1st Midterm: Exam-Style Problems

7 exam-style problems on Units 1 to 4 (first- and second-order ODEs, linear systems), worth 5 points each. The first partials of 2019 to 2025 are 2 or 3 problems in 60 to 90 minutes; the Exam simulator draws one ODE problem and one linear-system problem.

1st Midterm · Unit 1 · First-order modelling · 5 points · 30 min · Standard exam level

P01 — Two brine tanks in cascade: separation for the first tank, integrating factor for the second, the equal-rate case and the peak of salt

Two well-stirred tanks are connected in series. Tank A holds $V_A=100$ L of brine containing $20$ kg of dissolved salt; tank B holds $V_B$ litres of fresh water. At $t=0$ three pumps are switched on, all with the same flow rate $r=10$ L/min: fresh water enters A, the mixture of A flows into B, and the mixture of B is drained to the outside. Time is measured in minutes. Let $x(t)$ and $y(t)$ be the masses of salt (kg) in A and in B, and write $k_A=r/V_A$, $k_B=r/V_B$ for the rate constants. Part (c) uses $V_B=100$ L and part (d) uses $V_B=50$ L.

Setup and canonical formulation

Phase 1. Hypotheses and setup

  • Unknowns $x(t)$, $y(t)$ (kg), independent variable $t\ge0$ (min).
  • Hypotheses: perfect mixing (the concentration of the outflow of each tank is its mean concentration), equal inflow and outflow, so the volumes stay constant; salt is conserved (no reaction, no precipitation).
  • Operator: two first-order, linear equations with constant coefficients. The equation for $x$ is homogeneous and decoupled; the equation for $y$ is inhomogeneous, forced by $x$ (a triangular, one-way coupling).
QuantitySymbolValueUnit
Flow rate$r$$10$L/min
Volume of A$V_A$$100$L
Volume of B$V_B$$100$ in (c), $50$ in (d)L
Initial salt in A$x_0$$20$kg
Initial salt in B$y(0)$$0$kg
Rate constants$k_A=r/V_A$, $k_B=r/V_B$$0.1$; $0.1$ or $0.2$min$^{-1}$

Phase 2. Canonical formulation

The balance law (rate of change = rate in $-$ rate out) for each tank, in the linear standard form $y'+p(t)\,y=q(t)$ of Topic 2:

$$x'+k_A\,x=0,\qquad y'+k_B\,y=k_A\,x(t),\qquad x(0)=x_0,\quad y(0)=0.$$

Part (a) · 1 point

Model and dimensions

Write the initial value problem satisfied by $x$ and $y$ and check its dimensions.

Step 1. Tank A

Fresh water carries no salt, so the rate in is $0$. The outflow carries $r$ L/min at concentration $x/V_A$ kg/L:

$$\frac{dx}{dt}=0-r\,\frac{x}{V_A}=-k_A\,x,\qquad k_A=\frac{r}{V_A}.$$

Step 2. Tank B

Its inflow is the outflow of A, with concentration $x/V_A$; its outflow has concentration $y/V_B$:

$$\frac{dy}{dt}=r\,\frac{x}{V_A}-r\,\frac{y}{V_B}=k_A\,x-k_B\,y,\qquad k_B=\frac{r}{V_B}.$$

The initial data are $x(0)=x_0=20$ kg and $y(0)=0$ (fresh water).

Step 3. Dimensions

$[r]=$ L min$^{-1}$, $[V]=$ L, so $[k_A]=[k_B]=$ min$^{-1}$. Then $[k_Ax]=$ min$^{-1}\cdot$kg $=$ kg/min $=[dx/dt]$, and the same for every term of the second equation: both equations are dimensionally homogeneous. The exponents that will appear, $k_At$ and $k_Bt$, are dimensionless.

Numerically $k_A=10/100=0.1$ min$^{-1}$; $k_B=10/100=0.1$ min$^{-1}$ for $V_B=100$ L and $k_B=10/50=0.2$ min$^{-1}$ for $V_B=50$ L.

Key results
  • $x'=-\dfrac{r}{V_A}x$, $\ y'=\dfrac{r}{V_A}x-\dfrac{r}{V_B}y$, $\ x(0)=20$ kg, $y(0)=0$.
  • $k_A=k_B=0.1$ min$^{-1}$ in (c); $k_A=0.1$, $k_B=0.2$ min$^{-1}$ in (d).
  • Every term has units kg/min.

Part (b) · 1.5 points

Solution for different rate constants

Solve for $x(t)$ by separation of variables and, for $k_A\neq k_B$, solve for $y(t)$ with an integrating factor.

Step 1. Tank A by separation

$x\equiv0$ is not the solution ($x_0\neq0$). For $x>0$, separate: $\dfrac{dx}{x}=-k_A\,dt$. Integrate from $0$ to $t$:

$$\int_{x_0}^{x(t)}\frac{d\xi}{\xi}=\big[\ln\xi\big]_{x_0}^{x(t)}=\ln\frac{x(t)}{x_0},\qquad \int_0^t(-k_A)\,ds=-k_A\,t.$$

Hence $\ln(x/x_0)=-k_At$ and

$$x(t)=x_0\,e^{-k_At}.$$

Step 2. Integrating factor for B

Substitute $x(t)$: $y'+k_By=k_Ax_0e^{-k_At}$. With $p=k_B$ the integrating factor (Notes, p. 3) is $\mu(t)=e^{\int_0^tk_B\,ds}=e^{k_Bt}$, with $\mu'=k_B\mu$. By the product rule, $(\mu y)'=\mu y'+\mu'y=e^{k_Bt}(y'+k_By)$, so

$$\frac{d}{dt}\big(e^{k_Bt}y\big)=k_Ax_0\,e^{(k_B-k_A)t}.$$

Step 3. Integration

For $k_B\neq k_A$ an antiderivative of $e^{(k_B-k_A)s}$ is $\dfrac{e^{(k_B-k_A)s}}{k_B-k_A}$. Integrating from $0$ to $t$ and using $y(0)=0$ (Barrow's rule on both sides):

$$e^{k_Bt}y(t)-e^{0}\,y(0)=k_Ax_0\left[\frac{e^{(k_B-k_A)s}}{k_B-k_A}\right]_0^t=\frac{k_Ax_0}{k_B-k_A}\Big(e^{(k_B-k_A)t}-1\Big).$$

Multiplying by $e^{-k_Bt}$:

$$y(t)=\frac{k_A\,x_0}{k_B-k_A}\Big(e^{-k_At}-e^{-k_Bt}\Big).$$

Step 4. Check

$y(0)=\frac{k_Ax_0}{k_B-k_A}(1-1)=0$. Differentiating, $y'=\frac{k_Ax_0}{k_B-k_A}(-k_Ae^{-k_At}+k_Be^{-k_Bt})$ and $k_Ax-k_By=\frac{k_Ax_0}{k_B-k_A}\big[(k_B-k_A)e^{-k_At}-k_Be^{-k_At}+k_Be^{-k_Bt}\big]$, which is the same expression. The quotient $\frac{e^{-k_At}-e^{-k_Bt}}{k_B-k_A}$ does not change when $k_A$ and $k_B$ are exchanged (numerator and denominator both change sign), and it is positive for $t>0$: $y(t)>0$ whichever tank is faster.

Key results
  • $x(t)=x_0\,e^{-k_At}$.
  • $y(t)=\dfrac{k_A\,x_0}{k_B-k_A}\big(e^{-k_At}-e^{-k_Bt}\big)$, $k_A\neq k_B$.

Part (c) · 1.5 points

Equal volumes: the resonant case

Take $V_B=100$ L. Solve the equation for $y$ directly, show that the result is the limit of (b) as $k_B\to k_A$, and find the time and value of the largest amount of salt in B.

Step 1. Direct solution

With $k_A=k_B=k=0.1$ min$^{-1}$, Step 2 of (b) gives $\frac{d}{dt}(e^{kt}y)=kx_0e^{0}=kx_0$. Integrating from $0$ to $t$: $e^{kt}y(t)-y(0)=kx_0\,[s]_0^t=kx_0\,t$, so

$$y(t)=k\,x_0\,t\,e^{-kt}=0.1\cdot20\,t\,e^{-t/10}=2\,t\,e^{-t/10}\ \text{kg}.$$

The forcing $k x_0e^{-kt}$ decays at exactly the rate of the free response $e^{-kt}$ of tank B: the exponential guess fails and a factor $t$ appears, the first-order analogue of resonance.

Step 2. Limit of the general formula

Fix $k_A=k$. In $y=kx_0\,\dfrac{e^{-kt}-e^{-k_Bt}}{k_B-k}$ numerator and denominator vanish at $k_B=k$. By L'Hôpital's rule in the variable $k_B$, with $\frac{\partial}{\partial k_B}e^{-k_Bt}=-t\,e^{-k_Bt}$ (chain rule):

$$\lim_{k_B\to k}\frac{e^{-kt}-e^{-k_Bt}}{k_B-k}=\lim_{k_B\to k}\frac{t\,e^{-k_Bt}}{1}=t\,e^{-kt},$$

so $y\to kx_0\,t\,e^{-kt}$, the result of Step 1. The two cases join continuously.

Step 3. Maximum

By the product rule, $y'(t)=kx_0\big(e^{-kt}+t(-k)e^{-kt}\big)=kx_0\,e^{-kt}(1-kt)$. It is positive for $t<1/k$ and negative for $t>1/k$, so $y$ has its maximum at $t^*=1/k=10$ min:

$$y_{\max}=kx_0\cdot\frac1k\,e^{-1}=\frac{x_0}{e}=\frac{20}{e}\approx7.358\ \text{kg},$$

a concentration of $7.358/100\approx0.0736$ kg/L. At that moment tank A holds $x(10)=20e^{-1}$ kg as well.

Key results
  • $y(t)=k\,x_0\,t\,e^{-kt}=2\,t\,e^{-t/10}$ kg.
  • Maximum at $t^*=1/k=10$ min, $y_{\max}=x_0/e=20/e\approx7.358$ kg (concentration $0.0736$ kg/L).

Part (d) · 1 point

Smaller second tank, peak and long-time behaviour

Take $V_B=50$ L. Find the time and value of the largest amount of salt in B, compare the concentrations of both tanks then, give the limit $t\to\infty$ and the total salt that leaves the system.

Step 1. The formula

$k_A=0.1$, $k_B=0.2$ min$^{-1}$, so $\frac{k_Ax_0}{k_B-k_A}=\frac{0.1\cdot20}{0.1}=20$ kg and $y(t)=20\big(e^{-t/10}-e^{-t/5}\big)$.

Step 2. Maximum

$y'(t)=20\big(-\tfrac1{10}e^{-t/10}+\tfrac15e^{-t/5}\big)$. With $u=e^{-t/10}\in(0,1]$: $y'=20\big(-\tfrac{u}{10}+\tfrac{u^2}{5}\big)=\tfrac{20u}{10}(2u-1)$, which vanishes for $u=\tfrac12$, is positive for $u>\tfrac12$ (early times) and negative after. Hence $e^{-t^*/10}=\tfrac12$, $t^*=10\ln2\approx6.93$ min, and

$$y_{\max}=20\Big(\frac12-\frac14\Big)=5\ \text{kg}.$$

This agrees with the general time $t^*=\dfrac{\ln(k_B/k_A)}{k_B-k_A}=\dfrac{\ln2}{0.1}$.

Step 3. Concentrations at the peak

$x(t^*)=20\cdot\tfrac12=10$ kg, so A has $10/100=0.1$ kg/L and B has $5/50=0.1$ kg/L. This is general: $y'=0$ means $k_Ax=k_By$, i.e. $\frac{x}{V_A}=\frac{y}{V_B}$. Tank B stops gaining salt exactly when its concentration equals that of the brine coming in.

Step 4. Long time and total outflow

Both exponentials tend to $0$, so $x(t)\to0$ and $y(t)\to0$: all salt is washed out. The salt drained from B per minute is $k_By$; with the antiderivatives $-10e^{-t/10}$ and $-5e^{-t/5}$ and Barrow's rule on $[0,T]$, $T\to\infty$:

$$\int_0^\infty0.2\cdot20\big(e^{-t/10}-e^{-t/5}\big)dt=4\Big[-10e^{-t/10}+5e^{-t/5}\Big]_0^\infty=4\big(0-(-10+5)\big)=20\ \text{kg},$$

the whole initial mass $x_0$, as conservation of salt requires.

Key results
  • $y(t)=20\big(e^{-t/10}-e^{-t/5}\big)$ kg.
  • $t^*=10\ln2\approx6.93$ min, $y_{\max}=5$ kg; at $t^*$ both concentrations equal $0.1$ kg/L.
  • $x,y\to0$; total outflow of salt $\int_0^\infty k_By\,dt=20$ kg.

