Topic 7: Solved Problems

Step-by-step solutions of all 2 problems of the magnetic part of the official sheet (Problems T6andT7_Electric and Magnetic Properties, problems 11 and 12: the hysteresis loops of soft and hard magnetic materials and the effect of the microstructure on a ferromagnetic material, from Session 15). Problems 1 to 10 of the sheet are electrical and belong to Topic 6. The sheet prints no solution for these two, so both are derived here.

Problem 11 Problems T6andT7_Electric and Magnetic Properties.pdf #11 Soft and hard magnets · B-H loop
Click to Collapse ▲

Hysteresis Loops of Soft and Hard Magnetic Materials

Original statement · Problems T6andT7_Electric and Magnetic Properties.pdf, p. 3
  1. Draw the hysteresis curve of a soft magnetic material and a hard magnetic material and indicated in both cases the most significant features. What are the main differences between these two materials?

The sheet prints no solution for this problem.

Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Saturated loop, quasi-static. The loop is the one obtained by cycling the field slowly between $+H_{max}$ and $-H_{max}$, with $H_{max}$ large enough to reach saturation. The drawing is a schematic, as the statement asks for a sketch and gives no numbers.
  2. Features to indicate. The features of the slides are the saturation induction $B_s$ (saturation magnetization $M_s$), the remanence $B_r$, the coercivity $H_c$ and the permeabilities $\mu_i$ and $\mu_{max}$ [Session 15 Slides 16-17].
  3. Soft and hard. The two classes are separated by the coercivity, $H_c = 10\,000$ A/m [Session 15 Slide 18].
  4. Illustration with data. The numbers come from the tables of Slide 24 of Session 15: Table 20-4 (soft materials, with $H_c$ in A/m) and Table 20-6 (hard materials, with $\mu_0 H_c$ in tesla). $\mu_0 = 1.257\times10^{-6}$ H/m [Session 15 Slide 4].

Data

Soft material$\mu_{r,max}$$H_c$ in A/m$B_r$ in T
Ingot iron (99.8 % Fe)5000800.77
Fe-3 % Si, grain-oriented50 00071.20
Superalloy (Fe-5 % Mo-80 % Ni)450 0000.4not printed
Hard material$\mu_0 M_r$ in T$\mu_0 H_c$ in T
Co-steel (Fe-Co)1.070.02
Alnico-5 (Fe-Co-Al-Ni)1.050.06
Ferrite (BaFe₁₂O₁₉)0.420.31
Sm-Co (SmCo₅)0.870.80
Nd-Fe-B (Nd₂Fe₁₄B)1.231.21

Unknown: the two loops with their features, and the differences between the materials.

Model & Strategy

The loop comes from the motion of the Bloch walls. In a soft material the walls move easily, so a small field is enough to magnetize the material and to demagnetize it again. In a hard material the walls are difficult to move, so a large field is needed in both directions [Session 15 Slide 18].

H B Bs (hard) Bs (soft) Br (soft) Br (hard) −Hc (hard) Hc (soft) Hard magnetic material wide loop, high Br and Hc Soft magnetic material narrow loop, low Hc, high μi limit between them: Hc = 10 000 A/m
Figure 1. B-H hysteresis loops: a soft material has a narrow loop (low coercivity Hc, high initial permeability), a hard material a wide one (high remanence Br, saturation Bs and Hc); the slide fixes the limit at Hc = 10 000 A/m (schematic).

The permeabilities are read on the initial magnetization curve, which starts from the demagnetized state before the loop is traced:

Magnetic field H Magnetization M (or B) Ms slope = maximum permeability μmax slope = initial permeability μi growth of favourable domains rotation of domains: saturation random domains
Figure 2. Magnetization against field starting from the demagnetized state: slow growth (initial permeability), fast growth of favourable domains (maximum permeability), rotation of domains and saturation Ms (schematic).

Strategy.

