Topic 4: Solved Problems

Step-by-step solutions of problems 1-15 of the first official sheet on phase diagrams (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I: the lever rule, invariant reactions and compounds of Sessions 7 and 8) and problems 1-11 of the second (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II: the Fe-C system of Session 9 and a ternary diagram of Session 10), written in four phases and checked against the official solutions.

Data read on the diagrams of the problem sheet
SystemEutecticα limitβ limitMelting points
Pb-Sn (sheet p. 1)61.9 wt% Sn, 183 °C19.2 wt% Sn97.5 wt% Sn327 °C (Pb), 232 °C (Sn)
Ag-Cu (sheet p. 2)28.1 wt% Cu, 779.1 °C8.8 wt% Cu92 wt% Cu961.93 °C (Ag), 1084.87 °C (Cu)
Problem 1 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #1 Lever rule · two equations
Click to Collapse ▲

Phase Limits from the Phase Fractions of Two Alloys

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf

1. In the phase diagram of two hypothetic metals, A and B, there is a phase α rich in A and a phase β rich in B. Given the mass fraction of two alloys for a specific temperature (table), determine the composition of the phase limits (or solid solubility limits) of the α and β phases at such temperature.

Alloy compositionFraction of α phaseFraction of β phase
30% B0.780.22
65% B0.360.64
Official Solution: $C_\alpha = 11.7\%$, $C_\beta = 95\%$
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium: both alloys are at the same temperature, in equilibrium, and both contain α and β only, so both lie in the α + β two-phase region [Session 7 Slide 26].
  2. One tie line: at constant pressure a two-component, two-phase system has $F = C - P + 1 = 2 - 2 + 1 = 1$ degree of freedom, and fixing the temperature uses it [Session 7 Slide 13]. The compositions of α and β are therefore the same for both alloys: $C_\alpha$ and $C_\beta$ are the two ends of one tie line.
  3. Mass fractions obey the lever rule [Session 7 Slide 16].

Data

QuantityAlloy 1Alloy 2
Overall composition $C_0$ (% B)3065
$W_\alpha$0.780.36
$W_\beta$0.220.64

Unknowns: $C_\alpha$ and $C_\beta$ (% B). Two unknowns and two independent equations (one per alloy; $W_\beta = 1 - W_\alpha$ adds nothing new).

Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

The only frame is the phase diagram itself: composition in % B along the horizontal axis and temperature along the vertical axis. All the work is done on one horizontal line (the tie line at the given temperature), so it is one-dimensional and no change of basis is involved.

Why the lever rule. It is the tool that relates the amounts of the phases to the positions of the alloy and of the phase limits on the tie line [Session 7 Slide 16]:

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha}$$

Writing it once for each alloy gives two linear equations in $C_\alpha$ and $C_\beta$.

A 11.7 30 65 95 B Composition (% B) Temperature alloy 1: Wα = 0.78 alloy 2: Wα = 0.36 α β α + β Cα Cβ
Figure 1. Both alloys are in the α + β region at the same temperature, so they share the tie line from C_α to C_β; the two lever-rule equations give C_α = 11.7 % B and C_β = 95 % B.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

1. The two equations Call $D = C_\beta - C_\alpha$ the length of the tie line. Multiplying the lever rule by $D$:

$$W_\alpha D = C_\beta - C_0$$

Alloy 1 ($C_0 = 30$, $W_\alpha = 0.78$) and alloy 2 ($C_0 = 65$, $W_\alpha = 0.36$):

$$0.78\,D = C_\beta - 30 \qquad (1)$$
$$0.36\,D = C_\beta - 65 \qquad (2)$$

2. Length of the tie line Subtracting (2) from (1) eliminates $C_\beta$:

$$0.78\,D - 0.36\,D = (C_\beta - 30) - (C_\beta - 65) \;\Rightarrow\; 0.42\,D = 35 \;\Rightarrow\; D = \frac{35}{0.42} = 83.33\ \%\text{B}$$

3. Limit of β From (1):

$$C_\beta = 30 + 0.78 \times 83.33 = 30 + 65.00 = 95.0\ \%\text{B}$$

4. Limit of α

$$C_\alpha = C_\beta - D = 95.0 - 83.33 = 11.67 \approx 11.7\ \%\text{B}$$
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • β fractions (not used in the solution): $W_\beta = \dfrac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha}$ gives $\dfrac{30 - 11.67}{83.33} = 0.22$ and $\dfrac{65 - 11.67}{83.33} = 0.64$, exactly the values of the table.
  • Mass balance of B for alloy 1: $0.78 \times 11.67 + 0.22 \times 95.0 = 9.10 + 20.90 = 30.0\ \%$B $= C_0$.
  • Order: $C_\alpha = 11.7 < 30 < 65 < 95 = C_\beta$, so both alloys are indeed inside the α + β region, as assumed.
  • Units: all compositions are in % B (mass), fractions are dimensionless; each equation is homogeneous in % B.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in the units of the statement): with the limits found, an alloy at $C_0 = C_\alpha$ would be all α ($W_\alpha = 1$) and one at $C_0 = C_\beta$ all β ($W_\alpha = 0$); both given alloys lie between the two limits, as fractions between 0 and 1 require.

Interpretation At this temperature α can dissolve at most 11.7 % B and β at most 5 % A (95 % B). The alloy closer to the α limit (30 % B) has more α, as the lever rule predicts.

Check against the official solution

The official solution gives $C_\alpha = 11.7\%$ and $C_\beta = 95\%$; the result agrees. The official solutions PDF has no worked page for this problem; only the key of the statement is available.

Problem 2 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #2 Pb-Sn · hypereutectic
Click to Collapse ▲

Primary and Total β in a Pb-Sn Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf

2. From 2.8 kg of a Sn-Pb alloy, is it possible to have 2.21 kg of primary β and 2.53 kg of β total at (183 − ΔT) °C? Justify your answer.

Official Solution: Yes, for an alloy with composition $C_0 = 90\%$ B
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium cooling with the Pb-Sn diagram of the problem sheet (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 1): eutectic at $C_e = 61.9$ wt% Sn and 183 °C; at 183 °C the α limit is $C_\alpha = 19.2$ wt% Sn and the β limit $C_\beta = 97.5$ wt% Sn.
  2. Primary β exists only in a hypereutectic alloy ($61.9 < C_0 < 97.5$ wt% Sn): it is the β that forms in the β + L region before the eutectic reaction [Session 7 Slide 31].
  3. Just below the eutectic temperature the primary β keeps the amount it had just above it, and the liquid present just above becomes the eutectic [Session 7 Slide 32].
  4. "% B" in the key means wt% Sn (B is the Sn-rich side of the diagram).

Data

QuantityValue
Mass of alloy $m$2.8 kg
Mass of primary β $m_{\beta'}$2.21 kg
Mass of total β $m_\beta$ (at 183 − ΔT)2.53 kg
$C_\alpha$, $C_e$, $C_\beta$ at 183 °C19.2, 61.9, 97.5 wt% Sn

Unknown: the composition $C_0$. There is one unknown and two conditions, so the question is whether both masses can be met by the same $C_0$.

Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

The frame is the Pb-Sn diagram, composition in wt% Sn and temperature in °C; the work is on the horizontal tie lines just above and just below 183 °C, so it is one-dimensional and no change of basis is needed.

Strategy. The primary β fixes $C_0$ through the lever rule on the short tie line between the eutectic liquid and β (microconstituents). The total β is then predicted with the lever rule on the long tie line between α and β (phases), and compared with 2.53 kg. If they agree, the answer is yes.

L α β α + L β + L α + β 327 °C 232 °C 183 °C 0 (Pb) 20 40 60 80 100 (Sn) 0 100 200 300 Composition (wt% Sn) Temperature (°C) C0 = 90 61.9 97.5 19.2 183 + ΔT 183 − ΔT
Figure 2. Pb-Sn diagram of the problem sheet (eutectic 61.9 wt% Sn at 183 °C, α 19.2 and β 97.5 wt% Sn). The alloy with 79 % primary β is the hypereutectic Pb-90 wt% Sn; the tie lines just above and below 183 °C give the primary β and the total β.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

1. Mass fraction of primary β

$$W_{\beta'} = \frac{m_{\beta'}}{m} = \frac{2.21\ \text{kg}}{2.8\ \text{kg}} = 0.7893$$

2. Composition of the alloy Just above 183 °C the alloy is β (97.5 wt% Sn) plus liquid of eutectic composition (61.9 wt% Sn). The lever rule gives the β fraction, which is the primary β [Session 7 Slide 32]:

$$W_{\beta'} = \frac{C_0 - C_e}{C_\beta - C_e} = \frac{C_0 - 61.9}{97.5 - 61.9} = \frac{C_0 - 61.9}{35.6}$$

Solving for $C_0$:

$$C_0 = C_e + W_{\beta'}\,(C_\beta - C_e) = 61.9 + 0.7893 \times 35.6 = 61.9 + 28.10 = 90.0\ \text{wt\% Sn}$$

$61.9 < 90.0 < 97.5$: the alloy is hypereutectic, as primary β requires.

3. Total β predicted for this alloy Just below 183 °C the phases are α (19.2 wt% Sn) and β (97.5 wt% Sn):

$$W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{90.0 - 19.2}{97.5 - 19.2} = \frac{70.8}{78.3} = 0.9042$$
$$m_\beta = W_\beta\, m = 0.9042 \times 2.8\ \text{kg} = 2.532\ \text{kg} \approx 2.53\ \text{kg}$$

4. Answer Both conditions are met by the same alloy: yes, it is possible, with a Pb-90 wt% Sn alloy.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • Eutectic part: mass of eutectic $= 2.8 - 2.21 = 0.59$ kg; β inside it $= 2.53 - 2.21 = 0.32$ kg, a fraction $0.32 / 0.59 = 0.54$. The eutectic of the sheet diagram has $W_{\beta,e} = (61.9 - 19.2)/(97.5 - 19.2) = 42.7/78.3 = 0.545$ of β, and $0.545 \times 0.59 = 0.32$ kg: consistent.
  • Units: masses in kg, fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% Sn.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% Sn): as $C_0 \to 61.9$ the primary β tends to 0 (all eutectic), and as $C_0 \to 97.5$ to 1 (all primary β); 90.0 wt% Sn lies close to the β end, consistent with 0.79 of primary β.

Interpretation The two masses are not independent: once the primary β fixes the composition, the total β is fixed too. A different total β (say 2.40 kg) would have been impossible for any alloy.

Check against the official solution

The official key ("Yes, for an alloy with composition $C_0 = 90\%$") agrees. The worked page (Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, p. 6) finds $C_0 = 90\%$ from the primary β only; the check of the total β (2.53 kg) above completes the justification. The page writes the fraction as "079"; it is 0.79.

Problem 3 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #3 Pb-Sn · hypereutectic
Click to Collapse ▲

Phases and Microconstituents of a Pb-80 wt% Sn Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf

3. Using the Pb-Sn phase diagram for an alloy composition of Pb-80%Sn, indicate at the temperatures of $T_1 = 250$ ºC, $T_2 = 183 + \Delta T$ ºC, $T_3 = 183 - \Delta T$ ºC, $T_4 = 100$ ºC: a) The phases present, chemical composition of the phases and mass fraction. b) The micro constituents, chemical composition and mass fractions. Note the agreement that exists between the data obtained in (a) and (b).

Official Solution (the phase symbols print as empty boxes in the PDF and are restored from context): a) $T_1$: $C_L = 80\%$ Sn, $w_L = 1$; $T_2$: $C_L = 61.9\%$ Sn, $C_\beta = 97.5\%$ Sn, $w_L = 0.49$; $T_3$: $C_\alpha = 19.2\%$ Sn, $C_\beta = 97.5\%$ Sn, $w_\alpha = 0.22$; $T_4$: $C_\alpha = 5\%$ Sn, $C_\beta = 100\%$ Sn, $w_\alpha = 0.21$; b) $C_{\beta'} = 97.5\%$ Sn, $C_E = 61.9\%$ Sn, $w_E = 0.49$, $w_{\beta'} = 0.51$
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium cooling, Pb-Sn diagram of the problem sheet (p. 1): eutectic at 61.9 wt% Sn and 183 °C; at 183 °C, α of 19.2 and β of 97.5 wt% Sn.
  2. Values at 250 °C and 100 °C are readings of the figure: at 250 °C the alloy is above the liquidus on the Sn side (which goes from 183 °C at 61.9 wt% Sn to 232 °C at 100 wt% Sn); at 100 °C the solvus lines give α of about 5 and β of about 100 wt% Sn.
  3. $C_0 = 80$ wt% Sn lies between 61.9 and 97.5: a hypereutectic alloy, so the primary phase is β [Session 7 Slide 31].

Data

TemperatureRegionPhase compositions (wt% Sn)
$T_1 = 250$ °CL$C_L = 80$
$T_2 = 183 + \Delta T$β + L$C_L = 61.9$, $C_\beta = 97.5$
$T_3 = 183 - \Delta T$α + β$C_\alpha = 19.2$, $C_\beta = 97.5$
$T_4 = 100$ °Cα + β$C_\alpha = 5$, $C_\beta = 100$
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

The frame is the Pb-Sn diagram (wt% Sn, °C). At each temperature the work is on one horizontal tie line, so it is one-dimensional; no change of basis is needed.

Method. (a) Tie line for the compositions, lever rule for the fractions [Session 7 Slides 15-16]. (b) Below the eutectic temperature, the lever rule on the short tie line (β to eutectic liquid) gives the microconstituents, and the long tie line (α to β) gives the phases [Session 7 Slide 32]; comparing both answers part (b)'s "agreement".

L α β α + L β + L α + β 327 °C 232 °C 183 °C 0 (Pb) 20 40 60 80 100 (Sn) 0 100 200 300 Composition (wt% Sn) Temperature (°C) C0 = 80 61.9 97.5 19.2 5 T₁ T₂ T₃ T₄
Figure 3. Pb-80 wt% Sn at T₁ = 250 °C (liquid), T₂ = 183 + ΔT (β + L), T₃ = 183 − ΔT (α + β) and T₄ = 100 °C (α + β, with α of 5 and β of 100 wt% Sn, a reading of the figure). Problem sheet diagram.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1 = 250$ °C. Above the liquidus: one phase, liquid with the composition of the alloy. $C_L = 80$ wt% Sn, $W_L = 1$.

$T_2 = 183 + \Delta T$. Region β + L; tie line from $C_L = 61.9$ to $C_\beta = 97.5$ (length $97.5 - 61.9 = 35.6$):

$$W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_L}{C_\beta - C_L} = \frac{80 - 61.9}{97.5 - 61.9} = \frac{18.1}{35.6} = 0.508 \qquad W_L = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_L} = \frac{97.5 - 80}{35.6} = \frac{17.5}{35.6} = 0.492$$

$T_3 = 183 - \Delta T$. Region α + β; tie line from 19.2 to 97.5 (length 78.3):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{97.5 - 80}{97.5 - 19.2} = \frac{17.5}{78.3} = 0.224 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{80 - 19.2}{78.3} = \frac{60.8}{78.3} = 0.776$$

$T_4 = 100$ °C. Region α + β; tie line from 5 to 100 (length 95):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{100 - 80}{100 - 5} = \frac{20}{95} = 0.211 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{80 - 5}{95} = \frac{75}{95} = 0.789$$

b) Microconstituents At $T_1$ and $T_2$ the microconstituents are the phases themselves (liquid; primary β + liquid).

At $T_3$ there are two microconstituents: primary β (97.5 wt% Sn), formed in the β + L region, and eutectic (overall 61.9 wt% Sn), formed from the liquid present at $T_2$. With $P = C_0 - C_e$ and $Q = C_\beta - C_0$ on the short tie line:

$$W_{\beta'} = \frac{C_0 - C_e}{C_\beta - C_e} = \frac{80 - 61.9}{97.5 - 61.9} = 0.508 = W_\beta(T_2) \qquad W_E = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_e} = \frac{17.5}{35.6} = 0.492 = W_L(T_2)$$

Phases inside the eutectic:

$$W_{\beta,E} = W_\beta(T_3) - W_{\beta'} = 0.776 - 0.508 = 0.268 \qquad W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha(T_3) = 0.224$$

(all the α is in the eutectic, since the primary phase is β).

primary β eutectic (α + β)
Figure 4. Pb-80 wt% Sn below the eutectic temperature: primary β (51 %) in the eutectic α + β (49 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Agreement between (a) and (b)

  • $W_{\beta,E} + W_{\alpha,E} = 0.268 + 0.224 = 0.492 = W_E$: the phases of the eutectic add up to the eutectic.
  • Inside the eutectic, α is $0.224 / 0.492 = 0.455$, the same as the eutectic product of the sheet diagram, $(97.5 - 61.9)/(97.5 - 19.2) = 35.6/78.3 = 0.455$.
  • Mass balance at $T_3$: $0.224 \times 19.2 + 0.776 \times 97.5 = 4.30 + 75.66 = 80.0$ wt% Sn.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% Sn): at $C_0 = 61.9$ the alloy would be all eutectic ($W_{\beta'} = 0$) and at $C_0 = 97.5$ all primary β ($W_{\beta'} = 1$); 80 wt% Sn lies about halfway along the short tie line, hence about half of each.

Interpretation Below 183 °C the alloy is about half primary β and half eutectic. On further cooling to 100 °C the solvus lines move outwards (α purer in Pb, β practically pure Sn) and the amounts of the phases change slightly (α from 0.224 to 0.211) by solid-state precipitation, while the microconstituents keep their shape.

Check against the official solution

All the values agree with the key ($w_L = 0.49$, $w_\alpha = 0.22$, $w_\alpha = 0.21$; $w_E = 0.49$, $w_{\beta'} = 0.51$).

Erratum in the worked solution

Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, p. 7, writes "T2; phases α and L"; the phases at $T_2$ are β and L (the alloy is hypereutectic). On the same page the $T_3$ formula is printed with the denominator $97.5 - 61.9$, but the value 0.22 corresponds to $97.5 - 19.2 = 78.3$: $17.5 / 35.6$ would give 0.49, while $17.5 / 78.3 = 0.22$. The numbers of the page are right; the labels and that denominator are not.