Interpretation and checks

Phase 4. Asymptotic and physical checks

  • Limits: $t\to0^+$: $y\approx k_Ax_0\,t$ (B starts filling at the rate A loses salt, $k_Ax_0=2$ kg/min). $t\to\infty$: $y\sim\frac{k_Ax_0}{k_B-k_A}e^{-k_At}$ when $k_A<k_B$, so the slower tank sets the decay. $V_B\to0$ ($k_B\to\infty$): $y\to0$, B becomes a pipe.
  • Checks: both formulas satisfy the ODEs and $y(0)=0$ by substitution; the equal-rate case is the limit of the general one; $\int_0^\infty k_By\,dt=x_0$. Dimensions: $k\,x_0\,t$ is (min$^{-1}$)(kg)(min) $=$ kg, $t^*=1/k$ and $\ln(k_B/k_A)/(k_B-k_A)$ are in minutes.
  • Common mistakes in the exam: (1) using the volume of B in the inflow term of B (the inflow concentration is $x/V_A$); (2) applying the formula of (b) with $k_A=k_B$, which divides by zero, instead of noticing the factor $t$; (3) dropping the lower limit in the integrating-factor integral, which leaves $y(0)\neq0$; (4) reporting the maximum time without checking the sign of $y'$, or confusing the maximum of mass with the maximum of concentration.
1st Midterm · Unit 2 · First-order qualitative analysis · 5 points · 30 min · Conceptual / fast

P02 — Logistic population with constant harvesting: equilibria against the harvest rate, the critical rate 1/4, extinction times by partial fractions and by an arctangent

A fish population $P(t)$ grows logistically with intrinsic rate $r>0$ and carrying capacity $K>0$ and is fished at a constant rate $H\ge0$ (individuals per unit time), independent of the size of the stock:

$$\frac{dP}{dt}=rP\Big(1-\frac PK\Big)-H.$$

With $p=P/K$, $\tau=rt$ and $h=H/(rK)$ the model becomes, writing again $t$ for $\tau$ and $'$ for $d/dt$,

$$p'=p(1-p)-h,\qquad h\ge0.$$

The model is used only while $p\ge0$; if $p$ reaches $0$ the population is extinct (collapse). Part (c) uses $h=2/9$ and part (d) uses $h=1/2$.

Setup and canonical formulation

Phase 1. Hypotheses and setup

  • Unknown $p(t)\ge0$ (fraction of the carrying capacity), independent variable $t$ (dimensionless time, unit $1/r$); parameter $h\ge0$ (dimensionless harvest).
  • Operator: first order, nonlinear (quadratic in $p$), autonomous ($f$ does not depend on $t$). $f(p)=p(1-p)-h$ is a polynomial, so $f$ and $f'$ are continuous and Picard's theorem gives a unique local solution for every $p(0)$; distinct solutions never cross, and equilibria split the line into invariant intervals.
  • Separable: $\dfrac{dp}{f(p)}=dt$ wherever $f(p)\neq0$.

Phase 2. Canonical formulation

$$p'=f(p),\qquad f(p)=-\big(p^2-p+h\big)=-\Big[\Big(p-\frac12\Big)^2+h-\frac14\Big].$$

The completed square already shows that the sign of $h-\tfrac14$ decides everything.

Part (a) · 1 point

Equilibria and the critical harvesting rate

Find the equilibria as functions of $h$, the critical rate $h_c$ and its meaning.

Step 1. Equilibria

$f(p)=0\iff p^2-p+h=0$, with discriminant $1-4h$:

$$p_\pm=\frac{1\pm\sqrt{1-4h}}{2}\quad(h<\tfrac14),\qquad p=\tfrac12\quad(h=\tfrac14),\qquad \text{none}\quad(h>\tfrac14).$$

For $0\le h<\tfrac14$: $0\le p_-<\tfrac12<p_+\le1$, with $p_-=0$, $p_+=1$ when $h=0$ (the logistic equation). As $h$ grows the two equilibria approach each other, merge at $\tfrac12$ for $h=\tfrac14$ and disappear.

Step 2. Critical rate and meaning

$h_c=\tfrac14$. The natural growth $g(p)=p(1-p)$ has $g'(p)=1-2p=0$ at $p=\tfrac12$, with $g(\tfrac12)=\tfrac14$, its maximum. In original variables $h=H/(rK)$, so

$$H_c=\frac{rK}{4},$$

the largest growth the stock can produce, reached at $P=K/2$. Any constant catch above it exceeds what the population can regenerate at any size (the "maximum sustainable yield"). The merging and disappearance of two equilibria as a parameter crosses a value is called a saddle-node bifurcation (extension: a name beyond the course; the course only needs the phase lines of (b)).

Key results
  • $p_\pm=\dfrac{1\pm\sqrt{1-4h}}{2}$ for $h<\tfrac14$; one equilibrium $p=\tfrac12$ for $h=\tfrac14$; none for $h>\tfrac14$.
  • $h_c=\tfrac14$, i.e. $H_c=\dfrac{rK}{4}$, the maximum natural growth rate (reached at $P=K/2$).

Part (b) · 1.5 points

Phase lines in the three regimes

Describe the phase line and classify the equilibria for $h<h_c$, $h=h_c$, $h>h_c$, and say which initial populations survive.

Step 1. Case $0\le h<\tfrac14$

$f(p)=-(p-p_-)(p-p_+)$: $f<0$ for $p<p_-$, $f>0$ on $(p_-,p_+)$, $f<0$ for $p>p_+$. Phase line (arrows of $p'$):

$$0\ \ \longleftarrow\ \ p_-\ \ \longrightarrow\ \ p_+\ \ \longleftarrow$$

With $f'(p)=1-2p$ (Notes, p. 3, linear stability test):

$$f'(p_\pm)=1-\big(1\pm\sqrt{1-4h}\big)=\mp\sqrt{1-4h},$$

so $f'(p_-)>0$: unstable; $f'(p_+)<0$: asymptotically stable. Populations with $p(0)>p_-$ tend to $p_+$; those with $p(0)<p_-$ decrease and reach $0$ ($p_-$ is a survival threshold). For $h=0$, $p_-=0$ and nothing collapses.

Step 2. Case $h=\tfrac14$

$f(p)=-(p-\tfrac12)^2\le0$, with $f'(\tfrac12)=0$: the linear test is inconclusive and the sign of $f$ decides. $p'<0$ on both sides:

$$\longleftarrow\ \ \tfrac12\ \ \longleftarrow$$

From above, $p$ decreases to $\tfrac12$ (attracting side); from below, $p$ moves away towards $0$ (repelling side). The equilibrium is semi-stable: it is not stable, since an arbitrarily small loss pushes the stock into collapse.

Step 3. Case $h>\tfrac14$

$f(p)=-(p-\tfrac12)^2-(h-\tfrac14)\le-(h-\tfrac14)<0$ for every $p$. There is no equilibrium and every solution decreases at a rate at least $h-\tfrac14$, so from any $p(0)$ it reaches $0$ before the time $p(0)/(h-\tfrac14)$: collapse in finite time for every initial stock.

Key results
  • $h<\tfrac14$: $p_-$ unstable ($f'(p_-)=\sqrt{1-4h}>0$), $p_+$ asymptotically stable ($f'(p_+)=-\sqrt{1-4h}<0$). Survival iff $p(0)\ge p_-$ (with $p(0)=p_-$ the equilibrium itself).
  • $h=\tfrac14$: $p=\tfrac12$ semi-stable ($f=-(p-\tfrac12)^2\le0$): attracts from above, repels below. Survival iff $p(0)\ge\tfrac12$.
  • $h>\tfrac14$: $f\le\tfrac14-h<0$ everywhere, every solution decreases and collapses in finite time.

Part (c) · 1.5 points

Explicit solutions for h = 2/9

Solve with $p(0)=1/2$ and with $p(0)=1/4$; in the second case find the time of collapse.

Step 1. Factorisation and partial fractions

With $h=\tfrac29$: $\sqrt{1-\tfrac89}=\tfrac13$, $p_\pm=\tfrac{1\pm1/3}{2}$, i.e. $p_-=\tfrac13$, $p_+=\tfrac23$, and $f(p)=-(p-\tfrac13)(p-\tfrac23)$. Write

$$\frac{1}{(p-\frac13)(p-\frac23)}=\frac{A}{p-\frac13}+\frac{B}{p-\frac23}\iff1=A\Big(p-\frac23\Big)+B\Big(p-\frac13\Big).$$

At $p=\tfrac13$: $1=-\tfrac13A$, $A=-3$. At $p=\tfrac23$: $1=\tfrac13B$, $B=3$.

Step 2. Separation and integration

For $p\neq\tfrac13,\tfrac23$: $\dfrac{dp}{(p-\frac13)(p-\frac23)}=-dt$. By Step 1, $\displaystyle\int\Big(-\frac{3}{p-\frac13}+\frac{3}{p-\frac23}\Big)dp=-\int dt$. With the antiderivatives $\int\frac{dp}{p-c}=\ln\lvert p-c\rvert$:

$$3\ln\Big\lvert p-\frac23\Big\rvert-3\ln\Big\lvert p-\frac13\Big\rvert=-t+C\ \Longrightarrow\ \ln\left\lvert\frac{p-\frac23}{p-\frac13}\right\rvert=-\frac t3+\frac C3.$$

Exponentiating and absorbing the sign into the constant: $\dfrac{p-\frac23}{p-\frac13}=K\,e^{-t/3}$, with $K=\dfrac{p(0)-\frac23}{p(0)-\frac13}$ from $t=0$. The constant solutions $p\equiv\tfrac13$ and $p\equiv\tfrac23$, lost when dividing by $(p-\tfrac13)(p-\tfrac23)$, correspond to $K=\infty$ and $K=0$.

Step 3. Solving for p

Write $E=Ke^{-t/3}$: $p-\tfrac23=E\,p-\tfrac E3$, so $p(1-E)=\tfrac23-\tfrac E3$ and

$$p(t)=\frac{2-K\,e^{-t/3}}{3\big(1-K\,e^{-t/3}\big)}.$$

Step 4. The two initial data

  • $p(0)=\tfrac12$: $K=\dfrac{-1/6}{1/6}=-1$, $\ p(t)=\dfrac{2+e^{-t/3}}{3(1+e^{-t/3})}$. Check $p(0)=\tfrac36=\tfrac12$. As $t\to\infty$, $e^{-t/3}\to0$ and $p\to\tfrac23=p_+$: the stock recovers to the stable equilibrium, as the phase line predicts.
  • $p(0)=\tfrac14$ (below the threshold $p_-=\tfrac13$): $K=\dfrac{\frac14-\frac23}{\frac14-\frac13}=\dfrac{-5/12}{-1/12}=5$. Multiplying numerator and denominator by $e^{t/3}$:
$$p(t)=\frac{2e^{t/3}-5}{3\big(e^{t/3}-5\big)}.$$

Check $p(0)=\tfrac{-3}{-12}=\tfrac14$. $p=0$ when $2e^{t/3}=5$:

$$T_0=3\ln\frac52\approx2.749.$$

The formula has a pole at $t=3\ln5\approx4.83>T_0$, but the model has already stopped: the population is extinct at $T_0$. In original time, $t_{\text{real}}=T_0/r$.

Key results
  • Equilibria $p_-=\tfrac13$ (unstable), $p_+=\tfrac23$ (stable). General solution $\dfrac{p-\frac23}{p-\frac13}=K\,e^{-t/3}$, $p=\dfrac{2-Ke^{-t/3}}{3(1-Ke^{-t/3})}$.
  • $p(0)=\tfrac12$: $K=-1$, $p(t)=\dfrac{2+e^{-t/3}}{3(1+e^{-t/3})}\to\tfrac23$.
  • $p(0)=\tfrac14$: $K=5$, $p(t)=\dfrac{2e^{t/3}-5}{3(e^{t/3}-5)}$, collapse at $T_0=3\ln\tfrac52\approx2.749$.

Part (d) · 1 point

Collapse time for h = 1/2

Take $h=1/2$ and $p(0)=1$. Find the collapse time $T$ and $p(t)$ on $[0,T]$.

Step 1. Antiderivative

$p'=-\big[(p-\tfrac12)^2+\tfrac14\big]<0$. With $s=2p-1$, $ds=2\,dp$ and $(p-\tfrac12)^2+\tfrac14=\tfrac{s^2+1}{4}$:

$$\int\frac{dp}{(p-\frac12)^2+\frac14}=\int\frac{ds/2}{(s^2+1)/4}=2\int\frac{ds}{1+s^2}=2\arctan s=2\arctan(2p-1).$$

Step 2. Time to collapse

Separating, $dt=-\dfrac{dp}{(p-\frac12)^2+\frac14}$. As $t$ runs from $0$ to $T$, $p$ runs from $1$ down to $0$, so by Barrow's rule

$$T=\int_1^0\frac{-dp}{(p-\frac12)^2+\frac14}=\Big[2\arctan(2p-1)\Big]_0^1=2\arctan1-2\arctan(-1)=2\cdot\frac\pi4+2\cdot\frac\pi4=\pi.$$

The same computation from a general $p(0)$ gives $T=2\arctan(2p(0)-1)-2\arctan(-1)=2\arctan(2p(0)-1)+\tfrac\pi2$; for example $p(0)=\tfrac12$ gives $\tfrac\pi2$.

