mathbf k$ and $\boldsymbol\alpha_{10}=\dot\Omega\,\mathbf k=\beta\,\mathbf k$.
- 1 degree of freedom, $x$; constraints $y_1=0$, $z_1=0$ (rheonomic in $S_0$).
- $[{}_0R_1]=\begin{pmatrix}\cos\theta&-\sin\theta&0\\\sin\theta&\cos\theta&0\\0&0&1\end{pmatrix}$, $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\Omega(t)\,\mathbf k$, $\boldsymbol\alpha_{10}=\beta\,\mathbf k$.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Kinematics
Write the relative velocity and acceleration of $P$ and its absolute acceleration in $\mathcal B_1$, (i) with the Coriolis theorem and (ii) by differentiating $\mathbf r=x\,\mathbf i_1$ directly in $S_0$.
Step 1. Coriolis theorem
$O$ is fixed, so (Notes §3.2) $\mathbf a=\mathbf a_{rel}+\boldsymbol\alpha\times\mathbf r+\boldsymbol\omega\times(\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf r)+2\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf v_{rel}$, with $\mathbf r=x\,\mathbf i_1$ and $\mathbf k\times\mathbf i_1=\mathbf j_1$, $\mathbf k\times\mathbf j_1=-\mathbf i_1$:
Step 2. Direct differentiation
$\mathbf v=\dfrac{d}{dt}(x\,\mathbf i_1)=\dot x\,\mathbf i_1+x\Omega\,\mathbf j_1$ (product rule). Again, with $\dfrac{d}{dt}(x\Omega)=\dot x\Omega+x\dot\Omega=\dot x\Omega+x\beta$:
which is the same result. The term $\beta x\,\mathbf j_1$ is the tangential acceleration of the point of the table under $P$.
- $\mathbf v_{rel}=\dot x\,\mathbf i_1$, $\mathbf a_{rel}=\ddot x\,\mathbf i_1$.
- $\mathbf a=(\ddot x-\Omega^2x)\,\mathbf i_1+(2\Omega\dot x+\beta x)\,\mathbf j_1$.
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Forces and inertia forces
Write all the forces on $P$ in $S_1$, including the three inertia forces.
Step 1. Applied forces and reaction
The spring has zero natural length, so its force is $-k\,\overrightarrow{OP}=-kx\,\mathbf i_1$. The weight is $-mg\,\mathbf k$. The tube is smooth: its reaction has no $\mathbf i_1$ component, $\mathbf N=N_y\,\mathbf j_1+N_z\,\mathbf k$.
Step 2. Inertia forces of $S_1$
From the terms of (b) multiplied by $-m$ (Notes §4.9):
The Euler (azimuthal) force exists only because the rotation accelerates; it points against the sense of rotation for $\beta>0$.
- $\mathbf F_k=-kx\,\mathbf i_1$, $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf k$, $\mathbf N=N_y\,\mathbf j_1+N_z\,\mathbf k$.
- $\mathbf F_{E}=-m\beta x\,\mathbf j_1$ (Euler), $\mathbf F_{cf}=m\Omega^2x\,\mathbf i_1$, $\mathbf F_{cor}=-2m\Omega\dot x\,\mathbf j_1$.
Part (d) · 1.5 points
Equation of motion and reactions
Obtain the equation of motion free of reactions, and $N_y$, $N_z$. Why does the equation contain $\Omega^2$ but not $\beta$?
Step 1. Projections
Step 2. Result
Step 3. Why no $\beta$
The Euler force $-m\beta x\,\mathbf j_1$ and the Coriolis force are perpendicular to the tube: the wall absorbs them and they appear only in $N_y$. The angular acceleration still acts on $x$, but only through the time-dependent coefficient $\Omega(t)^2=(\Omega_0+\beta t)^2$. (In $S_0$ the same equation is the $\mathbf i_1$ component of $m\mathbf a$ of (b).)
- $\ddot x+\Big(\dfrac km-\Omega(t)^2\Big)x=0$.
- $N_y=m(\beta x+2\Omega\dot x)$, $\ N_z=mg$.
Part (e) · 2 points
Constant rate: the three regimes
Take $\beta=0$. Solve the equation of motion with $x(0)=x_0$, $\dot x(0)=v_0$ for $\Omega_0^2<k/m$, $\Omega_0^2=k/m$ and $\Omega_0^2>k/m$, write the Jacobi integral, and evaluate each case for the data of the Setup ($\Omega_0=6$, $10$, $12.5$ rad/s).
Step 1. $\Omega_0^2<k/m$
$\ddot x+\omega^2x=0$ with $\omega^2=k/m-\Omega_0^2>0$ (Notes Ch. 5): $x=A\cos\omega t+B\sin\omega t$. $x(0)=A=x_0$; $\dot x=-A\omega\sin\omega t+B\omega\cos\omega t$ gives $\dot x(0)=B\omega=v_0$. Data, $\Omega_0=6$: $\omega=\sqrt{100-36}=8$ rad/s, $x=0.1\cos8t$ m, period $2\pi/8=0.7854$ s. The spring wins over the centrifugal force.
Step 2. $\Omega_0^2=k/m$ (the trap)
$\ddot x=0$: integrating twice with Barrow's rule, $\dot x=v_0$ and $x=x_0+v_0t$. With $v_0=0$ the bead stays where it is, wherever that is: the spring force $kx$ is exactly the centrifugal force $m\Omega_0^2x$ at every $x$. With $v_0\neq0$ the bead drifts at constant relative speed. It is neither an oscillation of zero frequency nor an exponential escape. Data, $\Omega_0=10$: $x\equiv0.1$ m.
Step 3. $\Omega_0^2>k/m$
$\ddot x-\lambda^2x=0$ with $\lambda^2=\Omega_0^2-k/m$: $x=A\cosh\lambda t+B\sinh\lambda t$, with $x(0)=A=x_0$ and $\dot x(0)=B\lambda=v_0$. Writing it as $\tfrac12(x_0+v_0/\lambda)e^{\lambda t}+\tfrac12(x_0-v_0/\lambda)e^{-\lambda t}$, the growing exponential disappears only for $v_0=-\lambda x_0$, when $x=x_0e^{-\lambda t}$. Data, $\Omega_0=12.5$: $\lambda=\sqrt{156.25-100}=7.5$ s$^{-1}$, $x=0.1\cosh7.5t$ m.
Step 4. Jacobi integral
Multiplying the equation by $\dot x$: $\dfrac{d}{dt}\Big[\tfrac12\dot x^2+\tfrac12\Big(\dfrac km-\Omega_0^2\Big)x^2\Big]=0$, so
the energy in $S_1$ with the spring and centrifugal potentials. $\mathbf N$, $\mathbf F_{cor}$ and $\mathbf F_E$ do no work in $S_1$ because they are orthogonal to $\mathbf v_{rel}$.
- $\Omega_0^2<\omega_n^2$: $x=x_0\cos\omega t+\dfrac{v_0}{\omega}\sin\omega t$, $\omega=\sqrt{\omega_n^2-\Omega_0^2}$.
- $\Omega_0^2=\omega_n^2$: $x=x_0+v_0t$ (every position is a neutral relative equilibrium).
- $\Omega_0^2>\omega_n^2$: $x=x_0\cosh\lambda t+\dfrac{v_0}{\lambda}\sinh\lambda t$, $\lambda=\sqrt{\Omega_0^2-\omega_n^2}$; it decays only if $v_0=-\lambda x_0$.
- Data: $\omega=8$ rad/s, $x=0.1\cos8t$ m, period $0.7854$ s; $x\equiv0.1$ m; $\lambda=7.5$ s$^{-1}$, $x=0.1\cosh7.5t$ m.
Part (f) · 1 point
Reaching the end of the tube
For $\Omega_0=12.5$ rad/s, $\beta=0$ and the data of the Setup, find the time at which the bead reaches the rim ($x=L$), its relative speed then, and the reaction there.
Step 1. Time
$0.1\cosh7.5t_L=0.5\Rightarrow\cosh7.5t_L=5\Rightarrow t_L=\dfrac{\operatorname{arccosh}5}{7.5}=\dfrac{2.2924}{7.5}=0.3057$ s.
Step 2. Speed
$\dot x=x_0\lambda\sinh\lambda t$ with $\sinh\lambda t_L=\sqrt{25-1}=\sqrt{24}$: $\dot x=0.1\cdot7.5\cdot\sqrt{24}=3.674$ m/s. Check with the Jacobi integral: $\dot x^2=\lambda^2(L^2-x_0^2)=56.25\cdot0.24=13.5$ m$^2$ s$^{-2}$.
Step 3. Reaction
$N_y=m(0+2\Omega_0\dot x)=2\cdot0.2\cdot12.5\cdot3.674=18.37$ N, about nine times the weight $N_z=mg=1.962$ N.
- $t_L=\dfrac{\operatorname{arccosh}5}{7.5}=0.3057$ s; $\dot x=0.75\sqrt{24}=3.674$ m/s.
- $N_y=2m\Omega_0\dot x=18.37$ N, $N_z=mg=1.962$ N.
Part (g) · 1.5 points
Motor torque and power balance
With the angular-momentum theorem about the axis, find the torque $M$ the motor must deliver to keep $\Omega(t)$, and check it against $N_y$. Write the power balance of the bead in $S_0$. For the case of (f), give $M$ (beyond $I_T\beta$) and the power at $x=L$, and the work of the motor on the bead between $x_0$ and $L$.
Step 1. Angular momentum of the bead about the axis
$\mathbf r\times m\mathbf v=x\,\mathbf i_1\times m(\dot x\,\mathbf i_1+\Omega x\,\mathbf j_1)=mx^2\Omega\,\mathbf k$, so $H_z=mx^2\Omega$. By the product rule:
Step 2. Torque on the bead
Moments about the axis (Notes §4.8): the spring force passes through $O$; $\mathbf r\times\mathbf W=x\,\mathbf i_1\times(-mg\,\mathbf k)=mgx\,\mathbf j_1$ and $\mathbf r\times N_z\mathbf k$ are horizontal; only $\mathbf r\times N_y\mathbf j_1=xN_y\,\mathbf k$ counts. Hence $\dfrac{dH_z}{dt}=xN_y$, and with $N_y$ of (d): $xN_y=mx(\beta x+2\Omega\dot x)$, the same expression as Step 1. The two routes agree.
Step 3. Motor torque
The table receives the motor torque $M$ and the moment $-xN_y$ of the bead's push on the tube: $I_T\beta=M-xN_y$, so
Even at constant rate ($\beta=0$) the motor must supply $2m\Omega x\dot x$ whenever the bead moves radially.
Step 4. Power balance in $S_0$
$T=\tfrac12m(\dot x^2+\Omega^2x^2)$, $V=\tfrac12kx^2$. Differentiating, $\dfrac{d}{dt}(T+V)=m\dot x\ddot x+m\Omega\beta x^2+m\Omega^2x\dot x+kx\dot x$, and with $m\ddot x=-kx+m\Omega^2x$ from (d): $\dfrac{d}{dt}(T+V)=2m\Omega^2x\dot x+m\Omega\beta x^2=\Omega\,xN_y$. This is the power of $N_y\mathbf j_1$ on the absolute velocity, $N_y\,\Omega x$ (Notes §4.4): in $S_0$ the reaction of the moving tube works; in $S_1$ it does not.
Step 5. Numbers at $x=L$ (case (f), $\beta=0$)
$xN_y=0.5\cdot18.37=9.186$ N m and the power is $\Omega_0xN_y=12.5\cdot9.186=114.8$ W. Since $\beta=0$, the work of the motor on the bead is $\displaystyle\int M\Omega_0\,dt=\Omega_0\int\frac{dH_z}{dt}dt=\Omega_0\,[H_z]_{0}^{t_L}=\Omega_0\big(H_z(t_L)-H_z(0)\big)=m\Omega_0^2(L^2-x_0^2)=0.2\cdot156.25\cdot0.24=7.5$ J. Check: $T$ goes from $0.15625$ to $\tfrac12\cdot0.2\,(13.5+39.0625)=5.25625$ J and $V$ from $0.1$ to $2.5$ J, so $\Delta(T+V)=5.1+2.4=7.5$ J.
- $H_z=mx^2\Omega$, $\ \dfrac{dH_z}{dt}=m(2x\dot x\Omega+x^2\beta)=xN_y$; $\ M=I_T\beta+mx(\beta x+2\Omega\dot x)$.
- $\dfrac{d}{dt}(T+V)=\Omega\,xN_y=M_{bead}\,\Omega$ (the reaction works in $S_0$, not in $S_1$).
- Case (f): $xN_y=9.186$ N m, power $114.8$ W, work $=\Omega_0\Delta H_z=m\Omega_0^2(L^2-x_0^2)=7.5$ J $=\Delta(T+V)$.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $k/m$ and $\Omega^2$ are s$^{-2}$; $N_y=m(\beta x+2\Omega\dot x)$ is kg (s$^{-2}$ m) = N; $H_z=mx^2\Omega$ is kg m$^2$ s$^{-1}$; $M$ is N m and $M\Omega$ is W.
- Limits: $k=0$ gives the classic bead on a rotating rod, $x=x_0\cosh\Omega_0t$; $\Omega_0=0$, $\beta=0$ gives the plain oscillator $\omega=\omega_n$. With $\beta>0$ the coefficient $k/m-\Omega(t)^2$ eventually becomes negative: a bead that oscillates at first is pushed outwards once $\Omega(t)>\omega_n$.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) forgetting the Euler force $-m\boldsymbol\alpha\times\mathbf r$ (it changes $N_y$ and the torque, not the equation of motion); (2) at $\Omega_0^2=k/m$ writing an exponential or a harmonic solution instead of $x=x_0+v_0t$; (3) claiming that the energy $T+V$ of the bead is conserved because the tube is smooth: in $S_0$ the tube moves and its reaction works; (4) computing the motor torque without the $I_T\beta$ term of the table, or with the wrong sign of the bead's push.
P05 — Flight pendulum on an accelerating support: inertia forces, equilibrium and a change of regime
A flight-test pendulum hangs from a rail fixed to the ceiling of an aircraft cabin. The support $A$ slides along the rail with a constant acceleration $\mathbf a_A=a_0\,\mathbf i$ with respect to the inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ ($x$ horizontal, forward; $y$ vertical, upward; uniform gravity $-g\,\mathbf j$), starting from rest at $t=0$. The bob $P$ of mass $m$ is joined to $A$ by a massless, inextensible string of length $\ell$ that stays taut. The angle $\theta$ is measured from the downward vertical, positive towards $+x$. At $t=0$ the bob hangs at rest with respect to the cabin ($\theta=0$, $\dot\theta=0$).
Use the reference frame $S_1=\{A;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ that translates with $A$ (its axes stay parallel to those of $S_0$), and, only to project vectors, the unit vectors $\mathbf e_r=\sin\theta\,\mathbf i-\cos\theta\,\mathbf j$ and $\mathbf e_\theta=\cos\theta\,\mathbf i+\sin\theta\,\mathbf j$.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $\ell$, $g$, $a_0>0$. In the numerical parts (f) and (g): $a_0=g/\sqrt3$.
- Hypotheses: point particle, planar motion, string always taut (checked in (g)), no friction, $S_0$ inertial.
- $S_1$ is a translating frame: $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\mathbf 0$, so the only inertia force is $-m\,\mathbf a_A$ (no Coriolis, no centrifugal force).
Part (a) · 1 point
Degrees of freedom and frames
How many effective degrees of freedom has $P$? State the angular velocity of $S_1$ with respect to $S_0$ and the kind of inertia force that appears in $S_1$.
Step 1. Count
A free particle in the plane has 2 degrees of freedom. The string gives the holonomic constraint $|\mathbf r_{AP}|=\ell$, which removes one: $\theta$ describes the configuration. The motion of $A$ is given ($\mathbf a_A=a_0\mathbf i$), so it adds no unknown: the constraint is rheonomic in $S_0$ and scleronomic in $S_1$.
Step 2. The frame
$S_1$ keeps its axes parallel to those of $S_0$, so $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\mathbf 0$. In the relative-motion law $\mathbf F+\mathbf F_{in}=m\mathbf a_{rel}$ (Notes §4.9) the Coriolis term $-2m\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf v_{rel}$ and the centrifugal term vanish, and only $\mathbf F_{in}=-m\mathbf a_A$ remains.
- 1 degree of freedom, coordinate $\theta(t)$.
- $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\mathbf 0$; only the translational inertia force $-m a_0\mathbf i$.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Kinematics of $P$
Write the position, velocity and acceleration of $P$ relative to $S_1$, and the absolute velocity and acceleration of $P$ in $S_0$, in the basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta\}$.
Change of basis
The projection basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta\}$ is related to $\{\mathbf i,\mathbf j\}$ (planar, $\mathbf k$ common) by
so $R$ is orthonormal and right-handed ($\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\theta=\mathbf k$). The inverse is $R^T$: $\mathbf i=\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_r+\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$, used below.
Step 1. Derivatives of the unit vectors
From $\mathbf e_r=\sin\theta\,\mathbf i-\cos\theta\,\mathbf j$ and the chain rule $\frac{d}{dt}f(\theta(t))=\frac{df}{d\theta}\dot\theta$:
Step 2. Relative motion
($\ell$ is constant, so the string produces no radial relative velocity.)
Step 3. Absolute motion
The support starts from rest with constant acceleration: $\mathbf v_A=a_0t\,\mathbf i$, $\mathbf r_A=\tfrac12a_0t^2\,\mathbf i$. Since $S_1$ does not rotate, $\mathbf v_P=\mathbf v_A+\mathbf v_{rel}$ and $\mathbf a_P=\mathbf a_A+\mathbf a_{rel}$:
Projecting $\mathbf i=\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_r+\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$ (the dot products $\mathbf i\cdot\mathbf e_r=\sin\theta$, $\mathbf i\cdot\mathbf e_\theta=\cos\theta$):
- $\mathbf a_{rel}=\ell\ddot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta-\ell\dot\theta^2\mathbf e_r$.
- $\mathbf a_P=a_0\mathbf i+\mathbf a_{rel}$ with $\mathbf i=\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_r+\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$.
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Forces on $P$ in $S_1$
Write every force acting on $P$ in $S_1$ in the basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta\}$, including the inertia force. Which of them can do work in $S_1$?
Step 1. Weight
$\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j$ with $\mathbf W\cdot\mathbf e_r=-mg(\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf e_r)=mg\cos\theta$ and $\mathbf W\cdot\mathbf e_\theta=-mg\sin\theta$:
Step 2. Tension and inertia force
The string is massless and taut, so its force on $P$ points to $A$: $\mathbf T=-T\,\mathbf e_r$ with $T\ge0$ unknown. The inertia force of the translating frame is
Step 3. Work in $S_1$
The power of a force is $\mathbf F\cdot\mathbf v_{rel}$ with $\mathbf v_{rel}=\ell\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$: only the $\mathbf e_\theta$ components work. $\mathbf T\cdot\mathbf v_{rel}=0$. $\mathbf W$ and $\mathbf F_{in}$ are uniform forces, hence conservative, with potentials $V_g=-mg\ell\cos\theta$ and $V_{in}=ma_0\ell\sin\theta$ (check: $-\partial V/\partial\theta/\ell$ gives their $\mathbf e_\theta$ components).
- $\mathbf W=mg(\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_r-\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta)$, $\ \mathbf T=-T\mathbf e_r$, $\ \mathbf F_{in}=-ma_0(\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_r+\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta)$.
- $\mathbf T$ does no work (it is orthogonal to $\mathbf v_{rel}$); $\mathbf W$ and $\mathbf F_{in}$ are conservative.
Part (d) · 2 points
Equation of motion and tension
Obtain the equation $\ddot\theta=f(\theta)$ that does not contain $T$, and the expression of $T$ as a function of $\theta$ and $\dot\theta$.
Step 1. Newton in $S_1$
Step 2. Tangential projection
This equation has one unknown, $\theta(t)$, because the tension is orthogonal to $\mathbf e_\theta$.
Step 3. Radial projection
Step 4. Cross-check with the absolute frame
Newton in $S_0$ along $\mathbf e_r$: $m\,\mathbf a_P\cdot\mathbf e_r=m(a_0\sin\theta-\ell\dot\theta^2)=\mathbf W\cdot\mathbf e_r-T=mg\cos\theta-T$, which gives the same $T$.
- $\ell\ddot\theta=-g\sin\theta-a_0\cos\theta$.
- $T=m\big(\ell\dot\theta^2+g\cos\theta-a_0\sin\theta\big)$.
Part (e) · 1 point
Equilibrium and small oscillations
Find the equilibrium angle $\theta_e$ and the frequency of the small oscillations about it, as functions of $a_0$, $g$, $\ell$. What does the pendulum indicate?
Step 1. Equilibrium
Setting $\ddot\theta=0$: $g\sin\theta+a_0\cos\theta=0\Rightarrow\tan\theta_e=-a_0/g$. Two solutions differ by $\pi$; the stable one hangs below $A$: $\theta_e=-\arctan(a_0/g)$.
Step 2. Rewrite the equation
With $\cos\alpha=g/g_{eff}$, $\sin\alpha=a_0/g_{eff}$ ($\alpha=\arctan(a_0/g)$) and the identity $\sin(\theta+\alpha)=\sin\theta\cos\alpha+\cos\theta\sin\alpha$:
so $\theta_e=-\alpha$. Define $\varphi=\theta-\theta_e=\theta+\alpha$: $\ \ell\ddot\varphi=-g_{eff}\sin\varphi$, an ordinary pendulum in a gravity $g_{eff}$.
Step 3. Linearisation
For $|\varphi|\ll1$, $\sin\varphi\approx\varphi$ and $\ddot\varphi+\dfrac{g_{eff}}{\ell}\varphi=0$:
The pendulum aligns with the apparent gravity $\mathbf g-\mathbf a_A$ (the specific force) and oscillates faster than at rest.
- $\theta_e=-\arctan(a_0/g)$ (the bob lags behind), $g_{eff}=\sqrt{g^2+a_0^2}$.
- $\omega^2=g_{eff}/\ell$, stable equilibrium.
Part (f) · 1.5 points
First integral and the swing from $\theta=0$
Write a first integral of the motion in $S_1$. For $a_0=g/\sqrt3$, with the initial conditions of the statement, find the extreme angles of the swing and $\ell\dot\theta^2$ when the bob passes $\theta_e$.
Step 1. Energy in $S_1$
In $S_1$ the work is done by $\mathbf W$ and $\mathbf F_{in}$ (conservative, part (c)); $\mathbf T$ does none. Hence $E=T_{kin}+V_g+V_{in}$ is constant:
Check: $\dfrac{d}{dt}\dfrac Em=\ell\dot\theta\big(\ell\ddot\theta+g\sin\theta+a_0\cos\theta\big)=0$ by part (d). With $-g\cos\theta+a_0\sin\theta=-g_{eff}\cos(\theta+\alpha)$:
Step 2. Numbers
For $a_0=g/\sqrt3$: $\tan\alpha=1/\sqrt3$, so $\alpha=30^\circ$, $\theta_e=-30^\circ$ and $g_{eff}=g\sqrt{1+1/3}=2g/\sqrt3$. At $t=0$: $\theta=0\Rightarrow\varphi_0=30^\circ$, $\dot\theta=0$.
Step 3. Extremes and speed
Equating $E$ at $\varphi_0$ and at a generic $\varphi$:
It vanishes at $\varphi=\pm30^\circ$, i.e. $\theta=0$ and $\theta=-60^\circ$. At $\varphi=0$ the factor is $\cos0-\cos30^\circ=1-\cos30^\circ$:
- $\tfrac12\ell^2\dot\theta^2-g\ell\cos\theta+a_0\ell\sin\theta=$ const, i.e. $\tfrac12\ell^2\dot\theta^2-g_{eff}\ell\cos\varphi=$ const.
- $\theta_e=-30^\circ$, extremes $\theta=0$ and $\theta=-60^\circ$; $\ell\dot\theta^2(\theta_e)=2g_{eff}(1-\cos30^\circ)=(4/\sqrt3-2)\,g\approx0.309\,g$.
Part (g) · 1.5 points
Tension and a change of regime
For $a_0=g/\sqrt3$: (i) compute $T$ at $\theta_e$ and show that the string never goes slack. (ii) At the instant the bob passes $\theta_e$ for the first time (moving backwards, $\dot\theta<0$) the support stops accelerating ($a_0\to0$, $A$ keeps its velocity). Find the maximum angle of the following motion and the tension when the bob passes the vertical.
Step 1. Tension along the swing
From (d), $T=m(\ell\dot\theta^2+g\cos\theta-a_0\sin\theta)$ and $g\cos\theta-a_0\sin\theta=g_{eff}\cos\varphi$. With $\ell\dot\theta^2=2g_{eff}(\cos\varphi-\cos30^\circ)$ of (f):
At $\varphi=0$: $T=m\frac{2g}{\sqrt3}(3-\sqrt3)=mg(2\sqrt3-2)\approx1.464\,mg$. $T$ decreases with $|\varphi|$; its minimum is at $\varphi=\pm30^\circ$: $T=mg_{eff}\cos30^\circ=mg>0$. The string is taut during the whole swing.
Step 2. Initial conditions of phase 2
At the switch: $\theta_1=-30^\circ$, $\ell\dot\theta_1^2=(4/\sqrt3-2)g$. Afterwards $\ell\ddot\theta=-g\sin\theta$ (ordinary pendulum), with the energy per unit mass $\tfrac12\ell^2\dot\theta^2-g\ell\cos\theta=$ const. The bob has kinetic energy at $\theta_1$, which is not the equilibrium of the new motion.
Step 3. Maximum angle
Setting $\dot\theta=0$ at $\theta_m$:
so $\theta_m=\arccos(0.7113)=44.66^\circ$: the bob, which was at $-30^\circ$ moving backwards, first reaches $-44.66^\circ$ (beyond the old equilibrium), then swings through the vertical to $+44.66^\circ$: the new motion is symmetric, $\theta\in[-44.66^\circ,+44.66^\circ]$, about the vertical.
Step 4. Tension at the vertical
The energy $\tfrac12\ell^2\dot\theta^2-g\ell\cos\theta$ is the same at $\theta_1=-30^\circ$ and at $\theta=0$, so $\ell\dot\theta^2(0)=\ell\dot\theta_1^2+2g(\cos0-\cos30^\circ)$ with $\cos0-\cos30^\circ=1-\sqrt3/2$:
and with $a_0=0$: $T(0)=m\big(\ell\dot\theta^2+g\big)=mg\big(1+\tfrac1{\sqrt3}\big)\approx1.577\,mg$.
- $T(\varphi)=mg_{eff}(3\cos\varphi-2\cos30^\circ)$; $T(\theta_e)=mg(2\sqrt3-2)\approx1.46\,mg$; $T_{min}=mg$ at the turning points.
- Phase 2: $\cos\theta_{max}=1-\sqrt3/6$, $\theta_{max}\approx44.66^\circ$ (the swing is $\pm44.66^\circ$ about the vertical; the first turning point is behind the vertical, at $-44.66^\circ$); $T(0)=mg(1+1/\sqrt3)\approx1.58\,mg$.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $a_0$, $g$ and $\ell\dot\theta^2$ are accelerations (m s$^{-2}$); $\omega^2=g_{eff}/\ell$ is s$^{-2}$; $T$ is $m\times$ acceleration = N.