Problem 4 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #4 Pb-Sn · hypoeutectic
Click to Collapse ▲

Phases and Microconstituents of a Pb-30 wt% Sn Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf

4. Using the Pb-Sn phase diagram for an alloy composition of Pb-30%Sn, indicate at the temperatures of $T_1 = 250$ ºC, $T_2 = 183 + \Delta T$ ºC, $T_3 = 183 - \Delta T$ ºC, $T_4 = 100$ ºC: a) The phases present, chemical composition of the phases and mass fraction. b) The micro constituents, chemical composition and mass fractions. Note the agreement that exists between the data obtained in (a) and (b).

Official Solution (the phase symbols print as empty boxes in the PDF and are restored from context): a) $T_1$: $C_L = 36\%$ Sn, $C_\alpha = 12\%$ Sn, $w_L = 0.75$; $T_2$: $C_L = 61.9\%$ Sn, $C_\alpha = 19.2\%$ Sn, $w_L = 0.25$; $T_3$: $C_\alpha = 19.2\%$ Sn, $C_\beta = 97.5\%$ Sn, $w_\alpha = 0.86$; $T_4$: $C_\alpha = 5\%$ Sn, $C_\beta = 100\%$ Sn, $w_\alpha = 0.74$; b) $T_3$: $C_{\alpha'} = 19.2\%$ Sn, $C_E = 61.9\%$ Sn, $w_E = 0.25$, $w_{\alpha'} = 0.75$
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium cooling, Pb-Sn diagram of the problem sheet (p. 1): eutectic at 61.9 wt% Sn and 183 °C; α of 19.2 and β of 97.5 wt% Sn at 183 °C.
  2. Readings of the figure: at 250 °C the tie line meets the α solidus at 12 wt% Sn and the liquidus at 36 wt% Sn; at 100 °C the solvus lines give α of 5 and β of 100 wt% Sn (the same readings as the official solution).
  3. $19.2 < C_0 = 30 < 61.9$: a hypoeutectic alloy, so the primary phase is α [Session 7 Slide 30]. This is the same kind of alloy as the hypoeutectic example of the slides.

Data

TemperatureRegionPhase compositions (wt% Sn)
$T_1 = 250$ °Cα + L$C_\alpha = 12$, $C_L = 36$
$T_2 = 183 + \Delta T$α + L$C_\alpha = 19.2$, $C_L = 61.9$
$T_3 = 183 - \Delta T$α + β$C_\alpha = 19.2$, $C_\beta = 97.5$
$T_4 = 100$ °Cα + β$C_\alpha = 5$, $C_\beta = 100$
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Pb-Sn diagram (wt% Sn, °C); one horizontal tie line per temperature, so no change of basis is needed.

Method. Tie line and lever rule at each temperature [Session 7 Slides 15-16]; below 183 °C, the short tie line (α to eutectic liquid) gives the microconstituents and the long one (α to β) the phases [Session 7 Slide 32].

L α β α + L β + L α + β 327 °C 232 °C 183 °C 0 (Pb) 20 40 60 80 100 (Sn) 0 100 200 300 Composition (wt% Sn) Temperature (°C) C0 = 30 12 36 19.2 61.9 97.5 5 100 T₁ T₂ T₃ T₄
Figure 5. Pb-30 wt% Sn at T₁ = 250 °C (α of 12 and L of 36 wt% Sn, a reading of the figure), T₂ = 183 + ΔT (α + L), T₃ = 183 − ΔT (α + β) and T₄ = 100 °C. Problem sheet diagram.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1 = 250$ °C. α + L; tie line from 12 to 36 (length 24):

$$W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha} = \frac{30 - 12}{36 - 12} = \frac{18}{24} = 0.750 \qquad W_\alpha = \frac{C_L - C_0}{C_L - C_\alpha} = \frac{36 - 30}{24} = \frac{6}{24} = 0.250$$

$T_2 = 183 + \Delta T$. α + L; tie line from 19.2 to 61.9 (length 42.7):

$$W_L = \frac{30 - 19.2}{61.9 - 19.2} = \frac{10.8}{42.7} = 0.253 \qquad W_\alpha = \frac{61.9 - 30}{42.7} = \frac{31.9}{42.7} = 0.747$$

$T_3 = 183 - \Delta T$. α + β; tie line from 19.2 to 97.5 (length 78.3):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{97.5 - 30}{97.5 - 19.2} = \frac{67.5}{78.3} = 0.862 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{30 - 19.2}{78.3} = \frac{10.8}{78.3} = 0.138$$

$T_4 = 100$ °C. α + β; tie line from 5 to 100 (length 95):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{100 - 30}{100 - 5} = \frac{70}{95} = 0.737 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{30 - 5}{95} = \frac{25}{95} = 0.263$$

b) Microconstituents At $T_1$ and $T_2$ they coincide with the phases (α + liquid). At $T_3$: primary α (19.2 wt% Sn) and eutectic (61.9 wt% Sn overall):

$$W_{\alpha'} = \frac{C_e - C_0}{C_e - C_\alpha} = \frac{61.9 - 30}{61.9 - 19.2} = 0.747 = W_\alpha(T_2) \qquad W_E = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_e - C_\alpha} = \frac{30 - 19.2}{42.7} = 0.253 = W_L(T_2)$$

Phases inside the eutectic:

$$W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha(T_3) - W_{\alpha'} = 0.862 - 0.747 = 0.115 \qquad W_{\beta,E} = W_\beta(T_3) = 0.138$$
primary α eutectic (α + β)
Figure 6. Pb-30 wt% Sn below the eutectic temperature: primary α (75 %) in the eutectic α + β (25 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Agreement between (a) and (b)

  • $W_{\alpha,E} + W_{\beta,E} = 0.115 + 0.138 = 0.253 = W_E$.
  • Inside the eutectic, α is $0.115 / 0.253 = 0.455$, the eutectic product of the sheet diagram ($35.6/78.3 = 0.455$), the same as in Problem 3: the eutectic has the same make-up whatever the alloy.
  • Mass balance at $T_3$: $0.862 \times 19.2 + 0.138 \times 97.5 = 16.55 + 13.45 = 30.0$ wt% Sn.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% Sn): at $C_0 = 19.2$ the alloy would be all primary α and at $C_0 = 61.9$ all eutectic; 30 wt% Sn lies close to the α end, hence three quarters primary α.

Interpretation The alloy is three quarters primary α and one quarter eutectic, the structure of the hypoeutectic micrograph of Slide 30. From 250 °C to 183 °C the amount of α grows from 25 % to 75 % while the liquid gets richer in Sn, from 36 to 61.9 wt%.

Check against the official solution

The values agree with the key ($w_L = 0.75$, $0.25$; $w_\alpha = 0.86$, $0.74$; $w_E = 0.25$, $w_{\alpha'} = 0.75$). The α inside the eutectic is $0.862 - 0.747 = 0.115$; the worked page writes 0.11 because it subtracts the rounded values $0.86 - 0.75$.

Erratum in the worked solution

Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, p. 10, gives for $T_4$ the numbers of Problem 3: $\chi_\alpha = (100 - 80)/(100 - 5) = 0.21$ and $\chi_{\beta,\text{total}} = 0.79$. For this alloy ($C_0 = 30$) the correct values are $W_\alpha = 70/95 = 0.74$ and $W_\beta = 0.26$, as the key of the statement says. The $T_1$ formula on p. 9 is also printed with the wrong labels ($C_o - C_\beta$ over $C_E - C_\alpha$), while its numbers, $(30 - 12)/(36 - 12) = 0.75$, are right.

Problem 5 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #5 Ag-Cu · eutectic
Click to Collapse ▲

The Eutectic Ag-28.1 wt% Cu Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 2

5. Given an alloy Ag-28.1%Cu, indicate for the given temperatures, $T_1 = 900$ °C; $T_2 = (780 + \Delta T)$ °C; $T_3 = (780 - \Delta T)$ °C: a. Present phases, chemical composition of phases and mass fraction. b. Microconstituents, chemical composition and mass fraction at $T_3$.

Official Solution: a) $T_1$: Liquid (28.1%Cu); $T_2$: Liquid (28.1%Cu); $T_3$: $\alpha$($C_\alpha$ = 8.8%Cu) + $\beta$($C_\beta$ = 92%Cu); $x_\alpha = 0.77$; $x_\beta = 0.23$. b) Eutectic microconstituent (28.1%Cu); $C_{\alpha E}$ = 8.8%Cu; $C_{\beta E}$ = 92%Cu
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium cooling with the Ag-Cu diagram of the problem sheet (p. 2): eutectic at 28.1 wt% Cu and 779.1 °C (the statement rounds it to 780 °C); at that temperature (Ag) = α contains 8.8 wt% Cu and (Cu) = β contains 92 wt% Cu. Melting points: 961.93 °C (Ag) and 1084.87 °C (Cu).
  2. $C_0 = 28.1$ wt% Cu is exactly the eutectic composition [Session 7 Slides 26-27].

Data

QuantityValue
$C_0$28.1 wt% Cu
$C_\alpha$, $C_e$, $C_\beta$ at the eutectic temperature8.8, 28.1, 92 wt% Cu
Eutectic temperature779.1 °C ≈ 780 °C
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Ag-Cu diagram (wt% Cu, °C), one horizontal tie line per temperature; no change of basis is needed.

Why no lever rule above 780 °C. The eutectic liquid meets both liquidus lines at their lowest point, so it never enters a two-phase L + solid region: it stays liquid down to the eutectic temperature and then transforms at once, $L \rightarrow \alpha + \beta$ [Session 7 Slide 27].

L (Ag) (Cu) (Ag) + (Cu) 961.93 °C 1084.87 °C 779.1 °C 0 (Ag) 20 40 60 80 100 (Cu) 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 Composition (wt% Cu) Temperature (°C) C0 = 28.1 8.8 92 T₁ T₂ T₃
Figure 7. Ag-Cu diagram of the problem sheet. The eutectic alloy is liquid down to 779.1 °C and then becomes (Ag) of 8.8 and (Cu) of 92 wt% Cu.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1 = 900$ °C. Above the liquidus: liquid, $C_L = 28.1$ wt% Cu, $W_L = 1$.

$T_2 = 780 + \Delta T$. Still above the eutectic point: liquid, $C_L = 28.1$ wt% Cu, $W_L = 1$.

$T_3 = 780 - \Delta T$. α + β; tie line from 8.8 to 92 (length $92 - 8.8 = 83.2$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{92 - 28.1}{92 - 8.8} = \frac{63.9}{83.2} = 0.768 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{28.1 - 8.8}{83.2} = \frac{19.3}{83.2} = 0.232$$

b) Microconstituents at $T_3$ All the liquid of $T_2$ became eutectic: one microconstituent, the eutectic, $W_E = 1$, with overall composition 28.1 wt% Cu. Inside it: α (8.8 wt% Cu) with mass fraction 0.768 and β (92 wt% Cu) with mass fraction 0.232.

eutectic ((Ag) + (Cu))
Figure 8. Ag-28.1 wt% Cu below 779 °C: 100 % eutectic, (Ag) and (Cu) in alternating layers.
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • $W_\alpha + W_\beta = 0.768 + 0.232 = 1$.
  • Mass balance: $0.768 \times 8.8 + 0.232 \times 92 = 6.76 + 21.34 = 28.1$ wt% Cu $= C_0$.
  • Phase rule at the eutectic point (1 atm): $F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$, so the transformation happens at one temperature, with a plateau in the cooling curve, like a pure metal [Session 7 Slide 27].
  • Limiting case (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% Cu): the alloy sits exactly at the eutectic composition, so the primary fraction $(C_0 - C_e)/(C_\beta - C_e)$ (or its hypoeutectic twin) is 0: the end case of both formulas, an alloy that is all eutectic.

Interpretation The eutectic alloy has the lowest melting point of the system (779 °C, well below 961.93 °C for Ag and 1084.87 °C for Cu) and solidifies at a single temperature into a fine layered mixture of a Ag-rich and a Cu-rich solid.

Check against the official solution

Agrees with the key: $x_\alpha = 0.77$, $x_\beta = 0.23$; 100 % eutectic. The official solutions PDF has no worked page for this problem.

Problem 6 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #6 Ag-Cu · hypereutectic
Click to Collapse ▲

The Hypereutectic Ag-80 wt% Cu Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 2

6. Using the Cu-Ag phase diagram, for an alloy with composition $C_0$ = 80% Cu, for temperatures $T_1 = 900$ °C; $T_2 = (780 + \Delta T)$ °C; $T_3 = (780 - \Delta T)$ °C, determine: a. Present phases, chemical composition of phases and mass fraction. b. Microconstituents, chemical composition and mass fraction at $T_3$.

Official Solution: a) $T_1$: $C_L$ = 58%Cu; $C_\beta$ = 93%Cu; $X_L = 0.37$; $X_\beta = 0.63$; $T_2$: $C_L$ = 28.1%Cu; $C_\beta$ = 92%Cu; $X_L = 0.19$; $X_\beta = 0.81$; $T_3$: $C_\alpha$ = 8.8%Cu; $C_\beta$ = 92%Cu; $X_\alpha = 0.14$; $X_\beta = 0.86$. b) eutectic microconstituent ($X_E = 0.19$) and proeutectic β ($X_{\beta p} = 0.81$)
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium cooling, Ag-Cu diagram of the problem sheet (p. 2): eutectic 28.1 wt% Cu at 779.1 °C ≈ 780 °C; α = (Ag) of 8.8 and β = (Cu) of 92 wt% Cu at that temperature.
  2. Reading of the figure at 900 °C: the tie line meets the Cu-side liquidus at 58 wt% Cu and the (Cu) solidus at 93 wt% Cu (the readings of the official solution).
  3. $28.1 < C_0 = 80 < 92$: a hypereutectic alloy, primary phase β [Session 7 Slide 31].

Data

TemperatureRegionPhase compositions (wt% Cu)
$T_1 = 900$ °CL + β$C_L = 58$, $C_\beta = 93$
$T_2 = 780 + \Delta T$L + β$C_L = 28.1$, $C_\beta = 92$
$T_3 = 780 - \Delta T$α + β$C_\alpha = 8.8$, $C_\beta = 92$
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Ag-Cu diagram (wt% Cu, °C), one tie line per temperature; no change of basis. Lever rule for phases [Session 7 Slide 16]; short tie line (eutectic liquid to β) for the microconstituents [Session 7 Slide 32].

L (Ag) (Cu) (Ag) + (Cu) 961.93 °C 1084.87 °C 779.1 °C 0 (Ag) 20 40 60 80 100 (Cu) 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 Composition (wt% Cu) Temperature (°C) C0 = 80 58 93 28.1 92 8.8 T₁ T₂ T₃
Figure 9. Ag-80 wt% Cu at T₁ = 900 °C (L of 58 and (Cu) of 93 wt% Cu, a reading of the figure), T₂ = 780 + ΔT and T₃ = 780 − ΔT. Problem sheet diagram.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1 = 900$ °C (tie line length $93 - 58 = 35$):

$$W_L = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_L} = \frac{93 - 80}{93 - 58} = \frac{13}{35} = 0.371 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_L}{C_\beta - C_L} = \frac{80 - 58}{35} = \frac{22}{35} = 0.629$$

$T_2 = 780 + \Delta T$ (length $92 - 28.1 = 63.9$):

$$W_L = \frac{92 - 80}{92 - 28.1} = \frac{12}{63.9} = 0.188 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{80 - 28.1}{63.9} = \frac{51.9}{63.9} = 0.812$$

$T_3 = 780 - \Delta T$ (length $92 - 8.8 = 83.2$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{92 - 80}{92 - 8.8} = \frac{12}{83.2} = 0.144 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{80 - 8.8}{83.2} = \frac{71.2}{83.2} = 0.856$$

b) Microconstituents at $T_3$ Proeutectic (primary) β of 92 wt% Cu, and eutectic of 28.1 wt% Cu overall:

$$W_{\beta p} = \frac{C_0 - C_e}{C_\beta - C_e} = \frac{80 - 28.1}{92 - 28.1} = \frac{51.9}{63.9} = 0.812 \qquad W_E = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_e} = \frac{12}{63.9} = 0.188$$

Phases inside the eutectic:

$$W_{\beta,E} = W_\beta(T_3) - W_{\beta p} = 0.856 - 0.812 = 0.044 \qquad W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha(T_3) = 0.144$$
primary (Cu) eutectic
Figure 10. Ag-80 wt% Cu below 779 °C: primary (Cu) (81 %) in the eutectic (19 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • $W_{\alpha,E} + W_{\beta,E} = 0.144 + 0.044 = 0.188 = W_E$.
  • Inside the eutectic α is $0.1442 / 0.1878 = 0.768$, the make-up of the eutectic alloy of Problem 5.
  • Mass balance at $T_3$: $0.1442 \times 8.8 + 0.8558 \times 92 = 1.27 + 78.73 = 80.0$ wt% Cu.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% Cu): at $C_0 = 28.1$ the alloy would be all eutectic and at $C_0 = 92$ all primary β; 80 wt% Cu lies close to the β end, hence 0.81 of primary β.

Interpretation Between 900 °C and the eutectic temperature the amount of primary (Cu) grows from 63 % to 81 %, and the liquid becomes poorer in Cu, from 58 to 28.1 wt%. The final structure is mostly primary (Cu) crystals with about 19 % eutectic between them.

Check against the official solution

All values agree with the key. The worked page (Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, pp. 11-12) adds a fourth temperature, $T_4 = 500$ °C, that is not in the statement of the sheet, and writes $\chi_{Cu,E} = 0.86 - 0.81 = 0.04$ (exactly $0.856 - 0.812 = 0.044$).