Step 3. The solution

Integrating from $0$ to $t$: $2\arctan(2p-1)-2\arctan(1)=-t$, so $\arctan(2p-1)=\tfrac\pi4-\tfrac t2$ and

$$p(t)=\frac12+\frac12\tan\Big(\frac\pi4-\frac t2\Big),\qquad0\le t\le\pi.$$

Check: $p(0)=\tfrac12+\tfrac12\tan\tfrac\pi4=1$; $p(\pi)=\tfrac12+\tfrac12\tan(-\tfrac\pi4)=0$. By the chain rule $p'=\tfrac12\sec^2(\tfrac\pi4-\tfrac t2)\cdot(-\tfrac12)=-\tfrac14(1+\tan^2)$, and $-\big[(p-\tfrac12)^2+\tfrac14\big]=-\tfrac14\tan^2-\tfrac14$: the same. In original time the collapse happens at $t_{\text{real}}=\pi/r$.

Key results
  • $\displaystyle T=\int_0^1\frac{dp}{(p-\frac12)^2+\frac14}=\big[2\arctan(2p-1)\big]_0^1=\pi$.
  • $p(t)=\dfrac12+\dfrac12\tan\Big(\dfrac\pi4-\dfrac t2\Big)$, $0\le t\le\pi$.
  • For a general start $p(0)\in[0,1]$: $T=2\arctan(2p(0)-1)+\dfrac\pi2$.

Interpretation and checks

Phase 4. Asymptotic and physical checks

  • Limits: $h=0$ recovers the logistic equation ($p_-=0$, $p_+=1$). For $h>\tfrac14$ and $p(0)=1$, with $\omega=\sqrt{h-\frac14}$ the same arctangent integral gives $T=\frac2\omega\arctan\frac1{2\omega}$ ($=\pi$ for $\omega=\tfrac12$): $T\to\infty$ as $h\to\tfrac14^+$ (the stock lingers near $p=\tfrac12$, where $p'$ is almost zero) and $T\to0$ as $h\to\infty$.
  • Checks: every explicit solution was substituted back into the equation and satisfies its initial value; the solutions agree with the phase lines of (b) (monotone, no crossing of equilibria). Dimensions: $h=H/(rK)$ is (individuals/time)/((1/time)(individuals)), dimensionless; real times are the dimensionless ones divided by $r$.
  • Common mistakes in the exam: (1) applying the linear test $f'(p^*)$ at $h=\tfrac14$, where it gives $0$, and concluding "stable"; (2) forgetting that below $p_-$ the population collapses even for small harvesting; (3) reading the pole of the formula of (c) as the time of extinction instead of the first zero of $p$; (4) losing the factor $2$ from $ds=2\,dp$ in the arctangent integral.
1st Midterm · Unit 3 · Reduction of order · 5 points · 30 min · Standard exam level

P03 — A variable-coefficient equation with the solution x: reduction of order to x e^x, Abel's identity against the direct Wronskian, variation of parameters for the forcing x^4 and an IVP

Consider, for $x>0$, the equation

$$x^2y''-x(x+2)\,y'+(x+2)\,y=g_0(x).$$

The homogeneous equation ($g_0=0$) has a solution that is a polynomial of degree one. In parts (c) and (d) the right-hand side is $g_0(x)=x^4$, and the initial data of (d) are

$$y(1)=\frac12,\qquad y'(1)=-\frac12.$$

Setup and canonical formulation

Phase 1. Hypotheses and setup

  • Unknown $y(x)$, independent variable $x$ on the interval $(0,\infty)$.
  • Operator: second order, linear, with variable coefficients; homogeneous in (a) and (b), inhomogeneous in (c) and (d).
  • The leading coefficient $x^2$ vanishes at $x=0$: $x=0$ is a singular point, so all statements are made on $x>0$, where the coefficients of the standard form are continuous and the existence and uniqueness theorem holds (Topic 3, Concept - Existence and Uniqueness Theorem for Second-Order ODEs).

Phase 2. Canonical formulation

Dividing by $x^2\neq0$, with $\frac{x+2}{x^2}=\frac1x+\frac2{x^2}$, the standard form $y''+p(x)y'+q(x)y=g(x)$ is

$$y''-\Big(1+\frac2x\Big)y'+\Big(\frac1x+\frac2{x^2}\Big)y=\frac{g_0(x)}{x^2},\qquad p(x)=-\Big(1+\frac2x\Big),\quad g(x)=x^2\ \text{for}\ g_0=x^4.$$

Part (a) · 1.5 points

First solution and reduction of order

Find the polynomial solution $y_1$ of degree one and, with $y=v\,y_1$, a second solution $y_2$ linearly independent of $y_1$.

Step 1. Polynomial solution

With $y=\alpha x+\beta$: $y'=\alpha$, $y''=0$, and

$$-x(x+2)\alpha+(x+2)(\alpha x+\beta)=(x+2)\big(-\alpha x+\alpha x+\beta\big)=\beta\,(x+2).$$

This vanishes for all $x$ only if $\beta=0$. So $y_1=x$ (taking $\alpha=1$).

Step 2. Substitution y = v x

By the product rule, $y=vx$ gives $y'=v'x+v$ and $y''=v''x+v'+v'=v''x+2v'$. Substituting:

$$x^2\big(xv''+2v'\big)-x(x+2)\big(xv'+v\big)+(x+2)\,xv.$$

Expanding term by term: $x^3v''+2x^2v'-(x^3+2x^2)v'-(x^2+2x)v+(x^2+2x)v=x^3v''-x^3v'$. The terms in $v$ cancel because $y_1$ solves the equation, as they must. Hence

$$x^3\big(v''-v'\big)=0\iff v''=v'\qquad(x>0).$$

Step 3. First-order equation for w = v'

$w'=w$ is separable: $\frac{dw}{w}=dx$, $\ln\lvert w\rvert=x+C_1$, $w=Ce^x$. Integrating once more, $v=\int Ce^x\,dx=Ce^x+D$. Then $y=vx=C\,x\,e^x+D\,x$. The part $Dx$ is the old solution; the new one is

$$y_2=x\,e^x.$$

Check: $y_2'=(1+x)e^x$, $y_2''=(2+x)e^x$; $x^2(2+x)-x(x+2)(1+x)+(x+2)x=x(x+2)\big[x-(1+x)+1\big]=0$, times $e^x$.

Key results
  • $y_1=x$.
  • $y=v\,x$ gives $x^3(v''-v')=0$, so $v'=Ce^x$ and $y_2=x\,e^x$.
  • General homogeneous solution $y_h=c_1x+c_2\,x\,e^x$.

Part (b) · 1 point

Wronskian by Abel's identity and directly

Compute the Wronskian of $\{y_1,y_2\}$ from Abel's identity and from the determinant, and conclude that they form a fundamental set on $x>0$.

Step 1. Abel's identity

With $p=-(1+\frac2x)$, $W'=-pW=\big(1+\frac2x\big)W$. Separating, $\frac{dW}{W}=\big(1+\frac2x\big)dx$, and with the antiderivative $x+2\ln x$ ($x>0$):

$$\ln\lvert W\rvert=x+2\ln x+C_1\ \Longrightarrow\ W(x)=C\,x^2e^x.$$

Step 2. Direct determinant

$$W=\det\begin{pmatrix}y_1&y_2\\y_1'&y_2'\end{pmatrix}=\det\begin{pmatrix}x&x\,e^x\\1&(1+x)e^x\end{pmatrix}=x(1+x)e^x-x\,e^x\cdot1=x^2e^x.$$

The two results agree with $C=1$.

Step 3. Conclusion

$x^2e^x>0$ for $x>0$, so $y_1$, $y_2$ are linearly independent there and $y_h=c_1x+c_2xe^x$ is the general solution of the homogeneous equation (Robinson Ch. 11). The dichotomy "either $W\equiv0$ or $W$ never vanishes" applies on intervals where $p$ is continuous; $W(0)=0$ happens at the singular point $x=0$ and is no contradiction.

Key results
  • Abel: $W=C\,x^2e^x$.
  • Determinant: $W=x(1+x)e^x-x\,e^x=x^2e^x$, so $C=1$.
  • $W\neq0$ on $(0,\infty)$: fundamental set; $W(0)=0$ only at the singular point.

Part (c) · 1.5 points

Variation of parameters for the forcing x^4

With $g_0(x)=x^4$, find a particular solution by variation of parameters and write the general solution.

Step 1. Formula

For $y''+py'+qy=g$ with fundamental set $\{y_1,y_2\}$ (Robinson Eq. 18.8, Notes, p. 8):

$$y_p=-y_1\int\frac{y_2\,g}{W}\,dx+y_2\int\frac{y_1\,g}{W}\,dx,\qquad g=\frac{x^4}{x^2}=x^2.$$

Step 2. The two integrands

$$\frac{y_2\,g}{W}=\frac{x\,e^x\cdot x^2}{x^2e^x}=x,\qquad \frac{y_1\,g}{W}=\frac{x\cdot x^2}{x^2e^x}=x\,e^{-x}.$$

Step 3. The integrals

$\int x\,dx=\frac{x^2}2$. For the second, integrate by parts with $u=x$, $dv=e^{-x}dx$, so $du=dx$, $v=-e^{-x}$:

$$\int x\,e^{-x}dx=-x\,e^{-x}-\int(-e^{-x})\,dx=-x\,e^{-x}-e^{-x}=-(x+1)e^{-x}.$$

(Integration constants are omitted: they only add multiples of $y_1$ and $y_2$.)

Step 4. Particular and general solution

$$y_p=-x\cdot\frac{x^2}2+x\,e^x\cdot\big(-(x+1)e^{-x}\big)=-\frac{x^3}2-x^2-x.$$

The term $-x$ is a multiple of $y_1$ and can be absorbed: $y_p=-\dfrac{x^3}2-x^2$. Check, with $y_p'=-\frac32x^2-2x$, $y_p''=-3x-2$:

$$x^2(-3x-2)-x(x+2)\Big(-\frac32x^2-2x\Big)+(x+2)\Big(-\frac{x^3}2-x^2\Big)$$

The products are $x(x+2)\big(\tfrac32x^2+2x\big)=\tfrac32x^4+2x^3+3x^3+4x^2=\tfrac32x^4+5x^3+4x^2$ and $(x+2)\big(-\tfrac{x^3}2-x^2\big)=-\tfrac12x^4-x^3-x^3-2x^2=-\tfrac12x^4-2x^3-2x^2$, so

$$=\big(-3x^3-2x^2\big)+\Big(\frac32x^4+5x^3+4x^2\Big)+\Big(-\frac12x^4-2x^3-2x^2\Big)=x^4.\ \checkmark$$

The general solution is $y=c_1x+c_2\,x\,e^x-\dfrac{x^3}2-x^2$.

Key results
  • $\displaystyle\int\frac{y_2\,g}{W}dx=\int x\,dx=\frac{x^2}2$, $\ \displaystyle\int\frac{y_1\,g}{W}dx=\int x\,e^{-x}dx=-(x+1)e^{-x}$.
  • $y_p=-\dfrac{x^3}2-x^2$ (after dropping the multiple $-x$ of $y_1$).
  • $y=c_1x+c_2xe^x-\dfrac{x^3}2-x^2$.

Part (d) · 1 point

Initial value problem

Solve the IVP with $y(1)=\frac12$, $y'(1)=-\frac12$ and give the largest interval on which the solution is guaranteed to exist and be unique.

Step 1. Conditions

$y(1)=c_1+c_2e-\frac12-1=\frac12\Rightarrow c_1+e\,c_2=2$. $\ y'(1)=c_1+2e\,c_2-\frac32-2=-\frac12\Rightarrow c_1+2e\,c_2=3$.

Step 2. Constants

Subtracting the first equation from the second: $e\,c_2=1$, $c_2=e^{-1}$; then $c_1=2-1=1$. The system is uniquely solvable because its matrix is $\begin{pmatrix}y_1(1)&y_2(1)\\y_1'(1)&y_2'(1)\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}1&e\\1&2e\end{pmatrix}$, whose determinant $2e-e=e$ is exactly $W(1)\neq0$.

$$y(x)=x+x\,e^{x-1}-\frac{x^3}2-x^2.$$

Step 3. Interval

$p$, $q$ and $g$ of the standard form are continuous on $(0,\infty)$, which contains $x_0=1$; the existence and uniqueness theorem gives a unique solution on the whole of $(0,\infty)$. Nothing is guaranteed at or across $x=0$.

Key results
  • $c_1+e\,c_2=2$ and $c_1+2e\,c_2=3$, so $c_2=e^{-1}$, $c_1=1$.
  • $y(x)=x+x\,e^{x-1}-\dfrac{x^3}2-x^2$ on $(0,\infty)$.