- Limits: $a_0\to0$ gives $\theta_e=0$, $g_{eff}=g$ and the ordinary pendulum; $a_0\gg g$ gives $\theta_e\to-90^\circ$ (the string lies horizontal, behind the support) and $\omega^2\approx a_0/\ell$.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) writing the inertia force with the wrong sign (it is $-m\mathbf a_A$, opposite to the support's acceleration); (2) forgetting that $\mathbf T$ is orthogonal to $\mathbf v_{rel}$ and adding its work; (3) taking the old equilibrium as the centre of the new motion after the support stops: the bob keeps its speed and swings past the vertical; (4) using $g$ instead of $g_{eff}$ in the period.
P06 — Precessing orbit under an attractive inverse-cube perturbation: Binet equation, circular orbits and apsidal advance
A particle $P$ of mass $m$ moves about a fixed centre $O$ (inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$) under the single force
where $r=|\mathbf{OP}|$, $\mathbf e_r=\mathbf{OP}/r$, $\mu>0$ is the gravitational parameter of the centre and $\varepsilon>0$ (units m$^4$ s$^{-2}$) measures a small attractive perturbation (a model perturbation added to the Newtonian attraction). Once the motion is shown to be planar, use polar coordinates $(r,\theta)$ in the plane of the orbit, with $\theta$ measured counter-clockwise from a fixed reference line through $O$, the unit vectors $\mathbf e_r$, $\mathbf e_\theta$ ($\mathbf e_\theta$ points towards increasing $\theta$) and $h=r^2\dot\theta$.
A perigee is a point of minimum $r$ and an apogee a point of maximum $r$. In the numerical part the reference line $\theta=0$ passes through a perigee.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $\mu$, $\varepsilon$ and the initial conditions. Numerical case (part (f)): $\mu=4.0\times10^{14}$ m$^3$ s$^{-2}$; at $t=0$ the particle is at the perigee $r_p=8.0\times10^{6}$ m with the speed $v_p=1.0\times10^{4}$ m/s perpendicular to $\mathbf{OP}$; $\varepsilon=0.19\,h^2$.
- Hypotheses: point particle, $O$ fixed and $S_0$ inertial, no other force.
- Frames: $S_0$ (inertial, Cartesian) and the polar basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta,\mathbf k\}$ attached to $P$, with $\mathbf e_r=\cos\theta\,\mathbf i+\sin\theta\,\mathbf j$ and $\mathbf e_\theta=-\sin\theta\,\mathbf i+\cos\theta\,\mathbf j$ ($\mathbf i$, $\mathbf j$ in the plane of the orbit, $\mathbf k$ along $\mathbf H_O$, see (a)).
- Change of basis:
with rows of unit length ($\cos^2\theta+\sin^2\theta=1$) and mutually orthogonal ($-\cos\theta\sin\theta+\sin\theta\cos\theta=0$), so $[R][R]^T=I$, and $\det[R]=\cos^2\theta+\sin^2\theta=+1$: the polar basis is right-handed, $\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\theta=\mathbf k$.
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Planar motion and conservation of angular momentum
Show that the angular momentum $\mathbf H_O$ of $P$ about $O$ is constant, that the motion takes place in a fixed plane through $O$, and that $h=r^2\dot\theta$ is a constant of the motion. How many degrees of freedom remain?
Step 1. Torque of a central force
$\mathbf F$ is parallel to $\mathbf r=r\,\mathbf e_r$, so
By the angular momentum theorem about a fixed point (Notes §4.8), $\dot{\mathbf H}_O=\mathbf M_O=\mathbf 0$, so $\mathbf H_O=m\,\mathbf r\times\mathbf v$ is a constant vector.
Step 2. Plane of the motion
For every $t$, $\mathbf r\cdot\mathbf H_O=m\,\mathbf r\cdot(\mathbf r\times\mathbf v)=0$ (a triple product with a repeated vector). The position is always orthogonal to the fixed vector $\mathbf H_O$: $P$ moves in the fixed plane through $O$ orthogonal to $\mathbf H_O$ (if $\mathbf H_O=\mathbf 0$ the motion is radial, along a fixed line). Choose $\mathbf k$ along $\mathbf H_O$ (Notes §4.8.1).
Step 3. The constant $h$
In the plane, $\mathbf r=r\,\mathbf e_r$ and, with $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$ (chain rule on $\mathbf e_r(\theta(t))$),
So $h=|\mathbf H_O|/m=r^2\dot\theta$ is constant (twice the areal velocity). The particle has 3 degrees of freedom in space; the plane is fixed by the initial conditions, and in it 2 remain, $r$ and $\theta$, linked by the first integral $h$.
- $\mathbf M_O=\mathbf r\times\mathbf F=\mathbf 0$, so $\mathbf H_O=m\,\mathbf r\times\mathbf v$ is constant.
- $\mathbf r\cdot\mathbf H_O=0$: $P$ stays in the plane through $O$ orthogonal to $\mathbf H_O$; in it $\mathbf H_O=mr^2\dot\theta\,\mathbf k$, so $h=r^2\dot\theta=$ const.
- 2 degrees of freedom, $(r,\theta)$, with one first integral ($h$).
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Equations of motion and energy
Write the equations of motion in polar components. Show that $\mathbf F$ is conservative, find its potential energy, and write the energy integral as a one-dimensional problem in $r$ with an effective potential $U_{eff}(r)$.
Step 1. Acceleration in polar components
Differentiating $\mathbf v=\dot r\,\mathbf e_r+r\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$ with the product rule and $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$, $\dot{\mathbf e}_\theta=-\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_r$:
and $2\dot r\dot\theta+r\ddot\theta=\frac1r\frac{d}{dt}(r^2\dot\theta)$ (product rule: $\frac{d}{dt}(r^2\dot\theta)=2r\dot r\dot\theta+r^2\ddot\theta$).
Step 2. Newton's second law
$m\mathbf a=\mathbf F$ projected on $\mathbf e_r$ and $\mathbf e_\theta$ (Notes §8.3):
The second equation is the conservation of $h$ of part (a).
Step 3. Potential energy
$\mathbf F=f(r)\,\mathbf e_r$ with $f(r)=-m\mu/r^2-m\varepsilon/r^3$ depends only on $r$, so $\mathbf F=-\nabla V$ with $V'(r)=-f(r)$ (Notes §4.4). Choosing $V\to0$ as $r\to\infty$, $V(r)=-\displaystyle\int_\infty^rf(r')\,dr'$. An antiderivative of $-f(r')=\dfrac{m\mu}{r'^2}+\dfrac{m\varepsilon}{r'^3}$ is $G(r')=-\dfrac{m\mu}{r'}-\dfrac{m\varepsilon}{2r'^2}$, and Barrow's rule with $G(r')\to0$ as $r'\to\infty$ gives
Check: $-V'(r)=-\frac{m\mu}{r^2}-\frac{m\varepsilon}{r^3}=f(r)$.
Step 4. Energy integral and effective potential
The only force is conservative, so $E=\tfrac12m|\mathbf v|^2+V$ is constant (Notes §4.5), with $|\mathbf v|^2=\dot r^2+r^2\dot\theta^2=\dot r^2+h^2/r^2$:
The perturbation enters exactly as a reduction of the centrifugal barrier, $h^2\to h^2-\varepsilon$.
- $\ddot r-r\dot\theta^2=-\dfrac{\mu}{r^2}-\dfrac{\varepsilon}{r^3}$ and $\dfrac{d}{dt}(r^2\dot\theta)=0$.
- $V=-\dfrac{m\mu}{r}-\dfrac{m\varepsilon}{2r^2}$.
- $\dfrac Em=\tfrac12\dot r^2+U_{eff}(r)$, $\ U_{eff}=\dfrac{h^2-\varepsilon}{2r^2}-\dfrac{\mu}{r}$.
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Circular orbit and its stability
For a given $h$, find the radius $r_c$ and the speed of the circular orbit. Under what condition does it exist? Is it stable against small radial perturbations? Compare the frequency of the small radial oscillations with the angular rate on the circle.
Step 1. Equilibrium of the radial problem
A positive radius requires $h^2>\varepsilon$. If $h^2\le\varepsilon$ the barrier term is non-positive, $U_{eff}$ decreases monotonically towards $r\to0$, and the particle with $\dot r<0$ falls into the centre: no circular orbit exists.
Step 2. Speed
On the circle $\dot r=0$, so $v_c=r_c\dot\theta=h/r_c$. Equivalently, the radial equation with $\ddot r=0$ gives $r_c\dot\theta^2=\mu/r_c^2+\varepsilon/r_c^3$, i.e. $v_c^2=\mu/r_c+\varepsilon/r_c^2$; with $h^2=\mu r_c+\varepsilon$ both forms agree.
Step 3. Stability
$r_c$ is a minimum of $U_{eff}$: the circular orbit is stable. Linearising $\ddot r=-U_{eff}'(r)$ about $r_c$ with $\rho=r-r_c$ gives $\ddot\rho+U_{eff}''(r_c)\rho=0$, so the radial oscillations have $\omega_r^2=\mu/r_c^3$.
Step 4. Radial frequency versus angular rate
On the circle $\dot\theta_c=h/r_c^2$, so $\dot\theta_c^2=h^2/r_c^4$ and
For $\varepsilon=0$ (Kepler) the ratio is 1: $r$ returns to its minimum exactly once per turn and the slightly perturbed orbit closes (an ellipse). For $\varepsilon>0$ the radial oscillation is slower than the rotation, so the minimum of $r$ is reached after more than one turn: the perigee advances. Part (e) makes this exact for any amplitude.
- $r_c=\dfrac{h^2-\varepsilon}{\mu}$, it exists only if $h^2>\varepsilon$; $v_c^2=\dfrac{h^2}{r_c^2}=\dfrac{\mu}{r_c}+\dfrac{\varepsilon}{r_c^2}$.
- $U_{eff}''(r_c)=\mu/r_c^3>0$: stable. $\omega_r^2=\mu/r_c^3$, $\ \omega_r/\dot\theta_c=\sqrt{1-\varepsilon/h^2}<1$.
Part (d) · 2 points
Binet equation and the orbit
With $u=1/r$ and $\theta$ as the independent variable, derive the Binet equation of this force field, solve it with the perigee at $\theta=0$, and give the perigee and apogee radii.
Step 1. First derivative
$r=1/u$ with $u=u(\theta(t))$. Chain rule:
using $\dot\theta=h/r^2=hu^2$.
Step 2. Second derivative
$h$ is constant, so again by the chain rule
Step 3. Radial equation in $u$
Substitute $\ddot r$, $r\dot\theta^2=\frac1u\,h^2u^4=h^2u^3$, $\mu/r^2=\mu u^2$ and $\varepsilon/r^3=\varepsilon u^3$ in the radial equation of (b):
Dividing by $-h^2u^2$ (Notes §8.3, Eq. 8.12 with the extra term):
Step 4. Solution
With the scalar $k^2=1-\varepsilon/h^2>0$ (not the unit vector $\mathbf k$; the condition $h^2>\varepsilon$ of (c)), this is a forced harmonic oscillator in $\theta$ with "frequency" $k$. A particular solution is the constant $u_0=\mu/(h^2k^2)$; the homogeneous solution is $C\cos(k\theta-\theta_0)$. Choosing $\theta=0$ at a perigee (maximum of $u$) gives $\theta_0=0$ and $C\ge0$; write $C=u_0e$:
Check: $u''=-k^2u_0e\cos k\theta$ and $u''+k^2u=k^2u_0=\mu/h^2$.
Step 5. Apsides
$r$ is minimum where $\cos k\theta=1$ ($\theta=0$) and maximum where $\cos k\theta=-1$ ($k\theta=\pi$):
The shape looks like a conic with semi-parameter $r_c$, but the angle that appears is $k\theta$, not $\theta$: the apogee is reached at $\theta=\pi/k>\pi$.
- $u''+\Big(1-\dfrac{\varepsilon}{h^2}\Big)u=\dfrac{\mu}{h^2}$.
- $u=\dfrac{\mu}{h^2k^2}\big(1+e\cos k\theta\big)$, i.e. $r=\dfrac{r_c}{1+e\cos k\theta}$ with $r_c=\dfrac{h^2-\varepsilon}{\mu}=\dfrac{h^2k^2}{\mu}$.
- $r_p=\dfrac{r_c}{1+e}$ at $\theta=0$; $r_a=\dfrac{r_c}{1-e}$ at $k\theta=\pi$ (bounded orbit if $0\le e<1$).
Part (e) · 1.5 points
Apsidal precession
Find the angle swept between two consecutive perigees and the advance $\Delta\phi$ of the perigee per radial cycle; give its first-order form for $\varepsilon\ll h^2$. Is the orbit closed? Is the time between two perigees the time the particle needs to turn $360^\circ$?
Step 1. Angle between perigees
Perigees are at $\cos k\theta=1$, i.e. $k\theta=0,2\pi,4\pi,\dots$ Two consecutive ones are separated by $\theta=2\pi/k$, and since $k<1$ this is more than one turn. The advance per radial cycle is
positive: the perigee advances in the sense of the motion.
Step 2. Small perturbation
With $x=\varepsilon/h^2\ll1$ and the binomial series $(1-x)^{-1/2}=1+\tfrac12x+O(x^2)$:
Step 3. Closed or not
The orbit closes if after $q$ radial cycles the particle has made an integer number $p$ of turns: $q\,(2\pi/k)=2\pi p$, i.e. $k=q/p$ rational. Otherwise the perigee directions never repeat and the trajectory densely fills the annulus between $r_p$ and $r_a$.
Step 4. Time between perigees (the trap)
Substituting $\dot\theta=h/r^2$ in the radial equation of (b):
This is the radial equation of a Kepler orbit with angular momentum $\tilde h$ and the same $r_p$, $r_a$, so $r(t)$ is periodic with the Kepler period of semi-major axis $a=(r_p+r_a)/2$ (Notes §8.4, Eq. 8.18):
During $T_r$ the angle advances by $2\pi/k$, not $2\pi$: $\dot\theta=h/r^2=(h/\tilde h)\,(\tilde h/r^2)$ and $h/\tilde h=1/k$. The time to turn $360^\circ$ and the time between perigees are different quantities; equating them is the classic error. The energy also matches: at $r_p$, $\frac Em=U_{eff}(r_p)=-\frac{\mu}{2a}$.
- Angle between perigees $2\pi/k$; $\ \Delta\phi=2\pi\Big(\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{1-\varepsilon/h^2}}-1\Big)\approx\dfrac{\pi\varepsilon}{h^2}$.
- Closed only if $k$ is rational; for irrational $k$ the orbit fills the annulus $r_p\le r\le r_a$ (a rosette).
- Time between perigees: the radial period $T_r=2\pi\sqrt{a^3/\mu}$, $2a=r_p+r_a$; in that time $\theta$ advances $2\pi/k$, not $2\pi$.
Part (f) · 2 points
Numerical case
With the data of the Setup ($\mu=4.0\times10^{14}$ m$^3$ s$^{-2}$, $r_p=8.0\times10^6$ m, $v_p=1.0\times10^4$ m/s perpendicular to $\mathbf{OP}$, $\varepsilon=0.19\,h^2$), compute $h$, $\varepsilon$, $k$, $r_c$, $e$, $r_a$, $E/m$, the apsidal advance (exact and first-order), and the time between two perigees. Comment on the value of $v_p$.
Step 1. Constants of the motion
$h=r_pv_p=8.0\times10^6\times1.0\times10^4=8.0\times10^{10}$ m$^2$/s, $h^2=6.4\times10^{21}$ m$^4$ s$^{-2}$, $\varepsilon=0.19\,h^2=1.216\times10^{21}$ m$^4$ s$^{-2}$ and $k=\sqrt{1-0.19}=\sqrt{0.81}=0.9$.
Step 2. Orbit
At $\theta=0$, $r=r_p$: $r_p=r_c/(1+e)\Rightarrow e=r_c/r_p-1=1.62-1=0.62$. Then $r_a=r_c/(1-e)=1.296\times10^7/0.38=3.411\times10^{7}$ m and $a=(r_p+r_a)/2=2.105\times10^{7}$ m.
Step 3. Energy
in agreement with $-\mu/(2a)=-4.0\times10^{14}/(4.211\times10^{7})=-9.50\times10^{6}$ J/kg. Note that $\tfrac12v_p^2=\mu/r_p$: $v_p$ is exactly the escape speed of the unperturbed problem. Without the perturbation the orbit would be a parabola; the extra attraction makes it bound.
Step 4. Precession and times
The first-order formula underestimates by 15 %: $\varepsilon/h^2=0.19$ is not small. The apogee is at $\theta=\pi/k=200^\circ$ and the next perigee at $\theta=400^\circ$. Since $k=9/10$, the orbit closes after 9 radial cycles and 10 turns.
A numerical integration of the equations of (b) from the perigee confirms that $r$ is minimum again after $3.035\times10^4$ s with $\theta=400.0^\circ$.
- $h=8.0\times10^{10}$ m$^2$/s, $\varepsilon=1.216\times10^{21}$ m$^4$ s$^{-2}$, $k=0.9$.
- $r_c=1.296\times10^{7}$ m, $e=0.62$, $r_a=3.411\times10^{7}$ m, $a=2.105\times10^7$ m, $E/m=-9.50\times10^{6}$ J/kg.
- $\Delta\phi=40^\circ$ exactly ($2\pi/9$); first-order estimate $34.2^\circ$; apogee at $\theta=200^\circ$; $T_r=3.035\times10^4$ s.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $\mu/r^2$ and $\varepsilon/r^3$ are accelerations (m$^3$ s$^{-2}$/m$^2$ and m$^4$ s$^{-2}$/m$^3$); $\varepsilon/h^2$ is dimensionless (m$^4$ s$^{-2}$ over m$^4$ s$^{-2}$), so $k$ and $\Delta\phi$ are pure numbers; $r_c=(h^2-\varepsilon)/\mu$ has m$^4$ s$^{-2}$/(m$^3$ s$^{-2}$) = m; $\sqrt{a^3/\mu}$ has s.
- Limits: $\varepsilon\to0$ gives $k=1$, $\Delta\phi=0$, the conic $r=(h^2/\mu)/(1+e\cos\theta)$ of Notes Eq. 8.14 and $T_r$ equal to the orbital period. $\varepsilon\to h^2$ gives $k\to0$: the barrier disappears, $\Delta\phi\to\infty$ and $r_c\to0$ (the particle spirals in).
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) dropping the $\varepsilon u^3$ term when changing to $u$, or writing it on the wrong side, which changes the sign of the precession; (2) treating the orbit as a closed ellipse with $\theta$ in place of $k\theta$ (apogee at $180^\circ$); (3) taking the time between perigees as the time for one turn, or dividing $\Delta\phi$ by the period of a Kepler orbit with $h$ instead of $\tilde h$; (4) using the first-order $\pi\varepsilon/h^2$ when $\varepsilon/h^2$ is not small.
P07 — Insertion orbit and circularisation impulse: conic from the energy, apsides, apogee burn and time of flight
A probe $P$ of mass $m$ moves in the gravitational field of a planet of centre $O$, radius $R$ and gravitational parameter $\mu$: the only force is $\mathbf F=-\dfrac{m\mu}{r^2}\mathbf e_r$, with $r=|\mathbf{OP}|$, $\mathbf e_r=\mathbf{OP}/r$; $O$ is fixed and the frame $S_0$ attached to it is inertial. At $t=0$ the probe is at the distance $r_0$ from $O$ and its velocity $\mathbf v_0$ has the magnitude
(the local circular speed) and makes the flight-path angle $\gamma=30^\circ$ with the local horizontal, pointing away from the planet. Use polar coordinates $(r,\theta)$ in the orbital plane, with $\theta$ (the true anomaly) measured from the perigee $\Pi$ of the conic in the sense of the motion ($\Pi$ is a virtual point: with the data below it lies inside the planet, so the probe never reaches it; the trajectory arc starts at the surface $r=R$), the unit vectors $\mathbf e_r$, $\mathbf e_\theta$ and $h=r^2\dot\theta>0$. The local horizontal at $P$ is the direction of $\mathbf e_\theta$, so $\mathbf v_0=v_0(\sin\gamma\,\mathbf e_r+\cos\gamma\,\mathbf e_\theta)$.
When the probe reaches the apogee $A$, its engine fires a short tangential impulse $\Delta\mathbf v$ that puts it on the circular orbit of radius $r_a=|\mathbf{OA}|$.
Setup
- Data: $\mu$, $r_0$, $v_0=\sqrt{\mu/r_0}$, $\gamma=30^\circ$. Numerical part (f): $\mu=4.0\times10^{14}$ m$^3$ s$^{-2}$, $r_0=1.0\times10^{7}$ m, $R=6.0\times10^{6}$ m.
- Hypotheses: point particle; planet's field spherically symmetric; no drag; the impulse is instantaneous (the position does not change during the burn) and the mass of propellant is irrelevant for the kinematics.
- Frames: $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ with $\mathbf i$ towards $\Pi$, $\mathbf j$ in the orbital plane and $\mathbf k$ along $\mathbf H_O$; polar basis $\mathbf e_r=\cos\theta\,\mathbf i+\sin\theta\,\mathbf j$, $\mathbf e_\theta=-\sin\theta\,\mathbf i+\cos\theta\,\mathbf j$. Change of basis:
with $[R][R]^T=I$ (rows of length $\cos^2\theta+\sin^2\theta=1$, rows 1 and 2 orthogonal: $-\cos\theta\sin\theta+\sin\theta\cos\theta=0$) and $\det[R]=\cos^2\theta+\sin^2\theta=+1$, so $\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\theta=\mathbf k$.
- Results from Notes §8.4 used: orbit $r=p/(1+e\cos\theta)$ with $p=h^2/\mu$ (Eq. 8.14), $p=a(1-e^2)$ (Eq. 8.16), $r_p=a(1-e)$, $r_a=a(1+e)$, period $\tau=2\pi\sqrt{a^3/\mu}$ (Eq. 8.18); vis-viva $v^2=\mu(2/r-1/a)$ (Notes §8.5).
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Conserved quantities and type of conic
Explain why $h$ and the energy per unit mass $E/m$ are constant. Compute them from the initial conditions and decide the type of conic and its semi-major axis $a$.
Step 1. Why they are conserved
$\mathbf F$ is central, so its torque about $O$ is $\mathbf r\times\mathbf F=\mathbf 0$ and $\mathbf H_O$ is constant (Notes §4.8); the motion is planar and $h=r^2\dot\theta$ is constant (Notes §4.8.1). $\mathbf F=-\nabla V$ with $V=-m\mu/r$, and it is the only force, so the mechanical energy $E=\tfrac12mv^2-m\mu/r$ is constant (Notes §4.5).
Step 2. Angular momentum
With $\mathbf r=r_0\,\mathbf e_r$ and $\mathbf v_0=v_0(\sin\gamma\,\mathbf e_r+\cos\gamma\,\mathbf e_\theta)$:
Step 3. Energy and conic
A negative energy means a bounded orbit: an ellipse. The vis-viva equation (Notes §8.5) gives $E/m=-\mu/(2a)$, so $a=r_0$. Note the trap: the probe has exactly the circular speed of its radius, yet the orbit is not a circle, because the velocity is not horizontal; the speed fixes $a$ only, the direction fixes the shape.
- $h=r_0v_0\cos\gamma=\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}\sqrt{\mu r_0}$, $\ h^2=\tfrac34\mu r_0$.
- $E/m=\tfrac12v_0^2-\mu/r_0=-\dfrac{\mu}{2r_0}<0$: ellipse, $a=-\dfrac{\mu}{2E/m}=r_0$.
Part (b) · 2 points
Shape of the orbit and apsides
Find the semi-latus rectum $p$, the eccentricity $e$ and the perigee and apogee radii $r_p$, $r_a$. Verify the apsides independently from the energy equation.
Step 1. Semi-latus rectum
Step 2. Eccentricity
From $p=a(1-e^2)$ (Notes Eq. 8.16): $e^2=1-p/a=1-\tfrac34=\tfrac14$, so $e=\tfrac12$. Substituting $a=-\mu/(2E/m)$ and $p=h^2/\mu$ gives the general formula $e^2=1+2(E/m)h^2/\mu^2=1+2\big(-\tfrac{\mu}{2r_0}\big)\tfrac{3\mu r_0}{4\mu^2}=1-\tfrac34$, the same value.
Step 3. Apsides
and indeed $r_p+r_a=2a$.
Step 4. Independent check
With $v^2=\dot r^2+h^2/r^2$, the energy at an apsis ($\dot r=0$) reads $\dfrac{h^2}{2r^2}-\dfrac{\mu}{r}=\dfrac Em$. Multiplying by $2r^2/\mu$ with $h^2=\tfrac34\mu r_0$ and $E/m=-\mu/(2r_0)$:
the same $r_p=r_0/2$ and $r_a=3r_0/2$.
- $p=\tfrac34r_0$, $\ e=\sqrt{1-p/a}=\tfrac12$ (equivalently $e^2=1+2(E/m)h^2/\mu^2$).
- $r_p=a(1-e)=\tfrac12r_0$, $\ r_a=a(1+e)=\tfrac32r_0$.
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Position on the orbit, apsidal speeds and period
Find the true anomaly $\theta_0$ of the initial point (justify the sign), the speeds $v_p$, $v_a$ at the apsides of the conic ($v_p$ is the speed the conic would have at its virtual perigee) and the period $\tau$ of the full ellipse.
Step 1. True anomaly
so $\theta_0=\pm120^\circ$.
Step 2. Sign from the radial velocity
Differentiating $r=p\,(1+e\cos\theta)^{-1}$ with the chain rule and $\dot\theta=h/r^2$:
The velocity points away from the planet, $\dot r=v_0\sin\gamma>0$, so $\sin\theta_0>0$ and $\theta_0=+120^\circ$. Check: $\frac{\mu}{h}\,\frac12\,\frac{\sqrt3}2=\frac{\mu}{\sqrt3\sqrt{\mu r_0}}\frac{\sqrt3}{2}=\frac12\sqrt{\mu/r_0}=v_0\sin30^\circ$.
Step 3. Apsidal speeds
At the apsides the velocity is perpendicular to $\mathbf r$ ($\dot r=0$), so $v=h/r$:
Vis-viva check at the apogee: $\mu\big(\tfrac{2}{r_a}-\tfrac1a\big)=\tfrac{\mu}{r_0}\big(\tfrac43-1\big)=\tfrac{\mu}{3r_0}=v_a^2$.
Step 4. Period
Kepler's third law (Notes Eq. 8.18) with $a=r_0$: $\ \tau=2\pi\sqrt{a^3/\mu}=2\pi\sqrt{r_0^3/\mu}$.
- $\cos\theta_0=-\tfrac12$ and $\dot r>0$, so $\theta_0=+120^\circ$ (outbound, between perigee and apogee).
- $v_p=h/r_p=\sqrt3\sqrt{\mu/r_0}$, $\ v_a=h/r_a=\sqrt{\mu/r_0}/\sqrt3$; $\ \tau=2\pi\sqrt{r_0^3/\mu}$.
Part (d) · 2 points
Circularisation impulse at the apogee
Compute the impulse $\Delta\mathbf v$ (magnitude and direction) that makes the orbit circular at $r_a$, the change of energy per unit mass and the ratio of the new period to $\tau$. Why is the apogee the right place for a purely tangential burn?