Problem 7 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #7 Ag-Cu · hypoeutectic
Click to Collapse ▲

The Hypoeutectic Ag-10 wt% Cu Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 2

7. Using the Cu-Ag phase diagram, for an alloy with composition $C_0$ = 10% Cu, for the temperatures $T_1 = 900$ °C, $T_2 = (780 + \Delta T)$ °C, $T_3 = (780 - \Delta T)$ °C, determine: a. Present phases, chemical composition of phases and mass fraction. b. Microconstituents, chemical composition and mass fraction at $T_3$.

Official Solution: a) $T_1$: Liquid (10%Cu); $T_2$: $C_L$ = 28.1%Cu; $C_\alpha$ = 8.8%Cu; $X_\alpha = 0.94$; $X_L = 0.06$; $T_3$: $C_\alpha$ = 8.8%Cu; $C_\beta$ = 92%Cu; $X_\alpha = 0.98$; $X_\beta = 0.02$. b) eutectic microconstituent ($X_E = 0.06$) and proeutectic α ($X_{\alpha p} = 0.94$)
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium cooling, Ag-Cu diagram of the problem sheet (p. 2): eutectic 28.1 wt% Cu at 779.1 °C ≈ 780 °C; α = (Ag) of 8.8 and β = (Cu) of 92 wt% Cu.
  2. Reading of the figure at 900 °C: the Ag-side liquidus falls from 961.93 °C (0 % Cu) to 779.1 °C (28.1 % Cu), and at 10 wt% Cu it is just below 900 °C, so at 900 °C the alloy is still liquid (as the official solution states).
  3. $8.8 < C_0 = 10 < 28.1$: a hypoeutectic alloy, very close to the α limit; the primary phase is α [Session 7 Slide 30].

Data

TemperatureRegionPhase compositions (wt% Cu)
$T_1 = 900$ °CL$C_L = 10$
$T_2 = 780 + \Delta T$α + L$C_\alpha = 8.8$, $C_L = 28.1$
$T_3 = 780 - \Delta T$α + β$C_\alpha = 8.8$, $C_\beta = 92$
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Ag-Cu diagram (wt% Cu, °C), one tie line per temperature; no change of basis. Lever rule for the phases [Session 7 Slide 16] and for the microconstituents (short tie line from α to the eutectic liquid) [Session 7 Slide 32].

L (Ag) (Cu) (Ag) + (Cu) 961.93 °C 1084.87 °C 779.1 °C 0 (Ag) 20 40 60 80 100 (Cu) 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 Composition (wt% Cu) Temperature (°C) C0 = 10 8.8 28.1 92 T₁ T₂ T₃
Figure 11. Ag-10 wt% Cu at T₁ = 900 °C (liquid, just above the liquidus, a reading of the figure), T₂ = 780 + ΔT and T₃ = 780 − ΔT. Problem sheet diagram.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1 = 900$ °C. Liquid, $C_L = 10$ wt% Cu, $W_L = 1$.

$T_2 = 780 + \Delta T$ (tie line length $28.1 - 8.8 = 19.3$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_L - C_0}{C_L - C_\alpha} = \frac{28.1 - 10}{28.1 - 8.8} = \frac{18.1}{19.3} = 0.938 \qquad W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha} = \frac{10 - 8.8}{19.3} = \frac{1.2}{19.3} = 0.062$$

$T_3 = 780 - \Delta T$ (length $92 - 8.8 = 83.2$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{92 - 10}{92 - 8.8} = \frac{82}{83.2} = 0.986 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{10 - 8.8}{83.2} = \frac{1.2}{83.2} = 0.014$$

b) Microconstituents at $T_3$ Proeutectic (primary) α of 8.8 wt% Cu and eutectic of 28.1 wt% Cu overall:

$$W_{\alpha p} = \frac{C_e - C_0}{C_e - C_\alpha} = \frac{18.1}{19.3} = 0.938 \qquad W_E = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_e - C_\alpha} = \frac{1.2}{19.3} = 0.062$$

Phases inside the eutectic:

$$W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha(T_3) - W_{\alpha p} = 0.986 - 0.938 = 0.048 \qquad W_{\beta,E} = W_\beta(T_3) = 0.014$$
primary (Ag) eutectic
Figure 12. Ag-10 wt% Cu below 779 °C: primary (Ag) (94 %) with a little eutectic (6 %) between the grains.
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • $W_{\alpha,E} + W_{\beta,E} = 0.048 + 0.014 = 0.062 = W_E$; inside the eutectic α is $0.048/0.062 = 0.77$, as in Problem 5.
  • Mass balance at $T_3$: $0.9856 \times 8.8 + 0.0144 \times 92 = 8.67 + 1.33 = 10.0$ wt% Cu.

Interpretation The alloy is only 1.2 wt% Cu beyond the solubility limit of α, so almost all of it is primary (Ag) and just 6 % is eutectic, found as thin films between the α grains. An alloy below 8.8 wt% Cu would form no eutectic at all.

Check against the official solution

At $T_1$, $T_2$ and in part (b) the results agree with the key.

Discrepancy with the official solution

At $T_3$ the key gives $X_\alpha = 0.98$ and $X_\beta = 0.02$. With the data of the problem, $W_\alpha = 82/83.2 = 0.9856$ and $W_\beta = 1.2/83.2 = 0.0144$, which round to 0.99 and 0.01. The computed values are kept; the key's 0.98 and 0.02 follow from truncating 0.9856 to 0.98 and taking $1 - 0.98 = 0.02$, not from rounding.

Problem 8 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #8 Diagram construction
Click to Collapse ▲

Drawing a Eutectic Diagram and the 40 % B Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 3

8. Two metals (A and B) have partial solubility among each other. Metal A, with a melting point at 700 °C, can dissolve 5% of B at 0 °C, and its maximum solubility occurs at 400 °C, being 25% B. On the other hand, B metal melts at 600 °C, can dissolve 10% of A at 0 °C and its maximum solubility occurs at 400 °C, being 20% A. At 400 °C there is an eutectic reaction when the B content is 65%. a. Draw and identify the parts of the phase diagram in equilibrium (suppose straight lines). b. For an alloy 40% B, determine the phases composition and their relative proportions at 450 °C, 400 °C + ΔT and 400 °C − ΔT. c. For an alloy 40% B, draw its microstructure indicating the microconstituents and the mass fraction of each one. Additionally, indicate the mass fraction of each of the phases present in such microconstituents.

Official Solution: b) 450 °C: $C_L$ = 55%B; $C_\alpha$ = 20%B; $X_\alpha = 0.43$; $X_L = 0.57$; 400 °C + ΔT: $C_L$ = 65%B; $C_\alpha$ = 25%B; $X_\alpha = 0.62$; $X_L = 0.38$; 400 °C − ΔT: $C_\beta$ = 80%B; $C_\alpha$ = 25%B; $X_\alpha = 0.73$; $X_\beta = 0.27$. c) Eutectic microconstituent and proeutectic α; $X_{\alpha p} = 0.62$; $X_E = 0.38$; Phases in the eutectic microconstituent: $X(\alpha_E) = 0.11$; $X(\beta_E) = 0.27$.
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Binary eutectic system with partial solid solubility: α (rich in A) and β (rich in B) [Session 7 Slide 26].
  2. Straight lines between the given points, as the statement asks.
  3. Compositions in % B (mass); "20 % A" in β means 80 % B, and "10 % A" means 90 % B.

Points of the diagram

PointComposition (% B)Temperature (°C)Meaning
Melting point of A0700top of α solidus and of the A-side liquidus
Melting point of B100600top of β solidus and of the B-side liquidus
Eutectic point E65400lowest point of the liquid
Max. solubility of B in α25400end of the eutectic line, α side
Max. solubility of A in β80400end of the eutectic line, β side
α solvus at 0 °C50
β solvus at 0 °C900
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: composition (% B) on the horizontal axis and temperature (°C) on the vertical one. Each boundary is a straight segment, so a composition on it at a temperature $T$ comes from linear interpolation between its two end points; the tie lines are horizontal. No change of basis is needed.

Lines of the diagram (part a):

  • liquidus: $(0, 700) \to (65, 400)$ and $(100, 600) \to (65, 400)$;
  • solidus: $(0, 700) \to (25, 400)$ for α and $(100, 600) \to (80, 400)$ for β;
  • eutectic line: $(25, 400) \to (80, 400)$;
  • solvus: $(25, 400) \to (5, 0)$ for α and $(80, 400) \to (90, 0)$ for β.

Regions: L above the liquidus; α + L and β + L between liquidus and solidus; α and β next to the axes, bounded by solidus and solvus; α + β below the eutectic line, between the solvus lines.

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 Composition (% B) Temperature (°C) L α β α + L β + L α + β C0 = 40 20.8 54.2 25 65 80 450 °C
Figure 13. A-B diagram with straight lines: melting points 700 °C (A) and 600 °C (B), eutectic at 400 °C and 65 % B, maximum solubilities 25 % B in α and 20 % A in β (80 % B) at 400 °C, and 5 % B in α and 10 % A in β (90 % B) at 0 °C. Dashed: the 40 % B alloy, with its tie lines at 450 °C and just above and below 400 °C.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

b) Phases of the 40 % B alloy 450 °C. The alloy is between the A-side liquidus and the α solidus: α + L. On a straight segment from $(0, 700)$ to $(C_1, 400)$ the composition at $T$ is $C = C_1 \dfrac{700 - T}{700 - 400}$:

$$C_L = 65 \times \frac{700 - 450}{300} = 65 \times \frac{250}{300} = 54.17\ \%\text{B} \qquad C_\alpha = 25 \times \frac{250}{300} = 20.83\ \%\text{B}$$
$$W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_L - C_\alpha} = \frac{40 - 20.83}{54.17 - 20.83} = \frac{19.17}{33.33} = 0.575 \qquad W_\alpha = \frac{C_L - C_0}{C_L - C_\alpha} = \frac{54.17 - 40}{33.33} = \frac{14.17}{33.33} = 0.425$$

400 °C + ΔT. Still α + L, with the ends of the tie line at the eutectic temperature: $C_\alpha = 25$, $C_L = 65$ % B (length 40):

$$W_L = \frac{40 - 25}{65 - 25} = \frac{15}{40} = 0.375 \qquad W_\alpha = \frac{65 - 40}{40} = \frac{25}{40} = 0.625$$

400 °C − ΔT. α + β; $C_\alpha = 25$, $C_\beta = 80$ % B (length 55):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\beta - C_0}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{80 - 40}{80 - 25} = \frac{40}{55} = 0.727 \qquad W_\beta = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_\beta - C_\alpha} = \frac{40 - 25}{55} = \frac{15}{55} = 0.273$$

c) Microconstituents at 400 °C − ΔT $25 < 40 < 65$: hypoeutectic, so the microconstituents are proeutectic α (25 % B) and eutectic (65 % B overall). The α present just above 400 °C is the proeutectic α, and the liquid becomes eutectic [Session 7 Slide 32]:

$$W_{\alpha p} = \frac{C_e - C_0}{C_e - C_\alpha} = \frac{65 - 40}{65 - 25} = 0.625 \qquad W_E = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_e - C_\alpha} = \frac{40 - 25}{40} = 0.375$$

Phases inside the eutectic:

$$W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha - W_{\alpha p} = 0.7273 - 0.6250 = 0.1023 \qquad W_{\beta,E} = W_\beta = 0.273$$

The same numbers from the make-up of the eutectic, which is $(80 - 65)/(80 - 25) = 15/55 = 0.273$ α and $40/55 = 0.727$ β: $W_{\alpha,E} = 0.375 \times 0.273 = 0.102$ and $W_{\beta,E} = 0.375 \times 0.727 = 0.273$.

proeutectic α eutectic (α + β)
Figure 14. 40 % B alloy at 400 − ΔT: proeutectic α (62.5 %) in the eutectic α + β (37.5 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • Mass balance at 450 °C: $0.425 \times 20.83 + 0.575 \times 54.17 = 8.85 + 31.15 = 40.0$ % B.
  • Mass balance at 400 °C − ΔT: $0.727 \times 25 + 0.273 \times 80 = 18.18 + 21.82 = 40.0$ % B.
  • $W_{\alpha,E} + W_{\beta,E} = 0.102 + 0.273 = 0.375 = W_E$, and $W_{\alpha p} + W_{\alpha,E} = 0.625 + 0.102 = 0.727 = W_\alpha$.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in % B): as $C_0$ approaches either end of a tie line, the phase at that end tends to the whole alloy and the other to 0; the 40 % B alloy lies inside every tie line used, so all its fractions are between 0 and 1.

Interpretation On cooling from the liquid, α starts to form at the liquidus ($700 - 300 \times 40/65 = 515$ °C for this alloy), grows to 62.5 % at the eutectic temperature, and the remaining 37.5 % of liquid, of 65 % B, becomes eutectic at 400 °C. Most of the eutectic is β (0.273 of the alloy), which is all the β of the alloy.

Check against the official solution

At 400 °C ± ΔT the results agree with the key (0.62/0.38 are 0.625/0.375; 0.73/0.27). The key writes "$C_\alpha$ = 25%Cu" at 400 °C + ΔT, a typo for 25 % B.

Discrepancy with the official solution

450 °C. The key gives $X_L = 0.57$, $X_\alpha = 0.43$, which correspond to $C_L = 55$ and $C_\alpha = 20$ % B, presumably read graphically from its drawing (Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, pp. 14-25, show no 450 °C tie line). With the straight lines that the statement requires, linear interpolation gives $C_L = 54.17$ and $C_\alpha = 20.83$ % B, hence $W_L = 0.575$ and $W_\alpha = 0.425$. The difference comes from reading the drawing; the interpolated values are kept.

α in the eutectic. The key gives $X(\alpha_E) = 0.11$, which is $0.73 - 0.62$ with rounded values. Exactly, $0.7273 - 0.6250 = 0.1023$, confirmed by $0.375 \times 15/55 = 0.102$; the key's 0.11 is a rounding effect.

Problem 9 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #9 Al-Ni · intermetallics
Click to Collapse ▲

Invariant Reactions and an Al-20 wt% Ni Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 3

9. Given the Al-Ni phase diagram, answer the questions below. a. What is the maximum solubility of aluminum in solid state nickel? What about nickel in aluminum? b. Write down the invariant reactions, indicating the temperature, the reaction in equation form, the composition of each phase and the name of the reaction. c. Given an Al-20% Ni alloy, indicate at 400 °C: composition and mass fraction of the phases; composition and mass fraction of the microconstituents; draw the microstructure that can be expected when cooling in equilibrium conditions. Point out each microconstituent with arrows.

Al-Ni phase diagram of the problem sheet
Figure 16. Al-Ni phase diagram (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 3).
Official Solution: a) 10%Al; 1%Ni. b) eutectic reaction (639 °C; 1380 °C); peritectoid reaction (700 °C); peritectic reaction (854 °C; 1133 °C, 1400 °C). c) $C_{Al_3Ni}$ = 43%Cu; $C_\alpha$ = 1%Cu; $X_\alpha$ = 0.55; $X_{Al_3Ni}$ = 0.45; Microconstituents: eutectic (X = 0.64) and proeutectic $Al_3Ni$ (X = 0.36)
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium and the Al-Ni diagram of the sheet (weight percent nickel). Every composition and temperature below is a reading of the figure, to about ±1 wt% and ±10 °C, except the temperatures printed on it (639.9, 854, 1133, ~700, 1638 °C).
  2. Invariant reactions are the horizontal lines where three phases meet ($F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$) [Session 7 Slide 13; Session 8 Slide 6]; their type follows from the shape around the line (V above: eutectic; inverted V below: peritectic or peritectoid) [Session 8 Slide 6].
  3. Al₃Ni is drawn as a vertical line (stoichiometric compound) at about 42 wt% Ni [Session 8 Slide 15].
  4. The (Al) phase is the very thin field along the left axis; its solubility limit is about 1 wt% Ni at most.

Data read on the diagram

PointReading
Eutectic at 639.9 °CL ≈ 6 wt% Ni, (Al) ≈ 1 wt% Ni, Al₃Ni ≈ 42 wt% Ni
(Al) at 400 °C≈ 1 wt% Ni
(Ni) at its widest≈ 90 wt% Ni, i.e. ≈ 10 wt% Al
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Al-Ni diagram (wt% Ni, °C). Each question is answered on horizontal lines (tie lines and invariant lines), so the work is one-dimensional and no change of basis is needed.

Strategy. (a) Maximum solubility = the widest point of each terminal solid solution. (b) Scan the diagram from the bottom up for horizontal lines and name each reaction by its shape. (c) Lever rule on the (Al)-Al₃Ni tie line for the phases, and on the short tie line from the eutectic liquid to Al₃Ni (just above 639.9 °C) for the microconstituents [Session 7 Slide 32].

Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Maximum solubilities

  • Al in solid Ni: the (Ni) field is widest at its horizontal line near 1385 °C, at about 90 wt% Ni: about 10 wt% Al.
  • Ni in solid Al: the (Al) field is widest at the eutectic temperature, 639.9 °C, at about 1 wt% Ni (the field is too thin to read more precisely).

b) Invariant reactions (on cooling)

T (°C)ReactionName
639.9$L\,(6) \rightarrow (\text{Al})\,(1) + \text{Al}_3\text{Ni}\,(42)$eutectic
~700$\text{AlNi}\,(76) + \text{AlNi}_3\,(86) \rightarrow \text{Al}_3\text{Ni}_5\,(81)$peritectoid
854$L\,(28) + \text{Al}_3\text{Ni}_2\,(56) \rightarrow \text{Al}_3\text{Ni}\,(42)$peritectic
1133$L\,(44) + \text{AlNi}\,(61) \rightarrow \text{Al}_3\text{Ni}_2\,(59)$peritectic
≈1395$L\,(86.5) + \text{AlNi}\,(83) \rightarrow \text{AlNi}_3\,(86)$peritectic
≈1385$L\,(86.5) \rightarrow \text{AlNi}_3\,(86) + (\text{Ni})\,(90)$eutectic

(compositions in wt% Ni, readings of the figure). The two reactions near 1390 °C are only a few degrees and a few percent apart; the key gives them as 1400 °C (peritectic) and 1380 °C (eutectic).

c) Al-20 wt% Ni at 400 °C Phases. (Al) of about 1 wt% Ni and Al₃Ni of 42 wt% Ni (tie line length $42 - 1 = 41$):

$$W_{(\text{Al})} = \frac{C_{\text{Al}_3\text{Ni}} - C_0}{C_{\text{Al}_3\text{Ni}} - C_{(\text{Al})}} = \frac{42 - 20}{42 - 1} = \frac{22}{41} = 0.537 \qquad W_{\text{Al}_3\text{Ni}} = \frac{20 - 1}{41} = \frac{19}{41} = 0.463$$

Microconstituents. $6 < 20 < 42$: the alloy is hypereutectic with respect to the 639.9 °C eutectic, so Al₃Ni forms first (primary, proeutectic) and the remaining liquid of 6 wt% Ni becomes eutectic. Just above 639.9 °C (tie line from 6 to 42, length 36):

$$W_{\text{Al}_3\text{Ni},p} = \frac{C_0 - C_e}{C_{\text{Al}_3\text{Ni}} - C_e} = \frac{20 - 6}{42 - 6} = \frac{14}{36} = 0.389 \qquad W_E = \frac{42 - 20}{36} = \frac{22}{36} = 0.611$$

The microconstituents keep these amounts on cooling to 400 °C (Al₃Ni has a fixed composition and the (Al) solvus barely moves).

primary Al₃Ni eutectic ((Al) + Al₃Ni)
Figure 15. Al-20 wt% Ni at 400 °C: primary Al₃Ni crystals (about 39 %) in the eutectic (Al) + Al₃Ni (about 61 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • Mass balance at 400 °C: $0.537 \times 1 + 0.463 \times 42 = 0.54 + 19.45 = 20.0$ wt% Ni.
  • All the (Al) is inside the eutectic: $W_{(\text{Al})} = 0.537 < W_E = 0.611$, and the rest of the eutectic, $0.611 - 0.537 = 0.074$, is eutectic Al₃Ni; total Al₃Ni $= 0.389 + 0.074 = 0.463$ ✓.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in % Ni): at $C_0 \approx 6$ (the eutectic) the alloy would be all eutectic and at $C_0 = 42$ all primary Al₃Ni; 20 % Ni lies nearer the eutectic end, hence most of the alloy (0.61) is eutectic.

Interpretation The alloy is mostly eutectic of soft (Al) with about 39 % of hard Al₃Ni crystals that grew from the liquid between about 800 °C (liquidus at 20 wt% Ni, reading) and 639.9 °C. The Ni-rich side of the diagram is crowded with intermetallic compounds formed by peritectic and peritectoid reactions.

Check against the official solution

Parts (a) and (b) agree with the key (10 % Al, 1 % Ni; eutectics at 639.9 and ~1380 °C, peritectoid at ~700 °C, peritectics at 854, 1133 and ~1400 °C). The key writes the compositions of part (c) as "%Cu"; they are wt% Ni.

Discrepancy with the official solution

For part (c) the key uses $C_{\text{Al}_3\text{Ni}} = 43$ % (its eutectic liquid is not stated; the key's eutectic fraction 0.64 implies about 7 % Ni), and gives $X_\alpha = 0.55$, $X_{\text{Al}_3\text{Ni}} = 0.45$, eutectic 0.64 and primary Al₃Ni 0.36. The figure places the Al₃Ni line at about 42 % and the eutectic point at about 6 % Ni, which give 0.537/0.463 and 0.611/0.389. With the key's readings the same formulas give $(43 - 20)/(43 - 1) = 23/42 = 0.548$ for (Al) and $(43 - 20)/(43 - 7) = 23/36 = 0.64$ for the eutectic: the difference comes only from the readings, which are within the precision of the drawing. The values read here are kept.

Problem 10 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #10 Cu-Sn · eutectoids
Click to Collapse ▲

Reactions and Eutectoids in the Cu-Sn System

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 4

10. Considering the Cu-Sn phase diagram: a. Indicate the type of transformations, and write the reactions that take place at $T_1$ = 798 °C; $T_2$ = 755 °C; $T_3$ = 588 °C; $T_4$ = 415 °C; $T_5$ = 1084.87 °C. b. For a Cu-20%Sn alloy, indicate the phases and microconstituents, their composition and amount at $T_1$: 521 °C and $T_2$: 519 °C. c. Determine the percentage of Sn in an alloy having 54% liquid phase at 900 °C. Is this alloy in solid state at 700 °C?

Cu-Sn phase diagram of the problem sheet
Figure 17. Cu-Sn phase diagram (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 4).
Official Solution: a) peritectic; peritectic, eutectoid; peritectic and solidification of Cu. b) 521 °C: $C_{(Cu)}$ = 15.8%Sn; $C_\gamma$ = 27%Sn; $X_\gamma$ = 0.37; $X_{(Cu)}$ = 0.63; X(eutectoid): 0.48; X(proeutectoid Cu): 0.52. 519 °C: $C_{(Cu)}$ = 15.8%Sn; $C_\delta$ = 32%Sn; $X_\delta$ = 0.26; $X_{(Cu)}$ = 0.74; X(eutectoid): 0.37 and X(proeutectoid Cu): 0.63. c) 14.5%Sn
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium, Cu-Sn diagram of the sheet (wt% Sn). Printed values: 798 °C with 13.5, 22 and 25.5 wt% Sn; 755 °C with 30.6; 586 °C with 24.6; 520 °C with 15.8 and 27.0; 415 °C with 59 and 92.4. The rest are readings of the figure (±1 wt%).
  2. The statement's 588 °C is the 586 °C line of the diagram.
  3. The type of each reaction follows from its shape [Session 8 Slide 6].

Data

LinePhases and compositions (wt% Sn)
798 °C(Cu) 13.5, β 22, L 25.5
755 °Cβ ≈ 24, γ ≈ 25.5, L 30.6
586 °C(Cu) 15.8, β 24.6, γ ≈ 25.5
520 °C(Cu) 15.8, γ 27.0, δ ≈ 32
415 °Cε ≈ 38, η 59, L 92.4
900 °C(Cu) ≈ 9, L ≈ 19 (on the solidus and liquidus)
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Cu-Sn diagram (wt% Sn, °C); all the work is on horizontal lines, so no change of basis is needed.

Strategy. (a) Name each line by its shape. (b) Lever rule on the tie lines just above and just below 520 °C; the microconstituents come from the history of the alloy (it crosses 798, 586 and 520 °C). (c) Write the lever rule for the liquid at 900 °C and solve it for $C_0$.

Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Transformations

TReaction on coolingType
$T_1$ = 798 °C$(\text{Cu})\,(13.5) + L\,(25.5) \rightarrow \beta\,(22)$peritectic
$T_2$ = 755 °C$\beta\,(\approx 24) + L\,(30.6) \rightarrow \gamma\,(\approx 25.5)$peritectic
$T_3$ = 586 °C$\beta\,(24.6) \rightarrow (\text{Cu})\,(15.8) + \gamma\,(\approx 25.5)$eutectoid
$T_4$ = 415 °C$\varepsilon\,(\approx 38) + L\,(92.4) \rightarrow \eta\,(59)$peritectic
$T_5$ = 1084.87 °C$L \rightarrow (\text{Cu})$ for pure Cusolidification of a pure metal

b) Cu-20 wt% Sn History. $13.5 < 20 < 22$: at 798 °C the peritectic consumes all the liquid and leaves (Cu) + β. On cooling, β is transformed at 586 °C by the eutectoid into (Cu) + γ, and γ at 520 °C by a second eutectoid into (Cu) + δ.

Just above 586 °C ((Cu) 15.8, β 24.6; length 8.8):

$$W_\beta = \frac{20 - 15.8}{24.6 - 15.8} = \frac{4.2}{8.8} = 0.477 \qquad W_{(\text{Cu})} = \frac{24.6 - 20}{8.8} = \frac{4.6}{8.8} = 0.523$$

This (Cu) is proeutectoid, and this β becomes the eutectoid microconstituent at 586 °C.

At 521 °C (phases), (Cu) 15.8 and γ 27.0 (length 11.2):

$$W_\gamma = \frac{20 - 15.8}{27.0 - 15.8} = \frac{4.2}{11.2} = 0.375 \qquad W_{(\text{Cu})} = \frac{27.0 - 20}{11.2} = \frac{7.0}{11.2} = 0.625$$

Microconstituents at 521 °C: proeutectoid (Cu) 0.523 and eutectoid [(Cu) + γ] 0.477.

At 519 °C (phases), below the 520 °C eutectoid $\gamma\,(27.0) \rightarrow (\text{Cu})\,(15.8) + \delta\,(32)$; (Cu) 15.8 and δ ≈ 32 (length 16.2):

$$W_\delta = \frac{20 - 15.8}{32 - 15.8} = \frac{4.2}{16.2} = 0.259 \qquad W_{(\text{Cu})} = \frac{32 - 20}{16.2} = \frac{12}{16.2} = 0.741$$

Microconstituents at 519 °C, counted with respect to the 520 °C reaction: the γ present at 521 °C (0.375) becomes eutectoid [(Cu) + δ], and all the (Cu) that existed before (0.625) counts as proeutectoid. That (Cu) is made of the proeutectoid (Cu) of 586 °C (0.523) plus the (Cu) of the first eutectoid ($0.625 - 0.523 = 0.102$).

c) Alloy with 54 % liquid at 900 °C At 900 °C the tie line goes from (Cu) at $C_S \approx 9$ to L at $C_L \approx 19$ wt% Sn (readings). The lever rule for the liquid:

$$W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_S}{C_L - C_S} \;\Rightarrow\; C_0 = C_S + W_L\,(C_L - C_S) = 9 + 0.54 \times (19 - 9) = 9 + 5.4 = 14.4\ \text{wt\% Sn}$$

Solid at 700 °C? $13.5 < 14.4 < 22$, so at 798 °C the peritectic uses up all the liquid: below 798 °C the alloy is (Cu) + β, both solid. At 700 °C the (Cu) boundary is at about 14.5 wt% Sn (it goes from 13.5 at 798 °C to 15.8 at 586 °C), so the alloy (14.4) is (Cu), practically single-phase. The key gives 14.5 wt% Sn; the 0.1 difference is well within the ±1 wt% of the readings and does not change the answer. Yes, it is solid at 700 °C.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • 519 °C: $0.741 \times 15.8 + 0.259 \times 32 = 11.71 + 8.29 = 20.0$ wt% Sn.
  • 521 °C: $0.625 \times 15.8 + 0.375 \times 27.0 = 9.88 + 10.13 = 20.0$ wt% Sn.
  • (c): with $C_0 = 14.4$, $W_L = (14.4 - 9)/(19 - 9) = 0.54$ ✓.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% Sn): in (c), $W_L \to 0$ as $C_0 \to C_S = 9$ and $W_L \to 1$ as $C_0 \to C_L = 19$; 14.4 lies a little past the middle of the tie line, consistent with 0.54 of liquid.

Interpretation The Cu-rich side of Cu-Sn (bronzes) shows how one alloy can cross several invariant reactions: a peritectic during solidification and two eutectoids in the solid. Each eutectoid turns a single solid phase into a fine two-phase mixture.

Check against the official solution

All values agree with the key: 0.37/0.63 and 0.48/0.52 at 521 °C; 0.26/0.74 and 0.37/0.63 at 519 °C (the key counts microconstituents with respect to the 520 °C reaction, as explained in part b); 14.5 % Sn. The key's part (c) does not answer the question about 700 °C.

Erratum in the worked solution

The annotated diagram of Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, p. 35, labels the field above the liquidus at about 50 % Sn and 900 °C as "(Cu)+ε"; that field is the liquid L, as the sheet's own diagram shows.

Problem 11 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #11 Diagram construction
Click to Collapse ▲

Drawing a Diagram with a Stoichiometric Compound

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 4

11. Draw the hypothetic phase diagram of A and B from the following data. a) Melting temperatures: A = 850 °C; B = 350 °C. b) A and B form an stoichiometric compound AB₂ that melts at 1000 °C; neither A nor B are soluble in the compound. c) There is an invariant eutectic point (70% at. of A, 700 °C). d) There is an invariant peritectic point (80% at. of B, 500 °C). e) The composition of the liquid at 500 °C is 95% at. of B. f) The solubility of B in A is 10% at. at 700 °C and 2% at. at 25 °C. g) The solubility of A in B is 25 % at. at 25 °C. Connect the points with straight lines. Indicate all the phase areas and points in the diagram, and write the reactions of the three phases.

Official Solution: not given in the sheet
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Compositions in atomic percent of B (at.% B) on the horizontal axis; straight lines between the given points, as the statement asks.
  2. AB₂ contains two B atoms per A atom: $x_B = 2/3 = 66.7$ at.% B. It is stoichiometric and dissolves neither A nor B, so it is a vertical line [Session 8 Slide 15]; it melts at 1000 °C as a single phase, so it melts congruently (a maximum of the liquidus) [Session 8 Slide 17].
  3. The terminal solid solutions are α (B dissolved in A) and β (A dissolved in B).
  4. "80 % at. of B" for the peritectic point is the composition of the solid β formed there; the liquid at 500 °C has 95 at.% B (point e).

Points

Pointat.% BT (°C)
Melting point of A0850
Melting point of B100350
AB₂ (congruent melting)66.71000
Eutectic E (liquid)30700
α at E (max. solubility of B in A)10700
α at 25 °C225
Peritectic P (β formed)80500
Liquid at 500 °C95500
β at 25 °C (25 at.% A)7525
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: composition (at.% B) against temperature (°C). The diagram is built from straight segments between the points; no change of basis is involved.

How the points connect.

  • Left part (A to AB₂): a eutectic system between α and AB₂ [Session 7 Slide 26]: liquidus from A (0, 850) to E (30, 700) and from E up to AB₂ (66.7, 1000); α solidus from (0, 850) to (10, 700); eutectic line from α (10) to AB₂ (66.7) at 700 °C; α solvus from (10, 700) to (2, 25).
  • Right part (AB₂ to B): a peritectic system [Session 8 Slide 8]: liquidus from AB₂ (66.7, 1000) down to (95, 500) and then to B (100, 350); peritectic line from AB₂ (66.7) to L (95) at 500 °C, with β (80) on it; β solidus from (80, 500) to B (100, 350); β solvus from (80, 500) to (75, 25).
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

The diagram

0 (A) 10 30 66.7 80 95 B 0 200 400 600 800 1000 Composition (at.% B) Temperature (°C) 850 °C 350 °C AB₂ 1000 °C E (700 °C) P (500 °C) 2 75 L α + L α α + AB₂ L + AB₂ L + AB₂ AB₂ + β L + β β
Figure 18. A-B with straight lines: A melts at 850 °C, B at 350 °C, the stoichiometric compound AB₂ (66.7 at.% B) melts congruently at 1000 °C; eutectic E at 700 °C and 30 at.% B; peritectic P at 500 °C (β of 80, liquid of 95 at.% B); solubility of B in α 10 at.% at 700 °C and 2 at.% at 25 °C; solubility of A in β 25 at.% at 25 °C.

Phase areas

RegionBounded by
Labove the liquidus
α + L0-30 at.% B, between 850 and 700 °C
αleft of the α solidus and solvus
α + AB₂10-66.7 at.% B, below 700 °C
L + AB₂ (left)30-66.7 at.% B, between 700 °C and the liquidus
L + AB₂ (right)66.7-95 at.% B, between 500 °C and the liquidus
AB₂ + β66.7 at.% B to the β solvus, below 500 °C
L + βbetween the β solidus (80 → 100) and the liquidus (95 → 100), from 500 to 350 °C
βright of the β solidus and solvus

Reactions of three phases (on cooling)

  • Eutectic, 700 °C: $L\,(30\ \text{at.\% B}) \rightarrow \alpha\,(10\ \text{at.\% B}) + \text{AB}_2\,(66.7\ \text{at.\% B})$
  • Peritectic, 500 °C: $\text{AB}_2\,(66.7\ \text{at.\% B}) + L\,(95\ \text{at.\% B}) \rightarrow \beta\,(80\ \text{at.\% B})$

AB₂ melting at 1000 °C involves only two phases (AB₂ and a liquid of the same composition), so it is not a three-phase reaction.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • Each three-phase line has the middle phase in the right place: at 700 °C the liquid (30) lies between the two solids (10 and 66.7), the shape of a eutectic; at 500 °C the new solid β (80) lies between AB₂ (66.7) and L (95), with the liquid at one end, the shape of a peritectic [Session 8 Slide 6].
  • Phase rule: on each horizontal line three phases coexist, $F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$; in each two-phase area $F = 1$ [Session 7 Slide 13].
  • Limiting case (compositions in the units of the statement): at the composition of the stoichiometric compound the alloy is a single phase, so every lever-rule fraction there is 0 or 1; this is why the compound is drawn as a vertical line.

Interpretation The compound AB₂ splits the diagram into two simpler diagrams, A-AB₂ (eutectic) and AB₂-B (peritectic). Since B melts at only 350 °C, the liquid persists to low temperatures on the B side, and β forms from AB₂ and the B-rich liquid at 500 °C.

Check against the official solution

The sheet gives no solution for this problem and the official solutions PDF has no page for it, so there is nothing to compare with.

Problem 12 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #12 Ni-Mo · hypereutectic
Click to Collapse ▲

Invariant Reactions and a Ni-40 at.% Mo Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 5

12. According to the Ni-Mo phase, indicate: a. The equations that represent the invariant reactions, specifying the composition of the phases, temperature and type of reaction. b. The maximum solubility of Mo in Ni and at what temperature it is produced. c. The maximum solubility of Ni in Mo and at what temperature it is produced. d. Melting temperature of Ni and Mo. e. Present phases, their composition and amount for a Ni-40%Mo alloy at 1309 °C. f. Microconstituents and their amount for a Ni-40%Mo alloy at 1309 °C. Sketch the microstructure.