Interpretation and checks

Phase 4. Asymptotic and physical checks

  • Limits: as $x\to\infty$ the term $x\,e^{x-1}$ dominates and $y\to+\infty$; as $x\to0^+$, $y\to0$ and $y'(0^+)=1+e^{-1}$ (finite, though the theorem does not cover $x=0$).
  • Checks: $y_1$, $y_2$ and $y_p$ were substituted back; Abel's $W$ and the determinant agree; $y(1)=1+1-\frac12-1=\frac12$ and $y'(1)=1+2-\frac32-2=-\frac12$.
  • Common mistakes in the exam: (1) applying variation of parameters to $x^4$ without dividing by the leading coefficient $x^2$; (2) taking $p=-(x+2)$ instead of $-(x+2)/x$ in Abel's identity; (3) a sign slip in $\int xe^{-x}dx$; (4) keeping $-x$ in $y_p$ and still reporting $c_1=1$: with $y_p=-\frac{x^3}2-x^2-x$ the IVP gives $c_1=2$, and the solution $y(x)$ is the same.
1st Midterm · Unit 3 · Constant coefficients, Cauchy-Euler and forcing · 5 points · 30 min · High difficulty / trap

P04 — Inverse problem: rebuild y'' + a y' + b y = f from one homogeneous solution and one particular solution, then the resonant forcing e^{-x} sin 2x, an IVP and which forcings need the modified guess

The real constants $a$, $b$ of the equation

$$y''+a\,y'+b\,y=f(x)$$

are unknown. Two facts are known about it:

  • the function $y=e^{-x}\cos2x$ solves the homogeneous equation ($f=0$);
  • when the right-hand side is $f(x)=k\,x$, for a certain constant $k$, the polynomial $y=5x-2$ is a solution.

Afterwards the equation is driven by $f(x)=8\,e^{-x}\sin2x$, with initial data $y(0)=1$, $y'(0)=-3$. Finally, consider forcings of the form $f(x)=e^{\alpha x}\cos\omega x$ or $e^{\alpha x}\sin\omega x$ with real $\alpha$ and $\omega\ge0$, and in particular the purely oscillatory forcing $f(x)=\cos\omega x$.

Setup and canonical formulation

Phase 1. Hypotheses and setup

  • Unknowns: first the parameters $a$, $b$, $k$ (inverse problem), then the function $y(x)$, $x\in\mathbb R$.
  • Operator: second order, linear, constant coefficients, $L[y]=y''+ay'+by$. Coefficients and forcings are continuous on $\mathbb R$, so every IVP has a unique solution on all of $\mathbb R$.
  • Superposition: $y=y_h+y_p$, with $y_h$ from the characteristic equation $r^2+ar+b=0$ and $y_p$ from undetermined coefficients.

Phase 2. Canonical formulation

The equation is already in standard form. Writing $y=e^{-x}u$ (an exponential shift, extension: not in the course, it only organises the computation of (b)) turns $L$ into an operator on $u$ that will expose the resonance.

Part (a) · 1.5 points

Reconstruction of the equation

Find $a$, $b$ and $k$, and write the general solution of the homogeneous equation.

Step 1. Derivatives of the given solution

Product and chain rule on $y=e^{-x}\cos2x$:

$$y'=-e^{-x}\cos2x-2e^{-x}\sin2x=e^{-x}\big(-\cos2x-2\sin2x\big),$$
$$y''=-e^{-x}\big(-\cos2x-2\sin2x\big)+e^{-x}\big(2\sin2x-4\cos2x\big)=e^{-x}\big(-3\cos2x+4\sin2x\big).$$

Step 2. Conditions on a and b

$$L[y]=e^{-x}\Big[\big(-3-a+b\big)\cos2x+\big(4-2a\big)\sin2x\Big]=0\quad\forall x.$$

$e^{-x}\neq0$ and $\cos2x$, $\sin2x$ are linearly independent, so both brackets vanish: $4-2a=0\Rightarrow a=2$, and $-3-2+b=0\Rightarrow b=5$.

Cross-check: $e^{-x}\cos2x=\operatorname{Re}e^{(-1+2i)x}$ requires the root $r=-1+2i$; real coefficients give also $-1-2i$, so $r^2+ar+b=(r+1-2i)(r+1+2i)=(r+1)^2+4=r^2+2r+5$.

Step 3. The constant k

$y=5x-2$: $y'=5$, $y''=0$, so $L[y]=0+2\cdot5+5(5x-2)=25x$. Hence $k=25$. Undetermined coefficients give the same: with $y_p=Ax+B$, $L[y_p]=2A+5Ax+5B=25x$, so $5A=25$, $A=5$, and $2A+5B=0$, $B=-2$. The second fact is consistent with $a=2$, $b=5$ (it imposes $5a=2b$ through the constant term, which they satisfy).

Step 4. Homogeneous solution

$r^2+2r+5=0$: $r=\dfrac{-2\pm\sqrt{4-20}}{2}=-1\pm2i$ (Robinson Ch. 12), so

$$y_h=e^{-x}\big(c_1\cos2x+c_2\sin2x\big).$$
Key results
  • $a=2$, $b=5$; characteristic roots $r=-1\pm2i$.
  • $k=25$; $y_p=5x-2$ is recovered by the guess $Ax+B$.
  • $y_h=e^{-x}\big(c_1\cos2x+c_2\sin2x\big)$.

Part (b) · 1.5 points

Resonant forcing and the modified guess

For $f(x)=8\,e^{-x}\sin2x$ explain why the usual guess fails and find a particular solution.

Step 1. Why the usual guess fails

The forcing is $\operatorname{Im}\big(8e^{(-1+2i)x}\big)$ and $-1+2i$ is a simple root of $r^2+2r+5$. The guess $e^{-x}(A\cos2x+B\sin2x)$ lies in $y_h$, so $L$ of it is $0$ for every $A$, $B$, never $8e^{-x}\sin2x$. The rule (Robinson 14.5) multiplies the guess by $x$ (once, because the root is simple).

Step 2. Exponential shift

Let $y=e^{-x}u$. By the product rule, $y'=e^{-x}(u'-u)$ and $y''=-e^{-x}(u'-u)+e^{-x}(u''-u')=e^{-x}(u''-2u'+u)$. Then

$$L[y]=e^{-x}\Big[(u''-2u'+u)+2(u'-u)+5u\Big]=e^{-x}\big(u''+4u\big).$$

So $L[y]=8e^{-x}\sin2x$ becomes $u''+4u=8\sin2x$: an undamped oscillator forced exactly at its natural frequency $2$.

Step 3. Coefficients

With $u=x(A\cos2x+B\sin2x)$:

$$u'=(A\cos2x+B\sin2x)+x(-2A\sin2x+2B\cos2x),$$
$$u''=2(-2A\sin2x+2B\cos2x)+x(-4A\cos2x-4B\sin2x).$$

The terms with $x$ cancel against $4u$: $x(-4A\cos2x-4B\sin2x)+4x(A\cos2x+B\sin2x)=0$, so $u''+4u=4B\cos2x-4A\sin2x$. Matching with $8\sin2x$: $4B=0$ and $-4A=8$, so $A=-2$, $B=0$:

$$y_p=-2x\,e^{-x}\cos2x.$$
Key results
  • $e^{-x}(A\cos2x+B\sin2x)$ is a homogeneous solution: $L$ annihilates it.
  • Modified guess $y_p=x\,e^{-x}(A\cos2x+B\sin2x)$; $L[y_p]=e^{-x}\big(4B\cos2x-4A\sin2x\big)$.
  • $A=-2$, $B=0$: $y_p=-2x\,e^{-x}\cos2x$.

Part (c) · 1 point

Initial value problem

Solve the IVP with $f(x)=8e^{-x}\sin2x$, $y(0)=1$, $y'(0)=-3$, and describe its behaviour as $x\to\infty$.

Step 1. General solution and its derivative

$y=e^{-x}(c_1\cos2x+c_2\sin2x)-2xe^{-x}\cos2x$. Differentiating with the product rule and evaluating at $x=0$ ($\cos0=1$, $\sin0=0$):

$$\frac{d}{dx}\Big[e^{-x}(c_1\cos2x+c_2\sin2x)\Big]_{x=0}=-c_1+2c_2,\qquad \frac{d}{dx}\Big[-2xe^{-x}\cos2x\Big]_{x=0}=-2e^{0}\cos0=-2.$$

Step 2. Constants

$y(0)=c_1=1$; $y'(0)=-c_1+2c_2-2=-3\Rightarrow2c_2=0$, $c_2=0$:

$$y(x)=(1-2x)\,e^{-x}\cos2x.$$

Step 3. Long-time behaviour

$\lvert y\rvert\le\lvert1-2x\rvert e^{-x}\to0$, because $e^{-x}$ beats any polynomial. Here "resonance" does not mean unbounded growth: the factor $x$ only slows the decay, since the damping ($a=2>0$) sets the envelope $e^{-x}$.

Key results
  • $y'(0)=-c_1+2c_2-2$; $c_1=1$, $c_2=0$.
  • $y(x)=(1-2x)\,e^{-x}\cos2x\to0$ as $x\to\infty$.

Part (d) · 1 point

Which forcings need the modified guess

For $f=e^{\alpha x}\cos\omega x$ or $e^{\alpha x}\sin\omega x$, when is the modified guess needed? For $f=\cos\omega x$, find the amplitude of the particular solution as a function of $\omega$ and the frequency that maximises it.

Step 1. The rule

The guess $e^{\alpha x}(A\cos\omega x+B\sin\omega x)$ fails only when it solves the homogeneous equation, i.e. when $\alpha+i\omega\in\{-1+2i,-1-2i\}$: $\alpha=-1$ and $\omega=2$. For a polynomial or $e^{\alpha x}$ ($\omega=0$) the guess would need a real root, and there is none. For $\cos\omega x$ ($\alpha=0$) the real part $0$ never equals $-1$: no frequency of a purely oscillatory forcing needs the modified guess.

Step 2. Coefficients for cos(omega x)

$y_p'=-A\omega\sin\omega x+B\omega\cos\omega x$, $y_p''=-\omega^2y_p$. Then

$$L[y_p]=\big[(5-\omega^2)A+2\omega B\big]\cos\omega x+\big[(5-\omega^2)B-2\omega A\big]\sin\omega x=\cos\omega x.$$

From the second bracket $B=\frac{2\omega}{5-\omega^2}A$ (for $\omega^2\neq5$); substituting into the first, $A\,\frac{(5-\omega^2)^2+4\omega^2}{5-\omega^2}=1$. Hence $A=\frac{5-\omega^2}{D}$, $B=\frac{2\omega}{D}$ with $D=(5-\omega^2)^2+4\omega^2$ (the same formulas hold at $\omega^2=5$, solving directly).

Step 3. Amplitude and its maximum

$R=\sqrt{A^2+B^2}=\dfrac{\sqrt{(5-\omega^2)^2+4\omega^2}}{D}=\dfrac1{\sqrt D}$. Expanding, $D=\omega^4-10\omega^2+25+4\omega^2=\omega^4-6\omega^2+25=(\omega^2-3)^2+16\ge16$. $D$ is smallest, and $R$ largest, at $\omega^2=3$:

$$\omega=\sqrt3,\qquad R_{\max}=\frac1{\sqrt{16}}=\frac14.$$

This "practical resonance" is a finite peak, not a failure of the guess: it is the damped counterpart of the undamped resonance, and it sits below the frequency $2$ of the free oscillation.

Key results
  • Modified guess only for $\alpha=-1$, $\omega=2$. Never for $\cos\omega x$ ($\alpha=0$), for polynomials or for real exponentials.
  • $A=\dfrac{5-\omega^2}{D}$, $B=\dfrac{2\omega}{D}$, $D=(5-\omega^2)^2+4\omega^2=(\omega^2-3)^2+16$; amplitude $R(\omega)=\dfrac1{\sqrt D}$.
  • Maximum at $\omega=\sqrt3$, with $R_{\max}=\dfrac14$.

Interpretation and checks

Phase 4. Asymptotic and physical checks

  • Limits: as $x\to\infty$ every solution of the homogeneous equation decays like $e^{-x}$, so the long-time response to $\cos\omega x$ is $y_p$ alone; $R(0)=\frac15$ (static response $1/b$) and $R(\omega)\sim\omega^{-2}$ as $\omega\to\infty$.
  • Checks: $L[e^{-x}\cos2x]=0$, $L[5x-2]=25x$, $L[-2xe^{-x}\cos2x]=8e^{-x}\sin2x$ and the IVP were verified by substitution. With zero damping and forcing at the natural frequency (for example $y''+4y=8\sin2x$) the factor $x$ would grow without bound (true resonance); here $a=2$ gives the envelope $e^{-x}$, so $xe^{-x}\to0$.
  • Common mistakes in the exam: (1) deducing only $b$ from the homogeneous solution and forgetting that the $\sin2x$ coefficient fixes $a$; (2) trying $e^{-x}(A\cos2x+B\sin2x)$ for the resonant forcing and getting $0=8$; (3) calling $\omega=2$ or $\omega=\sqrt3$ resonant for $\cos\omega x$: the guess never needs modifying there; (4) losing the term $-2$ from $\frac{d}{dx}(-2xe^{-x}\cos2x)$ at $x=0$.
1st Midterm · Unit 4 · Linear systems and phase portraits · 5 points · 30 min · Standard exam level

P05 — The system x' = A(a) x with A = (-4, a; 1, 0): type of the origin for every a, the stable node a = -3 with P, P^{-1}, P^{-1}AP, and the stable focus a = -8 in real form with its sense of rotation

For a real parameter $a$ consider the planar system

$$\dot{\mathbf x}=A(a)\,\mathbf x,\qquad A(a)=\begin{pmatrix}-4&a\\1&0\end{pmatrix},\qquad \mathbf x=\begin{pmatrix}x_1\\x_2\end{pmatrix}.$$

The type of the origin changes with $a$. Afterwards two values are studied in detail: $a=-3$, with initial condition $\mathbf x(0)=(1,1)^T$, and $a=-8$, with initial condition $\mathbf x(0)=(0,1)^T$.