Step 1. Why the apogee
A circular orbit has $\dot r=0$ everywhere, so its velocity is perpendicular to $\mathbf r$. At the apogee $\dot r=0$ already: the velocity $v_a\,\mathbf e_\theta$ is horizontal and only its magnitude has to change. At any other point the burn would also have to cancel $\dot r$, so it could not be purely tangential.
Step 2. Impulse
The circular speed at $r_a$ follows from $\mu/r_a^2=v^2/r_a$ (or from vis-viva with $a=r_a$):
positive: the engine pushes forward, in the direction of motion.
Step 3. Energy
The position does not change during the burn, so only the kinetic energy changes:
Check with $E/m=-\mu/(2a)$: $-\dfrac{\mu}{2r_a}+\dfrac{\mu}{2a}=-\dfrac{\mu}{3r_0}+\dfrac{\mu}{2r_0}=\dfrac{\mu}{6r_0}$.
Step 4. New period
$\tau_{circ}=2\pi\sqrt{r_a^3/\mu}$, so $\tau_{circ}/\tau=(r_a/a)^{3/2}=(3/2)^{3/2}\approx1.837$.
- $v_{circ}=\sqrt{\mu/r_a}=\sqrt{2/3}\,\sqrt{\mu/r_0}$; $\ \Delta v=v_{circ}-v_a=\dfrac{\sqrt2-1}{\sqrt3}\sqrt{\dfrac{\mu}{r_0}}\approx0.239\sqrt{\mu/r_0}$, along $+\mathbf e_\theta$ (prograde).
- $\Delta E/m=\tfrac12(v_{circ}^2-v_a^2)=\dfrac{\mu}{6r_0}>0$; $\ \tau_{circ}/\tau=(3/2)^{3/2}\approx1.837$.
Part (e) · 1.5 points
Time of flight from $r_0$ to the apogee
Compute the time the probe needs to go from the initial point to the apogee. Show that it is not $\tau\cdot(60^\circ/360^\circ)$. (Extension: use the eccentric anomaly $\mathcal E$, defined by $r=a(1-e\cos\mathcal E)$.)
Step 1. Eccentric anomaly (extension)
Define $\mathcal E$ by $r=a(1-e\cos\mathcal E)$; it runs from $0$ at the perigee to $\pi$ at the apogee. Equating with $r=p/(1+e\cos\theta)$ and $p=a(1-e^2)$ and solving for $\cos\mathcal E$:
At $\theta_0=120^\circ$: $\cos\mathcal E_0=(\tfrac12-\tfrac12)/(1-\tfrac14)=0$, so $\mathcal E_0=\pi/2$ (outbound branch); check $r=a(1-0)=r_0$. At the apogee $\mathcal E=\pi$.
Step 2. Kepler's equation
The energy equation $\dot r^2+h^2/r^2=\mu(2/r-1/a)$ with $h^2=\mu a(1-e^2)$ gives
Substituting $r=a(1-e\cos\mathcal E)$: $2ar-r^2-a^2(1-e^2)=a^2\big[2-2e\cos\mathcal E-1+2e\cos\mathcal E-e^2\cos^2\mathcal E-1+e^2\big]=a^2e^2\sin^2\mathcal E$. Hence $\dot r=\pm\sqrt{\mu/a}\;a\,e\sin\mathcal E/r$. With $\mathcal E$ increasing along the motion, $\sin\mathcal E>0$ on the outbound branch ($0<\mathcal E<\pi$, $\dot r>0$) and $\sin\mathcal E<0$ on the inbound branch ($\pi<\mathcal E<2\pi$, $\dot r<0$), so the sign is $+$ on both branches: $\dot r=\sqrt{\mu/a}\;a\,e\sin\mathcal E/r$ for every $\mathcal E$. On the other hand, by the chain rule $\dot r=a\,e\sin\mathcal E\,\dot{\mathcal E}$, also valid on both branches. Equating (and, at the apses where $\sin\mathcal E=0$, by continuity):
Step 3. Integration with Barrow's rule
The antiderivative of $1-e\cos\mathcal E$ is $\mathcal E-e\sin\mathcal E$, so
and with $1/n=\sqrt{r_0^3/\mu}$ (because $a=r_0$): $\ t_{0\to A}=\big(\tfrac{\pi}{2}+\tfrac12\big)\sqrt{r_0^3/\mu}\approx2.071\sqrt{r_0^3/\mu}$. As a fraction of the period, $(\pi/2+1/2)/(2\pi)\approx0.330$.
Step 4. The trap
The angle swept is $60^\circ$, one sixth of a turn, but the time is a third of the period: near the apogee the probe is slow ($\dot\theta=h/r^2$ is small), so equal angles do not take equal times. A direct numerical quadrature of $dt=r^2\,d\theta/h$ from $120^\circ$ to $180^\circ$ gives the same $\pi/2+1/2$.
- $\cos\mathcal E=\dfrac{e+\cos\theta}{1+e\cos\theta}$: $\ \mathcal E_0=90^\circ$ at $\theta_0=120^\circ$, $\ \mathcal E=180^\circ$ at the apogee.
- $t_{0\to A}=\dfrac{1}{n}\big[\mathcal E-e\sin\mathcal E\big]_{\pi/2}^{\pi}=\Big(\dfrac{\pi}{2}+\dfrac12\Big)\sqrt{\dfrac{r_0^3}{\mu}}\approx0.330\,\tau$, twice the naive $\tau/6\approx0.167\,\tau$.
Part (f) · 1.5 points
Numerical values and a failed burn
With $\mu=4.0\times10^{14}$ m$^3$ s$^{-2}$, $r_0=1.0\times10^7$ m: compute $v_0$, $h$, $v_p$, $v_a$, $\tau$, $\Delta v$, $\Delta E/m$ and $t_{0\to A}$. If the engine had failed at the apogee, would the probe have survived, given the planet radius $R=6.0\times10^6$ m? If not, at which true anomaly and how long after the apogee would it hit the surface?
Step 1. Numbers
$\sqrt{\mu/r_0}=\sqrt{4.0\times10^7}=6325$ m/s $=v_0$ and $\sqrt{r_0^3/\mu}=\sqrt{2.5\times10^6}=1581$ s. Then $h=\tfrac{\sqrt3}2r_0v_0=5.477\times10^{10}$ m$^2$/s, $v_p=\sqrt3\times6325=1.095\times10^4$ m/s, $v_a=6325/\sqrt3=3651$ m/s, $\tau=2\pi\times1581=9935$ s, $v_{circ}=5164$ m/s, $\Delta v=5164-3651=1512$ m/s, $\Delta E/m=\mu/(6r_0)=6.67\times10^6$ J/kg, $\tau_{circ}=1.825\times10^4$ s and $t_{0\to A}=2.071\times1581=3274$ s, against the naive $\tau/6=1656$ s.
Step 2. Failed burn
$r_p=r_0/2=5.0\times10^6$ m is smaller than $R=6.0\times10^6$ m: after the apogee the probe would descend into the planet. Impact: $7.5\times10^6/(1+\tfrac12\cos\theta)=6.0\times10^6\Rightarrow\cos\theta=\tfrac12$, and on the inbound branch ($\dot r<0$, $\sin\theta<0$) $\theta=300^\circ$. There $\cos\mathcal E=(\tfrac12+\tfrac12)/(1+\tfrac14)=\tfrac45$ with $\mathcal E$ in $(\pi,2\pi)$: $\mathcal E_i=2\pi-\arccos\tfrac45=5.640$ rad, $\sin\mathcal E_i=-\tfrac35$.
Step 3. Time to impact
The circularisation burn is therefore not optional: it also raises the perigee from $0.5\,r_0$ to $1.5\,r_0$.
- $v_0=6325$ m/s, $h=5.477\times10^{10}$ m$^2$/s, $v_p=1.095\times10^4$ m/s, $v_a=3651$ m/s, $\tau=9935$ s, $\Delta v=1512$ m/s, $\Delta E/m=6.67\times10^6$ J/kg, $t_{0\to A}=3274$ s (naive: 1656 s).
- $r_p=5.0\times10^6$ m $<R$: impact at $\theta=300^\circ$ ($\cos\theta=\tfrac12$, $\cos\mathcal E=\tfrac45$), $4424$ s after the apogee.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $h=r_0v_0$ in m$^2$/s; $h^2/\mu$ in m$^4$ s$^{-2}$/(m$^3$ s$^{-2}$) = m; $E/m$ and $\mu/r$ in m$^2$ s$^{-2}$ = J/kg; $\sqrt{a^3/\mu}$ in s; $\Delta v$ in m/s.
- Limits: $\gamma\to0$ with $v_0=\sqrt{\mu/r_0}$ gives $h^2=\mu r_0$, $e=0$: the probe is already on the circle of radius $r_0$. $\gamma\to90^\circ$ gives $h=0$: a radial (degenerate) orbit, straight up and back down. For any $\gamma$, $a=r_0$, so the period does not depend on $\gamma$.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) concluding that the orbit is circular because $v_0=\sqrt{\mu/r_0}$; (2) using $h=r_0v_0$ without $\cos\gamma$; (3) taking $\theta_0=-120^\circ$ (the inbound point) without checking the sign of $\dot r$; (4) computing $\Delta v$ as $v_{circ}(r_0)-v_0$ or applying it at $r_0$; (5) converting angles into times with $\tau\,\Delta\theta/2\pi$, which is wrong for any $e\ne0$.
P08 — Seismic accelerometer on a vibrating base: inertia force, frequency response and the two operating regimes
A vibration sensor is a rigid case whose floor is bolted to a structure that moves vertically with the prescribed law $z(t)=Z\cos\nu t$ ($Z>0$, $\nu>0$), where $z$ is the height of the case floor above a fixed datum, measured along the upward vertical axis $y$ of the inertial frame $S_0$. Inside the case, a proof mass $m$ (a particle that can only move along the vertical) is joined to the case floor by a linear spring of stiffness $k$ and natural length $L_0$ and by a linear viscous damper of constant $c$ (force $-c$ times the velocity of the mass relative to the case). Uniform gravity $-g\,\mathbf j$ acts.
Let $S_1$ be the frame attached to the case. The relative coordinate $x$ is the height of the mass in $S_1$ measured from its static equilibrium level (the level where it rests when $z\equiv0$), positive upwards. Write $\omega_0=\sqrt{k/m}$ and $\zeta=c/(2\sqrt{km})$ (the Notes' damping parameter is $\gamma=c/(2m)=\zeta\omega_0$), and assume $0<\zeta<1$.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $k$, $c$, $L_0$, $g$, $Z$, $\nu$. Numerical part (f): $m=0.050$ kg, $k=500$ N/m, $c=2.0$ N s/m, $Z=2.0$ mm, $\nu=50$ rad/s, $g=9.81$ m/s$^2$.
- Hypotheses: point mass with vertical motion only (lateral guides are smooth), massless spring and damper, linear laws, $S_0$ inertial.
- Frames: $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j\}$ fixed; $S_1$ attached to the case, a translating frame: $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\mathbf 0$, origin acceleration $\ddot z\,\mathbf j$.
- Notation: $x$ is the vertical relative coordinate of the mass (along $\mathbf j$), not a coordinate along the horizontal axis $\mathbf i$ of $S_0$.
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Degrees of freedom, frames and kinematics
How many degrees of freedom does the mass have? Write the absolute position, velocity and acceleration of the mass in terms of $z$ and $x$, and identify the relative and the transport (dragging) acceleration.
Step 1. Degrees of freedom
The mass can only move along the vertical: 1 coordinate. The case is not a body of the problem but a prescribed motion, so it adds no unknown; the constraint "the mass moves on the vertical line of the case" is rheonomic in $S_0$ and fixed in $S_1$. The coordinate is $x$.
Step 2. Absolute kinematics
Let $\xi$ be the height of the mass above the case floor, so the absolute height is $y_P=z+\xi$, and $\xi=\xi_e+x$ with $\xi_e$ constant (found in (b)). Differentiating twice ($\xi_e$ is constant):
Step 3. Relative-motion reading
$S_1$ translates, so $\mathbf a_P=\mathbf a_{O_1}+\mathbf a_{rel}$ (Notes §3.2 with $\boldsymbol\omega=\mathbf 0$): transport acceleration $\ddot z\,\mathbf j$ with, by the chain rule on $\cos(\nu t)$, $\dot z=-\nu Z\sin\nu t$ and $\ddot z=-\nu^2Z\cos\nu t$; relative acceleration $\ddot x\,\mathbf j$; the Coriolis term $2\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf v_{rel}$ vanishes.
- 1 degree of freedom, $x(t)$; $z(t)$ is prescribed (rheonomic constraint).
- $y_P=z+\xi_e+x$, $\ \mathbf a_P=(\ddot z+\ddot x)\,\mathbf j$; $\mathbf a_{rel}=\ddot x\,\mathbf j$, transport $\ddot z\,\mathbf j=-\nu^2Z\cos\nu t\,\mathbf j$, no Coriolis term.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Forces in the case frame and static equilibrium
List the forces on the mass in $S_1$, including the inertia force, in terms of $\xi$ and $\dot\xi$. Find the static equilibrium height $\xi_e$ for $z\equiv0$ and the static deflection of the spring.
Step 1. Applied forces
- Spring: elongation $\xi-L_0$; the force on the mass is $\mathbf F_s=-k(\xi-L_0)\,\mathbf j$.
- Damper: opposes the velocity relative to the case, $\mathbf F_d=-c\dot\xi\,\mathbf j=-c\dot x\,\mathbf j$.
- Weight: $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j$.
- Guides: a smooth lateral reaction $\mathbf N$, horizontal; it has no vertical component and does no work.
Step 2. Inertia force
In the translating frame $S_1$ the relative-motion law is $m\mathbf a_{rel}=\sum\mathbf F-m\mathbf a_{O_1}$ (Notes §4.9), so
When the case accelerates upwards ($\ddot z>0$) the mass feels pushed down, as in a lift.
Step 3. Static equilibrium
With $z\equiv0$ there is no inertia force and at rest $\dot\xi=0$:
The spring is compressed by $\delta_{st}=mg/k$ and carries the weight.
- $\mathbf F_s=-k(\xi-L_0)\,\mathbf j$, $\ \mathbf F_d=-c\dot\xi\,\mathbf j$, $\ \mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j$, $\ \mathbf F_{in}=-m\ddot z\,\mathbf j=m\nu^2Z\cos\nu t\,\mathbf j$; lateral reaction $\mathbf N\perp\mathbf j$.
- $\xi_e=L_0-mg/k$; static deflection $\delta_{st}=mg/k$ (spring compressed).
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Equation of motion
Project the relative-motion law on $\mathbf j$ and obtain the equation of motion for $x$. Explain why $g$ does not appear, and write the equation in the normalised form with $\omega_0$ and $\zeta$.
Step 1. Projection
Step 2. Change of variable
With $\xi=\xi_e+x$, $\dot\xi=\dot x$, $\ddot\xi=\ddot x$ and $-k(\xi_e+x-L_0)=-kx-k(\xi_e-L_0)=-kx+mg$ (from (b)):
The weight is a constant force; measuring $x$ from the static equilibrium absorbs it into the spring preload, so it drops out of the dynamics. This is true only because the spring is linear: the same constant offset works at every $x$.
Step 3. Normal form
Dividing by $m$, with $k/m=\omega_0^2$ and $c/m=2\zeta\omega_0$:
This is Notes Eq. 5.32 with the force amplitude $F_1=m\nu^2Z$: the base motion acts as a harmonic force whose amplitude grows with $\nu^2$. Extension (Lagrange equations are not in the course notes): cross-check by Lagrange in $S_0$: $T=\tfrac12m(\dot z+\dot\xi)^2$, $V=mg(z+\xi)+\tfrac12k(\xi-L_0)^2$ and the damper's generalised force $-c\dot\xi$ give the same equation.
- $m\ddot x+c\dot x+kx=m\nu^2Z\cos\nu t$.
- $\ddot x+2\zeta\omega_0\dot x+\omega_0^2x=\nu^2Z\cos\nu t$; $g$ is cancelled by the static preload of the spring.
Part (d) · 2 points
Steady-state response
Using the complex representation, find the amplitude $X$ and the phase $\varphi$ of the steady-state solution $x_p=X\cos(\nu t+\varphi)$, and write $X/Z$ as a function of $r=\nu/\omega_0$ and $\zeta$. What is the complete solution?
Step 1. Complex equation
The real forcing is $\nu^2Z\cos\nu t=\mathrm{Re}\big(\nu^2Ze^{i\nu t}\big)$ (Notes §5.2 and §5.4). With $\tilde x=Ae^{i\nu t}$: $\dot{\tilde x}=i\nu\tilde x$, $\ddot{\tilde x}=-\nu^2\tilde x$ (chain rule on the exponential), and
Step 2. Amplitude and phase
Writing $A=Xe^{i\varphi}$, $|A|$ is the modulus of the numerator over that of the denominator:
so $\tan\varphi=-2\zeta\omega_0\nu/(\omega_0^2-\nu^2)$; the imaginary part of the denominator is positive, hence $-\pi<\varphi<0$ (the mass lags behind the forcing, Notes Eq. 5.42). The real part is $x_p=X\cos(\nu t+\varphi)$.
Step 3. Dimensionless form
Dividing numerator and denominator by $\omega_0^2$ with $r=\nu/\omega_0$:
Step 4. Complete solution
Add the general solution of the homogeneous equation (Notes Eq. 5.26, underdamped): $x=X\cos(\nu t+\varphi)+a\,e^{-\zeta\omega_0t}\cos(\omega_0\sqrt{1-\zeta^2}\,t+\beta)$, with $a$, $\beta$ fixed by the initial conditions. The second term is the transient.
- $A=\dfrac{\nu^2Z}{\omega_0^2-\nu^2+2i\zeta\omega_0\nu}$; $\ X=|A|=\dfrac{\nu^2Z}{\sqrt{(\omega_0^2-\nu^2)^2+4\zeta^2\omega_0^2\nu^2}}$.
- $\tan\varphi=-\dfrac{2\zeta\omega_0\nu}{\omega_0^2-\nu^2}$ with $-\pi<\varphi<0$; $\ \dfrac XZ=\dfrac{r^2}{\sqrt{(1-r^2)^2+(2\zeta r)^2}}$.
- $x=X\cos(\nu t+\varphi)+a\,e^{-\zeta\omega_0t}\cos(\omega_0\sqrt{1-\zeta^2}\,t+\beta)$.
Part (e) · 2 points
Operating regimes and the resonant peak
Discuss the limits $\nu\ll\omega_0$ and $\nu\gg\omega_0$: what does $x$ measure in each case? Then find the forcing frequency at which $X$ is maximum and the maximum value of $X/Z$. Is it at $\nu=\omega_0$, or at $\omega_0\sqrt{1-2\zeta^2}$ as in Notes §5.4.1?
Step 1. Low frequency: accelerometer
For $r\to0$ the denominator tends to 1 and $\varphi\to0$: $X\approx r^2Z=\nu^2Z/\omega_0^2$ and
The relative displacement is proportional to the acceleration of the base: the spring force $kx$ supplies the force $-m\ddot z$ the mass needs to follow the case.
Step 2. High frequency: vibrometer
For $r\to\infty$: $X/Z\to r^2/r^2=1$ and $\tan\varphi=2\zeta r/(r^2-1)\to0^+$ with $\varphi$ in the third quadrant, so $\varphi\to-\pi$, so $x\approx Z\cos(\nu t-\pi)=-z$. The absolute height $y_P=z+\xi_e+x\approx\xi_e$ is constant: the mass cannot follow the fast motion and stays still in $S_0$, so $x$ measures the displacement of the base.
Step 3. Maximum of the response
$(X/Z)^2=f(s)=s^2/D$ with $D=(1-s)^2+4\zeta^2s$ and $D'=-2(1-s)+4\zeta^2$. By the quotient rule, $f'(s)=0$ requires $2sD-s^2D'=0$, i.e. $2D=sD'$:
which is admissible ($s>0$) for $\zeta<1/\sqrt2$. Then $1-s=-2\zeta^2/(1-2\zeta^2)$ and
so $\nu_{peak}=\omega_0/\sqrt{1-2\zeta^2}$ and $(X/Z)_{max}=1/\big(2\zeta\sqrt{1-\zeta^2}\big)$.
Step 4. The trap
The Notes' resonant frequency $\sqrt{\omega_0^2-2\gamma^2}=\omega_0\sqrt{1-2\zeta^2}$ (Eq. 5.46) is for a force of constant amplitude $F_1$. Here the forcing $m\nu^2Z$ grows with $\nu^2$, which shifts the maximum of the relative amplitude above $\omega_0$. Neither $\nu=\omega_0$ (where $X/Z=1/(2\zeta)$) nor $\omega_0\sqrt{1-2\zeta^2}$ is the peak.
- $\nu\ll\omega_0$: $x\approx\nu^2Z\cos\nu t/\omega_0^2=-\ddot z/\omega_0^2$ (accelerometer). $\nu\gg\omega_0$: $X\to Z$, $\varphi\to-\pi$, $x\approx-z$ (the mass stays still in $S_0$: vibrometer).
- Peak at $r^2=\dfrac{1}{1-2\zeta^2}$, i.e. $\nu_{peak}=\dfrac{\omega_0}{\sqrt{1-2\zeta^2}}>\omega_0$ (for $\zeta<1/\sqrt2$); $\ \Big(\dfrac XZ\Big)_{max}=\dfrac{1}{2\zeta\sqrt{1-\zeta^2}}$.
Part (f) · 1.5 points
Numerical case
With the data of the Setup, compute $\omega_0$, $\zeta$, the static deflection, $X$, $\varphi$, the energy dissipated per cycle, the decay of the transient, and the error of an accelerometer that reads $\omega_0^2X$ as the base acceleration amplitude. Locate the resonant peak.
Step 1. Parameters
$\omega_0=\sqrt{500/0.050}=100$ rad/s, $\zeta=2.0/(2\sqrt{500\times0.050})=2.0/10=0.2$, $r=50/100=0.5$, $\delta_{st}=mg/k=0.050\times9.81/500=9.81\times10^{-4}$ m $=0.981$ mm.
Step 2. Amplitude and phase
Step 3. Energy per cycle
With $\dot x=-\nu X\sin(\nu t+\varphi)$ and $\int_0^{2\pi/\nu}\sin^2(\nu t+\varphi)\,dt=\pi/\nu$ (the antiderivative of $\sin^2u$ is $\tfrac u2-\tfrac{\sin2u}{4}$, evaluated between $u=\varphi$ and $u=\varphi+2\pi$):
In steady state this equals the work done per cycle by the inertia force $m\nu^2Z\cos\nu t$ on the relative motion.
Step 4. Transient
The homogeneous part decays as $e^{-\zeta\omega_0t}=e^{-20t}$: relaxation time $1/(\zeta\omega_0)=0.05$ s, and $e^{-20t}=0.01$ at $t=\ln100/20=0.230$ s. It oscillates at $\omega_d=\omega_0\sqrt{1-\zeta^2}=97.98$ rad/s.
Step 5. Accelerometer error and peak
The true acceleration amplitude is $\nu^2Z=2500\times0.002=5.0$ m/s$^2$; the instrument reads $\omega_0^2X=10^4\times6.442\times10^{-4}=6.44$ m/s$^2$, i.e. $+28.8$ %: at $r=0.5$ with $\zeta=0.2$ the sensor is too close to resonance. The peak is at $\nu_{peak}=100/\sqrt{0.92}=104.3$ rad/s with $X/Z=1/(0.4\sqrt{0.96})=2.552$, $X=5.10$ mm.
- $\omega_0=100$ rad/s, $\zeta=0.2$, $r=0.5$, $\delta_{st}=0.981$ mm.
- $X=0.644$ mm, $\varphi=-14.93^\circ$; $W=\pi c\nu X^2=1.30\times10^{-4}$ J per cycle.
- Transient $\propto e^{-20t}$ (relaxation time 0.05 s, below 1 % after 0.230 s), $\omega_d=97.98$ rad/s.
- $\omega_0^2X=6.44$ m/s$^2$ against $\nu^2Z=5.0$ m/s$^2$: $+28.8$ % error; peak at $\nu=104.3$ rad/s with $X=2.552\,Z=5.10$ mm.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $\omega_0^2=k/m$ in (N/m)/kg = s$^{-2}$; $\zeta=c/(2\sqrt{km})$ in (N s/m)/(kg s$^{-1}$) = 1; $\nu^2Z$ in m s$^{-2}$, the same as $\omega_0^2x$; $W=\pi c\nu X^2$ in (N s/m)(s$^{-1}$)(m$^2$) = J.
- Limits: $\zeta\to0$ gives $X/Z=r^2/|1-r^2|$, infinite at $r=1$; $Z\to0$ leaves the free damped oscillator of Notes §5.3. With $\zeta\approx0.7$ the factor $1/\sqrt{(1-r^2)^2+(2\zeta r)^2}$ stays close to 1 over a wide band (at $r=0.5$ it is 0.975, a $-2.5$ % error), which is why real accelerometers are built with that damping.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) writing the inertia force as $+m\ddot z$, or forgetting it and writing the spring force with the absolute coordinate; (2) keeping $mg$ in the equation after measuring $x$ from the static equilibrium (or dropping it when $x$ is measured from the natural length); (3) taking the peak at $\nu=\omega_0$ or at $\omega_0\sqrt{1-2\zeta^2}$; (4) choosing $\varphi$ in the wrong quadrant with the arctangent above resonance.
P09 — Bead on a vertical hoop held by a spring: reaction, equilibria and a pitchfork bifurcation
A smooth circular hoop of radius $a$ and centre $C$ is fixed in a vertical plane. A bead $P$ of mass $m$ is threaded on it (it can neither leave the hoop nor the plane). A linear spring of stiffness $k$ and natural length $l_0$ joins $P$ to the fixed point $A$, which lies on the vertical through $C$ at the height $d=2a$ above $C$. The natural length is $l_0=d-a=a$, so the spring is unstretched when the bead is at the top $T$ of the hoop. Gravity $-g\,\mathbf j$ acts. The position of the bead is given by the angle $\theta$ between $\mathbf{CT}$ (upward vertical) and $\mathbf{CP}$, positive clockwise in the figure (towards $+x$).
Use the inertial frame $S_0=\{C;\mathbf i,\mathbf j\}$ ($\mathbf i$ horizontal, $\mathbf j$ upward) and the unit vectors $\mathbf e_r=\sin\theta\,\mathbf i+\cos\theta\,\mathbf j$ (along $\mathbf{CP}$) and $\mathbf e_\theta=\cos\theta\,\mathbf i-\sin\theta\,\mathbf j$ (tangent to the hoop, towards increasing $\theta$). The results are expressed with the dimensionless stiffness
Setup
- Data: $m$, $a$, $k$, $g$; $d=2a$, $l_0=a$. Numerical values in (e) and (f): $a=0.40$ m, $g=9.81$ m/s$^2$.
- Hypotheses: point particle; smooth, rigid, fixed hoop (bilateral constraint); massless linear spring that can be stretched or compressed; $S_0$ inertial.
- Spring length: $l=|\mathbf{AP}|$ with $\mathbf{AP}=a\,\mathbf e_r-d\,\mathbf j$.
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Degrees of freedom, geometry and potential energy
How many degrees of freedom has the bead? Find the spring length $l(\theta)$ and the total potential energy $V(\theta)$; check that the applied forces are conservative.
Step 1. Degrees of freedom
A free particle has 3 coordinates. The hoop is a curve: two holonomic, scleronomic constraints (the plane and the circle $|\mathbf{CP}|=a$), so 1 degree of freedom remains, described by $\theta$ (Notes §2.7).