  1. Follow the loop step by step and mark where each feature appears.
  2. Put numbers on the features with the tables of Slide 24, converting the hard-material coercivity to A/m so that both classes are compared with the same unit and with the limit of 10 000 A/m.
  3. Compare the two classes feature by feature.
Step-by-Step Calculation

1. Path of the loop [Session 15 Slides 16-17]

  • Starting from the demagnetized state ($H = 0$, domains at random) the initial curve rises to saturation: $B = B_s$.
  • Reducing $H$ to zero does not bring $B$ back to zero: the induction left is the remanence $B_r$.
  • A field in the opposite direction, of magnitude $H_c$, brings $B$ to zero: the coercivity.
  • Going on to $-H_{max}$ gives $-B_s$, and the return branch is the mirror image through the origin.

The slope of the initial curve is the initial permeability $\mu_i$, and the line from the origin tangent to the curve gives the maximum permeability $\mu_{max}$.

2. Features on each loop

FeatureWhereSoft materialHard material
$\mu_i$, $\mu_{max}$slope of the initial curvehighlow $\mu_i$
$H_c$crossing of the $H$ axislow, below 10 000 A/mhigh, above 10 000 A/m
$B_r$crossing of the $B$ axisprinted as a feature, not as a rulehigh, printed on Slide 18
$B_s$plateaureached with a small fieldreached only with a large field
Loop areaenclosed by the loopsmalllarge

3. Hard-material coercivity in A/m

From $\mu_0 H_c$ in tesla, with $\mu_0 = 1.257\times10^{-6}$ H/m:

$$H_c = \frac{\mu_0 H_c}{\mu_0}$$

For Nd-Fe-B:

$$H_c = \frac{1.21\ \text{T}}{1.257\times10^{-6}\ \text{H/m}} = 9.626\times10^{5}\ \text{A/m}$$

The same division for the others:

Hard material$H_c$ in A/mAbove 10 000 A/m?
Co-steel$1.59\times10^{4}$yes
Alnico-5$4.77\times10^{4}$yes
Ferrite$2.47\times10^{5}$yes
Sm-Co$6.36\times10^{5}$yes
Nd-Fe-B$9.63\times10^{5}$yes

Ratio of the strongest hard material to the soft ones of the table:

$$\frac{9.626\times10^{5}\ \text{A/m}}{80\ \text{A/m}} = 1.2\times10^{4} \qquad \frac{9.626\times10^{5}\ \text{A/m}}{7\ \text{A/m}} = 1.4\times10^{5}$$

4. Energy lost per cycle (extension, order of magnitude)

The energy dissipated per unit volume in one cycle is the area enclosed by the loop, $W = \oint H\,dB$ (this relation is not printed on the slides). For an idealized rectangular loop of width $2H_c$ and height $2B_r$ the area is

$$W \approx 2H_c \times 2B_r = 4\,H_c\,B_r$$

For the grain-oriented Fe-3 % Si and for Nd-Fe-B:

$$W_{soft} \approx 4\times7\ \text{A/m}\times1.20\ \text{T} = 33.6\ \text{J/m}^3 \qquad W_{hard} \approx 4\times9.626\times10^{5}\ \text{A/m}\times1.23\ \text{T} = 4.74\times10^{6}\ \text{J/m}^3$$

The ratio is about $1.4\times10^{5}$, the same as the ratio of coercivities, because the two remanences are similar. This is why the soft materials are the ones used under alternating fields, where the cycle repeats many times per second, and the hard ones are used as permanent magnets, where it never repeats [Session 15 Slides 18-19].

5. Main differences

Soft magnetic materialHard magnetic material
Bloch wallseasy to movedifficult to move
Loopnarrowwide
Coercivity$H_c < 10\,000$ A/m$H_c > 10\,000$ A/m
Permeabilityhigh initial permeabilitylow initial permeability
Losses per cyclelowhigh
Demagnetizationeasyresistant
Usecores of transformers, generators and motors; materials under alternating fieldspermanent magnets
Result & Checks

Checks

  • Units of $H_c$. $[\mu_0 H_c]/[\mu_0] = \text{T}/(\text{H/m}) = (\text{Wb/m}^2)/(\text{Wb/(A}\cdot\text{m)}) = \text{A/m}$.
  • Units of the energy. $[H\,B] = (\text{A/m})(\text{T}) = \text{A}\cdot\text{T/m}$, and with $\text{T} = \text{N/(A}\cdot\text{m)}$ this is $\text{N/m}^2 = \text{J/m}^3$, an energy per unit volume.
  • The limit of the slide. All the soft materials of the table are below 10 000 A/m (the highest is 100 A/m for the low-carbon steel of Table 20-4) and all the hard ones above it. Co-steel, at $1.59\times10^{4}$ A/m, is the closest to the limit.
  • Limit $H_c \to 0$. The loop collapses into a single line with no area and no loss, the ideal soft material. For a very large $H_c$ the loop is so wide that the material keeps its magnetization against the fields it meets in use, the ideal permanent magnet.