Setup and canonical formulation

Phase 1. Hypotheses and setup

  • Unknown $\mathbf x(t)\in\mathbb R^2$, $t\in\mathbb R$; parameter $a\in\mathbb R$.
  • Operator: first-order, linear, homogeneous, constant coefficients: solutions exist for all $t$, are unique, and $\mathbf x\equiv\mathbf0$ is always an equilibrium. It is the only one when $\det A\neq0$.
  • The type of $\mathbf 0$ is read from $\tau=\operatorname{tr}A$, $\delta=\det A$ and $\Delta=\tau^2-4\delta$ (extension: the $(\tau,\delta,\Delta)$ table is derived from $\lambda^2-\tau\lambda+\delta=0$; Robinson Ch. 31 lists the cases by type of eigenvalue).

Phase 2. Canonical formulation

$\tau=-4+0=-4$ for every $a$, $\ \delta=(-4)(0)-a\cdot1=-a$, $\ \Delta=16+4a$. With an invertible matrix $P$ of (generalised) eigenvectors, $\mathbf x=P\mathbf z$ turns the system into $\dot{\mathbf z}=(P^{-1}AP)\,\mathbf z$ with $P^{-1}AP$ diagonal, a Jordan block, or the rotation-dilation block $\begin{pmatrix}\rho&\omega\\-\omega&\rho\end{pmatrix}$.

Part (a) · 1.5 points

Classification for all a

Classify the origin for every real $a$ (table with trace, determinant and discriminant) and describe the borderline cases.

Step 1. Characteristic polynomial

$$\det(A-\lambda I)=\det\begin{pmatrix}-4-\lambda&a\\1&-\lambda\end{pmatrix}=(-4-\lambda)(-\lambda)-a=\lambda^2+4\lambda-a,$$
$$\lambda_\pm=\frac{-4\pm\sqrt{16+4a}}{2}=-2\pm\sqrt{4+a}.$$

Step 2. Table

Range of $a$$\tau$$\delta=-a$$\Delta=16+4a$EigenvaluesOrigin
$a>0$$-4$$<0$$>16$real, opposite signssaddle (unstable)
$a=0$$-4$$0$$16$$0$ and $-4$line of equilibria $x_1=0$
$-4<a<0$$-4$$>0$$0<\Delta<16$real, both negativestable node
$a=-4$$-4$$4$$0$$-2$ doubleimproper stable node
$a<-4$$-4$$>4$$<0$$-2\pm i\sqrt{-4-a}$stable focus

For $-4<a<0$: $0<\sqrt{4+a}<2$, so both $-2\pm\sqrt{4+a}$ are negative. For $a>0$: $\sqrt{4+a}>2$, so $\lambda_+>0>\lambda_-$.

Step 3. Borderline values

  • $a=0$: $A\mathbf x=\mathbf0$ means $-4x_1=0$ and $x_1=0$, so every point of the $x_2$-axis is an equilibrium (eigenvalue $0$, eigenvector $(0,1)^T$). For $\lambda=-4$, $(A+4I)\mathbf v=\mathbf0$ has rows $(0,0)$ and $(1,4)$: $v_1+4v_2=0$, $\mathbf v=(-4,1)^T$. Every other orbit is a half-line parallel to $(-4,1)^T$ that ends on the $x_2$-axis as $t\to\infty$.
  • $a=-4$: $A+2I=\begin{pmatrix}-2&-4\\1&2\end{pmatrix}\neq0$; its second row gives $v_1+2v_2=0$, a single eigenvector line through $(-2,1)^T$. The origin is an improper stable node: all orbits approach it tangent to that line.
  • $a<-4$: $\rho=-2$, $\omega=\sqrt{-4-a}$. Sense of rotation from the test vector $(1,0)^T$: $A(1,0)^T=(-4,1)^T$, whose second component is positive on the positive $x_1$-axis, so orbits turn anticlockwise (equivalently $a_{12}=a<0$).

Since $\tau=-4\neq0$ there is never a centre, and since $\tau<0$ there is never an unstable node or focus: the only unstable case is the saddle.

Key results
  • $\lambda^2+4\lambda-a=0$, $\lambda=-2\pm\sqrt{4+a}$.
  • $a>0$ saddle; $a=0$ line of equilibria $x_1=0$; $-4<a<0$ stable node; $a=-4$ improper stable node, single eigenvector $(-2,1)^T$; $a<-4$ stable focus, anticlockwise.
  • Never a centre and never unstable apart from the saddle.

Part (b) · 1.5 points

The stable node a = -3

For $a=-3$ find eigenvalues and eigenvectors, build $P$, $P^{-1}$, check $P^{-1}AP$, write the general solution, solve with $\mathbf x(0)=(1,1)^T$ and describe the phase portrait.

Step 1. Eigenvectors

$A=\begin{pmatrix}-4&-3\\1&0\end{pmatrix}$, $\lambda^2+4\lambda+3=(\lambda+1)(\lambda+3)$.

  • $\lambda_1=-1$: $A+I=\begin{pmatrix}-3&-3\\1&1\end{pmatrix}$. Row 1: $-3v_1-3v_2=0$; row 2: $v_1+v_2=0$ (the same line). $\mathbf v_1=(1,-1)^T$.
  • $\lambda_2=-3$: $A+3I=\begin{pmatrix}-1&-3\\1&3\end{pmatrix}$. Row 1: $-v_1-3v_2=0$; row 2: $v_1+3v_2=0$. $\mathbf v_2=(3,-1)^T$.

Step 2. Change of basis

$$P=\begin{pmatrix}1&3\\-1&-1\end{pmatrix},\qquad \det P=(1)(-1)-(3)(-1)=2,\qquad P^{-1}=\frac12\begin{pmatrix}-1&-3\\1&1\end{pmatrix}.$$

Column by column, $AP=[A\mathbf v_1\mid A\mathbf v_2]$ with $A\mathbf v_1=(-4+3,\ 1)^T=(-1,1)^T=-\mathbf v_1$ and $A\mathbf v_2=(-12+3,\ 3)^T=(-9,3)^T=-3\mathbf v_2$:

$$AP=\begin{pmatrix}-1&-9\\1&3\end{pmatrix},\qquad P^{-1}AP=\frac12\begin{pmatrix}(-1)(-1)+(-3)(1)&(-1)(-9)+(-3)(3)\\(1)(-1)+(1)(1)&(1)(-9)+(1)(3)\end{pmatrix}=\frac12\begin{pmatrix}-2&0\\0&-6\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}-1&0\\0&-3\end{pmatrix}.$$

Step 3. Solution

In $\mathbf z=P^{-1}\mathbf x$: $\dot z_1=-z_1$, $\dot z_2=-3z_2$, so $z_1=c_1e^{-t}$, $z_2=c_2e^{-3t}$ (each separable: $\frac{dz_i}{z_i}=\lambda_i\,dt$). Back with $\mathbf x=P\mathbf z$:

$$\mathbf x(t)=c_1e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}1\\-1\end{pmatrix}+c_2e^{-3t}\begin{pmatrix}3\\-1\end{pmatrix}.$$

For $\mathbf x(0)=(1,1)^T$: $(c_1,c_2)^T=P^{-1}(1,1)^T=\frac12(-1-3,\ 1+1)^T=(-2,1)^T$, so

$$\mathbf x(t)=\begin{pmatrix}-2e^{-t}+3e^{-3t}\\2e^{-t}-e^{-3t}\end{pmatrix},\qquad \mathbf x(0)=\begin{pmatrix}1\\1\end{pmatrix}.$$

Step 4. Phase portrait in words

Both eigenvalues are negative: stable node. The eigenlines through $(1,-1)^T$ and $(3,-1)^T$ are invariant, with arrows towards the origin. In the $\mathbf z$-plane the orbits are $z_2=K\lvert z_1\rvert^{3}$ (exponent $\lambda_2/\lambda_1=3$), tangent to the $z_1$-axis at the origin. Back in $\mathbf x$: every orbit not on the fast line enters the origin tangent to the slow eigenvector $\mathbf v_1=(1,-1)^T$ ($\lvert\lambda_1\rvert=1$), and far from the origin ($t\to-\infty$) it is parallel to the fast one $\mathbf v_2=(3,-1)^T$. The orbit of the IVP behaves like $-2e^{-t}\mathbf v_1=e^{-t}(-2,2)^T$ for large $t$: it enters from the second quadrant along $x_2=-x_1$. Nullclines: $\dot x_1=0$ on $x_2=-\frac43x_1$, $\dot x_2=0$ on $x_1=0$ (there the motion is horizontal, $\dot x_1=-3x_2$).

Key results
  • $\lambda_1=-1$, $\mathbf v_1=(1,-1)^T$; $\lambda_2=-3$, $\mathbf v_2=(3,-1)^T$.
  • $P=\begin{pmatrix}1&3\\-1&-1\end{pmatrix}$, $\det P=2$, $P^{-1}=\frac12\begin{pmatrix}-1&-3\\1&1\end{pmatrix}$, $P^{-1}AP=\operatorname{diag}(-1,-3)$.
  • $\mathbf x(t)=\big(-2e^{-t}+3e^{-3t},\ 2e^{-t}-e^{-3t}\big)^T$; stable node, tangent to $\mathbf v_1$ at the origin.

Part (c) · 2 points

The stable focus a = -8

For $a=-8$ find the complex eigenvalues and an eigenvector $\mathbf v=\mathbf u+i\mathbf w$, build $Q=[\mathbf u\mid\mathbf w]$, $Q^{-1}$ and check $Q^{-1}AQ$; write the real general solution, solve with $\mathbf x(0)=(0,1)^T$ and find the sense of rotation.

Step 1. Eigenvalues and eigenvector

$\lambda^2+4\lambda+8=0$: $\lambda=\frac{-4\pm\sqrt{16-32}}{2}=-2\pm2i$. For $\lambda=-2+2i$:

$$A-\lambda I=\begin{pmatrix}-2-2i&-8\\1&2-2i\end{pmatrix}.$$

Row 2: $v_1+(2-2i)v_2=0$; with $v_2=1$, $v_1=-2+2i$. Row 1 checks: $(-2-2i)(-2+2i)-8=(4-4i+4i-4i^2)-8=8-8=0$. So $\mathbf v=(-2+2i,1)^T=\mathbf u+i\mathbf w$ with $\mathbf u=(-2,1)^T$, $\mathbf w=(2,0)^T$.

Step 2. Action of A on u and w

$A\mathbf u=(8-8,\ -2)^T=(0,-2)^T=\rho\mathbf u-\omega\mathbf w=(4,-2)^T-(4,0)^T$. $\ A\mathbf w=(-8,\ 2)^T=\omega\mathbf u+\rho\mathbf w=(-4,2)^T+(-4,0)^T$. Both agree with Robinson Eq. 29.3.