Ni-Mo phase diagram of the problem sheet
Figure 20. Ni-Mo phase diagram (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 5).
Official Solution: a) eutectic reaction (1310 °C); peritectoid reaction (910 °C); peritectic reaction (1362 °C). b) 26% Mo. c) 4% Ni. d) 1455 °C; 2623 °C. e) $C_{NiMo}$ = 52%Mo; $C_\alpha$ = 27%Mo; $X_\alpha$ = 0.48; $X_{NiMo}$ = 0.52. f) $X_{NiMo,p}$ = 0.25; $X_E$ = 0.75
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium, Ni-Mo diagram of the sheet. Its axis reads only "Mo (%)", but the compounds sit at their atomic compositions (Ni₄Mo ≈ 20, Ni₃Mo = 25, NiMo ≈ 52 % Mo; in wt% they would be at 29.0, 35.3 and 62.0), so the axis is in atomic % Mo (at.%), like the Ti-Si diagram of Problem 13. Printed temperatures: 1455, 2623, 1362, 1310, 910 and 870 °C. Compositions are readings of the figure (±1 at.%).
  2. α is the Ni-rich solid solution and β the Mo-rich one; NiMo is an intermediate phase with a narrow composition range; Ni₃Mo and Ni₄Mo are compounds that form in the solid.

Data read on the diagram

LinePhases (at.% Mo)
1310 °Cα ≈ 27, L ≈ 36, NiMo ≈ 52
1362 °CL ≈ 38, NiMo ≈ 55, β ≈ 96
910 °Cα ≈ 22, Ni₃Mo ≈ 25, NiMo ≈ 52
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Ni-Mo diagram (at.% Mo, °C); one horizontal line per question, so no change of basis is needed. Reactions are named by their shape [Session 8 Slide 6]; amounts by the lever rule [Session 7 Slides 16, 32].

Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Invariant reactions (on cooling)

T (°C)ReactionType
1362$L\,(38) + \beta\,(96) \rightarrow \text{NiMo}\,(55)$peritectic
1310$L\,(36) \rightarrow \alpha\,(27) + \text{NiMo}\,(52)$eutectic
910$\alpha\,(22) + \text{NiMo}\,(52) \rightarrow \text{Ni}_3\text{Mo}\,(25)$peritectoid

At 870 °C the compound Ni₄Mo appears inside the α field (the small dome); only α and Ni₄Mo take part, so it is not a three-phase reaction.

b), c), d)

  • Maximum solubility of Mo in Ni: about 27 at.% Mo (the key writes 26 %), at the eutectic temperature, 1310 °C.
  • Maximum solubility of Ni in Mo: about 4 at.% Ni (β at 96 at.% Mo), at the peritectic temperature, 1362 °C.
  • Melting points: Ni 1455 °C, Mo 2623 °C.

e) Phases of Ni-40 at.% Mo at 1309 °C Just below the eutectic: α (27) + NiMo (52), tie line length 25. On an at.% axis the lever rule gives atom (mole) fractions $X$, as the key writes them (the lever rule is a balance of whatever the axis counts; this remark is an extension, since the slides use wt% axes):

$$X_\alpha = \frac{C_{\text{NiMo}} - C_0}{C_{\text{NiMo}} - C_\alpha} = \frac{52 - 40}{52 - 27} = \frac{12}{25} = 0.48 \qquad X_{\text{NiMo}} = \frac{40 - 27}{25} = \frac{13}{25} = 0.52$$

f) Microconstituents at 1309 °C $36 < 40 < 52$: the alloy is hypereutectic, so primary NiMo forms first and the liquid of 36 at.% Mo becomes eutectic. Short tie line from 36 to 52 (length 16):

$$X_{\text{NiMo},p} = \frac{C_0 - C_e}{C_{\text{NiMo}} - C_e} = \frac{40 - 36}{52 - 36} = \frac{4}{16} = 0.25 \qquad X_E = \frac{52 - 40}{16} = \frac{12}{16} = 0.75$$
primary NiMo eutectic (α + NiMo)
Figure 19. Ni-40 at.% Mo just below 1310 °C: primary NiMo (25 %) in the eutectic α + NiMo (75 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • Atom balance at 1309 °C: $0.48 \times 27 + 0.52 \times 52 = 12.96 + 27.04 = 40.0$ at.% Mo.
  • Phases inside the eutectic: all the α (0.48) and NiMo $0.52 - 0.25 = 0.27$; $0.48 + 0.27 = 0.75 = X_E$ ✓. The eutectic alone is $(52 - 36)/(52 - 27) = 16/25 = 0.64$ α, and $0.75 \times 0.64 = 0.48$ ✓.
  • Limiting cases (atom fractions, dimensionless; compositions in at.% Mo): at $C_0 = 36$ the alloy would be all eutectic and at $C_0 = 52$ all primary NiMo; 40 at.% lies close to the eutectic end, hence three quarters eutectic.

Interpretation The alloy is three quarters eutectic (α + NiMo) with a quarter of primary NiMo crystals. On further cooling, the α and NiMo of this alloy reach the 910 °C peritectoid, where they react to form Ni₃Mo.

Check against the official solution

All values agree with the key (0.48/0.52; 0.25/0.75; 1455 and 2623 °C; the three reactions). The key gives 26 % Mo for part (b) and uses 27 % Mo in part (e); the figure reads about 27 %. All compositions are at.% and the fractions are atom fractions, as in the key's $X$.

Problem 13 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #13 Ti-Si · congruent melting
Click to Collapse ▲

Compounds and Cooling of a Ti-30 % Si Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 5

13. Given the following Ti-Si phase diagram answer the next questions: a) Indicate the phases or compounds with incongruent and congruent melting. b) Write down the invariant reactions, specifying their name, temperature, and composition of the phases present. c) For an alloy with 30% Si describe the solidification and cooling sequence to 600 °C. Describe specifically the microstructure that can be expected at 1329 °C, 1169 °C, and 600 °C. d) For the same alloy of part c) and the temperatures of 1329 °C and 1169 °C indicate phase composition, phase fractions and quantity of microconstituents present.

Ti-Si phase diagram of the problem sheet
Figure 22. Ti-Si phase diagram (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 6).
Official Solution: a) congruent melting: Ti₅Si₃ and TiSi₂; incongruent melting: Ti₃Si, Ti₅Si₄ and TiSi. b) Eutectic, T = 1330 °C; Eutectic, T = 1330 °C; Eutectic, T = 1480 °C; Peritectic, T = 1920 °C; Peritectic, T = 1570 °C; Peritectoid T = 1170 °C; Eutectoid, T = 865 °C. c) T = 1329 °C: $C_{\beta Ti}$ = 5.5% Si and $C_{Ti_5Si_3}$ = 35% Si, $x_{\beta Ti}$ = 0.17, $x_{Ti_5Si_3}$ = 0.83; T = 1169 °C: $C_{Ti_3Si}$ = 25% Si and $C_{Ti_5Si_3}$ = 35% Si, $x_{Ti_5Si_3}$ = 0.5, $x_{Ti_3Si}$ = 0.5. d) T = 1329 °C: $x_{eutectic}$ = 0.24, $x_{Ti_5Si_3,primary}$ = 0.76; T = 1169 °C phases and microconstituents are the same
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium, Ti-Si diagram of the sheet. Printed temperatures: 1670, 1414, 2130, 1920, 1570, 1480, 1330 (twice), 1170 and 865 °C. Compositions are readings of the figure (±1 %), on the axis as printed.
  2. The axis is labelled "% wt Silicon", but the compounds sit at 25 (Ti₃Si), 37.5 (Ti₅Si₃), 44.4 (Ti₅Si₄), 50 (TiSi) and 66.7 (TiSi₂), their atomic percentages of Si; the numbers below are read on the axis as printed, as the key does, so the fractions $x$ are atom (mole) fractions and the Phase 4 balances count Si atoms. Ti₅Si₃ has a composition range on the figure: about 35 on its Ti side (1330 and 1170 °C) and up to about 38 on its Si side (1920 °C).
  3. Melting is congruent at a maximum of the liquidus and incongruent at a peritectic line [Session 8 Slide 17].

Data read on the diagram

LinePhases (% Si)
1330 °C (Ti side)βTi ≈ 5.5, L ≈ 14, Ti₅Si₃ ≈ 35
1170 °CβTi ≈ 4, Ti₃Si 25, Ti₅Si₃ ≈ 35
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Ti-Si diagram (% Si, °C); all the work is on horizontal lines and the vertical line of the alloy, so no change of basis is needed. Reactions are named by their shape [Session 8 Slide 6], amounts by the lever rule [Session 7 Slides 16, 32].

Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Congruent and incongruent melting

  • Congruent: Ti₅Si₃ (top of the large dome, 2130 °C) and TiSi₂ (small maximum near 1500 °C).
  • Incongruent: Ti₅Si₄ and TiSi end at peritectic lines (1920 and 1570 °C), and Ti₃Si at the peritectoid line (1170 °C): on heating each decomposes into another phase plus liquid (or, for Ti₃Si, into two solids).

b) Invariant reactions (on cooling, % Si read on the axis)

T (°C)ReactionType
1920$L\,(\approx 48) + \text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_3\,(\approx 38) \rightarrow \text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_4\,(\approx 44)$peritectic
1570$L\,(\approx 59) + \text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_4\,(\approx 44) \rightarrow \text{TiSi}\,(50)$peritectic
1480$L\,(\approx 64) \rightarrow \text{TiSi}\,(50) + \text{TiSi}_2\,(\approx 67)$eutectic
1330$L\,(\approx 14) \rightarrow \beta\text{Ti}\,(\approx 5.5) + \text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_3\,(\approx 35)$eutectic
1330$L\,(\approx 84) \rightarrow \text{TiSi}_2\,(\approx 67) + (\text{Si})\,(\approx 100)$eutectic
1170$\beta\text{Ti}\,(\approx 4) + \text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_3\,(\approx 35) \rightarrow \text{Ti}_3\text{Si}\,(25)$peritectoid
865$\beta\text{Ti}\,(\approx 1) \rightarrow \alpha\text{Ti}\,(\approx 0.5) + \text{Ti}_3\text{Si}\,(25)$eutectoid

c) Cooling of Ti-30 % Si to 600 °C

  1. Liquid down to the liquidus of Ti₅Si₃ (roughly 1950 °C, a reading); there primary Ti₅Si₃ starts to crystallise.
  2. L + Ti₅Si₃ down to 1330 °C; the liquid becomes poorer in Si along the liquidus and reaches 14 % Si.
  3. At 1330 °C the remaining liquid gives the eutectic βTi + Ti₅Si₃.
  4. Between 1330 and 1170 °C: primary Ti₅Si₃ in a eutectic of βTi + Ti₅Si₃.
  5. At 1170 °C the peritectoid βTi + Ti₅Si₃ → Ti₃Si uses up all the βTi (the alloy, 30 %, lies between Ti₃Si, 25 %, and Ti₅Si₃, 35 %), so below it the alloy is Ti₃Si + Ti₅Si₃.
  6. No other line is crossed down to 600 °C; the boundaries of both compounds are vertical, so nothing changes.

At 1329 °C (βTi 5.5 / Ti₅Si₃ 35, length 29.5):

$$x_{\beta\text{Ti}} = \frac{35 - 30}{35 - 5.5} = \frac{5}{29.5} = 0.17 \qquad x_{\text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_3} = \frac{30 - 5.5}{29.5} = \frac{24.5}{29.5} = 0.83$$

At 1169 °C and at 600 °C (Ti₃Si 25 / Ti₅Si₃ 35, length 10):

$$x_{\text{Ti}_3\text{Si}} = \frac{35 - 30}{35 - 25} = \frac{5}{10} = 0.5 \qquad x_{\text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_3} = \frac{30 - 25}{10} = 0.5$$

d) Microconstituents At 1329 °C: primary Ti₅Si₃ and eutectic. Short tie line from the eutectic liquid (14) to Ti₅Si₃ (35), length 21:

$$x_{\text{Ti}_5\text{Si}_3,p} = \frac{30 - 14}{35 - 14} = \frac{16}{21} = 0.76 \qquad x_E = \frac{35 - 30}{21} = \frac{5}{21} = 0.24$$

At 1169 °C: the peritectoid has turned the βTi (which was inside the eutectic) and part of the Ti₅Si₃ into Ti₃Si; the structure is Ti₃Si and Ti₅Si₃, in the same amounts as the phases, 0.5 and 0.5.

primary Ti₅Si₃ eutectic (βTi + Ti₅Si₃)
Figure 21. Ti-30 wt% Si just below 1330 °C: primary Ti₅Si₃ (76 %) in the eutectic βTi + Ti₅Si₃ (24 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • 1329 °C: $0.17 \times 5.5 + 0.83 \times 35 = 0.94 + 29.06 = 30.0$ at.% Si (atom balance).
  • 1169 °C: $0.5 \times 25 + 0.5 \times 35 = 30$ at.% Si.
  • Eutectic at 1329 °C: it holds all the βTi (0.17) and Ti₅Si₃ $0.83 - 0.76 = 0.07$; $0.17 + 0.07 = 0.24 = x_E$ ✓.
  • Limiting cases (atom fractions, dimensionless; compositions in at.% Si as printed): at 1329 °C, as $C_0 \to 14$ the primary Ti₅Si₃ tends to 0 and as $C_0 \to 35$ to 1; 30 lies close to the compound end, hence 0.76 of primary Ti₅Si₃.

Interpretation The Ti-rich side combines a eutectic, a peritectoid and a eutectoid. The 30 % alloy ends up made only of two silicides, which are hard and brittle compounds.

Check against the official solution

All values agree with the key (0.17/0.83, 0.5/0.5, 0.24/0.76; the classification of the compounds and the seven reactions).

Problem 14 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #14 Invariant reactions
Click to Collapse ▲

Reading a Hypothetical Diagram with Several Compounds

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 6

14. In the following graph, a hypothetical phase diagram is represented, identify and explain the following: a) The existing phases in each phase field of the diagram. b) The invariant reactions writing the temperature and the reaction's equation, the composition of each phase inside the reaction and its name. c) The congruent and incongruent fusion phases.

Hypothetical A-B phase diagram of problem 14
Figure 23. Hypothetical A-B phase diagram (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 6).
Official Solution (annotated diagram of Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, p. 37; the sheet prints none): β incongruent melting; γ congruent melting; δ incongruent melting; ε incongruent melting
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium; the diagram has no printed values except the axes (wt% B; temperature assumed in °C, since the axis prints no unit), so every number below is a reading of the figure, to about ±1 wt% and ±10 °C.
  2. Phases are named as in the official solution (p. 37): terminal solid solutions α (A side) and ζ (B side), intermediate phases β, γ (a vertical line: a compound of fixed composition at about 62 % B), δ and ε, and the liquid L.
  3. Each horizontal line is an invariant reaction, named by its shape [Session 8 Slide 6]; melting is congruent at a maximum of the liquidus and incongruent at a peritectic line [Session 8 Slide 17].
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: composition (wt% B) against temperature. The diagram is read on horizontal lines, from the top down and from left to right; no change of basis is involved.

Method. (a) Single-phase fields are the regions bounded by curved lines that touch the axis or a dome; each two-phase field takes the phases on its two sides along a horizontal tie line [Session 7 Slide 15]. (b) For each horizontal line: the three phases at its ends and middle point, and the shape. (c) Where each intermediate phase ends at the top.

Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phase fields

FieldPhases
topL
A side, below the liquidusα + L, then α
around 20 % Bβ; α + β on its left; β + L above the 700 °C line on its right
23-62 % B, below 700 °Cβ + γ
43-62 % B, above 700 °Cγ + L
62 % Bγ (vertical line)
62-72 % B, above 660 °Cγ + L
closed field near 68 % B, 430-660 °Cδ, with γ + δ, δ + L and δ + ε around it
62-80 % B, below 430 °Cγ + ε
around 80 % Bε, with ε + L above it
81-94 % B, below 495 °Cε + ζ
B sideζ + L, then ζ

b) Invariant reactions (on cooling, wt% B)

T (°C)ReactionName
≈ 895$\alpha\,(8) + L\,(28) \rightarrow \beta\,(19)$peritectic
≈ 700$L\,(43) \rightarrow \beta\,(23) + \gamma\,(62)$eutectic
≈ 660$\gamma\,(62) + L\,(72) \rightarrow \delta\,(68)$peritectic
≈ 595$\delta\,(71) + L\,(84) \rightarrow \varepsilon\,(80)$peritectic
≈ 495$L\,(90) \rightarrow \varepsilon\,(81) + \zeta\,(94)$eutectic
≈ 430$\delta\,(68) \rightarrow \gamma\,(62) + \varepsilon\,(76)$eutectoid

c) Melting

  • γ melts congruently at about 865 °C: it is at the maximum of its liquidus dome, and the liquid formed has its composition.
  • β, δ and ε melt incongruently: each ends at a peritectic line (895, 660 and 595 °C), where on heating it gives a liquid plus a different solid (β → α + L, δ → γ + L, ε → δ + L).
  • The pure components A (≈ 1200 °C) and B (≈ 695 °C) also melt congruently, like any pure metal [Session 8 Slide 17].
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • On every eutectic and eutectoid line the parent phase (L or δ) lies between the two products; on every peritectic line the product lies between the two reactants, with the liquid at one end [Session 8 Slide 6].
  • Phase rule: three phases on each horizontal line, $F = 2 - 3 + 1 = 0$ [Session 7 Slide 13].
  • δ is a closed field: it is created by a peritectic at 660 °C and destroyed by a eutectoid at 430 °C, so it exists only between those temperatures.
  • Limiting case: an alloy with exactly the composition of a line compound (γ) is a single phase, with fractions 1 or 0 and no tie line; every two-phase reading above lies strictly between its tie-line ends.

Interpretation The diagram is a chain of simple diagrams joined at the compounds. A phase that touches the liquid only at a horizontal line cannot exist as a liquid of its own composition, which is the meaning of incongruent melting.