Interpretation

The decisive difference is the coercivity, and everything else follows from the mobility of the Bloch walls: the width of the loop, the losses and the use. The remanence alone does not separate the classes. The grain-oriented Fe-3 % Si has $B_r = 1.20$ T, more than the ferrite magnet (0.42 T) and about the same as Nd-Fe-B (1.23 T). Slide 18 lists a high remanence among the properties of the hard materials; in the data of Slide 24 it is the coercivity that is orders of magnitude apart ($7$ to $100$ A/m against $10^4$ to $10^6$ A/m), not the remanence.

Check against the official solution

ItemOfficialComputedComment
Loops and featuresnot printed on the sheet$B_s$, $B_r$ and $H_c$ marked on both loops; $\mu_i$ and $\mu_{max}$ on the initial magnetization curveconsistent with Session 15 Slides 16-18
Differencesnot printed on the sheetcoercivity, loop width, permeability, losses and useconsistent with Session 15 Slides 18-19; the energy per cycle and the numbers of Slide 24 are an extension
Problem 12 Problems T6andT7_Electric and Magnetic Properties.pdf #12 Microstructure · ferromagnetic properties
Click to Collapse ▲

Effect of Grain Size, Impurities and Porosity on a Ferromagnetic Material

Original statement · Problems T6andT7_Electric and Magnetic Properties.pdf, p. 3
  1. Specify in the following table how the increase in the following microstructural parameters affect the listed properties of a ferromagnetic material
Grain sizeImpuritiesPorosity
Hysteresis losses
Conductivity
Permeability
Coercitivity
Saturation Magnetization
Curie Temperature

The sheet prints no solution for this problem.

Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. One parameter at a time. Each column is an increase of that parameter with the composition of the ferromagnetic material and the other parameters kept constant.
  2. Domain walls control the loop. A larger grain gives the Bloch walls more mobility, and inclusions, dislocations and pores reduce it. With a larger mobility the permeability grows and the coercivity and the remanence fall; with a smaller mobility the opposite happens [Session 15 Slide 21].
  3. Impurities and porosity as obstacles. The slide groups inclusions, dislocations and pores as obstacles to the walls, so impurities (as particles of a second phase) and pores act in the same way on the loop. The effect of dissolved atoms is the same in direction (extension).
  4. Intrinsic properties. The saturation magnetization is constant for a material of a given composition [Session 15 Slide 20]. The Curie temperature is the temperature at which the saturation magnetization falls to zero, and the table of Slide 23 gives a different value for each element; both are fixed by the composition and the bonding, not by the microstructure (the link between $T_c$ and the composition is an extension).
  5. Conductivity. The electrical resistivity grows with the structural imperfections (grain boundaries, dislocations) and with the impurities [Session 13 Slides 16-17]; the effect of pores is an extension.
  6. Hysteresis losses. The energy lost per cycle is the area of the loop (extension, as in Problem T7-11): a wider loop (higher $H_c$) means higher losses.

Unknown: the effect (increase, decrease or none) of each parameter on each of the six properties.

Model & Strategy

Two chains separate the properties. The first goes from the microstructure to the mobility of the Bloch walls, and from the mobility to the permeability, the coercivity and the area of the loop. The second contains the properties that the microstructure does not change at all: the saturation magnetization and the Curie temperature, set by the composition. The conductivity follows its own chain, the scattering of the conduction electrons.

ParameterMobility of the Bloch wallsPermeabilityCoercivityLoop area (losses)
Larger grain sizeincreasesincreasesdecreasesdecreases
More impurities, poresdecreasesdecreasesincreasesincreases

Strategy.