Step 3. Change of basis

$$Q=\begin{pmatrix}-2&2\\1&0\end{pmatrix},\qquad \det Q=(-2)(0)-(2)(1)=-2,\qquad Q^{-1}=\frac1{-2}\begin{pmatrix}0&-2\\-1&-2\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\\frac12&1\end{pmatrix}.$$

$AQ=[A\mathbf u\mid A\mathbf w]=\begin{pmatrix}0&-8\\-2&2\end{pmatrix}$ and

$$Q^{-1}AQ=\begin{pmatrix}0\cdot0+1\cdot(-2)&0\cdot(-8)+1\cdot2\\\frac12\cdot0+1\cdot(-2)&\frac12\cdot(-8)+1\cdot2\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}-2&2\\-2&-2\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}\rho&\omega\\-\omega&\rho\end{pmatrix}.$$

Step 4. Real general solution and the IVP

In $\mathbf z$: $\dot z_1=-2z_1+2z_2$, $\dot z_2=-2z_1-2z_2$; with $r^2=z_1^2+z_2^2$: $r\dot r=z_1\dot z_1+z_2\dot z_2=z_1(-2z_1+2z_2)+z_2(-2z_1-2z_2)=-2r^2$ and $r^2\dot\theta=z_1\dot z_2-z_2\dot z_1=z_1(-2z_1-2z_2)-z_2(-2z_1+2z_2)=-2r^2$, i.e. $\dot r=-2r$, $\dot\theta=-2$, so $r=r_0e^{-2t}$, $\theta=\theta_0-2t$ (Barrow: $[e^{2s}r(s)]_0^t=0$). Back in $\mathbf x$:

$$\mathbf x(t)=e^{-2t}\Big[(a_1\cos2t+b_1\sin2t)\,\mathbf u+(b_1\cos2t-a_1\sin2t)\,\mathbf w\Big],\qquad (a_1,b_1)^T=Q^{-1}\mathbf x(0).$$

For $\mathbf x(0)=(0,1)^T$: $(a_1,b_1)^T=(0\cdot0+1\cdot1,\ \frac12\cdot0+1\cdot1)^T=(1,1)^T$. Then

$$\mathbf x(t)=e^{-2t}\Big[(\cos2t+\sin2t)\begin{pmatrix}-2\\1\end{pmatrix}+(\cos2t-\sin2t)\begin{pmatrix}2\\0\end{pmatrix}\Big]=e^{-2t}\begin{pmatrix}-4\sin2t\\\cos2t+\sin2t\end{pmatrix}.$$

Check: $\mathbf x(0)=(0,1)^T$. By the product rule $\dot x_1=e^{-2t}(8\sin2t-8\cos2t)$, and $-4x_1-8x_2=e^{-2t}\big(16\sin2t-8\cos2t-8\sin2t\big)=e^{-2t}(8\sin2t-8\cos2t)$; $\dot x_2=e^{-2t}\big(-2\cos2t-2\sin2t-2\sin2t+2\cos2t\big)=-4e^{-2t}\sin2t=x_1$.

Step 5. Rotation and portrait

At $(1,0)^T$, $\dot{\mathbf x}=A(1,0)^T=(-4,1)^T$: the velocity on the positive $x_1$-axis points upward, so orbits turn anticlockwise in the $\mathbf x$-plane. In the $\mathbf z$-plane they turn clockwise ($\dot\theta=-2$); the sense flips because $\det Q=-2<0$. The origin is a stable focus: spirals shrinking by the factor $e^{2\pi\rho/\omega}=e^{-2\pi}\approx0.0019$ each turn (one turn every $\pi$ time units). The IVP orbit starts at $(0,1)^T$, moves into the half-plane $x_1<0$ and crosses the $x_2$-axis again at $t=\pi/2$, at $(0,-e^{-\pi})^T$.

Key results
  • $\lambda=-2\pm2i$ ($\rho=-2$, $\omega=2$); $\mathbf v=(-2+2i,\ 1)^T$, $\mathbf u=(-2,1)^T$, $\mathbf w=(2,0)^T$.
  • $Q=\begin{pmatrix}-2&2\\1&0\end{pmatrix}$, $\det Q=-2$, $Q^{-1}=\begin{pmatrix}0&1\\\frac12&1\end{pmatrix}$, $Q^{-1}AQ=\begin{pmatrix}-2&2\\-2&-2\end{pmatrix}$.
  • $\mathbf x(t)=e^{-2t}\big(-4\sin2t,\ \cos2t+\sin2t\big)^T$; stable focus, anticlockwise in $\mathbf x$ (clockwise in $\mathbf z$), radius factor $e^{-2\pi}$ per turn.

Interpretation and checks

Phase 4. Asymptotic and physical checks

  • Limits: for every $a<0$ all solutions tend to $\mathbf0$ as $t\to\infty$ (asymptotic stability); for $a=0$ they tend to points of the $x_2$-axis; for $a>0$ only the orbits on the stable eigenline reach the origin. As $a\to-4^\pm$ the node's two eigenlines merge (from $a>-4$) or the spiral's rotation rate $\omega=\sqrt{-4-a}$ goes to $0$ (from $a<-4$): the improper node is the common boundary.
  • Checks: $P^{-1}AP$ and $Q^{-1}AQ$ were multiplied out; both IVP solutions satisfy the system and the initial data; $\operatorname{tr}(P^{-1}AP)=-4=\tau$ and $\det(P^{-1}AP)=3=\delta$ for $a=-3$, and the same for $a=-8$ ($-4$ and $8$).
  • Common mistakes in the exam: (1) calling $a=0$ a node: the origin is not isolated; (2) ordering $Q=[\mathbf w\mid\mathbf u]$ and then expecting $\begin{pmatrix}\rho&\omega\\-\omega&\rho\end{pmatrix}$ (that order gives the transpose); (3) reading the sense of rotation from the $\mathbf z$-plane, which is always clockwise, instead of from a test vector in $\mathbf x$; (4) making the node's orbits tangent to the fast eigenvector at the origin.
1st Midterm · Unit 4 · Linear systems and phase portraits · 5 points · 30 min · High difficulty / trap

P06 — Inverse problem: rebuild the matrix of a spiral sink from one real solution, solve an IVP and measure the decay per turn

The real $2\times2$ matrix $A$ of the linear system $\mathbf x'=A\mathbf x$, $\mathbf x=(x,y)^T$, is unknown. The only information available is that the system has the real solution

$$\mathbf x_1(t)=e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}\cos 2t-\sin 2t\\ \cos 2t-2\sin 2t\end{pmatrix}.$$

(a) Reconstruct $A$. Show that its eigenvalues are $-1\pm 2i$, find a complex eigenvector, and check that $P^{-1}AP$ is the real canonical form, with $P$ the matrix whose columns are the real and imaginary parts of that eigenvector, normalised so that the given solution is $\operatorname{Re}(e^{\lambda t}\boldsymbol\eta)$.

(b) Find a second real solution, prove that the two solutions form a fundamental set, write the real general solution and solve the initial value problem $\mathbf x(0)=(1,0)^T$.

(c) Classify the origin. Do the trajectories spiral in or out? Is the rotation clockwise or counter-clockwise? Justify with a test vector.

(d) (extension: the quadratic form $V$ is not in the course; it follows from the canonical form.) Let $V(x,y)=5x^2-6xy+2y^2$. Show that $V(\mathbf x)=\lvert P^{-1}\mathbf x\rvert^2$ and that $\frac{d}{dt}V(\mathbf x(t))=-2V(\mathbf x(t))$ along every solution. For the solution of (b), find the time needed for $\sqrt V$ to halve, and the first time $t>0$ at which the solution is back on the positive $x$ axis, with the ratio of its distances to the origin there and at $t=0$. Is the Euclidean distance $\lvert\mathbf x(t)\rvert$ decreasing for every solution?

Setup and canonical formulation

Phase 1. Hypotheses and setup

  • Unknowns: the four real entries of $A$; then the solutions $\mathbf x(t)\in\mathbb R^2$, $t\in\mathbb R$.
  • Operator: first-order, linear, homogeneous, constant coefficients, planar. Solutions exist for all $t$ and are unique for given $\mathbf x(0)$ (existence and uniqueness for linear systems).
  • Datum: one solution $\mathbf x_1$. Since $\mathbf x_1'(t)=A\mathbf x_1(t)$ for every $t$, evaluating at two instants where $\mathbf x_1$ takes independent values gives $A$ on a basis, hence $A$.
  • Course convention (Robinson Ch. 29): if $\lambda=\rho+i\omega$ ($\omega>0$) has eigenvector $\boldsymbol\eta=\mathbf u+i\mathbf w$, the real solutions are $e^{\rho t}(\cos\omega t\,\mathbf u-\sin\omega t\,\mathbf w)$ and $e^{\rho t}(\sin\omega t\,\mathbf u+\cos\omega t\,\mathbf w)$.
QuantityValue
$\mathbf x_1(0)$$(1,1)^T$
$\mathbf x_1(\pi/4)$$e^{-\pi/4}(-1,-2)^T$
Initial condition (b)$\mathbf x(0)=(1,0)^T$

Phase 2. Canonical formulation

Matrix form $\mathbf x'=A\mathbf x$. The target canonical form ("frame" of the problem) is $\mathbf z'=J\mathbf z$ with $\mathbf x=P\mathbf z$, $P=[\mathbf u\mid\mathbf w]$ and $J=\begin{pmatrix}\rho&\omega\\-\omega&\rho\end{pmatrix}$, so that $A=PJP^{-1}$.

Part (a) · 1.5 points

Reconstruct A, its eigenvalues and eigenvector, and check the canonical form

Step 1. Derivative of the given solution

Write $c=\cos2t$, $s=\sin2t$. By the chain rule $\frac{d}{dt}\cos2t=-2\sin2t$, $\frac{d}{dt}\sin2t=2\cos2t$, and by the product rule $\frac{d}{dt}\big(e^{-t}g(t)\big)=-e^{-t}g(t)+e^{-t}g'(t)$:

$$\mathbf x_1'(t)=-e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}c-s\\c-2s\end{pmatrix}+e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}-2s-2c\\-2s-4c\end{pmatrix}=e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}-3c-s\\-5c\end{pmatrix}$$

Step 2. Two instants give A on a basis

At $t=0$ ($c=1$, $s=0$): $\mathbf x_1(0)=(1,1)^T$, $\mathbf x_1'(0)=(-3,-5)^T$. At $t=\pi/4$ ($c=0$, $s=1$): $\mathbf x_1(\pi/4)=e^{-\pi/4}(-1,-2)^T$, $\mathbf x_1'(\pi/4)=e^{-\pi/4}(-1,0)^T$. Dividing the second relation by $-e^{-\pi/4}$:

$$A\begin{pmatrix}1\\1\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}-3\\-5\end{pmatrix},\qquad A\begin{pmatrix}1\\2\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\end{pmatrix}$$

With $P=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\1&2\end{pmatrix}$ this reads $AP=\begin{pmatrix}-3&1\\-5&0\end{pmatrix}$. $\det P=1\cdot2-1\cdot1=1\neq0$, and $P^{-1}=\frac{1}{1}\begin{pmatrix}2&-1\\-1&1\end{pmatrix}$, so $A=(AP)P^{-1}$ entry by entry:

$$\begin{aligned}A_{11}&=(-3)(2)+(1)(-1)=-7, & A_{12}&=(-3)(-1)+(1)(1)=4,\\ A_{21}&=(-5)(2)+(0)(-1)=-10, & A_{22}&=(-5)(-1)+(0)(1)=5.\end{aligned}$$
$$A=\begin{pmatrix}-7&4\\-10&5\end{pmatrix}$$

Step 3. Eigenvalues

$$p(\lambda)=\det(A-\lambda I)=(-7-\lambda)(5-\lambda)-(4)(-10)=\lambda^2+2\lambda-35+40=\lambda^2+2\lambda+5$$

$\lambda=\frac{-2\pm\sqrt{4-20}}{2}=-1\pm2i$, so $\rho=-1$, $\omega=2$. Check: $\operatorname{tr}A=-2=2\rho$, $\det A=-35+40=5=\rho^2+\omega^2$.

Step 4. Eigenvector from $(A-\lambda I)\boldsymbol\eta=\mathbf 0$

For $\lambda=-1+2i$, row 1: $(-7-(-1+2i))\eta_1+4\eta_2=0$, i.e. $(-6-2i)\eta_1+4\eta_2=0$, so $\eta_2=\frac{3+i}{2}\eta_1$. Taking $\eta_1=1+i$: $\eta_2=\frac{(3+i)(1+i)}{2}=\frac{3+3i+i-1}{2}=1+2i$. Row 2 as a check: $-10(1+i)+(5-(-1+2i))(1+2i)=-10-10i+(6-2i)(1+2i)=-10-10i+6+12i-2i+4=0$. Hence

$$\boldsymbol\eta=\begin{pmatrix}1+i\\1+2i\end{pmatrix}=\underbrace{\begin{pmatrix}1\\1\end{pmatrix}}_{\mathbf u}+i\underbrace{\begin{pmatrix}1\\2\end{pmatrix}}_{\mathbf w}$$

and indeed $\mathbf x_1=e^{-t}(\cos2t\,\mathbf u-\sin2t\,\mathbf w)$: the given curve is the real part of $e^{\lambda t}\boldsymbol\eta$.

Step 5. Frame check $P^{-1}AP=J$

$P=[\mathbf u\mid\mathbf w]$ is the matrix of Step 2. With $AP=\begin{pmatrix}-3&1\\-5&0\end{pmatrix}$:

$$\begin{aligned}(P^{-1}AP)_{11}&=2(-3)+(-1)(-5)=-1, & (P^{-1}AP)_{12}&=2(1)+(-1)(0)=2,\\ (P^{-1}AP)_{21}&=(-1)(-3)+1(-5)=-2, & (P^{-1}AP)_{22}&=(-1)(1)+1(0)=-1.\end{aligned}$$
$$P^{-1}AP=\begin{pmatrix}-1&2\\-2&-1\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}\rho&\omega\\-\omega&\rho\end{pmatrix}=J$$
Key results
  • $A=\begin{pmatrix}-7&4\\-10&5\end{pmatrix}$, $\operatorname{tr}A=-2$, $\det A=5$, $p(\lambda)=\lambda^2+2\lambda+5$, $\lambda=-1\pm2i$.
  • $\boldsymbol\eta=(1+i,\ 1+2i)^T$, $\mathbf u=(1,1)^T$, $\mathbf w=(1,2)^T$.
  • $P=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\1&2\end{pmatrix}$, $\det P=1$, $P^{-1}=\begin{pmatrix}2&-1\\-1&1\end{pmatrix}$, $P^{-1}AP=\begin{pmatrix}-1&2\\-2&-1\end{pmatrix}$.