Step 2. Spring length
With $d=2a$: $l=a\sqrt{5-4\cos\theta}$, from $l(0)=a$ at the top to $l(\pi)=3a$ at the bottom.
Step 3. Potentials
Weight: uniform, $V_g=mg\,y_P=mga\cos\theta$. Spring: $V_s=\tfrac12k(l-l_0)^2$, a function of the position only (Notes §4.4). Both are conservative, the reaction of the smooth fixed hoop does no work (part (b)), so
- 1 degree of freedom, $\theta$ (the hoop removes 2 of the 3 spatial coordinates).
- $l^2=a^2+d^2-2ad\cos\theta=a^2(5-4\cos\theta)$; $\ l(0)=a=l_0$, $\ l(\pi)=3a$.
- $V(\theta)=mga\cos\theta+\tfrac12k\big(l(\theta)-l_0\big)^2$, i.e. $\dfrac{V}{mga}=\cos\theta+\dfrac{\kappa}{2}\Big(\sqrt{5-4\cos\theta}-1\Big)^2$.
Part (b) · 2 points
Equation of motion and reaction of the hoop
Write the kinematics of $P$ in $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta\}$, the forces, the equation of motion free of the reaction, and the reaction $\mathbf N$ as a function of $\theta$ and $\dot\theta$. Check the equation of motion against $V(\theta)$.
Step 1. Change of basis
The pair $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta\}$ turns with $\theta$. Since $\theta$ grows clockwise (from $\mathbf j$ towards $\mathbf i$), the right-handed order in the plane is $\{\mathbf e_\theta,\mathbf e_r\}$: with $\mathbf k=\mathbf i\times\mathbf j$, $\mathbf e_\theta\times\mathbf e_r=(\cos\theta\cos\theta+\sin\theta\sin\theta)\,\mathbf k=\mathbf k$ (the order $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta\}$ has determinant $-1$). Then
with $[R][R]^T=\begin{pmatrix}\cos^2\theta+\sin^2\theta&\cos\theta\sin\theta-\sin\theta\cos\theta\ \sin\theta\cos\theta-\cos\theta\sin\theta&\sin^2\theta+\cos^2\theta\end{pmatrix}=I$ and $\det[R]=\cos^2\theta+\sin^2\theta=+1$.
Step 2. Kinematics
$\mathbf r_{CP}=a\,\mathbf e_r$. By the chain rule, $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\theta(\cos\theta\,\mathbf i-\sin\theta\,\mathbf j)=\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$ and $\dot{\mathbf e}_\theta=\dot\theta(-\sin\theta\,\mathbf i-\cos\theta\,\mathbf j)=-\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_r$. With $a$ constant:
Step 3. Forces
- Weight: $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j=-mg\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_r+mg\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$ (using $\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf e_r=\cos\theta$, $\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf e_\theta=-\sin\theta$).
- Spring: $\mathbf F_s=-k\,\dfrac{l-l_0}{l}\,\mathbf{AP}=-k\Big(1-\dfrac{l_0}{l}\Big)\big[(a-d\cos\theta)\,\mathbf e_r+d\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta\big]$, since $\mathbf{AP}\cdot\mathbf e_r=a-d\cos\theta$ and $\mathbf{AP}\cdot\mathbf e_\theta=-d\,(\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf e_\theta)=d\sin\theta$.
- Reaction: the hoop is smooth, so $\mathbf N$ is orthogonal to the tangent $\mathbf e_\theta$ (Notes §6.5); its component normal to the plane balances nothing (all other forces are in the plane), so $\mathbf N=N\,\mathbf e_r$.
Step 4. Equation of motion (tangential projection)
$N$ does not appear: this is the reaction-free equation.
Step 5. Reaction (radial projection)
Step 6. Check with $V$
By the chain rule, $\dfrac{dV}{d\theta}=-mga\sin\theta+k(l-l_0)\dfrac{dl}{d\theta}$ and, differentiating $l^2=a^2+d^2-2ad\cos\theta$ implicitly, $2l\,l'=2ad\sin\theta$, so $l'=ad\sin\theta/l$. Hence
which is the energy form $ma^2\ddot\theta=-V'(\theta)$ of Step 4 (the Lagrange equation, an extension beyond the course notes, gives the same).
- $\mathbf a_P=a\ddot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta-a\dot\theta^2\,\mathbf e_r$; $\ \mathbf N=N\,\mathbf e_r$ (smooth hoop, planar forces).
- $ma\ddot\theta=\sin\theta\Big[mg-kd\Big(1-\dfrac{l_0}{l}\Big)\Big]$, equal to $-V'(\theta)/a$.
- $N=mg\cos\theta+k\Big(1-\dfrac{l_0}{l}\Big)(a-d\cos\theta)-ma\dot\theta^2$ (positive: outwards).
Part (c) · 2 points
Equilibrium positions
Find all the equilibrium positions as functions of $\kappa$. Show that besides $\theta=0$ and $\theta=\pi$ there is a symmetric pair $\theta=\pm\theta^*$ only above a critical value $\kappa_c$, and give $\cos\theta^*(\kappa)$.
Step 1. Factorisation
From (b), with $d=2a$, $l_0=a$ and $k=\kappa mg/a$:
Equilibria are the zeros of $V'$ (Notes §4.6).
Step 2. $\sin\theta=0$
$\theta=0$ and $\theta=\pi$ are equilibria for every $\kappa$: by symmetry, the spring force and the weight are both along the vertical there, so they have no tangential component.
Step 3. The symmetric pair
$-1+2\kappa(1-a/l)=0\Rightarrow 1-a/l=1/(2\kappa)\Rightarrow l^*=\dfrac{a}{1-1/(2\kappa)}=\dfrac{2\kappa a}{2\kappa-1}$, which requires $\kappa>\tfrac12$ for $l^*>0$. Substituting into $l^2=a^2(5-4\cos\theta)$:
Step 4. Existence condition
A point of the hoop has $a\le l\le3a$; a new equilibrium needs $a<l^*<3a$. $l^*>a$ holds for every $\kappa>\tfrac12$. $l^*<3a\iff2\kappa<3(2\kappa-1)\iff\kappa>\tfrac34$. So the pair $\pm\theta^*$ exists only for $\kappa>\kappa_c=\tfrac34$; at $\kappa=\tfrac34$, $\cos\theta^*=\tfrac14(5-9)=-1$: the pair is born at the bottom. As $\kappa\to\infty$, $l^*\to a$ and $\theta^*\to0$.
- $\theta=0$ (top) and $\theta=\pi$ (bottom) for every $\kappa$.
- $G=0\iff 1-\dfrac{a}{l}=\dfrac{1}{2\kappa}\iff l^*=\dfrac{2\kappa a}{2\kappa-1}$; $\ \cos\theta^*=\dfrac14\Big(5-\dfrac{4\kappa^2}{(2\kappa-1)^2}\Big)$.
- The pair exists only for $\kappa>\kappa_c=\tfrac34$ ($\theta^*\to\pi$ as $\kappa\to\tfrac34^+$, $\theta^*\to0$ as $\kappa\to\infty$).
Part (d) · 1.5 points
Stability and the bifurcation
Classify the stability of each equilibrium in the two regimes $\kappa<\tfrac34$ and $\kappa>\tfrac34$. Describe what happens at $\kappa=\tfrac34$. Is "the bottom of the hoop is always stable" true?
Step 1. Second derivative
From $V'=\sin\theta\,G(\theta)$ with $G=-mga+kad(1-l_0/l)$, the product rule gives $V''=\cos\theta\,G+\sin\theta\,G'$, and by the chain rule $G'=kad\,\dfrac{l_0}{l^2}\,l'=kad\,\dfrac{l_0}{l^2}\,\dfrac{ad\sin\theta}{l}$.
Step 2. Top and bottom
At $\theta=0$: $l=l_0$, so $G(0)=-mga$ and $V''(0)=-mga<0$: unstable for every $\kappa$ (the spring is slack there and cannot hold the bead up).
At $\theta=\pi$: $l=3a$, $G(\pi)=-mga+k\,a\,2a\,\tfrac23=-mga+\tfrac43ka^2$ and $V''(\pi)=\cos\pi\,G(\pi)=mga-\tfrac43ka^2=mga\big(1-\tfrac43\kappa\big)$.
Step 3. The pair
At $\theta^*$, $G=0$, so $V''(\theta^*)=\sin\theta^*G'(\theta^*)=\dfrac{ka^2d^2l_0\sin^2\theta^*}{l^{*3}}>0$: a minimum, stable.
Step 4. The two regimes (the trap)
- $\kappa<\tfrac34$ (soft spring): two equilibria; top unstable, bottom stable.
- $\kappa>\tfrac34$ (stiff spring): four equilibria; top unstable, bottom unstable, $\pm\theta^*$ stable. The stretched spring pulls the bead up harder than gravity pulls it down, and the bead settles on one side.
The bottom is not always stable. At $\kappa=\tfrac34$, $V''(\pi)=0$ and $V'''(\pi)=0$ (symmetry), and $V''''(\pi)=\tfrac13mga>0$: the bottom is still a (flat) minimum. As $\kappa$ crosses $\tfrac34$ the minimum at the bottom splits into two minima that move away symmetrically: a supercritical pitchfork bifurcation (see the energy curves of the figure).
- Top: $V''(0)=-mga<0$, always unstable.
- Bottom: $V''(\pi)=mga\big(1-\tfrac43\kappa\big)$: stable for $\kappa<\tfrac34$, unstable for $\kappa>\tfrac34$.
- Pair: $V''(\theta^*)=\dfrac{ka^2d^2l_0\sin^2\theta^*}{l^{*3}}>0$: stable whenever it exists. Supercritical pitchfork at $\kappa=\tfrac34$ ($V''''(\pi)=\tfrac13mga>0$ there).
Part (e) · 1.5 points
Small oscillations
Compute the angular frequency of small oscillations (i) about the bottom for $\kappa=\tfrac12$ and (ii) about $\theta^*$ for $\kappa=1$ (give $\theta^*$). Numerical values for $a=0.40$ m.
Step 1. Linearisation
With $\theta=\theta_e+\eta$, $V'(\theta)=V'(\theta_e)+V''(\theta_e)\eta+O(\eta^2)$ and $V'(\theta_e)=0$, so $ma^2\ddot\eta+V''(\theta_e)\eta=0$ and $\omega^2=V''(\theta_e)/(ma^2)$ when $V''(\theta_e)>0$.
Step 2. Bottom, $\kappa=\tfrac12$
$V''(\pi)=mga(1-\tfrac43\cdot\tfrac12)=\tfrac13mga$, so $\omega^2=\dfrac{g}{3a}=\dfrac{9.81}{1.2}=8.175$ s$^{-2}$ and $\omega=2.859$ rad/s.
Step 3. Side equilibrium, $\kappa=1$
$l^*=2a/(2-1)=2a$, $\cos\theta^*=\tfrac14(5-4)=\tfrac14$, $\theta^*=\arccos\tfrac14=75.52^\circ$, $\sin^2\theta^*=\tfrac{15}{16}$. With $k=mg/a$, $d=2a$, $l_0=a$:
Numerically $\omega^2=\tfrac{15}{32}\times\tfrac{9.81}{0.40}=11.50$ s$^{-2}$, $\omega=3.391$ rad/s.
- (i) $\omega^2=\dfrac{g}{3a}$, $\ \omega=2.859$ rad/s.
- (ii) $l^*=2a$, $\cos\theta^*=\tfrac14$, $\theta^*=75.52^\circ$; $\ \omega^2=\dfrac{15}{32}\dfrac ga$, $\ \omega=3.391$ rad/s.
Part (f) · 1.5 points
Energy integral and the bead at the bottom
Write the energy first integral. For $\kappa=\tfrac12$ the bead leaves the top with a vanishingly small speed. Find its speed at the bottom and the reaction of the hoop there. Would a bead released exactly at rest at the top move?
Step 1. First integral
The reaction is normal to $\mathbf v_P=a\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$, so its power $\mathbf N\cdot\mathbf v_P=0$ (Notes §6.4 to §6.5); the other forces derive from $V$. Hence (Notes §4.5)
Check: $\dfrac{dE}{dt}=\dot\theta\big(ma^2\ddot\theta+V'(\theta)\big)=0$ by (b).
Step 2. Top versus bottom
$V(0)=mga+0$ and $V(\pi)=-mga+\tfrac12k(3a-a)^2=-mga+2ka^2$, so $V(\pi)-V(0)=2ka^2-2mga=2mga(\kappa-1)$.
Step 3. Speed at the bottom
$\theta=0$ is an equilibrium: released exactly at rest there, the bead stays. With an infinitesimal push, $E=V(0)$. For $\kappa=\tfrac12<\tfrac34$ the only equilibria are $0$ and $\pi$, so $V$ decreases monotonically on $(0,\pi)$ and the bead reaches the bottom with
With no spring ($\kappa=0$) it would be $v^2=4ga$: the spring stores part of the energy.
Step 4. Reaction at the bottom
At $\theta=\pi$: $l=3a$, $1-l_0/l=\tfrac23$, $a-d\cos\pi=3a$, $a\dot\theta^2=v^2/a=2g$ and $k=mg/(2a)$:
$N<0$ means the reaction points along $-\mathbf e_r$, towards $C$; at the bottom $-\mathbf e_r=\mathbf j$, so the hoop pushes the bead up with $2mg$. Check on the vertical: $N_{up}-mg+T_{spring}=mv^2/a$ with $T_{spring}=k(3a-a)=mg$ gives $N_{up}=2mg-mg+mg=2mg$.
- $\tfrac12ma^2\dot\theta^2+mga\cos\theta+\tfrac12k(l-l_0)^2=E$; $\ V(\pi)-V(0)=2mga(\kappa-1)$.
- $\kappa=\tfrac12$: $v_{bottom}^2=4ga(1-\kappa)=2ga$, $v=2.801$ m/s (against $4ga$ without spring).
- $N(\pi)=-2mg$: the hoop pushes the bead towards $C$, i.e. upwards with $2mg$. At rest exactly at the top the bead stays (equilibrium); it needs a disturbance.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $\kappa=ka/(mg)$ is (N/m)(m)/N = 1; $V$ and $mga$ in J; $\omega^2=g/a$ in s$^{-2}$; $N$ in N; $v^2=ga$ in m$^2$ s$^{-2}$.
- Limits: $\kappa\to0$ recovers the bead on a hoop under gravity alone (top unstable, bottom stable, $\omega^2=g/a$ at the bottom: our $V''(\pi)$ gives $mga$). $\kappa\to\infty$: the spring dominates and the stable positions approach the top, where the spring is unstretched. For $\kappa=1$, $V(\pi)=V(0)$: a bead leaving the top with a vanishing speed approaches the (now unstable) bottom only asymptotically, never reaching it in finite time.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) assuming the bottom is always the stable position; (2) missing the side equilibria by cancelling $\sin\theta$ without keeping the second factor; (3) using $l-l_0$ with the wrong natural length (the spring is unstretched at the top, not at the bottom); (4) forgetting that the reaction of a bead on a hoop can point either way (bilateral constraint), and assuming $N\ge0$; (5) "releasing from rest at the top" without noticing that it is an equilibrium.
P10 — Free fall from a tower on the rotating Earth: eastward deflection, the order of the north-south effect and an upward shot
A particle $P$ of mass $m$ is released from rest relative to the ground from the top of a tower of height $h$ standing at the point $A$ of the Earth's surface at latitude $\lambda$ (northern hemisphere). The Earth rotates with constant angular velocity of modulus $\Omega$ about its polar axis, whose unit vector $\mathbf k_E$ points to the north pole; the centre of the Earth is taken as fixed in an inertial frame $S_0$.
The local frame $S_1=\{A;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ is attached to the ground at the foot $A$ of the tower and rotates with the Earth: $x$ points east, $y$ points north, $z$ points up along the plumb line. In $S_1$ the particle feels the effective gravity $-g\,\mathbf k$, which already contains the centrifugal force of the point $A$ (gravitation plus $-m\boldsymbol\Omega\times(\boldsymbol\Omega\times\mathbf r_{CA})$, $C$ the centre of the Earth). Air drag is neglected and $h$ is small compared with the radius of the Earth.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $h$, $g$, $\Omega$, $\lambda$. Numerical part: $h=100$ m, $\lambda=40^\circ$, $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$, $\Omega=7.292\times10^{-5}$ rad s$^{-1}$ ($2\pi$ per sidereal day of $86\,164$ s).
- Hypotheses: point particle, uniform effective gravity along the height of the tower, $\Omega$ constant, $\Omega t\ll1$ during the fall (so a solution to first order in $\Omega$ is meaningful), no drag.
- $S_1$ is a rotating frame: $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\Omega\,\mathbf k_E$ with $\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}_{10}=\mathbf 0$.
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Degrees of freedom, angular velocity of $S_1$ and inertia forces
How many degrees of freedom has $P$? Write $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}$ in the basis of $S_1$ and list the inertia forces that act on $P$ in $S_1$, saying which one is absorbed into $-g\,\mathbf k$ and which one is kept.
Step 1. Count
$P$ is a free particle in space: 3 degrees of freedom, the coordinates $(x,y,z)$ of $\mathbf r=\overrightarrow{AP}$ in $S_1$. Nothing constrains it between release and impact.
Step 2. The angular velocity in the local basis
The local vertical $\mathbf k$ is the plumb line at $A$ (statement), and the latitude $\lambda$ is measured from this plumb line: it is the angle between $\mathbf k$ and the equatorial plane. The angle between $\mathbf k$ and $\mathbf k_E$ is therefore $90^\circ-\lambda$, so $\mathbf k_E\cdot\mathbf k=\sin\lambda$ by definition of $\lambda$. The polar axis lies in the meridian plane through $A$, which contains $\mathbf j$ (north) and $\mathbf k$, so $\mathbf k_E\cdot\mathbf i=0$, and it leans towards the north: $\mathbf k_E\cdot\mathbf j=\cos\lambda$. Check: $\cos^2\lambda+\sin^2\lambda=1$. The ground turns with the Earth, so
Step 3. Change of basis
The polar axis is best described with the cylindrical basis of the Earth at $A$, $\{\mathbf e_\rho,\mathbf e_\varphi,\mathbf k_E\}$: $\mathbf e_\rho$ perpendicular to the polar axis and pointing away from it, in the meridian plane of $A$, $\mathbf e_\varphi=\mathbf i$ (east), $\mathbf k_E$ the polar axis. This basis turns about $\mathbf k_E$ with angular velocity $\Omega$ relative to $S_0$, like the local one. Projecting the local unit vectors ($\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf e_\rho=-\sin\lambda$, $\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf k_E=\cos\lambda$, $\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf e_\rho=\cos\lambda$, $\mathbf k\cdot\mathbf k_E=\sin\lambda$):
Checks: the rows have unit length ($1$, $\sin^2\lambda+\cos^2\lambda$, $\cos^2\lambda+\sin^2\lambda$) and are mutually orthogonal (row 1 with rows 2 and 3: $0$; rows 2 and 3: $-\sin\lambda\cos\lambda+\cos\lambda\sin\lambda=0$), so $[R][R]^T=I$; expanding along the first row, $\det[R]=-1\cdot\big((-\sin\lambda)\sin\lambda-\cos\lambda\cos\lambda\big)=+1$. The third column of $[R]$ gives back $\mathbf k_E=\cos\lambda\,\mathbf j+\sin\lambda\,\mathbf k$.
Step 4. Inertia forces (Notes §3.2 and §4.9)
The acceleration of $P$ in $S_0$ is $\mathbf a=\mathbf a_{rel}+\mathbf a_{drag}+2\boldsymbol\omega_{10}\times\mathbf v_{rel}$. The point of $S_1$ that coincides with $P$ moves on a circle about the polar axis (the centre $C$ is fixed and $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}$ constant), so $\mathbf a_{drag}=\boldsymbol\Omega\times\big(\boldsymbol\Omega\times\mathbf r_{CP}\big)$ with $\mathbf r_{CP}=\mathbf r_{CA}+\mathbf r$. In $S_1$, $m\mathbf a_{rel}=\mathbf F+\mathbf F_{cf}+\mathbf F_{cor}$ with
The first term is the same at every point of the tower: added to the gravitational attraction it gives the effective weight $-mg\,\mathbf k$ that a plumb line at $A$ measures (this is how $\mathbf k$ is defined). The second term has modulus at most $m\Omega^2h\approx5.3\times10^{-7}\,m$ m s$^{-2}$ for $h=100$ m: it is of order $\Omega^2$ and is dropped. The Coriolis force is of order $\Omega$ and is the one that matters.
- 3 degrees of freedom $(x,y,z)$, no constraint during the fall.
- $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\Omega\cos\lambda\,\mathbf j+\Omega\sin\lambda\,\mathbf k$, constant.
- Inertia forces: centrifugal $-m\boldsymbol\Omega\times\big(\boldsymbol\Omega\times(\mathbf r_{CA}+\mathbf r)\big)$ (the part with $\mathbf r_{CA}$ is in $g$; the part with $\mathbf r$ is $O(\Omega^2h)$ and is neglected) and Coriolis $-2m\boldsymbol\Omega\times\mathbf v_{rel}$ (kept). No Euler force.
Part (b) · 2 points
Equations of motion in $S_1$
Write the vector equation of motion of $P$ in $S_1$ and its three scalar components, with the initial conditions.
Step 1. Vector equation
With the results of (a), the only forces in $S_1$ are the effective weight and the Coriolis force:
Step 2. The cross product
Step 3. Components
Dividing by $m$ and projecting on $\mathbf i$, $\mathbf j$, $\mathbf k$:
The particle starts at the top of the tower with zero velocity relative to the ground (in $S_0$ it moves east with the tower top): $\mathbf r(0)=h\,\mathbf k$, $\dot{\mathbf r}(0)=\mathbf 0$.
- $\ddot x=-2\Omega\big(\dot z\cos\lambda-\dot y\sin\lambda\big)$, $\ \ddot y=-2\Omega\dot x\sin\lambda$, $\ \ddot z=-g+2\Omega\dot x\cos\lambda$.
- $x(0)=y(0)=0$, $z(0)=h$, $\dot x(0)=\dot y(0)=\dot z(0)=0$.
Part (c) · 2 points
Solution to first order in $\Omega$
Solve the equations to first order in $\Omega$ and show that the particle lands at $\Delta x=\dfrac{2\sqrt2}{3}\,\Omega\cos\lambda\sqrt{\dfrac{h^3}{g}}$ east of the foot of the tower. Does the time of fall change at this order?
Step 1. Zeroth order
With $\Omega=0$: $\ddot x_0=\ddot y_0=0$ and $\ddot z_0=-g$, with $\dot{\mathbf r}_0(0)=\mathbf 0$ and $\mathbf r_0(0)=h\,\mathbf k$. Integrating twice with the limits $0$ and $t$ (antiderivative, then Barrow's rule $[F]_0^t=F(t)-F(0)$):
and in the same way $\dot y_0=0$, $y_0=0$.
Step 2. First order
Every Coriolis term carries a factor $\Omega$, so to first order the velocity inside it is the zeroth-order one, $\dot{\mathbf r}_0=-gt\,\mathbf k$:
with zero initial conditions, so $y_1=z_1=0$ and
Step 3. Landing point
Since $z_1=0$, the height is $h-\tfrac12gt^2$ up to $O(\Omega^2)$ and the particle reaches $z=0$ at $t_f=\sqrt{2h/g}$, as without rotation. Then $t_f^3=(2h/g)^{3/2}=2\sqrt2\,h^{3/2}/g^{3/2}$ and
The particle lands east of the foot $A$.
Step 4. Physical reading in $S_0$
At release the top of the tower is a distance $h\cos\lambda$ farther from the polar axis than the foot, so in $S_0$ it moves east $\Omega h\cos\lambda$ faster than the foot. The particle keeps that eastward speed while it falls, which is why it ends up ahead of the foot. But this lead speed $\Omega h\cos\lambda$ is measured against the foot, not against the rotating ground under the particle: relative to the ground ($S_1$) the particle starts at rest, and its eastward speed $\dot x_1=\Omega gt^2\cos\lambda$ is zero at release and grows like $t^2$, as the particle descends to points of the ground that move more slowly. The crude estimate "lead speed $\Omega h\cos\lambda$ during the whole fall", $\Omega h\cos\lambda\,t_f$, assumes the full lead from the start and is therefore $3/2$ of the exact first-order value: with $h=\tfrac12gt_f^2$, $\Omega h\cos\lambda\,t_f=\tfrac12\Omega g\cos\lambda\,t_f^3$, against $\Delta x=\tfrac13\Omega g\cos\lambda\,t_f^3$.
- Order 0: $z_0=h-\tfrac12gt^2$, $\dot z_0=-gt$, $x_0=y_0=0$.
- Order 1: $\ddot x_1=2\Omega g t\cos\lambda$, $\ \dot x_1=\Omega gt^2\cos\lambda$, $\ x_1=\tfrac13\Omega gt^3\cos\lambda$; $y_1=z_1=0$.
- $t_f=\sqrt{2h/g}$ (unchanged at first order), $\Delta x=\tfrac{2\sqrt2}{3}\Omega\cos\lambda\sqrt{h^3/g}$, to the east.
Part (d) · 1 point
Numbers
For $h=100$ m, $\lambda=40^\circ$: compute the time of fall and the eastward deflection. Where is the particle (east of the plumb line) at $t_f/2$?
Step 1. Time and deflection
$t_f=\sqrt{2\cdot100/9.81}=\sqrt{20.39}=4.515$ s. With $\cos40^\circ=0.7660$ and $\sqrt{h^3/g}=\sqrt{10^6/9.81}=319.3$ s:
A numerical integration of the exact equations of (b) (no expansion) gives the same value to four significant figures.
Step 2. Half-way
$x_1\propto t^3$, so at $t_f/2$ the deflection is $(1/2)^3\Delta x=0.210$ cm: most of the deflection builds up in the second half of the fall.
- $t_f=\sqrt{200/9.81}=4.515$ s.
- $\Delta x=1.681$ cm east; $x_1(t_f/2)=\Delta x/8=0.210$ cm.
Part (e) · 1.5 points
Is there a north-south deflection?
A student integrates the $y$ equation once more and reports a southward deflection $y_2(t_f)=-\tfrac23\Omega^2h^2\sin\lambda\cos\lambda/g$. Check the formula, and say whether it is a consistent result of the model of the statement.
Step 1. The second-order term
At second order the $y$ equation receives $\dot x_1$: $\ddot y_2=-2\Omega\dot x_1\sin\lambda=-2\Omega^2gt^2\sin\lambda\cos\lambda$. Integrating twice from rest:
(the lower limit contributes $0$ in both, since $\dot y_2(0)=y_2(0)=0$).
and with $t_f^4=4h^2/g^2$: $y_2(t_f)=-\tfrac23\Omega^2h^2\sin\lambda\cos\lambda/g$. With the data: $-1.78\times10^{-6}$ m, about $10^{-4}$ of $\Delta x$ (the ratio is $\tfrac12\Omega t_f\sin\lambda$).