Check against the official solution

Part (c) agrees with the key (β, δ, ε incongruent; γ congruent). The key gives no temperatures or compositions for part (b); they are readings of the figure here. The field labels agree with the annotated diagram of Solution problems Phase diagrams I.pdf, p. 37.

Problem 15 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf #15 Ti-B · peritectics
Click to Collapse ▲

The Ti-B System and Ti-10 % B and Ti-18 % B Alloys

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 7

15. Given the phase diagram of the figure, answer the following questions: a. Write down the invariant reactions, indicating the name, temperature and composition of the phases involved. b. List the congruent and incongruent melting phases or compounds. c. For an alloy with 10% B, indicate the composition of the phases, the amount of phases and the amount of microconstituents at 1000 °C and 500 °C. d. Describe the solidification sequence of an alloy with 18% B at a very slow cooling from the liquid state up to 500 °C.

Ti-B phase diagram of the problem sheet
Figure 25. Ti-B phase diagram in weight percent (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams I.pdf, p. 7).
Official Solution: a) peritectic (2200 °C); peritectic (2190 °C); eutectic (1540 °C); eutectic (2080 °C). b) Ti₃B₄ → L + TiB₂. c) 1000 °C: $C_{(\beta Ti)}$ = 0%B; $C_{TiB}$ = 18%B; $X_{(\beta Ti)}$ = 0.44; $X_{(TiB)}$ = 0.56; eutectic (x = 50%) and primary TiB (x = 50%). 500 °C: $C_{(\alpha Ti)}$ = 0%B; $C_{TiB}$ = 18%B; $X_{(\alpha Ti)}$ = 0.44; $X_{(TiB)}$ = 0.56; eutectic (x = 50%) and primary TiB (x = 50%)
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters

Hypotheses

  1. Equilibrium, Ti-B diagram of the sheet, read on its weight percent scale (bottom axis). Printed values: 1540, 884, ~2200, 2080, 3225 and 2092 °C. Compositions are readings of the figure (±1 wt%).
  2. Boron is practically insoluble in Ti: (βTi) and (αTi) are taken as 0 wt% B, as the key does.
  3. TiB, Ti₃B₄ and TiB₂ are compounds (Slide 15 of Session 8 shows the same system on the atomic scale).

Data read on the diagram

LinePhases (wt% B)
1540 °C eutectic(βTi) ≈ 0, L ≈ 2, TiB ≈ 18
~2200 °CL ≈ 13, Ti₃B₄ ≈ 24, TiB₂ ≈ 31
~2190 °CL ≈ 13, TiB ≈ 18, Ti₃B₄ ≈ 24
2080 °C eutecticTiB₂ ≈ 31, L ≈ 94, (βB) ≈ 100
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Ti-B diagram (wt% B, °C); horizontal tie lines and the vertical line of each alloy; no change of basis. Names of reactions from their shape [Session 8 Slide 6]; amounts from the lever rule [Session 7 Slides 16, 32].

Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Invariant reactions (on cooling)

T (°C)ReactionName
~2200$L\,(13) + \text{TiB}_2\,(31) \rightarrow \text{Ti}_3\text{B}_4\,(24)$peritectic
~2190$L\,(13) + \text{Ti}_3\text{B}_4\,(24) \rightarrow \text{TiB}\,(18)$peritectic
2080$L\,(94) \rightarrow \text{TiB}_2\,(31) + (\beta\text{B})\,(100)$eutectic
1540$L\,(2) \rightarrow (\beta\text{Ti})\,(0) + \text{TiB}\,(18)$eutectic

At 884 °C the titanium changes from (βTi) to (αTi) (its allotropic change, Topic 2); TiB does not take part.

b) Melting

  • TiB₂ melts congruently, at the top of the liquidus, 3225 °C.
  • Ti₃B₄ melts incongruently ($\text{Ti}_3\text{B}_4 \rightarrow L + \text{TiB}_2$ on heating at ~2200 °C), and so does TiB ($\text{TiB} \rightarrow L + \text{Ti}_3\text{B}_4$ at ~2190 °C): both end at peritectic lines [Session 8 Slide 17].

c) Ti-10 wt% B at 1000 °C and 500 °C Phases at 1000 °C: (βTi) 0 and TiB 18 (length 18):

$$X_{(\beta\text{Ti})} = \frac{18 - 10}{18 - 0} = \frac{8}{18} = 0.44 \qquad X_{\text{TiB}} = \frac{10 - 0}{18} = \frac{10}{18} = 0.56$$

At 500 °C the same, with (αTi) instead of (βTi): 0.44 and 0.56.

Microconstituents. $2 < 10 < 18$: hypereutectic, primary TiB and eutectic. Short tie line from the eutectic liquid (2) to TiB (18), length 16:

$$X_{\text{TiB},p} = \frac{10 - 2}{18 - 2} = \frac{8}{16} = 0.50 \qquad X_E = \frac{18 - 10}{16} = 0.50$$

The same at 1000 and 500 °C (the 884 °C change affects only the Ti inside the eutectic).

primary TiB eutectic (Ti + TiB)
Figure 24. Ti-10 wt% B below 1540 °C: primary TiB (50 %) in the eutectic Ti + TiB (50 %).

d) Ti-18 wt% B, very slow cooling to 500 °C

  1. Liquid, down to the liquidus on the TiB₂ side of the dome (roughly 2500 °C at 18 wt% B, a reading).
  2. L + TiB₂: primary TiB₂ crystallises; the liquid becomes poorer in B, down to 13 wt% at ~2200 °C.
  3. ~2200 °C, peritectic $L + \text{TiB}_2 \rightarrow \text{Ti}_3\text{B}_4$: since $13 < 18 < 24$, all the TiB₂ is used up and the alloy is L + Ti₃B₄.
  4. ~2190 °C, peritectic $L + \text{Ti}_3\text{B}_4 \rightarrow \text{TiB}$: the alloy has exactly the composition of TiB, so liquid and Ti₃B₄ are both used up: 100 % TiB.
  5. From ~2190 to 500 °C nothing changes: the alloy stays single-phase TiB.
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation

Checks

  • (c): $0.44 \times 0 + 0.56 \times 18 = 10$ wt% B; the eutectic (0.50) contains all the Ti (0.44) and $0.56 - 0.50 = 0.06$ of TiB, $0.44 + 0.06 = 0.50$ ✓.
  • (d): in equilibrium each peritectic is complete; with faster cooling the TiB would surround the Ti₃B₄ (and that the TiB₂) and the reactions would stay incomplete [Session 8 Slide 10].

Interpretation A Ti-B alloy with 10 % B is half eutectic (Ti + TiB) and half primary TiB, a hard boride; the 18 % B alloy is a single compound, reached through two peritectic reactions in a row.

Check against the official solution

Parts (a), (b) and (c) agree with the key (0.44/0.56 and 50 %/50 % at both temperatures). Part (b) of the key lists only Ti₃B₄; TiB is also incongruent and TiB₂ congruent, as shown above. The key gives no answer for part (d).

Problems on Fe-C phase diagrams

Problems 1-11 of the second official sheet (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II). Problems 1-10 use the metastable Fe-Fe₃C diagram of Session 9, shown below; problem 11 is a ternary diagram (Session 10); cementite is taken as 6.67 % C, as in the slides.

Fe-Fe₃C diagram of the problem sheet
Fe-Fe3C phase diagram of the problem sheet
Figure 26. Fe-Fe₃C phase diagram (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 1).
PointTemperatureCompositions (wt% C)
Eutectoid727 °Cγ 0.76 → α 0.022 + Fe₃C 6.67
Eutectic1147 °CL 4.30 → γ 2.14 + Fe₃C 6.67
Peritectic1493 °Cδ 0.09 + L 0.53 → γ 0.16
Fe-C Problem 1 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #1 Fe-C · hypoeutectoid steel
Click to Collapse ▲

Phases and Microconstituents of a 0.5 % C Steel

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf

1.- For a Fe-C alloy with $C_0$ = 0.5%C, at the following temperatures: $T_1$ = (1147+ΔT)ºC; $T_2$ = (1147−ΔT)ºC; $T_3$ = 900ºC; $T_4$ = (727+ΔT)ºC; $T_5$ = (727−ΔT)ºC. a) Indicate the phases present, their chemical composition and their mass fraction. b) Indicate the micro constituents, their chemical composition and their mass fraction at $T_5$.

Official Solution: a) $T_1$, $T_2$, and $T_3$: $C_\gamma$ = 0.5% C, $w_\gamma$ = 1; $T_4$: $C_\alpha$ = 0.022% C, $C_\gamma$ = 0.76% C, $w_\alpha$ = 0.35; $T_5$: $C_\alpha$ = 0.022% C, $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $w_\alpha$ = 0.93; b) $w_{\alpha'}$ = 0.35, $w_{\alpha,E}$ = 0.58, $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.07
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium cooling on the metastable Fe-Fe₃C diagram of the sheet (the diagram of Session 9 Slide 4): $C_\alpha$ = 0.022 % C, eutectoid 0.76 % C at 727 °C, cementite 6.67 % C.
  2. $C_0 = 0.5 < 0.76$: a hypoeutectoid steel [Session 9 Slide 14]; its solidus is far above 1147 °C, so at $T_1$, $T_2$ and $T_3$ it is fully austenitic.
  3. The microconstituents below 727 °C are proeutectoid ferrite and pearlite [Session 9 Slide 14].
TemperatureRegionPhase compositions (% C)
$T_1$, $T_2$, $T_3$γ0.5
$T_4$ = 727 + ΔTα + γα 0.022, γ 0.76
$T_5$ = 727 − ΔTα + Fe₃Cα 0.022, Fe₃C 6.67
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C); each temperature is one horizontal tie line, so no change of basis is needed. Phases from the lever rule [Session 7 Slide 16]; microconstituents from the short tie line α-eutectoid (0.022-0.76), exactly as in the 0.3 % C example of the slides [Session 9 Slide 18].

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 0.5 0.76 6.67 T₁ T₂ T₃ T₄ T₅
Figure 27. Fe-0.5 % C: γ at T₁, T₂ and T₃; α (0.022) + γ (0.76) just above 727 °C; α + Fe₃C just below it. Temperatures 1147 ± ΔT and 727 ± ΔT are drawn slightly apart.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1$, $T_2$, $T_3$: austenite only, $C_\gamma = 0.5$ % C, $W_\gamma = 1$.

$T_4$ (length $0.76 - 0.022 = 0.738$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_\gamma - C_0}{C_\gamma - C_\alpha} = \frac{0.76 - 0.5}{0.738} = \frac{0.26}{0.738} = 0.352 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{0.5 - 0.022}{0.738} = \frac{0.478}{0.738} = 0.648$$

$T_5$ (length $6.67 - 0.022 = 6.648$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{6.67 - 0.5}{6.648} = \frac{6.17}{6.648} = 0.928 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{0.5 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{0.478}{6.648} = 0.072$$

b) Microconstituents at $T_5$ The ferrite present at $T_4$ is the proeutectoid ferrite, and the austenite present at $T_4$ (0.76 % C) becomes pearlite:

$$W_{\alpha'} = 0.352 \qquad W_{\text{pearlite}} = 0.648$$

Inside the pearlite: eutectoid ferrite $W_{\alpha,E} = W_\alpha - W_{\alpha'} = 0.928 - 0.352 = 0.576$ and cementite $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.072$.

proeutectoid α pearlite (α + Fe₃C)
Figure 28. Fe-0.5 % C below 727 °C: proeutectoid ferrite (35 %) and pearlite (65 %).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • $0.576 + 0.072 = 0.648 = W_{\text{pearlite}}$, and $0.648 \times 0.889 = 0.576$ (pearlite is 88.9 % ferrite, Session 9 Slide 13) ✓.
  • Mass balance at $T_5$: $0.928 \times 0.022 + 0.072 \times 6.67 = 0.020 + 0.480 = 0.50$ % C ✓.
  • Limits: at $C_0 = 0.022$ there is no pearlite; at $C_0 = 0.76$ there is no proeutectoid ferrite.

Check against the official solution

All values agree with the key (0.35; 0.93; 0.35, 0.58, 0.07). The key writes $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7 % C; the 6.67 % C of the slides gives the same rounded results.

Fe-C Problem 2 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #2 Fe-C · eutectoid steel
Click to Collapse ▲

Phases and Microconstituents of a Eutectoid Steel

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf

2.- For a steel of $C_0$ = 0.76%C, at the following temperatures: $T_1$ = (1147+ΔT)ºC; $T_2$ = (1147−ΔT)ºC; $T_3$ = 900ºC; $T_4$ = (727+ΔT)ºC; $T_5$ = (727−ΔT)ºC. a) Indicate the phases present, their chemical composition and their mass fraction. b) Indicate the micro constituents, their chemical composition and their mass fraction at $T_5$.

Official Solution: a) $T_1$, $T_2$, $T_3$ and $T_4$: $C_\gamma$ = 0.76% C, $w_\gamma$ = 1; $T_5$: $C_\alpha$ = 0.022% C, $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $w_\alpha$ = 0.89, $w_{Fe_3C'}$ = 0.11; b) pearlite $w_{\alpha,E}$ = 0.89, $w_{Fe_3C,E}$ = 0.11
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium cooling on the Fe-Fe₃C diagram: α 0.022, eutectoid 0.76 % C at 727 °C, Fe₃C 6.67 % C [Session 9 Slide 4].
  2. $C_0 = 0.76$ % C is the eutectoid composition [Session 9 Slide 12]: the alloy is austenite down to 727 °C (it touches the eutectoid point only there).
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C), one tie line per temperature; no change of basis. The eutectoid reaction $\gamma\,(0.76) \rightarrow \alpha\,(0.022) + \text{Fe}_3\text{C}\,(6.67)$ turns all the austenite into pearlite at once [Session 9 Slide 10].

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 0.76 6.67 T₁ T₂ T₃ T₄ T₅
Figure 29. Fe-0.76 % C: γ down to 727 °C, then pearlite (α + Fe₃C).
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1$ to $T_4$: austenite, $C_\gamma = 0.76$ % C, $W_\gamma = 1$.

$T_5$ (length $6.67 - 0.022 = 6.648$):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{6.67 - 0.76}{6.648} = \frac{5.91}{6.648} = 0.889 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{0.76 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{0.738}{6.648} = 0.111$$

b) Microconstituents at $T_5$ One microconstituent, pearlite, 100 %, with overall composition 0.76 % C; inside it, eutectoid ferrite 0.889 and eutectoid cementite 0.111.

pearlite (α + Fe₃C)
Figure 30. Fe-0.76 % C below 727 °C: 100 % pearlite.
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Mass balance: $0.889 \times 0.022 + 0.111 \times 6.67 = 0.020 + 0.740 = 0.76$ % C ✓.
  • This is the make-up of every pearlite, the same as Worked example 15 of the theory (Session 9 Slide 13: 89 % and 11 %).
  • Limiting case (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% C): at exactly 0.76 % C the proeutectoid fraction $(0.76 - C_0)/(0.76 - 0.022)$ is 0, the end case of the hypoeutectoid formula: the steel is all pearlite.

Check against the official solution

Agrees with the key (0.89 and 0.11). The key calls the cementite of part (a) "$w_{Fe_3C'}$" (with a prime, the symbol of proeutectoid cementite); in a eutectoid steel there is no proeutectoid cementite, all of it is in the pearlite, as part (b) of the key says.

Fe-C Problem 3 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #3 Fe-C · hypereutectoid steel
Click to Collapse ▲

Phases and Microconstituents of a 1.5 % C Steel

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 2

3.- For an alloy Fe-1.5%C, at the following temperatures: $T_1$ = (1147+ΔT)ºC; $T_2$ = (1147−ΔT)ºC; $T_3$ = 900ºC; $T_4$ = (727+ΔT)ºC; $T_5$ = (727−ΔT)ºC. a) Indicate the phases present, their chemical composition and their mass fraction. b) Indicate the micro constituents, their chemical composition and their mass fraction at $T_5$.

Official Solution: a) $T_1$ and $T_2$: $C_\gamma$ = 1.5% C, $w_\gamma$ = 1; $T_3$: $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $C_\gamma$ = 1.3% C, $w_\gamma$ = 0.96, $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.04; $T_4$: $C_\gamma$ = 0.76% C, $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $w_\gamma$ = 0.87, $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.13; $T_5$: $C_\alpha$ = 0.022% C, $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $w_\alpha$ = 0.78, $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.22; b) Pearlite $w_{Fe_3C'}$ = 0.13, $w_{pearlite}$ = 0.87, $w_{\alpha E}$ = 0.78, $w_{Fe_3C,E}$ = 0.09
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium cooling, Fe-Fe₃C diagram [Session 9 Slide 4].
  2. $0.76 < C_0 = 1.5 < 2.14$: a hypereutectoid steel; at 1147 ± ΔT it is single-phase austenite (1.5 < 2.14).
  3. Reading of the figure: at 900 °C the $A_{cm}$ line is at about 1.3 % C (the key's value; a straight line from (0.76, 727) to (2.14, 1147) would give 1.33).
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C); one tie line per temperature. Below $A_{cm}$ proeutectoid cementite precipitates from the austenite [Session 9 Slide 19]; at 727 °C the remaining austenite (0.76 % C) becomes pearlite.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 1.5 1.3 6.67 0.76 T₁ T₂ T₃ T₄ T₅
Figure 31. Fe-1.5 % C: γ at 1147 ± ΔT; γ + Fe₃C at 900 °C (γ of about 1.3 % C, a reading) and just above 727 °C; α + Fe₃C below 727 °C.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1$, $T_2$: γ, 1.5 % C, $W_\gamma = 1$.