Part (b) · 1.5 points

Second real solution, fundamental set, general solution and IVP

Step 1. Complex solution split into real and imaginary parts

With Euler's formula $e^{(-1+2i)t}=e^{-t}(\cos2t+i\sin2t)$:

$$e^{\lambda t}\boldsymbol\eta=e^{-t}(\cos2t+i\sin2t)(\mathbf u+i\mathbf w)=e^{-t}\big[(\cos2t\,\mathbf u-\sin2t\,\mathbf w)+i(\sin2t\,\mathbf u+\cos2t\,\mathbf w)\big]$$

Since $A$ is real, real and imaginary parts are real solutions (Robinson Ch. 29). The real part is $\mathbf x_1$; the imaginary part is

$$\mathbf x_2(t)=e^{-t}(\sin2t\,\mathbf u+\cos2t\,\mathbf w)=e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}\sin2t+\cos2t\\ \sin2t+2\cos2t\end{pmatrix}$$

Step 2. Fundamental set

$\mathbf x_1(0)=\mathbf u$, $\mathbf x_2(0)=\mathbf w$, so the Wronskian at $t=0$ is $W(0)=\det\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\1&2\end{pmatrix}=2-1=1\neq0$. $W(0)\neq0$ is enough for independence (Notes, p. 9). Abel's formula for systems (extension) adds $W(t)=W(0)e^{(\operatorname{tr}A)t}=e^{-2t}\neq0$ for all $t$. Hence the general real solution is

$$\mathbf x(t)=c_1e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}\cos2t-\sin2t\\ \cos2t-2\sin2t\end{pmatrix}+c_2e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}\sin2t+\cos2t\\ \sin2t+2\cos2t\end{pmatrix},\qquad c_1,c_2\in\mathbb R$$

Step 3. Initial condition

At $t=0$: $c_1\mathbf u+c_2\mathbf w=(1,0)^T$, i.e. $c_1+c_2=1$ and $c_1+2c_2=0$. Subtracting, $c_2=-1$, then $c_1=2$:

$$\mathbf x(t)=e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}2(\cos2t-\sin2t)-(\sin2t+\cos2t)\\ 2(\cos2t-2\sin2t)-(\sin2t+2\cos2t)\end{pmatrix}=e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}\cos2t-3\sin2t\\-5\sin2t\end{pmatrix}$$

Step 4. Check by substitution

$\mathbf x(0)=(1,0)^T$. With $c=\cos2t$, $s=\sin2t$, the product rule gives $\mathbf x'=e^{-t}\big(-(c-3s)+(-2s-6c),\ 5s-10c\big)^T=e^{-t}(-7c+s,\ -10c+5s)^T$, and $A\mathbf x=e^{-t}\big(-7(c-3s)+4(-5s),\ -10(c-3s)+5(-5s)\big)^T=e^{-t}(-7c+s,\ -10c+5s)^T$. They agree.

Key results
  • $\mathbf x_2(t)=e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}\sin2t+\cos2t\\ \sin2t+2\cos2t\end{pmatrix}$, $W(0)=1\neq0$.
  • $\mathbf x(t)=c_1\mathbf x_1(t)+c_2\mathbf x_2(t)$; IVP: $c_1=2$, $c_2=-1$.
  • $\mathbf x(t)=e^{-t}\begin{pmatrix}\cos2t-3\sin2t\\-5\sin2t\end{pmatrix}$.

Part (c) · 1 point

Classification, spiralling and sense of rotation

Step 1. Type

The eigenvalues are complex with negative real part, so every solution is $e^{-t}$ times a bounded $\pi$-periodic vector: it tends to $\mathbf 0$ while winding around it. The origin is a stable focus (Robinson Ch. 31).

Step 2. Test vector

At $(1,0)$, on the positive $x$ axis, $\mathbf x'=A(1,0)^T=(-7,-10)^T$: the $y$ component is negative, so the solution crosses the positive $x$ axis downwards. That is a clockwise rotation.

Step 3. Global confirmation

With $\theta$ the polar angle, $\theta'=\dfrac{xy'-yx'}{x^2+y^2}$. Here

$$xy'-yx'=x(-10x+5y)-y(-7x+4y)=-10x^2+12xy-4y^2=-2(5x^2-6xy+2y^2).$$

The quadratic form $5x^2-6xy+2y^2$ has matrix $\begin{pmatrix}5&-3\\-3&2\end{pmatrix}$ with $5>0$ and determinant $10-9=1>0$: it is positive definite. So $\theta'<0$ at every point except the origin: the rotation is clockwise everywhere. In the canonical plane $J$ with $\omega=2>0$ rotates clockwise ($z_2'=-2z_1<0$ at $(1,0)$), and $\det P=1>0$ preserves orientation, which is consistent.

Step 4. Portrait in words

Trajectories are spirals that wind clockwise into the origin, one full turn every $T=2\pi/\omega=\pi$ time units. They are not circles: they are images under $P$ of logarithmic spirals of the $\mathbf z$ plane, so $\mathbf u=(1,1)$ and $\mathbf w=(1,2)$ are conjugate semi-diameters of the ellipses $V=\text{const}$ that the spirals cross.

Key results
  • $\rho=-1<0$, $\omega=2\neq0$: stable focus (spiral sink); $\operatorname{tr}A=-2<0$, $\det A=5>0$, $(\operatorname{tr}A)^2-4\det A=-16<0$.
  • $A(1,0)^T=(-7,-10)^T$: clockwise rotation.
  • $xy'-yx'=-2(5x^2-6xy+2y^2)<0$ off the origin.

Part (d) · 1 point

Decay of the canonical radius, return to the axis, Euclidean distance

Step 1. V is the canonical radius squared

$P^{-1}\mathbf x=\begin{pmatrix}2x-y\\-x+y\end{pmatrix}$, so $\lvert P^{-1}\mathbf x\rvert^2=(4x^2-4xy+y^2)+(x^2-2xy+y^2)=5x^2-6xy+2y^2=V$.

Step 2. Derivative along solutions

$V_x=10x-6y$, $V_y=-6x+4y$, $x'=-7x+4y$, $y'=-10x+5y$. By the chain rule

$$\begin{aligned}\frac{dV}{dt}&=(10x-6y)(-7x+4y)+(-6x+4y)(-10x+5y)\\&=(-70x^2+82xy-24y^2)+(60x^2-70xy+20y^2)=-10x^2+12xy-4y^2=-2V.\end{aligned}$$

(Equivalently $\frac{d}{dt}\lvert\mathbf z\rvert^2=2\mathbf z^TJ\mathbf z=2\rho\lvert\mathbf z\rvert^2$, because the skew part of $J$ gives $\mathbf z^T\begin{pmatrix}0&\omega\\-\omega&0\end{pmatrix}\mathbf z=0$.)

Step 3. Integration

For $V\neq0$ separate variables: $\displaystyle\int_{V(0)}^{V(t)}\frac{dV}{V}=\int_0^t(-2)\,d\tau$, so by Barrow's rule $[\ln V]_{V(0)}^{V(t)}=[-2\tau]_0^t$, i.e. $\ln V(t)-\ln V(0)=-2t$ and $V(t)=V(0)e^{-2t}$. For the IVP $V(0)=5\cdot1^2-0+0=5$, so $V(t)=5e^{-2t}$ and $\sqrt{V(t)}=\sqrt5\,e^{-t}$. Halving: $e^{-t_{1/2}}=\tfrac12$, so $t_{1/2}=\ln2\approx0.693$.

Step 4. Return to the positive x axis

$y(t)=-5e^{-t}\sin2t=0$ for $t=k\pi/2$. At $t=\pi/2$: $x=e^{-\pi/2}\cos\pi=-e^{-\pi/2}<0$ (negative axis). At $t=\pi$: $x=e^{-\pi}\cos2\pi=e^{-\pi}>0$. So the first return is $t=\pi$, with $\mathbf x(\pi)=e^{-\pi}(1,0)^T$ and ratio $\lvert\mathbf x(\pi)\rvert/\lvert\mathbf x(0)\rvert=e^{-\pi}\approx0.0432$. This holds for every solution: the trigonometric factors have period $T=\pi$, so $\mathbf x(t+\pi)=e^{-\pi}\mathbf x(t)$.

Step 5. The Euclidean distance

$\frac{d}{dt}\lvert\mathbf x\rvert^2=2\mathbf x^TA\mathbf x=2(-7x^2+4xy-10xy+5y^2)=2(-7x^2-6xy+5y^2)$. At $(0,1)$ it equals $10>0$: a solution through $(0,1)$ moves away from the origin at that instant. The Euclidean distance decays on average (by $e^{-\pi}$ per turn) but not monotonically; the quantity that decays monotonically, and exactly like $e^{-t}$, is $\sqrt V=\lvert P^{-1}\mathbf x\rvert$.

Key results
  • $V=\lvert P^{-1}\mathbf x\rvert^2=5x^2-6xy+2y^2$, $\frac{dV}{dt}=-2V$, $V(t)=V(0)e^{-2t}$; for the IVP $V(t)=5e^{-2t}$.
  • $\sqrt V$ halves in $t_{1/2}=\ln2\approx0.693$.
  • Back on the positive $x$ axis at $t=\pi$ (negative axis at $t=\pi/2$); $\mathbf x(\pi)=e^{-\pi}(1,0)^T$, ratio $e^{-\pi}\approx0.0432$.
  • No: $\frac{d}{dt}\lvert\mathbf x\rvert^2=2(-7x^2-6xy+5y^2)$ is positive at $(0,1)$.

Interpretation and checks

Phase 4. Asymptotic and physical checks

  • Limits: $t\to+\infty$: $\mathbf x\to\mathbf 0$ like $e^{-t}$; $t\to-\infty$: the spirals grow without bound. If $\rho$ were $0$ the trajectories would be the closed ellipses $V=\text{const}$ (a centre); here they cut those ellipses inwards.
  • Checks: $A\mathbf x_1=\mathbf x_1'$ for all $t$; $\operatorname{tr}A=2\rho$, $\det A=\rho^2+\omega^2$; $P^{-1}AP=J$; the IVP solution satisfies the system and $\mathbf x(0)=(1,0)^T$; Abel: $W(t)=e^{-2t}$.
  • Common mistakes in the exam: (1) reading $\mathbf w$ with the wrong sign: the course writes the real part as $\cos\omega t\,\mathbf u-\sin\omega t\,\mathbf w$, so $\mathbf w=+(1,2)$; (2) deciding the sense of rotation from $\omega>0$ alone: it must be checked with a test vector (it is clockwise here, and it would flip if $\det P<0$); (3) claiming that the Euclidean distance halves after $\ln2$: only the canonical radius $\lvert P^{-1}\mathbf x\rvert$ does; (4) taking the return time to the same half-axis as $\pi/\omega$ instead of $2\pi/\omega$.
1st Midterm · Unit 4 · Linear systems and phase portraits · 5 points · 30 min · Standard exam level

P07 — Non-homogeneous planar system with a defective matrix: Jordan form, equilibrium shift, IVP and the improper node

Consider the system

$$x'=-x+y,\qquad y'=-x-3y+4.$$

(a) Write it as $\mathbf x'=A\mathbf x+\mathbf f$. Show that $A$ has a repeated eigenvalue with only one independent eigenvector $\mathbf v$. Find a generalised eigenvector $\mathbf w$ with $(A-\lambda I)\mathbf w=\mathbf v$, build $P=[\mathbf v\mid\mathbf w]$, compute $P^{-1}$ and check that $P^{-1}AP$ is the Jordan form.

(b) Find a particular solution by undetermined coefficients (a constant vector) and the general solution.

(c) Solve the initial value problem $x(0)=3$, $y(0)=0$ and check your answer.

(d) Classify the equilibrium and describe the phase portrait: invariant line, direction of tangency as $t\to\pm\infty$, sense of turning (test vector), nullclines, and the behaviour of the orbit of (c).

Setup and canonical formulation

Phase 1. Hypotheses and setup

  • Unknowns $x(t)$, $y(t)$, $t\in\mathbb R$. First-order, linear, constant coefficients, non-homogeneous with a constant forcing; solutions exist for all $t$ and are unique given $\mathbf x(0)$.
  • Structure of the general solution (superposition): $\mathbf x=\mathbf x_p+\mathbf x_h$, with $\mathbf x_h$ the general solution of $\mathbf x'=A\mathbf x$.
  • Since $\mathbf f$ is constant and $0$ will not be an eigenvalue ($\det A\neq0$), a constant $\mathbf x_p$ exists: it is the equilibrium, and $\mathbf u=\mathbf x-\mathbf x_p$ obeys the homogeneous system.