Step 2. Why it is not a consistent answer
The equation of (b) is only exact to first order in $\Omega$: in (a) we dropped the residual centrifugal force $-m\boldsymbol\Omega\times(\boldsymbol\Omega\times\mathbf r)$, which is $O(\Omega^2)$. For $\mathbf r\approx z\,\mathbf k$ its $y$ component is $-m\Omega^2z\sin\lambda\cos\lambda$; with $z=z_0(t)$ it alone displaces the particle by
which is larger than $y_2$. The direction of the gravitational attraction also changes along the vertical through $A$ by an amount of the same order. A second-order answer must collect all these terms; keeping only the Coriolis one is inconsistent. To first order in $\Omega$, the only deflection is the eastward one, and $y=O(\Omega^2)$ is at the micrometre level.
- $\ddot y_2=-2\Omega\dot x_1\sin\lambda=-2\Omega^2gt^2\sin\lambda\cos\lambda$, $\ y_2=-\tfrac16\Omega^2gt^4\sin\lambda\cos\lambda$; at $t_f$: $-\tfrac23\Omega^2h^2\sin\lambda\cos\lambda/g=-1.78\times10^{-6}$ m.
- The formula is right but not consistent: it is $O(\Omega^2)$, the same order as the residual centrifugal term $-m\boldsymbol\Omega\times(\boldsymbol\Omega\times\mathbf r)$ dropped in (a), whose own effect is $-\tfrac56\Omega^2h^2\sin\lambda\cos\lambda/g=-2.22\times10^{-6}$ m, and as the change of direction of gravitation along the fall. To first order in $\Omega$ there is no north-south deflection.
Part (f) · 2 points
A projectile fired vertically upward
From $A$ a projectile is fired vertically upward (along $\mathbf k$) with speed $v_0$ relative to the ground. To first order in $\Omega$, where does it land? Compute it for $v_0=50$ m s$^{-1}$ at $\lambda=40^\circ$, and compare with the drop of (c) from the same maximum height.
Step 1. Zeroth and first order
Order 0: $z_0=v_0t-\tfrac12gt^2$, $\dot z_0=v_0-gt$, back at $z=0$ at $T=2v_0/g$. Order 1, from the $x$ equation of (b) with $\dot y_0=0$:
Step 2. Landing point
At $T=2v_0/g$: $v_0T^2=4v_0^3/g^2$ and $\tfrac13gT^3=\tfrac83v_0^3/g^2$, so
The projectile lands west of the launch point. With $v_0=50$ m s$^{-1}$: $\Delta x=-\tfrac43(7.292\times10^{-5})(0.7660)(125\,000)/96.24$ m $=-9.674$ cm; the flight lasts $T=10.19$ s and the apex is at $v_0^2/2g=127.4$ m.
Step 3. Why it does not cancel
On the way up ($\dot z_0>0$) the Coriolis force pushes west; on the way down it pushes east. The symmetric-looking guess "the two halves cancel" confuses force with displacement: $\dot x_1=-\Omega g\cos\lambda\,t(T-t)$ is negative during the whole flight and only returns to zero at $t=T$. The westward velocity gained on the way up is removed on the way down, but the westward displacement accumulated meanwhile remains.
Step 4. Comparison with the drop
Setting $v_0=\sqrt{2gh}$ (apex at height $h$): $\Delta x_{up}=-\tfrac43\Omega\cos\lambda(2gh)^{3/2}/g^2=-4\cdot\tfrac{2\sqrt2}{3}\Omega\cos\lambda\sqrt{h^3/g}$, that is, $-4$ times the eastward deflection of (c): $-6.73$ cm for $h=100$ m. The descent of the projectile alone would push it $1.68$ cm east, but it starts the descent already moving west.
- $\ddot x_1=-2\Omega\cos\lambda\,(v_0-gt)$, $\ \dot x_1=-\Omega g\cos\lambda\,t\,(T-t)\le0$, $\ x_1=-\Omega\cos\lambda\big(v_0t^2-\tfrac13gt^3\big)$, with $T=2v_0/g$.
- $\Delta x=-\tfrac43\,\Omega\cos\lambda\,v_0^3/g^2$: it lands west of $A$; $-9.674$ cm for $v_0=50$ m s$^{-1}$ ($T=10.19$ s, apex $127.4$ m).
- With $v_0=\sqrt{2gh}$ the westward offset is $4$ times the eastward deflection of the drop from $h$.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $[\Omega gt^3]=\text{s}^{-1}\cdot\text{m s}^{-2}\cdot\text{s}^3=\text{m}$; $[\Omega\sqrt{h^3/g}]=\text{s}^{-1}\sqrt{\text{m}^3/(\text{m s}^{-2})}=\text{s}^{-1}\cdot\text{m s}=\text{m}$; $[\Omega v_0^3/g^2]=\text{s}^{-1}\,\text{m}^3\text{s}^{-3}/(\text{m}^2\text{s}^{-4})=\text{m}$.
- Limits: at the poles ($\lambda=90^\circ$) $\cos\lambda=0$: $\boldsymbol\Omega$ is vertical, parallel to the fall, and there is no deflection; it is largest at the equator. In the southern hemisphere ($\lambda<0$) $\cos\lambda>0$ still: the drop also lands east. The expansion requires $\Omega t_f\ll1$ (here $3.3\times10^{-4}$).
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) writing $\boldsymbol\Omega=\Omega\,\mathbf k$ (the local vertical) instead of $\Omega(\cos\lambda\,\mathbf j+\sin\lambda\,\mathbf k)$; (2) a sign error in the Coriolis force (it is $-2m\boldsymbol\Omega\times\mathbf v_{rel}$) that sends the particle west; (3) keeping $O(\Omega^2)$ Coriolis terms while dropping the centrifugal term of the same order; (4) assuming that the up and down halves of a vertical shot cancel.
P11 — Pendulum whose string is hauled through a ring: a rheonomic constraint, angular momentum and the work of the hauling force
A bob $P$ of mass $m$ hangs from a light inextensible string that passes through a small, smooth ring $O$ fixed to the ceiling. The other end of the string leaves the ring and is hauled in so that the length between $O$ and $P$ is
The motion is planar, in the vertical plane of the inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ ($x$ horizontal, $y$ vertical upward, uniform gravity $-g\,\mathbf j$, $\mathbf k=\mathbf i\times\mathbf j$ out of the page). The angle $\theta$ is measured from the downward vertical, positive towards $+x$, and the string stays taut. Use the unit vectors $\mathbf e_r=\sin\theta\,\mathbf i-\cos\theta\,\mathbf j$ (from $O$ to $P$) and $\mathbf e_\theta=\cos\theta\,\mathbf i+\sin\theta\,\mathbf j$.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $g$, $\ell_0$, $u$. Numerical parts: (d) and (e) $m=0.5$ kg, $\ell_0=2$ m, $u=0.5$ m s$^{-1}$, $g=0$, initial transverse speed $\ell_0\dot\theta_0=1$ m s$^{-1}$; (f) $\ell_0=1$ m, $u=0.01$ m s$^{-1}$, $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$, $\theta(0)=0.05$ rad, $\dot\theta(0)=0$.
- Hypotheses: point particle, massless inextensible string, smooth ring (the tension $T$ is the same on both sides), no air drag, $S_0$ inertial, $\ell>0$.
Part (a) · 1 point
Degrees of freedom and the constraint
How many degrees of freedom has $P$? Classify the constraint imposed by the string.
Step 1. Count
In the vertical plane a free particle has 2 degrees of freedom. The taut string between $O$ and $P$ imposes
one equation, so 1 degree of freedom remains: $\theta$. The length is prescribed by whoever pulls the string, so it is not a second coordinate (Notes §2.7).
Step 2. Classification
The constraint involves only positions and time: it is holonomic. Time appears explicitly, so it is rheonomic: the constraint moves, and its reaction (the tension) can do work on $P$, unlike the fixed string of the ordinary pendulum. A string can only pull, so the constraint is unilateral and holds while $T\ge0$.
- $|\overrightarrow{OP}|-\ell_0+ut=0$: holonomic, rheonomic (depends on $t$), and unilateral ($T\ge0$).
- $2-1=1$ degree of freedom, coordinate $\theta(t)$; $\ell(t)$ is a given function, not an unknown.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Kinematics in polar coordinates
Write the position, velocity and acceleration of $P$ in $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta\}$, first for a general length $\ell(t)$ and then for $\ell=\ell_0-ut$.
Step 1. Change of basis and unit vectors
The working basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\theta,\mathbf k\}$ turns with $P$; its relation to the inertial basis is
Checks: rows 1 and 2 have length $\sin^2\theta+\cos^2\theta=1$ and $\sin\theta\cos\theta-\cos\theta\sin\theta=0$, row 3 is $\mathbf k$, so $[R][R]^T=I$; $\det[R]=\sin\theta\cdot\sin\theta-(-\cos\theta)\cos\theta=+1$, so the basis is right-handed ($\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\theta=\mathbf k$). By the chain rule, $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dfrac{d\mathbf e_r}{d\theta}\dot\theta=(\cos\theta\,\mathbf i+\sin\theta\,\mathbf j)\dot\theta=\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$ and $\dot{\mathbf e}_\theta=(-\sin\theta\,\mathbf i+\cos\theta\,\mathbf j)\dot\theta=-\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_r$.
Step 2. Position and velocity
$\mathbf r=\ell\,\mathbf e_r$. Product rule:
Step 3. Acceleration
Differentiating each product:
Step 4. Prescribed length
$\ell=\ell_0-ut$ gives $\dot\ell=-u$, $\ddot\ell=0$:
- $\mathbf v=\dot\ell\,\mathbf e_r+\ell\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$, $\ \mathbf a=(\ddot\ell-\ell\dot\theta^2)\,\mathbf e_r+(\ell\ddot\theta+2\dot\ell\dot\theta)\,\mathbf e_\theta$.
- With $\dot\ell=-u$, $\ddot\ell=0$: $\mathbf v=-u\,\mathbf e_r+\ell\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$, $\ \mathbf a=-\ell\dot\theta^2\,\mathbf e_r+(\ell\ddot\theta-2u\dot\theta)\,\mathbf e_\theta$.
Part (c) · 2 points
Forces and equations of motion
Write the forces on $P$ and obtain the equation of motion free of the tension and the tension itself.
Step 1. Forces
Weight: $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j$ with $\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf e_r=-\cos\theta$ and $\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf e_\theta=\sin\theta$, so $\mathbf W=mg\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_r-mg\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta$. Tension: the string pulls $P$ towards the ring, $\mathbf T=-T\,\mathbf e_r$, $T\ge0$.
Step 2. Transverse projection
With $\dot\ell=-u$: $(\ell_0-ut)\ddot\theta-2u\dot\theta+g\sin\theta=0$. The term $-2u\dot\theta$ has the form of a negative damping: hauling the string in feeds the swing.
Step 3. Radial projection
because $\ddot\ell=0$: a constant hauling speed adds no radial inertia term. The equation of Step 2 is also what a Lagrange equation (extension, not in the course notes) with $L=\tfrac12m(\dot\ell^2+\ell^2\dot\theta^2)+mg\ell\cos\theta$ gives.
- $\mathbf W=mg(\cos\theta\,\mathbf e_r-\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta)$, $\ \mathbf T=-T\,\mathbf e_r$.
- $\ell\ddot\theta+2\dot\ell\dot\theta+g\sin\theta=0$, i.e. $(\ell_0-ut)\ddot\theta-2u\dot\theta+g\sin\theta=0$.
- $T=m\big(g\cos\theta+\ell\dot\theta^2-\ddot\ell\big)=m\big(g\cos\theta+\ell\dot\theta^2\big)$.
Part (d) · 1.5 points
Angular momentum about $O$ and the gravity-free case
Compute $\mathbf H_O$ and $d\mathbf H_O/dt$. Is it conserved? Then remove gravity (a tether in orbit reeled in at constant speed, $g=0$): find $T(\ell)$ and, for the data of the Setup, $\dot\theta$, the speed and $T$ when $\ell=0.5$ m.
Step 1. Angular momentum
$\mathbf H_O=\mathbf r\times m\mathbf v=\ell\,\mathbf e_r\times m\big(\dot\ell\,\mathbf e_r+\ell\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta\big)=m\ell^2\dot\theta\,(\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\theta)$, and $\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\theta=\mathbf k$ (it is the cross product of $\mathbf i$ and $\mathbf j$ rotated by $\theta-90^\circ$):
Step 2. Its rate (Notes §4.8)
The tension passes through $O$, so its moment is zero; the weight gives $\mathbf r\times\mathbf W=\ell\,\mathbf e_r\times(-mg\sin\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta)=-mg\ell\sin\theta\,\mathbf k$. Product rule:
which is the equation of (c) multiplied by $m\ell$. With gravity $\mathbf H_O$ is not conserved.
Step 3. Gravity-free case
With $g=0$ the right-hand side vanishes: $\ell^2\dot\theta=h$ constant. In the tension, $\dot\theta=h/\ell^2$:
The transverse speed $\ell\dot\theta=h/\ell$ grows as the string shortens, and the tension grows like $\ell^{-3}$: whoever reels the tether in must pull harder and harder.
Step 4. Numbers
$h=\ell_0\cdot(\ell_0\dot\theta_0)=2\cdot1=2$ m$^2$ s$^{-1}$. $\ell=0.5$ m is reached at $t=(2-0.5)/0.5=3$ s. Then $\dot\theta=2/0.25=8$ rad s$^{-1}$, $\ell\dot\theta=4$ m s$^{-1}$, $|\mathbf v|=\sqrt{u^2+(\ell\dot\theta)^2}=\sqrt{0.25+16}=4.031$ m s$^{-1}$ and $T=0.5\cdot4/0.125=16$ N, compared with $T=0.5\cdot4/8=0.25$ N at the start.
- $\mathbf H_O=m\ell^2\dot\theta\,\mathbf k$; $\ \dfrac{d\mathbf H_O}{dt}=\mathbf r\times\mathbf W=-mg\ell\sin\theta\,\mathbf k$: not conserved.
- $g=0$: $\ell^2\dot\theta=h$, $T=m\ell\dot\theta^2=mh^2/\ell^3$, which grows without bound as $\ell\to0$.
- Data: $h=2$ m$^2$ s$^{-1}$; at $\ell=0.5$ m ($t=3$ s): $\dot\theta=8$ rad s$^{-1}$, $\ell\dot\theta=4$ m s$^{-1}$, $|\mathbf v|=4.031$ m s$^{-1}$, $T=16$ N (it was $0.25$ N at $\ell_0$).
Part (e) · 2 points
Who supplies the kinetic energy?
Show that $\dfrac{d}{dt}\big(E_{kin}+V\big)=T\,u$ and explain why this is the power of the hauling force. For $g=0$ and the data of (d), compute the work done by the hauling force between $\ell_0=2$ m and $\ell=0.5$ m and check it against the change in kinetic energy.
Step 1. Power of the tension
$\mathbf T\cdot\mathbf v=-T\,\mathbf e_r\cdot\big(\dot\ell\,\mathbf e_r+\ell\dot\theta\,\mathbf e_\theta\big)=-T\dot\ell=Tu$. On a fixed string ($\dot\ell=0$) the tension is orthogonal to the velocity and does no work; here the constraint moves and it does.
Step 2. Energy balance (Notes §4.4)
The work-energy theorem gives $\dfrac{dE_{kin}}{dt}=\mathbf W\cdot\mathbf v+\mathbf T\cdot\mathbf v$, and the weight derives from $V=mgy_P=-mg\ell\cos\theta$, so $\mathbf W\cdot\mathbf v=-dV/dt$. Hence
The string is massless and the ring smooth, so the tension has the same value $T$ at the free end, which moves with speed $u$ along the pull: the hauler's power is $Tu$. The mechanical energy of $P$ is not a first integral. Integrating the balance from $0$ to $t$ (Barrow's rule) gives instead
that is, the energy of $P$ grows by exactly the work done by the hauler. This is an energy balance, not a first integral in the strict sense: $W_{haul}(t)$ depends on the whole history $T(t')$, not on the state $(\theta,\dot\theta,t)$ alone.
Step 3. Work for $g=0$
With $T=mh^2/\ell^3$, change the variable to $\ell'=\ell_0-ut'$: $d\ell'=-u\,dt'$, so $dt'=-d\ell'/u$, and the limits become $t'=0\mapsto\ell'=\ell_0$, $t'=t\mapsto\ell'=\ell$:
An antiderivative of $mh^2\ell'^{-3}$ is $F(\ell')=-\dfrac{mh^2}{2\ell'^2}$ (check: $F'=-\tfrac{mh^2}{2}(-2)\ell'^{-3}=mh^2\ell'^{-3}$). Barrow's rule:
With the data: $\tfrac{0.5\cdot4}{2}\big(4-0.25\big)=3.75$ J.
Step 4. Check
$E_{kin}=\tfrac12m\big(u^2+h^2/\ell^2\big)$: from $\tfrac12\cdot0.5\,(0.25+1)$ to $\tfrac12\cdot0.5\,(0.25+16)$, a change of $\tfrac12\cdot0.5\cdot15=3.75$ J. The radial part $u^2$ is the same at both ends, so all the work goes into the transverse motion.
- $\mathbf T\cdot\mathbf v=-T\,\dot\ell=T\,u>0$: the tension does positive work although it is "a constraint force".
- $W_{haul}=\dfrac{mh^2}{2}\Big(\dfrac1{\ell^2}-\dfrac1{\ell_0^2}\Big)=3.75$ J $=\Delta E_{kin}$.
Part (f) · 2 points
Extension: the amplitude of small swings while hauling
This part goes beyond the course (adiabatic invariants and Bessel functions are not in the Notes). It is included because the result is a classic trap: neither the energy nor the angular momentum is conserved, so neither gives the amplitude.
For small angles, rewrite the equation of (c) with $\ell$ as the independent variable. Show that, when the hauling is slow ($u\ll\sqrt{g\ell}$), the angular amplitude grows like $\ell^{-3/4}$, and check it with the data of the Setup between $\ell_0=1$ m and $\ell=0.25$ m. Grading: the 2.0 points are for the change of variable (chain rule) and the reduced equation in $\ell$; the solution with Bessel functions and the $\ell^{-3/4}$ law are an extension, shown for completeness and not expected in the exam.
Step 1. Change of variable
For $\theta(t)=\Theta(\ell(t))$, the chain rule gives $\dot\theta=\Theta'\dot\ell=-u\Theta'$ and $\ddot\theta=\dfrac{d}{dt}(-u\Theta')=-u\Theta''\dot\ell=u^2\Theta''$. With $\sin\theta\approx\theta$ the equation of (c) becomes
and since $\dfrac{d}{d\ell}\big(\ell^2\Theta'\big)=\ell^2\Theta''+2\ell\Theta'$, it is $\dfrac1\ell\big(\ell^2\Theta'\big)'+\dfrac{g}{u^2}\Theta=0$.
Step 2. Exact solution
With $x=g\ell/u^2$ the equation is $x\,y''+2y'+y=0$, whose solutions are $x^{-1/2}J_1(2\sqrt x)$ and $x^{-1/2}Y_1(2\sqrt x)$ (Bessel functions of order 1). So
Step 3. Slow hauling
For large argument $J_1(z)\approx\sqrt{2/(\pi z)}\cos(z-3\pi/4)$ (and $Y_1$ with a sine). With $z\propto\ell^{1/2}$ the envelope is $\ell^{-1/2}z^{-1/2}\propto\ell^{-3/4}$:
The condition $z\gg1$ is $u\ll\sqrt{g\ell}$: the length changes little during one swing. The same law follows from the adiabatic invariant $E_{osc}/\omega$ with $E_{osc}\approx\tfrac12mg\ell\theta_a^2$ and $\omega=\sqrt{g/\ell}$: $\ell^{3/2}\theta_a^2$ stays constant.
Step 4. Numbers
At $\ell=0.25$ m, $z=2\sqrt{9.81\cdot0.25}/0.01=313\gg1$ and $u/\sqrt{g\ell}=0.0064$. The law predicts $\theta_a=0.05\,(0.25)^{-3/4}=0.05\cdot2.828=0.1414$ rad: the swing angle almost triples, while the horizontal excursion $\ell\theta_a\propto\ell^{1/4}$ shrinks by the factor $0.707$. A Runge-Kutta integration of $(\ell_0-ut)\ddot\theta-2u\dot\theta+g\sin\theta=0$ gives $0.1401$ rad at the last turning point ($\ell=0.253$ m), where the law gives $0.1400$ rad.
- Graded: $\dot\theta=-u\,\theta'$, $\ddot\theta=u^2\theta''$ (chain rule) and the reduced equation below. Everything after it (Bessel solution, $\ell^{-3/4}$ law, numbers) is an extension, not expected in the exam.
- $\ell\,\theta''+2\theta'+\dfrac{g}{u^2}\,\theta=0$, i.e. $\dfrac1\ell\dfrac{d}{d\ell}\big(\ell^2\theta'\big)+\dfrac{g}{u^2}\theta=0$.
- $\theta=\ell^{-1/2}\big[A\,J_1(z)+B\,Y_1(z)\big]$, $z=2\sqrt{g\ell}/u$; for $z\gg1$, $J_1,Y_1\sim\sqrt{2/(\pi z)}$ times a cosine, so the amplitude is $\propto\ell^{-1/2}\ell^{-1/4}=\ell^{-3/4}$.
- From $1$ m to $0.25$ m: $\theta_a=0.05\cdot4^{3/4}=0.1414$ rad; a numerical integration of the full equation agrees within $0.2\,\%$.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: every term of $\ell\ddot\theta+2\dot\ell\dot\theta+g\sin\theta$ is m s$^{-2}$; $[mh^2/\ell^3]=\text{kg}\,\text{m}^4\text{s}^{-2}/\text{m}^3=$ N; $[Tu]=$ W; $g\ell/u^2$ is dimensionless.
- Limits: $u=0$ gives the simple pendulum with $T=m(g\cos\theta+\ell\dot\theta^2)$ and energy conservation; $u<0$ (paying the string out) turns $-2u\dot\theta$ into a true damping and the amplitude decreases like $\ell^{-3/4}$.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) forgetting the Coriolis-like term $2\dot\ell\dot\theta$ when $\ell$ varies; (2) claiming that the tension does no work because "it is a constraint force" (it does, because the constraint is rheonomic); (3) writing energy conservation for $P$; (4) using $\ell^2\dot\theta=$ const with gravity (the weight has a moment about $O$); (5) believing that $T$ stays bounded in the gravity-free case.
P12 — Block on an accelerating turntable: the friction cone, the instant of slip and the direction in which the block starts to slide
A horizontal turntable rotates about the fixed vertical axis through its centre $O$. It starts from rest at $t=0$ with constant angular acceleration $\beta>0$, so its angular rate is $\Omega(t)=\beta t$ (counter-clockwise seen from above). A small block $P$ of mass $m$ rests on the table at the distance $r_0$ from the axis; at $t=0$ it lies on the fixed $x$ axis. The contact is rough, with static Coulomb coefficient $\mu$ and kinetic coefficient $\mu_k\le\mu$; gravity is $-g\,\mathbf k$.
Use the inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ ($\mathbf k$ vertical, upward), the turntable frame $S_1$ (rotating with the table), the angle $\varphi$ of $\overrightarrow{OP}$ from the $x$ axis and the unit vectors $\mathbf e_r=\cos\varphi\,\mathbf i+\sin\varphi\,\mathbf j$, $\mathbf e_\varphi=\cos\varphi\,\mathbf j-\sin\varphi\,\mathbf i$.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $g$, $\mu$, $\mu_k$, $r_0$, $\beta$. Numbers: $\mu=0.4$, $\mu_k=0.3$, $r_0=0.5$ m, $\beta=0.2$ rad s$^{-2}$, $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$.
- Hypotheses: point particle (the block does not tip), rigid horizontal table, Coulomb friction, no air drag.
- In (e) and (f) the friction force on $P$ is written $\mathbf F=F_r\,\mathbf e_r+F_\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$ and $\psi$ is its angle from the inward radius $-\mathbf e_r$, positive towards $+\mathbf e_\varphi$ (figure).
Part (a) · 1 point
Degrees of freedom and frames
How many degrees of freedom has $P$ while it sticks to the table, and while it slides on it? Give the angular velocity and the angular acceleration of $S_1$ relative to $S_0$.
Step 1. Count
A free particle has 3 degrees of freedom. While it touches the table, $z=0$ (bilateral as long as $N\ge0$): 2 remain, the polar coordinates $(r,\varphi)$. While it does not slip, it moves with the table: $r=r_0$ and $\varphi$ is the angle turned by the table, $\varphi=\int_0^t\beta\tau\,d\tau=\big[\tfrac12\beta\tau^2\big]_0^t=\tfrac12\beta t^2$. Nothing is left free: 0 degrees of freedom, and the friction force is an unknown reaction that adjusts to keep the block in place, as long as it can (Notes §6.6).
Step 2. Frames
$S_1$ turns about $\mathbf k$ with $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\Omega\,\mathbf k=\beta t\,\mathbf k$; its angular acceleration $\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}_{10}=\beta\,\mathbf k$ is not zero, so in $S_1$ the block feels an Euler force as well as the centrifugal and Coriolis forces.
- Sliding: 2 degrees of freedom $(r,\varphi)$ on the plane $z=0$. Sticking: 0 degrees of freedom, $r=r_0$, $\varphi=\tfrac12\beta t^2$ prescribed.
- $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\beta t\,\mathbf k$, $\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}_{10}=\beta\,\mathbf k$.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Kinematics while the block sticks
Compute the velocity and acceleration of $P$ in $S_0$ in the basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\varphi\}$.
Step 1. Change of basis and unit vectors
The polar basis $\{\mathbf e_r,\mathbf e_\varphi,\mathbf k\}$ turns with the table; its relation to the inertial basis is
Checks: rows 1 and 2 have length $\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi=1$ and $-\cos\varphi\sin\varphi+\sin\varphi\cos\varphi=0$, row 3 is $\mathbf k$, so $[R][R]^T=I$; $\det[R]=\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi=+1$ (right-handed, $\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\varphi=\mathbf k$). Then $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\varphi\,(-\sin\varphi\,\mathbf i+\cos\varphi\,\mathbf j)=\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$ and $\dot{\mathbf e}_\varphi=-\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_r$ (chain rule through $\varphi(t)$).
Step 2. Velocity and acceleration
$\mathbf r=r_0\,\mathbf e_r$ with $r_0$ constant:
The general polar formula $\mathbf a=(\ddot r-r\dot\varphi^2)\mathbf e_r+(r\ddot\varphi+2\dot r\dot\varphi)\mathbf e_\varphi$ gives the same with $\dot r=\ddot r=0$.
- $\mathbf v=r_0\Omega\,\mathbf e_\varphi$.
- $\mathbf a=-r_0\Omega^2\,\mathbf e_r+r_0\beta\,\mathbf e_\varphi$: centripetal and tangential parts.
Part (c) · 2 points
Forces and the friction needed to stick
List the forces on $P$ and find the normal reaction and the friction force needed for the block to move with the table. Check the result in $S_1$.
Step 1. Forces
Weight $-mg\,\mathbf k$; normal reaction $N\,\mathbf k$ ($N\ge0$); friction $\mathbf F=F_r\,\mathbf e_r+F_\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$ in the plane of contact, unknown while the block sticks.
Step 2. Newton in $S_0$
$m\mathbf a=-mg\,\mathbf k+N\,\mathbf k+\mathbf F$. Projecting:
Friction must pull inward (to bend the path) and forward (to speed the block up along with the table).