$T_3$ = 900 °C (γ 1.3 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 5.37):

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 1.5}{6.67 - 1.3} = \frac{5.17}{5.37} = 0.963 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{1.5 - 1.3}{5.37} = \frac{0.2}{5.37} = 0.037$$

$T_4$ (γ 0.76 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 5.91):

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 1.5}{5.91} = \frac{5.17}{5.91} = 0.875 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{1.5 - 0.76}{5.91} = \frac{0.74}{5.91} = 0.125$$

$T_5$ (α 0.022 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 6.648):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{6.67 - 1.5}{6.648} = \frac{5.17}{6.648} = 0.778 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{1.5 - 0.022}{6.648} = \frac{1.478}{6.648} = 0.222$$

b) Microconstituents at $T_5$ Proeutectoid cementite = the cementite at $T_4$, $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}'} = 0.125$; pearlite = the austenite at $T_4$, $W_{\text{pearlite}} = 0.875$. Inside the pearlite: $W_{\alpha,E} = 0.778$ (all the ferrite) and $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},E} = 0.222 - 0.125 = 0.097$.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • $0.778 + 0.097 = 0.875 = W_{\text{pearlite}}$; and $0.875 \times 0.889 = 0.778$ ✓.
  • Mass balance at $T_5$: $0.778 \times 0.022 + 0.222 \times 6.67 = 0.017 + 1.481 = 1.50$ % C ✓.
  • The proeutectoid cementite grows from 0.037 at 900 °C to 0.125 at 727 °C as the austenite loses carbon along $A_{cm}$.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% C): at $C_0 = 0.76$ the proeutectoid Fe₃C would be 0 and at $C_0 = 6.67$ the alloy would be all Fe₃C; 1.5 % C lies near the eutectoid end, hence only 0.125 of proeutectoid cementite.

Check against the official solution

Agrees with the key, except for the last figure.

Discrepancy with the official solution

The key gives $w_{Fe_3C,E} = 0.09$. Exactly, $0.222 - 0.125 = 0.097$ (≈ 0.10), confirmed by $0.875 \times 0.111 = 0.097$; the key subtracts the rounded values, $0.22 - 0.13 = 0.09$. The computed value is kept.

Fe-C Problem 4 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #4 Fe-C · ledeburite
Click to Collapse ▲

Phases and Microconstituents of a Eutectic Cast Iron

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 2

4.- For an alloy Fe-4.3% of C, at the following temperatures: $T_1$ = 1147 + ΔT ºC; $T_2$ = 1147 − ΔT ºC; $T_3$ = 900 ºC; $T_4$ = 727 + ΔT ºC; $T_5$ = 727 − ΔT ºC. a) Indicate the phases present, their chemical composition and their mass fractions. b) Indicate the micro constituents, their chemical composition and their mass fractions.

Official Solution (the phase symbols print as empty boxes in the PDF and are restored from context): a) $T_1$: $C_L$ = 4.3% C, $w_L$ = 1; $T_2$: $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $C_\gamma$ = 2.14% C, $w_\gamma$ = 0.53; $T_3$: $C_\gamma$ = 1.3% C, $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $w_\gamma$ = 0.44; $T_4$: $C_\gamma$ = 0.76% C, $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $w_\gamma$ = 0.40; $T_5$: $C_\alpha$ = 0.022% C, $C_{Fe_3C}$ = 6.7% C, $w_\alpha$ = 0.36; b) At $T_2$: $w_{Fe_3C,E}$ 0.47, $w_{\gamma,E}$ 0.53
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium cooling, Fe-Fe₃C diagram [Session 9 Slide 4]; $C_0 = 4.3$ % C is the eutectic composition: the alloy is liquid down to 1147 °C and then becomes 100 % ledeburite, $L \rightarrow \gamma\,(2.14) + \text{Fe}_3\text{C}\,(6.67)$ [Session 9 Slide 10].
  2. Reading of the figure: $A_{cm}$ at 900 °C ≈ 1.3 % C (as in Problem FC03).
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C); one tie line per temperature. Below 1147 °C the alloy stays in γ + Fe₃C, and the γ of the ledeburite loses carbon along $A_{cm}$ (more cementite precipitates), until at 727 °C it becomes pearlite ("transformed ledeburite", Session 9 Slide 11).

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 4.3 2.14 1.3 0.76 T₁ T₂ T₃ T₄ T₅
Figure 32. Fe-4.3 % C: liquid above 1147 °C, ledeburite (γ + Fe₃C) below it, and the tie lines at 900 °C and 727 ± ΔT.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Phases $T_1$: liquid, 4.3 % C, $W_L = 1$.

$T_2$ (γ 2.14 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 4.53):

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 4.3}{4.53} = \frac{2.37}{4.53} = 0.523 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{4.3 - 2.14}{4.53} = \frac{2.16}{4.53} = 0.477$$

$T_3$ (γ 1.3 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 5.37):

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 4.3}{5.37} = \frac{2.37}{5.37} = 0.441 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 1 - W_\gamma = 1 - 0.441 = 0.559$$

$T_4$ (γ 0.76 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 5.91):

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 4.3}{6.67 - 0.76} = \frac{2.37}{5.91} = 0.401 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 1 - 0.401 = 0.599$$

$T_5$ (α 0.022 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 6.648):

$$W_\alpha = \frac{6.67 - 4.3}{6.67 - 0.022} = \frac{2.37}{6.648} = 0.356 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 1 - 0.356 = 0.644$$

b) Microconstituents

  • $T_1$: liquid.
  • $T_2$: 100 % ledeburite (4.3 % C overall), made of $W_{\gamma,E} = 0.523$ and $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},E} = 0.477$ (Worked example 14 of the theory).
  • $T_3$, $T_4$: ledeburite whose austenite has rejected cementite: γ + Fe₃C in the amounts of part (a).
  • $T_5$: transformed ledeburite: the 0.401 of austenite at $T_4$ has become pearlite, inside a cementite matrix (0.599).
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Mass balance at $T_2$: $0.523 \times 2.14 + 0.477 \times 6.67 = 1.12 + 3.18 = 4.30$ % C ✓.
  • The amount of cementite only grows on cooling (0.477 → 0.559 → 0.599 → 0.644), because the solubility of C in the iron phase only falls.
  • Limiting case (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% C): at exactly 4.30 % C the primary fraction is 0 on both sides of the eutectic: the alloy is all ledeburite at $T_2$.

Check against the official solution

Agrees with the key at $T_3$, $T_4$ and $T_5$.

Discrepancy with the official solution

At $T_2$ the key gives $w_\gamma = 0.53$. With 6.67 % C for cementite (the value of the slides), $w_\gamma = 2.37/4.53 = 0.523$ (0.52); the key's 0.53 follows from 6.7 % C, $2.4/4.56 = 0.526$. The same gap appears in part (b): the ledeburite is $W_{\gamma,E} = 0.523$ and $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},E} = 0.477$ (0.52/0.48), against the key's 0.53/0.47. The difference is only the rounding of the cementite composition (the sheet's diagram ends at 6.7 % C); 0.523 and 0.477 are kept.

Fe-C Problem 5 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #5 Fe-C · lever rule
Click to Collapse ▲

Composition from the Cementite Fraction

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 2

5.- Calculate the composition of a Fe-C alloy whose composition is within the range in %C of (2.11 < $C_0$ < 4.3). Consider temperature is (727−ΔT)ºC and the mass fraction $\chi_{Fe_3C}$ is 0.38.

Official Solution: $C_0$ = 2.56%C
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium; just below 727 °C every Fe-C alloy is α (0.022 % C) + Fe₃C (6.67 % C) [Session 9 Slides 4, 9].
  2. The range given (2.11-4.3 % C) is that of hypoeutectic cast irons (the diagram of the slides puts the steel limit at 2.14 %).
  3. Unknown: $C_0$; one equation (lever rule for Fe₃C).
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C), on the tie line at 727 − ΔT, from 0.022 to 6.67 % C; one-dimensional, no change of basis. The lever rule is solved for the alloy composition instead of the fraction [Session 7 Slide 16].

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 2.55 6.67 727 − ΔT
Figure 33. The alloy with 38 % Fe₃C just below 727 °C lies at 2.55 % C (computed in the problem).
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation
$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{C_0 - C_\alpha}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} \;\Rightarrow\; C_0 = C_\alpha + W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}\,(C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha)$$
$$C_0 = 0.022 + 0.38 \times (6.67 - 0.022) = 0.022 + 0.38 \times 6.648 = 0.022 + 2.526 = 2.55\ \%\,\text{C}$$
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Check: $(2.548 - 0.022)/6.648 = 0.380$ ✓; and $2.11 < 2.55 < 4.3$, inside the given range ✓.
  • Units: percentages of C on both sides; $W$ dimensionless.
  • The alloy is a hypoeutectic cast iron: it would contain primary austenite and ledeburite just below 1147 °C.

Check against the official solution

Discrepancy with the official solution

The key gives $C_0 = 2.56$ % C, which follows from 6.7 % C for cementite: $0.022 + 0.38 \times 6.678 = 2.56$. With the 6.67 % C of the slides the result is 2.55 % C; the difference is only that rounding.

Fe-C Problem 6 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #6 Fe-C · hypoeutectic cast iron
Click to Collapse ▲

Hypoeutectic Cast Iron from its Ferrite Fraction

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 2

6.- Consider a steel with a content of C < 4.3% at (727−ΔT)ºC. In these conditions, $\chi_\alpha$ = 0.47. Indicate the mass fraction of the phases at (1147+ΔT)ºC and (1147−ΔT)ºC.

Official Solution: T1: $w_\gamma$ = 0.32, $\chi_L$ = 0.68; T2: $w_\gamma$ = 0.68, $\chi_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.32, $w_E$ = 0.68, $\chi_{\gamma E}$ = 0.36, $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.32
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium, Fe-Fe₃C diagram [Session 9 Slide 4]: α 0.022, γ 2.14 (at 1147 °C), eutectic 4.30, Fe₃C 6.67 % C.
  2. Unknown first: $C_0$, from the ferrite fraction just below 727 °C.
  3. The statement says "steel", but the result is above 2.14 % C, so the alloy is a hypoeutectic cast iron (it has ledeburite).
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C), with tie lines at 727 − ΔT (α-Fe₃C), 1147 + ΔT (γ-L) and 1147 − ΔT (γ-Fe₃C). Step 1 solves the lever rule for $C_0$; steps 2-3 apply it at 1147 ± ΔT; microconstituents as in Session 7 Slide 32.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 3.55 2.14 4.30 6.67 T₁ T₂ 727 − ΔT
Figure 34. The alloy with 47 % α just below 727 °C lies at about 3.55 % C: γ + L above 1147 °C, γ + Fe₃C below it.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

1. Composition

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_0}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} \;\Rightarrow\; C_0 = C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - W_\alpha\,(C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha) = 6.67 - 0.47 \times 6.648 = 6.67 - 3.125 = 3.545 \approx 3.55\ \%\,\text{C}$$

2. $T_1$ = 1147 + ΔT (γ 2.14 / L 4.30; length 2.16)

$$W_L = \frac{C_0 - C_\gamma}{C_L - C_\gamma} = \frac{3.545 - 2.14}{2.16} = \frac{1.405}{2.16} = 0.650 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{4.30 - 3.545}{2.16} = \frac{0.755}{2.16} = 0.350$$

3. $T_2$ = 1147 − ΔT (γ 2.14 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 4.53)

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{3.545 - 2.14}{4.53} = \frac{1.405}{4.53} = 0.310 \qquad W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 3.545}{4.53} = \frac{3.125}{4.53} = 0.690$$

Microconstituents at $T_2$: primary austenite = γ at $T_1$ = 0.350; ledeburite = L at $T_1$ = 0.650, made of γ $0.690 - 0.350 = 0.340$ and Fe₃C 0.310.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Ledeburite make-up: $0.340/0.650 = 0.523$ γ, as in Worked example 14 ✓.
  • Mass balance at $T_2$: $0.690 \times 2.14 + 0.310 \times 6.67 = 1.48 + 2.07 = 3.55$ % C ✓.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% C): the ferrite fraction $(6.67 - C_0)/6.648$ is 1 at $C_0 = 0.022$ and 0 at $C_0 = 6.67$; 0.47 lies between, so $C_0$ lies between those limits, here inside the cast-iron range.

Check against the official solution

The method matches the worked page of Solution problems Phase diagrams II.pdf, p. 12.

Discrepancy with the official solution

The worked page rounds the composition to $C_0 = 3.6$ % C before going on (with 6.7 % C it is 3.56) and so gives 0.68/0.32 at $T_1$, 0.32/0.68 at $T_2$, primary γ 0.32 and eutectic γ 0.36. With the unrounded $C_0 = 3.545$ % C the values are 0.650/0.350, 0.310/0.690, primary γ 0.350 and eutectic γ 0.340; the computed values are kept. The page also writes the formula for $\chi_L$ with the labels of the α-Fe₃C tie line; its numbers, $(3.6 - 2.14)/(4.3 - 2.14)$, are those of the γ-L tie line used here.

Fe-C Problem 7 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #7 Fe-C · hypereutectic cast iron
Click to Collapse ▲

Hypereutectic Cast Iron from its Cementite Fraction

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 2

7.- Consider an alloy of Fe-C, with content of C > 4.3%C at (727−ΔT)ºC. In these conditions, $\chi_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.73. Indicate the mass fraction of the phases at (1147+ΔT)ºC and (1147−ΔT)ºC.

Official Solution: T1: $w_L$ = 0.75, $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.25; T2: $w_\gamma$ = 0.39, $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.61, $w_{(Fe_3C)p}$ = 0.25, $w_E$ = 0.75, $w_{\gamma E}$ = 0.39, $w_{(Fe_3C)E}$ = 0.36
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium, Fe-Fe₃C diagram [Session 9 Slide 4].
  2. $C_0 > 4.3$: a hypereutectic cast iron; the primary phase is cementite, which forms in L + Fe₃C above 1147 °C.
  3. Unknown first: $C_0$ from the cementite fraction just below 727 °C.
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C). Tie lines: 727 − ΔT (α 0.022 / Fe₃C 6.67), 1147 + ΔT (L 4.30 / Fe₃C 6.67), 1147 − ΔT (γ 2.14 / Fe₃C 6.67). Lever rule each time [Session 7 Slides 16, 32].

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 4.88 4.30 2.14 T₁ T₂ 727 − ΔT
Figure 35. The alloy with 73 % Fe₃C just below 727 °C lies at about 4.88 % C: L + Fe₃C above 1147 °C, γ + Fe₃C below it.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

1. Composition

$$C_0 = C_\alpha + W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}\,(C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha) = 0.022 + 0.73 \times 6.648 = 0.022 + 4.853 = 4.875\ \%\,\text{C}$$

2. $T_1$ = 1147 + ΔT (length $6.67 - 4.30 = 2.37$)

$$W_L = \frac{6.67 - 4.875}{2.37} = \frac{1.795}{2.37} = 0.757 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{4.875 - 4.30}{2.37} = \frac{0.575}{2.37} = 0.243$$

3. $T_2$ = 1147 − ΔT (length $6.67 - 2.14 = 4.53$)

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 4.875}{4.53} = \frac{1.795}{4.53} = 0.396 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{4.875 - 2.14}{4.53} = \frac{2.735}{4.53} = 0.604$$

Microconstituents at $T_2$: primary cementite = 0.243; ledeburite = 0.757, made of γ 0.396 and Fe₃C $0.604 - 0.243 = 0.361$.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Ledeburite make-up: $0.396/0.757 = 0.523$ γ ✓ (Worked example 14).
  • Mass balance at $T_1$: $0.757 \times 4.30 + 0.243 \times 6.67 = 3.26 + 1.62 = 4.875$ % C ✓.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% C): at $C_0 = 4.30$ the primary Fe₃C would be 0 and at $C_0 = 6.67$ the alloy would be all Fe₃C; 4.875 % C lies near the eutectic end, hence 0.243 of primary Fe₃C.

Check against the official solution

Agrees with the key in the eutectic Fe₃C, 0.361 (key 0.36). The key does not give $C_0$; it is 4.875 % C (4.90 % with 6.7 % C for cementite: $0.022 + 0.73 \times 6.678 = 4.897$).

Discrepancy with the official solution

Four values differ from the key by 0.01: 0.757/0.243 (key 0.75/0.25) and 0.396/0.604 (key 0.39/0.61). The key works with $C_0$ rounded to 4.9 % and 6.7 % C for cementite: $(6.7 - 4.9)/2.4 = 0.75$, $(4.9 - 4.3)/2.4 = 0.25$, $(6.7 - 4.9)/4.56 = 0.395 \to 0.39$ and $0.605 \to 0.61$. With the slides' 6.67 % C and the unrounded $C_0$ the values above follow; they are kept.

Fe-C Problem 8 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #8 Fe-C · alloying elements
Click to Collapse ▲

Annealed 0.55 % C Steel Bar and the Effect of Nickel

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 2

8.- Examine closely the phase diagram Fe-C and answer the following questions. a) If there is a 5 kg annealed bar of an alloy with 0.55 % C, what is the quantity (mass expressed in kg) of pre-eutectoid ferrite, eutectoid ferrite and cementite that is contained at 726 ºC? b) List the phases and microconstituents in this steel, their composition and their percentage at 600 ºC. c) How are the carbon content and temperature at the eutectoid point modified in the diagram if Ni is added? How does this addition modify the steel's microstructure?