  1. Fill the first chain from Slide 21.
  2. Decide the conductivity from the scattering of the electrons, with Session 13.
  3. State why the saturation magnetization and the Curie temperature do not change with the microstructure.
  4. Collect the answers in the table of the statement.
Step-by-Step Calculation

1. Grain size [Session 15 Slide 21]

A larger grain size increases the mobility of the Bloch walls, because there are fewer grain boundaries to stop them. So:

  • permeability $\mu$: increases;
  • coercivity $H_c$: decreases (and the remanence $B_r$ too);
  • hysteresis losses: decrease, since a narrower loop has a smaller area;
  • conductivity: increases, because the grain boundaries are structural imperfections that scatter the electrons and raise the resistivity [Session 13 Slides 16-17].

2. Impurities [Session 15 Slide 21]

Inclusions of another phase are obstacles that pin the walls, and the mobility decreases. So:

  • permeability: decreases;
  • coercivity: increases (and the remanence too);
  • hysteresis losses: increase;
  • conductivity: decreases, because foreign atoms and particles raise the residual resistivity $\rho_i$ [Session 13 Slide 16].

3. Porosity [Session 15 Slide 21]

Pores are listed on the slide with the inclusions, so the loop changes as for the impurities:

  • permeability: decreases;
  • coercivity: increases;
  • hysteresis losses: increase;
  • conductivity: decreases (extension): the pores remove conducting section and scatter the electrons, so the same direction as for the impurities.

4. Saturation magnetization [Session 15 Slide 20]

The saturation magnetization is constant for a material of a given composition: it is reached when all the dipoles of the solid are aligned, and the number and the intensity of the dipoles are fixed by the composition. Therefore:

  • grain size: no effect;
  • impurities: no effect while they are only inclusions; if an impurity dissolves and changes the composition the value changes (extension);
  • porosity: no effect on the material itself. Per unit of total volume the pores only dilute the magnetization (extension).

5. Curie temperature [Session 15 Slide 23]

$T_c$ is the temperature at which the saturation magnetization falls abruptly to zero. Each material has its own value (Fe 1043 K, Co 1404 K, Ni 631 K, Gd 289 K), which depends on the elements, not on the size of the grains or on the pores. Grain size and porosity have no effect. Impurities have no effect as inclusions; dissolved elements that change the composition can shift it (extension).

6. Result

PropertyGrain size increasesImpurities increasePorosity increases
Hysteresis lossesdecreaseincreaseincrease
Conductivityincreasesdecreasesdecreases
Permeabilityincreasesdecreasesdecreases
Coercivitydecreasesincreasesincreases
Saturation magnetizationno effectno effect as inclusionsno effect
Curie temperatureno effectno effect as inclusionsno effect
Result & Checks

Checks

  • Consistency of the table. Permeability and coercivity move in opposite directions in every column, as the slide says ($\mu$ up with $H_c$ and $B_r$ down for a larger grain, and the reverse for the obstacles). The losses follow the coercivity.
  • Impurities and porosity act alike. Slide 21 puts inclusions, dislocations and pores in the same line, and the table gives the same entries for both columns, except for the properties that depend on the composition.
  • Limits. For no obstacles (a pure, dense, coarse-grained material) the walls move freely: the highest permeability and the lowest coercivity and losses. For a very porous material the loop widens and the section that carries the flux and the current shrinks.

Interpretation

One rule explains the table: whatever stops the Bloch walls raises the coercivity and the losses and lowers the permeability, and whatever frees them does the opposite. The saturation magnetization and the Curie temperature are properties of the composition, so no change in the microstructure alone moves them. The same rule is used on purpose in the two classes of Problem T7-11: soft magnetic materials are made pure, dense and with large grains, and hard magnetic materials are made with obstacles (fine grains, precipitates), which is an extension of the slide. A higher conductivity also raises the currents induced in a core under alternating fields, which adds to the losses; this is an extension, and the table asks only for the effects listed.

Check against the official solution

ItemOfficialComputedComment
All 18 entries of the tablenot printed on the sheetthe result table abovepermeability, coercivity: Session 15 Slide 21; saturation magnetization: Slide 20; conductivity: Session 13 Slides 16-17; the entries marked extension (porosity and conductivity, effect of composition on $M_s$ and $T_c$, losses as loop area) are not printed on the slides