Step 3. Check in $S_1$ (Notes §4.9)
In $S_1$ the block is at rest, $\mathbf v_{rel}=\mathbf 0$, so the Coriolis force vanishes. Centrifugal: $-m\boldsymbol\omega\times(\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf r)=-m\Omega^2\,\mathbf k\times(\mathbf k\times r_0\mathbf e_r)=-m\Omega^2\,\mathbf k\times r_0\mathbf e_\varphi=mr_0\Omega^2\,\mathbf e_r$. Euler: $-m\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}\times\mathbf r=-m\beta\,\mathbf k\times r_0\mathbf e_r=-mr_0\beta\,\mathbf e_\varphi$. Balance in the plane: $\mathbf F+mr_0\Omega^2\mathbf e_r-mr_0\beta\,\mathbf e_\varphi=\mathbf 0$, the same $F_r$ and $F_\varphi$.
- $N=mg$; $\ F_r=-mr_0\Omega^2=-mr_0\beta^2t^2$; $\ F_\varphi=mr_0\beta$.
- $|\mathbf F|=mr_0\sqrt{\Omega^4+\beta^2}$, increasing in time.
- In $S_1$: $\mathbf F+mr_0\Omega^2\,\mathbf e_r-mr_0\beta\,\mathbf e_\varphi=\mathbf 0$ (centrifugal and Euler forces, no Coriolis).
Part (d) · 2 points
When does the block slip?
Using the Coulomb condition, find the instant $t^*$ at which the block starts to slide. What condition must $\beta$ satisfy for the block to stick at all?
Step 1. The friction cone
Static friction holds while $|\mathbf F|\le\mu N$ (Notes §6.6). With (c):
Step 2. Slip instant
The left side grows with $t$ ($\Omega=\beta t$), so the inequality fails for the first time when it becomes an equality:
Step 3. Existence
A real $\Omega^*\ge0$ needs $\beta\le\mu g/r_0$. In the equality case $\beta=\mu g/r_0$ the formula gives $\Omega^*=0$, $t^*=0$: the friction is already at the limit of the cone at $t=0$ and the block slides as soon as $\Omega>0$, so it never sticks for a finite time. Sticking therefore requires the strict condition $\beta<\mu g/r_0$. If $\beta>\mu g/r_0$, already at $t=0$ (where $\Omega=0$) the tangential friction $mr_0\beta$ needed exceeds $\mu mg$: the table slides under the block from the start. Dropping $\beta^2$ in the cone (the usual shortcut $r_0\Omega^2=\mu g$) hides exactly this case.
- $r_0^2\big(\Omega^4+\beta^2\big)\le\mu^2g^2$; slip when $\Omega^{*4}=\Big(\dfrac{\mu g}{r_0}\Big)^2-\beta^2$.
- $t^*=\dfrac{\Omega^*}{\beta}=\dfrac1\beta\Big[\Big(\dfrac{\mu g}{r_0}\Big)^2-\beta^2\Big]^{1/4}$; requires $\beta<\mu g/r_0$ (at $\beta=\mu g/r_0$, $t^*=0$), otherwise it slips at $t=0$.
Part (e) · 1.5 points
Numbers and the direction of the friction at the slip instant
For the data of the Setup compute $\Omega^*$, $t^*$, the number of turns before slip and the speed of the block, and the angle $\psi$ of the friction force at $t^*$.
Step 1. Instant of slip
$\mu g/r_0=0.4\cdot9.81/0.5=7.848$ s$^{-2}$, so $(\mu g/r_0)^2=61.591$ s$^{-4}$ and $\Omega^{*4}=61.591-0.04=61.551$ s$^{-4}$. Then $\Omega^{*2}=7.8454$ s$^{-2}$, $\Omega^*=2.801$ rad s$^{-1}$ and $t^*=2.801/0.2=14.00$ s. Here $\beta^2/(\mu g/r_0)^2=6.5\times10^{-4}$: the tangential part barely changes $t^*$.
Step 2. Turns and speed
$\varphi^*=\tfrac12\beta t^{*2}=\Omega^{*2}/(2\beta)=7.8454/0.4=19.61$ rad, i.e. $19.61/2\pi=3.12$ turns. The speed is $r_0\Omega^*=1.400$ m s$^{-1}$, along $\mathbf e_\varphi$.
Step 3. Direction of the friction
At $t^*$: $|F_r|=mr_0\Omega^{*2}=3.923\,m$ N and $F_\varphi=mr_0\beta=0.1\,m$ N, so $\tan\psi=\beta/\Omega^{*2}=0.2/7.8454=0.0255$ and $\psi=1.460^\circ$. Check: $\cos\psi=r_0\Omega^{*2}/(\mu g)$, and $|\mathbf F|=\mu mg=3.924\,m$ N. The friction points to the axis, tilted $1.46^\circ$ forward.
- $\mu g/r_0=7.848$ s$^{-2}$, $\Omega^{*4}=61.551$ s$^{-4}$, $\Omega^*=2.801$ rad s$^{-1}$, $t^*=14.00$ s.
- $\varphi^*=\Omega^{*2}/2\beta=19.61$ rad $=3.12$ turns; $\ |\mathbf v|=r_0\Omega^*=1.400$ m s$^{-1}$.
- $\tan\psi=\beta/\Omega^{*2}=0.0255$, $\psi=1.460^\circ$, inward and slightly forward.
Part (f) · 2 points
How does the block start to slide?
Just after $t^*$ the friction is kinetic, of modulus $\mu_kmg$. Find the initial acceleration of $P$ relative to the table, its modulus and its direction. Does the block leave along the radius? Describe its motion in $S_0$ at that instant.
Step 1. Inertia forces at $t^*$
In $S_1$, with $\mathbf v_{rel}=\mathbf 0$, the inertia forces are those of (c): $\mathbf F_{in}=mr_0\Omega^{*2}\,\mathbf e_r-mr_0\beta\,\mathbf e_\varphi$. By (c) and (d), $\mathbf F_{in}=-\mathbf F_{needed}$ and $|\mathbf F_{in}|=\mu mg$. It points outward and backward (against the rotation), at the angle $\psi$ from $+\mathbf e_r$.
Step 2. Direction of sliding
Once static friction fails, the block starts to move relative to the table along the unit vector $\hat{\mathbf u}$ of its relative acceleration, and kinetic friction opposes that motion: $\mathbf F_k=-\mu_kmg\,\hat{\mathbf u}$. In $S_1$, $m\mathbf a_{rel}=\mathbf F_{in}-\mu_kmg\,\hat{\mathbf u}$ must be parallel to $\hat{\mathbf u}$, which is possible only if $\hat{\mathbf u}$ is along $\mathbf F_{in}$:
Components: $0.981\cos\psi=0.9807$ m s$^{-2}$ outward and $-0.981\sin\psi=-0.0250$ m s$^{-2}$ along $\mathbf e_\varphi$: the block lags behind the table as it drifts out. It does not start along the radius.
Step 3. Cross-check in $S_0$
In $S_0$, $\mathbf a=\mathbf F_k/m=\mu_kg\,\hat{\mathbf F}_{needed}$ (inward and forward, $2.943$ m s$^{-2}$), while the point of the table under the block has $\mathbf a_{drag}=\mu g\,\hat{\mathbf F}_{needed}$ ($3.924$ m s$^{-2}$, part (c)). With $\mathbf v_{rel}=\mathbf 0$ the Coriolis term vanishes and $\mathbf a_{rel}=\mathbf a-\mathbf a_{drag}=(\mu_k-\mu)g\,\hat{\mathbf F}_{needed}$: the same result. In $S_0$ the block moves at $1.400$ m s$^{-1}$ tangentially; it is not "flung out along the radius". It simply cannot be pulled inward hard enough to stay on its circle, so its path opens out.
Step 4. Equal coefficients
If $\mu_k=\mu$, $\mathbf a_{rel}(t^{*+})=\mathbf 0$: the sliding starts smoothly, driven by the growth of $\Omega$ after $t^*$, but in the same direction.
- In $S_1$: centrifugal $+$ Euler $=-\mathbf F_{needed}$, of modulus $\mu mg$, pointing outward and backward (at $\psi$ behind the outward radius).
- $\mathbf a_{rel}(t^{*+})=(\mu-\mu_k)\,g$ in that direction: $0.981$ m s$^{-2}$, components $0.9807$ m s$^{-2}$ along $\mathbf e_r$ and $-0.0250$ m s$^{-2}$ along $\mathbf e_\varphi$.
- In $S_0$ the velocity is tangential ($1.400$ m s$^{-1}$, no radial launch) and the acceleration $\mu_kg=2.943$ m s$^{-2}$ is smaller than the $\mu g=3.924$ m s$^{-2}$ needed to follow the table.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $\mu g/r_0$ and $\beta$ are s$^{-2}$, so $\Omega^{*4}=(\mu g/r_0)^2-\beta^2$ is s$^{-4}$ and $t^*=\Omega^*/\beta$ is s; $r_0\Omega^2$, $r_0\beta$, $\mu g$ are m s$^{-2}$.
- Limits: $\beta\to0$ (very slow spin-up) gives $r_0\Omega^{*2}=\mu g$, the classic result for uniform rotation, with $\psi\to0$ and sliding along the outward radius in $S_1$; $\beta\to\mu g/r_0$ gives $t^*\to0$ and $\psi\to90^\circ$: the block slides straight backward.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) writing $r_0\Omega^2\le\mu g$ and forgetting the tangential friction $mr_0\beta$; (2) forgetting the Euler force $-m\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}\times\mathbf r$ in $S_1$; (3) putting $|\mathbf F|=\mu N$ before slip (static friction is only bounded by $\mu N$); (4) claiming the block flies off radially in $S_0$.
P13 — Capsule descent under quadratic drag with two parachute stages: terminal speed, quadratures and the work of drag
In a drop test, a capsule of mass $m$ is released from rest from a hovering helicopter at the point $O$ and falls vertically. Its drogue parachute is open from the release: the air exerts on the capsule the drag $-c_1v^2$ along the motion, where $v=\dot y\ge0$ is the speed and $y$ the distance fallen, measured downward from $O$. When the speed reaches $v_1$, the main parachute opens instantaneously and the drag becomes $-c_2v^2$, with $c_2\gg c_1$. Gravity $g$ is uniform and points down; buoyancy and the variation of air density with height are neglected.
Setup
- Data: $m=1000$ kg, $g=9.81$ m s$^{-2}$. The parachutes are given by their terminal speeds: $v_{t1}=50$ m s$^{-1}$ (drogue) and $v_{t2}=8$ m s$^{-1}$ (main). The main parachute opens at $v_1=40$ m s$^{-1}$.
- Hypotheses: point particle, vertical motion (released with no horizontal velocity, no wind), constant drag coefficients within each stage, instantaneous opening.
- The time of stage 2 is counted from the opening, and $\Delta y$ is the distance fallen since the opening.
Part (a) · 1 point
Degrees of freedom, forces and equation of motion
How many degrees of freedom has the capsule? Write the forces and the equation of motion for $v$.
Step 1. Count
With no horizontal force and no horizontal initial velocity the motion is along the vertical: 1 degree of freedom, the coordinate $y$, with unit vector $\mathbf e_y$ pointing down.
Step 2. Forces and Newton
Weight $mg\,\mathbf e_y$ (positive: it points down). Drag $-c|\mathbf v|\mathbf v=-cv^2\,\mathbf e_y$ for $v\ge0$ (upward). Newton (Notes §4.3), with $\mathbf a=\dot v\,\mathbf e_y$:
- 1 degree of freedom, $y(t)$, positive downward.
- $m\dot v=mg-cv^2$ (for $v\ge0$).
Part (b) · 2 points
Terminal speed and $v(t)$ in stage 1
Define the terminal speed $v_t$ and integrate the equation for the drogue stage, from rest at $t=0$, to get $v(t)$ and $y(t)$.
Step 1. Terminal speed
The acceleration vanishes when $mg=cv^2$: $v_t=\sqrt{mg/c}$. With it the equation reads $\dot v=g\big(1-v^2/v_t^2\big)$. For the drogue, $c_1=mg/v_{t1}^2=9810/2500=3.924$ kg m$^{-1}$.
Step 2. Separation of variables
For $0\le v<v_t$:
The antiderivative of the left side is $F(v)=v_t\,\text{artanh}(v/v_t)$. Check with the chain rule: $\dfrac{dF}{dv}=v_t\cdot\dfrac{1}{1-(v/v_t)^2}\cdot\dfrac{1}{v_t}=\dfrac{1}{1-v^2/v_t^2}$.
Step 3. Limits (Barrow's rule)
Integrating from $(t=0,v=0)$ to $(t,v)$:
Since $\tanh<1$, $v$ approaches $v_t$ but never reaches it in finite time.
Step 4. Position
$y=\int_0^tv\,dt'$. With $w=\cosh(gt'/v_t)$, $dw=\dfrac{g}{v_t}\sinh(gt'/v_t)\,dt'$, so $\tanh(gt'/v_t)\,dt'=\dfrac{v_t}{g}\dfrac{dw}{w}$ and
- $v_t=\sqrt{mg/c}$, i.e. $c=mg/v_t^2$; $\ c_1=3.924$ kg m$^{-1}$.
- $\displaystyle\int\frac{dv}{1-v^2/v_t^2}=v_t\,\text{artanh}\frac{v}{v_t}$ for $v<v_t$.
- $v=v_t\tanh\dfrac{gt}{v_t}$, $\ y=\dfrac{v_t^2}{g}\ln\cosh\dfrac{gt}{v_t}$.
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Speed as a function of the distance fallen
Obtain $v(y)$ for stage 1 directly from the equation of motion, without using $t$.
Step 1. Chain rule
With $v=v(y(t))$: $\dot v=\dfrac{dv}{dy}\dot y=v\dfrac{dv}{dy}$, so $v\dfrac{dv}{dy}=g\big(1-v^2/v_t^2\big)$ and, separating, $\dfrac{v\,dv}{1-v^2/v_t^2}=g\,dy$.
Step 2. Substitution
$w=1-v^2/v_t^2$, $dw=-\dfrac{2v}{v_t^2}dv$, so $v\,dv=-\dfrac{v_t^2}{2}dw$. Limits: $v=0\mapsto w=1$, $v\mapsto w=1-v^2/v_t^2$:
Step 3. Result
Cross-check: inserting $y(t)$ of (b), $e^{-2gy/v_t^2}=\cosh^{-2}(gt/v_t)$ and $1-\cosh^{-2}=\tanh^2$, which is $v(t)^2/v_t^2$ of (b).
- $v\dfrac{dv}{dy}=g\Big(1-\dfrac{v^2}{v_t^2}\Big)$.
- $v^2=v_t^2\Big(1-e^{-2gy/v_t^2}\Big)$.
Part (d) · 1.5 points
Numbers for the drogue stage
If the main parachute never opened, how long and how far would the capsule fall before reaching $95\,\%$ of $v_{t1}$? When and where does it actually reach $v_1=40$ m s$^{-1}$?
Step 1. $95\,\%$ of the terminal speed
$v_{t1}/g=50/9.81=5.097$ s and $\text{artanh}\,0.95=\tfrac12\ln(1.95/0.05)=1.8318$, so $t_{95}=9.336$ s. From (c), $y=-\dfrac{v_t^2}{2g}\ln\big(1-v^2/v_t^2\big)$ with $v_t^2/2g=127.4$ m and $\ln(1/0.0975)=2.3279$: $y_{95}=296.6$ m.
Step 2. Opening of the main parachute
$\text{artanh}\,0.8=\tfrac12\ln9=1.0986$, so $t_1=5.097\cdot1.0986=5.600$ s, and $y_1=127.4\cdot\ln(1/0.36)=127.4\cdot1.0217=130.2$ m. A numerical integration of the equation of motion gives the same values.
- $t_{95}=\dfrac{v_{t1}}{g}\text{artanh}\,0.95=9.336$ s; $\ y_{95}=\dfrac{v_{t1}^2}{2g}\ln\dfrac{1}{1-0.95^2}=296.6$ m.
- $v_1=0.8\,v_{t1}$ is reached at $t_1=5.600$ s, $y_1=130.2$ m.
Part (e) · 2 points
Stage 2: the main parachute
At the opening $v_1>v_{t2}$. Find the acceleration just after the opening, solve for $v(t)$ in stage 2, and compute the time and the distance needed to come down to $1.05\,v_{t2}$. Why can the formula of (b) not be used?
Step 1. Acceleration at the opening
$c_2=mg/v_{t2}^2=9810/64=153.3$ kg m$^{-1}$ ($c_2/c_1=39.06$). Just after the opening $v=40$ m s$^{-1}$, so $\dot v=g\big(1-(40/8)^2\big)=-24g=-235.4$ m s$^{-2}$: the drag $c_2v_1^2=245.3$ kN is 25 times the weight.
Step 2. Why not $\tanh$
The formula $v=v_t\tanh(\dots)$ is bounded by $v_t$, so it can never start at $v_1=5v_{t2}$; equivalently the constant of integration would be $\text{artanh}\,5$, which is not real. For $v>v_t$ the antiderivative of $1/(1-v^2/v_t^2)$ is $v_t\,\text{arcoth}(v/v_t)$: $\dfrac{d}{dv}\big[v_t\,\text{arcoth}(v/v_t)\big]=\dfrac{1}{1-v^2/v_t^2}$, the same derivative as $\text{artanh}$ on the other branch.
Step 3. Integration
From $(t=0,v=v_1)$ to $(t,v)$:
$\coth>1$ and decreases, so $v$ decreases monotonically to $v_{t2}$ from above.
Step 4. Time to $1.05\,v_{t2}$
$t=\dfrac{v_{t2}}{g}\Big(\text{arcoth}\,1.05-\text{arcoth}\,5\Big)$, with $\text{arcoth}\,1.05=\tfrac12\ln41=1.8568$ and $\text{arcoth}\,5=\tfrac12\ln1.5=0.2027$: $t=0.8155\cdot1.6541=1.349$ s.
Step 5. Distance
As in (c), $\dfrac{v\,dv}{1-v^2/v_{t2}^2}=g\,dy$, now integrated from $(\Delta y=0,\ v=v_1)$ to $(\Delta y,\ v)$. Substitute $w=1-v'^2/v_{t2}^2$, $dw=-\dfrac{2v'}{v_{t2}^2}dv'$, so $v'\,dv'=-\dfrac{v_{t2}^2}{2}dw$; the limits become $w_1=1-v_1^2/v_{t2}^2=-24$ and $w=1-v^2/v_{t2}^2$. In stage 2 $v'>v_{t2}$, so $w<0$ on the whole interval and the antiderivative of $1/w$ is $\ln|w|$ (not $\ln w$):
With $|w_1|=(v_1^2-v_{t2}^2)/v_{t2}^2$ and $|w|=(v^2-v_{t2}^2)/v_{t2}^2$ the factors $v_{t2}^2$ cancel in the quotient; solving for $\Delta y$ and, inversely, for $v^2$:
With $v=8.4$ m s$^{-1}$: $\Delta y=3.262\cdot\ln(1536/6.56)=3.262\cdot5.456=17.80$ m.
- $c_2=153.3$ kg m$^{-1}$; $\dot v(0^+)=g\big(1-v_1^2/v_{t2}^2\big)=-24\,g=-235.4$ m s$^{-2}$ (a deceleration; drag $245.3$ kN against a weight of $9.81$ kN).
- $v=v_{t2}\coth\Big(\dfrac{gt}{v_{t2}}+\text{arcoth}\dfrac{v_1}{v_{t2}}\Big)$, decreasing towards $v_{t2}$ from above.
- To $8.4$ m s$^{-1}$: $t=1.349$ s, $\Delta y=17.80$ m.
Part (f) · 2 points
Work of the drag and energy balance
Is the mechanical energy conserved? Compute the work done by the drag (i) in stage 1, from the release to the opening, and (ii) in stage 2, from the opening to $v=8.4$ m s$^{-1}$, from the energy balance; then check (ii) by integrating the drag force along the path.
Step 1. Energy is not conserved
The power of the drag is $(-cv^2\,\mathbf e_y)\cdot(v\,\mathbf e_y)=-cv^3<0$ (Notes §4.4): it removes mechanical energy as long as the capsule moves. Only the weight is conservative ($V=-mgy$ with $y$ downward), so $\dfrac{d}{dt}\big(\tfrac12mv^2-mgy\big)=-cv^3$. At the opening the dissipated power is $c_2v_1^3=153.3\cdot64\,000$ W $=9.81$ MW.
Step 2. Stage 1
From $v=0$, $y=0$ to $v_1=40$ m s$^{-1}$, $y_1=130.2$ m: $\Delta E_{kin}=\tfrac12\cdot1000\cdot1600=800.0$ kJ and $W_{weight}=mgy_1=1277.1$ kJ, so $W_{drag,1}=800.0-1277.1=-477.1$ kJ.
Step 3. Stage 2 from the energy balance
$\Delta E_{kin}=\tfrac12\cdot1000\,(70.56-1600)=-764.7$ kJ and $W_{weight}=9810\cdot17.80=174.6$ kJ, so $W_{drag,2}=-764.7-174.6=-939.3$ kJ: in under $18$ m the main parachute absorbs almost twice what the drogue absorbed in $130$ m.
Step 4. Direct integral
$W_{drag,2}=-\int_0^{\Delta y}c_2v^2\,ds$ with $v^2=v_{t2}^2+(v_1^2-v_{t2}^2)e^{-2gs/v_{t2}^2}$ and $c_2v_{t2}^2=mg$:
and by (e), $\big(v_1^2-v_{t2}^2\big)\big(1-e^{-2g\Delta y/v_{t2}^2}\big)=v_1^2-v^2$, so $W_{drag,2}=-\big(mg\Delta y+\tfrac12m(v_1^2-v^2)\big)=-939.3$ kJ, the value of Step 3.
- No: the drag power $-cv^3<0$ dissipates energy ($9.81$ MW just after the opening).
- (i) $W_{drag,1}=\tfrac12mv_1^2-mgy_1=800.0-1277.1=-477.1$ kJ.
- (ii) $W_{drag,2}=\tfrac12m(8.4^2-40^2)-mg\Delta y=-764.7-174.6=-939.3$ kJ; the direct integral gives $-\big(mg\Delta y+\tfrac12m(v_1^2-v^2)\big)$, the same.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $[c]=$ N/(m s$^{-1}$)$^2=$ kg m$^{-1}$, so $\sqrt{mg/c}$ is m s$^{-1}$; $gt/v_t$ and $gy/v_t^2$ are dimensionless (arguments of $\tanh$ and $\exp$); $[cv^3]=$ W.
- Limits: for $gt\ll v_t$, $\tanh x\approx x$ gives $v\approx gt$ and $y\approx\tfrac12gt^2$ (free fall); for $t\to\infty$ both $\tanh$ and $\coth$ tend to 1 and $v\to v_t$, from below in stage 1 and from above in stage 2; $y\approx v_t t-\tfrac{v_t^2}{g}\ln2$ for large $t$ in stage 1.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) writing the drag as $+cv^2$ or $-cv$ (wrong sign or wrong law); (2) using $v=v_t\tanh(\dots)$ after the main parachute opens, which would need $\text{artanh}$ of a number larger than 1; (3) skipping the chain rule $\dot v=v\,dv/dy$; (4) assuming the terminal speed is reached in a finite time; (5) writing energy conservation with drag acting.
P14 — A spiral trajectory flown at constant speed: polar and intrinsic kinematics, a non-central force and zero power
A drone $P$ of mass $m$ flies in a horizontal plane (its weight is balanced by the vertical lift, which is not studied). In this plane take the inertial frame $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j\}$ and the polar coordinates $(r,\varphi)$ of $P$ about $O$, with $\varphi$ measured from $\mathbf i$ counter-clockwise and the polar basis $\mathbf e_r=\cos\varphi\,\mathbf i+\sin\varphi\,\mathbf j$, $\mathbf e_\varphi=-\sin\varphi\,\mathbf i+\cos\varphi\,\mathbf j$. The autopilot keeps $P$ on the logarithmic spiral
with a constant speed $|\mathbf v|=v_0$ and $\varphi$ increasing. At $t=0$ the drone is at $\varphi=0$, $r=r_0$. The resultant of the horizontal forces on the drone (thrust and drag) is called $\mathbf F$. Let $\mathbf e_t$, $\mathbf e_n$ be the unit tangent and the principal normal of the trajectory, $\rho$ its radius of curvature and $\alpha$ the angle between $\mathbf e_r$ and $\mathbf e_t$.
Setup
- Data: $r_0$, $b$, $v_0$, $m$. In the numerical parts: $r_0=20$ m, $b=3/4$, $v_0=10$ m/s, $m=2$ kg, and the drone flies from $r_1=r_0=20$ m to $r_2=50$ m.
- Hypotheses: point particle, planar motion in the horizontal plane, $S_0$ inertial; the trajectory and the speed are imposed by the autopilot (the force $\mathbf F$ is whatever is needed to keep them).
- Useful constant: $k\equiv\sqrt{1+b^2}$; for $b=3/4$, $k=\sqrt{1+9/16}=5/4$.
Part (a) · 2 points
Velocity in polar coordinates and the constant angle
How many parameters fix the position of $P$ on the trajectory? Write $\mathbf v$ in the polar basis and obtain $\dot r$ and $\dot\varphi$ as functions of $r$ from the two conditions of the statement. Show that the angle $\alpha$ between the velocity and the radius is constant. Give the numbers for the data of the Setup.
Step 1. Parameters
A free point of the plane has two coordinates $(r,\varphi)$. The trajectory $r=r_0e^{b\varphi}$ is one relation between them, so one parameter (for instance $\varphi$, or $r$, or the arc length $s$) fixes the position on the curve. The speed law $|\mathbf v|=v_0$ then fixes how that parameter changes with time: nothing is left free, which is why this is a pure kinematics problem and $\mathbf F$ is an output.
Step 2. Velocity in the polar basis
The polar basis turns with $\varphi$; its relation to the inertial basis is
with $[R][R]^T=\begin{pmatrix}\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi&-\cos\varphi\sin\varphi+\sin\varphi\cos\varphi\ -\sin\varphi\cos\varphi+\cos\varphi\sin\varphi&\sin^2\varphi+\cos^2\varphi\end{pmatrix}=I$ and $\det[R]=\cos^2\varphi+\sin^2\varphi=+1$ (same orientation as $\{\mathbf i,\mathbf j\}$). Differentiating the rows with the chain rule gives $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$ and $\dot{\mathbf e}_\varphi=-\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_r$.
With $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$ and $\dot{\mathbf e}_\varphi=-\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_r$ (Notes §2.6), differentiating $\mathbf r=r\,\mathbf e_r$ with the product rule:
Step 3. The trajectory relates $\dot r$ and $\dot\varphi$
By the chain rule $\frac{d}{dt}r(\varphi(t))=\frac{dr}{d\varphi}\dot\varphi$, with $\frac{dr}{d\varphi}=b\,r_0e^{b\varphi}=b\,r$:
Step 4. The speed fixes $\dot\varphi$
With $\dot\varphi>0$ (the statement):
The radial velocity is constant although $\dot\varphi$ is not: $\dot\varphi$ decreases as $1/r$.
Step 5. The angle with the radius
$\mathbf v=v_0\,\mathbf e_t$, so $\cos\alpha=\mathbf e_r\cdot\mathbf e_t=\dot r/v_0$ and $\sin\alpha=\mathbf e_\varphi\cdot\mathbf e_t=r\dot\varphi/v_0$:
independent of the point: the logarithmic spiral cuts every radius at the same angle (it is the equiangular spiral).