Phase 2. Canonical formulation

$$\mathbf x'=A\mathbf x+\mathbf f,\qquad A=\begin{pmatrix}-1&1\\-1&-3\end{pmatrix},\qquad \mathbf f=\begin{pmatrix}0\\4\end{pmatrix}.$$

Target frame: $\mathbf u=P\mathbf z$ with $P=[\mathbf v\mid\mathbf w]$, which turns $\mathbf u'=A\mathbf u$ into $\mathbf z'=J\mathbf z$, $J=\begin{pmatrix}\lambda&1\\0&\lambda\end{pmatrix}$.

Part (a) · 1.5 points

Repeated eigenvalue, generalised eigenvector and Jordan form

Step 1. Characteristic polynomial

$$\det(A-\lambda I)=(-1-\lambda)(-3-\lambda)-(1)(-1)=\lambda^2+4\lambda+3+1=\lambda^2+4\lambda+4=(\lambda+2)^2$$

so $\lambda=-2$ is a double root ($\operatorname{tr}A=-4=2\lambda$, $\det A=4=\lambda^2$).

Step 2. Eigenvectors

$N=A+2I=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\-1&-1\end{pmatrix}$. Row 1: $v_1+v_2=0$; row 2: $-v_1-v_2=0$, the same equation. The rank of $N$ is 1, so the eigenspace is one-dimensional, spanned by $\mathbf v=(1,-1)^T$: $A$ is not diagonalisable. Also $N^2=\begin{pmatrix}1-1&1-1\\-1+1&-1+1\end{pmatrix}=0$, as the Cayley-Hamilton theorem predicts.

Step 3. Generalised eigenvector

$N\mathbf w=\mathbf v$: row 1 $w_1+w_2=1$, row 2 $-w_1-w_2=-1$ (the same). Any solution works; take $w_2=0$, $w_1=1$: $\mathbf w=(1,0)^T$. It is not a multiple of $\mathbf v$, as required.

Step 4. Change of basis and Jordan form

$P=[\mathbf v\mid\mathbf w]=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\-1&0\end{pmatrix}$, $\det P=1\cdot0-1\cdot(-1)=1$, $P^{-1}=\frac11\begin{pmatrix}0&-1\\1&1\end{pmatrix}$.

$A\mathbf v=-2\mathbf v=(-2,2)^T$ and $A\mathbf w=(-1,-1)^T=\mathbf v-2\mathbf w$, so $AP=\begin{pmatrix}-2&-1\\2&-1\end{pmatrix}$. Then

$$\begin{aligned}(P^{-1}AP)_{11}&=0(-2)+(-1)(2)=-2, & (P^{-1}AP)_{12}&=0(-1)+(-1)(-1)=1,\\ (P^{-1}AP)_{21}&=1(-2)+1(2)=0, & (P^{-1}AP)_{22}&=1(-1)+1(-1)=-2.\end{aligned}$$
$$P^{-1}AP=\begin{pmatrix}-2&1\\0&-2\end{pmatrix}=J.$$
Key results
  • $p(\lambda)=\lambda^2+4\lambda+4=(\lambda+2)^2$, $\lambda=-2$ (double); $N=A+2I=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\-1&-1\end{pmatrix}$, rank 1, $N^2=0$.
  • $\mathbf v=(1,-1)^T$, $\mathbf w=(1,0)^T$.
  • $P=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\-1&0\end{pmatrix}$, $\det P=1$, $P^{-1}=\begin{pmatrix}0&-1\\1&1\end{pmatrix}$, $P^{-1}AP=\begin{pmatrix}-2&1\\0&-2\end{pmatrix}$.

Part (b) · 1.5 points

Particular solution and general solution

Step 1. Undetermined constant vector

With $\mathbf x_p=(p,q)^T$ constant, $\mathbf x_p'=\mathbf 0$ and the system gives $A\mathbf x_p=-\mathbf f$:

$$-p+q=0,\qquad -p-3q+4=0.$$

The first gives $q=p$; substituting, $-4p+4=0$, so $p=q=1$. The solution is unique because $\det A=4\neq0$. So $\mathbf x^*=(1,1)^T$ is the only equilibrium.

Step 2. Homogeneous part in the Jordan frame

Let $\mathbf u=\mathbf x-\mathbf x^*$; then $\mathbf u'=\mathbf x'=A\mathbf x+\mathbf f=A\mathbf u+(A\mathbf x^*+\mathbf f)=A\mathbf u$. With $\mathbf u=P\mathbf z$ ($P$ constant): $\mathbf z'=P^{-1}AP\,\mathbf z=J\mathbf z$, i.e.

$$z_1'=-2z_1+z_2,\qquad z_2'=-2z_2.$$

The second equation gives $z_2=c_2e^{-2t}$. The first becomes $z_1'+2z_1=c_2e^{-2t}$; multiply by the integrating factor $e^{2t}$: $(e^{2t}z_1)'=e^{2t}z_1'+2e^{2t}z_1=c_2$ (product rule). Integrating, $e^{2t}z_1=c_1+c_2t$, so $z_1=(c_1+c_2t)e^{-2t}$.

Step 3. Back to the original frame

$\mathbf u=P\mathbf z=z_1\mathbf v+z_2\mathbf w=c_1e^{-2t}\mathbf v+c_2e^{-2t}(t\mathbf v+\mathbf w)$, the formula of Robinson Ch. 30. Adding $\mathbf x^*$:

$$\mathbf x(t)=\begin{pmatrix}1+(c_1+c_2+c_2t)e^{-2t}\\ 1-(c_1+c_2t)e^{-2t}\end{pmatrix}.$$

The fundamental matrix $\Phi=\big[e^{-2t}\mathbf v\mid e^{-2t}(t\mathbf v+\mathbf w)\big]$ has $\det\Phi=e^{-4t}\det[\mathbf v\mid t\mathbf v+\mathbf w]=e^{-4t}\det[\mathbf v\mid\mathbf w]=e^{-4t}\neq0$, in agreement with Abel's formula for systems (extension) $W(t)=W(0)e^{(\operatorname{tr}A)t}$.

Key results
  • $\mathbf x_p=\mathbf x^*=(1,1)^T$.
  • $\mathbf x(t)=\begin{pmatrix}1\\1\end{pmatrix}+c_1e^{-2t}\begin{pmatrix}1\\-1\end{pmatrix}+c_2e^{-2t}\left[t\begin{pmatrix}1\\-1\end{pmatrix}+\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\end{pmatrix}\right]$.
  • In components: $x=1+(c_1+c_2+c_2t)e^{-2t}$, $y=1-(c_1+c_2t)e^{-2t}$.

Part (c) · 1 point

Initial value problem x(0) = 3, y(0) = 0

Step 1. Constants

$x(0)=1+c_1+c_2=3$ and $y(0)=1-c_1=0$. Hence $c_1=1$ and $c_2=2-c_1=1$:

$$x(t)=1+(2+t)e^{-2t},\qquad y(t)=1-(1+t)e^{-2t}.$$

Step 2. Check

By the product rule, $x'=e^{-2t}-2(2+t)e^{-2t}=-(3+2t)e^{-2t}$ and $y'=-e^{-2t}+2(1+t)e^{-2t}=(1+2t)e^{-2t}$. Right-hand sides:

$$-x+y=-1-(2+t)e^{-2t}+1-(1+t)e^{-2t}=-(3+2t)e^{-2t},$$
$$-x-3y+4=-1-(2+t)e^{-2t}-3+3(1+t)e^{-2t}+4=(1+2t)e^{-2t}.$$

Both equations hold, and $x(0)=3$, $y(0)=0$.

Key results
  • $c_1=1$, $c_2=1$.
  • $x(t)=1+(2+t)e^{-2t}$, $y(t)=1-(1+t)e^{-2t}$.
  • $x'=-(3+2t)e^{-2t}$, $y'=(1+2t)e^{-2t}$.

Part (d) · 1 point

Classification and phase portrait

Step 1. Type

A double negative eigenvalue with a one-dimensional eigenspace gives a stable improper node (Robinson Ch. 31): it lies on the parabola $(\operatorname{tr})^2=4\det$ of the trace-determinant plane, at the border between the nodes and the foci.

Step 2. Eigen-direction and tangency

The line $\mathbf x^*+s\mathbf v$, i.e. $x+y=2$, is invariant ($c_2=0$: $\mathbf u=c_1e^{-2t}\mathbf v$ moves straight to $(1,1)$). For $c_2\neq0$, $\mathbf u=e^{-2t}\big[(c_1+c_2t)\mathbf v+c_2\mathbf w\big]$ and the term $c_2t\mathbf v$ dominates as $t\to\pm\infty$: the direction of $\mathbf u$ tends to $\pm\mathbf v$ at both ends. So every orbit enters $(1,1)$ tangent to the line $x+y=2$, and far away (as $t\to-\infty$) it is again parallel to that line, on the other side: each orbit turns half a revolution.

Step 3. Sense of turning

With $\mathbf u'=A\mathbf u$: $u_1'=-u_1+u_2$, $u_2'=-u_1-3u_2$, so

$$u_1u_2'-u_2u_1'=u_1(-u_1-3u_2)-u_2(-u_1+u_2)=-u_1^2-2u_1u_2-u_2^2=-(u_1+u_2)^2\le0,$$

zero only on the invariant line. The polar angle around $(1,1)$ never increases: orbits turn clockwise. Test vector: at $(2,1)$, $\mathbf u=\mathbf w=(1,0)$, and $\mathbf u'=A\mathbf w=(-1,-1)^T$ points down, crossing the horizontal through $(1,1)$ downwards on its right: clockwise.

Step 4. Nullclines

$x'=0$ on the line $y=x$ (vertical slopes there); $y'=0$ on $x+3y=4$ (horizontal slopes). Both pass through $(1,1)$ and split the plane into four sectors where $(x',y')$ keeps its signs; e.g. at $(3,0)$: $x'=-3<0$, $y'=1>0$.

Step 5. The orbit of (c)

$u_1+u_2=(2+t)e^{-2t}-(1+t)e^{-2t}=e^{-2t}>0$: the orbit never meets the invariant line and stays in the half-plane $x+y>2$ (uniqueness forbids crossing an invariant line). For $t\ge0$, $x'=-(3+2t)e^{-2t}<0$ and $y'=(1+2t)e^{-2t}>0$: it moves monotonically from $(3,0)$ to $(1,1)$, with $u_2/u_1=-(1+t)/(2+t)\to-1$, i.e. arriving from the lower right tangent to $x+y=2$. Backwards in time it crosses $y=1$ at $t=-1$ and $x=1$ at $t=-2$, and escapes to infinity parallel to $(-1,1)$.

Key results
  • $(1,1)$ is a stable improper node: $\operatorname{tr}A=-4<0$, $\det A=4>0$, $(\operatorname{tr}A)^2-4\det A=0$, one eigen-direction.
  • Invariant line $x+y=2$ (through $(1,1)$ along $\mathbf v=(1,-1)$); all other orbits are tangent to it at $(1,1)$ and parallel to it as $t\to-\infty$.
  • $u_1u_2'-u_2u_1'=-(u_1+u_2)^2\le0$: orbits turn clockwise; test vector $A\mathbf w=(-1,-1)^T$ at $(2,1)$.
  • Nullclines: $x'=0$ on $y=x$; $y'=0$ on $x+3y=4$. The orbit of (c) stays in $x+y>2$; for $t\ge0$ $x$ decreases to 1 and $y$ increases to 1.

Interpretation and checks

Phase 4. Asymptotic and physical checks

  • Limits: $t\to+\infty$: $\mathbf x\to(1,1)$ like $te^{-2t}$, slower than a pure $e^{-2t}$ because of the secular factor $t$. $t\to-\infty$: $\lvert\mathbf x\rvert\to\infty$. If $\mathbf f=\mathbf 0$ the portrait is the same, centred at the origin.
  • Checks: $P^{-1}AP=J$ with $\det P=1$; $A\mathbf x^*+\mathbf f=\mathbf 0$; the IVP solution satisfies both equations and the initial data; $\det\Phi=e^{-4t}$ matches Abel's formula for systems (extension).
  • Common mistakes in the exam: (1) writing $\mathbf x_h=c_1e^{-2t}\mathbf v+c_2te^{-2t}\mathbf v$, which forgets $\mathbf w$ and is not a fundamental set; (2) solving $(A-\lambda I)\mathbf w=\mathbf v$ with the wrong sign of $\lambda$ (using $A-2I$); (3) trying a particular solution $\mathbf c\,t$ or $\mathbf c\,e^{-2t}$ for a constant forcing: a constant vector suffices since $\det A\neq0$; (4) drawing a star node (all straight lines), or claiming orbits cross the eigenline.