Official Solution: a) $\alpha'$ = 1.43 kg; pearlite = 3.6 kg; $\alpha_{total}$ = 4.6 kg; $\alpha_{eutectoid}$ = 3.17 kg; Fe₃C = 0.4 kg; b) $x_{\alpha pre}$ = 0.26; $x_{eutectoid}$ = 0.72; $w_{\alpha total}$ = 0.92; $w_{Fe_3C}$ = 0.08; c) possible decrease in amount of primary ferrite
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Annealed means slowly cooled: equilibrium structure, Fe-Fe₃C diagram [Session 9 Slide 4].
  2. $C_0 = 0.55 < 0.76$: hypoeutectoid; at 726 °C (just below 727 °C) the structure is proeutectoid ferrite + pearlite [Session 9 Slide 14].
  3. At 600 °C the ferrite solvus gives slightly less than 0.022 % C; the difference does not change the result to two decimals, so 0.022 % C is used (a reading of the figure).
  4. Data: $m$ = 5 kg.
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C); tie lines just above 727 °C (α 0.022 / γ 0.76, for the proeutectoid ferrite) and below it (α 0.022 / Fe₃C 6.67, for the phases). Masses are fractions times 5 kg.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 0.55 6.67 726 °C 600 °C
Figure 36. Fe-0.55 % C at 726 °C and at 600 °C: α + Fe₃C, as proeutectoid ferrite and pearlite.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) At 726 °C

$$W_{\alpha'} = \frac{0.76 - 0.55}{0.76 - 0.022} = \frac{0.21}{0.738} = 0.285 \;\Rightarrow\; m_{\alpha'} = 0.285 \times 5 = 1.42\ \text{kg}$$
$$W_{\text{pearlite}} = 1 - 0.285 = 0.715 \;\Rightarrow\; m_{\text{pearlite}} = 0.715 \times 5 = 3.575 \approx 3.58\ \text{kg}$$
$$W_{\alpha,\text{total}} = \frac{6.67 - 0.55}{6.648} = \frac{6.12}{6.648} = 0.921 \;\Rightarrow\; m_{\alpha,\text{total}} = 4.60\ \text{kg}$$
$$m_{\alpha,E} = 4.60 - 1.42 = 3.18\ \text{kg} \qquad m_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = (1 - 0.921) \times 5 = 0.079 \times 5 = 0.40\ \text{kg}$$

b) At 600 °C

  • Phases: α (≈ 0.022 % C) 92 % and Fe₃C (6.67 % C) 8 %.
  • Microconstituents: proeutectoid ferrite 28.5 % and pearlite (0.76 % C overall) 71.5 %. The microconstituents formed at 727 °C do not change on further slow cooling.

c) Effect of nickel Ni is a γ-stabilising element: it displaces the eutectoid point to lower temperature and lower %C [Session 9 Slides 22-23]. With a lower eutectoid composition, the same 0.55 % C steel lies closer to the eutectoid point, so the short tie line gives less proeutectoid ferrite and more pearlite.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Mass check: $1.42 + 3.58 = 5.00$ kg; $4.60 + 0.40 = 5.00$ kg; pearlite $3.18 + 0.40 = 3.58$ kg ✓.
  • Carbon, with the unrounded masses $m_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = 0.0794 \times 5 = 0.397$ kg and $m_\alpha = 4.603$ kg: $0.397 \times 0.0667 + 4.603 \times 0.00022 = 0.02649 + 0.00101 = 0.0275$ kg C $= 0.55\,\%$ of 5 kg ✓.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, masses in kg, compositions in wt% C): at $C_0 = 0.022$ the steel would be all proeutectoid α and at $C_0 = 0.76$ all pearlite; 0.55 % C lies nearer the eutectoid end, hence 0.715 of pearlite.

Check against the official solution

Part (a) agrees with the key in 3.6, 4.6 and 0.4 kg; (c) agrees.

Discrepancy with the official solution

The key gives 1.43 kg of proeutectoid ferrite and 3.17 kg of eutectoid ferrite. Here $0.2846 \times 5 = 1.423 \to 1.42$ kg and $4.60 - 1.42 = 3.18$ kg; the key's 3.17 follows from its 1.43. The gap is 0.01 kg in the last digit; the computed values are kept.

Discrepancy with the official solution

For part (b) the key gives $x_{\alpha pre} = 0.26$ and $x_{eutectoid} = 0.72$, which do not add up to 1 and do not match its own part (a) ($1.43/5 = 0.286$, $3.6/5 = 0.72$). The lever rule gives 0.285 proeutectoid ferrite and 0.715 pearlite, the same at 726 and at 600 °C; these values are kept.

Fe-C Problem 9 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #9 Fe-C · secondary cementite
Click to Collapse ▲

A 3 % C Cast Iron from 1146 to 800 °C

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 3

9. Examine closely the phase diagram Fe-C answer the following questions. a) Calculate the percentage of C in an alloy that has 64.7 % of austenite and 35.5 % of cementite at 800 ºC. What kind of alloy is it? b) What microconstituents does it have at 1146ºC? Calculate the quantity of each one. c) How do microconstituents change when cooling down from 1146 ºC to 800 ºC?

Official Solution: a) $C_0$ = 3%; hypoeutectic cast iron; b) $w_{\gamma primary}$ = 60.2%; $w_{ledeburite}$ = 39.8%; $w_{Fe_3C\,ledeburite}$ = 18.8%; $w_{\gamma ledeburite}$ = 21%; $w_{\gamma total}$ = 81.2%; c) Fe₃C precipitates (secondary Fe₃C); $w_{Fe_3C\,secondary}$ = 16.3%
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium, Fe-Fe₃C diagram [Session 9 Slide 4].
  2. Reading of the figure: at 800 °C the $A_{cm}$ line is at about 1.0 % C (a straight line from (0.76, 727) to (2.14, 1147) gives $0.76 + 73 \times 1.38/420 = 1.00$).
  3. The data of the statement add up to 100.2 %; each fraction is used on its own to get $C_0$, and the two results are compared.
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C). Tie lines: 800 °C (γ 1.0 / Fe₃C 6.67), 1147 + ΔT (γ 2.14 / L 4.30), 1146 °C (γ 2.14 / Fe₃C 6.67). The lever rule is solved for $C_0$ in (a) and applied in (b) and (c); microconstituents as in Session 7 Slide 32.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 3 2.14 4.30 1.0 1148 °C 1146 °C 800 °C
Figure 37. Fe-3 % C: γ + L just above 1147 °C, primary γ + ledeburite just below it, γ (about 1.0 % C, a reading) + Fe₃C at 800 °C.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Composition From the austenite: $W_\gamma = \dfrac{6.67 - C_0}{6.67 - 1.0} = 0.647 \Rightarrow C_0 = 6.67 - W_\gamma\,(6.67 - 1.0) = 6.67 - 0.647 \times 5.67 = 6.67 - 3.668 = 3.00$ % C.

From the cementite: $W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \dfrac{C_0 - 1.0}{5.67} = 0.355 \Rightarrow C_0 = 1.0 + W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} \times 5.67 = 1.0 + 0.355 \times 5.67 = 1.0 + 2.013 = 3.01$ % C.

Both give $C_0$ ≈ 3.0 % C: $2.14 < 3.0 < 4.30$, a hypoeutectic cast iron.

b) Microconstituents at 1146 °C Just above 1147 °C (γ 2.14 / L 4.30; length 2.16):

$$W_{\gamma,p} = \frac{4.30 - 3.0}{2.16} = \frac{1.30}{2.16} = 0.602 \qquad W_L = \frac{3.0 - 2.14}{2.16} = \frac{0.86}{2.16} = 0.398$$

At 1146 °C the liquid has become ledeburite (0.398) and the primary austenite remains (0.602). Phases at 1146 °C (γ 2.14 / Fe₃C 6.67; length 4.53):

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{3.0 - 2.14}{4.53} = \frac{0.86}{4.53} = 0.190 \qquad W_{\gamma,\text{total}} = 1 - 0.190 = 0.810$$

All the cementite is in the ledeburite (0.190), so the austenite of the ledeburite is $0.398 - 0.190 = 0.208$.

primary γ ledeburite (γ + Fe₃C)
Figure 38. Fe-3 % C just below 1147 °C: primary austenite (60 %) and ledeburite (40 %).

c) From 1146 to 800 °C The austenite (primary and eutectic) loses carbon along $A_{cm}$, from 2.14 to 1.0 % C, and the excess precipitates as secondary cementite [Session 9 Slide 11]. At 800 °C:

$$W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}}(800) = \frac{3.0 - 1.0}{5.67} = \frac{2.0}{5.67} = 0.353 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},\text{sec}} = 0.353 - 0.190 = 0.163$$
Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Ledeburite make-up: $0.190/0.398 = 0.477$ Fe₃C, as in Worked example 14 ✓.
  • At 800 °C: γ $1 - 0.353 = 0.647$ — exactly the 64.7 % of the statement ✓.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% C): at 800 °C the austenite fraction is 1 at $C_0 = 1.0$ and 0 at $C_0 = 6.67$; 3.0 % C lies about a third of the way along, hence 0.647 of austenite.

Check against the official solution

Agrees with the key: 3 %, hypoeutectic cast iron, 60.2 %, 39.8 % and 16.3 %.

Discrepancy with the official solution

With 6.67 % C the cementite of the ledeburite is 19.0 % (key 18.8 %), its austenite 20.8 % (key 21 %) and the total austenite 81.0 % (key 81.2 %). The key uses 6.7 % C for cementite, which gives 18.86 %, so its 18.8 is also truncated. Differences of 0.2 percentage points at most; the computed values are kept.

Fe-C Problem 10 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #10 Fe-C · pearlite limits
Click to Collapse ▲

Fe-Cementite Questions and Pearlite Limits

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 3

10.- Using the Fe-cementite phase diagram, indicate: a) What real alloy or alloys comply the following conditions $W_\alpha$ = 0.267 at 727 − ΔT ºC? b) What is the maximum and minimum content (mass fraction W) of pearlite in a steel? Explain why. c) Indicate the invariant points that appear in the diagram and explain which microconstituents are formed during cooling. d) For the alloys with 1.5% C and 3% C, indicate the microconstituents and if the mass fraction of them changes on cooling in the range between 1148 ºC and 727 + ΔT ºC.

Official Solution: a) $C_0$ = 4.9% C; b) Max: 100% for $C_0$ = 0.76%C; min: 0% for $C_0$ < 0.022%C; d) 1.5% C; $T_1$: $w_\gamma$ = 1, $T_2$: $w_{Fe_3C}$ 0.12, $w_\gamma$ = 0.88; 3% C; $T_1$: $w_\gamma$ = 0.6, $w_L$ = 0.4, $T_2$: $w_{\gamma total}$ = 0.62, $w_{Fe_3C\,Total}$ = 0.38, $w_{Fe_3C\,secondary}$ = 0.20
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. Equilibrium, Fe-Fe₃C diagram [Session 9 Slides 4, 10].
  2. Below 727 °C every alloy is α (0.022) + Fe₃C (6.67); one ferrite fraction gives one composition.
  3. "Steel" = up to 2.14 % C [Session 9 Slide 4].
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the Fe-Fe₃C diagram (wt% C, °C). The lever rule on the α-Fe₃C tie line (a), the short tie line through the eutectoid point (b), the invariant lines (c) and the tie lines at 1148 °C (the statement's temperature, just above the eutectic: 1147 + ΔT) and 727 + ΔT (d) [Session 7 Slides 16, 32].

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Composition (wt% C) Temperature (°C) L γ γ + Fe₃C α + Fe₃C C0 = 4.9 6.67 727 − ΔT
Figure 39. The alloy with 26.7 % α just below 727 °C lies at about 4.9 % C, a hypereutectic cast iron.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation

a) Alloy with $W_\alpha$ = 0.267

$$W_\alpha = \frac{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_0}{C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha} \;\Rightarrow\; C_0 = C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - W_\alpha\,(C_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} - C_\alpha)$$ $$C_0 = 6.67 - 0.267 \times (6.67 - 0.022) = 6.67 - 0.267 \times 6.648 = 6.67 - 1.775 = 4.895 \approx 4.9\ \%\,\text{C}$$

Only one alloy: a hypereutectic cast iron.

b) Pearlite in steels Pearlite is the austenite of 0.76 % C present just above 727 °C.

  • Maximum, 100 %, for the eutectoid steel, $C_0$ = 0.76 % C: all of it is austenite of eutectoid composition.
  • Minimum, 0 %, for $C_0 \le 0.022$ % C: the alloy never crosses the eutectoid line inside the α + γ field (it stays α).
  • Between them, hypoeutectoid: $W_{\text{pearlite}} = (C_0 - 0.022)/(0.76 - 0.022)$; hypereutectoid: $W_{\text{pearlite}} = (6.67 - C_0)/(6.67 - 0.76)$, which at the steel limit (2.14 % C) is $4.53/5.91 = 0.77$.

c) Invariant points and their products on cooling [Session 9 Slide 10]

  • Peritectic, 1493 °C: $\delta\,(0.09) + L\,(0.53) \rightarrow \gamma\,(0.16)$: austenite.
  • Eutectic, 1147 °C: $L\,(4.3) \rightarrow \gamma\,(2.14) + \text{Fe}_3\text{C}$: ledeburite (cast irons).
  • Eutectoid, 727 °C: $\gamma\,(0.76) \rightarrow \alpha\,(0.022) + \text{Fe}_3\text{C}$: pearlite (steels, and the austenite of cast irons).

d) 1.5 % C and 3 % C between 1148 °C and 727 + ΔT 1.5 % C (hypereutectoid steel). At 1148 °C: austenite only, $W_\gamma = 1$. At 727 + ΔT (γ 0.76 / Fe₃C 6.67):

$$W_\gamma = \frac{6.67 - 1.5}{5.91} = 0.875 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C}} = \frac{1.5 - 0.76}{5.91} = 0.125$$

The microconstituents change: proeutectoid cementite appears at $A_{cm}$ and grows to 0.125.

3 % C (hypoeutectic cast iron). At 1148 °C (γ 2.14 / L 4.30): $W_\gamma = 1.30/2.16 = 0.602$, $W_L = 0.398$. At 727 + ΔT (γ 0.76 / Fe₃C 6.67):

$$W_{\gamma,\text{total}} = \frac{6.67 - 3.0}{5.91} = \frac{3.67}{5.91} = 0.621 \qquad W_{\text{Fe}_3\text{C},\text{total}} = \frac{3.0 - 0.76}{5.91} = \frac{2.24}{5.91} = 0.379$$

The microconstituents (primary austenite and ledeburite) change too: the austenite loses carbon and secondary cementite precipitates. The ledeburite brought $0.190$ of cementite at 1146 °C (Problem FC09), so the secondary cementite is $0.379 - 0.190 = 0.189$.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • (a): $(6.67 - 4.895)/6.648 = 0.267$ ✓.
  • (d): 1.5 %: $0.875 \times 0.76 + 0.125 \times 6.67 = 0.665 + 0.834 = 1.50$ % C ✓; 3 %: $0.621 \times 0.76 + 0.379 \times 6.67 = 0.47 + 2.53 = 3.0$ % C ✓.
  • Limiting cases (fractions dimensionless, compositions in wt% C): the pearlite fraction of a hypereutectoid steel, $(6.67 - C_0)/(6.67 - 0.76)$, is 1 at the eutectoid composition and falls to 0 at 6.67 % C; at 1.5 % C it is 0.875.

Check against the official solution

(a), (b) and the 3 % C phases agree with the key (4.9 %; 100 % and 0 %; 0.6/0.4; 0.62/0.38). The key does not answer part (c).

Discrepancy with the official solution

For 1.5 % C the key gives 0.12/0.88 against 0.125/0.875 here (0.13/0.87 when rounded, as in the key of Problem 3 for the same alloy). The key's value follows from 6.7 % C for cementite: $(1.5 - 0.76)/(6.7 - 0.76) = 0.74/5.94 = 0.1246 \to 0.12$. With the slides' 6.67 % C it is $0.74/5.91 = 0.125$, which is kept.

Discrepancy with the official solution

The key gives 0.20 of secondary cementite for the 3 % C alloy. With the values of the diagram, $0.379 - 0.190 = 0.189$ (0.19); the key's 0.20 is not reproduced by any rounding of these data. The computed value is kept.

Sheet II Problem 11 Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf #11 Ternary · reading a composition
Click to Collapse ▲

Composition of a Ternary Alloy

Original statement · Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 3

11.- Determine the composition in wt% of the ternary alloy H marked in the diagram below:

Ternary diagram of problem 11
Figure 41. Ternary diagram with the alloy H (Problems T4_PhaseDiagrams II.pdf, p. 3).
Official Solution: 40% C + 33% A + 30%B
Phase 1 · Hypotheses & Parameters
  1. The diagram is a ternary composition triangle in weight percent: corners A (top), B (bottom left) and C (bottom right); the grid lines are every 10 % [Session 10 Slide 5].
  2. The axes, as labelled on the sheet: "porcentaje en peso de A" on the right side, "de B" on the left side, "de C" on the bottom.
  3. H is drawn on a node of the grid (a reading of the figure).
  4. Unknowns: $w_A$, $w_B$, $w_C$, with $w_A + w_B + w_C = 100$ %.
Phase 2 · Frames & Strategy

Frame: the triangle itself. Each component is read along the lines parallel to the side opposite its corner: constant A is parallel to B-C, constant B parallel to A-C, constant C parallel to A-B [Session 10 Slides 5, 7]. The three readings are independent, so the condition that they add up to 100 % is a check of the reading, not an extra equation.

A B C H 30 % A 30 % B 40 % C
Figure 40. Alloy H of the problem sheet: the lines through H parallel to the sides give 30 % A, 30 % B and 40 % C.
Phase 3 · Step-by-Step Derivation
  1. % A. The horizontal line through H (parallel to B-C) is the third line above the base B-C: it meets the A axis (right side) at 30 % A.
  2. % B. The line through H parallel to the A-C side meets the B axis (left side) at 30 % B.
  3. % C. The line through H parallel to the A-B side meets the C axis (bottom) at 40 % C.

Composition of H: 30 wt% A, 30 wt% B, 40 wt% C.

Phase 4 · Checks & Interpretation
  • Sum: $30 + 30 + 40 = 100$ % ✓.
  • Position check: on the 30 % A line, the remaining 70 % is shared between B and C; H is at $40/70 = 0.57$ of the way from the B side to the C side of that line, which agrees with its place on the drawing.
  • Limits: a point on a side has 0 % of the opposite component; a corner is 100 % of its component.

Check against the official solution

Discrepancy with the official solution

The key gives "40% C + 33% A + 30% B", which adds up to 103 %, so it cannot be right. H lies on the 30 % A line of the grid (the third line above B-C), and with 30 % B and 40 % C the sum is 100 %. The value 33 % A is a typo for 30 %; the reading 30/30/40 is kept.