Step 6. Numbers
$k=5/4$: $\dot r=\frac{(3/4)\cdot10}{5/4}=6$ m/s, $\ r\dot\varphi=\frac{v_0}{k}=8$ m/s (check: $6^2+8^2=10^2$), $\ \tan\alpha=4/3$, $\ \alpha=53.13^\circ$.
- One parameter ($\varphi$, or $r$, or $s$); with the speed imposed, the motion is fully determined.
- $\dot r=b\,r\dot\varphi$, $\ \dot\varphi=\dfrac{v_0}{r\sqrt{1+b^2}}$, $\ \dot r=\dfrac{b\,v_0}{\sqrt{1+b^2}}$ constant.
- $\tan\alpha=\dfrac{r\dot\varphi}{\dot r}=\dfrac1b$; numbers: $\dot r=6$ m/s, $r\dot\varphi=8$ m/s, $\alpha=\arctan(4/3)=53.13^\circ$.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Time law: $r(t)$, $\varphi(t)$ and the flight time
Integrate the results of (a) to obtain $r(t)$ and $\varphi(t)$, and check that they lie on the spiral. Compute the time needed to go from $r_1=20$ m to $r_2=50$ m and the angle turned.
Step 1. Radial law
$\dot r=c$ with $c=bv_0/k$ constant. Integrating from $0$ to $t$ with Barrow's rule, $r(t)-r(0)=\int_0^tc\,d\tau=c\,t$:
Step 2. Angular law (quadrature)
Substitution $u=r_0+c\tau$, $du=c\,d\tau$; the limits $\tau=0\mapsto u=r_0$ and $\tau=t\mapsto u=r(t)$:
since $\frac{v_0}{kc}=\frac{v_0}{k}\cdot\frac{k}{bv_0}=\frac1b$. Inverting, $r(t)=r_0e^{b\varphi(t)}$: the time law lies on the spiral, as it must.
Step 3. Flight time and angle turned
$r_2-r_1=c\,t_{12}$:
- $r(t)=r_0+\dfrac{b\,v_0}{\sqrt{1+b^2}}\,t$, $\ \varphi(t)=\dfrac1b\ln\dfrac{r(t)}{r_0}$.
- $t_{12}=\dfrac{(r_2-r_1)\sqrt{1+b^2}}{b\,v_0}=5$ s; $\ \Delta\varphi=\dfrac{\ln(5/2)}{3/4}=1.2217$ rad $=70.00^\circ$.
Part (c) · 1.5 points
Arc length and the intrinsic basis
Obtain the arc length $s(r)$ measured from $r_0$, and check it against $v_0\,t_{12}$. Write $\mathbf e_t$ and the principal normal $\mathbf e_n$ in the polar basis.
Step 1. Arc length
From $\varphi(r)=\frac1b\ln\frac r{r_0}$, $\frac{d\varphi}{dr}=\frac1{br}$, so $r\,d\varphi=\frac{dr}{b}$ and
Integrating from $r_0$ to $r$ (Barrow):
From 20 m to 50 m: $s=\frac{5/4}{3/4}\cdot30=50$ m, equal to $v_0t_{12}=10\cdot5=50$ m, as it must at constant speed.
Step 2. Unit tangent
$\mathbf e_t=\mathbf v/v_0$ with the components of (a):
Step 3. Principal normal
The components of $\mathbf e_t$ are constant, so only the basis vectors change. With the product rule and $\dot{\mathbf e}_r=\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$, $\dot{\mathbf e}_\varphi=-\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_r$:
By the chain rule $\frac{d\mathbf e_t}{ds}=\frac{\dot{\mathbf e}_t}{\dot s}$ with $\dot s=v_0$, and the principal normal is the unit vector of $d\mathbf e_t/ds$ (Notes §2.4). The vector $(-\mathbf e_r+b\,\mathbf e_\varphi)/k$ has modulus $\sqrt{1+b^2}/k=1$, so
Check: $\mathbf e_t\cdot\mathbf e_n=(-b+b)/k^2=0$, and $\mathbf e_n$ is $\mathbf e_t$ turned $+90^\circ$ (to the left of the motion, towards the concave side and partly towards $O$).
- $s(r)=\dfrac{\sqrt{1+b^2}}{b}\,(r-r_0)$; from 20 m to 50 m: $s=50$ m $=v_0t_{12}$.
- $\mathbf e_t=\dfrac{b\,\mathbf e_r+\mathbf e_\varphi}{\sqrt{1+b^2}}$, $\ \mathbf e_n=\dfrac{-\mathbf e_r+b\,\mathbf e_\varphi}{\sqrt{1+b^2}}$ (towards the concave side, to the left of the motion).
Part (d) · 2 points
Acceleration, radius of curvature
Compute the acceleration in polar components. Obtain the radius of curvature $\rho$ and show that $\mathbf a=\dfrac{v_0^2}{\rho}\,\mathbf e_n$. Numbers at $r=20$ m and at $r=50$ m.
Step 1. Polar acceleration
Differentiating $\mathbf v=\dot r\,\mathbf e_r+r\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi$ with the product rule (Notes §2.6):
Step 2. The derivatives needed
$\ddot r=0$ because $\dot r$ is constant. From $\dot\varphi=\frac{v_0}{k}\,r^{-1}$, with the chain rule $\frac{d}{dt}r^{-1}=-r^{-2}\dot r$:
Step 3. Components
Step 4. Intrinsic form and radius of curvature
The curvature is $1/\rho=|d\mathbf e_t/ds|=\dot\varphi/v_0=\frac1{rk}$ (part (c)), so $\rho=r\sqrt{1+b^2}$. In the intrinsic basis (Notes §2.5) $\mathbf a=\dot v\,\mathbf e_t+\frac{v^2}{\rho}\,\mathbf e_n$ with $\dot v=0$:
which coincides with Step 3: the two routes agree. Check: $\sqrt{a_r^2+a_\varphi^2}=\frac{v_0^2\sqrt{1+b^2}}{r(1+b^2)}=\frac{v_0^2}{\rho}$.
Step 5. Numbers
At $r=20$ m: $\rho=20\cdot\frac54=25$ m, $|\mathbf a|=\frac{100}{25}=4$ m/s$^2$, $a_r=-\frac{100}{20\cdot25/16}=-3.2$ m/s$^2$, $a_\varphi=\frac34\cdot3.2=2.4$ m/s$^2$ (check: $3.2^2+2.4^2=16$). At $r=50$ m: $\rho=62.5$ m and $|\mathbf a|=1.6$ m/s$^2$: the spiral opens up and the turn becomes gentler.
- $a_r=-\dfrac{v_0^2}{r(1+b^2)}$, $\ a_\varphi=\dfrac{b\,v_0^2}{r(1+b^2)}$, $\ \rho=r\sqrt{1+b^2}$, $\ |\mathbf a|=\dfrac{v_0^2}{r\sqrt{1+b^2}}$.
- At $r=20$ m: $\rho=25$ m, $a_r=-3.2$ m/s$^2$, $a_\varphi=2.4$ m/s$^2$, $|\mathbf a|=4$ m/s$^2$; at $r=50$ m: $|\mathbf a|=1.6$ m/s$^2$.
Part (e) · 1.5 points
Force, torque and angular momentum about $O$
Find the horizontal force $\mathbf F$ needed at $r=20$ m. Is it a central force about $O$? Compute the torque $\mathbf M_O$ and the angular momentum $\mathbf H_O(t)$, and verify the angular momentum theorem between $r_1$ and $r_2$.
Step 1. The force
Newton's second law in the inertial frame, $\mathbf F=m\mathbf a$, with $m=2$ kg and the numbers of (d):
In general $\mathbf F=\frac{mv_0^2}{\rho}\mathbf e_n$. Since $\mathbf e_n\cdot(-\mathbf e_r)=1/k$, the angle $\gamma$ between $\mathbf F$ and $-\mathbf e_r$ has $\cos\gamma=1/\sqrt{1+b^2}$, i.e. $\tan\gamma=b$: $\gamma=\arctan(3/4)=36.87^\circ$. The force is not central: $F_\varphi\ne0$ at every point.
Step 2. Torque
$\mathbf M_O=\mathbf r\times\mathbf F=r\,\mathbf e_r\times(F_r\mathbf e_r+F_\varphi\mathbf e_\varphi)=r\,F_\varphi\,\mathbf k$ (since $\mathbf e_r\times\mathbf e_\varphi=\mathbf k$):
constant along the whole flight, although $\mathbf F$ changes.
Step 3. Angular momentum
$\mathbf r\times\mathbf v=r\,\mathbf e_r\times(\dot r\,\mathbf e_r+r\dot\varphi\,\mathbf e_\varphi)=r^2\dot\varphi\,\mathbf k$, so with $\dot\varphi$ of (a):
At $r=20$ m: $H_O=\frac{2\cdot20\cdot10}{1.25}=320$ kg m$^2$/s; at $r=50$ m: $800$ kg m$^2$/s.
Step 4. Angular momentum theorem
About the fixed point $O$, $\dot{\mathbf H}_O=\mathbf M_O$ (Notes §4.8). By the chain rule $\frac{d}{dt}H_O=\frac{mv_0}{k}\dot r=\frac{mv_0}{k}\cdot\frac{bv_0}{k}=\frac{m\,b\,v_0^2}{1+b^2}=M_O$. Integrating from $0$ to $t_{12}$ (Barrow): $H_O(t_{12})-H_O(0)=\int_0^{t_{12}}M_O\,dt=96\cdot5=480$ kg m$^2$/s, and indeed $800-320=480$. The angular momentum is not conserved, and the areal velocity $\frac12r^2\dot\varphi$ grows: Kepler's second law does not hold for this force.
- At $r=20$ m: $F_r=-6.4$ N, $F_\varphi=4.8$ N, $|\mathbf F|=8$ N; it makes $\arctan b=36.87^\circ$ with $-\mathbf e_r$: not central.
- $\mathbf M_O=m\,r\,a_\varphi\,\mathbf k=\dfrac{m\,b\,v_0^2}{1+b^2}\,\mathbf k=96$ N m (constant); $\ \mathbf H_O=\dfrac{m\,r(t)\,v_0}{\sqrt{1+b^2}}\,\mathbf k$: 320 kg m$^2$/s at 20 m, 800 kg m$^2$/s at 50 m; $\Delta H_O=96\cdot5=480$ kg m$^2$/s.
Part (f) · 1.5 points
Power, kinetic energy and the trap
Compute the power of $\mathbf F$ and the work it does between $r_1$ and $r_2$, and check the result with the kinetic energy theorem. A student argues: "the speed is constant, so the drone is in equilibrium and the net force is zero; and since $\mathbf F$ does no work, it must be a central (or conservative) force". Discuss.
Step 1. Power and work
The power of $\mathbf F$ is $P=\mathbf F\cdot\mathbf v$ (Notes §4.5). With $\mathbf F=\frac{mv_0^2}{\rho}\mathbf e_n$ and $\mathbf v=v_0\mathbf e_t$:
In polar components the same result is $m(a_r\dot r+a_\varphi r\dot\varphi)=m\frac{v_0^2}{rk^2}\big(-\frac{bv_0}{k}+b\,\frac{v_0}{k}\big)=0$. The work between $r_1$ and $r_2$ is $W_{12}=\int_0^{t_{12}}P\,dt=0$.
Step 2. Kinetic energy theorem
$\frac{d}{dt}\big(\tfrac12m\,\mathbf v\cdot\mathbf v\big)=m\,\mathbf a\cdot\mathbf v=P=0$, consistent with $|\mathbf v|=v_0$: $E_{kin}=\tfrac12\cdot2\cdot10^2=100$ J at every instant.
Step 3. The trap
- "Constant speed means zero force" confuses the speed $|\mathbf v|$ with the velocity vector. The direction of $\mathbf v$ turns with angular rate $\dot\varphi$ (since $\alpha$ is constant, $\mathbf e_t$ turns exactly as $\mathbf e_r$), so $\mathbf a=\frac{v_0^2}{\rho}\mathbf e_n\neq\mathbf0$: at 20 m the autopilot must supply 8 N.
- "No work, so central" is false: zero power only means $\mathbf F\perp\mathbf v$ at each instant. Here $\mathbf F$ is perpendicular to $\mathbf v$ but makes $36.87^\circ$ with the radius, so it has a moment about $O$ and $\mathbf H_O$ grows by 480 kg m$^2$/s.
- A force perpendicular to the velocity is not conservative in general either: being workless along this path says nothing about the work along other paths. What matters for the energy budget is that it does no work along the actual motion.
- $P=\mathbf F\cdot\mathbf v=\frac{mv_0^2}{\rho}\,v_0\,(\mathbf e_n\cdot\mathbf e_t)=0$; $W_{12}=0$; $E_{kin}=\tfrac12mv_0^2=100$ J at every instant.
- Constant speed is not constant velocity: $|\mathbf F|=mv_0^2/\rho\neq0$. Zero power only says $\mathbf F\perp\mathbf v$; the force is neither zero nor central ($\mathbf M_O\ne\mathbf0$).
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $\dot r=bv_0/k$ and $r\dot\varphi$ are m/s; $\rho=rk$ is m; $a=v_0^2/\rho$ is m$^2$s$^{-2}$/m = m s$^{-2}$; $M_O=mbv_0^2/k^2$ is kg m$^2$s$^{-2}$ = N m; $H_O=mrv_0/k$ is kg m$^2$/s; $t_{12}=(r_2-r_1)k/(bv_0)$ is s.
- Limiting cases: $b\to0$ gives $r=r_0$, $\dot r=0$, $\alpha=90^\circ$, $\rho=r_0$, $a_\varphi=0$: uniform circular motion with a central force $-mv_0^2/r_0\,\mathbf e_r$ and $\mathbf H_O$ constant. $b\to\infty$ gives $\alpha\to0$: an almost radial straight flight with $\rho\to\infty$ and $\mathbf a\to\mathbf0$.
- Flying inwards: with $\varphi$ decreasing, $r$ decreases linearly and reaches $O$ after the finite time $r_0k/(bv_0)=10/3$ s and the finite length $r_0k/b=100/3$ m, while $\varphi=\frac1b\ln(r/r_0)\to-\infty$: infinitely many turns in a finite time, with $\dot\varphi$ and $|\mathbf a|$ growing without bound. A real autopilot cannot follow the spiral to the end.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) setting $a_r=0$ because $\dot r$ is constant (the centripetal term $-r\dot\varphi^2$ remains); (2) taking $\dot\varphi$ constant and dropping $r\ddot\varphi$ in $a_\varphi$; (3) writing $\rho=r$ as for a circle; (4) concluding from $P=0$ that $\mathbf F=\mathbf0$ or that $\mathbf H_O$ is conserved.
P15 — Relative orbital motion near a target on a circular orbit: Clohessy-Wiltshire equations, drift and a counter-intuitive rendezvous
A target $T$ moves on a circular orbit of radius $R_T$ around the Earth, whose centre $O$ is the origin of the inertial frame $S_0$ and whose gravitational parameter is $\mu$ (the Earth's gravity on a mass $m$ at $\mathbf r$ is $-m\mu\,\mathbf r/|\mathbf r|^3$). The target's angular velocity is constant, $n\,\mathbf k$, with the mean motion $n=\sqrt{\mu/R_T^3}$ ($\mathbf k$ normal to the orbital plane). A chaser $P$ of mass $m$, subject only to the Earth's gravity, moves in the same plane close to $T$.
Use the frame $S_1=\{T;\mathbf e_x,\mathbf e_y,\mathbf k\}$ attached to the target: $\mathbf e_x$ radial, pointing away from $O$; $\mathbf e_y=\mathbf k\times\mathbf e_x$ along the target's velocity (along-track); $S_1$ rotates with $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=n\,\mathbf k$. The relative position of the chaser is $\boldsymbol\rho=x\,\mathbf e_x+y\,\mathbf e_y$ with $|\boldsymbol\rho|\ll R_T$. Initial conditions at $t=0$: $x_0$, $y_0$, $\dot x_0$, $\dot y_0$ (relative to $S_1$).
Setup
- Data: $\mu$, $R_T$, $n=\sqrt{\mu/R_T^3}$, the initial conditions. Numerical part (f): $\mu=3.986\times10^{14}$ m$^3$/s$^2$, $R_T=6778$ km (low Earth orbit), chaser 1 km behind the target ($x_0=0$, $y_0=-1000$ m).
- Hypotheses: point masses, planar motion in the orbital plane, $S_0$ inertial, no drag, no other bodies; the target's orbit is not affected by the chaser; terms of order $|\boldsymbol\rho|^2/R_T^2$ are neglected in the gravity difference.
- The frame $S_1$ has a uniformly rotating basis ($\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}_{10}=\mathbf 0$) and an accelerated origin ($\mathbf a_T=-n^2R_T\,\mathbf e_x$).
Part (a) · 1.5 points
Degrees of freedom, frame and relative kinematics
How many degrees of freedom has $P$ in this planar problem? Write the absolute acceleration of $P$ in the basis of $S_1$ as the sum of the acceleration of $T$, the relative acceleration, the Coriolis and the centripetal terms, and list the inertia forces that act on $P$ in $S_1$.
Step 1. Count
$P$ is free in the orbital plane: 2 degrees of freedom, the coordinates $(x,y)$ in $S_1$. There are no constraints and no reactions; the only force is gravity.
Step 2. Motion of the frame
$T$ moves on a circle of radius $R_T$ with constant angular velocity $n\mathbf k$, so its acceleration is purely centripetal: $\mathbf a_T=-n^2R_T\,\mathbf e_x$. The basis of $S_1$ turns with $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=n\mathbf k$, and $\dot{\boldsymbol\omega}_{10}=\mathbf 0$.
Change of basis: take the inertial basis $\{\mathbf i,\mathbf j,\mathbf k\}$ of $S_0$ with $\mathbf i$ along $\overrightarrow{OT}$ at $t=0$. Then $\mathbf e_x=\cos nt\,\mathbf i+\sin nt\,\mathbf j$, $\mathbf e_y=\mathbf k\times\mathbf e_x=-\sin nt\,\mathbf i+\cos nt\,\mathbf j$, and
The rows have length $\cos^2nt+\sin^2nt=1$, rows 1 and 2 are orthogonal ($-\cos nt\sin nt+\sin nt\cos nt=0$) and row 3 is $\mathbf k$, so $[R][R]^T=I$; $\det[R]=\cos^2nt+\sin^2nt=+1$. Differentiating, $\dot{\mathbf e}_x=n\,\mathbf e_y=n\mathbf k\times\mathbf e_x$ and $\dot{\mathbf e}_y=-n\,\mathbf e_x=n\mathbf k\times\mathbf e_y$ (Poisson), which confirms $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=n\,\mathbf k$.
Step 3. Relative kinematics
In $S_1$: $\mathbf v_{rel}=\dot x\,\mathbf e_x+\dot y\,\mathbf e_y$, $\mathbf a_{rel}=\ddot x\,\mathbf e_x+\ddot y\,\mathbf e_y$. With $\mathbf k\times\mathbf e_x=\mathbf e_y$, $\mathbf k\times\mathbf e_y=-\mathbf e_x$:
The composition of accelerations (Notes §3.2), with the Euler term zero, gives
Step 4. Inertia forces
Written as $m\mathbf a_{rel}=\mathbf F+\mathbf F_{in}$ (Notes §4.9), the inertia force is $\mathbf F_{in}=-m\mathbf a_T-2m\boldsymbol\omega\times\mathbf v_{rel}-m\boldsymbol\omega\times(\boldsymbol\omega\times\boldsymbol\rho)$: the dragging force of the origin $mn^2R_T\,\mathbf e_x$, the centrifugal force $mn^2\boldsymbol\rho$ (about $T$) and the Coriolis force $-2mn\,\mathbf k\times\mathbf v_{rel}$. The Coriolis force is perpendicular to $\mathbf v_{rel}$ and does no work in $S_1$.
- 2 degrees of freedom, $(x,y)$; $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=n\mathbf k$ constant, $\mathbf a_T=-n^2R_T\,\mathbf e_x$.
- $\mathbf a_P=\big(-n^2R_T+\ddot x-2n\dot y-n^2x\big)\mathbf e_x+\big(\ddot y+2n\dot x-n^2y\big)\mathbf e_y$.
- Inertia forces in $S_1$: $-m\mathbf a_T=mn^2R_T\,\mathbf e_x$, centrifugal $mn^2\boldsymbol\rho$, Coriolis $-2mn\mathbf k\times\mathbf v_{rel}$; no Euler force.
Part (b) · 2 points
Linearised gravity and the equations of motion
Expand the gravity on $P$ to first order in $|\boldsymbol\rho|/R_T$ and obtain the two equations of relative motion. Explain why the terms in $R_T$ disappear.
Step 1. The exact gravity
$\mathbf r_P=\overrightarrow{OT}+\boldsymbol\rho=(R_T+x)\,\mathbf e_x+y\,\mathbf e_y$ and $|\mathbf r_P|^2=R_T^2\big(1+\tfrac{2x}{R_T}+\tfrac{x^2+y^2}{R_T^2}\big)$.
Step 2. First-order expansion
Keeping only first-order terms, $u=2x/R_T$ and $(1+u)^{-3/2}=1-\tfrac32u+O(u^2)$:
(the product $x\cdot3x/R_T$ and $y\cdot3x/R_T$ are second order and dropped). The circular orbit of $T$ gives $n^2R_T=\mu/R_T^2$ (Notes §8.3), i.e. $\mu/R_T^3=n^2$.
Step 3. Newton in $S_0$, projected on the basis of $S_1$
$m\mathbf a_P=-m\mu\mathbf r_P/|\mathbf r_P|^3$ with $\mathbf a_P$ of (a):
The terms $-n^2R_T$ cancel: the gravity at $T$ is exactly what keeps $T$ (and $S_1$) on its orbit, so only the difference of gravity between $P$ and $T$ (the tidal term) drives the relative motion. Likewise the centrifugal term $-n^2y$ cancels the along-track gravity component. Hence
- $-\mu\,\mathbf r_P/|\mathbf r_P|^3\approx-n^2R_T\,\mathbf e_x+n^2\big(2x\,\mathbf e_x-y\,\mathbf e_y\big)$ (using $\mu=n^2R_T^3$).
- $\ddot x-2n\dot y-3n^2x=0$, $\qquad\ddot y+2n\dot x=0$.
Part (c) · 2 points
Closed-form solution
Solve the equations of (b) for the initial conditions $x_0,y_0,\dot x_0,\dot y_0$.
Step 1. First integral
$\ddot y+2n\dot x=\frac{d}{dt}\big(\dot y+2nx\big)=0$. Integrating from $0$ to $t$ (Barrow): $\big[\dot y+2nx\big]_0^t=0$, so
Step 2. Radial equation
Substitute $\dot y=C-2nx$ in the radial equation: $\ddot x-2n(C-2nx)-3n^2x=0$, i.e.
A particular solution is the constant $x_p=2C/n$; the homogeneous solution is $A\cos nt+B\sin nt$. The initial conditions give $x(0)=2C/n+A=x_0$ and $\dot x(0)=nB=\dot x_0$:
Step 3. Along-track position
From Step 1, $\dot y=C-2nx=-3C-2nA\cos nt-2nB\sin nt$. Integrating from $0$ to $t$ with the antiderivatives $\int\cos n\tau\,d\tau=\frac{\sin n\tau}{n}$ and $\int\sin n\tau\,d\tau=-\frac{\cos n\tau}{n}$ (chain rule: $\frac{d}{d\tau}\sin n\tau=n\cos n\tau$) and Barrow's rule:
With $C$, $A$, $B$:
Check: $x(0)=x_0$, $y(0)=y_0$, $\dot x(0)=\dot x_0$, $\dot y(0)=-6nx_0-3\dot y_0+6nx_0+4\dot y_0=\dot y_0$.
- First integral $\dot y+2nx=C\equiv\dot y_0+2nx_0$; then $\ddot x+n^2x=2nC$.
- $x(t)=4x_0+\dfrac{2\dot y_0}{n}-\Big(3x_0+\dfrac{2\dot y_0}{n}\Big)\cos nt+\dfrac{\dot x_0}{n}\sin nt$.
- $y(t)=y_0-(6nx_0+3\dot y_0)\,t+\Big(6x_0+\dfrac{4\dot y_0}{n}\Big)\sin nt+\dfrac{2\dot x_0}{n}(\cos nt-1)$.
Part (d) · 1.5 points
Secular drift: the trap of the lower orbit
Find the along-track drift per orbit and the condition for no drift. A chaser is placed 1 km below the target on its own circular orbit (radius $R_T-1$ km): does it keep its position below $T$? Compare with a chaser released 1 km below $T$ at rest in $S_1$.
Step 1. Drift per orbit
The periodic terms of $y(t)$ repeat after one orbital period $2\pi/n$, and $x(2\pi/n)=x_0$; only the secular term changes:
It vanishes iff $6nx_0+3\dot y_0=0$:
Step 2. Chaser on its own circular orbit
The circular orbit of radius $R_T+x_0$ has angular rate $n'=\sqrt{\mu/(R_T+x_0)^3}=n\,(1+x_0/R_T)^{-3/2}\approx n\big(1-\tfrac{3x_0}{2R_T}\big)$. Its velocity in $S_1$ is the absolute velocity minus the transport velocity $n\mathbf k\times\mathbf r$: $\dot y_0=(R_T+x_0)(n'-n)\approx R_T\cdot n\cdot\big(-\tfrac{3x_0}{2R_T}\big)=-\tfrac32nx_0$ (first order). Then $C=\tfrac12nx_0$, $A=-3x_0+3x_0=0$, so $x(t)=x_0$ for all $t$ and
For $x_0=-1000$ m: $\Delta y_{orbit}=+3000\pi=+9425$ m per orbit. The trap: "same circular motion, so it stays below" is wrong. The lower orbit has a shorter period (Kepler), so the chaser moves ahead of the target at $\tfrac32n|x_0|$. The no-drift value $-2nx_0$ is not the circular-orbit value $-\tfrac32nx_0$: the drift-free relative motion is the ellipse of (e), not a fixed point.
Step 3. Chaser at rest in $S_1$
With $\dot y_0=0$ (and $\dot x_0=0$): $\Delta y_{orbit}=-12\pi x_0=+12\,000\pi$ m $=+37.70$ km per orbit, while $x$ oscillates between $x_0$ and $7x_0$ ($x(t)=4x_0-3x_0\cos nt$, i.e. down to 7 km below $T$): a point "at rest" below the target is moving slower than the local circular speed and falls into an eccentric orbit.
- $\Delta y_{orbit}=-\dfrac{2\pi}{n}\,(6nx_0+3\dot y_0)=-12\pi x_0-\dfrac{6\pi\dot y_0}{n}$; no drift iff $\dot y_0=-2nx_0$ (i.e. $C=0$).
- Own circular orbit: $\dot y_0\approx-\tfrac32nx_0$, $x\equiv x_0$, $\Delta y_{orbit}=-3\pi x_0=+9.42$ km per orbit for $x_0=-1$ km: it moves ahead of $T$.
- At rest in $S_1$ ($\dot y_0=0$): $\Delta y_{orbit}=-12\pi x_0=+37.70$ km per orbit.
Part (e) · 1.5 points
Bounded relative orbit
For $\dot y_0=-2nx_0$, show that the relative trajectory is an ellipse centred on the along-track axis, with the along-track semi-axis twice the radial one. Find its centre, its period and its sense of motion.
Step 1. Substitution
With $\dot y_0=-2nx_0$: $4x_0+2\dot y_0/n=0$, $3x_0+2\dot y_0/n=-x_0$, $6nx_0+3\dot y_0=0$ and $6x_0+4\dot y_0/n=-2x_0$. Then (c) gives
Step 2. The ellipse
With $A_e\cos\delta=x_0$, $A_e\sin\delta=\dot x_0/n$ and the addition formulas, $x=A_e\cos(nt-\delta)$ and $y-y_c=-2\big(x_0\sin nt-\tfrac{\dot x_0}{n}\cos nt\big)=-2A_e\sin(nt-\delta)$. Using $\cos^2+\sin^2=1$:
an ellipse centred at $(0,y_c)$, with semi-axes $A_e$ (radial) and $2A_e$ (along-track), run once per orbital period $2\pi/n$.
Step 3. Sense of motion
The $\mathbf k$-component of $\big(x\,\mathbf e_x+(y-y_c)\,\mathbf e_y\big)\times\big(\dot x\,\mathbf e_x+\dot y\,\mathbf e_y\big)$ is $x\dot y-(y-y_c)\dot x=A_e\cos\theta\,(-2A_en\cos\theta)-(-2A_e\sin\theta)(-A_en\sin\theta)=-2nA_e^2<0$ (with $\theta=nt-\delta$): the ellipse is run in the sense of $-\mathbf k$. Above the target ($x>0$) the chaser moves backwards ($\dot y<0$), below it moves forwards: higher means slower.
- $x=x_0\cos nt+\dfrac{\dot x_0}{n}\sin nt$, $\ y=y_c-2x_0\sin nt+\dfrac{2\dot x_0}{n}\cos nt$, $\ y_c=y_0-\dfrac{2\dot x_0}{n}$.
- $\dfrac{x^2}{A_e^2}+\dfrac{(y-y_c)^2}{4A_e^2}=1$, $A_e=\sqrt{x_0^2+\dot x_0^2/n^2}$; period $2\pi/n$; run in the sense of $-\mathbf k$ (opposite to the orbital motion).
Part (f) · 1.5 points
A low Earth orbit case: two manoeuvres
Data: $\mu=3.986\times10^{14}$ m$^3$/s$^2$, $R_T=6778$ km; the chaser is 1 km behind the target, $x_0=0$, $y_0=-1000$ m, at rest in $S_1$, and receives an impulse at $t=0$. (i) The impulse is radial, $\dot x_0=+0.5$ m/s. Describe the motion and give the position after half an orbit and after one orbit. (ii) Which along-track impulse $\dot y_0$ (with $\dot x_0=0$) brings the chaser onto the target after exactly one orbit? Which way does it point, how far does the chaser go from the orbit, and with what relative velocity does it arrive?
Step 1. Mean motion
Step 2. Radial impulse
$x_0=0$, $\dot y_0=0$: $C=\dot y_0+2nx_0=0$, so the motion is the bounded ellipse of (e), with $A_e=\dot x_0/n=0.5/1.1314\times10^{-3}=441.9$ m:
At half an orbit ($nt=\pi$): $x=0$, $y=-1000-4\cdot441.9=-2768$ m (the chaser rose and fell behind); centre of the ellipse $y_c=y_0-2\dot x_0/n=-1884$ m. After one orbit it is back at $(0,-1000)$ m: a radial impulse alone gains nothing.
Step 3. Along-track impulse for a one-orbit rendezvous
With $x_0=\dot x_0=0$, (c) gives $x=\frac{2\dot y_0}{n}(1-\cos nt)$ and $y=y_0-3\dot y_0t+\frac{4\dot y_0}{n}\sin nt$. At $t=2\pi/n$, $\sin2\pi=0$, $\cos2\pi=1$: $x=0$ and
The trap: to catch a target 1 km ahead, the chaser must thrust backwards. The backward impulse lowers its orbit ($x$ reaches $\frac{4\dot y_0}{n}=-212.2$ m at half orbit), and the lower orbit is faster, so it gains $3|\dot y_0|\cdot2\pi/n=1000$ m in one period. A forward impulse would raise the chaser and make it fall behind.
Step 4. Arrival
At $t=2\pi/n$: $\dot x=2\dot y_0\sin nt=0$ and $\dot y=-3\dot y_0+4\dot y_0\cos nt=\dot y_0$. The chaser arrives at $T$ with $\mathbf v_{rel}=-0.0600\,\mathbf e_y$ m/s, so a second impulse of $+0.0600$ m/s along $\mathbf e_y$ stops it at the target (total $0.120$ m/s). A numerical integration of the full nonlinear two-body equations from the same initial state misses the target by about 3 m (2.8 m) after one orbit, consistent with neglecting terms of order $|\boldsymbol\rho|^2/R_T$.
- $n=1.1314\times10^{-3}$ rad/s, period $2\pi/n=5553$ s $=92.6$ min.
- (i) $C=0$: bounded ellipse with $A_e=\dot x_0/n=441.9$ m, centre $y_c=-1884$ m; at half orbit $(x,y)=(0,-2768$ m$)$; after one orbit back at $(0,-1000$ m$)$: no gain.
- (ii) $\dot y_0=\dfrac{y_0\,n}{6\pi}=\dfrac{y_0}{3\cdot2\pi/n}=-0.0600$ m/s (backwards); $x$ reaches $4\dot y_0/n=-212.2$ m at half orbit; arrival with $\mathbf v_{rel}=\dot y_0\,\mathbf e_y$, so a braking impulse of $+0.0600$ m/s is needed. A nonlinear two-body integration misses the target by about 3 m (2.8 m).
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $n$ is s$^{-1}$ ($\mu/R^3$ is m$^3$s$^{-2}$/m$^3$); every term of $\ddot x-2n\dot y-3n^2x$ is m s$^{-2}$; $\dot y_0/n$ is m, so $x(t)$ and $y(t)$ are m; $\Delta y_{orbit}=-12\pi x_0-6\pi\dot y_0/n$ is m.
- Limiting cases: $\boldsymbol\rho=\mathbf 0$ with zero relative velocity stays at the origin (the target itself). $n\to0$ (no gravity, non-rotating frame): expanding $\cos nt\approx1-\tfrac12n^2t^2$ and $\sin nt\approx nt-\tfrac16n^3t^3$ in (c) gives $x\to x_0+\dot x_0t$, $y\to y_0+\dot y_0t$, uniform straight motion, as it must.
- Physical meaning of $C$: $C=\dot y+2nx$ is constant; it measures the difference of orbital period between chaser and target (to first order the chaser's semi-major axis differs from $R_T$ by $2C/n$). Equal periods ($C=0$) means no drift; that is why the radial impulse of (f)(i) gives a closed loop.
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) forgetting the acceleration of the origin $\mathbf a_T$ or the centrifugal term, which leaves an $R_T$ term that does not cancel; (2) expanding $|\mathbf r_P|^{-3}$ with the wrong exponent ($1-2x/R_T$ instead of $1-3x/R_T$); (3) assuming that a chaser below the target on its own circular orbit, or at rest in $S_1$, keeps its relative position; (4) thrusting towards the target to catch it.
P16 — Particle on a free wedge: a moving constraint, the reaction, momentum and energy, and the limit of a massless wedge
A wedge of mass $M$ rests on a smooth horizontal table. Its upper face is a smooth plane inclined at the angle $\alpha$ ($0<\alpha<\pi/2$) to the horizontal, descending towards $-x$; the top edge is $A$ and the corner of the wedge under $A$ is $B$. A particle $P$ of mass $m$ is placed on the incline. The inertial frame is $S_0=\{O;\mathbf i,\mathbf j\}$ ($x$ horizontal, $y$ vertical upwards, gravity $-g\,\mathbf j$). The wedge translates without rotating (it does not tip), and its position is the abscissa $X$ of $B$. The position of $P$ on the incline is the distance $s=|AP|$ measured from $A$ down the slope, along the unit vector $\mathbf u=-\cos\alpha\,\mathbf i-\sin\alpha\,\mathbf j$; $\mathbf n=-\sin\alpha\,\mathbf i+\cos\alpha\,\mathbf j$ is the unit normal of the incline pointing out of the wedge. Both bodies are released from rest at $t=0$ with $s=0$.
Setup
- Data: $m$, $M$, $\alpha$, $g$. Numerical parts: $\alpha=30^\circ$, $M=2m$, and the particle has slid a distance $L$ along the incline.
- Hypotheses: point particle, rigid wedge translating on the table, all contacts smooth (no friction), $S_0$ inertial; the contact of $P$ with the incline is unilateral ($N\ge0$, checked in (d)).
- Frames: $S_0$ and the frame $S_1=\{A;\mathbf n,\mathbf u\}$ attached to the wedge, ordered so that it is right-handed: $\mathbf n\times\mathbf u=\big[(-\sin\alpha)(-\sin\alpha)-\cos\alpha\,(-\cos\alpha)\big]\mathbf k=\mathbf k$ (the order $\{\mathbf u,\mathbf n\}$ would give $\mathbf u\times\mathbf n=-\mathbf k$, a left-handed basis). $S_1$ translates with acceleration $\ddot X\,\mathbf i$ and does not rotate.
- Basis change: $\mathbf i=-\sin\alpha\,\mathbf n-\cos\alpha\,\mathbf u$, $\ \mathbf j=\cos\alpha\,\mathbf n-\sin\alpha\,\mathbf u$ (from $\mathbf i\cdot\mathbf n=-\sin\alpha$, $\mathbf i\cdot\mathbf u=-\cos\alpha$, $\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf n=\cos\alpha$, $\mathbf j\cdot\mathbf u=-\sin\alpha$).
In matrix form:
with $[R][R]^T=\begin{pmatrix}\sin^2\alpha+\cos^2\alpha & -\sin\alpha\cos\alpha+\cos\alpha\sin\alpha\\ -\sin\alpha\cos\alpha+\cos\alpha\sin\alpha & \cos^2\alpha+\sin^2\alpha\end{pmatrix}=I$ and $\det[R]=\sin^2\alpha+\cos^2\alpha=+1$.
Part (a) · 1 point
Degrees of freedom and constraints
How many degrees of freedom has the system particle + wedge? Classify the constraint that keeps $P$ on the incline, as seen in $S_0$ and in $S_1$.
Step 1. Count
The wedge is a rigid body in the plane (3 coordinates); the table fixes its height and, since it does not tip, its orientation: 1 coordinate $X$ remains. The particle has 2 coordinates in the plane; staying on the incline removes one, leaving $s$. In total 2 degrees of freedom, $(X,s)$. Unlike a fixed incline, $X(t)$ is an unknown: the motion of the support depends on the motion of the particle.
Step 2. Classification
The condition "$P$ on the incline" reads $\overrightarrow{AP}\cdot\mathbf n=0$, i.e. $-(x_P-X)\sin\alpha+(y_P-h)\cos\alpha=0$ with $\overrightarrow{OA}=X\,\mathbf i+h\,\mathbf j$, a relation between the positions of $P$ and of the wedge: it is holonomic and, written in the system coordinates $(X,s)$ (or $(X,x_P,y_P)$), it contains no explicit time, so it is scleronomic. It would be rheonomic for $P$ alone only if the motion $X(t)$ of the wedge were prescribed from outside; here $X$ is an unknown, so the time enters only through the coordinates. In $S_1$ the plane is fixed. It is unilateral: $P$ can leave the plane upwards, so it holds only while $N\ge0$. Smooth: the reaction is $\mathbf N=N\,\mathbf n$, with no component along $\mathbf u$ (Notes §6.4).
- 2 degrees of freedom, $(X,s)$.
- $P$ on the incline: holonomic, unilateral, smooth; scleronomic as a relation between the coordinates $(X,s)$ of the system (no explicit $t$); it would be rheonomic for $P$ alone only if $X(t)$ were a prescribed function of time, which it is not here.
Part (b) · 1.5 points
Kinematics of $P$
Write the position, velocity and acceleration of $P$ relative to $S_1$ and in $S_0$, in the basis $\{\mathbf n,\mathbf u\}$.
Step 1. Relative motion
$\mathbf u$ is fixed in $S_1$, so $\mathbf r_{rel}=\overrightarrow{AP}=s\,\mathbf u$, $\ \mathbf v_{rel}=\dot s\,\mathbf u$, $\ \mathbf a_{rel}=\ddot s\,\mathbf u$. The relative velocity is tangent to the incline.
Step 2. Absolute motion
$\overrightarrow{OA}=X\,\mathbf i+h\,\mathbf j$ with the height $h$ of the wedge constant, so $\mathbf v_A=\dot X\,\mathbf i$, $\mathbf a_A=\ddot X\,\mathbf i$. Since $\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\mathbf 0$ (Notes §3.2):
Substituting $\mathbf i=-\cos\alpha\,\mathbf u-\sin\alpha\,\mathbf n$:
and in Cartesian components $\mathbf v_P=(\dot X-\dot s\cos\alpha)\,\mathbf i-\dot s\sin\alpha\,\mathbf j$.
- $\mathbf r_{rel}=s\,\mathbf u$, $\ \mathbf v_{rel}=\dot s\,\mathbf u$, $\ \mathbf a_{rel}=\ddot s\,\mathbf u$.
- $\mathbf a_P=\ddot X\,\mathbf i+\ddot s\,\mathbf u=(\ddot s-\ddot X\cos\alpha)\,\mathbf u-\ddot X\sin\alpha\,\mathbf n$.
Part (c) · 2.5 points
Equations of motion and the reaction
Write the forces on $P$ in $S_1$, including the inertia force, and on the wedge. Obtain $\ddot X$, $\ddot s$ and $N$, and the reaction of the table on the wedge.
Step 1. Forces on $P$ in $S_1$
Weight $\mathbf W=-mg\,\mathbf j=mg\sin\alpha\,\mathbf u-mg\cos\alpha\,\mathbf n$; reaction $\mathbf N=N\,\mathbf n$; inertia force of the translating frame (Notes §4.9) $\mathbf F_{in}=-m\,\mathbf a_A=-m\ddot X\,\mathbf i=m\ddot X\cos\alpha\,\mathbf u+m\ddot X\sin\alpha\,\mathbf n$. There is no Coriolis or centrifugal force ($\boldsymbol\omega_{10}=\mathbf 0$).
Step 2. Projections for $P$
$m\,\ddot s\,\mathbf u=\mathbf W+\mathbf N+\mathbf F_{in}$:
The $\mathbf u$ equation is free of the reaction (dynamical decoupling, Notes §6.5), but it still contains the unknown $\ddot X$.
Step 3. The wedge
Forces on the wedge: its weight $-Mg\,\mathbf j$, the table reaction $R\,\mathbf j$ (smooth table, vertical) and $-\mathbf N=-N\mathbf n=N\sin\alpha\,\mathbf i-N\cos\alpha\,\mathbf j$. Newton for the translating wedge, $M\ddot X\,\mathbf i=-Mg\,\mathbf j+R\,\mathbf j-N\mathbf n$:
Step 4. Solve
Substituting $N$ of Step 2 in the wedge equation: $M\ddot X=m\sin\alpha\,(g\cos\alpha-\ddot X\sin\alpha)$, so $\ddot X\,(M+m\sin^2\alpha)=m\,g\sin\alpha\cos\alpha$:
Then, with $\sin^2\alpha+\cos^2\alpha=1$:
and $R=Mg+N\cos\alpha$. All three accelerations are constant. Check with the system: the vertical external forces are $R-(M+m)g=N\cos\alpha-mg$, which equals $m\,\mathbf a_P\cdot\mathbf j=-m\ddot s\sin\alpha$ (the wedge has no vertical acceleration). An independent check with the Lagrange equations in $(X,s)$ gives the same $\ddot X$ and $\ddot s$.
Step 5. Numbers ($\alpha=30^\circ$, $M=2m$)
$M+m\sin^2\alpha=2m+m/4=\tfrac94m$: $\ \ddot X=\dfrac{mg\cdot\frac12\cdot\frac{\sqrt3}2}{\frac94m}=\dfrac{\sqrt3}{9}g=0.1925\,g$, $\ \ddot s=\dfrac{3m\,g\cdot\frac12}{\frac94m}=\dfrac23g$, $\ N=\dfrac{2m\cdot m\,g\frac{\sqrt3}2}{\frac94m}=\dfrac{4\sqrt3}{9}mg=0.7698\,mg$ (smaller than $mg\cos30^\circ=0.866\,mg$ on a fixed wedge).
- $\ddot s=g\sin\alpha+\ddot X\cos\alpha$, $\ N=m(g\cos\alpha-\ddot X\sin\alpha)$, $\ M\ddot X=N\sin\alpha$.
- $\ddot X=\dfrac{m\,g\sin\alpha\cos\alpha}{M+m\sin^2\alpha}$, $\ \ddot s=\dfrac{(M+m)\,g\sin\alpha}{M+m\sin^2\alpha}$, $\ N=\dfrac{M\,m\,g\cos\alpha}{M+m\sin^2\alpha}$.
- Table reaction $R=Mg+N\cos\alpha$.
Part (d) · 1.5 points
Limits, the sign of $N$ and the massless wedge
Check that $N>0$ for every $M>0$. Study the limits $M\to\infty$ and $M\to0$. In the second one a student says: "the particle slides down a plane, so it accelerates along the incline with $g\sin\alpha$ times some factor and presses on it". Discuss.
Step 1. Sign of the reaction
$N=\dfrac{Mmg\cos\alpha}{M+m\sin^2\alpha}$: numerator and denominator are positive for $M>0$ and $0<\alpha<\pi/2$, so $N>0$ throughout the motion (the accelerations are constant, so $N$ is too). The unilateral constraint is never violated, and $R=Mg+N\cos\alpha>Mg>0$: the wedge stays on the table.
Step 2. Heavy wedge
Dividing numerator and denominator by $M$ and letting $M\to\infty$ ($m/M\to0$): $\ddot X\to0$, $\ddot s\to g\sin\alpha$, $N\to mg\cos\alpha$, the results of a fixed incline.
Step 3. Massless wedge (the trap)
Setting $M=0$: $N\to0$, $\ddot X\to\dfrac{mg\sin\alpha\cos\alpha}{m\sin^2\alpha}=g\cot\alpha$, $\ddot s\to\dfrac{mg\sin\alpha}{m\sin^2\alpha}=\dfrac{g}{\sin\alpha}$. The absolute acceleration is
The particle falls freely; the incline exerts no force on it. A massless wedge cannot push back ($M\ddot X=N\sin\alpha$ with $M=0$ forces $N=0$), so it flies away horizontally with $g\cot\alpha$, exactly the motion that keeps the surface under the falling particle. The first half of the student's statement is harmless: $\ddot s=g\sin\alpha\cdot\dfrac{M+m}{M+m\sin^2\alpha}$ is indeed $g\sin\alpha$ times a factor, and this factor is $\ge1$ for every $M$ (because $M+m\ge M+m\sin^2\alpha$), growing from $1$ ($M\to\infty$) to $1/\sin^2\alpha$ ($M\to0$), which gives $\ddot s\to g/\sin\alpha$. The error is the second half, "the particle presses on the wedge": $N\to0$, the incline exerts no force and the particle is in free fall, merely accompanied by the surface.
- $N>0$ for $M>0$ and $0<\alpha<\pi/2$: the particle never leaves the incline; $R>Mg>0$.
- $M\to\infty$: $\ddot X\to0$, $\ddot s\to g\sin\alpha$, $N\to mg\cos\alpha$ (fixed incline).
- $M\to0$: $N\to0$, $\ddot X\to g\cot\alpha$, $\ddot s\to g/\sin\alpha$ and $\mathbf a_P\to-g\,\mathbf j$: free fall; the massless wedge is pushed away just fast enough to stay in contact without force.
- The factor $\ddot s/(g\sin\alpha)=(M+m)/(M+m\sin^2\alpha)\ge1$ grows to $1/\sin^2\alpha$ as $M\to0$; the student's error is "presses on the wedge", since $N\to0$.
Part (e) · 2 points
First integrals and the speeds after sliding a distance $L$
Show that the horizontal linear momentum of the system and its mechanical energy are conserved, explaining why the reaction $\mathbf N$ does no net work although it works on each body. For $\alpha=30^\circ$, $M=2m$, find $\dot s$, $\dot X$ and $|\mathbf v_P|$ when $P$ has slid a distance $L$, and the work of $\mathbf N$ on $P$ and on the wedge.
Step 1. Horizontal momentum
The external forces on the system $\{P,\text{wedge}\}$ are $-mg\,\mathbf j$, $-Mg\,\mathbf j$ and $R\,\mathbf j$: no horizontal component. $\mathbf N$ is internal (action-reaction pair). The linear momentum theorem gives $\frac{d}{dt}p_x=0$, with $p_x=M\dot X+m\,\mathbf v_P\cdot\mathbf i=M\dot X+m(\dot X-\dot s\cos\alpha)$. From rest, $p_x=0$:
Consequently the centre of mass has $\ddot x_G=0$ and moves only vertically.
Step 2. Energy
Powers: the weights are conservative; $R\,\mathbf j\cdot\dot X\,\mathbf i=0$; the pair $\mathbf N$, $-\mathbf N$ has total power
because the relative velocity is tangent to the smooth incline (Notes §6.4). So the mechanical energy of the system is constant (Notes §4.5). With the zero of potential energy at $s=0$, the height of $P$ changes by $-s\sin\alpha$:
Step 3. Kinetic energy for $\alpha=30^\circ$, $M=2m$
$\dot X=\frac{m\cdot\frac{\sqrt3}2}{3m}\,\dot s=\frac{\sqrt3}{6}\,\dot s$. For $P$: $\dot X-\dot s\cos\alpha=\big(\tfrac{\sqrt3}{6}-\tfrac{3\sqrt3}{6}\big)\dot s=-\tfrac{\sqrt3}{3}\dot s$, whose square is $\tfrac13\dot s^2$, and $\dot s^2\sin^2\alpha=\tfrac14\dot s^2$, so $|\mathbf v_P|^2=\tfrac7{12}\dot s^2$ and $\tfrac12m|\mathbf v_P|^2=\tfrac7{24}m\dot s^2$. For the wedge: $\dot X^2=\tfrac3{36}\dot s^2=\tfrac1{12}\dot s^2$ and $\tfrac12(2m)\tfrac1{12}\dot s^2=\tfrac2{24}m\dot s^2$. Total:
Step 4. Speeds after sliding $L$
With $s=L$ and $mgL\sin30^\circ=\tfrac12mgL$:
Check with (c): constant $\ddot s=\tfrac23g$ from rest gives $\dot s^2=2\ddot sL=\tfrac43gL$. The time to slide $L$ is $\sqrt{2L/\ddot s}=\sqrt{3L/g}$ and the wedge has moved $\Delta X=\tfrac{\sqrt3}{6}L=0.2887\,L$ towards $+x$.
Step 5. Work of the reaction on each body
Kinetic energy theorem for $P$ alone: $\tfrac12m|\mathbf v_P|^2=W_{weight}+W_{N\to P}$ with $W_{weight}=\tfrac12mgL$: $W_{N\to P}=\tfrac7{18}mgL-\tfrac9{18}mgL=-\tfrac19mgL$. For the wedge: $W_{-N\to wedge}=\tfrac12(2m)\dot X^2=\tfrac19mgL$. The reaction does work on each body (the incline moves), but the two works cancel: energy is transferred from $P$ to the wedge.
- $p_x=M\dot X+m(\dot X-\dot s\cos\alpha)=0\Rightarrow\dot X=\dfrac{m\cos\alpha}{M+m}\,\dot s$; $\ \tfrac12M\dot X^2+\tfrac12m|\mathbf v_P|^2-mgs\sin\alpha=0$.
- $\alpha=30^\circ$, $M=2m$: $E_{kin}=\tfrac38m\dot s^2$, $\dot s^2=\tfrac43gL$ ($\dot s=1.1547\sqrt{gL}$), $\dot X=\tfrac13\sqrt{gL}$, $|\mathbf v_P|=\tfrac{\sqrt7}{3}\sqrt{gL}=0.8819\sqrt{gL}$.
- Work of $\mathbf N$ on $P$: $-\tfrac19mgL$; on the wedge: $+\tfrac19mgL$; total 0.
Part (f) · 1.5 points
The absolute path of $P$
Show that $P$ moves along a straight line in $S_0$ and find the angle $\beta$ of this line with the horizontal. Compare it with $\alpha$ for $\alpha=30^\circ$, $M=2m$.
Step 1. A straight path
$\mathbf a_P=\ddot X\,\mathbf i+\ddot s\,\mathbf u$ is a constant vector (part (c)). Integrating twice from rest (Barrow): $\mathbf v_P=\mathbf a_P\,t$ and $\mathbf r_P-\mathbf r_P(0)=\tfrac12\mathbf a_P\,t^2$, so $P$ moves along the fixed straight line through its initial position with direction $\mathbf a_P$.
Step 2. Its slope
In Cartesian components $\mathbf a_P=(\ddot X-\ddot s\cos\alpha)\,\mathbf i-\ddot s\sin\alpha\,\mathbf j$; the line descends towards $-x$ with
From (c), $\dfrac{\ddot X}{\ddot s}=\dfrac{m\cos\alpha}{M+m}$ (the same ratio as $\dot X/\dot s$ in (e)), so $\cos\alpha-\dfrac{m\cos\alpha}{M+m}=\dfrac{M\cos\alpha}{M+m}$ and
Step 3. Numbers
$\tan\beta=\tfrac32\cdot\tfrac1{\sqrt3}=\tfrac{\sqrt3}2=0.8660$, $\beta=40.89^\circ$. The particle descends more steeply than the incline, because the incline recedes under it. Check with (e): $|v_{Py}|/|v_{Px}|=\sqrt{gL/3}\big/\tfrac23\sqrt{gL}=\tfrac{\sqrt3}2$.
- $\tan\beta=\dfrac{\ddot s\sin\alpha}{\ddot s\cos\alpha-\ddot X}=\Big(1+\dfrac mM\Big)\tan\alpha$.
- $\alpha=30^\circ$, $M=2m$: $\tan\beta=\tfrac{\sqrt3}{2}$, $\beta=40.89^\circ>\alpha$.
Interpretation and checks
- Dimensional check: $\ddot X$ and $\ddot s$ are $g$ times a ratio of masses times trigonometric factors (m s$^{-2}$); $N=Mmg\cos\alpha/(M+m\sin^2\alpha)$ is kg$\cdot$m s$^{-2}$ = N; $\dot s^2=\tfrac43gL$ is m$^2$s$^{-2}$; the works are $mgL$ times numbers (J).
- Limiting cases: $M\to\infty$ recovers the fixed incline ($\beta\to\alpha$); $M\to0$ gives free fall ($\beta\to90^\circ$, $\tan\beta\to\infty$); $\alpha\to0$ gives $\ddot X=\ddot s=0$, $N=mg$ (nothing moves); $\alpha\to\pi/2$ gives $N\to0$, $\ddot X\to0$, $\ddot s\to g$ (the particle falls along the vertical face).
- Common mistakes in the exam: (1) using $N=mg\cos\alpha$ as on a fixed incline; (2) forgetting the inertia force $-m\ddot X\,\mathbf i$ in $S_1$, or giving it the wrong sign; (3) writing energy conservation for $P$ alone (the reaction works on $P$: $-\tfrac19mgL$ here); (4) assuming the particle's absolute path is parallel to the incline.